THE DIAPASON APRIL, 2008
St. Vincent’s Cathedral Church Bedford, Texas Cover feature on pages 30–31
Apr 08 Cover.indd 1 3/10/08 11:12:05 AM Visit us at Anthony & Beard The Chenaults James David Christie Peter Richard Conte Clive Driskill-Smith AGO ‘08 Minneapolis Booths
Jeremy Filsell S. Wayne Foster Gough Duo David Hurd Paul Jacobs 302 & 400 just inside the main entrance to the exhibition room
Martin Jean Huw Lewis Bruce Neswick New York Piano Organized Rhythm Organ Duo
Paulsson & Canning Pierre Pincemaille Mary Preston Jean-Baptiste Robin John Rose John Scott Dong-Ill Shin (Chartres) [email protected]
toll-free phone: (888) 999-0644
outside US & Canada: Herndon Spillman Daniel Sullivan Carole Terry Johannes Unger (860) 560-7800
fax (860) 560-7788
1 Gold St, #R
Hartford CT 06103-2914 Unger-Ochoa Duo Olivier Vernet Vernet Duo Ulrich Walther (St.Albans)
CONCERTARTISTS.COM
Bradley Welch William Whitehead Carol Williams nental Europeans, yet we now look back also have worked directly for the factory on those instruments as quite dated— in voicing (analog, digital and pipe), as THE DIAPASON though, to be sure, a start in the right a voicer and consultant, and with many A Scranton Gillette Publication direction. In my view it was not until the pipe organ companies. My work affi lia- Ninety-ninth Year: No. 4, Whole No. 1181 APRIL, 2008 mid-1970s that American builders really tions have absolutely nothing to do with caught up to the classical sounds of the the current sorry situation at Trinity. I am Established in 1909 ISSN 0012-2378 harpsichord. currently employed by Chad Perry and An International Monthly Devoted to the Organ, Of particular interest in the articles Associates, the Tristate Rodgers dealer. the Harpsichord, Carillon, and Church Music was the discussion of performance for As Owen Burdick is no longer em- the moment for live audiences vs. how, ployed at Trinity, there may be some hope for instance, Walcha played for the re- for either restoring or using signifi cant cord on recordings. My feeling is that it portions of the 154/IV Skinner. I cannot CONTENTS Editor & Publisher JEROME BUTERA [email protected] is possible to capture a lot of the excite- believe that this organ was so maligned 847/391-1045 ment of the moment in a recording, and and obviously left to deteriorate through FEATURES that the best recordings are fi lled with the years. The ‘drastic reconfi guration The Clarence Dickinson Festival enough of this vitality so that, for that over the years’ (the original organ was William Carey University, Hattiesburg, Mississippi Associate Editor JOYCE ROBINSON very reason, they do not become tire- 151 ranks) was partially due to moving by Gene Winters 21 [email protected] some after more than one hearing. More the choir to the chancel. In Larry King’s 847/391-1044 Celebrating a milestone birthday: documentary types of recordings do tenure, the choir was moved to the gal- “Guardian Angel” not seem to wear as well. I suggest that lery and would perform from the chancel by Oswald Ragatz 22 Contributing Editors LARRY PALMER this difference of perceptions is partly a occasionally. A ‘drastic reconfi guration’ Harpsichord function of the Zeitgeist—the spirit of meant three added ranks of pipework to The Musical Tradition at the Sainte-Clotilde the times. Much of the period instru- the chancel organ. Yes, it is still an Aeo- Basilica in Paris, France JAMES MCCRAY ment movement has changed directions lian-Skinner. I’m sure there are many by Carolyn Shuster Fournier 26 Choral Music in the last 15-plus years, moving perhaps more than 21 stops (unless the rest were more toward the true spirit of bygone damaged to the point of no return) to be NEWS & DEPARTMENTS BRIAN SWAGER days, though we cannot be certain. The ‘good enough’ to incorporate into a new Letters to the Editor 3 Carillon question of such certainty is of less inter- pipe instrument. Here & There 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10, 12 est to me than it used to be, inasmuch as As many fi gures have been misquoted HERBERT L. HUESTIS Appointments 6 OrganNet Forum I feel that what has happened has, above in the past, let it suffi ce to say that the Nunc Dimittis 8 Osiris Organ Archive all, succeeded in bringing the music to Skinner would have cost about half the Rockefeller Chapel, Chicago 12 www.wu-wien.ac.at/earlym-l/organs/local.html life. There was a lot of hiding behind a quoted price that was made public to Carillon News by Brian Swager 12 e-mail: [email protected] screen of correctness for many years (not totally rebuild the organ by several very that Walcha needed to hide behind any- reputable companies. The organ was not In the wind . . . by John Bishop 13 thing). With the likes of such new Ital- damaged physically during the 9/11 at- On Teaching by Gavin Black 15 Prepress Operations DAN SOLTIS ian groups as that led by Fabio Biondi, tack except for dust, grit and small debris, performances have indeed become alive. some of which could have been there pre- REVIEWS The Germans are also catching on; I was viously due to below-par maintenance. Music for Voices and Organ 16 THE DIAPASON (ISSN 0012-2378) is published monthly by Scranton Gillette Communications, Inc., 3030 W. Salt most impressed last season with the work There is an insurance report about the Book Reviews 17 Creek Lane, Suite 201, Arlington Heights, IL 60005-5025. of the Akademie für alte Musik Berlin actual damage on fi le. New Recordings 18 Phone 847/391-1045. Fax 847/390-0408. Telex: 206041 as well as a recent performance by the Per St. Paul’s Chapel, I suggested MSG RLY. E-mail:
APRIL, 2008 3
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 3 3/10/08 11:15:26 AM Apostle, West Hartford, under the direc- sic of Roberta Bitgood (1908–2007) sung and Vaughan Williams, Five Mystical William Carey University will pres- tion of Richard Coffey, artistic director. by the choirs of First Church of Christ; Songs. For information: 801/328-8941; ent Frederick Swann and Mina Belle CONCORA will perform the same pro- June 8, fi rst-place winners of the 2007
Canterbury Singers USA at York Minster, UK University of Evansville AGO members at the Taylor & Boody organ in Vincennes, Indiana (l to r): Zachary Guenzel, Douglas Reed (sponsor), Michael Salazar, The Canterbury Singers USA (To- dent composer, Mark Bunce, received Matthew Vanover, Joshua Goodwin, Patrick Ritsch, Karol Farris, Cal Leferink, ledo, Ohio) sang for a week in residence its European premiere at York Minster. Jeremy Webster, and John Posey following Christmas at York Minster in This was the choir’s eleventh choral tour the UK. The seven services included fi ve to the UK and third visit to York. James The University of Evansville AGO works by Buxtehude on the Taylor & Choral Evensongs, one Choral Matins R. Metzler (front row, left) serves as chapter sponsored a concert commem- Boody organ (1981, II/22) at the First and one Choral Eucharist. A new setting director and Michael Gartz (front row, orating the 300th anniversary of Dietrich Christian Church in Vincennes, Indiana. of the Evening Canticles (Magnifi cat right) serves as organist. The choir will Buxtehude’s death on October 21, 2007. Some compositions were performed on and Nunc Dimittis) by the choir’s resi- return to the UK in 2009. Douglas Reed’s students performed the university’s McGary harpsichord.
4 THE DIAPASON
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 4 3/10/08 11:15:48 AM manual organ of 72 ranks was dedicated shire. In support of this effort, the “Villa” in recital by Frederick Swann, who will is providing a special package rate of return to play its 40th anniversary recital $398 for four night’s lodging and eleven on May 4 at 4 pm. In addition to his re- meals in the hotel dining room, inclusive cital, Mr. Swann will also be playing the of all taxes and tips. organ for the Sunday morning worship Organ demonstrations will be pre- service on May 4. For further informa- sented by John Atwood, Kevin Birch, tion, contact Lorenz Maycher, organist Ed Boadway, Carol Britt, Lynn Edwards at the church, at 601/428-8491. Butler, Charles Callahan, Michael Frie- sen, Mark Howe, Peter R. Isherwood, The American Organ Archives Barbara Owen, Lois Regestein, Permelia of the Organ Historical Society is Sears, and James L. Wallmann, and the sponsoring a tour of Vermont and New tour will visit two organ shops, those of Hampshire organs in the Lake Sunapee A. David Moore and Andrew T. Smith. region of New Hampshire as a benefi t for Restoration work by E. A. Boadway, A. the archives. Between August 25 and 29, David Moore, Stephen Russell, Andrew the tour will visit 15 historical organs by R. Smith, and Robert N. Waters will be Clarence Dickinson Casavant, Hook, Estey, Hamill, Hook & prominently featured. All participants Hastings, Hutchings, Plaisted, Johnson, are donating their efforts in support of discussing their lives and contributions Marklove, Alexander Mills, and A. David the American Organ Archives, the re- to church music. William Carey Uni- Frederick Swann Moore. Edgar A. Boadway, of Claremont, search library of the Organ Historical versity houses the Clarence Dickinson New Hampshire, is chairman. Of the $189 Society, located at Talbott Library, West- Collection, Dr. Dickinson’s own personal First Presbyterian Church, Laurel, registration, $130 of it will be tax deduct- minster Choir College, Rider University, library. For further information, contact Mississippi, announces the fortieth anni- ible as a charitable contribution. Princeton, New Jersey. Patricia Furr, head librarian at Carey versary of its 1968 Aeolian-Skinner, Opus Headquarters will be at Twin Lake For information, contact Stephen L. University, at 601/318-6170, or
Colin Andrews Cristina Garcia Banegas Emanuele Cardi Sophie-Véronique Shin-Ae Chun Organist/Lecturer/ Organist/Harpsichordist/Conductor Organist/Lecturer/ Cauchefer-Choplin Organist/Harpsichordist/ Recording Artist Organ Faculty and Chair Recording Artist Interpreter/Improviser/ Recording Artist Lecturer, Organ Performance University of the Republic Organ and Soprano with Lecturer/Recording Artist Music Director and Organist & Sacred Music Studies Conductor, De Profundis Polina Balva (St. Petersburg) Titular Organist First Congregational Church East Carolina University Vocal/Instrumental Ensemble Titular Organist St. Jean-Baptiste de la Salle Toledo, Ohio School of Music Director, International Organ Festival St. Maria della Speranza Deputy Titular Organist Greenville, North Carolina Montevideo, Uruguay Battipaglia, Italy St. Sulpice, Paris, France
Maurice Clerc Leon Couch Laura Ellis Catherine Ennis Faythe Freese Interpreter/Improviser/ Organist/Lecturer Organist Organist/Lecturer/Recording Artist Organist/Lecturer Recording Artist College Organist Associate Professor of Director of Music Associate Professor of Organ Titular Organist Assistant Professor of Organ Organ and Carillon St. Lawrence Jewry School of Music St. Benigne’s Cathedral and Music Theory University of Florida Trinity Laban Organ Professor University of Alabama Faculty Converse College Gainesville, Florida Irish Piper & Organ Duo Tuscaloosa, Alabama National Conservatory Spartanburg, South Carolina The Reduced Handel Company Dijon, France London, England
Johan Hermans Michael Kaminski Angela Kraft Cross William Kuhlman Tong-Soon Kwak Organist/Lecturer/ Organist Organist/Pianist/Composer/ Organist Organist Recording Artist Director of Music Ministries Recording Artist Professor of Music Emeritus Professor of Organ Conservatory of Music Saint Francis Xavier Church Organist Luther College College of Music Cathedral Organist Brooklyn College Faculty The Congregational Church Decorah, Iowa Yonsei University St. Quintinus Cathedral St. Francis College Faculty San Mateo, California Artistic Director Artistic Director Brooklyn, New York Torch International Organ Academy International Organ Festival Seoul, Korea Hasselt, Belgium www.ConcertArtistCooperative.com Beth Zucchino, Founder and Director 7710 Lynch Road, Sebastopol, CA 95472 PH: (707) 824-5611 FX: (707) 824-0956 Established in 1988
APRIL, 2008 5
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 5 3/10/08 11:16:12 AM of Music degree in organ performance Appointments and the Sacred Music Diploma from the Eastman School of Music, where he studied with David Higgs and Wil- Jennifer Bauer has been named di- liam Porter; he earned his Bachelor of rector of marketing and public relations Music degree at St. Olaf College under for VocalEssence. She holds a Bachelor John Ferguson. He is a graduate of the of Music in bassoon performance and American Boychoir School in Prince- an MBA from the University of Wis- ton, New Jersey, where he began his consin (Madison). Bauer previously musical career as a treble chorister un- served as direct marketing manager for der James Litton. the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, and Jacobson has earned fi rst prize in sev- has held positions with the DePaul Uni- eral organ competitions: the 2005 John versity School of Music, and the Elgin R. Rodland Scholarship Competition, Choral Union. For information:
University of Michigan Forum • 29th International Organ and Church Music Institute “Music of César Franck & Olivier Messiaen” June 15–17, 2008 Ralph Kneeream, Gordon Atkinson, Tapani Yrjola with U-M Faculty CONCORA executive director Jane Penfi eld, CONCORA board president Robert M. Borden, CONCORA artistic director Richard Coffey, Hartford Symphony Orchestra music director Edward Cumming U-M Historic Organ Tour 55 CONCORA celebrated the 60th birth- Church Music Institute in Waterville, Three Great Cities: Budapest, Vienna, Prague day of its founder and artistic director, Maine, and the University of Connecti- July 11–23, 2008 Richard Coffey, on February 2 at the cut at Storrs. Farmington Club in Farmington, Con- Coffey has served on the boards of Information from Conlin Travel, Ann Arbor necticut. The evening included dinner directors of the New Britain Symphony, 734/677-1562 and testimonials by Hartford Symphony the Hartford AGO chapter, and Chorus Orchestra music director Edward Cum- America. He also serves regionally as ad- ming and CONCORA executive director judicator and clinician for keyboard and Jane Penfi eld. Musical entertainment was choral competitions and festivals. He 48th Conference on Organ Music provided by the CONCORA singers. served for fi ve years on a panel of advi- October 5–8, 2008 Richard Coffey founded CONCORA, sors to the Institute of Sacred Music at Connecticut Choral Artists, as a profes- Yale University, and has made presen- “Music of Messiaen” sional vocal ensemble in 1974. He is or- tations at conventions of the American Commemorating the centenary of the composer’s birth ganist and minister of music of the South Choral Directors Association, Chorus Church of New Britain, where he con- America, and the American Guild of Or- Almut Rossler, Carolyn Shuster Fournier, Denny Wilke ducts a choir of professional and amateur ganists. He frequently writes reviews for singers and serves as artistic director of The Choral Journal. and U-M Faculty its music series. He is also music director Coffey holds degrees in music from the • of the Hartford Chorale. University of North Carolina at Greens- Coffey has prepared choruses for boro and the School of Sacred Music of For additional information: many orchestras and festivals, and was New York’s Union Theological Seminary. chorusmaster of the Connecticut Opera He was awarded France’s “premier prix” Dr. Marilyn Mason, Professor of Music Association for fi ve seasons. For three in organ performance following stud- The University of Michigan School of Music, Theatre and Dance years, Coffey was visiting artist in cho- ies with organist Marie–Claire Alain. In 1100 Baits Drive ral music at the Hartt School, Univer- 1992 Coffey was named Choral Director sity of Hartford, where he conducted of the Year by the Connecticut Chapter Ann Arbor, MI 48109 the Hartt Chamber Singers and taught of the American Choral Directors As- 734/764-2500 graduate seminars in choral literature. sociation. In 2007 he was awarded the [email protected] He has served on the faculties of Sum- Lifetime Achievement Award by the merTerm at Central Connecticut State Greater New Britain Arts Alliance and a University, the President’s College of Major Achievement Award by the Hart- the University of Hartford, the Colby ford Symphony Orchestra.
6 THE DIAPASON
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 6 3/10/08 11:16:32 AM
Frank Ferko Scott Hanoian Iain Quinn Martin Argall at Medinah Temple, 1978
-page 6 Fugue in A Minor, Prelude and Fugue on works including Bless the Lord, all you survived by his wife of 65 years, Charب ing in Action, 1943, which the Gunns “O Traurigkeit,” Fugue in A-fl at Minor, his hosts, Mirabile Mysterium, O esca lotte, two daughters, four grandchildren, have performed regularly in their all- and Prelude and Fugue in G Minor. Ha- viatorum, and the Magnifi cat and Nunc and a brother. American programs. The April concert noian was recently appointed director of dimittis, respectively. Quinn is director will focus on the life of monks, and it will music and organist at Christ Episcopal of cathedral music and organist at the Lloyd E. Cast, Jr. died on January also include works of Samuel Barber and Church in Grosse Pointe, Michigan. The Cathedral Church of St. John, Albuquer- 26. He was 75. Born in Hollywood, Cali- Olivier Messiaen. booklet comes with notes on the music, que, New Mexico. fornia, he received bachelor and master Ferko’s setting of O salutaris hostia for a full stoplist and an interview with Ha- of music degrees from Indiana Univer- unaccompanied SSAA chorus is featured noian about his career as a professional Daniel Roth is featured on a new sity, as well as a Doctor of Music (honoris on a new recording by the St. Mary’s musician. For information:
EHGLHQWRUJDQFRP Christian Lane • Thomas Winpenny • Samuel Gaskin
RONALD CAMERON BISHOP Consultant Distinguished pipe organ builders of Padua, Italy Pipe Organs Digital Enhancements Via Facciolati, 166 • 35127 Padua, Italy All-digital Instruments Telephone (39-049) 750-666 • Telefax (39-049) 850-483 • In the United States: 330-867-4370 8608 RTE 20, Westfield, NY 14787-9728 www.ruff atti.com • organs@ruff atti.com Tel 716/326-6500 Fax 716/326-6595
8 THE DIAPASON
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 8 3/10/08 11:17:00 AM DIANE BISH SIGNATURE SERIES COMBINATION ORGAN INSTALLED AT CORAL RIDGE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH
new combination Diane Bish A Signature Series™ digital and pipe organ has been installed in DeVos Chapel at Coral Ridge Presbyterian Church, Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Ms. Bish served as senior organist and artist-in-residence at Coral Ridge for over 20 years. The stunning three-manual, 58 stop instrument includes 20 ranks of pipes, including a Trompette en Chamade, in addition to its complement of digital voices. Burton K.Tidwell oversaw the details of the organ, including design, pipe scaling and tonal finishing.
Coral Ridge Presbyterian Church highlighted the new organ at Church Music Explosion 2008!
Diane Bish Signature Series™ Quantum™ DB-58Q Diane Bish has recorded a stunning virtuoso performance on the DeVos Chapel organ at Coral Ridge Presbyterian Church. This performance will be featured on the nationally broadcast Joy of Music television program. A DVD will be available for purchase on the Joy of Music web site: www.dianebishtv.com
150 Locust Street, P.O. Box 36 Macungie, PA 18062-0036 Phone: 610-966-2202 Fax: 610-965-3098 ® E-mail: [email protected] Web site: www.allenorgan.com state area of Iowa, Illinois and Wisconsin. Jean Langlais. After two years as director stein, grandsons of Felix F. Schoenstein, Scientist (The Mother Church), both in He was an inveterate convention-goer at of music at the First Unitarian Church who founded the company in 1877. In Boston, well into the 1980s. McKown meetings of both the American Guild of in Worcester, Massachusetts, he moved the 1980s Bertram came out of retire- cared meticulously for the Casavant or- Organists and the Organ Historical So- to New York in 1962 and enrolled at the ment for several years to help his brother gan as a gift to his church. ciety. He served on the committee that Union Theological Seminary, joining the Lawrence and new owner Jack Bethards The Organ Clearing House man- planned and executed the 1986 OHS seminary faculty in 1963 and completing to enlarge the fi rm’s operations. Edward aged the purchase and sale and served convention in eastern Iowa. his doctorate in sacred music in 1968. and Vincent have also been involved with as general contractor for the renovation August Knoll was well known as a suc- In 1964 Westenburg was hired as or- the company from time to time. The and modifi cation of the organ. The pit- cessful mentor of many music students, ganist and choirmaster at Central Pres- three brothers were proud to see that the man windchests were releathered by and many of these students went into byterian Church in Manhattan, and he traditions established by their family are Columbia Organ Works of Columbia, careers in music. He was also a famil- quickly assembled an early version of the continuing in the 21st century. Pennsylvania. The new case and build- iar fi gure playing and directing in many Musica Sacra Choir. He was also music —William Vaughan ing frame was designed by Jay Zoller community bands throughout the area. director of the Collegiate Chorale from and built by QLF Pipe Organ Compo- His constant support and interest in all 1973 to 1980 and a lecturer at the Metro- John-Paul Buzard Pipe Organ nents of Rocky Mount, Virginia. The things musical will be deeply missed. politan Museum of Art from 1979 to 1982. Builders is undertaking a comprehen- façade pipes were made of polished tin —Mark R. Nemmers In 1990 he became music director at the sive rebuilding of the Wicks organ at Holy with gilded mouths by Organ Supply In- Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church. Cross Lutheran Church in Collinsville, dustries of Erie, Pennsylvania. Karlheinz Stockhausen, age 79, died In addition to conducting, Westenburg Illinois. The church (in whose cemetery The organ was installed in Midlothian December 5, 2007. He began musical taught choral music and conducting at the 19th-century St. Louis organbuilder by Amory Atkin, president of the Organ studies at age six, with a local organist, the Mannes College of Music from 1971 Wilhelm Metz is buried) had at one point Clearing House, Joshua Wood, vice- Franz-Josef Kloth, and studied composi- to 1977, and led the choral department a 1914 tubular-pneumatic action Wicks president, and Terence Atkins, Dean tion with Swiss composer Frank Martin at the Juilliard School from 1977 to 1989. organ. This was replaced in 1946 by a Conry, and Nicolas Bruno of the OCH in Cologne and with Olivier Messiaen He was also a visiting professor at Rut- 2-manual, 11-rank electromechanical ac- crew. Executive director John Bishop and Darius Milhaud in Paris. An infl uen- gers University from 1986 to 1992. He is tion Wicks instrument, which was altered coordinated the various phases of the tial German composer, he was prominent survived by his two sons, two daughters, and enlarged by Wicks in 1976. The pres- project. Robert Waters and Scot Hun- in the avant-garde movement in the mid and six grandchildren. ent project includes complete rebuilding tington performed tonal fi nishing. to late 20th century; he wrote many com- of the console; installation of a new solid- Salisbury Presbyterian Church is positions that included electronic sound. state relay and combination action; total home to an active music program led by His 362 compositions include 45 choral refurbishment of all wind system compo- Sharon Miller, director, and John Miller, works. He founded the Stockhausen Here & There nents and windchests; installation of new organist. A dedication recital was played Foundation for Music in 1994, to pre- expression equipment; total revoicing of in November of 2007 by Bradley Welch serve his works and provide instructions the organ to bring its disparate pipes into of Dallas, Texas. on performing his music. Details can be Bärenreiter announces the release harmony with each other, and the instal- found at
www.mander-organs.com 27 Marlboro Lane • Eugene, OR 97405 Imaginative Reconstructions (541) 521-7348 [email protected]
10 THE DIAPASON
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 10 3/10/08 11:17:32 AM Celebrating 50 Years of
1950s
Rodgers Instruments A member of the Roland Group 1300 NE 25th Avenue Hillsboro, Oregon 97124 503.648.4181 [email protected] www.rodgersinstruments.com 2000s 1990s 1980s 1970s 1960s
FOUNDED 1958 Rockefeller Chapel, Chicago Carillon News by Brian Swager The Schantz Organ Company has completed the rebuild of and modifi - cations to the E. M. Skinner Opus 634 Sixth International Queen Fabiola (1928) at Rockefeller Chapel, Chicago. Carillon Competition When installation and tonal fi nishing Since its foundation in 1922, the Royal is complete the organ will stand at 132 Carillon School “Jef Denyn” in Mech- ranks. The tonal design of the instrument elen, Belgium, has been involved in the was restored to the original Skinner de- support and development of the art of sign. Additions and tonal modifi cations carillon playing. As part of this effort, to the organ have been made in keeping the school organizes the international with Skinner tonal concepts. The project Queen Fabiola Carillon Competition in is scheduled for completion later this cooperation with the city of Mechelen. spring. Built into the chapel in 1928, this This competition, widely recognized as organ is one of the few remaining mas- the most prestigious of its kind, provides terworks of Skinner. The original design a powerful stimulus for the recognition featured four manuals and 126 stops. For of carillon playing as an artistic expres- information:
Atlanta First United Methodist Church A.E. Schlueter Pipe Organ Company and Atlanta First United Methodist Church are pleased to announce the recent com- pletion and dedication of their new pipe organ.
This instrument features a 5-manual console and 93 ranks of pipes in 9 divisions. The complete specification is available at www.pipe-organ.com for this and other pro- jects. A.E. Schlueter Pipe Organ Co.
P.O. Box 838, Lithonia, GA 30058 800-836-2726 www.pipe-organ.com
12 THE DIAPASON
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 12 3/10/08 11:17:59 AM and one contemporary. On Sunday, the round before May 15 to the Royal Carillon trips, I’ve visited art museums from candidates will perform the obligatory School “Jef Denyn,” Frederik de Merod- Whitney to Walker and from Getty work as the contemporary composition, estaat 63, B-2800 Mechelen, Belgium. to Guggenheim. I’ve participated in a a baroque or classical work chosen by The organizers may refuse any submis- census of migrating whales in southern the jury, and a romantic composition also sions that do not meet the required stan- California, been to baseball games in chosen by the jury. dards. No appeal against their decision is a dozen cities, and attended a perfor- First Prize: €3000, Prize of the Minister possible. After approval by the organiz- mance of A Prairie Home Companion at of Culture of the Flemish Government ers, candidates will receive a confi rma- the Fitzgerald Theater in St. Paul. I’ve Second Prize: €2000, Prize of the tion and additional practical guidelines. worshipped in many of America’s great Province of Antwerp churches. On one notable Sunday morn- Third Prize: €1500, Prize of the City ing, I attended the radio broadcast at of Mechelen and the Mechelen City the Mormon Tabernacle, a nine o’clock Guides League service at the Episcopal cathedral, and Fourth Prize: €1300, Prize of the City In the wind . . . eleven-thirty at the Roman Catholic ca- of Roeselare and the Royal Tower and by John Bishop thedral, all in Salt Lake City. I’ve visited Carillon Society “Jef Denyn” John Bishop organbuilding shops all over the country. Fifth Prize: €1000, Prize of Mr. A. And restaurants—sushi in Los Angeles, Jans, honorary president of the Archeo- Life’s rhythm bers for the installation of new instru- an Argentinean steak house in Dallas, logical Society and Mr. P. van den Broek, Working with the Organ Clearing ments built by others. This means that Dungeness crab and salmon in Seattle, honorary director of the carillon school House is all about travel. Most organ- we travel frequently—sometimes it feels and I’ve mentioned before the Brazilian Extra Prize: €1000, Prize of SABAM builders spend most of their time in the like constantly. Many of our trips last two steak house in Philadelphia next to the for the best interpretation of a Belgian workshop building an instrument, and or three weeks. We arrive in a city, settle Wanamaker store. contemporary work. then go on the road to install it. Ours into a hotel, fi nd our way around, and es- Applicants should send their curricu- is mostly site work. The OCH crew is tablish a temporary life rhythm of work, “If you got to ask, you ain’t got it . . . ” lum vitae with a suitable photograph, busy dismantling or installing organs, rest, meals, and calling home. (Fats Waller answering a fan’s question the nine scores, and the choice of which shipping organs and organ parts around It’s fun to visit the sites that make a about rhythm) work they will perform in the elimination the country, or preparing organ cham- distant city special. While on business Exotic and exciting to be sure, but
EXCEL.
IN WORSHIP
IN PERFORMANCE
At Goulding & Wood, we understand that an instrument must serve the musicians who play it. Every aspect of our design is focused on providing the resources for the varying roles organists must fill. Our tonal designs offer creative and comprehensive resources for the authoritative performance of literature, the nuanced accompaniment of choirs, and the imaginative leadership of congregational singing. Our exclusive slider chest design, with our full ten-year war- ranty, ensures an unsurpassed reliability and effective musical response to the organist’s touch. Our visual designs sensitively complement the surroundings of the instrument while giving the musician ergonomic, intuitive control of the organ’s resources. In all aspects, the instrument creates an ideal setting for the musician’s inspiration to excel, both in worship and performance.
823 Massachusetts Avenue • Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 Voice: 800.814.9690 • Facsimile 317.637.5236 www.gouldingandwood.com
APRIL, 2008 13
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 13 3/10/08 11:18:17 AM often while traveling I miss the rhythm the quiet and regular pace of Pentecost of life at home—chores, meals, errands, through the summer, when choirs are on the familiarity of place. And while many recess, there’s no Sunday school, services evenings on the road bring thrilling new are moved to the chapel, fi sh are jumpin’, experiences, others are dull and lonely. and the cotton is high . . . one of these Recently I ate alone in a restaurant in mornings you’re gonna rise up singing, New York, where a young man was play- so hush little baby, don’t you cry. ing the piano. The food was good, service I’m thrilled by the rhythm of good friendly, and there was a pleasant bustle hymn playing. A steady and stately tem- in the place, but the piano playing was po, quick enough that the average con- deadly. He sat with rigid spine, ninety- gregant can sing a phrase in one breath, degree angle between neck and chin, slow enough that everyone can sing all never moving his head. He was play- the words. Some ebb and fl ow of regis- ing standard crooner-type stuff as if he tration—not only playing each stanza on a were an animatron in a department-store different setting or manual, but including Christmas tableau. (Some- plink, plink, some Swell-box action and a knob or two where- plink, plink, over the rainbow- to accentuate the text within the stanza. plink . . . skies- plink, plink, are- plink, The organist who can’t think of anything plink . . . ) Yikes. special to do with stanza three of Hymn As he went from one song to another, 432 in The 1982 Hymnal (O praise ye the I refl ected on rhythm, how on the one Lord!) isn’t worth listening to: hand it’s important for musical rhythm to be fi rm and clear, even dependable, O praise ye the Lord! All things that give and on the other hand it’s essential that sound; rhythm be fl exible and alive. A listener Hermann Eule keydesk, Ladegast organ, St. Nikolaikirche, Leipzig (copyright © each jubilant chord re-echo around; Hermann Eule Orgelbau, Germany; reprinted with permission) loud organs, his glory forth tell in deep is troubled by the unpredictability of tone, poor rhythm. A congregation is afraid to and sweet harp, the story of what he sing if the organist’s rhythm is untrust- company logo on the right-hand end of (ba-) long (ba) day, (ba-dump) . . .” My hath done. worthy. But if it’s too rigid or too strict, it the keydesk. car’s directional signals have a triplet stops being music. It’s like the little girl beat to them and make me think of the Doesn’t that imply some pistons being dressed up in a starched pinafore, afraid “I got rhythm . . . ” subject of Mendelssohn’s C-minor fugue pushed? (It was sung at our wedding and to move. Swiss musician and educator Émile (Prelude and Fugue in C minor) when I it gets me every time!) Once at lunch with colleagues (it was Jaques-Dalcroze (1865–1950) is best sit at a traffi c light: (ba-dee, ba-dah, ba- Stanza three of O little town of Bethle- the Brazilian place in Philadelphia, you known for the development of Eurhyth- dee, ba-dah . . .). hem gives another registration hint: How really have to try it!), we were joined by a mics, a study of motion as it relates to the Nowadays, carpenters often use pneu- silently, how silently, the wondrous gift lover of organ music who was also a clas- performance of music. As a student at matic nail guns that are loaded with car- is given. Please don’t tear into that with sic-car enthusiast. He talked about driv- Oberlin in the 1970s, I was lucky to par- tridges of nails or staples. But watch a mixtures and trumpets a-popping. ing on a beautiful road in a terrifi c car, ticipate in a special month-long seminar skilled carpenter using an old-fashioned Or how about Dear Lord and Father up and down hills, slowing a little before in Eurhythmics, led by Oberlin’s retired “analog” hammer—it’s a pleasure to see of Mankind (I know, I know, it’s not in- a curve and accelerating through it, tak- professor of Eurhythmics Inda Howland, his natural rhythm as even, free strokes clusive . . .), stanza fi ve: ing a moment to notice a beautiful view who had studied with and was a disciple of the hammer send the nail into the or a particular building. He compared of Dalcroze. wood in even increments. Twenty nails, Breathe through the hearts of our desire this with musical performance. A great There’s a touching anecdote about how a hundred strokes, no bruised thumbs, I thy coolness and thy balm; musician, he said, knows how to step on Dalcroze was led to develop this special- feel another song coming on (and it’s not Let sense be dumb, let fl esh retire; speak through the earthquake, wind, and fi re, the gas just enough to make a passage ty. He was working with a piano student If I had a hammer . . . ). O still, small voice of calm. thrilling, how to slow slightly to notice a whose rhythm was poor enough that he We think of rhythms in larger cycles. special sight, how to put the pressure on had trouble playing even beats. Look- Where we live, the ocean’s high tides are That’s one hymn I wouldn’t end on Gen- when things get exciting. ing out his window across the campus about twelve hours and twenty or thirty eral 8. Listening to Mr. Plink-Plink in New where he taught, Dalcroze happened to minutes apart. It’s not an exactly regular The organist reads the words and York, I thought of that Philadelphia see this student striding along with pur- cycle, but high tide advances by about thinks of stop combinations, rhythmic lunch where all of us around the table re- poseful rhythmic footsteps. It was clear forty-fi ve minutes each day. It affects liberties, commas inviting breaths. The sponded to the driving metaphor. I loved to him that the student had good rhythm the rhythm of life in subtle ways. My organbuilder thinks of quiet stop actions, the images from that conversation. I pic- at least in his walking, and Dalcroze was wife takes a water shuttle to her offi ce. If fast pistons, swell shutters that don’t tured an organist wearing Great Race- inspired to understand how to connect it’s low tide at seven-thirty in the morn- squeak, bass pipes that speak promptly. style goggles, gloves, and scarf playing a the easy rhythms found in everyday life, ing, the ramp to the boat is dramatically How can your organist play rhythmically snazzy toccata. such as footsteps and heart beats, with steeper than if it’s high tide—an issue in if low C says fffffwwwaah? Having never owned a Porsche, I musical performance. winter weather. The cycles make it be And this is where the art of organbuild- didn’t know until recently that the auto- Dalcroze exercises are tailored to em- something like high tide one Monday, ing really gets special. Of all the musi- maker publishes a magazine for its cus- ulate natural and easy forms of rhythm. low tide the next Monday. cal instruments, the organ is the most tomers. One of our neighbors does drive You toss or bounce a ball back and forth We tell time in days, weeks, and mechanical. Any medium-sized organ a Porsche, and he thought I’d be inter- in musical time with a partner for ex- months. The tides tell time in lunar has thousands upon thousands of mov- ested in an article about a pipe organ that ample, establishing a beat and letting the months—the tide clock on our wall ing parts, little things pushing and pull- he read in the Porsche magazine. bounce of the ball occupy one beat, two counts lunar seconds. For centuries, the ing, huffi ng and puffi ng. Switches open In 2002, Porsche established a new beats, or a four-beat measure. The pace British Navy used tide cycles as pay peri- and close, magnets are energized by the factory in Leipzig, Germany, joining of the rhythm is defi ned by the arc of the ods—there are thirteen lunar months in hundred, huge masses of wood move si- luminaries like Franz Liszt, J. S. Bach, bounce—it fl oats or soars, giving the im- a year so there were thirteen paychecks. lently as a swell pedal is moved by the Johann Goethe, Robert and Clara age or feeling of freedom within rhyth- Ocean tides give us the image of ebb organist. A rhythmical poke at a toe stud Schumann, and Kurt Masur as good citi- mic defi nition. If it’s a four-beat bounce, and fl ow, and we translate that into larger gives a rhythmic response. No organ- zens. As the fi rm was introducing itself it has a life and airiness not found in the cycles like the rhythm of holiday seasons. ist, chorister, or congregant has to wait to the city, it provided funding for the pile-driving, one-beat bounce, a great As I write, Lent has just started. We’re or be jarred by a machine responding a renovation of the great Ladegast organ demonstration of rhythmic principles. coming out of the post-Christmas ebb, split-second late. A good tracker action at St. Nikolaikirche, the “other” church Where do we fi nd rhythm in our lives? getting ready to step on the gas and ac- operates in real time. A good electric or in the town where Bach made music. Drive on a concrete highway. There are celerate into Easter with its strong ju- electro-pneumatic action operates at the Hermann Eule of Bautzen, Germany, expansion joints every fi fty feet or so and bilant rhythms (a-ha-ha-ha-ha lay-hay speed of light: 670,616,629.2 miles per was the organbuilder, and the artists at the tires of your car go ba-dump, ba- looo-ooo ya). Many church musicians hour or 186,282.397 miles per second. Porsche won a major design prize for the dump, ba-dump. When I was a kid these see post-Easter ebbs, followed by spe- Let’s face it, we can argue about control- keydesk. (See photo.) Hang on to your rhythms inspired family singing: “I’ve cial services at Pentecost, church-school ling the speed of attack but there’s no ap- hats! Form follows function? Careful of been working on the rail- (ba-dump) Sunday, and something around high- preciable difference in response time. your tempos. And be sure to note the road (ba-dump), all (ba-dump) the live- school graduation, all of which leads into The machines we build that blow air into organ pipes must support the player with instant response so the machine can THE ORGAN CLEARING HOUSE vanish into the art. That achieved, the rhythm can be free, the music alive, and CASAVANT ORGAN, OPUS 3178, 1972 we can leave Mr. Plink-Plink sitting stiffl y on a piano bench in New York, stifl ing an Before(left): otherwise pleasant dinner, while we ac- Centre Methodist celerate into a turn with the sun shining Church, Malden, MA and the wind in our hair. Q After(right): Salisbury Presbyterian Church, Midlothian, VA OrganmasterShoes FAST Delivery Ɣ 3 Widths Renovated and installed by the Organ Clearing HALF Sizes Available House. New Case by QLF Pipe Organ Components.
The Organ Clearing House PO Box 290786 • Charlestown, MA 02129 Ph: 617.688.9290 • www.organclearinghouse.com John Bishop Amory Atkin Joshua Wood Call us: 1 (413) 773-0066 9-5 EST Executive Director President Vice President FAX 1 (413) 773-0166 organmastershoes.com
14 THE DIAPASON
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 14 3/10/08 11:18:34 AM Bach’s E-fl at major fugue: bine stops that don’t even produce the gression or a bit of a hymn is good—add- b-fl at – g – c – b-fl at – same letter-name notes as one another. ing and taking away various 4′ and higher On Teaching e-fl at – e-fl at – d – e-fl at This is certainly the thing that seems the stops at random. by Gavin Black Depending on what the overtones of least intuitive and the most questionable 4) after a while, remove the 8′ stop. each pipe happen to be doing, a counter about registration to many of those who The student will hear the music sudden- melody could arise that went like this: are not yet experienced with the organ. ly jump up in pitch. Registration and teaching—Part II d – d – g – d – g – g – f# – g (This can be true especially if someone 5) repeat all of this with a softer 8′ stop. In last month’s column, I emphasized or that went like this: stops to think about all of the pitches that Anyone performing or listening to this the usefulness of starting off the teach- f – b – e – f – b-fl at – are present in a thick texture. For exam- exercise will certainly notice that not all ing of registration with a clear explana- b-fl at – f# – b-fl at ple, a G-major 7th chord played on a reg- of the combinations work equally well. 2 tion of the meaning of the foot-desig- or any number of other possibilities. It istration that includes a 2 ⁄3′ stop includes Some of the sounds that could blend in nation of organ stops and with a set of will be different for each different stop on the pitches g, a, b, c, d, f, f#. If you throw theory will not seem to blend very well in demonstrations of that meaning. This is a which you play the melody. The “extra” in a tierce you add a d#. That this would practice, perhaps because a 4′ or higher necessary foundation for understanding melody will be quiet, and usually it will be acceptable makes a lot more sense if stop is too loud or too bright (or for that everything about combining stops and range from one to three octaves above you know that all of those “extra” pitches matter out of tune) or because a given 8′ about choosing organ sounds for music. the “offi cial” melody. It is quite possible are present anyway as overtones.) stop is too thin or weak or has something Once a student clearly understands the that these inherent counter-melodies are So the most basic description of the about its intrinsic overtone development meaning of all the numbers on the stop one source of the human invention of structure of the art of combining organ that confl icts with rather than supports knobs, it is time for that student to be- counterpoint. This is all a bit of a detour stops, and the most useful as a starting the addition of higher-pitched stops. gin exploring the art of combining stops. from learning techniques of registration point, goes something like this: that, as These considerations are extremely im- This starts with developing an awareness as such, but it is a useful exercise both for long as you have one or more 8′ stops portant. They are also subjective and in of what the stop pitch levels imply about learning to listen carefully to sound and present in your combination of stops, the end belong to the realm of artistic the structure of stop combinations, and for remembering that sounds themselves anything and everything higher than 8′ judgment or discretion. A student listen- continues with the development of an are complex and interesting, often doing pitch has the potential to blend with the 8′ ing to or trying out this exercise should be ear for the aesthetic nature of different more than we might at fi rst expect.) sound. In so doing, it will change the na- encouraged to notice aesthetic aspects of sounds, and then with the acquisition of Once a student understands the basic ture of the sound by changing the overall each sound. However, the main point for knowledge about registration practices concept of overtones (and believes in balance of the overtones, and by changing the moment is that the dropping of the 8′ in different schools of organ composition them!), it is easy for him or her to under- the volume, but it will not upset the pitch pitch makes a sound that is utterly differ- or in the work of specifi c composers. stand the blending of stops of different identifi cation of the notes that you play. ent in kind from the adding or dropping The concept that it is OK to combine pitches: a 4′ stop blends with and rein- A simple exercise to demonstrate this of any higher-pitched stops. stops that are not at the same pitch level as forces the fi rst upper partial of an 8′ stop, would be as follows: Of course, it might occur to a student, 2 one another, and that the resulting sound a 2 ⁄3′ stop the second upper partial, a 2′ 1) choose a keyboard that has more or a teacher might want to mention for will be (or at least can be) a coherent mu- stop the third, etc. One advantage of go- than one 8′ stop and several higher- completeness if nothing else, that it is per- sical sound at a coherent pitch level, is not ing through all of this quite systematical- pitched stops. fectly possible to use sounds that omit 8′ self-evident. In fact, it is counterintuitive ly is that it answers the question of how 2) draw the louder (loudest) 8′ stop. stops, for some special reason or in some to most people who have not already be- in the world it can make sense to com- 3) play a simple passage—a chord pro- special way. The simplest of these is the come well versed in organ registration. It seems, if anything, self-evident that this kind of mixing will result in obvious paral- lel octaves and fi fths, and also in a gener- alized jumble of pitches, which would at a minimum make clarity impossible (be- cause notes that you play in the tenor reg- ister, for example, would produce pitches proper to the treble register, etc.). Since the blending of stops at different pitch levels in fact can work the way it does be- cause of the overtone series, it is useful to explain something about overtones to students. It is certainly not necessary to go into all of the scientifi c details—the physics of the creation of overtones, the reasons for inharmonicity of overtones in certain situations, or even what the notes of the overtone series are, above the fi rst few. However, it is a good idea to review the basics: 1) Almost all musical sounds pro- duced acoustically have many frequen- cies blended together. (It usually takes a Uif!Sfw/!Tvtbo!Gmboefst! computer to produce a sound at exactly Sfdups one frequency.) Uif!Sfw/!Ibssjtpo!Xftu 2) These frequencies are (usually) a) a given frequency and b) other frequencies !Bttpdjbuf!Sfdups that are multiples of that fi rst frequency. (Of course we use the lowest frequency Boof!Ujnqbof to identify the note, as in “A 440.”) Ejsfdups!pg!Nvtjd!Njojtusjft 3) These multiples produce sounds Tu/!KpioÖt!! that are related to the lowest frequency Dzouijb!Tuspnbo by common musical intervals: octave, Fqjtdpqbm!Divsdi Pshbo!Dpnnjuuff octave-and-a-fi fth, two octaves, two-oc- taves-and-a-third, etc. Opsxppe!Qbsjti Tv{boof!Xfmdi On most organs it is possible to fi nd PxofsÖt!Sfqsftfoubujwf individual notes on some stops in which Difwz!Dibtf-!Nbszmboe some specifi c overtones can be heard as Uisff!nbovbm!boe!qfebm!.! separate pitches. These can be used to demonstrate the existence of overtones 74!Sbolt-!69!Tupqt and the pitch levels of some of them. Gedeckts, fl utes, and quintadenas are of- Efejdbujpo!.!Tbuvsebz-!Nbz!21 ten the most fruitful for this, and notes in Gps!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!dpoubdu!uif! the octave and a half or so below middle c are the most promising, because they are divsdi!pgßdf!bu!412.765.8878/ the easiest to hear. Usually it is possible to fi nd a pipe or two in which the twelfth is clear (quiet, perhaps, but clear), others in which the seventeenth is, and others in which the octaves are. To someone who has never tried to listen to overtones be- fore, these sounds are usually hard to hear at fi rst, but then suddenly “come in.” The teacher can help with this, fi rst by mak- Uif!Efßojujpo!pg!Mfhbdz ing sure to zero in on the pipes with the clearest individual overtones, and then by briefl y playing, singing, or whistling the actual note corresponding to the overtone that you wish to help the student to hear. *«iÊ"À}>Ê Õ`iÀÃ This will attune the student’s expectation to that pitch, and it will probably only be Ejsfdu!jorvjsjft!up;!! necessary for the fi rst few notes. (A further exercise in listening to over- tones is this: play a simple melody on one Cfshibvt!Qjqf!Pshbo!Cvjmefst stop. Try to hear and follow the counter- 3262!Nbejtpo!Tusffu-!Cfmmxppe-!JM!71215 melody created by the clearest and most 819.655.5163!¦!xxx/cfshibvtpshbo/dpn noticeable overtones. For example, con- sider the notes of the fugue subject of
APRIL, 2008 15
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 15 3/10/08 11:18:53 AM use of a 4′ or higher sound to play the mu- three. In planning registration for a piece Using a trumpet with the weekly an- sic at an octave or more higher than the on the harpsichord, it is always possible Music for Voices them and as an addition to the singing of written pitch. Also fairly common is the to use what I consider to be the soundest hymns will certainly add spark to the ser- use of a non-8′ registration accompanied and most artistically thorough approach: and Organ vice. As William Rice says in A Concise by the moving of the hands to a differ- simply trying the piece out on every pos- by James McCray History of Church Music: ent position on the keyboard to bring the sible sound, listening carefully and with pitch in line with original expectations. attention, and deciding which sound you Church music is suffering from severe These are useful things to bear in mind as like best. Choir with trumpet growing pains. Interest in the development a performing organist, but they are spe- This approach is almost always impos- of an effective program of church and The quality of tone of the trumpet is no- church-school music was, until recently, cial cases that can best be thought about sible on the organ. It is always impossible limited to a few more or less well-trained at a slightly later stage in learning, and on any organ but the very smallest. How- ble and brilliant; it comports with warlike ideas, with cries of fury and of vengeance, musicians, ministers, and even fewer educa- that should certainly not distract a stu- ever, it seems to me that it is still—albeit as with songs of triumph; it lends itself to tors. The present trend is toward involving dent from developing the most thorough only in an underlying theoretical way— the expression of all energetic and grand all who are directly or indirectly affected by possible understanding of “normal” stop the best approach, and the right concept sentiments, and to the majority of tragic church music in the exciting and disturbing combination and registration. The same to have in the back of one’s mind when accents. exploration of the contributions music can can be said about the use of 16′ sound in working out registrations. That this is —Hector Berlioz (1803–1869) make to the total life of the church. multi-voiced or chordal manual playing. true can, I think, be almost proven logi- This, in theory, just transposes the music cally. If you are using a given registration, Berlioz’s description quoted above The reviews below feature choir an- down an octave, but often doesn’t—for whether it comes from an editor, or from certainly lends itself to use with choirs, thems with trumpet. As the church year some psychoacoustic or just plain acoustic your teacher, or from something that you although in church situations the trum- for the choir winds down this spring fol- reasons—quite sound like that. jotted down in your copy years before, pet is most often found as a component lowing an early Easter, programming a So far we have developed a rather or from any other source, but there is of a brass ensemble. Easter may be the work with trumpet may be inspirational scientifi c approach—perhaps too sci- in fact a different registration that you most frequently consistent use of choir not only to the congregation, but also to entifi c for some people’s taste—to the would like better if only you heard it, with brass in church services; however, the choir. teaching or learning of registration. We then you should in theory be using that there is a wealth of repertoire available have asked students to think very clearly other registration. Therefore, ideally, to choral directors that uses the trum- Remembrance, Dan Locklair. SATB, about the pitch designations of stops, one would always hear every registration pet as a solo instrument. Smaller church trumpet in C, and organ, Subito Mu- about overtones, about what overtones before making a fi nal choice. choirs often are overpowered by a brass sic, 9148000-445, $2.25 (M). imply about the use of different pitches (I am not right now dealing with the ensemble, so using just the trumpet still Using the famous Matthew 5 text of of stops, and about how to make sure extra-musical quasi-ethical consider- gives a noble quality to the choir without the Beatitudes, Locklair’s sensitive work that a sound is grounded in unison pitch. ations of authenticity that arise when sacrifi cing the voices. A prime example is a tribute to the memory of his par- We have not yet talked about either how a specifi c registration comes from the of this may be seen in Dan Locklair’s Re- ents. The choir is often divisi, with the to choose registrations that “sound good” composer. I will address that at least membrance reviewed below. women and/or men in four parts singing (or “beautiful” or “appropriate” or any- briefl y next month.) In a recommended book by James close harmonic chords that unfold dia- thing else) or about how to respect com- The purpose of taking a student very Ode titled Brass Instruments in Church tonically to create the warm, mild dis- posers’ wishes or any other way to tailor systematically through what I described Services (Augsburg Publishing House), sonances. The trumpet part adds to the sounds to pieces. We have also barely above as a scientifi c approach to the the author reminds the reader that “The serenity of the music with slow, sustained mentioned stop names, or even names technique of registration—the feet, the sounds of the ram’s horn in Biblical times, lines of a repeated theme between the of important categories of stops, diapa- overtones, the combinations at different while not producing beautiful tones, did textual verses. The organ part, on three sons, fl utes, reeds, and so on. Nor have pitch levels—is to allow the student then convey defi nite messages to the people staves, includes registrations and is very we mentioned any rules or even ideas to feel free to try anything and everything of God and became a traditional part of easy, often doubling the choral parts. about how or whether to combine stops (again, knowing that there won’t really be the worship service.” This useful book This gentle music is fi lled with repeti- of different types, or for that matter of time for everything!) without fear of do- has three parts to it: I: Brass Instruments tion, making the music easy to learn and the same type. ing something that really, in some con- in Worship since the Reformation; II: perform. Highly recommended to choirs Organs have lots and lots of sounds. crete way, doesn’t and can’t work. This Preparations for Church Performances; capable of singing in four parts for both For example, by my calculations, allow- will enable the student to be relatively III: Scoring for Brass Instruments. The the women and the men. ing only for sounds that include 8′ pitch independent of outside guidelines, and historical background in chapter I is of and leaving cornets and “céleste” stops increase the chance that the student will particular interest, although the appen- I Am Forever Who I Am, Kurt von out of any ensemble, but taking into ac- contribute something new and interest- dix contains collections of music suitable Kampen. SAB or SATB, congrega- count couplers, the Grand Orgue of the ing to the world of the organ. It will also for use in church services. Today, with tion, trumpet, suspended cymbal, Mander organ at St. Ignatius Loyola in almost certainly provide the student with the myriad of publications for choir/ timpani, and organ, Concordia Pub- New York—a well-known, recent, large a great measure of out-and-out fun, and brass, the scoring chapter (III) may be of lishing House, 98-3865, $1.60 (M-). but not gargantuan organ—commands keep the job of practicing as interesting the least interest to most directors. This is the choral score; full score and 121,889,158,594,564 different sounds. as it can be. The trumpet is especially useful instrumental parts are separate although A hypothetical medium-sized organ in Next month I will talk about ways to in hymn singing. In many of today’s a reproducible congregational page is on which three manuals have 25 to 30 stops practice listening to the more subjective, churches congregational singing has lost the back cover. There are fi ve verses to would have about 200 million to about sound-quality-oriented aspects of the its fervor. The melody is often barely the text, with the congregation joining on a billion 8′-based sounds available in the blending and combining of stops. I will heard rising from the congregation, but some of them and always on the refrain. manual divisions. If the pedal division also talk about helping students to begin if enhanced with a trumpet on some of Most of the choral music is in unison or of such an organ had eight stops, then, to relate sound to other aspects of their the verses, it will burst forth regally, es- two parts and repeats the basic melody assuming normal couplers, the pedals concept of a piece of music, and to both pecially on hymns having a robust text with additional obbligato or harmony would have a quarter of a trillion differ- structural and historical considerations. Q of praise. Furthermore, adding a trum- lines. The organ part, on two staves, gen- ent sounds available. pet to the introduction of the hymn may erally doubles the voices. Gavin Black is director of the Princeton Harpsichords, on the other hand, have Early Keyboard Center in Princeton, New inspire the congregation to sing with rather few sounds. Most large harpsi- Jersey. He welcomes feedback by e-mail at greater enthusiasm than usual. To save You Call Us, Lord, William Braun. chords have seven to ten different avail-
Specialists in Choral ANNUAL AND ONE-TIME COPYRIGHT and Organ Music
2209 Crestmoor Road, Suite 220 Nashville, TN 37215 PERMISSIONS WITH THE 615-386-3542 § 800-851-9023 § 615-297-4291 Fax www.loisfyfemusic.com CLICK OF A MOUSE
• EASY—online permission and reporting • ECONOMICAL—based on average weekend attendance • THOROUGH—your favorite songs • CONVENIENT—includes a growing list of publishers
LOG ON TODAY! WWW.ONELICENSE.NET
16 THE DIAPASON
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 16 3/10/08 11:19:10 AM Father’s God in Years Long Gone.” This sings alternating phrases with the adults. It would be diffi cult to fi nd a person gation participate in the music of that version is primarily a unison statement The opening has a trumpet fanfare, which more qualifi ed than William Smith to worship and not simply appreciate it as with an obbligato line or contrasting bass later continues above the choir before an write this book. From his doctoral dis- concertgoers might; and yet, inasmuch line for the men. The setting is easy, with extended, more lyrical solo section with sertation (“Musical Aspects of the New as he recognizes that any “group noise” limited trumpet music. the organ. There is a reproducible page Testament”) through his work as a mu- requires leadership, he devotes a good for the congregation; they join the choir sical educator and pastor, to his current deal of space to choirs, soloists, instru- Praise We the Lord, Michael Larkin. on the refrains. The music is not diffi cult work as an active member of the Hymn mentalists, and even “song leaders.” As SATB, trumpet, and keyboard, Con- and is a wonderful simple setting that Society of the United States and Canada for matters of taste, “[n]o kind of music cordia Publishing House, 98-3800, brings children and adults together. and chaplain of a chapter of the Ameri- is barred from the church’s worship as $1.75 (M). can Guild of Organists, Smith marshals long as it is useful to the congregation.” A transposed trumpet part is included Around the Throne They Stand, Dan- his years of experience and the depth These statements, taken together, point on the back cover. The trumpet plays iel Preus. SATB, trumpet, organ, and of his thoughtful consideration to guide to the sorts of tensions the pastors and throughout most of the anthem with congregation, Concordia Publishing the reader through some of today’s more musicians, for whom the book is written, a simple lyric line that soars above the House, 98-3684, $1.60 (M-). perplexing issues regarding music in increasingly face. Before he gets into choir. The keyboard part, on two staves, The fi rst three pages are for trumpet/ Christian worship. He is even married to the labyrinthine byways of choice facing is a chordal accompaniment that is very organ, who play a long introduction be- a church organist! I am a retired pastor those who design worship services today, easy. With the choral parts on two staves fore the choir enters. The fi rst two verses who—having been guided in these mat- he examines the biblical, historical, and and often in two parts, this anthem will are for the choir in unison to the same ters over the years by knowledgeable and theological perspectives on music as wor- very useful to smaller church choirs, but music. The third verse employs the con- perceptive music colleagues—never had ship. Virtually every page is replete with it is strange that there is no tempo indi- gregation, and the fourth the unaccom- to face or solve many of the problems he citations of biblical passages, allusions to cation in the score. panied choir; everyone sings on the fi fth examines. And yet I fi nd myself mutter- historical debates and revolutions in ser- verse, which grows to an “alleluia” and ing occasionally, “I wish I’d had this book vice music, and his theological justifi ca- Nations, Hear the Prophet’s Word, “amen.” Music for the trumpet and con- 30 years ago!” tions for his position. arr. Jeffrey Honoré. SAB, trumpet, gregation is included on the back cover. Smith sets forth his theological posi- Readers of this book will search for optional fl ute, and keyboard, Choris- tion early on: “the most fundamental his opinions on some of the larger issues. ters Guild, CGA 1002, $1.85 (E). axiom of music in the church” is that the Is contemporary worship music, with its Subtitled “All Creation Clap Your “role of music in the church is that of ser- “praise teams” and rock-and-roll beats, Hands,” this setting has two different Book Reviews vant; its task is functional, diaconal, and replacing our more traditional music, and texts, one for Advent and one for Epiph- pastoral.” And lest the word “servant” if so, to what effect? Is the organ a dying any. The choral parts are on two staves mislead, he maintains that music is not instrument? Are hired professional mu- with the theme based on “Good King Joyful Noise: A Guide to Music in the intended merely to facilitate worship, sicians replacing volunteer choirs in our Wenceslas.” The fl ute and trumpet parts Church for Pastors and Musicians, but rather that the “music of the church’s newer churches? In his examination of are included separately at the end. The William S. Smith. Providence House service is itself worship.” Given the fact each of these—and many, many more— music is bouncy, rhythmic and is useful Publishers, Franklin, TN, 2007. Pa- that a worship service is literally for the questions Smith provides a useful his- for small choirs. With the pre- and post- per, $24.95; purpose of worship by all participants, torical context, from ancient Israeli wor- Christmas texts it is not only a bargain
APRIL, 2008 17
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 17 3/10/08 11:19:29 AM the early church and Reformation, to celebratory mass on November 29, 1926, ing the resources of the Cavaillé-Coll the mid-20th century, before turning to New Recordings when the Cavaillé-Coll Grand Orgue at organ extremely well. This is the longest more recent changes, and demonstrates St. Sulpice was rededicated after ma- movement on the recording and much of thereby that our current disputes are not jor restoration work. Philippe Bellenot it is played on full organ. so new after all. Obstinate adherents to The Widor Mass, Op. 36: The Grand (1860–1928), who is represented by four A soft, much shorter improvisation, single positions on any of these questions 19th-Century St. Sulpice Tradition. choral works on this recording, was the Salut du Saint-Sacrement, then sets the may be disappointed that Smith usually Daniel Roth, grand orgue; Mark organist of the Orgue de Chœur and mood for Benediction, which follows the winds up looking at both sides, point- Dwyer & Stephen Tharp, orgue choir director at St. Sulpice from 1878 Mass. The fi rst choral work in this section ing out the pros and cons, and taking a de chœur; Chœur Darius Milhaud, to 1922. Thus, for 44 years he worked is Philippe Bellenot’s Tantum Ergo, and middle position. But his conclusions are Camille Haedt-Goussu, director. in tandem with Widor in arranging the this is a little disappointing, suggesting inexorably determined by the general Recorded at Saint Sulpice, Paris, music. After Bellenot’s death in 1928, that the earlier and equally disappointing theological understanding of worship France. JAV Recordings compact disc Widor commented that he had lost a Ave Maria might have been fairly charac- set forth in the early chapters; and such JAV 158;
18 THE DIAPASON
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 18 3/10/08 11:19:51 AM time meeting with brides or recording Dr. Pascual, appointed in 2003, is the publishers and catalog numbers in the were published in his lifetime, op. 8 for their own renditions. fi rst woman to hold this distinguished accompanying booklet. A group of seven organ or harpsichord, and op. 10 for or- These performances feature the large post; her musical playing places her instrumentalists, the Ars Nova Brass, gan, pianoforte or harpsichord; but the 106-rank Aeolian-Skinner organ at the squarely in line with such predecessors play in Bruckner’s elegant Tota pulchra two sets of Nine Voluntaries were pub- National Presbyterian Church in Wash- as Pietro Yon and the blindingly brilliant es as well as the concluding number by lished posthumously, with only the organ ington, DC. Installed in 1969 and report- Charles Courboin. It is great to hear Jiʼní Ropek, Salve Regina. being mentioned on the title page, and edly built in “American Classic” style, the Bruce Simonds’ Dorian Prelude on “Dies —Charles Huddleston Heaton the Voluntary in D survives in MS only. organ is a fi ne but not remarkable instru- Irae,” one of his two classic compositions Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania In these fi ve volumes, David Patrick has ment. Its strengths seem aligned with the for organ. Lynn Trapp’s exciting Images
APRIL, 2008 19
Apr 08 pp. 2-21.indd 19 3/10/08 11:20:11 AM sages marked p and f, and also full organ Flute, which could well be used through- from bar 7 to be taken too quickly), no. Swell, with an even greater leaning to- (which was occasionally suggested as an out apart from where the direction “Di- 5/3 in D minor, where the echoing phras- wards the language of the galant, and the alternative to Diapasons by some com- aps” appears between the staves in the es are marked for fl ute, no. 7/2 in E with fi rst movements are again richly varied posers). The second movements of Set I original; the original contains the direc- triplet 16th-notes, and no. 8/3 in A, both in style—only nos. 3, 5 and 6 are in the are for Trumpet, although here marked tion “Gr. Organ” at a distance of two for Echo Cornet. The one movement for older style for Diapasons. as for Swell, with a 26-bar conclusion for bars from “Diaps,” which is retained in Trumpet and Echo is no. 5/2 in D, the Many of the pieces contain full four- Diapasons in no. 1, fugal (Nos. 2 and 3), the modern edition, but it does not seem instruction Trumpet Bass appearing in note chords in the bass, and particular for Cornet (Nos. 5–9), of which 3, 5 and to make sense without linking the two; bar 47; there is no instruction to revert to care should be exercised that the stops 7 have short written-out cadenzas over a footnote to this effect may well have the Choir in bar 58 when the Echo reap- selected are not too thick and muddy in the 6/4 chords supplied by the editor, been useful in guiding the less-experi- pears, the Trumpet bass probably being the bottom octaves. There are several which could be used as a model to deco- enced player. used from bar 68 to the end. passages in thirds that will require care- rate the 6/4 chord in no. 9. No. 8 ends The one-movement Voluntary No. 5 The middle movements of nos. 1, 3, 8, ful practicing to ensure a clean perfor- with ten bars, which, although without varies from chordal writing for Full, to and 10 are written for the Swell (in no. mance. A few movements call for a low registration in the original, were prob- indications for Swell and for Choir when 10 the indication is omitted in this edition, B, A or G, which was available on the ably intended as a close on the Diapa- p is also present against both at their fi rst although printed clearly in the original) English organ of Dupuis’ time; today sons, as Jonas Blewitt recommended in appearance; in addition there is the use and comprise cantabile decorated me- these notes will have to be supplied on his treatise; here the editor has marked of p and f without manuals being speci- lodic lines against chords, with written- the pedals. The editor has suggested them as Swell. In this voluntary, the fi - fi ed. First movements are also quite var- out cadenzas. In no. 3 f and p are marked, other places where the pedals (normally nal chord in the Cornet movement con- ied, with 1/1 and 2/1 being for Diapasons but there is plenty of scope in the others pull-downs permanently coupled to the tains a tenor A, which was not available only. No. 3/1 is a bright Allegro for Full for judicious use of the swell pedal. The Great) could be used. on the 18th-century Cornet, suggesting Organ, with testing 16th-note passages middle movement of no. 8 is a short Si- The total of 37 voluntaries (if we ac- to me that Dupuis intended the bass to in thirds and interludes on the Swell; 6/1 ciliano also for the Swell. No. 2 is an Ada- cept the editor’s division of the Pieces be played on the Great Diapasons in this is marked Full without the Sesquialtera, gio without registration indication, but into Voluntaries) is greater than any oth- movement, as the A could not be taken with LH passages in eighth-note thirds; could be played on the Choir or possibly er contemporary composer, and there is by the LH, a point not commented on and 7/1 is an Adagio in G minor in 6/8 with Swell for RH and Choir for LH. much fi ne music to be discovered within by the editor. for Swell in the RH against LH Choir The fi rst movements are as varied as these fi ve volumes, all of which are very No. 6 in the original misses out some Stop Diapason and Flute, a cadence on the two sets of nine voluntaries, particu- clearly printed and are produced in spi- of the manual changes, here suggested the dominant leading to a Cornet move- larly good being the Moderato in C mi- ral ring binding, which ensures that they by the editor in brackets, although he ment in B-fl at. nor in no. 3 and the more chordal no. 5. lie fl at on the music stand. Each contains also uses brackets for some of the mark- Nos. 4/1 and 8/1 alternate passages Nos. 7 and 8 hark back to the older Dia- a short biography and notes on the edito- ings that are in the original, leading to for the Diapasons with the Swell, while pason movements, and the rhythmically rial procedure, with a list of corrections a lack of clarity. No. 4 has a movement 9/1 contrasts chords on full organ with varied no. 9 makes a stirring prelude to either listed in the introduction or clear- in 3/4, with tuneful solo writing for the Swell. Several movements again contain the fugue. In no. 1 there is a slur cov- ly marked in the score with footnotes. Swell mainly in one but occasionally in written-out cadenzas, this time from the ering groups of 16th-notes in arpeggio Useful comments on registration, par- two parts against a bass line, conclud- original print. The MS Voluntary in D is patterns, with the tail of the fi rst note of ticularly the concept of full organ at the ing with a written-out cadenza over a dated October 2, 1789—the fi rst move- each group also being set as a quarter- time, are included from the treatises by dominant pedal. The original contains a ment alternating Swell with Full, the note—this is also seen in the volumes of Blewitt and Marsh, but in the two earlier whole-note middle E in the second part fugal second movement concluding with pieces by J. Worgan that are described sets of nine voluntaries some of the edi- of the bar, but this is omitted in this mod- half-note chords. The very attractive on the title page as being for organ only, torial suggestions are for interpretations ern edition. concerto movements included in this and may just imply that a similar treat- on a modern instrument rather than re- The second set contains a greater va- volume are the Gavot and Minuet in C, ment for such fi gures was expected in printed accurately from the original. riety of voluntaries, including no. 1 and both with variations, from no. 3, and the other pieces of the period. For example, in Set I, No. 2, the open- 8 in four movements (although the third Minuet with variations in B-fl at from no. In op. 10, the editor has arranged ing is marked Diapasons or Full Organ, movement of no. 8 is only a four-bar 6; the latter includes crossed-hands pas- the 21 pieces into seven voluntaries, of and the Swell is suggested in brackets Grave for Diapasons, linking the Cornet sages in variation 6. which nos. 3 and 7 have two movements, for the Diapasons—possibly a closer ap- movement and the fi nal 3/8 lyrical an- The two volumes entitled Pieces for nos. 1, 2, and 5 have three movements, proximation to the sound required, given dante larghetto), nos. 3 and 7 in three, the Organ, opp. 8 and 10, contain sepa- and nos. 4 and 6 have four movements. that the majority of modern instruments and no. 5 in only one; only voluntaries 2, rate movements not divided into volun- Fugues close each group, nos. 5 and 7 have thick diapasons—with the com- 4, 6, and 9 are in two movements. There taries as such, but the keys used allow an being unexpectedly in the tonic minor. poser’s indication of p being suggested is one movement for Trumpet and Echo arbitrary arrangement to be selected. In (There is a printing error in the subject as played on the Swell, when the Choir (1/4), fi ve for Cornet (1/2 for Cornet op. 8, six of the editor’s groupings of the of the fugue in no. 7: the 16th-note form- would have been more suitable and his- Swell and Flute, 2/2 marked Andante, 28 pieces fall into three movements (nos. ing an “extra” alto part should be delet- torically accurate. 6/2 without tempo, and 7/2 and 8/2 both 1–3, 5, 8 and 10)—the third movement of ed!) The movements for solo stops are Inaccurate from a historical perspec- marked Moderato). Fugues appear as nos. 1, 3 and 10 being in the dominant— no. 4/2 for the Flute in the RH against tive are the indications in voluntaries 5 1/4, 3/3, 7/3 and 9/2. with nos. 2 and 5 being in the tonic major, the Stop Diapason in the LH—unusual and 6 from the fi rst set for the LH to be The remaining movements include a and no. 8 in the tonic minor. The other since the treatises tell us that the fl ute played on the Swell in the Cornet move- most expressive Adagio for Swell (3/2)— fi ve voluntaries comprise a grouping of at 4-ft pitch is usually accompanied by ment, with the RH Echo passages in the editor is surely mistaken when, al- two movements each. Fugues close all of itself—followed in 4/3 by a movement no. 5 and the RH Swell passages in no. though he keeps the original marking the pieces except for 5, 7 and 8, each one for Trumpet, implied Echo (marked p) 6 also suggested as being played on the of Swell against the LH, he suggests being in the major. The example in 12/8 and with the bass also marked Trumpet Swell. The inclusion of the specifi cation that the RH be played on the Great—a that closes no. 11 is marked Allegro ma in places. A further similar movement of a typical 3-manual organ of the period movement switching between Full non Presto, a clear warning against tak- for Trumpet is no. 6/2, followed by the would have been most helpful as well, so Swell, Choir Organ and Full without the ing the piece too quickly. only movement in Dupuis’ works for Vox that players could select the stops for the Sesquialtera (4/2), and the Andante lar- There are far fewer movements for Humana in the RH over Diapasons. The Swell passages in particular from a point ghetto mentioned above (8/4), in which solo stops, the Cornet being represented Cornet and Echo feature in 5/2 with a of historically informed knowledge. It the two-part RH calls for Swell, Diaps in no. 2/3 (marked for Swell, with p and f cadenza in 32nd-notes covering two would also have been helpful if the fact Great Organ and Choir Organ. The LH dynamics; the moderato tempo is neces- octaves. Middle movements of nos. 1 that the Swell descended only to tenor is marked for Choir Stop Diapason and sary to prevent the 32nd-notes appearing and 2 are of the cantabile type for the G had been mentioned so that players would realize that if the LH contained notes below this, then it would have to have been played on the Choir. However, in the other volumes the /44/ (%533 /2'!. 0!243 original instructions (suggestions) re- garding stop selection are transcribed accurately. Not included is a commen- 4RADITION AND 0ROGRESS tary on the interpretation of most of the ornaments, a most tricky concept at this later stage, the beat still being played as &OR