march 19, 2015 | Vol. 113 no. 19 | middleburycampus.com Questions Surround Off-Campus Housing Lottery By Emilie Munson year’s lottery, which took place On Feb. 19, a group of 10 dis- on Feb. 17. Of these rising seniors, gruntled students shook up a approved only eight varsity ath- Community Council-sponsored letes were chosen from the lottery, By The Numbers “Community Conversation” event of the 37 varsity athletes who ap- People who applied: 111 individuals groups: (students can apply in with loud allegations directed to- plied. Three others athletes were wards the College’s Residential accepted just after the lottery approved: 58 groups of three) Life team. These ten students, all because Residential Systems Co- former or current varsity athletes, ordinator Karin Hall-Kolts, who Varsity athletes approved: 11 59 application groups complained that they had been organizes and conducts the lot- varsity athletes applied: 37 17 athlete groups applied unfairly treated in the off-campus tery, forgot to add their names to housing lottery on the basis of the pot. their identities as athletes. It was the shockingly low ac- % of student body that is ceptance rate among varsity ath- 38 groups approved, The off-campus housing lot- varsity athletes: tery is a random process through letes that caused the Community 6 groups of athletes Conversation outcry. How could which rising seniors can apply to were approved live in houses not owned by the the lottery be random if so few 28% College. Interested students can athletes were accepted, they chal- submit applications for groups of lenged. up to three people. These applica- “It just doesn’t seem random tions are then put into a pot and based on who got it,” said Riley selected at a drawing event that is Dickie ’16, a former men’s hockey Cassie Kent open to all students who applied. player who was rejected from the tion may have rigged the lottery Based on calculations per- The applications are then drawn lottery and spoke at the Commu- weren’t approved to live off cam- against varsity athletes that they formed by Paige-Wright Profes- from the pot by a random student nity Conversation event. “It just pus. I think that’s really weird.” believed were more likely to throw sor of Economics Paul Sommers who applied for off-campus hous- “I don’t think that the people and this reporter using hypergeo- ing. According to the College’s “I would like to think that it in the hat were chosen to be in the lacrosse players, these ten stu- metric probability distribution, website, the only criterion that is random because it is such an hat,” said Mary Claire Ecclesine dents claimed there was foul play. the probability that only these may bar applicants from being ac- important thing for so many stu- 11 athletes, who applied in 6 ap- dents,” added Maggie Caputi ’16, member. “I just think that maybe The Campus Investigates plication groups, would be ac- College discipline. a women’s lacrosse team member some people were taken out. And In the light of these claims, the cepted in a random lottery—and As the Campus reported on who was accepted in the lottery there’s no way that anyone could Campus decided to investigate so many others would be reject- Feb. 25, 58 rising seniors were ap- but also spoke out at the Commu- know that.” just how random the off-campus ed—is 35/10,000 chances. If we proved to live off campus in this nity Conversation. “At the same time, I think it’s really suspect that Claiming that the administra- housing lottery was on Feb. 19. SEE STATISTICS, PAGE 3 Julia Alvarez ’71 to Deliver May Commencement Address Found Across Campus By Joe Flaherty in the Dominican Republic. to speak to a graduating class at By Jason Zhang of Art, “Outside In: Art of the Novelist, poet and College President of the College Ron- an institution that means a great Earlier last week, a series of Street,” which launched on Feb. writer-in-residence Julia Alvarez ald D. Liebowitz said in an inter- deal to her. anonymous graffiti paintings 13. Other events included the view, “Julia has inspired genera- “It’s very touching to be there ’71 will deliver this year’s com- appeared across campus, spark- completion of a new Museum fa- tions. As a writer-in-residence, with a class that is about to set mencement address. Alvarez, ing debate and concern. The çade and a museum piece com- she has touched so many individ- out on the journey that I am along with four others, will re- graffiti pieces were found at Bi- menting on Andy Warhol both uals in the area of creative writ- looking back on now,” Alvarez ceive an honorary degree at the Hall, Forest Lounge, the Center painted by British street art- May 24 ceremony. ing and expression of one’s own said. “They’re saying goodbye ist Ben Eine over Winter Break self.” to a certain kind of connection for the Arts, Virtue Field House, Alvarez is the acclaimed au- Warner, Hillcrest, Ross and and a documentary screening of thor of novels, essays and books, - to the College, but this place re- Munroe, according to Facilities “Style Wars” by the co-producer including In the Time of the bury graduate to do a creative mains under your skin and in Services and student sources. and photographer Henry Chalf- and How the García writing thesis in poetry. She your bloodstream, I think.” credits faculty members such as At BiHall, one stencil spray- ant. Girls Lost Their Accents. She was The College exhibition con- awarded the National Medal of C. A. Dana Professor of English Dominican Republic when she painting depicted a riot police trasts with the black and white Arts — the highest honor given & American Literatures David was 10 to escape the regime of officer holding a baton, with graffiti that appeared outside to artists and arts patrons by the Price and Robert Pack, the poet, Rafael Trujillo. the words “TOO MANY COPS, the CFA and on College build- U.S. government — by President faculty member and longtime di- In addition to graduating TOO LITTLE JUSTICE.” The Obama in 2013. In addition to rector of the Bread Loaf Writer’s from the College, Alvarez has stencil appeared next to a large ings. The juxtaposition reveals writing, Alvarez and her husband Conference, for supporting her taught at Middlebury since 1988 sprayed security camera and the not only the different level of run a sustainable coffee farm and early writing efforts. and in 1998 transitioned from words “NO CAMERAS.” At the artistic expression, but also the literacy center called Alta Gracia Alvarez said in an interview her tenured position to become entrance of Ross dining hall, divergent destinies of the works that she relishes the opportunity writer-in-residence. She holds a a graffiti work read “BLACK by famous graffiti artists and the master’s in creative writing from POWER MATTERS”. ones that appeared on campus. Syracuse University. Addition- A stenciled rat in a suit ap- Many current social issues ally, Alvarez has frequented the peared in multiple locations: are at play in the messages in- Bread Loaf Writers’ Conference herent to the graffiti. Joanne and the Bread Loaf School of Warner, the Field House and a Wu ’15 commented on the dis- English. trashcan at the entrance of CFA. play outside of Ross Dining “The Bread Loaf Writer’s Con- Another, on the exterior Hall, which read “BLACK POW- ference, the Bread Loaf School of wall of the CFA entrance, read English — I had been trying to get “THIEF,” which is stylistically ER MATTERS.” back here ever since I graduat- different from the others. “It She said, “I think damaging ed,” Alvarez explained. “So I took does not make any sense, un- public property in any form is the job [in 1988] and here I am.” like the stencil ones, which are irresponsible, in part because Liebowitz also noted Alvarez’s better done. I think they are try- we are in this living space to- - ing to say something but just gether. There are many non- lege. “She is an inspiration to not in the right way,” said Elyse destructive ways to get out your a whole host of creative under- Barnard ’15, who saw the iso- message that are equally, if not graduates here at Middlebury,” lated one at the CFA and a few less, impactful. I do not agree he said. at Ross. with it. But I do agree that it has Alvarez, who said she antici- The appearance of the graffiti a high impact factor because it pates departing her writer-in- coincides with a wave of cam- gets people’s notice.” residence position within the pus events focusing on street On the effectiveness of the College Communications next year, sees her address as an art. Most notably, the exhibi- message, Wu mentioned the in- Author, poet, writer-in-residence and Middlebury grad Julia opportunity to say goodbye to the tion held at the College Museum stallation in the Davis Family Alvarez ’71 will be the commencement speaker on May 24. SEE ALVAREZ, PAGE 3 SEE FACILITIES, PAGE 2 CHILI FEST!!! MIDD’S OWN COLLEGE PAGE 4-5 SOCIOLOGY CELEBRATES PODCAST IRISH TRADITIONS PAGE 14 AND TUNES PAGE 17 inside 2NEWS | march 19, 2015 Sga Update CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 Professor of American Studies Timothy firmed that this is not the first time graf- Spears saw the graffiti at the Athletic fiti has appeared on campus. According Library focusing on the issues of Mexican Complex and heard about others, but to the College archives, numerous inci- immigration and mistreatment of Mexi- could not speculate about their purpose dents of graffiti have occurred at the Col- can labor. lege, from basic desk inscriptions in 1966 She points out the deficiency of con- ’17, did not hear about it at all partly be- to political messages on the cement can- text of the campus graffiti and compares it to the more academic way of putting By Claire Treesh in promptly to remove the graffiti works. an installation in the library, which goes a studio and gallery for student graffiti, through the bureaucracy. “I think they Moser explained the cleaning process in murals and stenciling until the room was have a very provocative display in the li- an email response to the Campus. He painted over in 2012. At the same time, At their meetings on March 8 and March brary. That also attracts attention,” she said, “A solvent is used to remove graf- homophobic graffiti appeared in Ross 15, the SGA passed notable acts and resolu- said. fiti on painted surfaces, then these sur- and prompted the then Ross Commons tions. The Senate also voted to ratify Maddy “It’s egotistic vandalism that some- faces will be repainted when weather al- Heads Steve and Katy Smith Abbott and Sanchez ’17 as the Director of Transporta- body else has to clean up,” John D. Bern- the administration to resolutely step inghausen Professor of Chinese Thomas paste to extract the graffiti. Both of these in. These incidents and the most recent and six new members of the Awards Com- Moran wrote in an email response to the methods are effective, and are labor in- all point to a long history of active and mittee. Campus. tensive.” passionate students with a desire to be However, not everyone knew as much Moser, Spears and Moran, all con- heard. meeting was the Honor Code Biennial Ref- about the graffiti pieces that appeared. erendum Resolution, sponsored by Presi- dent Custer ’15. The committee drafted this resolution in Winter Term, after carefully New Internship Funding for CSE considering the Honor Code’s merits and failings. As Custer described, the committee By Minori Fryer the globe, at a location that matches the gram as a graduate of the University of students’ skills and area of interest. Past the Pacific, said, “I have met all of the was set up to think about “how we can come A new summer internship opportu- students who have participated in the students who have participated in Am- together as a community to talk about the nity has been launched by the Middle- program at the University of the Pacific bassador Corps, and they all come back Honor Code”. The resolution, which details bury Center for Social Entrepreneurship have interned in countries such as Ne- a completely different person.” how a revision process of the Honor Code (MCSE) in conjunction with the The pal, Paraguay, Uganda, Vietnam, China, As a result of the enriching experi- could take place, was discussed at length. Center for Social Impact Learning (CSIL) Rwanda and Kenya, working on projects ence, some students have developed long After some concern surrounding the time- at the Middlebury Institute for Interna- term relationships with the organiza- line of the process, the resolution was put tional Studies at Monterey (MIIS) with tions, and often return to work for them to a vote and passed nearly unanimously. the goal of supporting students as agents “The program is not only upon graduating. The next issue was the Senate Reform of social change. enriching for American “The program is not only enrich- Act, sponsored by Custer. The act, which Introduced this academic year, the ing for American students, but it is also was created in the hopes of changing stu- program known as Ambassador Corps students, but it is also enriching for the local communities in dent perception and understanding of the was brought to the College by Jeremy enriching for the local which the students make an impact,” efforts of the SGA, met much contention. Hildebrand, founder of the Global Cen- communities in which the Babak said. “The program works on the Many senators had issues with the po- ter for Social Entrepreneurship at the ethic of ‘paying it forward’, and the great tential adjustment of types of senators, as University of the Pacific in California, students make an impact.” thing about the way it works is that there outlined in the act. The act entailed elimi- who is now the director for CSIL at MIIS. Mustafa Babak is definitely a fruitful and tangible out- Mustafa Babak, CSE program and CSE Program and outreach associate come for the students upon completion.” replacing them with eight “cluster board” outreach associate as well as the point- Although the deadline for the first senators, representing different groups person between the CSE at Middlebury associated with public health, disaster round of applications already passed on on campus. The eight senators would be and CSIL at MIIS, describes the program relief and micro-finance. March 10th, students who are interested representatives from the cluster boards: as an “extraordinary opportunity for There is a program fee of $2,000 for can apply for the second round of ap- academic and activists, cultural organiza- Middlebury students,” for its unique and the 8 to 12 week program; however, eli- plications that are due on April 10. Ac- tions, special interest and activities orga- well-structured nature. gible students (such as those receiving cording to Babak, avid and experienced nizations, publications, religious organiza- Open to College students of all class financial aid from the College) can apply entrepreneurs, as well as those who are tions, athletics, and visual and performing years, applicants are chosen by the Cen- for bulk-funding from the CSE to help beginners to social entrepreneurship are arts. Some of the senators supported this ter for Social Impact Learning at MIIS cover the costs, as a result of a generous all encouraged to apply, as long as stu- change, saying that people’s actual inter- through a rigorous selection process. donation. dents are able to demonstrate their pas- ests would be better represented with this Successful applicants are placed in one Babak, who is familiar with the pro- sion for social change. kind of system. However, there was con- of MIIS’s partner organizations around cern from senators, such as from Senator Gogineni ’16, who said that an increase in the number of senators would greatly de- Midd Alum Featured on reddit Front Page While the bill also containted of other By Tess Weitzner Savard was sifting through the footage Post, The Daily Mail and NBC News. changes to the senate, the issue of cluster the following day that he discovered To quell speculation from skeptics board senators seemed to be the biggest College Digital Media Producer Ben the octopus’ photos and decided to post who believed the photos were fake, point of interest. Therefore Custer made a Savard ’14 achieved Internet fame after a them on Reddit. Savard created and shared a graphics motion to split the bill, in order to only vote photo of himself taken by an octopus was “Reddit is a website I’ve been on for on the senators section at that meeting. The featured on the front page of Reddit, a a while. I know the format, I know how entire photo series. motion was passed and the act was put to popular entertainment, news and social to make [posts] appealing to people. I Despite his internet fame, Savard has a vote. The senators voted 9-6-2, and the networking site. The photo of Savard wanted everyone to see [the photos], and act did not pass because it required a 2/3 dressed in a white lab coat rapidly it’s cool if people hopefully attract some research for the photos. majority. circulated the Internet and credited attention to the sciences at Middlebury,” Savard said, “I am not the story, I am At the March 15 meeting, two acts were its photographer, Middlebury’s female Savard said. hopefully just there to tell a good story. I passed: The Coffee Hour Act, sponsored California Two-Spot Octopus. On March 10, the post garnered more don’t want to be the researcher, I want to by Custer and the LaundryView Invest- Before the photo was taken, Savard was than 2.2 million views on Reddit, and be the GoPro, I want to capture things in ment Act, sponsored by Senator Toy ’17. working on a video about the College’s that number has since risen to over a cool way and make sure that research The Coffee Hour Act will entail one coffee science departments and decided to 3.3 million. The image has reached hour a week provided by the SGA, available feature the neuroscience research of popularity among the site’s users, with unappreciated...I was here for four years for students to meet with and talk to their several comparing the image to a ’90s and I’m realizing now there’s so many senators. Each senator is required to attend was observing whether octopi could be alternative rock album and a “promo different aspects of Middlebury that I at least three coffee hours a semester, likely trained to open a puzzle box with food shot for an educational TV show.” didn’t appreciate, and most of that is after firstly watching another octopus The post has also been featured on based around the work the students are Custer said that he envisioned these being demonstrate. Savard prepared to record news outlets such as The Washington doing.” easy, casual study breaks for students, with the experiment by inserting a GoPro the added ability to get to know SGA mem- camera with an automatic shutter inside bers or offer suggestions. the aquarium containing the octopus. The LaundryView Investment Act is a “[The octopi] grab everything we put project that has been a reoccurring discus- sion for SGA during the entire academic According to her, octopi are naturally year. After extensive research, the adminis- curious creatures. It therefore came tration has told the SGA that the funding for as no surprise LaundryView, a program which would tell the octopus immediately reached for students which machines were open/work- the camera when it was placed in the ing, would have to come directly from the tank. In doing so, the octopus happened SGA’s budget. This act designated $8,500 to direct the lens towards Savard and capture several photos. and $3,500 for the second year to be paid “It was all very circumstantial,” - Savard said. dent Life Survey, it was found that nearly The photos captured the progression 72 percent of the student body thought they from the moment the octopus grabbed the camera to when it directed the Courtesy Ben Savard camera toward Savard. It was not until put to a vote and passed 10-6-1. The photo of Ben Savard ’14 was taken by a California Two-Spot Octopus. march 19, 2015 | News 3 Statistics Prof. Calculates Probability of Foul Play CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 - excluded two application groups, whose names were not or were likely not in the - lottery pot at the time of the drawing (the three athletes who were accepted just after - their own names in the lottery pot so that are two-fold. - they know that the pot was not pre-select- First, Hall-Kolts sent the emails inform- tion of their group. 44/10,000 chances. off campus and all were rejected in the ini- express desire to see the waitlist and know tial lottery. - students who applied in all-athlete groups ing nature. - organizer of the proposed Palmer social house “The Hall,” felt his social house ap- - - plication was denied for the same reason: - though slight, that ing them against this outcome would “The reason we do the draw non-athletes who - occur. It is not im- - the spring. is to address the concern spond right away In an email to Adams sent after the result to occur in a that there is something other and get a higher group’s rejection, which Denious shared with the Campus, Adams explained that the random lottery pro- spot on the waitlist. with the Campus, Stewart explained, “We College plans on hosting a series of meeting cess. than random chance [hap- Adams respond- - with local property owners to try to address Sommers inter- pening]. It is completely ed that this was this issue. preted these low not an issue he was Finally, and most radically, some stu- - random chance.” as an athlete house asking us how many Doug Adams the timing of the - Associate dean of students email was not inten- Finally, a student who wished to remain thing impeding the tional. anonymous told the Campus that during randomness of the “[The email was sent] at the time that his application process for a mod he was lottery system. she [Karin] was done processing the infor- - “Somewhere there is an element of non- mation,” Adams explained. “We certainly - randomness,” Sommers said. “And it may can adjust our times if it’s felt that that is a housing to all-male groups of athletes. This - in the lottery. “A large group of my friends lottery not thoroughly mixing the slips.” tually awarded a mod for next year, how- they were not informed of their position on Administrative Response the waitlist. This lead them to suspect that Adams denies that applications for so- Campus last students were not getting off the waitlist that fair.” week, Associate Dean of Students for Lastly, in the largest sense, the student Residential and Student Life Doug Adams other factors, such as pressure from par- maintained that the lottery was 100 percent According to Adams, this year an espe- random. donors to the College. “The reason we do the draw is to address “The perception of a lot of kids is that at the College. the concern that there is something other percent of the stu- As Denious sug- than random chance [happening],” Adams dents who were “Somewhere there is an ele- gested in his email said. “It is completely random chance.” Adams countered that these allegations to Adams, some stu- ment of non-randomness. are “completely not true.” He said the reason that students’ posi- social houses next And it may be as simple as administrators draw off-campus attended the lottery drawing. tions on the waitlist are not shared with year are athletes. someone who conducts the “We always with the drawing. positions changing often when students look at athletic sta- lottery not thoroughly mix- on this one aspect of tus after we make their identity. - ing the slips. ” the acceptances “This [Denious’s campus instead. for the main rea- Paul Sommers Palmer social house complaints of discrimination against a paige-wright professor of economics “We don’t take anything into consider- son that we want group] was a group to make sure that - raised. we are not discriminating against a group,” He maintains that the off-campus hous- around [on the waitlist].” Adams said. “We look for the strongest pro- in the country, social interests, and some ing lottery is one of the most transparent gram, not [at] the group of students that are of us happen to play sports,” Denious said. processes of any at the College. On Campus Housing Policies Thus, according to Adams, the applica- sweeping generalizations, and completely can get, currently,” Adams said. housing policies and suspected discrimina- the committee felt were the strongest; they person in the house and completely goes claims. unfairly in on-campus housing processes. athletes on their roster or the gender of - those athletes. letic community here without really know- The Waitlist house application process, two groups of In addition to the lottery itself, athletes Implications understanding the culture of each team,” - The Campus - with the waitlist process that follows it. cause of their identities as athletes. After the initial lottery, students who ap- Campus on - - - - Campus say gardless of whether or not the lottery was form them whether they were accepted or for certain whether athletic identity may random, it is important to know that ath- not, and those students not accepted must - letes applied for Homestead House with - one non-athlete. The group felt optimistic others, consciously or unconsciously. The spond to the email quickly as the order in which students respond determines their They were the only group that applied to place on the waitlist. A higher spot on the Alvarez and Four Others to Receive Honorary Degrees MCAB’s WHAT’S CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 an honorary Doctor of Science degree. - - - College. HAPPENING AT - science, language instruction, and design- MIDDLEBURY? the local school for the past 20 years. undergraduate science education,” Li- - CHECK BACK IN - - ters degree. The other honorary degree APRIL FOR NEW graduates, which is highly unusual for a - PROGRAMMING - AND WARMER - - eral Arts, a lecture titled “The Lord Alone WEATHER - (HOPEFULLY). countries. In addition to winning three an intentional theme for the ceremony. Grammys, Hahn also attended the Mid- - “All of the honorary degree recipients - - HAVE A man, French and Japanese. - itz said. day.” - RELAXING SPRING The commencement ceremony will Christina Johnston, the principal of take place at 10 a.m. on May 24. BREAK! 4Local |March 19, 2015
By Annie Grayer, Alessandria Schumacher and Isabelle Dietz