This article was downloaded by:[UVA Universiteitsbibliotheek SZ] On: 9 December 2007 Access Details: [subscription number 769895062] Publisher: Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK

International Spectator Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title~content=t768481834 Walks the Tightrope Paul Aarts

Online Publication Date: 01 December 2007 To cite this Article: Aarts, Paul (2007) 'Saudi Arabia Walks the Tightrope', International Spectator, 42:4, 545 - 550 To link to this article: DOI: 10.1080/03932720701780413 URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03932720701780413

PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE

Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.informaworld.com/terms-and-conditions-of-access.pdf This article maybe used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan or sub-licensing, systematic supply or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material. Downloaded By: [UVA Universiteitsbibliotheek SZ] At: 15:51 9 December 2007 ad euiyEnvironment’’. Security Saudi Re with ‘‘Coping Kostiner, see initiative, Abdullah’s is,afwlnso ad rbasicesn novmn nLbnn The Lebanon. in involvement increasing Arabia’s Lebanon, from Saudi absent on been never lines has Kingdom few a First, Blaming initiative 2002 Abdullah’s Prince Crown by and (illustrated conflict plan Arab-Israeli Fahd the in Arabia 1981 and Saudi arenas the past, inter-Arab the in scen both In the disputes policy. behind of subtle, foreign a Saudi to for adhered ascendency mostly of times are These Aarts Paul Tightrope the Walks Arabia Saudi h nentoa pcao,Vl 2 o ,Dcme 07 545–550 2007, December 4, No. ß 42, Vol. Spectator, International The 3 2 1 Aarts Paul u ttesm iei sseig gi nec ftecss idof kind a Iran. cases, the of of each Republic in Islamic again position, seeking, the bold is a with it taking time before, same ever the than at more but now, is mentioned, issues the nawvrn n oeie ofsn a,tog agl nln ihSaudi with line in relations. largely ‘‘polygamous’’ though developing way, done of With being confusing pattern is most. this sometimes long-established that the and Arabia’s show out will Riyadh set wavering article has This worries a region. and in what the influence in is role growing Tehran’s the this contain Iran’s events, to observes and three Riyadh all light civil In apprehension, to the dimensions. growing and al-Qaeda comes Strip; and factor’’ Gaza Sunni-Shia the its ‘‘Iran the in confronta- with armed U-turn: Iraq and the in this Lebanon; war of in explain war the Israeli-Arab between may 2006 tion summer developments the Three of is outcome that dangers. issue regional sensitive every evolving virtually on attitude. lead region. open the Eastern and the Middle take assertive in the to more strings haunting a trying pulling for is come of Abdullah have consisted King to which seems role moment the regional shadows, limited this with contrast o h adPa,seht:/w.nse.o.lpoesdc/adeghm o rw Prince AbuKhalil and Expansion’’; Crown ‘‘Saudi Trabulsi, for http://www.knesset.gov.il/process/docs/fahd_eng.htm; Pa and see ‘‘Determinants Nonneman, Plan, Fahd the For 07Ittt faiInternazionali Affari Istituto 2007 hsbrto ciimsesfo h os fSu’ ecpino rapidly of perception Saud’s of House the from stems activism of burst This ece nentoa eain tteUniver the at Relations International teaches trso ad oeg oiy’ n at n a uje ‘‘The Duijne, Van and Aarts and Policy’’; Foreign Saudi of tterns ‘hrceitc fSuiRl nLebanon’’. in Role Saudi of ‘‘Characteristics , inlCalne’ n ‘ad einlStrategy’’. Regional ‘‘Saudi and Challenges’’ gional sapoc,paigterl farbiter of role the playing approach, es iyo mtra;Eal [email protected] Email: Amsterdam; of sity 3 u nrcn ie thsdeviated has it times recent in but SN09-79pitIS 7192 online 1751-9721 print/ISSN 0393-2729 ISSN O:10.1080/03932720701780413 DOI: ou vivendi modus 1 .Mc in Much ). 2 nall On Downloaded By: [UVA Universiteitsbibliotheek SZ] At: 15:51 9 December 2007 lnsol ese ntesm esetv;t aei a o envr successful. very been not Debate has com_content&task it date to Saudi perspective; same the in seen be should plan http://www.cfr.org/pub 2007 March oehn hthsmtwt h prvlo h Sgovernment. US the of approval the with and met Iran Iraq, has in that also something but Lebanon in politica only sectarian funded have int Saudis Lebanon, the operations yet in clandestine not involved has era’’ also ‘‘new Even policy. a propaganda. Lebanese Saudi Saudi entered for criticise has openly centre to major Arabia dared a Saudi even become has like bloody which looks the It for thereby ’s Hezbollah. judgement), blame During that nuanced Iran. the later of laying it of ally (though the cultivation an adventurism’’ 2006, its ‘‘irresponsible as July its hence sees in policy, Lebanon it active into which more incursion Hezbollah, a to pursue opposition to Sunni role low-profile its from 546 6 5 4 fold, the it. into put back observer Hamas one bring as to Iranians, the trying of were wings’’ Saudis the was The ‘‘clipping fighting internecine halt. thereby bitter a increasingly of government to year the unity a brought of A almost end administration). and the Palestinian out for hammered the called was of also boycott Saudis European the and (when 2007 US February in Saud Fatah provided This and the financially. Hamas and behind Iran politically matter, Arab-Israeli motivation both that Hamas, the strategic for to in the closer and get posture to of prominent able that been to more has and a annoyance, its taking to been Much arena. also has Arabia Saudi Hamas Luring aa opeey ote i ohn oudrietedeal. the undermine to nothing they did nevertheless, they ; so in completely, not success Hamas would Saudi Saudis the the that about confident happy seemed not were Iranians the aishv otiue ocligdw etra n oiia esosin tensions political and sectarian digni- down Iranian calming and was Saudi to cooperation between Iranian Lebanon. letters contributed doubt, of have a exchanges Without and taries between other. visits and tensions and government the Siniora here easing on the crucial camp, in and Hariri role hand, Saad one major the the a on played opposition, also Hezbollah-led the has Arabia Saudi however, aa bdn ‘rnpnesam fSuimediat Saudi of aims ponders ‘‘Iran Abedin, Influence’’, Mahan Iranian Back Roll to Aim Illusions’’. ‘‘Grand ‘‘Saudis Samuels, Gause, and Greg Redirection’’; ‘‘The Hersch, codn osm ore,teSui’spotfrSnifre nLbnnhas Lebanon in forces Sunni for support Saudis’ the sources, some to According .Aarts t r a A P. oln) 1Fbur 07http://www 2007 February 21 (online), ¼ view&id ¼ 510&Itemid iain185.Terluc nArl20 fteAdla peace Abdullah the of 2007 April in relaunch The lication/12895/. ¼ 165 oeet n aaiiaygop (not groups paramilitary and movements l ne owae ebla.Apparently, Hezbollah. weaken to ended sta olwdnto salbton but Israel on not followed that ts -rkrd‘Mcaareet’between agreement’’ ‘‘Mecca i-brokered o sU acesu pyos gis Tehran’’, against ‘psy-ops’ up ratchets US as ion adshrhyciiie ebla for Hezbollah criticised harshly Saudis eal odslc hi nlec over influence their displace to able be h cuidPlsiinterritories), Palestinian occupied the oni nFrinRelations Foreign on Council .saudidebate.com/index.php?option 6 5 4 Obviously, Strikingly, oln) 16 (online), ¼ Downloaded By: [UVA Universiteitsbibliotheek SZ] At: 15:51 9 December 2007 ihbt ie,tog eeicdmr nesadn o aa hndd for did, than Hamas for understanding more evinced Egypt. he instance, of disappointment though his fate sides, expressed the both king sealed Saudi with events government The violent unity agreement. these power-sharing Obviously, national Mecca March. the the in office dismissed taken Abbas had which Mahmoud President Strip, o Gaza and Palestinian installations, overran security forces Authority Islamist Hamas-led well-organised expected, than Sooner turned territories Palestinian occupied ttclskyise n esatmtbefrafnldeal. final a for Relations timetable a sets and issues key tackles it hni oe oIa,tetidise h adshv o ae oeactive more a do. to taken what now knowing have not paralysed, Saudis seemed the they 2006, issue, late third Until too. the there, Iraq, role to comes it When confusion Saudi and mess Iraqi The 10 9 8 7 egto hsseii omo lsrinvolv closer of to form Saudis specific the by this howeve of urged is, and weight It funded coalition. being alternative is an Allawi form Iyad Minister government Prime the Iraqi like former not does showing Riyadh started Undoubtedly, ofNouriMaliki,whichitseesasaclientofTehran.Thatiswhy,asisrumoured, Saudis politics. the Iraqi that in clear, interest became place more in regime Iran-friendly an leave ae,hwvr ilmtciiitvswl aet eresumed. be to have will initiatives with diplomatic however, efforts later, mediating its reopen to hurry iigcniin nteGz ti n oeclsfrhl rmHms Riyadh Hamas, equation. from the help of for part be calls of still more will deterioration and Tehran Strip further that Gaza the realises the boycott, in international conditions unceasing living the with particular norgmn nSuiAai o onrmnt ofgtSisi rq many Iraq; 2006), in numbers. (December the Shias knows official fight Nobody go much so. to doing not countrymen nevertheless certainly are sponsoring for Saudis in is Arabia involved Saudi There risks in the phenomenon’’). encouragement also realised ‘‘blowback now leadership (the and Saudi 1980s militants The it early much. from the lesson in too its did Afghanistan States it learned United time have same the to the seemed antagonise at communication, to of want channels the ambitions not open Iranian of keep cognizant to dilemma: wanting a and faced leadership Saudi the that appeared rgGue ‘STyn oSfe ad adLn oadMlk Government’’, Maliki toward unless Line pointless Hard be will Saudi conference Soften peace to East Trying Middle ‘‘US US-backed Gause, a Greg that said have Saudis the date, To Group, Crisis International http://www.usip.org/isg/iraq_study_group_r uigtesme f20,rnwdcahsbtenFthadHmsi the in Hamas and Fatah between clashes renewed 2007, of summer the During twsol fe h ees fteIa td ru’ recommendations Group’s Study Iraq the of release the after only was It oln) uut20,http://www.cfr 2007, August 6 (online), 7 ttetm fwiig tlosa huhSuiAai si no in is Arabia Saudi though as looks it writing, of time the At 10 whenthecontoursofapossibleUSwithdrawalthatcould fe Gaza After 33. , eport/report/1206/iraq_study_group_report.pdf 4Jn,atrHmsto oto fthe of control took Hamas after June, 14 n noasrgl o oto fteGz Strip. Gaza the of control for struggle a into .org/publication/13988/gause.html upr fteIlmsswofuh in fought who Islamists the of support s ,rte ifcl odtrieteexact the determine to difficult rather r, epc oti su.Soe ahrthan rather Sooner issue. this to respect mn.Cnuigsig Confusing ement. ad rbaWlsteTightrope the Walks Arabia Saudi 8 nta otx,in context, that In asaon,such abound, nals oni nForeign on Council 547 9 It Downloaded By: [UVA Universiteitsbibliotheek SZ] At: 15:51 9 December 2007 ovcinta rae stability greater that conviction Jordan?’’; rnas o,adi h uue hydfntl aetesrnetcrsin cards strongest the the with have terms definitely speaking they on future, remain to the Riyadh in to Iraq. for and energies wise Now, and be eyes Iranians. would their ‘‘jihadist it turn emirat this scenarios, and (‘‘after and Peninsula!’’) emboldened monarchies expected, Arabia the feel US-supported victory, now the Saudi generally claim Iraq would region, wor one and jihadists the Afghanistan the the the In mini-states), in would into case, multiplied. jihadists Iraq elsewhere be negative the havens would that they the effect’’ safe in if meaning even In affected for but Iraq, adversely territory, included. look in be Iraqi probably favourably still leave would would out most – Arabia situation. turn others security Saudi will and own did, things Saudis Arabia’s – that Saudi jihadists on unlikely that influence quite an seems have It will – negative ‘‘illegitimate’’. or as occupation US of the summit of League Arab – the 2007 during March – denouncement unexpected Abdullah’s King as 548 15 14 13 12 11 of fears paraded Abdullah East. King Middle Saudi the Jordan’s across 2004, which cutting late crescent’’ In in ‘‘Shia Shias’’. new the divide, a of statements Sunni-Shia near-hysterical rise extraordinary, ‘‘the delivered a state on of Sunn heads of the Sunni Middle several emergence on the war, that prominently conclude the to figures tempted witnessing Arabia be might is one foregoing, East the of basis the On logic balance-of-power Classic n o h onre hyaelvn in.’’ living meaningful are a they hardly countries Shi with the the Jordan of not ‘‘Most like opined and much population, its country among a minority Shia Egypt, of Mubarak Hosni el(rneBne i utn h ad ainlscrt dio,pasakey a plays advisor, opposed security national as publicly Aviv Saudi Tel the with all talks Sultan, here). Israel. direct role bin with and Astonishingly, convergence Bander indirect in strategic (Prince Arabia. involved new well been a have Saudi Saudis into joined the were them Indeed, leaders of leading Sunni – these actions Abdullah year, Hezbollah’s last of King summer the by in Lebanon in out broke usatoday.com/news/wordl/iraq- he er ae,teJrainkn se toepit ‘oyuwn rno h ak fthe of p banks countries the Both on Iran 2. want Region’’, Redirection’’, you Across ‘‘The ‘‘Do Worry Hersch, point: a one ‘Rift’ at asked ‘‘Shiite-Sunni king Blanford, Jordanian the later, years Environment’’. Security Three Group, Saudi Crisis ‘‘The Duijne, International Van and Aarts hti biu,o h te ad sta eeomnsi rq–positive – Iraq in developments that is hand, other the on obvious, is What 12 .Aarts t r a A P. Ha’aretz 15 0Arl2007. April 20 , rni rq o uhInfluence? Much How Iraq: in Iran 2006-04-13-iraq-rift_x.htm nIre n aetn ilgv rnls eeaei h region. the in leverage less Iran give will Palestine and Israel in cueIa sa xseta hetadsaethe share and threat existential an as Iran icture ie vnbfr h 06Lebanon 2006 the before Even side. i si h ufrgo.I aho these of each In region. Gulf the in es tcs cnro(h iitgainof disintegration (the scenario st-case 14 hn sstoterir sfighting as earlier, out set as Then, S Today USA 13 nArl20,President 2006, April In 3Arl20,http://www. 2006, April 13 , ´ tsaelylt Iran, to loyal are ites 11 Downloaded By: [UVA Universiteitsbibliotheek SZ] At: 15:51 9 December 2007 ad rbascel uprsamr grsieln gis rnad‘isclients’’. ‘‘its and Iran sam against line the aggressive more At a supports stability. secretly Arabia regional Saudi interests of and convergence a is oil there that Tehran in and Riyadh in understanding wary a be two the between contacts frequent been have Bank and Valbjorn As complicated. more argue, becomes convincingly picture the inspection, closer Journal connection’’. oteSui r edn conflicting sending are Saudis the So bomb’’. Iran action military nuclear that take a is will getting America one that from nightmares: is Iran other ‘‘two prevent the had to and the bomb, he nuclear to May that a develop Bush in Iraq will President And ‘‘presenting told platter’’. was al-Feisal, and silver Saud policy hearts a US Arab on for that Iranians Tehran Turki complained against 2005, fight publicly September vital Washington, as the early in As Abdullah to and credibility King have minds. Arab gain US, sometimes the the to they from of that trying himself framework leaders is distancing new as By region. Washington. this role the against in their tough is in talk reassert it are and and to leaders country world, attempt Muslim Saudi the to wider the inside them resistance’’, pushing both of is opinion, ‘‘model This public a from as pressure rise under Hezbollah’s to due Mainly bets its Hedging motives’’. anti-Shia non-sectarian on the based explains policy a and selling controversial of policy way a anti-Iran ‘‘as that explicitly rhetoric Arabism too of a kind the into makes new developed has a latter of the exasperation, torchbearer their to Much not Hezbollah. do like Abdullah groups Shiism King Arabia’s of Saudi adherents like leaders fear Arab conservative words, other In 19 18 17 16 iky ‘ eetsLo nWne’;adKrnElo os,‘SuiBlnigAct’’, Balancing Illusions’’. ‘‘Saudi ‘‘Grand House, Samuels, Elliot and Redirection’’; Karen ‘‘The and Hersch, Winter’’; 7. War’’, in Cold Lion Arab New Desert’s a ‘‘A of Dickey, ‘‘Signs Bank, and 7 Valbjorn War’’, Cold Arab New a of ‘‘Signs Bank, and Valbjorn ept h rbeai htrco rnsPeietMhu haiea,there Ahmadinejad, Mahmud President Iran’s of rhetoric problematic the Despite upon but persuasive, appear may reference of frame sectarian this glance, first At re oblnearsn einlpower, regional rising a t balance according with to logic, order coincides power only of not orient balance split anti-US classic The and nature. pro- in between sectarian divide the less far Sunni-Shi motives a with making as appears initially What pi 2007. April 4 , e se per smc stegoigpwro oua radical popular of power growing the as much as n ofsn esgs h sthat? is Why messages. confusing and ´ pi a nfc eapteno alliance of pattern a be fact in may split i Shi hc te regiona other which o ie oee,wr a pedthat spread has word however, time, e tos u tas ieycmle iha with complies nicely also it but ations, ´ einlcmeiosadteesesto seems there and competitors regional iornot i esl hnSuiabsao to ambassador Saudi then Feisal, bin ad rbaWlsteTightrope the Walks Arabia Saudi 07 i rte,FrinMinister Foreign brother, his 2007, a lcrfe h rbsres This streets. Arab the electrified has iaisadd;adFle,‘TeHizbullah-Iran ‘‘The Fuller, and added); (italics 18 . 16 lstateswillallyin 17 alStreet Wall 549 19 Downloaded By: [UVA Universiteitsbibliotheek SZ] At: 15:51 9 December 2007 abon .adA ak ‘in faNwAa odWr h 06LbnnWradthe and War Lebanon 2006 The War. Cold Arab New a of ‘‘Signs Bank. A. and M. Valbjorn, rbli .‘SuiEpnin h eaeeC Lebanese The Expansion: ‘‘Saudi F. Trabulsi, Illusions’’. ‘‘Grand D. Samuels, otnr .‘Cpn ihRgoa hlegs aeSuyo rw rneAdla’ Peace Abdullah’s Prince Crown of Study Case A Challenges: Regional with ‘‘Coping J. Kostiner, onmn .‘Dtriat n P and ‘‘Determinants G. Nonneman, otnr .‘SuiRgoa taey h oe fMediation’’. of Power The Strategy: Regional ‘‘Saudi J. Kostiner, nentoa rssGroup. Crisis International Group. the Crisis in International Enemies Our Benefitting Policy New Administration’s the Is Redirection. ‘‘The M. S. Hersch, ulr .‘TeHzulhIa oncin oe o un Resistance’’, Sunni for Model Connection: Hizbullah-Iran ‘‘The Winter’’, G. in Fuller, Lion Desert’s ‘‘A C. War Dickey, Post-civil (the Lebanon in Role Saudi the of Characteristics and ‘‘Determinants A. AbuKhalil, at,P n .vnDin.‘TeSuiScrt niomn:Pu C Plus Environment: Security Saudi ‘‘The Duijne. van J. and P. Aarts, References 550 ato ht ad rbawnst oti rnsabtosbta h aetime be same may the Iran at with but flirting ambitions Iran’s and contain Saud to of wants House doesnotwanttoclashwithit Arabia the Saudi of that. skill of a part been without long Chin – has towards Washington alliances east’’ from ‘‘looking wit by distance ties (also take bets well-preserved to their in them up unpopular prompting giving deeply become world, has Arab administration Bush the the that realise leaders Saudi htw r insigi la c fblnigcmeigpesrs The pressures. competing balancing of act clear a is witnessing are we What ofrne‘KndmwtotBres ad xaso nteWrd’ igsCollege, King’s Divide’’, World’’, Sunni-Shi’i the in Expansion 2007. Saudi September 6–8 Borders. London, without ‘‘Kingdom conference o 2005. Co, Affairs Foreign Society, ntaie’ In Initiative’’. http://www.dayan.org/Saudi_Regional_Strategy.pdf uooy nMlil niomns’ In Environments’’. Multiple in 2005. Co, Autonomy’ & Hurst London: 352–371. Nonneman: G. and Aarts P. C,2 ac 2005. March 21 ICG, 07030fa_fact_hersh? Terror?’’. on War 139–150. (2006): 1 no. o h A-IArsac rjc n‘TeDnmc fCag nteAa World: Arab the 2007. in the September Expansion 6–8 Saudi in Borders. London, without College, Change ‘‘Kingdom King’s conference World’’, 2007. of the February at Dynamics presented 23–24 Paper Rome, Years)’’. ‘‘The Power’’, State on of project Re-structuring the research and Globalisation IAI-SIIA the for .Aarts t r a A P. ad rbai h aac;PltclEooy oit,FrinAffairs Foreign Society, Economy, Political Balance; the in Arabia Saudi h e Yorker New The ideEs Report East Middle dtdb .ArsadG onmn 1–5.Lno:Hrt& Hurst London: 315–351. Nonneman: G. and Aarts P. by edited , rni rq o uhInfluence? much How Iraq: in Iran fe Gaza After h tatcMonthly Atlantic The ten fSuiFrinPolicy: Foreign Saudi of atterns ut ihrp owalk. to tightrope a quite – ac 07 www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/03/05/ 2007, March 5 , ideEs eotn.8.Busl:IG uut2007. August 2 ICG, Brussels: 86. no. Report East Middle , Newsweek 4,Srn 07 6–11. 2007: Spring 242, h S hyaesml egn their hedging simply are They US. the h n ni) aiaigi contradictory in Navigating ). and a neto 9015’.Pprpeetda the at presented Paper 1920–1952’’. onnection ad rbai th in Arabia Saudi pi 2007. April 9 , ue20:46–76. 2007: June , ideEs eotn.3.Brussels: 38. no. Report East Middle e vvNotes Aviv Tel ¸aChange Onblnig n ‘Relative and ‘Omnibalancing’ aac;PltclEconomy, Political Balance; e ahntnQuarterly Washington ... ,25March2007, ’ ae prepared Paper ’’. ,editedby 30,