New Data on Minerals. М., 2008. Volume 43 5
1 2+ NALIVKINITE , Li2NaFe7 Ti2(Si8O24)O2(OH)4F, A NEW MINERAL OF THE ASTROPHYLLITE GROUP FROM THE DARAI-PIOZ MASSIF, TADJIKISTAN Atali A. Agakhanov Fersman Mineralogical Museum, RAS, Moscow, [email protected] Leonid A. Pautov Fersman Mineralogical Museum, RAS, Moscow, [email protected] Yulia A. Uvarova Queen’s University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada Elena Sokolova University of Manitoba, Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada Frank C. Hawthorne University of Manitoba, Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada Vladimir Y. Karpenko Fersman Mineralogical Museum, RAS, Moscow, [email protected]
Nalivkinite, a new astrophyllite-group mineral, was discovered in the moraine of the Darai-Pioz alkaline massif located at the intersection of the Zeravshansky, Turkestansky and Alaisky Ridges, Tadjikistan. Nalivkinite occurs in the amphibole-quartz-feldspar rock in association with calcybeborosilite-(Y), bafertisite, jinshajiangite, zircon and thorite. Nalivkinite is brown with a bronze hue and a vitreous luster; in thin plates, it is transparent. Mohs hard- 3 3 ness is 3, Dmeas. = 3.32(2) g/cm , Dcalc. = 3.315 g/cm . It is biaxial positive, np = 1.703(2), nm= 1.716(2), ng
=1.745(2), 2Vmeas. = +68(2)°, 2Vcalc. = +68.6°. Nalivkinite is triclinic, space group P 1, a = 5.3745(6) Å; b = 11.9299(15) Å; c = 11.6509(14) Å; a =113.325(3)°, b = 94.524(2)°, g = 103.080(2)°, V = 656.2(2) Å3, Z = 1. Cell dimensions refined from X-ray powder diffraction data are as follows: a = 5.3707(2) Å; b = 11.9327(5) Å; c = 11.6546(4) Å; a =113.384(1)°, b = 94.547(1)°, 103.047(1)°, V = 655.85(2) Å3. The strongest reflections in the X-ray powder diffraction powder pattern are as follows: [(d, Å), (I, %), (hkl)]: 10.56 (100) (001), 3.50 (100) (003), 2.780 (80) (1–42), 2.648 (45) ( 211), 2578 (70)(130), 2.474 (15) ( 212), 2.295 (30) (131), 2.106 (35) ( 142), 1.760 (30) (133), 1.660 (15) (0–73). The infrared spectrum of nalivkinite is similar to that of astrophyllite, and the strongest lines are as follows (cm–1): 3600, 1621, 1077(sh), 1056, 975, 929, 696, 649, 566, 441, 438. The chemical composition (electron microprobe, wt. %, Li2O and Rb2O by ICP OES, H2O by the Penfield method): Al2O3 – 0.67, SiO2 – 35.92, TiO2 –
10.50, Nb2O5 – 1.68, CaO – 1.29, MgO – 0.09, MnO – 5.26, FeO – 32.76, Na2O – 1.62, K2O – 2.49, Li2O – 3.76, Cs2O –
1.40, Rb2O – 0.85, H2O – 3.13, F – 0.75, O=F2 – 0.32, total – 100.04. The empirical formula of nalivkinite is 2+ (Li1.03K0.69Cs0.13Rb0.12)1.97(Na0.69Ca0.30)0.99(Fe5.97Mn0.97Mg0.03)6.97(Ti1.72Nb0.16Zr0.08)1.96[Si7.83Al0.17]8O25.98OH4.07 (F0.52OH0.48)1.00 2+ and the ideal formula is Li2NaFe7 Ti2(Si8O24)O2(OH)4F. The crystal structure of nalivkinite was refined to an R1 index of 6.26%. The name honors Dmitry Vasiljevich Nalivkin, a famous Russian geologist (1889–1982), author of numerous works on the geology, stratigraphy and paleontology of Central Asia. The holotype sample of nalivki- nite is deposited at the Fersman Mineralоgical Museum, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow. 3 tables, 3 figures, 12 references. Keywords: nalivkinite, astrophyllite lithium analogue, Darai-Pioz alkaline massif.
Introduction The astrophyllite group includes nine Minerals of the astrophyllite group have mineral species: the structurally characterized the general formula A2BC7D2T8O26 species astrophyllite, magnesioastrophyllite, [10]–[13] (OH)4X0–1, where A = K, Cs, Rb, H2O, kupletskite (with two polytypes: kupletskite- + [10] [6] H3O , Li, Na and o; B = Na and Ca; C 1А and kupletskite-2М) and niobokuplet- = Fe2+, Fe3+, Mn, Na, Mg and Zn; [6]D = Ti, skite, and the structurally uncharacterized Nb and Zr; [4]T = Si and Al; X = F, OH, O species niobophyllite, cesium-kupletskite and o (Piilonen et al., 2003; Uvarova et al., (recently renamed into a kupletskite-Cs) and 2008). zircophyllite. The minerals of the astrophyllite
1 – Nalivkinite is recommended for the publication by the Commission on New Minerals and Mineral Names of the Russian Mineralogical Society, and was approved by the Commission on New Minerals, Nomenclature and Classification of the International Mineralogical Assosiation on December 4, 2006. 6 New Data on Minerals. М., 2008. Volume 43 group are commonly accessory minerals, but and the lion's share of mineralogical and pet- may be rock-forming minerals in alkaline rographic work has been done on material rocks. There has been much work on the latter collected from glacial debris. The vein rocks occurrence: a detailed review of the 19th and are even less accessible to observation in early 20th Century literature (including the situ, particularly granitic pegmatites, subal- original data on astrophyllite) are given by kaline granitic pegmatites with rare-metal Bonshtedt (1931); later reviews and new data and rare-earth mineralization, reedmergner- are given by Semenov (1972), Macdonald and ite pegmatites, carbonatites, pectolite- Saunders (1973), Piilonen et al. (2003) and microcline-calcite veins, etc. Among the Uvarova et al. (2008). hydrothermally-altered rocks are albitites, Ganzeev et al. (1969) first drew attention aegirine-quartz-microcline-albite rocks with to a deficiency of potassium and enrichment wollastonite, miserite, agrellite, as well as of lithium in astrophyllite from the Darai- fenites. Detailed descriptions are given by Pioz massif: Li, % – 0.59; 0.59; 0.27, equiva- Dusmatov (1968, 1971). lent to 1.27; 1.27; 0.58 wt. % Li2O. Higher An important feature of rocks of the massif contents of lithium (Li2O – 1.30; 1.36 wt. %) is their enrichment in Li. According to in astrophyllite from Darai-Pioz were report- Dusmatov (1971), the following Li (ppm) con- ed by Burova and Dusmatov (1971). Their tents were recorded: biotite granites – 135, work prompted re-investigation of this quartz syenites – 45, aegirine syenites – 70, unusual astrophyllite from Darai-Pioz. cancrinite syenites – 180, fenitized rocks – Accordingly, the Li analogue of astrophyl- 250. There are sixteen Li minerals recorded lite was discovered in rocks from the Upper from the Darai-Pioz massif, seven of which Darai-Pioz massif, and was named nalivki- were discovered there. Indeed, Ganzeev et al. nite in honour of Dmitry Vasiljevich (1969) wrote: “Astrophyllite is a sensitive indi- Nalivkin (1889–1982), participant of the cator of enrichment of Rb, Cs and Li in alka- Pamiro-Tadjik expedition (1920–1930) and line-rock massifs”. These words prove to be author of numerous works on the geology, true for the Darai-Pioz massif. stratigraphy and paleontology of Central Nalivkinite occurs in boulders of the gla- Asia. cial moraine; in-place exposures have not been found. The samples consist of fine- to Occurrence coarse-grained amphibole-quartz-feldspar rock of leucocratic appearance, with a patchy Nalivkinite was found in fenitized rocks texture caused by aggregates of amphibole, of the Upper Darai-Pioz massif by the upper bafertisite, calcybeborosilite-(Y) and nalivki- reaches of the Darai-Pioz river, started from nite. Microcline forms large grayish-yellow the same glacier (Tadjikistan). In plan, the idiomorphic grains 1–8 cm in size, and the massif is slightly elongated in a northwest- albite component does not exceed Ab4, erly direction and adjoins the core of a large although intergrowths of virtually pure albite synclinal fold of С2–3 slates, and the north- are observed. Quartz forms light grey, translu- ern part of the massif an anticlinal fold of cent, sometimes smoky, icy coarse-grained interbedded S1w–S2ld slates and lime- aggregates. Sodic amphibole occurs as pris- stones. The exposed part of the massif con- matic crystals, frequently deformed, up to sists of granites, aegirine and quartz syen- 3 cm long, in which relict aegirine can be ites, and cancrinite foyaites, and covers 18 observed. Fine-grained albite is common. The km2 (Dusmatov, 1971). A significant part of characteristic mineral of nalivkinite-bearing the massif is covered by glaciers and is com- rocks is calcybeborosilite-(Y) which occurs as pletely inaccessible. In the last century, the anhedral dark-grey-to-brown crystals up to 3 glaciers of Central Asia have receded exten- cm in size. There are thick lamellar aggregates sively, and the Darai-Pioz glacier is no of brown-red manganous bafertisite and jin- exception. The receding glacier has left a shajiangite (fig.1), and rectangular pseudo- steep-walled trough valley. Some parts of morphs of fine-grained quartz-calcite-micro- the massif can be seen but close examination cline up to 5–15 mm in size. is not possible without special equipment. There are minor concentrations of dipyra- As a result, knowledge of the massif is, in midal lilac crystals of zircon (1–3 mm), black many respects, rather fragmentary in nature, octahedral crystals of uraniferous pyrochlore 2+ Nalivkinite, Li2NaFe7 Ti2(Si8O24)O2(OH)4F, a new mineral of the astrophyllite group from Darai-Pioz Massif, Tadjikistan 7
Fig. 1. Intergrowth of nalivkinite (Naliv) with jinshajiangite (Jin), pyrochlore (Pyr) and stillwellite-(Ce) (Stil). The BSE image of a polished section (top) and characteristic X-ray maps of the specified elements (bot- tom).
(0.5–2 mm), and pinkish-red prismatic crys- Physical properties tals of stillwellite-(Се) from 4 to 10 mm, grains Appearance of nalivkinite is very similar of pale-violet fluorite up to 1 mm, crystals of to that of astrophyllite. In hand specimen, it is pale-green thorite, yellow wedge-shaped brown with a bronze hue; in thin plates, it is crystals of Nb-bearing titanite (Nb2O5 = pale brown and transparent. Cleavage is per- 2.64 wt. %, size <1 mm). Willemite, smithonite fect on (001), good on (010), and imperfect on and barite occur in cavities caused by leaching (100). On breaking, lamellae and thin mica- of sphalerite. like layers frequently occur. Nalivkinite is Nalivkinite forms large gold-brown lamel- brittle with a pale-yellow streak and a vitreous lar aggregates up to 4 х 5 cm (fig. 2) that are lustre that is particularly prominent on cleav- frequently deformed, shattered and penetrat- age fragments. In short-wave and long-wave ed by a network of quartz veinlets to UV-light, the mineral does not fluoresce. The 0.1–0.2 mm thick. The same veinlets also cut Mohs hardness is 3. Micro-indentation VHN the lamellar aggregates of bafertisite. was determined with a 20g load on a PMT-3 8 New Data on Minerals. М., 2008. Volume 43
Fig. 2. A general view of the amphi- bole-quartz-feldspar rock in which nalivkinite was discovered. Large platy aggregates of brownish-gold- en nalivkinite in microcline, inter- grown with black anhedral. crystals of sodic amphibole and pale-violet euhedral crystals of zircon. Size of sample: 5 x 4 x 1.5 cm
instrument standardized on NaCl; the mean trometer (Avatar, Thermo Nicolet, specimen: value is 190 kg/mm2 (average of 10 measure- powder dispersed in KBr pellet). It has strong ments in the range 170–218 kg/mm2). A absorption bands as follows (cm–1): 3600, density of 3.32(2) g/cm3 was determined by 1621, 1077 (shoulder), 1058, 975, 929, 696, 649, weighing grains in water-diluted Clerichi 568, 447 and 438, and is very similar to that of solution. The calculated densities for grains A astrophyllite. Presence of a narrow peak and B are 3.315 g/cm3 and 3.299 g/cm3, around 1620 cm–1 was noted by Morgunova respectively. et al. (2000) for potassium-poor astrophyllite Nalivkinite is biaxial positive; refractive and cesium-kupletskite from Darai-Pioz. indices were measured by spindle stage and are as follows: np = 1,703(2); nm = 1,716(2); Chemical composition ng = 1,745(2) (for a wavelength of 589 nm). The optical-axial angle, measured on a The chemical composition of nalivkinite
Fedorov stage, is as follows: 2Vmeas. = was determined primarily by electron-micro- +68(2)°; 2Vcalc.= +68.6° (because of strong probe analysis in a polished section embed- dispersion, it was necessary to make our meas- ded in epoxy resin and prepared from sample urements with Na light). Dispersion is strong, No 5321. Grains for the determination of alka- r > v. In the immersion liquids, practically all nalivkinite particles lay on the cleavage plane Fig. 3. IR spectrum of nalivkinite. (001). Most grains resemble elongate paral- lelepipeds, and there are two discernable types of fragments: one has positive elonga- tion and direct extinction Ng||a, whereas the other less regular fragments with cross cleav- age on (010) have negative elongation and inclined extinction Nm:b = 3o. In convergent light, all fragments laying on (001) give an obtuse-bisectrix figure. The optic-axial plane is almost perpendicular to the (001) cleavage. Nalivkinite is pleochroic, Ng = light yellow- ish-brown, Nm = reddish brown, Np = inten- sive brown, with absorption Np > Nm > Ng. The infrared spectrum of nalivkinite (fig. 3) was measured on a Fourier-transform IR-spec- 2+ Nalivkinite, Li2NaFe7 Ti2(Si8O24)O2(OH)4F, a new mineral of the astrophyllite group from Darai-Pioz Massif, Tadjikistan 9
lis and H2O content (and for determination of amount of the ammonium vanadate solution physical properties) were extracted from this was added, the abundance of which was titrat- sample. Grains were analyzed on a JEOL ed with 0.01M Mohr’s Salt solution (Sizykh et JCXA-50A with an accelerating voltage of al., 1977). Two aliquots of diabase W-2a refer- 20 kV and a current of 2 nA for energy-disper- ence sample were analysed simultaneously to sive examination, and an accelerating voltage check for accuracy. The measured content of of 15 kV and a probe current of 25 nA for wave- FeO in nalivkinite is 29.46 wt. %. This value is length-dispersive analysis. Al, Si, Ti, Са, Mg, close to the amount of FeO measured by elec- Mn, Fe, Zr, Na, K, Cs, Ti and Nb were tron microprobe: 30.84 wt. %, indicating that analysed with a Link EDS system, and F was there is negligible Fe2O3 in nalivkinite. measured by WDS. Standards used were as Inspection of the table of nalivkinite analy- follows: microcline USNM 143966 (Al, Si, K), ses shows that some variation in Fe, Mn, Nb, ilmenite USMN 96189 (Ti, Fe), anorthite Cs, F and some other elements (that are not USNM 137041 (Ca), LiNbO3 (Nb), MgF2 (Mg), essential with regard to the nomenclature of Mn (Mn), omphacite USNM 110607 (Na), the group). Some of these variations are shown CsTbP4O12 (Cs) and MgF2 (F). Data were in the BSE image in figure 2. reduced using the PAP program. The chemical formula of nalivkinite, nor- Concentrations of Li and Rb were meas- malized on the basis of 8 (Si+Al) atoms using ured by ISP OES. Carefully selected grains of the average composition of A (Table 1) is as nalivkinite were digested in heated follows: 2+ polypropylene tubes with 40 % hydrofluoric (Li1.03K0.69Cs0.13Rb0.12)1.97(Na0.69Ca0.30)0.99(Fe5.97Mn0.97Mg0.03)6.97 acid (HF) and nitric acid (HNO3). The result- (Ti1.72Nb0.16Zr0.08)1.96(Si7.83Al0.17)8O25.98OH4.07 (F0.52OH0.48)1.00. ing solution was evaporated twice with addi- For B (Table 1), it is 2+ tion of HNO3 to dissolve the dry residue. The (Li1.14K0.74Cs0.09)1.97(Na0.79Ca0.22)1.01(Fe5.61Mn0.90Sn0.09 solution was analysed with a Varian ICP-OES Ca0.07Mg0.04Zn0.04Pb0.02) 6.77(Ti1.55Nb0.24Zr0.16 VISTA Pro. The content of H2O was deter- Ta0.04)1.99(Si7.85Al0.15)8O25.88OH3.99F1.00. mined by the Penfield method using 40 mg of The ideal formula of nalivkinite is: 2+ sample. The results of analysis are shown in Li2NaFe7 Ti2(Si8O24)O2(OH)4F. table 1 (analyses 1–12). Lithium content and The compatibility index, calculated for of some other components in nalivkinite were the average composition of A is as follows: also determined by S.G. Simakin using sec- (1 Kp/Kc) = 0.024 (excellent); ondary-ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) with a that for B is (1 Kp/Kc) = 0.013 (superior). Cameca IMS-4F (Institute of Microelectronics and Information science, Russian Academy of X-Ray powder diffraction data Science). Concentrations of each element were calculated from the intensity relations of X-ray powder diffraction data (tab. 2) were the ion current of an element normalized to 30 recorded with a RKU-114M camera (114.6 Si+ using calibration constants from reference mm diameter), and with a DRON-2.0 X-ray samples. For three points, the data are as fol- diffractometer using quartz as an internal lows (wt. %): Li2O – 1.03, 1.23, 0.99; Rb2O – standard .The X-ray powder diffraction pat- 1.14, 0.92, 0.97; K2O – 2.61, 2.37, 3.21; F – tern of nalivkinite is similar to that of astro- 0.74, 0.77, 0.89. Taking into account the preci- phyllite. The unit-cell parameters refined sion of the SIMS method and the natural vari- from the powder data are as follows: a = ability of these constituents in nalivkinite, 5.3707(2) Å, b = 11.9327(5) Å, c = these results are in good agreement with those 11.6546(4) Å, a = 113.384(1)°, b = 94.547(1)°, obtained by electron-microprobe analysis and g = 103.047(1)°, V = 655.85(2) Å3, with Z = 1. ICP OES. The composition of the nalivkinite grain on which the single-crystal X-ray data Crystal structure were collected (and the crystal structure was refined) is given in table 2 (column B). The The crystal structure of nalivkinite 2+ FeO (i.e., Fe ) content was determined on the (Uvarova et al., 2008) was refined to an R1 sample of grains from which the grain used for index of 6.26% based on 2041 observed [Fo > structural analysis was extracted. A weight of 4sIFI] unique reflections measured with 10.32 mg was digested in a fluoroplastic cru- MoKa X-radiation on a Bruker P4 diffrac- cible by boiling in 40% HF to which a known tometer equipped with a Smart 4K CCD 10 New Data on Minerals. М., 2008. Volume 43
Table 1. Chemical composition of nalivkinite, wt. % Compo- A B nents 123456789101112Avg
SiO2 36.57 36.45 35.41 35.81 35.95 36.46 36.30 35.02 35.88 36.01 35.08 36.13 35.92 36.11
Al2O3 0.44 0.65 0.78 0.59 0.65 0.48 0.76 1.29 0.52 0.58 0.58 0.72 0.67 0.58
TiO2 10.26 10.03 10.58 11.14 10.40 11.11 10.41 9.23 10.91 10.94 10.57 10.40 10.50 9.48
Nb2O5 1.39 1.60 1.74 1.07 1.90 1.81 1.49 3.35 1.16 1.13 1.19 1.93 1.65 2.40
ZrO2 0.58 0.99 0.61 0.65 0.54 0.40 1.34 0.62 1.16 1.02 0.89 0.74 0.80 1.47 MnO 5.01 5.21 5.16 5.05 5.19 5.53 5.33 5.42 5.13 5.31 5.58 5.15 5.26 4.86 FeO 33.47 32.56 32.84 32.53 32.52 32.71 33.66 33.11 32.92 32.30 32.11 32.43 32.76 30.84 CaO 1.38 1.43 1.19 1.12 1.42 1.06 1.43 1.27 1.28 1.31 2.43 2.20 1.29 1.24 MgO 0.00 0.11 0.00 0.12 0.04 0.18 0.13 0.00 0.11 0.30 0.02 0.03 0.09 0.11
Na2O 1.54 1.72 1.81 1.68 1.58 1.59 1.51 1.73 1.55 1.34 1.67 1.76 1.62 1.88
K2O 2.62 2.35 2.58 2.31 2.48 2.49 2.56 3.12 2.37 2.32 2.43 2.20 2.49 2.68
Cs2O 1.56 1.07 1.46 1.57 1.89 1.76 0.23 0.57 1.27 1.70 1.80 1.87 1.40 0.93
Rb2O* 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85 0.85
Li2O* 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.18 1.30
H2O** 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.13 2.75 F 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 0.75 1.45 Total 100.73 100.08 100.07 99.55 100.47 101.49 101.64 100.64 100.17 100.17 99.11 100.61 100.36 100.20