TOURISM DEVELOPMENT AND MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR CAVES PROTECTED AREA

Final

Transboundary Joint Secretariat for the Southern Caucasus

ASSESSING AND DEVELOPING THE ECO- POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS IN

Contract number: 2008.65.550 / 2013.11.001

Version: Final 12.01.2014

Issue/Version No.: Final

Contract No.: 2008.65.550 / 2013.11.001

Date: 7.11.2014

Contact Information: Paula Ruiz Rodrigo Österreichische Bundesforste AG Consulting Pummergasse 10-12 3002 Purkersdorf Austria T: +43 2231 600 5570 F: +43 2231 600 5509 [email protected] www.oebfconsulting.at

Authors: Janez Sirse / Lela Khartishvili

Financed by: Transboundary Joint Secretariat

ASSESSING AND DEVE LOPING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - FINAL

CONTENT

CONTENT ...... I ANNEXES ...... III LIST OF FIGURES ...... IV LIST OF TABLES ...... V ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS ...... VII 1 INTRODUCTION ...... 8 2 METHODOLOGY ...... 9 3 PROFILE OF IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA ...... 11 4 BASIC CHARACTERISTICS OF TOURISM IN IMERETI CAVES ...... 15 4.1 TOURISM VISITS TO IMERETI CAVES ...... 15 4.2 MAIN MARKETS AND PROFILE OF VISITORS TO IMERETI CAVES ...... 17 5 SWOT AND VALUE CHAIN ANALYSIS OF IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA ...... 21 5.1 SWOT – STRENGTH, WEAKNESSES, OPPORTUNITIES AND THREATS EVALUATION.... 21 5.2 VALUE CHAIN ANALYSIS OF TOURISM IN IMERETI CAVES ...... 25 6 TOURISM STAKEHOLDERS IN IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA ...... 27 7 TOURISM PRODUCTS AND POTENTIALS IN PAS ...... 29 8 TOURISM TRENDS AND GUIDING PRINCIPLES IN PROTECTED AREAS ...... 31 8.1 KEY TOURISM TRENDS ...... 31 8.2 TOURISM TRENDS IN PROTECTED AREAS ...... 31 8.3 TOURISM GUIDING PRINCIPLES IN PAS AND KARST CAVES ...... 33 9 MARKET POTENTIAL FOR IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA ...... 35 9.1 MARKET SEGMENTATION ...... 35 9.2 MARKET POTENTIAL FOR IMERETI CAVES ...... 36 10 VISION AND OBJECTIVES OF TOURISM DEVELOPMENT IN IMERETI CAVES PA ...... 37 11 STRATEGIC PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT IN IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA ...... 39 11.1 SBU – STRATEGIC BUSINESS UNIT PRINCIPLE AND TOURISM PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT IN IMERETI CAVES ...... 39 11.2 STRATEGIC TOURISM PRODUCT STRUCTURE IN IMERETI CAVES PA IN 2013 AND 2020 ...... 44 11.3 DEVELOPMENT AND INVESTMENT PROJECTS ...... 46 11.4 HR – HUMAN RESOURCE, EDUCATION AND TRAININGS ...... 48 11.5 IMERETI CAVES PA BUDGET AND REVENES...... 50 11.6 PROMOTION AND MARKETING ...... 50 11.6.1 INFORMATION AND PROMOTION MATERIALS ...... 51 11.6.2 PROMOTION, MARKETING AND SALES ...... 52 11.7 ORGANIZATION OF PA’S MANAGEMENT AND STAKEHOLDERS’ COOPERATION ...... 54 11.8 QUALITY STANDARDS AND BRAND DEVELOPMENT ...... 55 11.9 REVENUE POLICY ...... 56 11.10 POLICY ...... 60 11.11 SAFETY AND SECURITY ...... 62 12 ACTION PLAN ...... 64 13 EFFECTS OF TOURISM DEVELOPMENT IN IMERETI CAVES ...... 69 13.1 ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL EFFECTS ...... 69 13.2 CHALLENGES AND RESTRICTIONS ...... 69 13.3 MONITORING OF REALIZATIO OF DEVELOPMENT PLAN ...... 70 14 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ...... 71 15 BASIC LITERATURE AND SOURCES ...... 73 16 ANNEXES ...... 74

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG i ASSESSING AND DEVE LOPING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - FINAL

ANNEX 1 WORKING MATERIA ABOUT IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA COLLECTED DURING ASSESSMENT PHASE ...... 74 1 IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA ...... 75 1.1 BASIC PROFILE OF PROTECTED AREA ...... 75 1.2 ANALYSIS OF IDOLS, COMPETITIORS AND STAKEHOLDERS ...... 80 1.3 SWOT ANALYSIS FOR PROTECTED AREA ...... 82 1.4 ANALYSIS OF EXISTING AND POTENTIAL TOURIST PRODUCTS...... 86 ANNEX 2 ILLUSTRATION OF TOURISM EXISTING AND POTENTIAL PRODUCTS FOR IMERETI CAVES AND OKATSE CANYON ...... 88 ANNEX 3 EVALUATION OF ATTRACTIVENESS AND COMPETITIVENESS OF NEW TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SERVICES IN IMERETI CAVES ...... 97 ANNEX 4 PROPOSAL OF SELECTED INTERNATIONAL MARKETING PARTNERS AND CHANNELS FOCUSED ON NATURE AND ADVENTURE TOURISM ...... 100

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG ii ASSESSING AND DEVE LOPING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - FINAL

ANNEXES

ANNEX 1 WORKING MATERIA ABOUT IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA COLLECTED DURING ASSESSMENT PHASE ...... 74 ANNEX 2 ILLUSTRATION OF TOURISM EXISTING AND POTENTIAL PRODUCTS FOR IMERETI CAVES AND OKATSE CANYON ...... 88 ANNEX 3 EVALUATION OF ATTRACTIVENESS AND COMPETITIVENESS OF NEW TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SERVICES IN IMERETI CAVES ...... 97 ANNEX 4 PROPOSAL OF SELECTED INTERNATIONAL MARKETING PARTNERS AND CHANNELS FOCUSED ON NATURE AND ADVENTURE TOURISM ...... 100

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG iii ASSESSING AND DEVE LOPING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - FINAL

LIST OF FIGURES

FIGURE 1: LOCATION OF IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA AND SATAPLIA NATURE RESERVE12 FIGURE 2: PLAN OF PROMETHEUS CAVE ...... 13 FIGURE 3: TOURISM TRENDS IN PROTECTED AREAS...... 32 FIGURE 4: LEVEL OF ATTRACTIVENESS AND COMPETITIVENESS OF 11 NEW TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SERVICES IN IMERETI CAVES ...... 45 FIGURE 5: THE STRUCTURE OF VISITORS ACCORDING TO EXPERIENCES THAT THEY EXPECT IN IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA IN 2013 AND IN 2020TOURISM STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION MODEL – RESOURCES AND POLICY ...... 46

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG iv ASSESSING AND DEVE LOPING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - FINAL

LIST OF TABLES

TABLE 1: BASIC INFORMATION OF IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA (STATUS END OF 2013)14 TABLE 2: NUMBER AND STRUCTURE OF EMPLOYEES IN IMERETI CAVES (STATUS MID OF 2014)14 TABLE 3: NUMBER OF VISITORS TO IMERETI CAVES FROM 2009 TILL 2013 ...... 15 TABLE 4: THE PROPORTION OF DOMESTIC VISITORS TO IMERETI CAVES FROM 2009 TO 201315 TABLE 5: DISTRIBUTION OF VISITORS TO IMERETI CAVES BY MONTHS IN 2013...... 16 TABLE 6: SEASONALITY OF VISITATION TO IMERETI CAVES AND TO PAS IN GEORGIA IN 201316 TABLE 7: INTENSITY OF VISITATION TO IMERETI CAVES AND PAS IN GEORGIA BY MONTHS IN 2013 ...... 17 TABLE 8: MAIN COUNTRIES OF ORIGIN OF FOREIGN VISITORS TO IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA IN 2013 ...... 17 TABLE 9: MAIN MOTIVES FOR VISITING IMERETI CAVES IN 2013 (IN %) ...... 18 TABLE 10: DISTRIBUTION OF VISITORS TO GROUPS AND INDIVIDUALS WHEN VISITING IMERETI CAVES FOR 2013 ...... 18 TABLE 11: DISTRIBUTION OF VISITORS DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS WHEN VISITING IMERETI CAVES FOR 2013 ...... 18 TABLE 12: MAIN OBSERVATIONS OF VISITORS ABOUT POSITIVE EXPERIENCES WHILE VISITING IMERETI CAVES ...... 19 TABLE 13: MAIN OBSERVATIONS OF VISITORS ABOUT NEGATIVE EXPERIENCES WHILE VISITING IMERETI CAVES ...... 19 TABLE 14: PRICE LIST FOR SATAPLIA NATURE RESERVE AND PROMETHEUS CAVE (IN GEL) ... 20 TABLE 15: SWOT ANALYSIS FOR IMERETI CAVES ...... 24 TABLE 16: VALUE CHAIN ANALYSIS OF TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SERVICES IN IMERETI CAVES25 TABLE 17: IDENTIFICATION OF MAIN TOURISM RELATED STAKEHOLDERS IN IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA ...... 28 TABLE 18: IDENTIFICATION OF EXISTING TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SERVICES IN IMERETI CAVES (STATUS MID YEAR 2014) ...... 30 TABLE 19: MATRIX OF TOURISM COMPATIBILITY AND PROFILES OF ECO-TOURISTS ACCORDING TO CATEGORY AND MANAGEMENT PURPOSE OF PAS ...... 34 TABLE 20: IMERETI CAVES SBU NATURE ...... 40 TABLE 21: IMERETI CAVES SBU CULTURE & EDUCATION ...... 41 TABLE 22: IMERETI CAVES SBU SPORTS & ADVENTURES ...... 41 TABLE 23: IMERETI CAVES SBU HEALTH ...... 42 TABLE 24: IMERETI CAVES SBU PLEASURE ...... 42 TABLE 25: IMERETI CAVES SBU BUSINESS – MICE ...... 43 TABLE 26: IMERETI CAVES SBU FUN & ENTERTAINMENT ...... 43 TABLE 27: EVALUATION OF ATTRACTIVENESS AND COMPETITIVENESS OF 11 NEW TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SEVRICES IN IMERETI CAVES PA (TOTAL SCORES RANGE FROM 1 TO 100) ...... 44 TABLE 28: THE STRUCTURE OF VISITORS ACCORDING TO EXPERIENCES THAT THEY EXPECT IN IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA IN 2013 AND IN 2020 ...... 46 TABLE 29: OVERVIEW OF INVESTMENT PROJECTS, TOURISM PRODUCTS AND RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS IN IMERETI CAVES IN THE PERIOD 2014 – 2020 ...... 47

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG v ASSESSING AND DEVE LOPING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - FINAL

TABLE 30: OPERATIONAL BUDGET AND COMMERCIAL REVENUES OF IMERETI CAVES FOR 2013/2014 AND ESTIMATION OF BUDGET AND COMMERCIAL REVENUES AFTER INVESTMENT PROJECTS, NEW PRODUCTS DEVELOPMENT AND PERFORMING FULL TOURISM FUNCTIONS ...... 50 TABLE 31: BASIC PHASES IN BRAND DEVELOPMENT ...... 56 TABLE 32: IMERETI CAVES ENTRANCE FEE ...... 58 TABLE 33: IMERETI CAVES ADDITIONAL OFFER...... 58 TABLE 34: IMERETI CAVES ADDITIONAL OFFER FOR ...... 58 TABLE 35: COMPARATIVE REVIEW OF INTENSITY OF VISITATION IN IMERETI CAVES WITH POSTOJNA CAVE FOR 2013 ...... 61 TABLE 36: ACTION PLAN FOR IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA FOR THE PERIOD 2015 - 202064

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG vi ASSESSING AND DEVE LOPING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - FINAL

ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS

ABTA Association of British Agents APA Agency for Protected Areas ATOL Air Travel Organizers’ Licencing in UK BKNP Borjomi Kharagauli National Park CBD on Biodiversity CNF Caucasus Nature Fund DMO Destination Management Organization ETDC Ecological Tourism Development Centre ETIS European Tourism Indicators System for sustainable destinations FAM Familiariazation trips (for TO/TA and/or journalists) GCAA Georgia Civil Aviation Agency GITOA Georgia Incomming Tour Operators Association GNTA Georgia National Tourism Administration GTA Georgia Tourism Association HR Human resource IUCN International Union for Conservation of Nature MICE Meetings, Incentives, Congresses, Events MoE Ministry of Environment Protection and Natural Resources NACRES Centre for Biodiversity Conservation and Research NACHPG National Agency for Cultural Heritage Preservation of Georgia NGO Non - Governmental Organization NP National Park ONS Office for National Statistics of UK PA Protected Area SBU Strategic Business Unit TA Tourist/ TIC Tourist Information Center TJS Transboundary Joint Secretariat for the Southern Caucasus TO UNDP United nations Development Programme UNEP United Nations Environment Programme USAID United States Agency for International Development UNWTO United Nations World Tourism Organization WB World Bank WWF World Wildlife Fund

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG vii ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

1 INTRODUCTION

The project „Assessing and development the eco-tourism potential of the protected areas in Georgia”has a task to prepare “Tourism development and management plan for Imereti caves protected area” as a sample for market oriented tourism development strategy for protected area in Georgia.Imereti caves were selected by APA as one of seven PAs that were assessed by the project.

The "Tourism development and management plan for Imereti Caves"is a strategic guiding document for protected areas administration in the field of tourism contributing to objectives of PA management.It includes proposals of tourism products and services, required facilities, staff capacities and cooperation with stakeholders, required investments for infrastructure and tourism products and services, expected revenues and required operational costs.

This document is prepared on the basis of “Strategy of tourism development in protected areas in Georgia” as the main deliverable of the project. Imereti tourism development and management plan is thus on one side application of national tourism strategy of protected areas to one selected protected area and on the other side a model for preparation of such tourism development and management plans for other protected areas in Georgia.

Imereti caves Protected Areas includes Prometheus cave natural monument, Sataplia Managed Reserve and Nature Reserve, Okatse Canyon Natural Monument. Sataplia Nature Reserve was established already in 1935 to protect the geological, speleological and botanical monuments. There are 5 caves in the reserve. Sataplia is touristically very well organized offering visit to the cave, Jurassic park, educational, rock and Kolchic forest trailsand scenic glass viewpoint all together 3.110 m long. Prometheus Cave was discovered in June 1984. It is estimated that the whole length of the cave is about 20.000 meters but research was done only in 3.700 m while tourists have a cave trail of 1.420 m long. The cave is very attractive for domestic and international visitors and offers after 1.420 m of walking also a 380 m long boat trip to the exit of the cave. In the area there are also several smaller caves that can be organized for tourist visitation.Okatse Canyon is newly developed tourism natural monument with and walking and viewing platform over the gorge that was officially open in September 2014.

Prometheus Cave and Sataplia are the most tourism oriented natural protected monuments in Georgia. There were 145.375 domestic and international visitors to both monuments in 2013, with nearly equal visitation – 72.954 visitors in Prometheurs cave and 72.421 in Sataplia. The share of international visitors is constantly increasing and reached 23% of all visitors in 2013.

When preparing this document for Imereti Caves authors considered also “Tourism development marketing plan for Imereti”, prepared by GNTA in 2012.

Tourism development and management plan focuses on the period to the year 2020. It is structured in chapters analyzing present situation of protected area, with tourism products and services, organization and employment situation, relations with main tourism stakeholders and assessment of development potentials. There is detailed presentation of present tourism visitation, market situation and potential demand. Document brings vision, mission and main objectives and elaboration of strategic tourism product development based on marketing concept. Next chapters describe strategy implementation model with main projects, HR needs, marketing, policy measures and sustainability implementation policy. The document ends with estimation of basic economic and other information of investment projects till 2020 and with action plan. The document has several annexes that bring additional information and explanations to findings and proposals of good practices from various fields of tourism development in PAs from developed countries.

The “Strategy of tourism development in protected areas in Georgia” is as any other document based on some conditions and estimations as well as internal and external factors with different possible effects in implementation time. Therefore, monitoring of implementation of the strategy gives also the signals when and where to adopt strategy or implementation policy to keep the direction that leads to the long term vision.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 8

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

2 METHODOLOGY

“Tourism development and management plan for Imereti Caves protected area” is a sample case of national tourism development strategy for protected areas in Georgia applied to one selected protected area. APA selected for this sample case Imereti Caves PA. With this document and additional guidelines for tourism development and management planning in PAs in Georgia APA would like to introduce more organized and result oriented development of tourism in PAs due to the need to manage more efficiently tourism flows and to benefit from tourist visitation of PAs.

Imereti caves document was done in 3phases: inception, 1st assessment phase and final-strategy development and management setting phase. Each phase results were discussed and evaluated at workshops and meetings with beneficiary and other stakeholders.

In short inception phase project team was informed about basic challenges and problems of tourism development in protected areas in Georgia bythe client and beneficiary and important institutions. Experts also collected basic documents, materials and data.

The 1st phase was focused on assessment and evaluation of eco-tourism potentials in PAs in Georgia where natural and other potentials and existing tourism products have been analysed, SWOT analysis have been performed and stakeholder cooperation model discussed in order to establish partnership of PAs, tourism suppliers and local population. Special emphasize has been given also to demand and market situation.

This assessment was done for 7 selected PAs during the field trip of expert team and among these 7 PAs was also Imereti Caves Protect Area - Prometeus Cave natural monument, Sataplia Managed Reserve and Nature Reserve, Okatse Canyon Natural Monument. Field visits took place from 5th to 27th August. Project team met PAs administration, directors, rangers, instructors, employees in visitors’ centres, representatives of municipalities and tourism organizations, tourism suppliers as owners, restaurateurs, producers of food and , tour operators and travel agencies, tour guides, drivers, etc. The experts’ observations and findings from field visits were combined and improved with available documents related to PAs as well as with documents and literature covering this subject and collected from various sources. These working materials of assessment of 7 PAs are attached as an annex to 1st phase project report. Working documents of assessment of Imereti caves protected area are attached to this document in Annex 1.

Assessment analysis of 7 PAs and findings with some preliminary conclusions were presented and discussed on workshop on 18. September 2014. The participants discussed and added their views and proposals for improvement and next steps.

The 2nd phase of preparation of Tourism development and management plan for Imereti Caves Protected area started with refinement of assessment findings that resulted from preparing the proposal of "The strategy of tourism development of protected areas in Georgia". During the 2nd field visit to Imereti caves PA from 19. – 24. October 2014 these refined findings were discussed and finalized, strategy objectives defined, implementation policy discussed and investment projects prepared.

Imereti caves protected area has all together 21 natural and managed reserves and monuments: 1. Sataplia strict nature reserve 2. Sataplia Managed reserve 3. Promethe Cave natural monument 4. Tetri Cave natural monument 5. Khomuli Cave natural monument 6. Tsutskhvati Cave natural monument 7. Navenakhevi Cave natural monument 8. Nagarevi Cave natural monument 9. Iazoni Cave natural monument 10. Sakazhe Cave natural monument 11. Tskaltsitela Valley natural monument 12. Okatse Canyon natural monument

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 9

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

13. Okatse waterfall natural monument 14. Gabzaruli Lake natural monument 15. Satsurblia Cave natural monument 16. Salkota Cave natural monument 17. Didgele Cave natural monument 18. Melouri Cave natural monument 19. Bgera Cave natural monument 20. Gliana Sakazhe Cave natural monument 21. Mukhura waterfall natural monument

During the assessment and further discussions it was concluded that besides already open Sataplia nature and managed reseve, Prometheus caves and recently open Okatse canyon there is speleological research performed in 8 other caves that could be potentially tourist caves. Among them priority is given to Navenakhevi, Satsurblia and Melauri caves which can be developed and open for visitors in the period covered by this tourism development plan.

This 2nd phase was realized in very intensive and interactive cooperation especially with Imereti caves PA administration and with Tskaltubo municipality leaders and Tourism and management centre of Tskaltubo.

Final phase of the project was elaborated with presentation of draft document “Tourism development and management plan for Imereti caves” on workshop on 7th November with APA headquarters and Imereti Caves PA administrations in the conference hall in Prometheus administration building.

Project team used several methods in project implementation: desk research, field visits, quantitative and qualitative methods, workshops, focus groups and interviews. Assessment was done by SWOT analysis and supporting templates and questionnaires. Simplified value chain analysis was done for Imereti Caves too. Strategy formulation was based on SBU – Strategic Business Units methodology was used for focusing on product development based on expected experiences of visitors and attractiveness-competitiveness portfolio method for prioritizing tourism potential product development was used. Throughout project preparation experts’ team used standardized forms and templates that enable to follow the process of development of this document and can be used also in other cases.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 10

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

3 PROFILE OF IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA

Georgia has more than 100 years long tradition of protection of nature and its richness. The first overall protected area was Lagodekhi Strict nature reserve dating back to the year 1912. The last one was Pshav-Khevsureti Protected Area (110.205 ha) which was officially constituted as PA in April 2014.

At the end of 2014, Georgia has 87 protected areas with different categories according to IUCN criteria: 14 strict nature reserves (140.672 hectares), 11 national parks (352.459,219 hectares),41 natural monuments (2.257,74 hectares), 19 managed nature reserves (70.392,78.255 hectares) and 2 protected landscapes (34.708 hectares). Protected nature represents 600.490,04 hectares – 8.62% of whole Georgian territory.

Imereti Caves Protected Areas was first established in 2011 based on Sataplia Strict Nature Reserve. It is located in west side of Georgia in Imereti region and includes four municipalities – Tskaltubo, , Terjola and Tkibuli.Imereti Caves Protected Areas can be described as speleological underground mystery. Additional unique attraction is dinosaur’s footprints in Sataplia

With unique natural attractiveness without competition in an area, Imereti caves are easily accessible from the main transit road connecting West and East Gerogia, from international airport and gives additional tourism product to those tourists in Tskatubo health and spa resort, Black Sea and to visitors of UNESCO cultural heritage in Kutaisi: Bagrati cathedral and Gelati monastery.

The total area of Imereti Caves Protected Areas amounts to 518.1 ha and includes Sataplia Nature Reserve (330 ha), Sataplia Managed Reserve (34 ha), Prometheus Cave Natural Monuments (46.6 ha), Okatse Canyon and Waterfall Natural Monuments and and other 16 Natural Monuments. The administrative building is located in Sataplia Managed Reserve and is administring Imereti Caves Protected Areas.

Sataplia Nature Reserve was established in order to protect the geological, speleological and botanical monuments. The Nature Reserve is situated at a height of 500 meters above sea level. The climate is subtropical. Annual amount of precipitation reaches 1900 mm. Five karst caves can be found in the territory of Sataplia Managed Reserve, there is a domed hall 100 meters away from the entrance, in the center of which the sizes and beauty of erected stalagmites and downward from above stalactites can be seen. Sataplia cave is situated at a height of 360 meters above sea level.

Sataplia Cave was first discovered in 1925 by Petre Chabukiani, who worked as an environmentalist in Kutaisi. He also found the vestiges of settlement of primitive man and discovered the dinosaur footprints. The cave was named after Mount Sataplia, an extinct volcano 494 meters in height. Since ancient times this mountain has been ideal location for bees and surrounding villages have a long tradition in beekeeping and accumulating honey in the rockcracks.

98% of Sataplia PAs is covered with subtropical young forest of Colchic type. In the forest dominate beech groves with box-tree underbrush and hornbeam groves with Oriental hornbeam underbrush. Among coniferous plants natural yew trees (Taxus baccata) can be found in the PA. 67 species of wood plants are described in the territory of the Nature Reserve, out of which 30 are tree species and 37 bush species; among them 59 species are deciduous and 8 evergreen. Nearly half of wood plants are relict. It is remarkable, that rare and threatened 9 wood plants species of Georgia’s Red List are widespread in the Nature Reserve, beside 3 endemic to Caucasus and one to Georgia. Sataplia Nature Reserve is inhabited by 12 species of mammals, 5 species of reptiles, 4 species od amphybians and 30 species of birds. Constant temperature of +14C° is maintained into the Sataplia cave during the winter and summer periods. Due to interesting microclimate of the cave the live organisms adapted to the darkness inhabit there (freshwater mollusks, blind crayfishes, spiders, bats, etc.). Total length of the Sataplia cave is 900 meters. Track length is 310 meters. In the cave can be found stalactites, stalagmites, “stone curtains”, arch ceiling and domed hall.

Sataplia Managed Reserve Infrastructure includes visitor center that contains 8 rooms hotel, conference hall and cinema room with 3D screen; conservation building of dinosaur footprint, exhibition hall, glass panoramic view-point, cafes, shops, well-arranged cave and marked

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 11

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL trails. Visitors can observe fossilized dinosaur footprints, karst caves, rock trail, Colchis forest and panoramic viewpoints.

Source: APA website and Imereti caves brochures

FIGURE 1: LOCATION OF IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA AND SATAPLIA NATURE INFRUSTRUCTURE AND TRAILS

Prometheus cave is located 14 km away from Sataplia, in the village of Kumistavi of the Tskaltubo region. The cave was discovered in June 1984. It is situated at a height of 147 meters above sea level. There is the Orpiri cave on the opposite side, which is up to 35 meters long and it ends by the same exit. 600 meters away from Orpiri cave the Opicho cave is located. Spring flows out in the cave, which forms a lake nearby after passing 8 meters. There are 17 halls found in the cave, 6 of which are open to visitors. Although 3.700 meters have been explored, only 1.420 meters are suitable for visitors, with the tours ending at a 380-meter long river flowing through the cave.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 12

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Prometheus Cave infrastructure includes visitors center and well-arranged cave. Visitors have an opportunity to observe the cave on foot as well as by boat.

Source: APA website and Imereti caves brochures

FIGURE 2: PLAN OF PROMETHEUS CAVE

Imereti Caves Protected Areas Administration has one of the best-arranged infrastructure in Sataplia Managed Reserve, Prometheus Natural Monument and Okatse Canyon. Imereti caves are open for visitors throughout the year,although the majority – 82% of visitors arrive from May till October.

Imereti caves protected area is centrally organized as administration unit of APA – Agency for Protected Areas in Georgia. Imereti caves PA administration covers 3 sites: Sataplia nature reserve, Prometheus cave and Okatse canyon.. Caves are also the smallest PA in the countrymeasured by the surface.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 13

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

TABLE 1: BASIC INFORMATION OF IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA (STATUS END OF 2013)

Tourist Open Imereti caves Surface Total length Budget Employees Visitors length of for PA (ha) of cave (m) (GEL) total total trail (m) visits

Imereti caves 504 1,460,197 42 145,888

Sataplia 364 900 3.110/310 - 13 72.421 I-XII

Prometheus 47 20.000/3.700 1.420+380 - 19 73.467 I-XII cave

Okatse - - 0 -

Georgia PAs 520.273 - 6,215,696 492 350,641 total

Source: APA and information from Pas Note: Data for Imereti caves include Prometheus and Sataplia caves.

The total number of employees in Imereti Caves is 41 persons as full time and 28 as Freelance in peak season. Ther are 9 persons employed to serve both natural monuments and 19 for Prometheus Cave and 13 for Sataplia Nature Reserve.

TABLE2: NUMBER AND STRUCTURE OF EMPLOYEES IN IMERETI CAVES (STATUS MID OF 2014)

caves PA caves PA

Engineer Cashier Imereti administration Employees total Management Office Environment protection dvlp Product Marketing/ Visitors service Rangers guides Tour Others

Prometheus 5 8 2 2 3 1 2 1 0 2

Sataplia 5 5 2 3

Total 42 3 1 2 1 0 2 10 13 4 5 Source: Information from APA and Imereti caves PA administration

There is a plan to employ first staff for Okatse canyon in 2015.

Imereti Caves are understaffed but they solve the problem with seasonal worlkers. Problem with staff is especially in tourism/hospitality services. PA+s administration underlines also the need for education and trainings in marketing, sales and branding, tour guiding, foreign languages (English and Russian) and project preparation.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 14

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

4 BASIC CHARACTERISTICS OF TOURISM IN IMERETI CAVES

4.1 Tourism visits to Imereti caves

Statistical evidence of visitation to Imereti caves protected areas dates back to 2009. This statistics is based on registration of visitors buying entrance tickets and is thus very reliable compared to overall statistics for protected areas in Georgia where there are no entrance fee to form the basis for statistics.

Imereti caves became in last years the leading protected area in Georgia regarding tourist visitation. In 4 years from 2009 on the number of all visitors to Sataplia nature reserve and Prometheus cave increased by 3 times. This increase was especially significant when opening Prometheus cave open for visitors with modern and attractive facilities and organization. Today, both nature monuments register nearly the same number of visitors – around 72.500 summing up in total of about 145.000 domestic and international visitors.

The statistical figures corresponding to the number of visitors to Imereti Caves during the first 10 months of 2014 show a significant increase of 152.065 domestic and international visitors. This number is so far larger than the number of visitors during the whole 2013. Among these visitors 66% are domestic and 34% international who registered a high increase of their share compared to the corresponding 29% in 2013.

Major share of visitors in Imereti Caves are domestic visitors 71% but their share dropped sharply in last 4 years; in 2009, the share of domestic visitor was 97%! Domestic market is very important for development of Imereti caves protected areas. It is more important for Sataplia Nature Reserve mainly because of schools . The share of international visitors in Prometheus cave – 34% is much higher than the average of all PAs in Georgia – 28%.

TABLE3: NUMBER OF VISITORS TO IMERETI CAVES FROM 2009 TILL 2013

Sataplia Prometheus Imereti caves total Georgia PAs total Year Domes Interna Domes Interna Domes Interna Domes Interna Total Total Total Total tic tional tic tional tic tional tic tional 2009 48.141 1.361 49.502 0 0 0 48.141 1.361 49.502 62.997 5.764 68.670 2010 23.116 322 32.438 0 0 0 23.116 322 32.438 105.215 21.294 126.509 2011 67.815 7.338 75.153 24.558 3.604 28.162 92.373 10.942 103.315 255.477 48.246 302.643 2012 48.598 8.427 57.025 31.044 8.356 39.400 79.642 16.783 96.425 230.955 67.995 294.074 2013 55.832 16.589 72.421 48.225 25.242 73.467 104.057 41.831 145.888 255.540 101.078 356.618 Source: APA – Agency for protected areas

According to APA statistics visits to Sataplia and Prometheus caves represent 41% of all visitors to PAs in Georgia in 2013. This share dropped from 2009 when there were 72.1% of all registered visitors in PAs in Georgia in Imereti caves – in Sataplia nature reserve. This only shows positive trend of improving attractiveness of Georgian PAs for international and domestic visitors.

TABLE4: THE PROPORTION OF DOMESTIC VISITORS TO IMERETI CAVES FROM 2009 TO 2013

Prometheus – Imereti Caves - Year Staplia - Domestic (5) Domestic (%) Domestic (%) 2009 97,3% 0,0% 97,3% 2010 71,3% 0,0% 71,3% 2011 90,2% 87,2% 89,4% 2012 85,2% 78,8% 82,6% 2013 77,1% 65,6% 71,3% Source: APA – Agency for protected areas

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 15

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Imereti Caves are open for visitors all the year. Both natural monuments – Sataplia and Prometheus are closed for visitors one day a week – but not the same day, one each Monday the other each Tuesday. The most frequented month is June when pupils from schools visit Imereti caves as a part of their education and tourism . These visits affect especially Sataplia where 41% of all domestic visitors in 2013 came to Sataplia in June 2013.

In Imereti caves, 81% of all visitors come from May till end of September – in 5 months. This is even higher concentration than for whole PAs in Georgia where share of visitors in these 5 months is 78%. If we eliminate the effect of school visitation to Imereti caves in June, we see that the most frequently visited month in Imereti caves and in all PAs in Georgia is August. On the other hand international visitors come mainly in the months before – May, June July and after summer –peak season even in October when they are on touring in Georgia and make nearly obligatory stop in Imereti caves. The fact that Imereti caves are open for visitors all year and the share of visits in 7 months reaches only 19% represent important possibility to increase the overall visitation to Imereti caves protected area.

TABLE5: DISTRIBUTION OF VISITORS TO IMERETI CAVES BY MONTHS IN 2013

Sataplia Prometheus Imereti caves total Georgia PAs total Month Domes Internati Domes Internati Domes Internati Domes Internati 2013 Total Total Total Total tic onal tic onal tic onal tic onal January 200 115 315 356 213 569 556 328 884 2.114 669 2.783 February 427 165 592 305 158 463 732 323 1.055 2.995 760 3.715 March 834 447 1.281 586 368 954 1.420 815 2.235 4.411 1.737 6.148 April 1.273 950 2.223 935 938 1.873 2.208 1.888 4.096 7.745 3.796 11.541 May 5.786 2.326 8.112 3.553 3.174 6.727 9.339 5.500 14.839 22.978 12.170 35.148 June 22.828 3.060 25.888 16.054 3.718 19.772 38.882 6.778 45.660 55.473 9.483 64.956 July 6.262 3.000 9.262 7.675 2.789 10.464 13.937 5.789 19.726 34.869 19.640 54.509 August 8.310 2.200 10.510 11.846 1.212 13.058 20.156 3.412 23.568 38.815 22.576 61.391 September 3.974 1.985 5.959 7.118 961 8.079 11.092 2.946 14.038 23.391 16.648 40.039 October 3.268 2.000 5.268 4.000 1.834 5.834 7.268 3.834 11.102 19.736 9.577 29.132 November 2.000 644 2.644 3.000 1.119 4.119 5.000 1.763 6.763 11.875 3.202 11.775 December 300 67 367 1.000 42 1.042 1.300 109 1.409 3.326 975 4.290 Year 2013 55.832 16.589 72.421 48.225 25.242 73.467 104.057 41.831 145.888 227.728 101.233 325.427

Source: APA – Agency for protected areas

TABLE6: SEASONALITY OF VISITATION TO IMERETI CAVES AND TO PAS IN GEORGIA IN 2013

Sataplia Prometheus Imereti caves total Georgia PAs total Month Domes Internati Domes Internati Domes Internati Domes Internati 2013 Total Total Total Total tic onal tic onal tic onal tic onal January 0,4% 0,7% 0,4% 0,6% 1,3% 0,8% 0,5% 1,0% 0,6% 0,9% 0,7% 0,9% February 0,8% 1,0% 0,8% 0,5% 1,0% 0,6% 0,7% 1,0% 0,7% 1,3% 0,8% 1,1% March 1,5% 2,6% 1,8% 1,0% 2,2% 1,3% 1,3% 2,4% 1,5% 1,9% 1,7% 1,9% April 2,3% 5,6% 3,1% 1,7% 5,7% 2,6% 2,0% 5,6% 2,8% 3,4% 3,7% 3,5% May 10,4% 13,7% 11,2% 6,3% 19,2% 9,2% 8,3% 16,4% 10,2% 10,1% 12,0% 10,8% June 41,2% 18,0% 35,7% 28,5% 22,5% 27,1% 34,8% 20,2% 31,4% 24,4% 9,4% 20,0% July 11,3% 17,7% 12,8% 13,6% 16,9% 14,3% 12,5% 17,3% 13,6% 15,3% 19,4% 16,7% August 15,0% 13,0% 14,5% 21,0% 7,3% 17,9% 18,0% 10,2% 16,2% 17,0% 22,3% 18,9% September 7,2% 11,7% 8,2% 12,6% 5,8% 11,1% 9,9% 8,8% 9,7% 10,3% 16,4% 12,3% October 5,9% 11,8% 7,3% 7,1% 11,1% 8,0% 6,5% 11,4% 7,6% 8,7% 9,5% 9,0% November 3,6% 3,8% 3,7% 5,3% 6,8% 5,6% 4,5% 5,3% 4,7% 5,2% 3,2% 3,6% December 0,5% 0,4% 0,5% 1,8% 0,3% 1,4% 1,2% 0,3% 1,0% 1,5% 1,0% 1,3% Year 2013 100,0% 100,0% 100,0% 100,0% 100,0% 100,0% 100,0% 100,0% 100,0% 100,0% 100,0% 100,0%

Source: calculated on the basis of data from APA – Agency for protected areas

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 16

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Such seasonality has an impact on intensity of visitation in peak months, on satisfaction of visitors and employees and on sustainability of natural and social environment. It is evident that 863 visitors per day in June in Sataplia as well as 659 visitors per day in June in Prometheus cave are very high. If we consider that both monuments are open for visitors 10 hours per day in June it means that in Sataplia each hour there are 86 persons and in Prometheus 66 persons on the trail or in the cave which are too big numbers for groups. These figures require improvement of management of visitors flows at least for June.

It is also interesting to observe that Imereti caves with 1.522 visitors per day contribute 70% of all daily visitor to all PAs in Georgia – 2.165 visitors per day in June.

TABLE7: INTENSITY OF VISITATION TO IMERETI CAVES AND PAS IN GEORGIA BY MONTHS IN 2013

Sataplia Prometheus Imereti caves total Georgia PAs total Month Visitors/ Visitors/ Visitors/ Visitors/ 2013 Total Total Total Total day day day day January 315 10 569 18 884 29 2.783 90 February 592 21 463 17 1.055 38 3.715 133 March 1.281 41 954 31 2.235 72 6.148 198 April 2.223 74 1.873 62 4.096 137 11.541 385 May 8.112 262 6.727 217 14.839 479 35.148 1.134 June 25.888 863 19.772 659 45.660 1.522 64.956 2.165 July 9.262 299 10.464 338 19.726 636 54.509 1.758 August 10.510 339 13.058 421 23.568 760 61.391 1.980 September 5.959 199 8.079 269 14.038 468 40.039 1.335 October 5.268 170 5.834 188 11.102 358 29.132 940 November 2.644 88 4.119 137 6.763 225 11.775 393 December 367 12 1.042 34 1.409 45 4.290 138

Year 2013 72.421 198 73.467 201 145.888 400 325.427 892 Source: calculated on the basis of data from APA – Agency for protected areas

4.2 Main markets and profile of visitors to Imereti caves

International visitors count 23% of all visitors to Imereti caves and are increasing faster than domestic visitors. Main foreign markets are neighbouring and Russian speaking countries, East European and Baltic countries, Israel and Germany. International visitors came to Imereti Caves in 2013 from 15 countries – also from long haul USA and China markets.

TABLE8: MAIN COUNTRIES OF ORIGIN OF FOREIGN VISITORS TO IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA IN 2013

Imereti caves Visitors Foreign Country Country Country Country Domestic PA total visitors 1 2 3 4 Visitors

Imereti caves 145,888 41,831 Ukraine Israel Poland Russia 104,057

Georgia total 350,642 101,642 249,000

Source: APA and information from PAs

After opening Kutaisi International Airport the number of visitors to Imereti region has significantly increased due to new airlines mainly operated by low cost carriers. GNTA reports that there were 68.568 arrivals of international visitors to Kutaisi airport in 2013. From the airport website we can see that 5 air carriers operate from Kutaisi airport: WizzAir, S7, URAL, Bellavia and Georgia Airways flying to 8 destinations. All these international visitors start their travel in Georgia by visiting Imereti caves. With more low cost air carriers number of international visitors would increase even faster.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 17

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

GNTA estimates that majority of international visitors are individuals organizing their trip by themselves. The share of organized visitors that arrived in organization of TOs/TAs does not exceed 30% of total visitors. In spite of this fact, estimations for Imereti caves say that 70% of their visitors are group visitors. Besides groups of school children international travellers usually use Georgian TO to organize their touring in Georgia. From Tourism development marketing strategy for Imereti (GNTA, 2012) we learn that TO regularly include in their tours to Imereti cultural monuments and in 60% also Imereti caves.

Therefore, we must conclude that group tourism market is very important for Imereti caves, which has also the consequence for promotion and marketing – besides marketing oriented towards individual customers B2C marketing oriented towards corporate partners B2B is more important. B2B marketing includes in the case of Imereti caves schools, TOs/TAs, and accommodation providers in Tskaltubo and Kutaisi and national and international speleological associations. Main motives to visit Sataplia reserve and Prometheurs cave are nature experience and education.

TABLE9: MAIN MOTIVES FOR VISITING IMERETI CAVES IN 2013 (IN %)

Name Motive 1 Motive 2

Sataplia & Prometheus cave Nature - 67% Education - 37%

Source: Calculated on the basis of APA survey for Imereti caves

Visitors to Sataplia Reserve and Prometheus Cave come mainly in groups as school children or in organization of Georgian tour operators when touring in Georgia.

TABLE10: DISTRIBUTION OF VISITORS TO GROUPS AND INDIVIDUALS WHEN VISITING IMERETI CAVES FOR 2013

Groups Name Individuals Total (TO/TA) Sataplia & Prometheus cave 30% 70% 100% Source: Information from Imereti caves PA administration

According to estimations of Imereti Caves administration students and school children are the biggest groups of visitors, then come individuals, families and couples.

TABLE11: DISTRIBUTION OF VISITORS DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS WHEN VISITING IMERETI CAVES FOR 2013

Individual Researchers/ Children/ Name Families Couples Students Total visitors Scientists Schools Sataplia & Prometheus 16% 7% 20% 1% 28% 28% 100% cave Source: Information from Imereti caves PA administration

Visitors to Imereti caves are rather critical about their experiences. They state several positive characteristics about Sataplia Reserve and Prometheus Cave. Among positive observations are the nature and landscape, very good location close to main transit road West-East Georgia, hospitable staff which goes together with good services and good-attractive trails.

Satisfaction Satisfaction Satisfaction Satisfaction Name 1 2 3 4 Nature & Prometeus cave Trail Location Landscape Hospitable Buildings - Visitors center and services staff facilities

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 18

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Additional tourism products Small train Visitors' Audio guides and services in PA and boat service Nature & Glass Sataplia cave Trail Location Landscape Viewpoint Hospitable Buildings - Visitors center and services staff facilities Additional tourism products Visitors' and services services Source: Information from Imereti caves PA administration

TABLE12: MAIN OBSERVATIONS OF VISITORS ABOUT POSITIVE EXPERIENCES WHILE VISITING IMERETI CAVES

Visitors state many critical observations that PA administration should seriously consider and do all to eliminate them. The first group of critics focuses on organization of infrastructure for tourists: visitors’ center, catering place, parking place, toilets which are not properly organized and equipped. Then come critics regarding lack of staff, guides and too big groups, another group of critics relates to lack of information, resting places while waiting and services especially for children.

Dissatis- Dissatis- Dissatis- Dissatis- Dissatis Name faction 1 faction 2 faction 3 faction 4 faction 5 Prometheus cave

Waiting place Not fully Catering Visitors center and is not Lack of utilized place too services organized qualified staff visitors small and equipped center Not sufficient Additional tourism Too big number of products and services groups staff Sataplia reserve

Visitors Bad, not Visitors center and center is far Lack of enough services from main guides toilets entrance Not sufficient No Additional tourism information No picnic Café does not Trails need playgrounds products and services about area function maintenance for children opening time Tourists not Availability of informed in Lack of information & advance interpretation promotion about the desks length of trail Public No regular No shelters accessibility transport Parking not public for rainy or & Parking timetable is organized transport sunny days not reliable Sign posting on roads Lack of signs

Limitted Tourism products and tourist offer services in especially for community/destination kids Source: Information from Imereti caves PA administration

TABLE13: MAIN OBSERVATIONS OF VISITORS ABOUT NEGATIVE EXPERIENCES WHILE VISITING IMERETI CAVES

Faster and more efficient tourism development in PAs in Georgia is one of the sources for financial sustainability of APA and PAs in realization of their mission to conserve, protect and manage nature, natural values and natural heritage. Economic effects of tourist activitiesare estimated to 16% of

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 19

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL overall budget of APA and PAs in 2013. Major revenues are coming from Imereti cave – 90% of all tourism revenues in all protected areas in Georgia.

Imereti caves collected 918.984 GEL revenues from tourism activities in 2013 and they will rise toapproximately1,2million GEL in 2014according to provisional statistics and forecast by Imereti caves administration. Nearly all revenues come from entrance fees – 89%. Average revenue per visitor in Imereti Caves was 6.3 GEL in 2013 including revenues from all services. This average revenue per visitor is even lower than the price of a ticket for an adult – 7 GEL. Imereti caves PA receive other revenues from concession of café and souvenir shop in Sataplia and and souvenir shop in Prometheus visitors center.

We present the price list for Sataplia nature reserve and for Prometheus cave in the figure below. It obvious that the assortiman of products and services offered to visitors does not offer much possibilities to increase revenues of Imereti caves.

No. PRODUCT/SERVICE ITEM PROMETHEUS SATAPLIA

1 Entry ticket

Pupils & students 3,5 3,0

Normal ticket 7,0 6,0

2 Boat trip 7,0

3 Audio guide 7,0

4 Civil marriage ceremony 100 100

5 Conferenece hall / day 100 100

6 VIP Service

1 – 10 persons 100 + ticket 100 + ticket

11 – 20 200 + ticket 200 + ticket

7 Coin mintage price 1,0

Source: APA website, 1. 11.2014

TABLE14: PRICE LIST FOR SATAPLIA NATURE RESERVE AND PROMETHEUS CAVE (IN GEL)

Due to the specific character of the tourism products that Imereti Caves are offering,the local community does not have a lot of benefits of visitation to Sataplia Reserve and Prometheus Cave. Visitors are spending in Imereti caves not more than 3 hours and do not require services from local communities like accommodation, food & beverage, guiding, agricultural products and others. International visitors are mainly on the tour in Georgia and while staying in the region they are based mainly in Kutaisi or in Tskaltubo health resort. Domestic visitors are mainly excursionists or transit passengers visiting also Imereti caves. Therefore, strengthening local communities and their economic performances by tourism development of Imereti caves should take different forms and measures as in the case of other PAs in Georgia proposed in chapter with stakeholders and their cooperation.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 20

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

5 SWOTAND VALUE CHAIN ANALYSIS OF IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA

5.1 SWOT – Strength, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats evaluation

SWOT analysis gives us the overview which strengths and weaknesses are at present time in operations and what opportunities and threats are in the environment and in the future that could affect operations.

During the field visits to Imereti SWOT was discussed in details. Imereti Cave system with Prometheus and Sataplia Caves being open for visitors represent the most important attraction in broader region. There is no competition for these caves in the range of nearly 1.000 kilometers. With further tourism development of some caves the whole system will become even more attractive for domestic and international visitors.

Important strength is also accessibility being close to international airport, main road, tourist resorts in Tskaltubo and at Black Sea and UNESCO heritage monuments - Bagrati and Gelati monasteries. Both, Satapalia Nature Reserve and Prometheus Cave are also the best equipped with tourism infrastructure and facilities among all PAs in Georgia. Opportunity for further development and increase of visitation is the fact that Georgia is becoming more and more recognized tourist dertination worldwide with two digit yearly growth of international tourist arrivals.

STRENGTH of IMERETI CAVES PA and WEAKNESSES of IMERETI CAVES PA and SURROUNDINGS SURROUNDINGS

TRANSPORT / ACCESSIBILITY TRANSPORT / ACCESSIBILITY > Good location, 240 km from capital , > Lack of road and tourism signalization 160 km from Black Sea, 20 km from Kutaisi > Poor public transport - no reliable > 30 km from Kutaisi international airport scheduled public transport > Close to the main road-international > Bus stations are scarce and information is highway and the cross road of the country - limited connecting west to the east > Very limited accessibility for disabled people > Good access roads to Sataplia reserve and > Rather bad road to Okatse Prometheus cave > Few low cost air carriers to Georgia > Close to bus and train station in Kutaisi > Limited parking places in Sataplia and Prometheus > Access roads and parking to be developed for new tourist caves > Poor internet accessibility

NATURAL & CULTURAL ASSETS NATURAL & CULTURAL ASSETS > Prometheus Cave has 17 halls, 6 halls open > Okatse and Sataplia are not easy accessible in to visitors winter time if there is snow > Rich diversity of geological, speleological > No risk assessment in regard to safety in and botanical monuments in the PA caves, glass view platform and canyon (colchic forest, timber plants,etc). walking platform > Rich biodiversity in Prometheus Cave > Slow rehabilitation of cultural monuments and (guttered stalactites, stalagmites, petrified sites and poor waste management waterfalls, hanging stone curtains, inhabited by organisms: bats, freshwater mollusks, spiders, etc.) > Distinguished landscape full of caves and canyons, unique Colchis wetlands, gorge of Rioni > Several cultural and archaeological monuments close to the PAs: IX century Ubisa church, X century Motsameta church, Chabukiani memorial > Two UNESCO heritage sites close to the

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 21

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

PAs: XII century Gelati Monastery complex and frescoes and XI century Bagrati Temple > Strong recognition of Tskaltubo resort and city Kutaisi > Mild climate

INFRASTRUCTURE INFRASTRUCTURE > Good and diverse infrastructure facilities in > Visitor centres and PAs administration Sataplia and Prometheus buildings are not fully utilized > Hotel infrastructure (8 rooms for 16 persons) > Closed hotel and conference room with 1 big conference room (cca 100 seats) > Water, electricity supply, and WIFI problems > Visitors centers in Sataplia > Administration buildings > No places for tourists to rest > Speleological Museum in Sataplia > No places for visitors that are not allowed to > Scenic glass viewpoint with bar enter the cave (children and accompanying > and Bar close to the Visitor center parents) > Information and ticket center with small shop > Poor or no infrastructure for disabled persons at the entrance to the Sataplia > Lack of First aid service > Audio guides available in several languages > Lack of restrooms > Postal service > Poor additional tourism products and services > Tourist Accommodation in Tskaltubo and (shopping areas, cultural events, Kutaisi (guesthouses, hotels, private playgrounds, lack of entertainment offer, etc.) accommodation, etc.)

TOURISM DEVELOPMENT TOURISM DEVELOPMENT > Sataplia PA and Prometheus cave are open all > No tourism development and management year round plan > Visited by 150 000 visitors in 2013. > Lack of professional-skilled hospitality staff Prometheus #1 destination place (visited 75 (tourist guides, tourist and marketing 000 >tourists) in the region specialists) > Prometheus developed tourism product: > Poor results of concession practice hiking trail - 1.420 m cave trail with 6 halls in > Seasonality, peak season is in June Prometheus plus 380 m water trail by boat > No scheduled tours (moderate difficulty) > Limited number of visitors / Restriction due > Prometheus tourism product: civil marriage to capacity per day in Prometheus(40 persons ceremony in Hall of Love per group, which start every 15 minutes) > Sataplia developed tourism product: walking > Reservations except for TO's groups are not trail 3.3 km., 2 hrs, easy walking. Trail to visit available the conservation building for dinosaur > Bad location of TIC in Kutaisi footprints, the unique karst cave, exhibition > Lack of promotional material - except APA's hall, Colchic Forest, and the wild bee habitat maps area. Suitable for families and children. > Not sufficient promotion, PR and marketing > VIP service for visitors > Lack of tourist programmes for children and families > Poor statistics on local and regional levels > Limited knowledge of foreign languages > No price differentiation > No Quality standardization > Poor brand image of tourist destinations

COOPERATION COOPERATION > Hospitable people with interest in tourism > No local or regional HORECA associations development (hotels, guest houses, ,...) > Imereti caves PA is member of ISCA – > Low integration of local population in tourism International Show Caves Associaition development > Some examples of good cooperation with > Very weak cooperation in implementation of national and international TO/TA tourism development marketing plan for > Local administrations interested in tourism Imereti region prepared by GNTA development > Weak cooperation with Kutaisi municipality > International funds are interested to and tourism department contribute to the PA and region development > Lack of local NGOs and public initiatives > Good cooperation with local municipality and DMO in Tskaltubo

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 22

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

> Good cooperation with GNTA in establishing joint TIC at Kutaisi airport OPPORTUNITIES IMERETI CAVES PA and THREATS of IMERETI CAVES PA and SURROUNDINGS SURROUNDINGS

TRANSPORT / ACCESSIBILITY TRANSPORT / ACCESSIBILITY > Further buiding of highway from Tbilisi to > Road conditions and maintenance Black Sea > Natural catastrophes (flods, etc) affecting > More low cost air carriers to Kutaisi airport accessibility > Development of regular scheduled transport from Tskaltubo Health Resorts to Sataplia and Prometheus > Development of regular transport from Kutaisi to Sataplia and Prometheus > Development of accessibility for disabled people (for wheelchair users, elders, baby strollers, etc.) > Dzedzhieti – Okatse road rehabilitation/development

NATURAL & CULTURAL ASSETS NATURAL & CULTURAL ASSETS > Potential resources for PA: Solkota cave, > Natural catastrophe with dramatic effect on Sarkumali cave, Gumbri cave Satsurblia cave, caves (because of earth quake for example) Satevzia cave (Khoni), Deviskhvreli (village > Degradation of natural & cultural assets due Lashe), Sagvarjile (Terjola), Shvalieti Cave to excessive use (Kvirila Valley), Darkvetis Ekhi, Mgvimevi Cave, Samgle Cave, Samertskhle Cave, Satobavi Cave, Sadzrokhia Cave, Sachinke Cave > New tourist adventure park – Martvili Gochkadili & Okatse > Use of natural resources for healing and spa in Tskaltubo (water, peloid mud, climate,..) > Landscape and country side in Imereti introduced to tourism development > Sustainable management of environmental impacts > Higher awareness of natural and cultural heritage

INFRASTRUCTURE INFRASTRUCTURE > To restructure and use more efficiently > Lack of financial resources for development tourism hospitality and administration and maintenance buildings in Sataplia and Prometheus > Limits to growth because of more strict > More hotel rooms in Sataplia and camps in environmental protection standards each nature monument > Limits to growth because of safety standards > Use of renewable energy sources: Solar implementation for sport/ adventure activities system installation on old and new > Lack of project ideas and project prepared for infrastructure investment > Improved signs and interpretation boards > Lack of HR to implement project plans installation > Development of recreational facilities > Development of rest facilities > Playgrounds for children > Improved standard for parking > Parking slots for bikes > Improving water supply system in Sataplia > New tourism facilities in Tskaltubo, Sairme, Kutaisi etc. > More capacity for long stays in Imereti region

TOURISM DEVELOPMENT TOURISM DEVELOPMENT > Extension of existing and introduction of new > Tourism development without a strategy and

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 23

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

tourism organized caves in Imereti Caves PA marketing plan tourism offer > Slow development and preparation of project > Possibilities for travel around by horses, plans bicycles and even by foot: 8 trails around > Not enough support for tourism development Prometheus Caves are investigated and entrepreneurship in tourism > Trails for biking for example connecting > Not enough professional – skilled staff caves can be developed: interested to work in Imereti caves PA and in - Tskaltubo – Dzedzileti (7-8 km) tourism - Tskaltubo – Dzedzileti – Okatse (20 km) > Lack of promotion and marketing - Tskaltubo – Dzedzileti – Okatse – > Overcrowded areas due to lack of visitor Martvili (25 km) monitoring /visitor management > Offer for people with special requirements (blind, deaf, on wheelchair, family with baby strollers, elderly, etc.) > More promotion and marketing of Imereti caves PA > Development of Okatse-Martvili adventure park > Plans to establish PA in Racha-Lechkhumi > Incentives to develop traditional products/souvenirs (made by stone, honey, …). > Possibilities to develop community based and agro/ > Develop wine tasting service in caves > Improvement of the image of Imereti region as tourist destination

COOPERATION COOPERATION > Participation in and cooperation with > Slow development of stakeholders‘ Tskaltubo resort DMO cooperation model – DMO or other forms > Cooperation with GITOA and TOs/TAs > Centralized system of management of PAs > Cooperation with big companies and > Low response of stakeholders for cooperation institutions for cross marketing (Khareba for example) > Development of PPP - Public Private Partnership in joint investment > Possible development and cooperation with Friends of Imereti caves PA association > Integration of local entrepreneurs - guest houses, taxi drivers, traditional products in tourism in PA > Strengthen cooperation with Universities and Research Institutes > Enhance the involvement of local communities in tourism (education programs, businesses, etc.) > Intensify cooperation with local media: “Kutaisi”, “ImeretisMoabe”, “PS”, “AkhaliGazeti”, "KutaisuriVersia", "Chveneburebi" (Journal); Scientific Journal “Gantiadi”; TV: "Rioni"; Radio: "DzveliKalaki" (old City) Source: Information of PA, project workshop and various documents

TABLE15: SWOT ANALYSIS FOR IMERETI CAVES

There are weaknesses that affect tourism image and quality of overall satisfaction of visitors to Imereti caves. With implementation of tourism development marketing strategy of Imereti region tourism is becoming more and more developed in this region, the infrastructure is improving, the entrepreneurship of many small tourism suppliers are getting more and more professional and the diversity and quality of tourism products and services are improving generally in the region and in Imereti caves too.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 24

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

With so many advantages that Imereti Caves have and with such unique attractiveness management of Imereti caves PA, APA intends to make the best use of potentials and opportunities from the point of view ofpromotion of nature protection, visitors' satisfaction and financial sustainability of PAs.

5.2 Value chain analysis of tourism in Imereti caves

Value chain analysis shows the individual processes and the whole chain, from the first step of getting information about tourism attraction/offer of Imereti caves until the final process of PA administration to revisit the cave and recommend the visit of cavesand how this affects the experience of visitors.

Analysis of visitors’ value chain of tourism in Imereti caves gave us the following evaluation (scores 1 – very bad, 2 – bad, 3 – average, 4 – good, 5 – very good):

DECISION PROCES SCORE DESCRIPTION Information about Imereti caves No web site information No promotion materials available 1 No promotion & marketing activites

Booking-buying the trip to Imereti No advance booking available caves Booking available at TO in Georgia 3 Booking available on the spot

Travel to Imereti caves Transport vehicle and driver available, knowing the way 4 Bad sign posting on the roads Rather good roads to natural monuments

Arrival and welcome Parking availbe, often too crowded Visitors center and limited information 3 available Often longer waiting time for visit of caves

Visit of nature monuments/caves High attractiveness of caves and monuments – unique dinosaurus footprints Good infrastructure in the caves and on 5 trails Good guiding

Availability - Consumption of Very limited offer of additional products additional products and services and services 1 No suggestive marketing of additional products and services

Post sales – No souvenirs or products to take home for revisits/recommendations to visit memory the caves 1 No loyalty activities and suggestions by staff

SOURCE: Evaluation is done on the basis of information of PAs administration and project analysis

TABLE16: VALUE CHAIN ANALYSIS OF TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SERVICES IN IMERETI CAVES

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 25

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Information: Each travel starts with collecting the information about target destination. We can say that Imereti caves practically do not have any information available for potential visitors. They have only 2 short basic information on the back side of the map of Sataplia and Prometheus. Imereti caves administration does not have website, neither is web site of APA strong enough to expose the most tourism oriented PA in Georgia. With google search you don’t get Sataplia or Prometheus or Imereti Caves as search result. Imereti caves do not attend tourism fairs, don’t have advertising on main roads or systematic work with media and especially with TOs. There are no leaflets in hotels or bigger guest houses in Kutaisi and Tskaltubo. Imereti Caves are simply on of the most important attractions in Imereti region that nearly all accommodation providers know and suggest to visit to their guest.

Imereti caves are members of ISCA - International Show Caves Association which gives them the only international exposure except some relations with partner caves’ organizations in Poland and Czech Republic.

Booking is the decision to visit Imereti caves. Majority of visitors are coming to Imereti caves when visiting Imereti region because of culture or simply stop over when touring in Georgia, because of staying in Kutaisi and Tskaltubo resort. Booking is done mainly through Georgian TO when planning their tour throughout Georgia (even in the case of arrival as individual to Georgia).

Travel to Imereti cavesis simple for majority as they are coming with local TOs and drivers who know the roads which sometimes lack of signs and directions. For individuals it is a problem that can be solved by asking for direction few times after leaving the main road.

Arrival and welcomeis well organized in parking place which is often too small and visitors’ center where visitors buy tickets and get basic information. Visitors centers and waiting areas are sometimes too crowded and do not offer any activity to visitors – especially for children while waiting for guided tour.

Visits of nature monumentof Sataplia or Prometheus give visitors very good experience, are highly attractive and well guided. Periodical comments regarding too many groups or too big groups in the caves or trails and too long trail for walking in Sataplia not explained before do not spoil very good impression of visitors.

Consumption of additional products and services practically does not exist which proves also the structure of revenues. Majority of complaints of visitors focus on this segment which at the same time shows also a lost opportunity to increase revenues of PA from tourism.

Post sales – revisits/recommendations by Imereti caves PA administration does not exist; there are few postcards, souvenirs, products and similar to remind visitors about the caves; there are no loyalty instruments for visitors; and there are no activities to work with Georgian TOs to keep having Imereti caves in their tour programmes, to inform them about news, to stimulate them to increase visitation of groups to the caves.

Overall value chain analysis show too big variations in the phases-chain elements of travel experiences of visitors to Imereti caves. But there is unique attraction as basic tourism product and improvement of overall satisfaction requires mainly more efficient use of existing facilities, small investment in programmes and services and permanent capacity building, education and trainings in hospitality and marketing business.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 26

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

6 TOURISMSTAKEHOLDERS IN IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA

Protected areas with increasing tourism visitation represent opportunity for development of local communities and population. Usually, increased visitation stimulates inhabitants of local communities to develop and offerfacilities and services for visitors of PAs.Increased tourist visitation can also have negative effects to local communities and population with more crowds, more noise, more cars, more waste, more use of basic infrastructure – roads, parking places, water, electricity, etc. Therefore, tourism development must be based on mutual interests and benefits of PAs and local communities and population. Cooperation of PA and stakeholders in the neighbourhood must be established to share resources and benefits.

Stakeholders’ groups have different expectations and views in tourism in protected areas. Local municipalities and population see the opportunities for local businesses, employment, improvement of quality of life, earning foreign currency and redistribution of income; additionally they expect promotion of conservation of natural and cultural heritage, sustain cultural identity, provide education opportunities, health benefits and greater understanding, awareness and appreciation of nature. Tourism brings also better access to services. Tourism enhances respect for local traditional, cultural values, local events and self-esteem.

Protected areas management expects from tourism promotion of conservation and heritage appreciation, generation of revenues for their operations, creation of employment and income, development of long term sustainable economic activities, building alliances with local communities and population, management of resources, fostering research, creation of positive experiences and generating satisfied and loyal visitors.

Tourism operators, products and service poviders expect to run their business with profit, exploit market potentials, develop products and services to target markets, expect loyal visitors and support visitors and assist them to understand nature, natural values and natural heritage.

Tourist expect to enhance personal experiences, feel personal accomplishment, improve health, participate in social experiences, meet other people, exploit family history, tradition, bonding, group team building, reaffirm cultural values, promote nature conservation and preservation and spend good time.

In all these interests there are some that are diverse, conflicting and generallyspeaking there are too many interests as tourism is an economic activity witha very big number of small suppliers on one side and an even bigger number of consumers that have different preferences, expectations, culture and habits on the other side. Thus, a mechanism to coordinate interest of suppliers must be established which usually takes the form of DMO – Destination Management Organization or association of suppliers.

Main tourism related stakeholders for Imereti caves are Georgian TOs/TAs that are ground operators for groups of tourists. Another very important stakeholders are hotels and bigger accommodation facilities in Tskaltubo, Kutaisi and Batumi and other Black Sea resorts. It is the most important for Imereti caves to be in touring programmes of TOs. It will become also very important to organize scheduled or shuttle transfer from Kutaisi and Tskaltubo hotels to one and another cave. It will be also important for Imereti caves to participate and cooperate with GITOA and Tsklatubo resort DMO.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 27

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

MAIN TOURISM RELATED STAKEHOLDERS OF IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA > Tskaltubo health resort with hotels and sanatorium > Kutaisi hotels and guest houses (in Kutaisi and surrounding) MAIN TOURISM & HOSPITALITY > TOs & TAs STAKEHOLDERS > Kutaisi International airport > Kutaisi public transport company > Kutaisi and Tskaltubo taxis > Bagrati Cathedral (UNESCOWorld Heritage Site) > Gelati Monastery (UNESCO World Heritage Site) CULTURAL ATTRACTIONS AND SITES > Motsameta Church > Museums in Kutaisi and in Vani > Tskaltubo DMO - Tourism and resort management centre of Tskaltubo TOURISM ORGANISATIONS > GITOA > TIC in Kutaisi > ISCA - International Show Caves Association ASSOCIATIONS, NGOS, CENTERS, > ETDC/Eco Tourism Development Centre, Agro Touristic CLUBS Association KORENA > Kutaisi University > Akaki Tsereteli State University > Kutaisi Technical University EDUCATIONAL ORGANISATIONS > Vakhushti Bargationi Institute of Geography - Department of Geomorphology-Geoecology > Schools in Georgia and from the region > Tskaltubo municipality > Kutaisi municipality – tourism department LOCAL COMMUNITIES > Local communities close to Imereti caves: Kunimstavi, Khomuli, Gumbrini, Banoja, Jimastari, Gordi, Kinchkha, Khvilishi. CROSS MARKETING ORGANIZATIONS, > Khareba wine company DONORS & INTERNATIONAL > Banks ORGANISATIONS > WB – World Bank Source: Information of PA administration and various documents

TABLE17: IDENTIFICATION OF MAIN TOURISM RELATED STAKEHOLDERS IN IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA

Imereti caves have different situation compared to all other PAs in Georgia regarding stakeholders and their cooperation with PA. Imereti Caves is an attraction where visitors stay only a few hours. Imereti caves do not need accommodation providers, even not a lot of food and drinks providers, neither diversity of local products and services. The main motiv of visitors is to see and experience the caves with underground karst attractions and natural values in one hour or a little bit more. And management of PA can only use this situation of numerous visitation to offer and sell to visitors some products and services that increase total revenues in addition to the present main main source of entrance fees.

Imereti caves in fact cannot offer as many opportunities to local communities as other PAs can. Still, it would be important for Imereti caves administration to offer possibilities to local population and different producers to expose and sell their products on standardized stands near visitors’ centers or near parking places. In order to strengthen links with PA and local communities and population PA could invite these people to visit the caves, to attend open days of PA, to attend thematic events, etc. It would also be very fruitful to organize yearly meetings with these communities and people and present them new development of caves, increasing image of caves and Imereti region, to present them, especially to young people professional and business opportunities and to listen to their observation about tourism development in and around caves and about problems that they face with increasing tourist visitation. This will contribute to social sustainability of tourism development in Imereti caves. Association of Friends of Imereti caves PA could be established if there is enough interest from local communities and population. If there is not enough interest from local stakeholders association could have positive effect as one of promotion tools for Imereti caves.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 28

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

7 TOURISM PRODUCTS AND POTENTIALS IN PAS

Protected areas and APA have developed several tourism products and services so far, several with substantial support of international project and organizations. PAs offer to the visitors: information in visitor centres, maps and information materials, rangers and guides. Visitors’ centres offer also expositions, interpretation desks, and in some cases: accommodation, snacks and drinks, shops and meeting rooms with equipment. Some PAs have also small hotels or rooms and restaurants.

The increase in number of visitors and general demand leads to an increased need of more products and services in PAs. Visitors’ services development should follow some principles that take into account in the first place the nature of protected area, expected experience of visitors, motives and behaviour patterns of visitors and intensity of market demand.

Below we present standard characteristics – patterns of eco-tourists. Motivations and main activities performed during the eco-trip have been listed as well.

Both figures show that there are motives and activities for hard and soft eco-tourists as well as for mixed structured eco-tourist group. PAs should take this into account when developing tourism products and services for specific groups. It is also worth to note that eco-tourists care the most about safety (crime, hygiene, accident risk, ..), friendliness of locals, authentic culture and lifestyle, quality of food, prices and quality of accommodation. Less important are: existence of package tours, presence of world class and known attractions and quality of infrastructure (roads, health centres etc.)

Attractions in PA

> Sataplia nature reserve with cave, colchic forest, cliff and nature trails and glass view platform > Prometheus cave with astonishing karst cave formations > Navenahevi, Satsurblia, Melauri and several other not explored caves > Okatse canyon

Tourism infrastructure & facilities in PA

ACCOMMODATION FACILITIES > Hotel with 8 room in Sataplia VISITORS FACILITIES > Visitors center in Sataplia > Ticket & info center in Sataplia > Visitors center in Prometheus > Visitors center in Okatse > Scenic glass view platform in Sataplia > Walking and view platform in Okatse canyon > Parking places in Sataplia, Prometheus and Okatse > Restrooms in Sataplia and Prometheus and Okatse in or close to Ticket & Visitors center RESTAURANTS AND SHOPS > Cafes and shops in Visitors centers, at the exit of Sataplia Cave and on scenic glass view platform in Sataplia MUSEUMS > Speleological museum in Sataplia MEETING FACILITIES > Conference and meeting rooms in Sataplia hote/Visitors center and in Prometheus administration building ADMINISTRATION BUILDINGS > Administration buildings in Sataplia and Prometheus and joint with visitors center in Okatse

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 29

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Tourism products in PA

NATURE PROGRAMMES > Sataplia cave visit > Sataplia rock trail > Sataplia nature educational trail > Sataplia colchic forest > Sataplia Jurassic parc with dinosaur footprints > Prometheus cave visit > Boat tour in Prometheus cave > Okatse nature walking trail CULTURAL & EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMMES > Nature educational trail in Sataplia > Speleological museum visit in Sataplia > Speleological research programmes SPORT & ADVENTURES PROGRAMMES > Canyoning > Adrenaline view platform in Okatse > Scenic view platform in Sataplia HEALTH PROGRAMMES > None yet FUN & ENTERTAINMENT > Small train trail in Prometheus > Wedding in cave MICE - BUSINESS PROGRAMMES > Meetings in conference facilities > Wedding in caves PLEASURE > Meditation in cave > Shopping

Tourist attractions and products in broader area – destination > Martvili/GochKadili Canyon, Svaneti, Sport park, stadium and sports hall in Tskaltubo > Tskaltubo health & spa resort , Clinics and hospitals > Bagrati Cathedral, Gelati Academy, Kutaisi State University, Quevri wine production > Katskhi pillar > Kutaisi and Tskaltubo hotels; TOs/TAs; Universities > Wellness & Spa center in Tskaltubo, Khareba wine celler, Shopping in Kutaisi > Casinos, Festivals and concerts in Kutaisi and in Tskaltubo, Sports & Aqua parks in Kutaisi and in Tskaltubo Source: Information from Imereti caves PA administration, from field visits, workshops and various documents

TABLE18: IDENTIFICATION OF EXISTING TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SERVICES IN IMERETI CAVES (STATUS MID YEAR 2014)

During assessment phase and at workshop we identified wide range of potential tourism products that Imereti caves and other PAs in Georgia could develop to meet experiences and expectations of visitors. We attach in Annex 2 photographic illustration of several potential tourism products for Imereti caves and Okatse canyon. We linked existing and potential products and services according to SBUs – Strategic Business Units and added target market segments in Chapter 11.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 30

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

8 TOURISM TRENDS AND GUIDING PRINCIPLES IN PROTECTED AREAS

This topic was in details elaborated in “Strategy for tourism development in protected areas in Georgia”. Therefore, we present here only key points related directly to Imereti caves protected area.

8.1 Key tourism trends

Tailor-Made Experiences One of the key trends for next years is expected to be tour operators expanding their tailor-made offerings in response to growing consumer demand for more flexible itineraries but still with all the security and benefits of a package. Consumers are looking for more individual holiday experiences that their friends/family might not have done.

Multi-destination travel The rise of multi-centre holidays where holidaymakers may combine two or more destinations in their trip are also growing in popularity and fuelling the trend for tailor-made holidays. This is particularly the case for longer haul holidays where travellers look to make the most out of their journeys but is also increasingly popular for breaks in .

In Search of Adventure The fast pace of modern life has given rise to an increase in the number of adventure travellers. Tour operators are offering more options to cater for holidaymakers’ growing sense of adventure.

Value Consumers will continue to seek value for money from their holidays, rather than cutting back on going away. One trend expected in next years is for consumers to book earlier to secure good value deals for their holidays. We also expect all-inclusive holidays to experience strong demand in next years particularly amongst the family market.

Package holidays The trend for an increase in package holiday bookings is expected to continue. The trend is likely to be fuelled by consumers valuing the security and cost effectiveness that package holidays provide.

8.2 Tourism trends in protected areas

There is no such thing as the “average protected area visitor”. In reality, markets comprise many segments, each of which has somewhat different characteristics, expectations, activity participation and spending patterns. This reduces adverse impacts on the protected area, increases the economic benefits and makes it more likely that visitors are satisfied.

The growth of interest in sustainable tourism and reflects a rising tide of social concern about the quality of the natural environment and the effects of tourism. Activities closely associated with experiencing natural environments are very popular. Some trends complement each other. Some operate at global level, some at the local level. Many represent collisions in powerful, but countervailing values and attitudes. Thus, trends discussed and presented below can interact in various ways.

More individual and authentic travel experiences Consumers will demand more individual and authentic travel experiences in future. More people would turn their backs on artificial ‘travel worlds’ and instead seek authentic holiday destinations and experiences with more interaction with local communities. Consumers will continue to focus on value for money offers and will take advantage of modern technology to use information and recommendations available on commercial and social websites and buy travel products and services.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 31

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

More individual and Rising educational authentic travel levels and demand for Ageing population experiences travel

Changes in the Accessible travel for Changing roles of distribution of leisure all women time

Advances in global Importance of service Changing leisure communications and quality patterns information technology

Increasing social and Proliferation of travel Personal security and environmental options safety concerns

FIGURE 3: TOURISM TRENDS IN PROTECTED AREAS

Rising educational levels and demand for travel Higher education levels are strongly correlated with demand for outdoor recreation activities, and lead to change in the patterns of recreation and tourism in protected areas. As a result, there is a general trend towards appreciative activities, with more travellers seeking life-enriching travel experience: learning-while-travelling, wildlife viewing, attending festivals, cultural appreciation and nature study.

This type of tourism requires explanatory materials (e.g. guides, booklets, mobile presentations, etc.), interpretive facilities (e.g. in visitor centres) and interpretive guiding (e.g. ecotours). It increases the expectations of service quality in protected areas, and raises political pressure for greater protection of cultural and natural heritage.

Ageing population Older individuals are staying healthier longer. Older people are increasingly able to lead healthy, physically active lives. So, while the demand for such activities as downhill skiing or mountain climbing decreases with age, elderly people maintain, or even extend, their interest in other outdoor activities, such as walking, nature study, fly-fishing or wildlife observation. A reduced demand for camping sites is offset by a greater demand for more comfortable lodge accommodation. Older visitors need more accessible trails with lesser gradient etc; they have more disposable income, are willing to pay more for of interpretation, guiding and other services.

Accessible travel for all With improved accessibility the €100 billion travel and tourism market for people with disabilities or physical restrictions could develop also in favour of protected areas. In Europe alone, there are 80 million people with disabilities. When including travel companions, the potential size of the “” market is estimated at 133 million people. Worldwide, the number is estimated at between 600 million and 900 million. These figures mean that roughly 10% of the population needs “barrierfree” or “accessible” travel.

Changing roles of women Women are becoming numerically dominant, emancipated and successful in business. Women increase demand for tourism travel and it is often women who choose travel destination. There are differences between the interests of men and women at the individual activitiy level. Men tend to be more interested in physical challenging activities, women tend to be interested in more appreciative activities, such as nature and culture studies and ecotourism. Many women are interested in protected area recreation opportunities.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 32

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Single, young women are not generally strong users of protected areas, but women with young children often choose parks as a good places for child-centred leisure. Older, retired women, especially those travelling with their partners, show strong interest in the activities which involve visiting protected areas.

Changes in the distribution of leisure time For many people, leisure time is increasing due to shorter working week, increases in the automation of housework and other factors. There are more short leisure trips in a year – 2 to 4 days. Therefore many parks now need to allow for short visits by tourists with limited time, which call for higher quality service and specialized recreation opportunities.

Importance of service quality Tourists are increasingly demanding high quality recreational opportunities and the services that support them. They expect guides to be knowledgeable and good communicators. They want their hosts to make them feel welcome, comfortable and part of the communities they visit. Increased ecotourism means greater demand for specialized recreation and accommodation.

Changing leisure patterns Rising incomes in North America, Europe, Australia and some parts of Asia, older population, more active lifestyle are driving up the volume of and outbound travel from there countries. If this continues, there is likely to be a further general increase in recreation pressures upon all protected areas, even remote ones, and of demand for higher quality service.

Advances in global communications and information technology Many people are now getting access to a huge volume of information about protected areas and travel options from Internet and other communication technologies. The Internet leads to increased demand for trips to a wider variety of locations, and enables park agencies to provide current, sophisticated information directly to visitors at very low cost. Technology may have far-reaching consequences. For example, local hotels, resorts and so forth can cross-market their web sites with those of nearby protected areas, and so increase the number of short visits by business travelers. And visitors themselves can help promote awareness of protected areas by providing web cam information about the park to the world while experiencing the park.

Proliferation of travel options Visitors are travelling more efficiently, quickly and further afield. The proliferation of long-haul air travel has revolutionized the global visitation of protected areas, with people seeking out world heritage sites, national parks and other attractions. Indeed, the very existence of protected area, particularly of a national park, is often a lure for tourists.

Personal security and safety Many protected areas have been badly affected by unrealistic security concerns created by misleading media reports. PA managers must expect some naïve visitors who are not prepared for dangers that might occur in natural environment. It is important to take security seriously and to tell people exactly what the situation is. Failure to do so can lead to complicated and expensive results, since it is becoming more common for park visitors to take legal action against park management for safety- related injury or damage to personal property.

Increasing social and environmental concerns People express concern about social injustices and environmental problems. They are increasingly aware of the need for low impact tourism which does not harm the environment. They are often adopting “green consumer” life styles. Protected areas are well placed to take advantage of this trend as they embody the values that such travelers hold.Tourists are attracted to destinations that have a positive reputation, and are actively avoiding destination that have social or environmental problems. There are also international schemes for recognising the adoption of high environmental standards in tourism provision, such as the Green Globe 21 scheme.

8.3 Tourism guiding principles in PAs and karst caves

Tourism and recreation in protected areas are highly attractive to more and more visitors. When we speak about tourism development in protected areas we generally talk about ecotourism – responsible travel to nature areas that conserves the environment and sustains the well- being of local people. The terminology recognizes some forms of tourism related to ecotourism like:

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 33

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL responsible tourism, sustainable tourism nature based tourism, adventure tourism, pro poor tourism, etc. The closest to ecotourism is community based tourism for conservation and development.

There are 3 pillars of ecotourism: > Environmental and socio-cultural compatibility with involvement of local people in tourism related decisions in conservation and economic planning and operations, > Creation of economic benefits for nature conservation and for well-being of local people and > Promotion of environmental awareness and acceptance of nature conservation as a tool for sustainable development, resource use and land management

Extended definition of ecotourism includes also culture and says that ecotourism is a form of tourism that fosters learning experiences and appropriation of the natural environment, or some components thereof, within its associated cultural context. It has the appearance of being environmentally and socio-culturally sustainable, in line with best practice thresholds, and preferably in a way that enhances the natural and cultural resource base of the destination and promotes the viability of the operation. (Weaver & Lawton, 2001).

General scheme of category of protected area and applicable tourism visitation in some categories was developed on the level and purpose of protection, primary management objectives and basic profiles of eco-tourists visiting protected areas. Tourism activities in protected areas are strictly forbidden in some IUCN categories of protected areas and in some allowed under certain regulations and principles. There is also differentiation among 3 eco-tourist groups: hard eco-tourists with strong environment commitment individual visitation, soft eco-tourists with weak environment commitment, multipurpose and group travel and third mixed – structured group of eco-tourists who have the characteristics of both groups – strong environment commitment, social networking and multipurpose travel.

IUCN Tourism as eco-tourist profile 2) Short description category objective 1) Hard Soft Mixed I. Strict nature reserve & wilderness: I.a Strict nature reserve - - - - I.b Wilderness area 2 yes - - II. National park 1 yes yes - III. Natural monument 1 yes yes - IV. Habitats managed area 3 yes yes - V. Protected landscape 1 - yes yes VI. Managed resource protected area 3 - yes - 1. Type of objective for specific category of protected area (scientific, education, protection, sustainable use, maintenance of cultural attributes and tourism & recreation): 1 – primary objective; 2 – Secondary objective; 3 – Potentially applicable objective; - not applicable 2. Eco-tourist profiles: Hard eco-tourists; Soft eco-tourist; Mixed structured eco-tourists; Source: Figure is combined from different IUCN and Weaver & Lawton 2001 documents and organized for the purpose of this study.

TABLE19: MATRIX OF TOURISM COMPATIBILITY AND PROFILES OF ECO-TOURISTS ACCORDING TO CATEGORY AND MANAGEMENT PURPOSE OF PAS

ISCA – International Show Caves Association provides guidelines for development and management of caves open for tourism visits undertaking works that does not demage the natural structure of caves; use of materials compatible with caves like cement, concrete, glass and not organic materials; lightnening not affecting lampenflora, clorophyll, enabling safe visits even in the case of a sudden shortage of electricity; climate conditions and air flow, carrying capacities that sets the upper limit for tourist visitation of caves;role of guides in explaining the natural environment in caves and the role of scientists in looking for solutions in the case of problems. (ISCA website: http://www.i-s-c- a.com/documents).

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 34

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

9 MARKET POTENTIAL FOR IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA

9.1 Market segmentation

Market for Imereti Caves – Sataplia Nature Reserve, Prometheus Cave and some other caves as well as for Okatse Canyon has some basic characteristics that differ from the market of visitors to other protected areas. First and the most important characteristic is that the majority of this market represents excursionists – one day visitors. Their main interest – motiv is the visit of the attraction – site or monument, consume some side products and services – maybe linked to food & beverage, shopping, rest, maybe attend an event and then travel further if on a tour or holidays or travel back home. Therefore, we cannot expect the visitors to Sataplia or Prometheus cave to stay longer than few hours. It is also not to expect that these visitors will revisit Imereti caves frequently if there are no new attractions or significant tourist offer.

Profile of these visitors is: > Soft eco-tourist have moderate environment commitment, weak enhancement of sustainability, have multipurpose trips, have short and physically passive trips to protected areas, expect services, emphasize interpretation of nature and use intermediaries like TO/TA. > Mixed – structured eco-tourists have a combination of strong environmental commitment, enhancing sustainability, want to be physically active, expect services and desire social interaction; they have also multipurpose trips, are in large groups, use intermediaries like TO/TA and emphasize interpretation of nature. > Soft adventuretourists blends physical adventures with such enriching activities as culinary pursuits, , archaeological and wildlife viewing by day, while offering comfortable stays in family-owned accommodations with gourmet experiences by night > Children from 8 – 17 years already attending school > Working couples with no children (DINKs – double income – no kids): 25 – 50 years old, with average or above-average household income, > Couples with small (up to 15 years old) children (families): 25 – 40 years old, with average or above-average household income, > Older couples no living with their children (empty nesters) 45 – 65 years old, with average or above-average household income, > Seniors – from 65 years on > Mainly organized organization of trip by TO/TA > Use of accommodation: Hotel/, Ecolodge, Guest House, Camping, > Travel to/visit of Imereti caveswill be the secondary motiv while travelling for leisure, on multi-sites/countries touring, on business trip, transitting and during that travel they visit also Imereti caves

Market of tourists with overnight stay is very limitted. This segment is focused on some special theme activities like speleological adventure discoveries, nature camps and adventure packages that could be offered by special caves for professionals (Melauri cave), adventureous Okatse canyon, nature camps for youth in Sataplia or Prometheus, spa and health packages in Satsurblia Cave, meditation packages in caves or in nature and similar. As stated, this market is very limited and does not encourage PAs administration to develop significant accommodation facilities.

Profile of these visitors is: > Hard eco-touristswith strong environmental commitment, enhancing sustainability, have specialized and longer trips, want to be physically active with little available/offered services, emphasize personal experience and make own trip arrangements. > Hard adventure tourists tend to involve more physically demanding activities and/or specialised training and usually stay longer in destination, spend more locally > Youngsters / students: 18 – 26 years old, with average or above-average household income, travelling abroad at least once in 2 years > Working couples with no children (DINKs – double income – no kids): 25 – 50 years old, with average or above-average household income, > Mainly individual organization of trip > Use of accommodation: Camping, , Lodge/, Farm stay, Backpackers accommodation, Recreational vehicle and Home stay > Will travel purposely – the prime motiv will be to travel to Imereti caves protected area

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 35

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Domestic tourist marketwill be more important for Imereti caves also in the future. It consists of schools children who visit Sataplia and Prometheus cave for educational purposes in school programme. Domestic excursionists form the second group and Georgians on holidays in mountains, at Black Sea or in Tshaltubo is the third group.

International tourist marketwill grow faster and will be constantly increasing its share and might exceed 50% in 2020. The major group of international visitors will be the one that will be on tours in Georgia with multi-site visits, fast increasing will be the group of tourist on holidays and healing in Tskaltubo resort and big potential are also holiday makers at the Black sea taking a tour to inland – to Kutaisi and Imereti caves. Increasing will be also the number of international visitors in transit on the main road.

Based on statistics of origin of international visitors in 2013main international tourist marketsare: neighbouring countries (Turkey, Azerbaijan), Russia and Russian speaking countries (Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, Kazakhstan), European countries (Germany, Poland, Czech Republic, Netherlands), Baltic countries (Lithuania, Latvia) and Israel.

This market segmentation dictates that organized market so called B2B mainly with TOs will be the most important in promotion and marketing and in increase of visitation to Imereti caves protected area.

9.2 Market potential forImereti caves

Tourism demand to visit Imereti cavesis by majority- 77% composed of domestic and 23% of international visitors.

Domestic demand is very important for Imereti caves: > about 35.000 school childrenvisit each year Sataplia and Prometheus caves out of total of about 50.000 pupilsin one generation > each year about 25.000 university students visit both nature monuments out of total population of about 120.000 students enrolled on universities in Georgia

These 2 categories of domestic visitors represent more than half of total domestic visitors and have limited growth potential due to the fact that there are not many repeat visitors and that generation size will not grow in the future.

> Individuals, couples and families – about 50.000represent the other group of domestic visitors which has the biggest potential for growth due to increase of income, increase of travel intensity and improved transport infrastructure. There is the biggest potential to increase this segment from more than 2.000.000 inhabitants of Kutaisi, Batumi and Tbilisi.

International visitorsto Georgia are fast increasing.In 2013 Georgia registered 5,392,000 international arrivals of tourists (38,3%), same day visitors (39,6%) and transit travellers (22,1%).

International tourists visiting Imereti caves have 3 main source markets: > Imereti – mainly Tskaltubo and Kutaisi will host about 350.000 mainly international visitors in 2020. Today, Imereti has about 3.130 beds in hotels and other types of accommodation (GNTA) which host about 210.000 international visitors for 1 or 2 nights. According to GNTA Industry report about 210.000 international visitors choose Kutaisi as one of their destinations while staying in Georgia.With rehabilitation of Tskaltubo health and spa resort Imereti will have about 5.000 beds, significant proportion in standardized hotels in Tskaltubo and Kutaisi. Tskaltubo resort will operate all year round with more than 90% occupancy rate. > Black Sea visit each year about 960.000 leisure tourists and representanother important market for Imereti caves. International visitors will be especially interested to make excursions to inland where Imereti – Kutaisi with Bagrati and Gelati cathedrals, Vani and Imereti caves are the biggest attraction for 1 day excursionist from the Black sea. > Transit passengers accountmore than 10.5 million on the main road from Black Sea to Tbilisi at Kutaisi (Road Direction of the Ministry of Transport).

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 36

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

10 VISION AND OBJECTIVES OF TOURISM DEVELOPMENT IN IMERETI CAVES PA

Tourism development in protected areas in Georgia is very intensive. It brings recognition of natural attractions of Georgia but also a pressure to develop new infrastructure, products and services, to offer more information and interpretation about nature, biodiversity, wilderness and also cultural heritage as well as to manage better challenges of increasing visitation such as bad access roads to PAs, problems with water, electricity or IT, or problems with waste management. Thus APA and PA administrations are all the time balancing between their primary activities related to nature conservation, protection and management and activities that should meet the demand and expected experiences of visitors.

Visitation of protected areas in Georgia will be only increasing in the following years and there is necessary to approach to tourism development in PAs with clear strategy and policy. Time horizon for this strategy, objectives and activities is 2020. It is far enough to set strategic goals but also short enough to be practical in proposed activities and policy as the situation require immediate reaction.

Imereti caves are the leading and most exposed tourism oriented protected area in Georgia. Due to attractiveness of these natural monuments, easy access and reasonably short time to experience this underground mystery Imereti Caves register 41% of all visits to protected areas in Georgia and contribute 90% to the revenues from commercial – mainly tourism activities of all PAs. With these figures, Imereti Caves have the biggest effect on awareness rising and education of people about the value of nature and on financial sustainability of APA originating from commercial – tourism activities.

Imereti caves have the possibilities to increase visitation and revenues faster than other PAs in Georgia. Therefore, there are realistic expectations from Imereti caves PA administration to manage protected area strategically to sustain sustainability, increase the value of nature, increase the number of visitors and increase economic revenues from tourism. PA administration must be aware of realistic development opportunities and its responsibility to use resources as much efficient as possible to achieve expected results.

Vision:

Imereti caves protected areawill bethe leading tourism focused protected area in Georgia. They will offerto domestic and international visitors unique underground karst natural mystery anddiverse high quality services fulfilling personal experiences of nature, education, culture and pleasure.

Tourism in Imereti caves will be one of the pillars of tourism in Imereti region, the mostsignificant source of commercial revenues for APA and one of the most internationally recognized Georgian natural attractions.

Mission:

To use natural resources in balanced way to preserve and even increase natural value of Imereti Caves and to contribute to financial sustainability of APA and protected areas in Georgia and to economic development, employment and economic and social welfare of inhabitants in Imereti region.

Objectives:

General objective of tourism development of Imereti Caves is to operate as successful model of balanced sustainable and tourism oriented protected area in Georgia with great natural and educational value and economic efficiency and high internationally recognized tourism attraction.

Specific objectives of strategic tourism development in Imereti caves protected areas are:

Objective 1: Increase the number of domestic and international visitors  Increase number of visitors from 145.000 in 2013 to at least300.000 in 2020  Increase the share of international visitors from 23% in 2013 to 50% in 2020

Objective 2: Increase revenues from tourism and commercial activities  Increase the revenues from tourism from 918.600 GEL in 2013 to 4.500.000 GEL in 2020

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 37

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

 Increase the share of revenues from sales of products and services other than from entry fees.

Objective 3: Increase overall satisfaction of visitors  Increase satisfaction of visitors and decrease complaints  Increase the length of stay of visitors  Increase the loyalty – the rate of return visitors to PAs

Objective 4: Restructure and use efficiently visitors' infrastructure and develop new tourism products and services in Imereti Caves  Complete basic PA's infrastructure  Improve efficiency of use of existing tourism facilities  Develop and offer new tourism products and services  Connect/Link Tskaltubo health & spa resort and Imereti Caves PA

Objective 5: Develop professional HR team in Imereti caves and provide permanent trainings  Organize & mobilize tourism/hospitality staff  Provide permanent trainings of Imereti caves PA staff

Objective 6:Contribute to the development of local communities and stakeholders’ cooperation in Imereti region  Provide local communities and local populationopportunities for business development  Strengthen knowledge of local population about Imereti Caves PA and protected areas in Georgia and their commitment to nature and natural values  Contribute to organization and cooperation of tourism stakeholders in Imereti region

Objective 7: Implement sustainable principles and measures and provide services assuring security and safety  Strengthen sustainability measures in Imereti Caves PA  Provide comprehensive safety and security measures and action plan

Objective 8: Emphasize and mediate education and awareness rising about nature and natural values to visitors to Imereti caves  Increase the knowledge of nature, natural values and PAs among visitors

Objective 9:Contribute to the image of protected areas and tourism in Georgia  Increase the perception of protected areas in Georgia as tourism destination

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 38

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

11 STRATEGIC PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT IN IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA

11.1 SBU – Strategic Business Unit principle and tourism product development in Imereti caves

SBU is becoming the guiding principle for development of a cluster of tourism products/activites that leads to satisfaction of main motive and fulfillment of expectations when visiting a certain tourism destination. Respecting this principle leadsinto:a tourism product specialization, the creation of a unique image of tourism destination and a increase of visitors’ satisfaction and loyalty. The idea of SBU evaluation is the prioritization for strategic development as a basis for investment programs, product development as well as for marketing.

Strategic Business Units (SBUs) are based on core motivations/experiences of visitors.Travellers today have a high degree of experience and pay more attention to what they consume and how they experience the product “journey”; more than the geographic location in general, the experience has priority. This has pushed the tourism industry to stop concentrating only on the product and its characteristics but on what the visitors look for, what kind of experience, how it is perceived emotionally and on the gap between what they want to see and feel and what they really see and feel.

Experiences make the difference in today’s tourism industry. The personal fulfillment of experiences is the core of what people are looking for. In consequence, the motivation-based approach is applied. So the choice of travel destination today is heavily influenced by how people feel about a place, perceptions of a place, the sense of a place and not of physical characteristics of a place.

We have identified 7 different SBUs when evaluating tourism situation and potentials in PAs in Georgia that are today or could become important in the future. Today, the most important SBUs in Georgia are nature, education & culture and sports & adventure. In the case of Imereti caves nature and education and culture are now the mains SBUs and offer products for visitors looking experiences related to nature and to education and culture. These two SBUs will be dominant also in the future but this plan proposes to get also products that will offer experiences for visitors looking for sports and adventures in Okatse canyon, health experiences (mainly for visitors of Tskaltubo resort) that will enjoy in cave health and spa treatments and additionally some pleasure and fun and entertainment for minor groups of visitors to increase satisfaction of visitors to Imereti caves.

Each SBU can contain several tourism products – a cluster of complementary products and services offering unique experiences. Development of tourism products focused on the dominant SBU(s) will help developing unique brand of Imereti caves PA, meet expectations of visitors, achieve their satisfaction and loyalty while optimize benefits for PAs and to some extent also for local communities.

After detailed SWOT, value chain, product potentials and market analysis we propose the following tourism product development for Imereti Caves under identified SBUs:

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 39

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

SBU: NATURE Back to nature, Feel authentic, Going back to origins, Experience the peace and tranquillity of the natural environment, Seeing wildlife in its natural habitat, Escaping the urban environment, Learning about natural environment, Absence of crowd, Rest and relaxation Typical products: National park visits, hiking/bushwalking, wildlife viewing, guided trail walk, bird watching, nature photography, meeting local people, nature park visits EXISTING PRODUCTS POTENTIAL PRODUCTS MARKET TARGET GROUPS > Soft ecotourists – > Sataplia cave visit > New caves visit interested and casual > Sataplia rock trail > Nature ecological walking nature visitors > Sataplia nature educational trail > Special interest visitors trail > Nature&art education (fauna, flora, ethnology, > Sataplia colchic forest camps etc.) > Sataplia Jurassic parc with > Recreation in nature > Families dinosaur footprints > Playgroungs in nature > Students > Prometheus cave visit > Botanical tours > Children > Boat tour in Prometheus > Geological trails > DINKs (dual income-no cave > Historical trail kids) > Okatse nature walking trail > Empty nesters

Major attractions in destinations around Imereti caves linked to SBU:

Svaneti, Borjomi Kharagauli National Park, Katskhi pillar

TABLE20: IMERETI CAVES SBU NATURE

SBU: CULTURE & EDUCATION Deep understanding of local culture and experience of local daily life, Learn something new, Self-discovery, Meeting new people with similar interest, Opportunity to be with friends and/or relatives, Having new experience, Being able to tell my friend about my experiences Typical products: Historical & Archaeological sites, Educational workshops, Meeting local people, Indigenous culture tours, Scientific & research studies, Theme park visits. EXISTING PRODUCTS POTENTIAL PRODUCTS MARKET TARGET GROUPS > Nature educational camps - orientation and survival camps > Junior rangers and young nature scientists camps > Art camps > Research and scientific > Culture focused visitors > Nature educational trail in study and camps > Nature visitors with strong Sataplia > Natural science laboratory cultural interest > Speleological museum visit programme > Scientists and Researchers in sataplia > Learning experience of > Students > Speleological research traditional activities in > Youth and children programmes PAs/NPs > Families > Ethnological educational > Empty nesters tours > Ethnographical educational tours > Traditional local crafts, culture, events > Photographic courses

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 40

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

> Photo exhibition trails > Photographic competition Festival > Story telling programmes > Myths, legends and history programmes > Quevri & Wine history

Major attractions in destinations around Imereti caves linked to SBU:

Bagrati Cathedral, Gelati Academy, Vardzia, Mgvimevi Monastery, Kutaisi State University, Quevri wine production

TABLE21: IMERETI CAVES SBU CULTURE & EDUCATION

SBU: SPORTS & ADVENTURES Feel the adrenalin, Experience the limit of your physical strength, Self-discovery, Having exciting and adventurous experience, Having new experience, Reputation, Opportunity to meet other people with similar interest, Being able to tell friends about experience Typical products: Cycling, Four-wheel driving, Canyoning, Rafting, Kayaking, Sport fishing, Horseback riding, Swimming EXISTING PRODUCTS POTENTIAL PRODUCTS MARKET TARGET GROUPS > Canyon hiking trails > Rafting in canyon > Adventure tours > Kinckha waterfall > Rock climbing > Caving for adrenaline > Sports and adventure lovers > Canyoning visitors > Speleological tours > Sports and nature > Adrenaline view platform in > Cycling Okatse associations & clubs > Adventure parks > Students > Scenic view platform in > Mountain trekking Sataplia > DINKs (dual income-no > Zip line kids) > Archery > Demanding nordic walking trails > Horseback riding in wilderness > Mini golf

Major attractions in destinations around Imereti caves linked to SBU:

Martvili/GochKadili Canyon, Svaneti tours Sport park, stadium and sports hall in Tskaltubo

TABLE22: IMERETI CAVES SBU SPORTS & ADVENTURES

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 41

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

SBU: HEALTH Be healthy, Live longer, Be fit, Look good, Absence of stress Typical products: Health and medical treatments, Beauty surgery, Health recovery, National park visits, Soft fitness sport activities (Hiking, Cycling, Cross country skiing, Snowshoeing, etc), Climate healing, Cave healing,.. EXISTING PRODUCTS POTENTIAL PRODUCTS MARKET TARGET GROUPS > Patieints with specific health indications > Cave healing & spa > Post surgery and medical > Climate health programmes convalescents > Anti addiction programmes > DINKs (double income – no kids)

Major attractions in destinations around Imereti caves linked to SBU:

Tskaltubo health & spa resort , Clinics and hospitals

TABLE23: IMERETI CAVES SBU HEALTH

PLEASURE SBU: Slow down life, Enjoy, Lifestyle Rest and Relaxation, Absence of crowds, Positive previous experience, Reputation, Having new experiences, Opportunity to be with friends and/with relatives; Being able to tell my friends about my experiences Typical products: Wellness & Spa programmes, Gastronomic tours, Wine tours and tasting, Meeting local people, Shopping, Sunbathing EXISTING PRODUCTS POTENTIAL PRODUCTS MARKET TARGET GROUPS > Shopping: postcards, T shirts, cups, caps,.. > Spiritual programmes > Soft ecotourists – casual > Meditation programmes nature visitors > Wellness (gong therapy, yoga,..) > Young professionals > Bioenergy trail > Social life and network > Meditation in cave > Fitness > Shopping searching visitors > Sunrise/sunset watching > DINKs (double income – > Sun bath platform no kids) > Soft nature walking and hiking trails > Empty nesters > Summer kitchen with typical food > Traditional cooking and tasting > Wine tasting

Major attractions in destinations around Imereti caves linked to SBU:

Wellness & Spa center in Tskaltubo, Khareba wine celler, Shopping in Kutaisi

TABLE24: IMERETI CAVES SBU PLEASURE

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 42

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

SBU: BUSINESS - MICE Be successful, Having new experience, Reputation Meeting people with similar interests, Being able to tell my friends about my experiences Typical products: Conferences, Congresses, fairs and exhibitions, team buildings EXISTING PRODUCTS POTENTIAL PRODUCTS MARKET TARGET GROUPS > Team buildingprogrammes > MICE organizers > Meetings &Incentives > International and > Meetings in conference programmes Domestic Corporations facilities > Fairs & Exhibition programmes > Trade and Professional > Civil Wedding Ceremony > Workshops Associations in caves > Friends of PA Festival > DINKs (double income – > Science & Research Conferences no kids)

Major attractions in destinations around Imereti caves linked to SBU:

Kutaisi and Tskaltubo hotels; TOs/TAs; Universities

TABLE25: IMERETI CAVES SBU BUSINESS – MICE

SBU: FUN & ENTERTAINMENT Have fun, Feel ″in″, Having exciting experiences, Meeting new people with similar interest, Being able to tell my friends about my experiences, Share my experiences with my friends Typical products: events and festivals, concerts, partying, shopping, nightlife EXISTING PRODUCTS POTENTIAL PRODUCTS MARKET TARGET GROUPS > Open days of PA > Events and festivals: popular events, > Young professionals celebrations, anniversary > Trend setters and trend events, etc. followers > Small train trail in > Fun parks for children > Social life and network Prometheus > Entertainment playgrounds seekers > Wedding in cave > Concerts > Students > Video & movie > DINKs presentations in visitors’ > Families center in Sataplia > Empty nesters > Market places and market days

Major attractions in destinations around Imereti caves linked to SBU:

Casinos, Festivals and concerts in Kutaisi and in Tskaltubo, Sports & Aqua parks in Kutaisi and in Tskaltubo

TABLE26: IMERETI CAVES SBU FUN & ENTERTAINMENT

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 43

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

11.2 Strategic tourism product structure in Imereti caves PA in 2013 and 2020

We concluded that Imereti caves need additional tourism facilities, products and services in order to enable more comfortable visitation of main attraction – karst caves and underground world and to avoid approaching the upper limit of carrying capacities in the year 2020. Additionally we also concluded that additional products and services are needed in order to extend the length of stay and satisfaction of visitors. We formulated these new products and services based on potentials and visitors’ expectations of experiences when visiting Imereti caves PA.

These new products must be attractive, based on their natural and physical characteristics, and competitive, based on characteristics of demand. We evaluated attractiveness and competitiveness of these new products according to their 10 characteristics.Detailed evaluation is presented in Annex 3.Results give us an answer about priority development of new products and servicices and about weak characteristics that must be improved while preparing projects and developing this new offer to increase attractiveness and achieve the highest competitiveness.

TABLE27: EVALUATION OF ATTRACTIVENESS AND COMPETITIVENESS OF 11 NEW TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SEVRICES IN IMERETI CAVES PA (TOTAL SCORES RANGE FROM 1 TO 100)

ATTRACTIVENESS COMPETITIVENESS PRODUCT (from 1 to 100) (from 1 to 100)

1. Nature Walking Trail 57 66

2. Prometheus cave 3 new halls 51 53

3. Satsurblia spa cave 48 56

4. Navenakhevi visitors cave 47 53

5. Melauri adventure cave 58 54

6. Recreation 51 68

7. Playgrounds 51 62

8. Pleasure & Wellness 57 62

9. Nature&Art camps 58 64

10. Events 53 71

11. Wine ageing & tasting 37 55

Source: Tables in Annex3

Evaluation of attractiveness shows that, at present, average scores of new caves only contribute to natural value and attractiveness while their cultural, educational values still need to be developed. New caves have also mainly limited possibilities for further development. There are also no other tourism facilities or offer in neighbourhood. From the point of view of competitiveness scores are higher but still not high because of a need for investment and the need for additional employees.

New caves contribute more to the image of Imereti caves and will increase satisfaction of visitors but not in the short run. In this respect “soft” tourism products and services like playgrounds, recreation, nature camps, pleasure and event will bring results faster.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 44

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

It is important to emphasize that all these products will increase satisfaction of visitors, also satisfaction of employees and will not affect natural environment significantly and will be acceptable also for inhabitants in local communities.

Source: Data from Table 12.

FIGURE 4: LEVEL OF ATTRACTIVENESS AND COMPETITIVENESS OF 11 NEW TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SERVICES IN IMERETI CAVES

Based on evaluation of existing tourism products and services in Imereti caves and motives of visitors to Imereti caves we grouped products in SBU that offer experiences to the visitors that they expect during their travel. Today, experiencing authentic nature is the prevailing motive of visitors to Imereti caves (for 63%), followed by education and culture with (37%). This high share of the last group of visitors is because of school groups visiting caves as a part of their education programme in schools.

Future development of Imereti caves will be focused on strengthening the main motive- nature - to increase the attractiveness of natural monuments, expose their value and to position Imereti caves on domestic and international market as nature productsand finally to increase the visit numbers to the PA. To increase the value of nature PA administration will develop cave health programmes and wellness programmes in a natural environment. Additionally, PA administration will develop some programmes to increase satisfaction of visitors and to extend their time when visiting the caves. These new products will also contribute to increase revenues from other sources than only from entrance fees. We don’t expect that these new products offering health, pleasure and entertainment experiences to visitors will contribute more than 10% of overall satisfaction with experience in Imereti caves.

Okatse canyon together with Martvili adventure sports programme will address other market target group than Imereti caves. In this sense, is the decision of APA to organize this nature sports and adventure center as separate administration fully in accordance with product specialization and target marketing.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 45

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

TABLE 28: THE STRUCTURE OF VISITORS ACCORDING TO EXPERIENCES THAT THEY EXPECT IN IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA IN 2013 AND IN 2020

Imereti caves

ment MICE

No of No

Fun & Fun

Health TOTAL

Nature Nature

visitors

Sports & Sports

Pleasure

Culture & Culture

Education

Entertain- - Business

Adventure experience Imereti caves 2013 63 37 100 145.888 Imereti caves 2020 65 27 5 5 100 300.000

Source: Calculated on the basis of APA guest surveys, Information from Imereti caves PA administrations and own estimations

Source: Data from Table 13.

FIGURE 5: THE STRUCTURE OF VISITORS ACCORDING TO EXPERIENCES THAT THEY EXPECT IN IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA IN 2013 AND IN 2020TOURISM STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION MODEL – RESOURCES AND POLICY

11.3 Development and investment projects

Future development of Imereti caves protected area need investment in basic infrastructure, tourism facilties and products and in speleological research and safety and sustainable visitors’ flows. We identified together with PA’s administration the following investment project to be realized in the period untill 2020.

Estimation of total value of identified project is 2.851.600 GEL and total number of all additional employees based on realization of projects in Imereti caves is 21.

There are some crucial investment in Imereti caves: > running water system and supply in Sataplia in order to be able to use PAs’s and tourism facilities in Sataplia > connecting biking trail on a special track from Tskaltubo health resort to Prometheurs cave in order to connect two most attractive tourist places in Imereti region also for bikers with a safe trail > opening new caves for visitors > restructure PAs administration buildings and visitors centers for more tourism/revenue generation use > develop tourist products to increase satisfaction and extend the length of stay of visitors > research and development projects

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 46

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

TABLE29: OVERVIEW OF INVESTMENT PROJECTS, TOURISM PRODUCTS AND RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS IN IMERETI CAVES IN THE PERIOD 2014 – 2020

Start & No Investment project/Tourism Programme Value GEL HR needed completition year Basic infrastructure 1 Water reservoirs and system instalations in Sataplia 800,000 2015 2 Defence wall for Sataplia and Prometheus 22,000 2015

Transport, Welcome and Information infrastructure: 3 Restructuring of visitors center in Prometeus cave 50,000 2015 4 Improvement of parking places in Sataplia and Prometheus 2016 5 Investment in access for handicaped visitors in Prometheus50,000 2016 6 Explanatory audio guides in & outside caves 2014 7 Electronic Information boards and kiosks 1,600 2014 8 Electronic ticketing/booking on line system 15,000 1 2015 9 Bike trail Tskaltubo - Prometheus (special track along the road) 2017 10 Bikes parking slots 5,000 2014

Tourism-hospitality infrastructure: 11 Renovation of Sataplia objects/facilities 120,000 2014/2015 12 Expansion of hotel capacities by 2 rooms (up to 10 total) 30,000 5 2015 13 Camping place in Sataplia and Prometheus 30,000 2 2015/2016 14 3 cave halls in Prometeus cave-research 25,000 2015 15 Preparation 3 cave rooms for visitors in Prometeus 2016/2017 16 Preparing for visitation Navenahevi cave 1,000,000 7 2015 17 Preparing for adventure visitation Melauri cave 200,000 2015/2016 18 Preparation for visitation Satsurblia spa cave 250,000 2016/2017

Tourist products and services 19 Nature Eco walking trail (long) 15,000 1 2015 20 Recreation facilities 15,000 1 Arching 2015 Mini golf 2015 21 Nature & Art camps Short Eco education trail 10,000 1 2015 Art & Photo courses 22 Playgrounds 5,000 1 2015 Find the treasure Playground for children 23 Pleasure & Wellness 50,000 1 1016/2017 Bioenergetic trail Meditation platform Gong meditation/relaxation Sun bath platform 24 Events 30,000 1 2015 25 Wine aging and tasting 2015 26 Binoculars (2) 3,000 2015

Research & development projects 27 Nature impact monitoring system 50,000 2015/2010 28 Further speleological research 50,000 2016/2018 29 Risk Assessment and Evacuation investment 10,000 2015 30 Carrying capacity assessment of tourist caves 15,000 2017 2,851,600 21

Source: Workshop with Imereti caves PA administration

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 47

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Estimation of the value of all projects is 2.851.600 GEL. If we assume yearly increase of revenues from tourism in Imereti caves by 30% this would mean that at the end of 2020 cummulative amount of revenues will be 18.240.000 GEL (starting with 1.43 million GEL revenues in 2015). In the same period 2015-2020, with yearly increase of operating costs by 2.5% cumulative amount of costs will be 5.500.000 GEL (starting with 850.000 GEL operational costs in 2015). This simple calculation shows that Imereti caves will generate in next 6 years net revenue of about 12.740.000 GEL and it is obvious that with these anticipated net revenues PA administration and APA can cover all investment costs of upper listed projects.

In spite of this positive revenue/costs balance with simplified calculation,it is recommended that Imereti caves will seek co-financingfor their projects, also with financial support of international donors especially for infrastructure and for research and development projects.

11.4 HR – Human resource, education and trainings

Imereti caves PA is the most tourism oriented protected area in Georgia and this position will be even more prominent in the future by setting ambitious objectives and expecting significant results in increase of number of visitors and in revenues from tourism. Assessment of HR showed a big lack of professional hospitality staff. Imereti caves PA administration employs two visitors specialists and nine tour guides as tourism/hospitality staff.

In order to manage already existing tourism facilities and products and services and to meet further development requirements tourism/hospitality HR must be significantly increased in quantity and quality (knowledge and experiences) to perform at high professional standards that are necessary to achieve the set objectives.

We estimate that Imereti caves need the following permanent profiles in tourism and hospitality (12 persons):  Tourism – Hospitality head manager, also deputy head of PA’s administration- responsible to update, implelemnt and monitor tourism development strategy,marketing plans, brand development, organization of work of tourism - hospitality staff, cooperation with other organizations like GNTA, GITOA, DMO, Association of Friend of PAs,TO/TA, MICE, Associations, etc and is responsible for results from tourism activities;  Revenue manager & controller – plan and monitor revenues from tourism, propose price, concession and lease policy, propose contracting conditions for TOs and other partners, monitor electronic booking system functioning and results, controls costs and analyse deviations from plans;  Marketing head manager – organize, implement and monitor promotion and marketing activities abroad and in Georgia, development and use of promotion materials, realization of promotion and marketing tools and distribution channels, monitor work with tourism corporate and individual markets, organize visitors centers, CRM – customer relation management, organize and coordinate work of promotion and marketing staff in PA, organize work of tour guides, organize visitors statistics and guest survey analysis and is responsible for results from tourism marketing activities;  Corporate marketing specialist – implement activities related to corporate market: TOs, Hotels, institutions;  Individual marketing specialist – responsible for promotion and marketing on individual markets, implement and evaluate promotion and marketing activities abroad and in Georgia;  MICE marketing specialist and protocol – organizer of event, meetings, incentives and leader of protocol at the occasion of high level visits;  Web and E- promoter - marketer (for on-line marketing tools) – responsible for development of electronic promotion and communication tools, work with electronic booking system, use, updating and direct marketing with e-tools;  Tourism product, services and quality standards developer – responsible for tourism products and services development, maintenance of these products, their proper use, development of quality standards for these products, monitor quality of performed services;  Accommodation, F&B and other facilities manager–responsible for operation of capacities and facilities with own staff, monitoring operations of capacities and facilities on management contracts and concessions;  Accommodation, F&B and other facilities assistants – employees for hotel and camp management, cafes and restaurant operations, shops operations, etc;

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 48

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

 Tourism animator and products and services on site promoter – monitor visitors flows, propose visitors to use products and services of PA, story teller, help groups, visitors that need help, children to play while waiting and perform suggestive sales and post sales activites;  Tourist information specialists – responsible for collection of relevant information, management of these information (classification, data base organization, distribution for promotion and marketing use) and to deliver information to customers directly or indirectly;  Tour guides – lead tour groups in caves and on trails in PA

21 persons will be additionally necessary after realization of investment projects and further tourism products development in PA. All together, it seems that optimal number of employees in Imereti caves PA will be around 70-75 persons

The PA should have additionallypart time and seasonal staff. They could be students trained for information management and delivery and available for mainly summer season and for information service on fairs and exhibitions. High demand in the peak season is for tourist guides for guiding in protected areas. There is also a need for animators and event support. Besides, seasonal tourism- hospitality facility staffcould also be contracted to work in facilities (accommodation, F&B, shops etc.).

In order to strengthen commitment of employees and to introduce more motivation for innovative, entrepreneurial and customer oriented work HR policy should incorporate: > Recruitment policy stressing the personal qualities needed to pursue a career in this service industry; > Recognition that payment of low wages undermines the objective of providing a quality product; > Improvement of the working conditions of staff; > Provision of lifelong personal development programmes > Development of career paths and professional recognition in co-operation with training bodies and vocational educational establishments; > The acquisition of transferable skills across the sector; > Reduction of seasonality and increase permanent employment; > Provision of non-monetary incentives as for example public acknowledgement and awards, study visits abroad, free training courses, etc.

Efficient work in hospitality requires permanent education and trainings – lifelong learning. We indicate some of themes for trainings to be delivered to tourism and hospitality staff in APA and PAs administration and service providers: > Hosting and welcoming visitors (hospitality) > Information management and delivering information > Marketing and sales > Suggestive sales > Corporate marketing and support to TO/TA > Use of e-promotion media > CRM – customer relations management > Animation and event organization > Tourism product development > Team work and stakeholders cooperation > Management of tourism facilities (basic) > Tourism Guiding > Rangers training about hospitality and delivering information (basic) > Foreign languages

Several training courses could be developed by Universities in close cooperation with trade association, professionals and practitioners. Involvment of Universities is important also from the point of view of recruiting educated staff and to provide seasonal staff. Trainings should be practice oriented with presentation of good practices and site visits. Very good results in HR development give also study visits of other PAs in Georgia, to similar or twin PAs abroad.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 49

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

11.5 Imereti caves PA budget and revenes

Imereti caves operated in 2013 with total budget of approximately 350.000 GEL. 75% of total operational budget are labour costs and the rest operational costs for maintenance, electricity, communal costs and similar. On the other side, revenue from tourism accounted in 2013 918.000 GEL.

TABLE30: OPERATIONAL BUDGET AND COMMERCIAL REVENUES OF IMERETI CAVES FOR 2013/2014 AND ESTIMATION OF BUDGET AND COMMERCIAL REVENUES AFTER INVESTMENT PROJECTS, NEW PRODUCTS DEVELOPMENT AND PERFORMING FULL TOURISM FUNCTIONS

Cost item/Revenues 2013/14 - GEL 2020 - GEL Salaries permanent employees 210.000 550.000 Salaries seasonal employees 50.000 75.000 Costs of operations 90.000 150.000 Marketing 0 85.000 Toral Costs 350.000 860.000 Total Revenues 918.000 4.500.000 Net revenues 568.000 3.640.000

Source: Estimations based on data of Imereti caves PA administration and own calculations

Optimal budget was estimated under assumptions that all investment projects and new products will be realized with 21 new employees. For tourism and hospitality operations we proposed 12 additional employees. In Imereti Caves would be alltogether 74 employees. We calculated also 50% increase of salaries. Increase of costs for operations were calculated on the basis of new investment and general need to increase maintenance. To budget of Imereti Caves we added also costs for marketing in the amount of 10% of total operational budget.

Total budget to cover operational budget of Imereti caves would amount to 860.000 GEL per year. In so called optimal year Imereti Caves should achieve yearly revenues between 4.500.000 – 5.300.000 GEL. Net revenues in Imereti caves would be more than 3,640.000 GEL per year.

11.6 Promotion and marketing

Promotion and marketing is essential for successful tourism development of Imereti Caves PA and for achievement of development objectives in 2020. Promotion and marketing must be focused on individual and corporate market – mainly on TOs, on brand development and image building on domestic and international market.

The first step in this direction is to allocate at least10% additional operational budget of Imereti caves for promotion and marketing.

APA and Imereti caves PA administrations should develop marketing strategy and operational plans for Imereti Caves, develop logo of Imereti Caves as subordinated logo of APA and implement planned promotional and marketing activites. There are already all major elements of promotion and marketing presented in the action plan at the end of this document and give the possibility to start implementing them already in 2015.

Imereti Caves PA should perform promotion and marketing with their own staff, mostly independently but in coordination and also jointly with APA and GNTA.

GNTA is developing national tourism strategy and there is much room for appropriate positioning of PAs in the document and in promotion of Georgia on international markets. Imereti Caves as the most tourism exposed protected area in Georgia should be one of the icons of Georgian tourism and GNTA’stourism promotion.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 50

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Imereti caves should integrate and contribute to APA and GNTA promotion and marketing: > Use of Georgia tourism logo and APA logo on promotional and marketing materials > Participation on tourism fairs organized by GNTA and APA with a desk, materials and information person > Presence with APA and GNTA on information stands on airports in Georgia > Stronger presence of Imereti caves and Georgian PAs in GNTA promotional materials > Use of GNTA FAM trips of media and TOs/TAs to visit Imereti caves > Use of market intelligence information of GNTA and APA for marketing planning and performing > Active participation in DMOs development and functioning in Imereti region > Joint awareness rising activities (about nature, clean environment, use of natural and cultural resources, etc.)

11.6.1 Information and promotion materials APA has produced basic informationmaterial for Imereti caves – map and presentation of Sataplia Nature Reserve and Prometheus Cave. It is obvious that protected areas need more information and promotion materials – some for mass distribution and some for special target markets.

When planning production of information & promotion materials it should be considered that majority of nowadays tourists get information from internet, social media or other electronic tools. Therefore, printing of expensive materials and their free distribution should be rather limited. For Imereti Caves it is also important to address properly corporate market – group visitors visiting caves by TOs.

Imereti caves PA should produce followingprinted materials: > Image brochure > Short 2 page leaflet of both caves for mass distribution > Travel agents salesfolder for corporate market – TOs/TAs > Postersfor selected-limited distribution to TOs/TAs, schools, etc. > Roll-upsfor selected-limited use on temporary, ad-hoc presentations > Awareness raising and education leaflets with code of conduct in PAs (for mass distribution) > Yearly report and magazine for corporate and institutional market

Photo monographs of Imereti caves isimportant image and promotion materials and could be used as promotional gift, as image tool and also for selling in visitor centers and bookshops in Georgia. Imereti Caves could also prepare and support production of Speleological Imereti Caves Magazine with promotional, professional and scientific character.

Electronic information & promotion tools: > Web site of Imereti caves with link/as a part of APA website > Video of Imereti Caves > Video spots of Imereti Caves > Radio messages and communication > All printed materials available also on web site in e-form > Social media: Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn and Flickr

It is important to underline that website must be constantly updated,respond fast and clear to questions and inquiries, and social media presence should be permanently administered/interactively communicated.

Electronic information and explanatory boards, kiosks and touch screens are manily on the site electronic tools that offer information to visitors, give explanations and also promote products and services that Imereti Caves offer to visitors.

Products – gadgets& souvenirsare promotional materials and sales products. There could be a wide range of such products. Imereti Caves and APA could organize a tender/contest to collect ideas, proposals and models of such products. After selection of such products with APA & Imereti Caves logo,they would be available for sale in visitor centers and shops bringing benefits to producers, Imereti Caves and APA. Some examples of such products: > T – shirts > Caps > Cups > Badges

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 51

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

> Scarves > Flag > Postcards > Calendars (wall and table) > DVDs > Local products

Imereti Caves will participate on fairs, exhibitions or workshops individually or/and together with APA and GNTA. Therefore, PA’s administration must design and developtypical fair stand/booth or information stand to be used on fairs and other presentations.

11.6.2 Promotion, Marketing and Sales

Individual tourist market represent the majority of international visitors to Georgia and to protected areas – 85% or even more are individuals, organizing their trip by themselves: getting information mainly from internet (not only from APA's web site but also from web sites of TOs/TAs, Sports & Adventures associations and social media), and also from fairs, from relatives or friends and magazins.Hard ecotourists learn about PAs they plan to visit from professional brochures, guide books, articles and similar sources. They organize part of their trip at home the other part when arriving at the destination. When coming to destination – to Georgia, they can travel alone or use ground operators – Georgian TOs that take smaller groups on tours across Georgia. This is the segment of international visitors that together wth domestic visitors form 70% of visitors that come to Imereti Caves in groups.

International promotion and marketing is important for Imereti Caves. It brings international recognition of the caves, increases the basic motive to visit Georgia, contributes to the image of Georgian tourism and attracts professional special market groups to visit Imereti Caves: speleologists, nature caves lovers, scientists, researchers and similar.

Marketing on international markets will have very low direct effects on individual travellers – we can assume that very few individuals will decide to visit only Imereti Caves in Georgia except from neighbouring foreign markets – Turkey, Armenia or Azerbaijan. We can expect significant indirect effect of this international marketing: when visiting Georgia these travellers will decide to visit also Imereti Caves when touring or having holidays in Georgia.

International marketing should be focused on corporate market: international TOs who organize travel to Georgia and is important that they plan also a visit to Imereti Caves andinternational and national speleological associations and organizations that will directly plan to visit to Imereti Caves to discover new attractive underground attractiveness and natural value.

For international marketingthe use of electronic media is getting more and more important and influential and is a must forefficient marketing.Tourist fairs and exhibitions are still important promotion and marketing channels especially when providing business exchange.Presentation on some big international fairs like ITB, FITUR, BIT, WTM or MITTis organized by GNTA andAPA as well as Imereti caves should attend them on GNTA stand. Very interesting are some other target markets Baltic countries, Poland, Israel, neighbouring countries: Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Turkey.There are some specialized fairs and exhibitions specialized in nature, sports and adventure.The list of several specialized fairs is in Annex 4.

FAM – familiariazation trips of international TOs represent direct marketing with important providers of international visitors and as already stated, it is important to present them directly the attractiveness, advantages and benefits visiting Imereti Caves. International TOs are preparing tour programmes for international visitors when visiting Georgia and marketing activities should achieve that Imereti Caves are one of destinations for these international visitors in Georgia.

FAM- familiarization trips of international journalists and media is another promotion and marketing channel for individual market as well as indirectly also for corporate – group market. Good selection of professional media and known journalist or writer is needed in relation with target countries. FIJET – International Federation of Tourist Journalists and Writers and country chapters can help in elaborating this task.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 52

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Tour operators or travel agents sales folder or manualwill give tothe corporate marketall basic information about tourism products and services that they can use when developing tourist packages for certain travel destination. TO/TA sales folder or manual should include factsheets about Imereti caves protected areas, short descriptions with maps, contacts information,tourism products and services (accommodation, F&B, trails, availableequipment to rent, short description with contact of local/regional tourism stakeholders offering tourism and tourism related products and services (accommodation, F&B, transport, ground TOs/TAs, calendar of main events, basic information about the country (surface, population, political system, economic figures, currency) and useful information (embassies, police, emergency, airports, railway and bus stations, air carriers, weather etc.). It is important to have reliable and updated information. Prices for products and services are tentative only and are usually printed on a separate sheet and inserted in manual when needed. Good example of sales manual is the one of Postojna cave: http://www.postojnska-jama.eu/assets/pdf-2014- dalje/prirocnik-2015/PJ-Prirocnik-2015-AN-MAIL.pdf.

A list international TOs focused on nature and caving tourism with their web sites is given in Annex 4. They could be addressed and invited to FAM trips to Georgiawith intention to establish business cooperation.

Promotion and marketing activities of Imereti caves PAon domestic market in Georgia are focusedon international and domestic visitors, on individual and to group visitors. We stated already that majority of international visitors arrive to Georgia on individual basis, but majority of them visit Imereti Caves by local TOs when having holidaysfor tourism in Georgia.

As a consequence, cooperation with Georgian TOs is the most important marketing/sales channel for Imereti Caves. The PA stated during workshops that they had an agreement with 35 Georgian TOs to include Imereti Caves in their tour programmes. This cooperation must be intensified and enlarged in the future. Therefore, we propose in the action plan several activities how to strengthen this market. To increase interest to visit Imereti caves either individually or by Georgian TOs it is important to promote caves in tourism resorts and hotels in Tskaltubo, in Batumi and Black Sea, in Kutaisi and in Tbilisi. Personal visits of marketing staff and a corporate folder of Imereti Caves with FAM trips will give the best sales results. APA and Imereti caves PA should also work more closely with GITOA – Georgian Incoming Tour Operators Association.

Significant share of group visitors are pupils and students from schools, colleges and universities. This market has limited growth potential but can perform a stable increase each year. These groups need only more balanced distribution of their visitation to Imereti caves during the year as they now are too much concentrated in the month of June. Direct meetings with schools and involvement of Ministry of Education with support of APA would solve this problem.

Incentive visits for management of big companies and institutions to Imereti caves would be also very useful. PA’ administration can offer programmes for management meetings in their conference facilities in natural environment, team building programmes, visits caves of business partners of these companies, etc.

Important communication and marketing tool for international and domestic marketing isPR – Public Relations and Guest relations many times named also CRM - Customer Relations Management. CRM professionals prepare information and distribute them to general or specific target audience: media, TOs/TAs, corporate market, political/administrative community, business community, international PAs community and also to local – internal community of PAs in Georgia. They manage complaints and problems of visitors, they register visitors' comments, proposals and praises. CRM professionals are responsible for post sales activities and for increase of loyalty of visitors.

Advertising should be concentrated on travellers on main road connecting Black Sea and Tbilisi with jumbo panels – billboards and on airports.

Efficient promotion tool can be visitors’ card which supports promotion, increase awareness rising, increase visitation and loyalty and contribute to revenues of PAs. If APA developsFriends of Georgia Protected Areas Card – a membership card with yearly membership fee and promotional gift for domestic and international market Imereti caves should introduce this card too.

In order to increase visitation and to improve management of visitation to Imereti caves – to avoid masses, waiting time and dissatisfaction Imereti caves should introduce electronic booking system that would first of all enable tour operators to plan their visits to caves in advance.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 53

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

11.7 Organization of PA’s managementand stakeholders’ cooperation

Georgia has centralized system of nature conservation, protection and management. APA – Agency of protected areas was established as a legal entity under public law in the Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources Protection of Georgia and started operations in February 2008.The Agency’s primary responsibility is to manage Georgia’s strict nature reserves, national parks, natural monuments, managed reserves, protected landscapes, biosphere reserves, world heritage sites and wetland sites of international importance. The objective of the Agency is to improve the management of protected areas, ensure functionality of territorial administrations, supervise the process of following legally established regulations and to plan, create and develop new protected areas.

Imereti Caves PA has territorial administration within APA and has very littleindependence. This centralized organization has a strong advantage especially when we consider fast developing nature conservation, the need for uniform nature protection and management policy, building unique image of protected areas in Georgia and efficient synergic management. This advantage is obvious also from the point of view of the lack of professional leadership and management knowledge and experiences to run PAs. There are also disadvantages of centralized system resulting mainly in long procedures and slow decision making processes that affect primarily more advanced and active PAs with more innitiatives.

Tourism is a market oriented activity requiring entrpreneurship, innitiatives, fast decision making and intensive promotion, marketing and sales. Tourism requires more independent management whereresponsibilities and obligations are clearly set and procedures for decision making more flexible.

In our case it is expected that APA will devolve more responsibilities to Imereti Caves PA'sadministration and also bind administration to achieve planned results.The devolution process should be step by step enabling smooth transition of responsibilities and successful acceptance of obligations. The devolution process in Imereti caves PA should start on the following areas: > Employment and HR management: enabling PAs administration to develop strong and efficient tourism/hospitality team, recruiting staff based on professional criteria respecting also local/regional origin of candidates; employment of seasonal staff; develop criteria and provide incentives on top of basic salaries according to achieved results of employees; education, trainings and study visits; > Tourism and hospitality facilities use and management: organize management of hospitality facilities by own permanent staff and seasonal staff, organize flexible opening time, identify potential local/regional providers of products and services important for PA, negotiate and propose agreements with subcontractors, being able to engage subcontractors in the case of vis major – accident, damage of PA's facilities, etc.; > Revenue and price policy: provide flexible price policy, introduce products on the market, negotiate and propose agreements' conditions with TOs and other organizations and institutions; > Cooperation with local/regional communties and partners: participate and support local innitiatives, actively participate in Tskaltubo resort DMO, provide initiatives to municipalities, enable local communities and population to know Imereti Caves better, role of protected areas and possibilities that visitsto Imereti caves offer for business development to local population; > Dispose of certain share of yearly budget: for operational promotion and marketing, for smaller maintenance of tourism and hospitality facilities, for trainings and study visits, for local innitiatives and cooperation, for small purchases.

Imereti caves PA administration must develop strong tourism/hospitality department in order to achieve tourism objectives. In this sense, basic organization of Imereti caves PA’s administration should consist of: > Management (head, deputy head and revenue manager & controller) > Marketing and sales (promotion material, marketing, rezervations, on site sales, cashiers,...) > Nature protection and sustainability (environment specialist, rangers,…) > Products and services development (attractions – caves, trails, recreation, pleasure, health, nature camps, etc. development) > Hospitality facilities management (hotel and other accommodation, restaurants, cafes, shops,...) > Supporting services (maintenance, parking,…)

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 54

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Cooperationwith stakeholders on national, regional and local level is important for Imereti caves from the point of view of promotion, sales, image and relations-cooperation building. On national level GNTA and GITOA are the most important for Imereti Caves. On regional – destination level GNTA should proceed with establishment of regional DMOs – Destination Management Organizations where PAs should be one of important stakeholders. In Tskaltubo there is already Tskaltubo resort DMO where Imereti Caves should participate and cooperate in joint development of Tskaltubo destination with healt& spa and nature – Imerety Caves.

On local level relations should consist of cooperation with municipalities and their tourism departments and TICs that are local extension of GNTA. Imereti Caves should cooperate also with universities and research centers and support innitiatives to establish HORECA associations of hotels, restaurants, cafes, guides, etc.

Association of Friends of Protected Areais local initiative in some regions. Some protected areas in Georgia have initiated establishment of Association Friends of PA with an aim to develop and offer some products and services for visitors instead of PAs administration and to support fundraising for PAs’ related activities. This would enable PAs to get additional financial resources indirectly for tourism products and services development as they cannot perform commercial activities. Associations gathermembers with interest in developing tourism products and services in close relations with PAs and are located in or in neighbouring area of PAs.

Imereti Caves PA does not meet the same situation like nearly all other PAs in Georgia where Association of Friends of PAs were established. Therefore, the role of such association should be different in the case of Imereti Caves. The mission of Association of Imereti Caves PA should be focused on support to nature protection and sustainable development, strengthnening the commitment to natural values with card of Friends of PAs in Georgia, awareness rising, and promotion of PA. It would be reasonable to establish such association if APA supports development of these associations and establish network ofAssociations of Friends of PA on national level with Federation/Union of Associations of Friends of PA of Georgia.

11.8 Quality standards andbrand development

Development of marketing strategy for Imereti caves PA must be based on high quality of facilities, products and services. Nowadays all tourism product and service providers and destinations look for excellence in quality. Excellence in quality is the only possibility to achieve satisfaction of visitors and consequently willingenes to pay higher prices. Therefore, there are quality standards and trainings to achieve them, there are quality competitions, awards, and other actions locally and nationwide. Handbooks are prepared to describe these standards, symbols and visual identification systems are developed to expose good, better excellent products and services and differentiate providers and destinations.

High quality of products and services is one of priorities in tourism development in protected areas in Georgia. Basics for quality are standards that products and services have to achieve to be competitive and to satisfy consumers. Imereti Caves PA should develop and implement such standards for whole variety of products and services for visitors. This range of Imereti Caves offer starts with the equipment, arrangement and guidance in caves and on trails and can reach products that are sold in shops in visitor centers or other shops being certified with Imereti caves label.

Based on such standards the PA administration should develop a quality management and certification system. Certification is on voluntary basis for external (non Imereti caves PA) providers of products and services but includes conditions for cooperation with PA.

Quality standards could be introduced for: > Cave and nature trails > Accommodation > Food and beverage facilities > Transport > Service providers: guides, museum, recreation, events, etc. > Shops > Typical products from PA or area around PA (herbs, fruit, crafts, souvenirs, etc.)

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 55

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Standards enable monitoring of quality, reliable promotion, and image and brand development. Quality standards should consider the following elements: > Technical quality - standards (quality and safety of trails, illumination, the size of the room in hotel, restaurant, variety and the quality of equipment, WC and bathroom, corridors and similar) > Functional quality (places with view and interpretation, inner places and outside in good order, responsiveness, professional and hospitality of staff, good communication, language skills, accessibility on general and for disabled persons, products well designed and packed, information available, etc) > Commitment to environment (consistency with cave structure and materials, use of natural materials, ecologically produced products, traditional habits and culture, rational use of energy and rare resources) > Knowledge of PA

Evaluation of products and services is done with evaluation questionnaires and valid for 2 years. Certified products and services are registered and can use Imerety Caves and APA logo. Quality standards and certification should be publically promoted and acknowledged assupport to entrepreneurship and local development. Quality standards are also the basis for brand development.

Based on quality standards and other attributes of protected areas the highest level of market image positioning and differentiation of Imereti Caves is brand development. It is a task of marketing strategy and requires long development, testing and implementation process. Here are 4 basic considerations about brand development of Imereti Caves.

OBJECTIVE CONTENT

Differentiate Imereti caves Geographical location (Caucasus), No other caves in the range of from its competitors; 1.000 kilometers, Dinosaur footprints, Historical facts and legends: Jason and golden fleece,

Increase awareness and Strengthening the competitive advantages; unique underground recognition, and therefore mystery, dinosaur footprints, high quality standards and memorability of Imereti caves certificates, high safety standards, on-line monitoring of visitors’ over time amongst potential impact in caves, increased awareness about Imereti caves and PAs visitors; in Georgia.

Create a positive image for Define marketing and communication strategy with corporate Imereti caves that makes identity – logo and communication tools; creative use of people responsive to communication/marketing tools and channels, systematic, promotion and marketing; consistent and permanens market communication;

Give the PAs strong and Define the personality, culture (values), physical evidences of compelling brand identity Imereti caves, consumer (visitor) experience, reflections of consumer (visitor), relationship (Imereti caves-visitor) and provide identification of local population with brand identity.

Source: Handbook on Tourism Destination Branding (2009)

TABLE31: BASIC PHASES IN BRAND DEVELOPMENT

Successful tourism branding requires brand management with brand manager, brand steering group, internal communication to employees and trainingsand monitoring of the brand’s impact through customer feedback and market research.

11.9 Revenue policy

Imereti Caves PA is the only protected area in Georgia that is fully tourism oriented withvery goodtourism infrastructure and equipement, and has reached very fast increase of visitor numbersin last years. Total revenues from toruism were 918.000 GEL in 2013 and might reach 1.200.000 GEL in 2014. Revenues from tourism originate for 90% from entrance fees and the rest from concessions for

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 56

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL shops and catering in Sataplia and Prometheus. Imereti caves contribute 90% to overall revenues from tourism of all protected areas in Georgia.

Main revenues in Imereti Caves are from entrance fees which are set rigid not considering possible differentiation regarding age, season, type of visitors. Besides, the variety of additional offer of products and services, accommodation, catering, shopping is very limited and does not contribute to the revenues of Imereti Caves as much as they could, or as much as this offer contributes in some other tourism oriented caves. For example in Postojna cave in Slovenia the share of revenues from entrance fees is 59% and revenues from other products and services41 %. In Škocjan UNESCO cave in Slovenia as another example, entrance fees represent 60% of all revenues, the rest 40% are revenues from state budget and international - EU projects. The share of revenues from tourism reaches on average up to 25% of total budget of protected areas in developed countries.

Imereti caves PA administration with strong support of APA must therefore look for additional financial resources where revenues from commercial – mainly tourism related activities are contributing more and more to overall budges of Imereti Caves and APA.

Revenues of Imereti caves should origin from the following potential sources: > Governmental funding for nature conservation, protection and management > Entrance fees for visitors > User fees for products and services offered, events and special – VIP services > Concessions and lease for speleological healing and wine aging > Packages for visitors (transport, visit of a cave, event, product-souvenir; wellness-pleasure, wine tasting; nature & art camps; etc > Accommodation in hotel and camps > Meetings (MICE) services and equipment > Equipment rental (lockers, bikes, stks for Nordic walking, ...) > Food sales in cafes, restaurants and stores > Merchandise sales (Imereti Caves products, souvenirs, > Internet access, WIFI > Membership or alliance cards if Friends of Georgia Protected Areas Card will be introduced by APA > Sales or/and licencing of intellectual property for photos, videos, texts > Parking > Cross product selling (accommodation in Tskaltubo resort & visit of Imereti caves; > Cross-marketing with bigger companies (for example water, internet provider, mobile service provider,...) > Public investment (investment in running water supply in Sataplia, fence around PA) > Private sector initiatives (products and services in local communities linked to Imereti caves) > Technical assistance projects from bilateral and multilateral sources > Sponsorship > Donations > Voluntourism (which is in fact cost reducing and not revenue generating) of local population in the field of assistance to rangers, aweareness rising about nature, waste management, etc.

Imereti caves have entrance feefor Prometheus cave, for boat trip as exit possibility in Prometheus cave, for Sataplia cave and nature trails. Entrance fees are all the year the same, they differ only for pupils and students – half of entrance ticket for adults. There is special entrance fee for VIP events (wedding in cave, meditation in cave, small group or individual visit with guide). TOs have free entrance for their .

We propose to have additional groups: tickets for families, retired persons and multi-entry tickets. We also propose to differentiate price for tickets for high season and off season.

Simulation with higher entrance fees for July and August show that there would be 12% increase of total revenues – instead of 918.000 GEL in 2013 there would be 1.028.000 GEL. Peak summer entrance fees would be:

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 57

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

2013 Jul&Aug Entrance tickets GEL GEL Pupils&Students 3,5 5 Familes 14 20 Adults 7 10

Avg price 6,16 8,8

TABLE32: IMERETI CAVES ENTRANCE FEE

Products and services offered to visitors of Imereti caves should be more numerous, should be adopted to short stay of visitors – even food should be already prepared for sale in cafes and shops and should be attractively packed and presented.

We propose some examples of additional offer for services, shopping, accommodation and catering:

Sports&Recreation GEL Wellness&Pleasure GEL Shop GEL Stiks for nordic walking 2 Gong therapy 10 Imereti caves brochure 7 Badminton 4 Bioenergetic guided tour10 Coin - Sataplia dinosaur 1 Volley ball 4 Meditation guided in nature10 Postcard 1 Baskett ball (4 basket) 4 Wine tasting 15 T shirt 8 Archery 4 Packages for Tskaltubo 15 Cap 5 Mini golf 4 Calender wall 10 DVD Imereti caves Packed food Packed sweets

Souvenirs

TABLE33: IMERETI CAVES ADDITIONAL OFFER

Hotel & AccommodationGEL Cafe & Restaurant GEL Cafe & Restaurant GEL Hotel half board 70 Coffee 3 Croisson 2 Camp half board 25 Tea 2 Hot dog 3 Conference room - 1 day100 Water 1 Toast 3 1/2 day 60 Ice tea 2 Sendwich 3 Rent laptop 50 Limonade 2 Boiled egg 2 Rent projector 50 Coca Cola 3 Salad 5 Coffee break 6 Bier 3 Matsone 3 Lunch/Dinner 15 Wine - glass 2 Fruit basket 3 Hachapuri (1/6) 1 Ice cream 2 Daily soup - vegi 4 Pop corn 1 Daily soup - meat 4 Peanuts/Wollnuts 2 French fries 3 Churchela Crep 4 Small chocolates Cheese 5

TABLE34: IMERETI CAVES ADDITIONAL OFFER FOR HOTEL

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 58

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Concession policy and practice depend on the role of public and private sector in PAs management. Public administration – central or local of a certain protected area has to take care primarily about:  Environmental protection  Infrastructure building and maintenance (roads, energy, ICT, sanitation)  Trails, camping places, shelters,observation platforms, etc  Security and safety  Monitoring of impacts and evaluation of quality  Managing access and visitors flows  Information (visitors centers, nature interpretation)  Conflict resolution

The private sector’s role is to provide accommodation and food, transportation, information, media (books, videos, etc.) guiding, site promotion and advertising, products (equipment, clothes, souvenirs) and personal services, etc. The private sector provides products and services that tourists need and enjoy while visiting protected areas and ensure a comfortable stay in or in close neighbourhood of protected areas.

Imereti Caves PA differs from other protected areas in Georgia. Caves are open to visitors with very good infrastructure and developing products and services. Imereti caves attract many visitors and have big revenues from visiting tourist. APA has had organized tenders to give in concession hospitality facilities (hotel, restauranf and café, shops) with small success. Visitors are complaining that there is nearly no additional offer especially when they have to wait to enter the cave. The hotel is closed, the conference room is closed, and the catering offer is poor.

We propose that Imereti Caves PA administration takes over management of all products and services including tourism and hospitality ones: accommodation, catering and shops.With own management Imereti Caves PA and APA can benefit from tourism activities significantly, with a midterm increase the economic value of tourist site and achieve much better position for negotiations with potential concessionaires when the site and tourism are well developed, with recognized image, high quality products and well developed domestic and international market of visitors. The only concession or lease would be in the case of speleological healing and wine ageing for which Tskaltubo health resort and Khareba winery as for example would be capable to manage.

To develop and manage complete tourism and hospitality offer together with visit of caves and natural monuments is the optimal solution for development of highly recognized tourism site, with unique image and brand. This is also the only way how to increase revenues from tourism as revenues from entrance fee can increase only when number of visitors is increasing. Increase of prices for entrance tickets is not recommended, to have higher prices for international visitors is not advisable and acceptable.

APA and Imereti caves PA should give in this case in concession speleological healing and wine ageing as for both Imereti caves PA administration is not equipped and trained – capable to manage.

If management of all attractions and commercial tourism facilities of Imereti Caves PA is not possible/acceptableto the PA’s administration, then concession should be considered with 2 alternatives. The first alternative is to give in concession the complete protected area with attractions and tourism facilities. In this case a profound estimation of potential revenues should be done in order to negotiate the concession fee as well as all other rights and obligations in the concessions agreement/contract. Another alternative is to give in concession the visitors center (or both centers at Prometheus cave and Sataplia) as one package and tourism hospitality complex in Sataplia as another package. In both alternatives separate negotiation and contract should be agreed for speleological healing and wine ageing.

There are 5 principles of concession policy that need to be respected before its implementation. > First is concessionaire qualification with financial capacity, tourism experience, educational level and language ability. > Then come legal responsibility with length of contract, late or non-payment of the fee, facility ownership, environment damage, fines and contract non-fulfilment. > Third is financial responsibility with financial insurance mechanisms, concession – user fee, Income requirements and maintenance/repair reservations. > Environmental responsibility is the next section with infrastructure development, monitoring plan, use of scarce resources, alternative energy use and waste management and risk analysis.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 59

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

> The last principle is social responsibility that reflects the attitude towards local communities and population: capacity building, local employment, community assessment and revenue sharing and local business involvement.

Concession contracts must include as minimum:  Minimum and compulsory operating hours  Range of services  Level and standards for customer services  Environmental practices  Pricing policy if PA has monopoly position or there is competition  Public access to facilities  Infrastructure maintenance responsibilities  Safety and sustainability requirements  Signage - indoor and outdoor  Advertising  Staff and operations accreditation/licensing standards  Design of facilities using local and natural materials  Monitoring of concession contract and operation  Concession fee and payment mechanism  Duration of contract  Guarantees - financial for accidents or damage  Consequences if contract/concession fails

The concession fee can be based on different principles. The most usual would be to set the flat annual fixed fee plus flexible fee as a percentage of all revenues on monthly basis or even fixed amount per customer served. The fee could increase in time. Concession contracts should be agreed for 10 to 15 years with possibility for extension and with clause for immediate termination in the case of violation the rules.

Concession policy contracting and monitoring should be done by APA centrally.

11.10 Sustainable tourism policy

Visitors of Imereti caves protected areas complains about too much crowd from time to time but visitor denisity is only one aspect of sustainable management of protected area. There is a question of waste management, environmentally and socially responsible behaviour of visitors, use of energy, scares natural resources like water, etc.

Carrying capacities

There has been no professional evaluation of carrying capacities done for Imereti caves. Some estimations state that even 4 times more visitors can enter in caves as compared to visits in peak month – June.

As long there is no professional evaluation of carrying capacities done international comparison could be a satisfactory indicator of possibilities to expand tourist numbers to Imereti caves. In the table below we compared visits to Prometheus cave with visits to Postojna cave in Slovenia. Comparisson of number of visitors per length of Imereti caves,average daily visitors in a year or in summer season month show that Imereti Caves have a potential to increase visitation byat least 2 times. With improved management of visitors’ flows throughout the year, better daily scheduling of groups and increase use of additional products and services there will be more room for increasing visitor numbers without negative impact on nature and environment. With extension of Prometheus cave and opening of new caves for tourists the capacities of caves to receive more tourists will increase even more.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 60

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

TABLE35: COMPARATIVE REVIEW OF INTENSITY OF VISITATION IN IMERETI CAVES WITH POSTOJNA CAVE FOR 2013

Visitors/day Visitors /1m Visitors/day Imereti caves PA Visitors total / open trail/1m cave August months

Imereti caves - Prometheus cave 145.888 51/4* 405 761

Postojna cave - Slovenia 556.000 128/26* 1.523 3.871

Škocjan UNESCO caves 111.120 37/18 304 838

Georgia total 350.642 974 1.980 * No of visitors is calculated for 1m of visitors' trail/1m total length of the cave

Source: Calculated from APA data and international from Postojna cave, 2014

At this point we must conclude and underline that according to international comparisons visit numbers to Imereti Caves are still far from the point to undertake substantial restrictive measures for tourist visits. Management of visitors’ flowsin Imereti cavesneeds better organization and improvement. It is obvious from complaints of visitorswhen they wait too long, are in too big group or are too many groups in the cave with not balanced tempo of visits so that they interfere and disturb each other.

A first step toimprove visitors’ flows is to discuss with schools and the Ministry of education to distribute more equally school groups visits throughout the year thus decreasing the preasure that they have now in June.

Second step in management of visitors’ flows is flexible opening time for visitors – longer in summer season and shorter in other seasons with examptions for weekends and public holidays.

Another step that would bring better results are fixed scheduled visits which can have the maximal frequency in summer months (for example each 20 minutes) and decreasing frequency in less visited months (maybe each hour). There would be again convenient to have bigger frequency on weekends and public holidays.

Significant contribution to better use of time to visit Imereti Caves would be the introduction of electronic booking system accessible via internet to book entry ticket for a certain day and certain time as long as there is enough places in the group for that partciular day and time. It is clear that at the ticket counter there should have to be always updated overview of tickets booked so cashiers would always know how much tickets are still available for certain groups that can be sold on the spot.

As usually there will be visitors coming without prior bookings and there must be a time available also for them (for example each 3rd group in one hour in summer season). In this case they will know how long they will have to wait and while waiting they can visit and experience some other products or services of the PA.

Finally, nowadays practice that Prometheus cave and Sataplia are closed for visitors 1 day per week should be abolished.

Visitors’ flows managementin Imereti caves can have also some othermeasures when visiting PA’s trails, nature zones, museums, recreation areas, playgrounds, etc.:  Zoning - visitors are allowed to visit and are guided to these zones that are also equipped with basic infrastructure for their use  “Honeyspots” -as the name says – sweet-attractive places to where youpurposely guide visitors in order to avoid other groups, avoid demaged spots, etc;  Tourist routes -tourist routes or trails are constructed to guide visitors to attractive places on a safe way and at the same time avoiding possible negative effects on nature; alternative routes or trails should also be available and used in the case of too high visitation on primary routes;

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 61

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

 Pricing and levies – pricesor extra fees could be applied for entering the caves or special zones, use of visitors infrastructure, etc.,in the case of extremely high visitation; usually such situations are predicted already in revenue-pricing policy to have higher prices on weekend or publicic holidays when demand becomes too high.  Regulations &Restrictions – they should be applied in special situations and consist of o Permanent or temporary closure of some areas o Visitors’ group size o Age or physical conditions of visitors limitations o Visitation schedule respecting living rhythm of animals, flowering period in some areas, daily schedule to some attractions, etc.  Permits and special requirements: o Special permits for entering certain caves:for example for scientists and researchers, photographers, etc. o Visitors’ and/or operators’ qualifications and skills:for caving adventures, etc o Technology requirements: special dress, shoes, equipment for not fully explored caves…  Code of conduct in Imereti caves: giving basic rules and norms of behaviour in Imereti caves protected areas.

Nature impact assessment and monitoring

In order to apply sustainable tourism measures especially in the case of excessive visiting numbers,monitoring of visitors’ flows is needed. From sustainability point of view number of visitors on weekends, public holidays in summer seasonusually exceeds the number of visitors in other periods of the week and day. Therefore it isimportant to measure several aspects of intensity of visits as well as qualitative aspect like motives, satisfaction, country of origin, place from where visitor is coming to Imereti caves, etc

Imereti Caves registersthe number of visitors who buy entry ticket, so the total number of visitors is very reliable. It would be very useful to adopt the visitors' surveywhich is in use today. Itshould be improved and more focused on the needs of Imereti Caves. It would be very useful to have also on- line survey on Imereti caves web site as for those who intend to visit PA and those who visited it.

PA administration is going to install on line monitoring system in Prometheus Cave with Czech technical support measuring temperature, humidity, CO2, radon, etc.

Systematic and periodical analysis of impact of tourism in caves, on natural environment, social environment are needed to getuseful results of effects of tourism in protected areas and surrounding communities and to undertake measures for sustainable use of resources and tourism development.

11.11 Safety and security

There were no bad accidents of visitors in Imereti Caves. Some visitors feel bad when being in cave or feel claustrophobia, in few cases only visitors hurt – distortion or break a leg on stairs in the cave. The PA administration made an assessment of safety in the cave, they monitor installations and equipment and provide basic safety support.

The PA administration does not have a built-in system to report about possible dangerous situations. There are explanatory and warning signs on the walls but most probably not enough.Administration use water measuring instrument in the cave lake to signal when the water level rises.Rangers observe the boat trail every morning and clean the paved cave trail – slipping parts and stones with special equipment. They have also practical transportation equipment to take wounded visitors out of the cave. The PA has basic medical equipment and first aid in the visitor centers and in the cave, rangers use also transportation equipment.

The PA administration has an evacuation plan for the cave.Rangers, guides and employees have been basically trained on how to react in such case. Having a licensed/certified safety specialist is a priority need for PA administration and more professional trainings are needed for employees and especially those working in risky areas. In the case of accidents emergency 112 service is mobilized.

Visitors are informed about basic dangers in the caves.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 62

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Imereti Caves need professional assessment of safety situation and possible risks for visitors in the cave. The danger of earthquake is emphasized in this case. On this basis an evacuation plan should be prepared and safety exits provided and indicated with signs. Additionally, the PA administration needs also guidelines to assure security for visitors, to identify possible dangers for the caves and for visitors and how to react.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 63

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

12 ACTION PLAN

Management of Imereti Caves PA must assure with strong support and assistance of APA following the vision of strategic development and to achieve general and specific objectives. In order to achieve objectives a set of activites must be formulated accordingly and their realization must be done fficiently and in time.

The general development objective of Imereti caves is to operate as a successful model of balanced sustainable and tourism oriented protected area in Georgia with great natural and educational value and economic efficiency and internationally highly recognized tourism attraction. This general objective was decomposed to 9 specific objectives for which we elaborated activities that will assure achievement of these objectives if activities are realized.

Mainly all activities are in domain of Imereti Cave PA administration coordinated, agreed and realized with more responsibilities and resources devolved to PA’s administration and with support of APA. Whenever external support is needed procurement is applied according to Georgian legislation. All activites are also permanent in all years ahead. Some, like production of promotional materials might be more intensive in some years but. Nevertheless, also promotional material need to be reprinted and updated with new facts and photos adopting also language in which tourist market is addressed.

TABLE36: ACTION PLAN FOR IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA FOR THE PERIOD 2015 - 2020

STRATEGY OBJECTIVES ACTIVITIES 2015 - 2020

1. Increase the number of domestic and international visitors Prepare 5 year marketing and promotion plan and annual 1- 1.1 year operational marketing plans for Imereti caves Assure yearly budget for promotion and marketing in the 1.2 amount of 10% of total budget of Imereti caves PA Design and develop Imereti caves logo and built hierarchy with 1.3 APA – Georgian logo of protected areas Produce basic information & promotion printed materials: 1.4 Image brochure, TO folder, leaflet/flyer, posters Produce basic information & promotion electronic tools: web 1.5 site, e-newsletter, Facebook, Flickr, Twitter and update regularly 1.6 Produce video, DVD, video spot and advertising messages Prepare target oriented mailing list: TOs, Media, and Increase number of 1.7 Stakeholders (hotels, international and national institutions, visitors from 145.000 etc.) in 2013 to at least Participate on GNTA stand on general fairs and exhibitions 1.8 300.000 in 2020 abroad Participate with APA on selected special fairs, exhibitions and 1.9 Increase the share of workshops abroad international visitors Participate on tourism fairs, exhibitions and workshops in 1.10 from 29% in 2013 to neighbouring countries 50% in 2020 1.11 Participate on tourism fairs in Georgia Organize promotional campaign in shopping malls in Tbilisi and 1.12 Batumi 1.13 Regularly update Imereti caves web site Regularly produce and distribute e-newsletter (at least once 1.14 per month) Organize FAM – familiarization trips of GITOA and Georgian 1.15 TOs to PA Organize FAM – familiarization trips of TOs from neighbouring 1.16 countries to PA Organize FAM – familiarization trips of Embassies inGeorgia 1.17 with Imereti Caves presentation Organize FAM – familiarization trips for influential international 1.18 & national bloggers

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 64

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Organize visit of Imereti Caves tourism product for 1.19 sales/reception staff in Tskaltubo and Kutaisi hotels Introduce traditional International Culinary&Art Festival in 1.20 cooperation with Embassies (presentation of countries culinary, culture, tradition,etc.) Identify and contact international TOs organizing tours to 1.21 Georgia 1.22 Visit Georgian TOs with PA's offer and business proposal Visit hotels in Tskaltubo, Kutaisi, Adjara and Tbilisi with PA's 1.23 offer and business proposal Identify, contact and inform about Imereti caves international 1.24 and national Show Cave and Speleological associations 1.25 Invite ICSA to organize annual conference in Imereti caves Promote and communicate on social media (Facebook, Twitter, 1.26 Instagram, blogs, etc.) 1.27 Promote and advertise on airports Tbilisi, Kutaisi and Batumi Promote and advertise on domestic market – billboard on the 1.28 main road 1 Organize FAM – familiarization trips of journalists and media 29 Regularly inform media with e-newsletter 1.30 Organise yearly open days in Imereti caves - Festival 1.31 Abolish practice of 1 day closed PA for visitors Introduce flexible opening time for visitors accordingto 132 intensity of demand 2. Increase revenues from tourism and commercial activities 2.1 Develop and implement price policy Prepare differentiation of entry fees following yield 2.2 management principles 2.3 Introduce multi- entry/seasonal entry ticket When introducing charges for new services (like for parking) 2.4 consider a discount for consumption in PAs restaurant or bar. Offer new products and services that will be charged to 2.5 costumers Develop and offer packages to visit Imereti caves (transport, 2.6 welcome, visit of cave, souvenir, event or a soft activity) mainly for tourists in Tskaltubo or other groups Develop and offer tailor made – VIP programmes with high 2.7 value added (weddings, meditation, wine tasting,...) Increase the revenues Develop and use electronic booking system for better time from tourism from 2.8 planning of visits, to increase satisfaction with shortening 918.600 GEL in 2013 waiting time and to increase revenues to at least 4.500.000 Produce and sell products like postcards, T shirts, cups, GEL in 2020. 2.9 calendars, DVDs

Organize promotional action with products cross selling in Increase the share of 2.10 Kutaisi markets (with wine producer, restaurant owner, Vani revenues from sales of museum, Socar company, Gelati and Bagrati cathedral, etc). products and services other than from entry 2.11 Organize and implement donation scheme Organize open air cinema festival / retrospective of Georgian fees. 2.12 films Organize open air theatre (for example in cooperation with 2.13 Tumanishvili Theater Tbilisi) / Georgian dance show Organize 1 hour animation programme for kids - puppet show 2.14 with cave mascot (in cooperation of Nodar Dumbadze Youth Theatre for example) Organize and implement cross-marketing with big companies and institutions (Khareba winery, Georgia bank, TBC, IC 2.15 Group Insurance company, Georgia-Auto Insurance companies, Publishing company for example) Manage Imereti caves and tourism facilities, products and 2.16 services by qualified and committed PA administration and tourism professionals

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 65

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

3. Increase overall satisfaction of visitors Prepare questionnaire for visitors and organize representative 3.1 surveying and guest analysis Register complaints, discuss about complaints on management 3.2 board and solve them by the highest priority Offer visitors realistic information about PA and inform if there 3.3 Increase satisfaction are any problems or deficiencies Offer to visitors professional guiding service – personal or with of visitors and 3.4 decrease complaints e-guides Organize scheduled visits & time management in the case of 3.5 Increase the length of excessive demand stay of visitors Discuss with relevant authorities and schools to distribute visits 3.6 of school groups throughout the year Increase the loyalty – Offer to visitors activities and services to spend time while 3.7 the rate of return waiting to enter in cave/on trail visitors to PAs Inform and promote new products and services of PA and 3.8 direct visitors to them 3.9 Improve guiding and interpretation facilities and services in PA Introduce visitors card »Friend of Georgia PAs« for highly 3.10 committed and frequent visitors, VIPs, as an award etc. Organize efficient safety and security measures and implement 3.11 them professionally if needed Restructure and use efficiently visitors' infrastructure and develop new tourism 4. products and services in Imereti caves Develop and complete basic infrastructure for PA management 4.1 and visitors (running water, WIFI, PA fence, parking) Provide efficient use of administration buildings and visitors 4.2 Complete basic PA's centers for visitors welcome, information and services infrastructure Expand accommodation capacities (hotel, camp) in Sataplia to 4.3 market acceptable dimension Improve efficiency of 4.4 Develop and offer new caves to tourism market use of existing tourism Develop and offer to tourism market products and services to facilities 4.5 extend the stay and increase satisfaction (Playgrounds, Nature

& Art camps, Pleasure programmes and Recreation activities) Develop and offer new Enable comfortable and visible access to PA for all also for tourism products and 4.6 disabled visitors services Enable connection of Tskaltubo health resort and Prometheus 4.7 Cave with biking trail on separate track Connect/Link Develop quality standards for products and services related to Tskaltubo heakth&spa 4.8 resort and Imereti Imereti caves PA Introduce and promote quality certification system for tourism caves PA 4.9 products and services based on PA standards Assess and monitor quality standards and use of labels in 4.10 practice 5, Develop professional HR team in Imereti caves and provide permanent trainings Organize tourism/hospitality team in Imereti caves PA: 5.1 hospitality management, marketing, web & e-marketing, Press & guest relations, visitors services, guides Organize tender and mobilize capable staff fulfilling certain 5.2 Organize & mobilize criteria tourism/hospitality 5.3 Introduce stimulative salaries and incentives for staff in PA staff Apply other stimulative measures for employees in PA (health 5.4 insurance, education & trainings, public awards) Provide permanent Provide education and trainings for Imereti caves PA tourism & 5.5 trainings of Imereti hospitality staff caves PA staff 5.6 Educate / Train staff how to deal with complaints Organize workshops on Communication and Marketing 5.7 programmes Increase salaries / introduce stimulating salary system for 5.8 outstanding work achievement

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 66

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

5.9 Introduce Best employee of Imereti caves yearly programme 5.10 Provide study visits to protected areas abroad Develop Imereti Cave Scholarship programme for outstanding 5.11 Georgian student for Master or Doctoral thesis/ maybe in cooperation with Erasmus Mundus Programme Contribute to the development of local communities and stakeholder s' cooperation in 6. Imereti region Provide population in local communities information about 6.1 tourism visitation to Imereti caves, hospitality and needs of tourists Offer to local entrepreneurs to present and sell their products 6.2 Provide local around visitors center or in the parking place area communities and local Implement PPPPs – people, public, private partnerships to 6.3 population achieve participatory approach of sustainable development opportunities for Introduce measures to stimulate innovations and 6.4 business development entrepreneurship (like Financial Participatory Approach) 6.5 Employ local people Strengthen knowledge 6.6 Engage local people for seasonal work or volunteering of local population 6.7 Motivate local youth to study for work in PA about Imereti caves Organize open day of Imereti caves PA and use this PA and protected 6.8 opportunity to spread the knowledge about Imereti caves PA areas in Georgia and and PAs in Georgia their commitment to Organize traditional high level charitable concert in cooperation with nature and natural 6.9 state orchestra and national TV values Support establishment of HORECA associations of hotels, guest 6.10 Contribute to houses, restaurants, guides,... Lead the initiative for establishment of Imereti Caves organization and 6.11 cooperation of tourism orchestra, choir or dancing group Develop Imereti Cave Mascote educational programme for stakeholders in 6.12 Imereti region pupils (supporting health life style, habits, etc.) Organize and promote establishment of Association of Friends 6.13 of Imereti caves PA as a member of Georgia network of Associations 6.14 Participate and coordinate activities with Tskaltubo resort DMO Implement sustainable principles and measures and provide services assuring 7. security and safety 7.1 Analyze and define carrying capacities for Imereti caves PA 7.2 Manage and monitor visitors' flows in Imereti caves PA Introduce equipment and methods for permanent 7.3 measurement of nature impact of tourism visitation 7.4 Analyze social impact of tourism visitation Inform / Educate visitors about scarce resources (energy, 7.5 Strengthen water,..) and local habits, tradition etc. sustainability 7.6 Intensify use of renewable energy measures in Imereti Introduce and promote use of recycling materials and »no 7.7 caves PA plastic« packing Organize waste management and collection as well as 7.8 Provide awareness raising campaigns comprehensive safety Prepare comprehensive safety and security risk assessment for 7.9 and security measures visitors and employees and action plan Develop action plan and organize staff to manage risks and 7.10 accidents Equip PA and »hot« spots with equipment to assure safety and 7.11 security 7.12 Analyze risks and accidents and share findings with APA Introduce award programme for visitors using sustainable 7.13 transport

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 67

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

Emphasize and mediate education and awareness rising about nature and nature 8. values to visitors of Imereti caves Use information and promotion materials to provide 8.1 information about nature and PAs Install explanatory boards in PA to express the importance of 8.2 nature, natural values and PAs Include in guiding »live« and »e-guiding« information about 8.3 nature, natural values and PAs and use examples to be illustrative and more persuasive Increase the Organize quiz among young visitors about nature, natural knowledge of nature, 8.4 values and PAs with useful awards natural values and PAs Organize discussion on social media about nature, natural 8.5 values and PAs Propose to schools that are visiting Imereti caves to stimulate 8.6 pupils to make posters, articles, etc. about their visit and importance of nature, natural values and PAs. 8.7 Organize educational days in cooperation with Universities 8.8 Develop Junior Ranger programme 9. Contribute to the image of protected areas and tourism in Georgia Use logos of APA and GNTA on all communication tools and 9.1 promotion activities Participate actively on all promotion events of APA and as 9.2 many as possible on those of GNTA Develop and use typical product/souvenir representing Imereti 9.3 Increase the caves, nature and Georgia perception of »Inspire« film makers, artists, etc to use Imereti caves in their 9.4 protected areas in artistic works Georgia as tourism Support worldwide knows Georgian sportsmen/sportswoman/ 9.5 destination team Propose presence and participate in cultural, economic and 9.6 political delegations abroad or in Georgia Propose to host cultural, economic and political high level 9.7 delegation to Georgia in Imereti caves 9.8 Propose typical product/souvenir to state protocol of Georgia

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 68

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

13 EFFECTS OF TOURISM DEVELOPMENT IN IMERETI CAVES

13.1 Economic and social effects

Estimations and forecast show that Imereti caves PA could generate at least 4,5 million GEL revenues from comercial – mainly tourism activities in 2020. This is 4.5 times more than in 2013 but with less than 2 times more employees than in 2013. The increase of revenues will be origined from the increase of number of visitors (2 times more), consumption of newly developed tourism products and services in addition to natural attractions with entrance fees and with efficient management of natural attractions, reserves and monuments and tourism - hospitality facilities.

The revenues from tourism will substantially contribute with financial resources to APA's budget and will contribute to improve the financial sustainability of APA and PAs in Georgia, in order to protect and manage more efficiently protected areas.

Additionally to this direct increase of revenues, there is a wide range of indirect economic effects of tourism visits in Imreti caves PA. Consider very simply that the majority of these visitors are arriving to Imereti caves with TOs, small buses and vans and their revenues are consecuently bigger. The visitors in Imereti caves make a stop in the restaurant and shops, visit another attractions and some of them overnight in the region, spend time visiting other places (like museums), using other services (wellness in Tskaltubo, sports with bikes, etc..). All these suppliers and service providers benefit from visitors of Imereti caves,not to mention that also producers of agricultural and food products earn when selling their products to restaurants or directly to visitors.

Indirect effects of tourism in Imereti caves PA generate also other business opportunities – to develop new products, souvenirs, offer guiding to different parts of the region, participate in events, etc. With these business opportunities are created not only employment opportunities for the local population, but also, new opportunities for the young people to study and to work in tourism and tourism related activities, etc.

This wide range of tourism direct and indirect effects contributesas well to better cooperation between various stakeholders from private-business and from public-administration sector.

With investment in tourism, in infrastructure – roads, electricity, waste management and information and communication technology, in culture, education and knowledge, in health prevention and care, safety and security, the region becomes more developed, attractive for investors and business developers and attractive for visitors from Georgia and from abroad. Social effects of tourism development are numerous – increase of education and knowledge, broader knowledge of cultural and social differences of visitors from different parts of the world, knowledge of foregin languages, improved communication, improvement of respect of local culture, tradition and habits, increase of pride of local population on their region, attractions and values, etc.

It is important to emphasize that tourism visits to Imereti caves contribute substantially to the image of Imereti region and to its domestic and international attractiveness.

13.2 Challenges and restrictions

Imereti caves protected area administration is facing several challenges and also restrictions in implementing tourism development plan.

The most important challenges are:  How to maintain balanced tourism development and protect the nature from negative effects of tourism development  How to manage intensified tourism visits in the future and further development of tourism speleological attractions  How to meet visitors’ expectations and offer them uniques natural attractions and high quality services

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 69

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

 How to develop an efficient management and marketing team and visitors services in the still centralized PA management system  How to develop and maintain authentic image with a complex tourist offer and avoid »touristifying commercialization«  How to involve local communities and population in tourism development and to offer them business opportunities  How to contribute to tourism development in Imereti region and form »nature« as one of three pillars of tourism development in the region together with other two »culture« and »health&spa«  How to disseminate the awareness of nature and its values to numerous visitors, from pupils, to domestic and international visitors of Imereti caves PA  How to develop good practice in balanced tourism development and nature protection for transfwer to other PAs in Georgia and in Caucasus

The Imereti Caves PA Administration will have severe restrictions in implementation of tourism development plan such as:  Lack of qualified tourism, hospitality and HR professionals  Limited possibilities for decentralized decision making and management  Limited funds for investment and marketing  Limited and not enough discovered natural speleological resources for tourism development  Very loose tourism regional cooperation without stable organization  Drawbacks in regional developlment of infrastructure and business/entrepreneural environment

13.3 Monitoring of realizatio of development plan

Implementation of the tourism development plan should be regularly monitored and evaluated. This is the task of the controller that we described in the HR section of this document. During the realization of the development plan, there can be internal or/and external changes that affect the work and business results for Imereti caves PA. Based on that, monitoring should focus on:  Planned/expected results – revenues, average achieved price  Promotion and marketing activities and results – number of visitors, groups of visitors  Use of resources – HR, operational activities

Monitoring of the the upper three segments of tourism development and evaluation of gaps – differences between what was planned/expected and what is the situation at the time of monitoring gives to PA's administration the tool to react, change and improve the development performances with adoption of appropriate measures. These measures could be oriented towards an increase of revenues and visitors with marketing and towards lowering the costs of the use of resources. Adoption of strategic objectives, policy measures and actions to a changing situation are normal especially when the PA is exposed to market and competition- and tourism is strongly depenedent on the market.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 70

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

14 CONCLUSIONSAND RECOMMENDATIONS

On the basis of assessment analysis, market potentials and implementation model we can sumarize the most outstanding conclusions and give strategic recommendations for development and management of tourism in Imreti Caves Protected Area. a) There is a high and constantly increasing domestic and international demand for visiting Imereti Caves Protected Area. This demand will result on a pressure increase over the available natural and other resources, and the tourism products and services and will be a decisive factor of further tourism development. b) This increasing demand meets now well organized and equiped but rather limited natural resources of Imereti caves avaiable for tourist visits. PA must therefore provide further research of the cave system and develop new cave attractions, sites and trails and organize additional products and services for visitors. c) Sustainable tourism development must be the leading rule of tourism development in Imereti caves. It must enable balanced tourism development, protection of natural values, contribution to the development of local communities and education and awareness of the importance of nature and natural protection among visitors and population. d) Awareness rising and education of visitors of Imereti caves and especially many pupils and students among them about nature, natural values and protected areas in Georgia is part of the mission and should be one of important tasks of Imereti caves protected area administration. e) Normative restriction for tourism development in Imereti caves and protected areas in whole must be reviewed and released to enable protected areas to perform commercial activities which are supporting their basic mission, to make procurment and concession policy more flexible and to enable step by step decentralization of protected areas administration. f) Imereti caves protected area administration should manage the whole system of natural monuments and tourism facities, products and services by themselves and with their existing and new staff without giving in concession separate parts of facilties. g) Imereti caves must invest in promotion and marketing, to become internationally known natural and , to develop recognized image, to attract visitors and to assure stable financial resources for nature protection and sustainable tourism development in Imereti caves and in protected areas in Georgia. h) Marketing and sales must be especially focused on cooperation with Georgian TOs and hotels and other accommodation facilities in Tskaltubo, Black Sea cost and Tbilisi. i) To develop tourism in Imereti caves on large scale and to meet realistic but still ambitious objectives Imereti Caves PA Administration must get with plans also more responsibilities to manage the resources, capacities and market demand. This is a step by step process that APA should assist and develop as a model for other more tourism oriented PAs in Georgia. j) Management of strongly tourism oriented Imereti Caves Protected Area requires also the establishment of a strong and capable tourism & hospitality team in PAs administration. They should work on tourism marketing and sales, management of tourism accommodation, restaurant and other facilities and on relations with visitors on the site. k) Tourism development and image building must be based on high quality products and services, satisfaction of the visitors’ expectations and strategic development of tourist attractions and sites that provide unique experiences to the visitors. From this point of view, Imereti Caves Protected Area which includes now cave system and adventurous Okatse canyon (with plans for further tourism development of Martvili canyon) should be touristically 2 types of products, with 2 different images attracting 2 different target groups of visitors. Therefore, it would be reasonable to manage these 2 sites by two different administrations. l) Imereti Caves Protected Area must establish a strong cooperation with the emerging tourist health&spa resort in Tskaltubo and with the Imereti region, in order to use the synergy of 3 main tourist attractions/resources of the region: nature, health & spa and culture. m) Tourism is bringing many benefits to Imereti caves protected area but has limited benefits for local communities. Imereti caves PA administration, municipality and international

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 71

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STR A T E G Y - F INAL

organizations should promote and provide local communities and population with business opportunities arising from more and more visitors to the caves. n) Research work of cave system and natural resources, safety and safety risks, sustainability parameters and visitors satisfaction must accompany tourism development in Imereti caves. o) Nature protection, infrastructure development, research and awareness rising about the values of the nature among visitors will still require public financing and/or support of international donor organizations. Therefore, Imereti caves PA administration and APA should prepare and propose projects to attarct these financial resources.

ÖSTERREICHISCHE BUNDESFORSTE AG 72

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - DRAFT

15 BASIC LITERATURE AND SOURCES

Main documents and sources used in the project implementation:

1. Action plan for tourism development in Imereti region; Gigauri Lali & Eka Devidze; 2013 2. Assessment of Ecotourism Potentials in Georgia; IUCN; 2008 3. Agency for Protected Area Report 2007 – 2012; APA; 2013 4. Biodiversity Planning Support Programme. Guide to Best Practices for Sectorial Integration: Integrating Biodiversity into the Tourism; UNEP; 2012 5. Demand for , Travel in Protected Areas – Dimension of Tourists’ Ecological Behaviour; Minciu R., Padurean M., et all; Tourism Review; 2012 6. Effective tourism product development in PAN parks region; PAN Parks Foundation; 2007 7. Georgian Tourism in Figures 2013; Georgian National Tourism Administration; 2013 8. Indicators of Sustainable Development of Tourism Destinations; UNWTO & UNEP; 2004 9. ITB World Travel Trends Report, 2012/2013; Messe Berlin GmbH; 2012 10. Legends of nature – Georgia; KfW; 2013 11. Preferences of Europeans towards Tourism. Flash Eurobarometer 392; European Commission; 2014 12. Sustainable Tourism in Protected Areas: Guidelines for Planning and Management; World Commission on Protected Areas and IUCN; 2002 13. Sustainable tourism development and action plan for the city of Kutaisi and Imereti region; WB; 2010 14. The European Charter for Sustainable Tourism in Protected Areas; EUROPARC; 1995 15. Travel Trends Report 2013; ABTA; 2012 16. Tourism development marketing plan for Imereti; Georgian National Tourism Administration; 2012

Project team received during the work also working materials and documents and used numerous websites: > Mission reports of OEBF twining project relating to some PAs > Development and Management plan > Imereti development, marketing and action plan > Tourism guide books and brochure fro Imereti > Internal document of Tskaltubo resort rehabilitation > Statistical data from APA, GNTA and TIC Kutaisi

73

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - DRAFT

16 ANNEXES

Annex 1 WORKING MATERIA ABOUT IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA COLLECTED DURING ASSESSMENT PHASE

Table of Contents

1 IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA ...... 75 1.1 BASIC PROFILE of Protected Area: IMERETI & PROMETHEUS CAVES ...... 75 1.2 ANALYSIS OF IDOLS, COMPETITIORS AND STAKEHOLDERS ...... 80 1.3 SWOT ANALYSIS for Protected Area ...... 82 1.4 ANALYSIS OF EXISTING AND POTENTIAL TOURIST PRODUCTS ...... 86

74

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

1 IMERETI CAVES PROTECTED AREA Tourism development and management plan for Imereti caves will be prepared separately from Tourism development strategy for PAs in Georgia as a sample for other Pas. 1.1 BASIC PROFILE of Protected Area

BASIC INFORMATION

Status (NP, PA,..): ProtectedArea A Strict Nature Reserve, a ManagedNaturalReserveand 19NaturalMonuments are included in ImeretiPAs: 1. Sataplia strict nature reserve 2. Sataplia Managed reserve 3. Promethe Cave natural monument 4. Tetri Cave natural monument 5. Khomuli Cave natural monument 6. Tsutskhvati Cave natural monument 7. Navenakhevi Cave natural monument 8. Nagarevi Cave natural monument 9. Iazoni Cave natural monument 10. Sakazhe Cave natural monument 11. Tskaltsitela Valley natural monument 12. Okatse Canyon natural monument 13. Okatse waterfall natural monument 14. Gabzaruli Lake natural monument 15. Satsurblia Cave natural monument 16. Salkota Cave natural monument 17. Didgele Cave natural monument 18. Melouri Cave natural monument 19. Bgera Cave natural monument 20. Gliana Sakazhe Cave natural monument 21. Mukhurawaterfall naturalmonument

Does PA have strict area? Sataplia Strict Nature Reserve

Surface (in ha, km2): 518.1 ha

Year of establishment of PA: ICPAs were created on the basis of Sataplia Strict Nature Reserve in 2007 by the Georgian Law on „Establishment and Management of Protected Areas of Imereti Caves“.

Accessible all year? YES , mainly from May until OctoberNOif NO, in which months:

MAP??

MAIN ATTRIBUTES/VALUES OF PA:

Complex character and includes geological, paleontological, speleological, and botanical rarities.

75

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Winter is mostly warm and dry, while summer is hot. January is the coldest month with an average temperature of 9.6° while July is the hottest month with an average temperature of 30.9 °, which is lower by 5° comparing to other regions of Imereti. Monthly average temperatures in Imereti Caves PA

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

9.6 ° 12.5° 15.6 ° 20.4 ° 25.7 ° 29 ° 30.9 ° 33.1 ° 27.1 ° 21.5 ° 11.5 ° 10.5°

Source: Imereti Caves PA administration

EMPLOYEES in PA

Total No of employees: 42 No of management: 3

No of administration: 12 No of protection: 2

No of product development: / No of marketing: 2

No of Rangers: 10 No of guides: 13

Other employees: Including the staff of the existing facilities at Okatse Waterfall, 46 people are employed. In total, up to 57 posts are planned when the new visitor centre at Okatsi Waterfall will be opened.

Do you need more employees now? YES NO if YES, how many new: Vacancy is announced on Environmental specialist, PA administration needs additional two employees - guide (in Prometheus) and PR specialist (in Sataplia, as administration office is there)

YEARLY BUDGET OF PA:

Total (GEL): approximately For tourism & commercial activities: 350.000Gel

INVESTMENT PLANS of PA (short description and value):

Investment 1 BP project with 6 Million and 700 thousand Lari (among them one mill - from state budget) for Sataplia's infrastructure – conservation of Dinosaurs steps was made, new constructions (visitor centre, cave equipment, exhibition hall, glass view point, cafe, souvenir shop, sign boards – in 2010 )

Investment 2 Kartu group – visitor centre and infrastructure in Prometheus + state budget (Budget ....)

Investment 3 Czech Development Agency – improvement of ICPA's management, investigation of caves, development ofspeleotherapy and cave monitoring system. Second phase (ongoing project) is dedicated to complete, use monitoring system and establish speleocentre.

Investment 4 Maintenance Plan – with CNF budget (shelters, marking ...)

Investment 5 11 bridges by Pan Park/Toyota Europe

Investment 6??Management Plan – EU Twinning project??

76

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

TRAINING NEEDS:

Management Procurement management, management in decentralization (as it is expected)

Branding, Marketing & SalesYes.

Hospitality & Services Yes, English and Russian languages upgrading courses for guides

Tourist guiding Guide and manage tours for guides, rangers

Sustainable energy use

Environmental waste management

Safety and risk management

Conservation & protection

Others Project preparing & writing – there was no any serious training course in this field so far (Training by TJS for visitor services, early 2014)

MAIN PRODUCT FOR VISITORS

Accommodation Kutaisi, Tskaltubo (< 50 beds) outside the city of Kutaisi. There are three houses in village Banoja (where the administration building exists) which are sometimes rented by tourists; but service conditions are too far from touristic demands.

Food&Beverages Kutaisi, Tskaltubo – picnic places were not considered from the beginning in order to involve local population and give them possibilities to develop catering services. However this is a demanded issue and could be developed in villages - on the way to Sataplia (both from Kutaisi and Tskaltubo) at local families or nearby where local food could be provided.

Trails NO (?? There is a small trail in Sataplia, or is this not considered a "real trail"?

Events: local celebration in Kutaisi – Kutaisoba (with traditional Georgian dances and folk music, visitors wear traditional clothes, choxa)

Market place NO and is preferable

Others fieldequipment including mobiles at Prometheus STORY TELLING: According to Greek mythology Jason stole Golden Fleece from Kutaisi. The City was the capital of the ancient Kingdom of Colchis. Archaeological evidence indicates that the city functioned as the capital of the kingdom of Colchis as early as the second millennium BC. It is widely believed by historians that when Apollonius Rhodius was writing about Jason and the Argonauts and their legendary journey to Colchis, Kutaisi/Aia was the final destination of the Argonauts and the residence of King Aeëtes.

77

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

EQUIPMENT

Transportation: 4 high wheel based vehicles + 1 sedan and 1 bus (mainly for their staff) + train with 20 seats

IT/Wi-Fi, touch screens, audio guides – touch screen monitors both in Sataplia and Prometheus No Wi-Fi, audio guides were recently invented in Prometheus and will be developed in Sataplia soon (Rati and ICPA staff are working on texts which will be translated in English and Russian)

MICE /beamers, speaker system: Beamers are available, while speaker system is not. Conference rooms are designed for 50 persons in both places.

Others:Souvenir shop and cafe management is given to private (concession agreement with Kutaisi business people) sector for 10 years. They were rented by auction recently (as a result 11% from revenue from Sataplia and 52% - from Prometheus)

VISITORS to PA

Total: nearly 150 000 in 2013: Foreign: in 2013 Sataplia 72.421 and Sataplia – 23% Prometheus 73.467 Prometheus 34%

Overnight visitors: on PA territory< 2 1 day visitors: >90% %

From which foreign countries: Ukraine, Israel, Poland, Russia

Main motifs for visit: InMay – mostly school excursions; and individuals from June until October

Satisfaction with what: Nature

Dissatisfaction with what Guide service, catering service, product, water, toilets – there is no running water in Sataplia.

What do visitors propose/recommend? Excursion, cafe, souvenir shop, boat in Prometheus

Average expenditures per person (GEL): No data provided

MAIN PARTNERS – STAKEHOLDERS of PA (Name key partners and their activity)?

Thereare agreements with 35 TOs (guide does not pay any entrance fee and they do not stand in queue). Hotels, guesthouses, catering, schools/institutions, TIC in Kutaisi, municipalities No common events or activities were developed yet!

COOPERATION WITH OTHER Pas and ASSOCIATIONS (which and on which area)

Ajameti Sanctuary – individual consultations are In Georgia: permanently made

78

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

In Armenia and Not yet Azerbaijan

Other countries and I.S.C.A – International Show Caves Association; Czech Caves internationalorganizations Association

OTHER COMMENTS, IDEAS, PROPOSALS…

 Family type businesses are preferable to be developed – in villages around Caves and in village Gordi  Local product marketing place preferable around PAs  Rural/farm tours around Prometheus village  »Special day« or festival is preferable to arrange annually by all stakeholders as a marketing /capacity development tool (involvement of local population around PA in preferable)  8 trails around Prometheus Cave are under investigation and should be developed there  Transportation service is currently an issue. At this time Taxi (without A/C) from Kutaisi costs 35 Gel to Sataplia; 60 Gel to Prometheus which is expensive for locals and not easily accessible for tourists (no information about the service, taxi places, etc.)  Sataplia should be bordered (fenced?) due to cows from around villages. Thank you for your cooperation!

JanezSirse: [email protected] Lela Khartishvili: [email protected]

79

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

1.2 ANALYSIS OF IDOLS, COMPETITIORS AND STAKEHOLDERS

IDOLS: Which PA (in Georgia and abroad) is the best for comparison? And why?

Czech Republic – administration building small but very informative and well equipped with touristic materials, souvenirs and exhibitions. There were accommodation rooms for guides. Building was simple and impressive.

COMPETITORS: Who are competitors to PA? And Why? In which areas

Martvili – GochKadili Canyon, It has good offers for canyoning and hiking. Toba Lake is impressive for camping.

KEY STAKEHOLDERS: Who are main stakeholders to cooperate with PA?

1. Hotels and guesthouses in Tskaltubo and Kutaisi 2. Among 10 Tskaltubohotels, three has own therapy ACCOMMODATION (hotels, Tskaltubo resort and hotels are very imoportant for Imereti B&B, camps, huts…) caves. All together there is about 1.350 bedsavailable in 2012 (by GNTA)

Restaurants, Cafees

FOOD & BEVERAGE Some families in Village Kumistavi developed restorants/cafes for (restaurants, bistros&bars) Prometheus caves visitors. Some families in village Gordi are also ready to develop catering services/offers (especially families living close to visitor centre).

SPORT ACTIVITIES (summer&winter; Not yet indoor&outdoor)

Bagrati Cathedral (UNESCO World Heritage Site) Gelati Monastery(UNESCO World Heritage Site) Motsameta Church Geguti Palace, which was one of the residences of Georgian monarchs "OkrosChardakhi", Georgian Kings’ Palace Pantheon, where many notable citizens are buried Tskaltubo ethnography (local lore) museum Museums of Georgian writer Niko Lortkipandize and linguist CULTURE ACTIVITIES GiorgiAkhvlediani (museums, galleries, concerts, festivals…) Museums:  Kutaisi State Historical Museum  Kutaisi Museum of Sport  Kutaisi Museum of Martial Art  Museum of ZakariaPaliashvili  Kutaisi State Historical Archive  Kutaisi State Scientific-Universal Library  David Kakabadze Fine Art Gallery  Art Salon in Kutaisi

80

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Theatres:  Kutaisi LadoMeskhishvili State Academic Theatre  Kutaisi MelitonBalanchivadze State Opera House  Kutaisi IakobGogebashvili State Puppet Theatre  Cinema and Entertaining Centre “Suliko” 

SACRAL, SPIRITUAL & RELIGIOUS CENTERS Close to Gelati, Motsameta Monasteris, Bagrati Cathedral (churches, monasteries...)

HEALTH & WELLNESS Tskaltubo – three hotels provide with massage and min ACTIVITES (medical, health, procedures. There is one renovated bath (#6) which is used by spa, climate...) visitors

CASINOS & ENTERTAINMENT Two casinos on the way to Tskaltubo – Black Sea and three (casinos, music& dance, electronic casinos in Tskaltubo Town shows…)

CONGRESS, FAIRS (congress, meetings, fairs capacities and Yes, in both administration building organizers…)

Honey shop in front of the entrance of Prometheus WINE & FOOD PRODUCTS cave;However, local community has ability to offer also other (wine, water, juices, products: bread, cheese, fruit, water, wine, vodka. agricultural&food products…) Sataplia means Honey place – right marketing should be done to promote Sataplia and local product (Tapli /honey) form this place

OTHER PRODUCTS & Few handmade souvenirs (glasses with vodka), embroideries are SOUVENIRS (for daily use and developed. souvenirs: books, DVDs, crystal, leather…) is needed – none exists at this moment.

Souvenir shops, however not sufficient product and high taxes. SHOPS (shopping centres, open markets...) APA's interest rate (from revenue) in Prometheus is 52% and in Sataplia -11%. Both souvenir shops are rented by auction.

TIC – TOURIST INFORMATION New TIC is opening in Tskaltubo – support of World Bank and CENTERS GNTA.

TOUR OPERATORS & TRAVEL There is a tour operatori company “Wonderland” based in Kutaisi, also small AGENCIES travel agency “Corena” in Gelati. Main target is Poland –due to new cheap flights Warsow - Kutaisi

No any local networks or initiatives. ASSOCIATIONS, MARKETING There is agro touristic association in Gelati but has no ORGANIZATIONS, NGOs (trade contact/relation with Imereti Caves. associations, reservation systems, design& marketing Guides are familiar with Ecotourism association of Georgia and agencies, NGOs…) have been investigating some canyoning trails in Okatse and Martvili (not connecting to Imereti Caves PA) together.

81

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

1.3 SWOT ANALYSIS for Protected Area

STRENGTH of Protected Area WEAKNESSES of Protected Area

 High natural, cultural, historical value  Geographic location, very central, connecting Western and Eastern Georgia  Caucasus and the Black Sea proximity  Great Silk Road passed on Imereti  International route Tbilisi – Batumi, axis toward other countries  No tours scheduled  Close to the main road-international highway  Long waiting times to enter the cave  Lack of service skills, especially guide Good road and air accessibility   Lack of trained and experienced human  Close to the international airport Kutaisi resources (especially guides: so far there (Kopitnari), bus and train station (19 km) are 6 guides that guide at least 6 groups per day (total/ each): walking distance 8-10 km  Close to famous resort for post-Soviet per day countries Tskaltubo and Kutaisi  Infrastructure – visitor centre is big but not  Mild climate, picturesque nature used  No places for tourists to rest  Cool place in summer  No places for visitors that are not allowed  Clean environment /waiting to enter the cave (children and  Distinguished landscape full of caves and accompanying parents) canyons  Reservations except TO's groups are not  Hospitable people with interesting organic available farming  Lack of promotional material for sale  Fair recognition: visited by 150 000 visitors (except APA's maps on different PAs are in 2013. Prometheus #1 destination place available) (visited 75 000 > tourists) in the region  Limited number of visitors / Restriction due  Visitor centres, audio guides available to capacity per day in Prometheus (40  Developed product – 1.400 m. cave trail persons per group, which starts every 15 with six halls in Prometheus plus 380 m. minutes) water trail by boat (moderate difficulty)  High-pressure from tourists (sometimes  Sataplia developed some touristic products: more than limitation) 3.3 km., 2 hrs, pedestrian; rather easy trail.  No attention/consideration in tourism Trail to visit the conservation building for infrastructure for disabled people dinosaur footprints, the unique karst cave,  Lack of animation and interpretation in exhibition hall, Colchic Forest, and the wild tourist sites bee habitat area. Particularly suitable for families and particularly Sataplia – a favourite among children  Prometheus has the main attraction – the cave and boat trail as an exit option for visitors  Other offers developed the civil marriage signing ceremony; conference hall in both places.  Local population around caves is motivated STRENGTH of broader area - destination WEAKNESSES of broader area - destination

 UNESCO sites – Bagrati, Gelati  Poor Infrastructure (Public/ private  Second largest city of Georgia - Kutaisi transport, itineraries)  Region (Kutaisi) is connected to the main  The public transportation to key tourism railway and highway lines of Caucasus sites such as Gelati, Sataplia, etc. are very  Recognition of resort Tskaltubo limited  The quality and variety of food, wines and especiallysparkling wine  Lack of transport facilities (in villages,  The peoples hospitality as well as their regions)

82

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

traditions and folklore  Bus stations are scarce and service  New popular trail to Martvili (Samegreli information is limited region) which arises tourist flows to this  Facility areas are lacking in most of tourism direction and extreme tourism itself sites: for example, food and beverage structures, hygienic services, shopping areas, etc.  Insufficiently skilled service staff  Lack of sign boards, especially from Tskaltubo  WC (however there is a building possibility within GNTA/WB project)  No activities for tourists at the evening time  Local people are not involved in tourism development activities – catering, guiding, product selling, etc.  Lack of traditional product packaging and no labelling  Insufficient marketing  No statistics at regional and local level  Lack of services for persons with disabilities  Low level of service (on a regional level)  Lack of accommodation in communities  Poor hotel conditions and lack of accommodation services  Insufficient entertainment offer;  Lack of tourist guides, souvenir shops (handcraft articles, souvenirs, maps, guides, leaflets, etc.);  Lack of leisure service for residents;  25 travel agents registered in the region but only very few are active  Poor brand image  Insufficient road network and tourist signalization  Lack of some bicycle tracks in the city  Language barrier, few foreign languages spoken  Weak management on a regional level  The lack of entrepreneurshipand the ignorance of the populationregarding tourist activities directly affect the structure of the tourism sector  Lack of international level accommodation: there is no presence of international chains of hotels  Difficulty to find information on the existing possibilities. There is scarce information available, not only in guides, but also on the Internet or other information sources  Inexistence of a structured tourist product  No timetables or map available for tourists

83

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

OPPORTUNITIES of Protected Area THREATS of Protected Area

 Good possibilities to travel around surrounding areas by horses, bicycles and by foot. 8 trails around Prometheus caves are investigated  Trails with one camp site (for biking and hiking) connecting caves can be developed:  Tskaltubo – Dzedzileti (7-8 km)  Tskaltubo – Dzedzileti – Okatse (20 km)  Tskaltubo – Dzedzileti – Okatse – Matvili (25 km)  The government plans to establish a PA in Racha-Lechkhumi and cooperation possibility  Possibilities to develop agro/rural tours  Possibility to develop traditional product /souvenirs (made by stone, honey, especially in Sataplia).  Developing canyoning recreational facilities  To develop other caves and deviate tourist  Unskilled guides for canyoning, additional demands/groups training is necessary  in Caves, especially for  Unsafety conditions in Canyon in Okatse Tskaltubo visitors where 80% arrives to during different weather conditions (regular region for medical treatments check of water level etc.)  To develop short tour program for disabled people  Intensive cooperation with local media: “Kutaisi”, “ImeretisMoabe”, “PS”, “AkhaliGazeti”, "KutaisuriVersia", "Chveneburebi" (Journal); Scientific Journal “Gantiadi”; TV: "Rioni"; Radio: "DzveliKalaki" (oldCity)  Potential resources for PA: SolkotaCave, SarkumaliCave, GumbriCave SatsurbliaCave, SatevziaCave (Khoni), Deviskhvreli (village Lashe), Sagvarjile (Terjola), ShvalietiCave (Kvirila Valley), DarkvetisEkhi, MgvimeviCave, SamgleCave, SamertskhleCave, SatobaviCave, SadzrokhiaCave, Sachinke Cave(research “Physical Geography of Imereti)

 OPPORTUNITIES of broader area –  THREATS of broader area – destination destination  Second airport development (4 km from Kutaisi) for private flights  Prior place as a tourism destination for Georgian government and international donors (World Bank projects). - The world Bank supports regional development in  Political instability in the region and broader Georgia. Imereti region is part of it. The area project covers two broad areas -  Migration of the population Infrustructure Investments and Institutional  The passive attitude of local population and Management. The project supports GNTA little interest toward the tourism economy capacity development and the Municipal development Funds in the region. DMO and linkages with other regional institutions is established.  WB/GNTA implement new project in Imereti where rehabilitation of touristic sites in

84

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Tskaltubo has been developed  It is planned to Tourist Information Centre, bike rental point and camping site (80 ha) in Tskaltubo central park. This is a good example of PPP – potential of bike tours exists, government contributes with place and private sector will manage touristic services  Eco and agro tourism products development  Possibility to arrange day trips and 2-3 day programs /jeep tours to Lechkhumi, Lower Svaneti), Svaneti and Upper Imereti regions. You can get in 2 hours to Svaneti region – one of the most popular touristic place. The distance from Tskaltubo to Ushguli is 145 km  Strengthen the potential of cooperation with Gelati Academy of Sciences, established in the 12th century by King David IV. There is also one of the most important educational centres in modern Georgia, Akaki Tsereteli StateUniversity, established in 1930.  Strengthen the cooperation with Kutaisi State University’s Tourism Division (Faculty of Business, Law and Social Sciences) - students in Tourism Management academic program, in Business Administration (Module Tourism Management), in Resorts’ Tourism academic program  Product development with Vani museum  Offering diverse tourism products and service improvement  Strengthening the management of small and medium enterprises  The proper use of the potential of agriculture and agro-industrial sectors  Offering vocational education and trainings within communities  Traditions and values protection  Mobilization and involvement of local people in tourism infrastructure rehabilitation processes  Developing a special Cluster for sustainable Tourism Businesses by means of a Business Incubator  Development of Quality labels & Eco labels  International investors attraction  Incentivize a DMO creation Origin of persons answering this questioner

85

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

1.4 ANALYSIS OF EXISTING AND POTENTIAL TOURIST PRODUCTS

Existing tourist products in PA:

 1.420 m walking and 380 m boat tour in Prometheus  3.300 m in Sataplia area  walking tour to Okatse& panoramic walk way over the canyon

Existing main tourist products in broader area – destination:

 Cultural tour to visit Gelati, Motsameta Monasteries, Bagrati Cathedral  Jeep tours to Lentekhi – Ushguli and Tskaltubo – Ambrolauri - Terjola  Tskaltubo health resort is in the process of rehabilitation supported by WB and will represent important tourism resort in Imereti region

Potential tourist products in PA:

 Extreme tours  Camping sites around Prometheus and Okatse  Enhance of local initiatives around Okatse and Prometheus –offering catering, min water, camping accommodation services  Bike tours  Extreme tours can be developed – 8 trails around Prometheus canyon are already investigated. Documentation/reportsexist - one of them starts from the place where the first cave was discovered. It will be not lightened – 430 m. Documents, permission should be regulated to start canyoning tours  There are 7 interesting caves, among which one was investigated by Czech cave association and recommended to develop speleotherapy. Infrastructure is under development.  Bike tours which go to Prometheus from Tskaltubo (well developed resort) and Kutaisi, also to Sataplia from both places are subject to develop (municipality plans with GNTA)  Offers for disabled people  There are possibilities to develop optional trails around Sataplia PA (proper investigation and planning needed)  Family touring & adventure (bike parks)  Soft nature (relax) products  Picnic and wine tasting with local producers  Hiking  Trekking  Canyoning  Caving  Horse riding  Walking  Nature photography  Dinner with typical food of the region in the caves  Caving spa: health care & spa packages (Speleotherapy, using caves environment to benefit pulmonary diseases; spa treatments for circulatory, nervous, muscular and skin diseases  Meditation day  Quit smoking week in PA  Shuttle service from Tskaltubo/Kutaisi with booking possibilities there?

Potential main tourist products in broader area – destination:

 Local population is more actively involved in tour business and they could develop rural/farm tours  Tskaltubo is as a spa resort with a past glorious reputation still enduring in many countries  There were 10 000 beds in 22 hotels with 150 000 holiday-makers during Soviet period in

86

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Tskaltubo  Old hotels have potential to be renovated. Municipality intends to invite investors as soon as rehabilitation works (road, central park maintenance end etc.) are finished. They will announce tender with favourable conditions for investors in order to restore old buildings and re-establish Tskaltubo as it was during old times  Besides medical treatments diverse excursion can be developed to Prometheus (5 km), Sataplia (6 km), Okatse (30 km), Martvili (40 km) and Khvamli (50-60 km)  Ballet Festival in Kutaisi, with shows, evenings, dinners, excursions, wine tasting, etc.)  Leisure and natural experiences area: Sairme and Nunisi  Gorda Canyon experience with information centre  Sport & Adventure in Chiatura area (climbing, downhill biking, canyoning, paintball, etc.)  Myths, legends and history related to Imereti (Golden Fleece, the Kolkhis, etc.) still produce interest in western culture  Religious Touring  Disabled Touring  City breaks in Kutaisi  Health (maternity treatments, give birth in water, rejuvenation spa, …) and wellness packages (vine therapy, baths, cosmetic treatments,…)  Sairme package: Sairme water has got unique healing properties and it is used for curing many diseases including: diseases of nervous system, cardio vascular  Meetings and incentives  Fairs & Events  Gastronomy & Wine (wine routes, learning experience- gastro courses, collaboration with local people in the whole wine making process, taking home own wine)  Picnic and wine tasting with local producers  Katshki pillar  Chiatura industrial area  Rural wine cellars (Qoreti, Ivantsminda villages, Sachkhere)  Mobile apps for tours  River tour  Archaeological tour  Best panoramic view tour  Gastronomy tour  Traditional market tour  Gardening & learning experience (traditions and crafts)

87

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Annex 2 ILLUSTRATION OF TOURISM EXISTING AND POTENTIAL PRODUCTS FOR IMERETI CAVES AND OKATSE CANYON

SPORTS & ADVENTURES

Biking Tours and Biking Events Parks organize biking tours with developed standards:well-signposted biking tours and trails, maps of biking tours and biking trails, dedicated accommodation for bikers (hotels, campsites and tourist farms), biking guides, bike hire, bike repairs and at least one bikers’ information point. Parks are offering and attracting several recreational biking competitions and top-level international competitions.

BIKING TOURS BIKING TOURS BIKING EVENTS

Horseback riding tours Experiencing parks from the saddle is a pleasure usually offered by PA stakeholders. Trips are organized to follow guides into meadows and forest or to ride in the landscape parks.

HORSEBACK RIDING HORSEBACK RIDING HORSEBACK RIDING TOURS TOURS TOURS

88

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Climbing is the activity of using one's hands, feet, or any other part of the body to ascend a steep object.

CLIMBING CLIMBING CLIMBING

Abseiling, also called rappelling, is the controlled descent down a rock face using a rope. Climbers use this technique when a cliff or slope is too steep and/or dangerous to descend.

RAPPELLING RAPPELLING RAPPELING

A Zip Line consists of a pulley suspended on a cable, usually made of stainless steel, mounted on an incline. It is designed to enable a user propelled by gravity to travel from the top to the bottom of the inclined cable by holding on to, or attaching to, the freely moving pulley.

ZIP LINING ZIP LINING ZIP LINING

Paintball is a sport in which players compete, in teams or individually, to eliminate

89

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Archery is the art, practice, or skill of propelling arrows with the use of a bow. It can be organised as a trails or a tournament.

ARCHERY ARCHERY ARCHERY

Adrenalin Park activities are appropriate for individuals or different groups (schools, business groups or athletes and sport teams). High Ropes Course can contains more elements, (usually 8m above ground): giant swing, high beam, individual exercises, team exercises, climbing wall.

ADRENALIN PARK ADRENALIN PARK ADRENALIN PARK

SPORTS& ADVENTURES: WATER BASED

Canyons that are ideal for canyoning are often cut into the bedrock stone, forming narrow gorges with numerous drops, beautifully sculpted walls, and sometimes spectacular waterfalls.

90

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

CANYONING CANYONING CANYONING

Freshwater / Cave diving is a type of Scuba diving with further risks. It usually completed in a Freshwater lake but often in a River or Cave. Despite being a potentially dangerous activity it can be rewarded with interesting marine life and even in some areas extremely high visibility, which can often be found in Caves.

DIVING DIVING DIVING

ADVENTURE & SPORTS: WINTER

Ice climbing is the activity of ascending inclined ice formations. Usually, ice climbing refers to roped and protected climbing of features such as icefalls, frozen waterfalls, and cliffs and rock slabs covered with ice refrozen from flows of water.

ICE CLIMBING ICE CLIMBING ICE CLIMBING

Teambuilding and motivational meetings in Cave

91

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Teambuilding package includes fun problem-solving, such as treasure hunts. Under the expert guidance of experienced analysts, you can encourage teamwork, promote collective motivation and study reactions to unexpected situations.

CAVE CAVE CAVE TEAMBUILDING TEAMBUILDING TEAMBUILDING

Therapeutic riding is also being developed in parks. This form of riding is designed in particular for those with special needs, and is a combination of medicine, education and sport.

THERAPEUTIC THERAPEUTIC THERAPEUTIC RIDING RIDING RIDING

The Segway Personal Transport is a two-wheeled, self-balancing, battery-powered electric vehicle that visitor might use for their trips within NP/PA.

SEGWAY TOURING SEGWAY TOURING SEGWAY TOURING

Sunset / sunrise tours offers different kind of activities during sunrise or sunset (kayaking, hiking, meditation, etc.)

92

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

SUNSET TOURS SUNSET TOURS SUNSET TOURS

Accessibility Trails for disabled people offers educational, relaxing or soft sport activities in NPs.

BARRIER FREE BARRIER FREE BARRIER FREE TRAILS TRAILS TRAILS

Playground trails for children can be organised as a trail or separate area within the park area.

PLAYGROUND PLAYGROUND PLAYGROUND

EDUCATION

93

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Botanical Tours offers interpretation of flora and fauna of the selected area and is appropriate for individuals or groups.

BOTANICAL TOURS BOTANICAL TOURS BOTANICAL TOURS

Herb tours Herb tours are offering knowledge on how to pick herbs with expert gardening advice.

HERB TOURS HERB TOURS HERB TOURS

94

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Geological Tours offers interpretation of the geology in the protected areas and history.

GEOLOGICAL TOURS GEOLOGICAL TOURS GEOLOGICAL TOURS

PLEASURE

Bioenergetic Trails: Magnetic signal pulsedaction ofnatureandthe bodyrestores its energyin a natural way.

BIOENERGY TRAIL BIOENERGY TRAIL BIOENERGY TRAIL

Mediation trail usually offers a opportunity for walking meditation, spiritual contemplation and pilgrimage.

MEDITATION TRAIL MEDITATION TRAIL MEDITATION TRAIL

95

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Gong Bath Trails offers a opportunity for meditation and is appropriate for individuals and groups.

GONG BATH TRAIL GONG BATH TRAIL GONG BATH TRAIL

96

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Annex 3 EVALUATION OF ATTRACTIVENESS AND COMPETITIVENESS OF NEW TOURISM PRODUCTS AND SERVICES IN IMERETI CAVES

97

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

IMERETI CAVES: Atractiveness of main tourism products in Imereti caves PA mid 2014 (scores 1 - 10)

No. Name of tourism product

tion

TOTAL

groups) Parking

Transport Transport

The sizeof The sizeof The

importnace for product inhabitants

importance value Spots importance importance

product (for product

resource for for resource

accessible &accessible

Other tourist tourist Other

Natural value Natural or individuals

Cultural value Cultural

Acceptability of Acceptability

ATTRACTIVENESS ATTRACTIVENESS

Educational value Educational extension further destina- in supply 1. Nature Eco walking Trail 8 3 4 6 8 9 2 10 7 57 2. Prometeus cave 3 rooms 8 3 2 8 5 3 2 10 10 51 3. Satsurblia spa cave 10 2 1 3 5 4 8 10 5 48 4. Navenakhevi visitors cave 10 3 2 8 5 2 2 10 5 47 5. Melauri adventure cave 10 2 9 5 5 6 5 10 6 58 Recreation (archery, mini 7 1 7 3 4 8 2 10 9 51 6. golf, …) 7. Playground 7 1 5 5 4 8 2 10 9 51 Pleasure (bioenergy, 8 3 1 6 4 8 8 10 9 57 8. meditation, ..) 9. Nature&Art camps 9 7 3 5 5 8 2 10 9 58 10. Events 4 8 1 5 8 6 2 10 9 53 11. Wine aging & tasting 5 4 1 4 3 3 2 8 7 37

98

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

IMERETI CAVES: Competitiveness of main tourism products in Imereti caves PA mid 2014 (scores 1 - 10)

No. Name of tourism product

level level

TOTAL

visitors

Product Product product needed needed needed

employees

tion level tion for level tion for

tion to image to tion

infrastructure infrastructure

Investment in Investment

Invest-ment inInvest-ment inInvest-ment

innovativeness

HR available for for available HR

tourism product product tourism

Product satisfac- Product satisfac- Product

Product contribu- Product expectation Price

nature protection protection nature COMPETITIVENESS COMPETITIVENESS 1. Nature Eco Walking Trail 8 10 5 1 8 6 8 10 10 66 2. Prometeus cave 3 rooms 8 8 5 1 7 3 5 8 8 53 3. Satsurblia spa cave 10 10 10 1 4 3 4 10 4 56 4. Navenakhevi visitors cave 8 10 8 1 2 4 4 10 6 53 5. Melauri adventure cave 7 10 8 2 4 5 4 10 4 54 Recreation (archery, mini 10 10 7 1 9 8 9 7 7 68 6. golf, …) 7. Playground 7 7 6 1 9 8 9 7 8 62 Pleasure (bioenergy, 8 7 9 1 9 8 9 7 4 62 8. meditation, ..) 9. Nature&Art camps 8 8 6 1 9 8 9 8 7 64 10. Events 10 10 8 1 9 9 9 8 7 71 11. Wine aging & tasting 8 8 7 1 8 7 7 5 4 55

99

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Annex 4 PROPOSAL OF SELECTED INTERNATIONAL MARKETING PARTNERS AND CHANNELS FOCUSED ON NATURE AND ADVENTURE TOURISM

TOURISM FAIRS & EXCHANGES & EXHIBITONS

DATE TOURISM FAIR / EVENT CITY COUNTRY January CMT - International exhibition for caravanning, Stuttgart Germany motoring, tourism January Vakantiebeurs - Tourism and Leisure Fair Utrecht Netherland January FITUR - Feria Internacional de Turismo Madrid Spain February EMITT - East Mediterranean Istanbul Turkey and Travel Exhibition February IMTM - International Mediterranean Tourism Market Tel Aviv Israel February BIT - Borza Internazionale del Turismo Milano Italy February Outdoor - Outdoor Trade Fair London Great Britain February F.R.E.E - Interactive fair for leisure and travel München Germany February Holiday World - international travel fair Prag Czech Republic February / Utazas - Travel International Tourism Exhibition Budapest Hungary March March ITB - Internationale Tourismus Börze Berlin Germany March MITT - Moscow International Travel & Tourism Moskva Russia March UITT - Ukraine International Travel & Tourism Kiev Ukraine April AITF – Azerbaijan International Travel & Tourism Baku Azerbaijan April ARGUS Bike Festival Wien Austria April COTTM - China Outbound Travel & Tourism Market Peking China April KITF - Kazakhstan International Tourism Fair Almaty Kazakhstan May The International Birdwatching Fair of Comacchio Po Delta Park of Italy the Region Emilia Romagna August Eurobike - Holiday on Bike Düsseldorf Germany August British Birdwatching Fair Rutland Water Great Britain Nature Reserve September TourNatur - The fair for trekking and hiking Friedrichshafen Germany October ITB Asia Singapore Singapore November WTM - World Travel Market London Great Britain November EIBTM - Global Meetings & Incentives Exhibition Barcelona Spain November Tactical & Adventure Fair Eindhover The Netherlands

100

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

TRAVEL AGENCY / TOUR OPERATOR

Tour Operator / Travel Agency/ Travel Web Site Association Natural Habitat Adventures http://www.nathab.com/ Wildside Nature Tours http://wildsidenaturetours.com/ Backroads http://www.backroads.com/ VBT Bicycling Vacations www.vbt.com BikeHike Adventures www.bikehike.com Trek Travel www.trektravel.com DuVine Adventures www.duvine.com Ciclismo Classico www.ciclismoclassico.com Great Explorations www.great-explorations.com Aegea Adventures www.aegeaadventures.com Sierra Club Outings www.outings.sierraclub.org GAP Adventures www.gapadventures.com KE www.keadventure.com Butterfield & Robinson www.butterfield.com Austin-Lehman Adventures www.austinlehman.com REI Adventures www.rei.com/adventures Adventure Consultants www.adventureconsultants.co.nz Bio Bio Expeditions www.bbxrafting.com H2Outfitters www.h2outfitters.com Pure Adventures www.discoverfrance.com Country Walkers www.countrywalkers.com Classic Journeys www.classicjourneys.com The Wayfarers www.thewayfarers.com Distant Journeys www.distantjourneys.com JOURNEYS International www.journeys.travel EarthWatch Institute www.earthwatch.org iExplore www.iexplore.com Mountain Madness www.mountainmadness.com National Geographic Expeditions www.nationalgeographicexpeditions.com ROW Adventures www.rowadventures.com Explorers' Corner www.explorerscorner.com Mountain Travel Sobek www.mtsobek.com Nuturalist Journeys www.naturalistjourneys.com Baobab Expeditions www.baobabexpeditions.com Geographic Expeditions www.geoex.com Artisans of Leisure www.artisansofleisure.com Kensington Tours www.kensingtontours.com

101

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

Civilized Adventures www.civilizedadv.com Zegrahm & Eco Expeditions www.zeco.com Wild Frontiers Adventure Travel www.wildfrontiers.co.uk MIR Corporation www.mircorp.com Adventures Abroad www.adventures-abroad.com Lindblad Expeditions www.expeditions.com Natural Habitat Adventures www.classicescapes.com Classic Escapes www.intrepidtravel.com Intrepid Travel www.intrepidtravel.com Gecko's Grassroots Adventures www.geckosadventures.com TUI www.tui.com Jahn Reisen www.jahnreisen.de Alltours www.alltours.de Travelix www.travelix.de Gulet www.gulet.at Thomas Cook www.thomascook.com FTI www.fti.de ASSOCIATIONS / ORGANISATIONS DRV (Deutscher Reiseverband) www.drv.de ÖRV (Österreichischer Reisebüroverband / www.oerv.at Association of Austrian Travel Agents) WKO (Fachverband der Reisebüros) www.reisebueros.at FIT/FTI (Fédération de l’Industrie du Tourisme / www.fti-fit.be Federatie van de Toeristische Industrie) ABTTA (Association of Bulgarian Tour Operators www.abtta.com and Travel Agents) UHPA (Association of Croatian Travel Agencies) www.uhpa.hr TA (Association of Cyprus Travel Agents) www.acta.org.cy DRF (Danmarks Rejsebureau Forening / www.drf-dk.dk The Association of Danish Travel Agents and Tour Operators) FETAVE (Federation Empresarial de Associaciones www.fetave.org Territoriales de Agencias de Viajes Españolas) ACAVe (Asociación Catalana de agencias de Viajes www.acave.travel Especializdas) Spain ETFL (Estonian Association of Travel Agents) www.etfl.ee SMAL (Suomen matkatoimistoalan liitto / The www.smal.fi Association of Finnish Travel Agents) SNAV (Syndicat National des Agences de Voyages) www.snav.org HATTA (Hellenic Association of Travel and Tourist www.hatta.gr Agencies) MUISZ (Association of Hungarian Travel Agencies) www.muisz.com ITAA (Irish Travel Agents Association) www.itaa.ie

102

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

ALTA (Association of Latvian Travel Agents www.alta.net.lv FATTA (Federation of Associations of Travel & www.fatta.org Tourism Agents) Malta CTU – Montenegro Tourism Association http://www.ctu-montenegro.org/ ANVR (Algemeen Nederlands Vereniging van www.anvr.nl Reisondernemingen), The Netherlands VIRKE (The Norvegian Travel Trade Association) www.virke.no PIT (Polska Izba Turystyki), Poland www.pit.org.pl APAVT (Associação Portuguesa das Agências de www.apavtnet.pt Viagens e Turismo), Portugal ACCKA (Asociace Ceskych Cestovnich Kancelari a www.accka.cz Agentur), Czech Republic ANAT (Asociatia Nationala A Agentiilor De Turism), www.anat.ro Romania YUTA (National Association of Travel Agencies), www.yuta.rs Serbia SACKA (Slovak Association of Travel Agents), www.sacka.eu Slovakia ZTAS (Združenje turističnih agencij Slovenije, www.ztas.org g.i.z.), Slovenia SRF (Svenska Resebyråföreningen / Association of www.srf-org.se Swedish Travel Agents) SRV (Schweizerrischer Reisebüro-Verband), www.srv.ch Switzerland ABTA - The Travel Association, United Kingdom www.abta.com

CORPORATE PARTNER

ORGANISATION WEB SITE The European Outdoor Group (EOG) http://www.europeanoutdoorgroup.com/ EOCA European Outdoor Conservation Association http://www.outdoorconservation.eu/ ISCA – International Show caves Associaiton http://www.i.s.c.a.org SPELEOLOGICAL ORGANISATIONS European Speleological Federation www.eurospeleo.eu Austrian Speleological Association www.hoehle.org Belgian national federation of speleology http://www.speleo.be/ Bulgarian federation of speleology http://www.speleo-bg.org/ Croatian speleological federation http://www.speleo.hr/ Danish speleological society www.speleo.dk Verbandderdeutschenhoehlen-undkarstforscher, http://www.vdhk.de/ Germany Federacion espanola de espeleologia, Spain http://www.fedespeleo.com/ French federation of speleology http://www.ffspeleo.fr/ Finnish caving society http://caving.fi/

103

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

British caving association http://british-caving.org.uk Hellenic federation of speleology, Greece http://www.fhs.gr/ Hellenic speleological society, Greece /www.ese.edu.gr/ Hungarian speleological society http://www.barlang.hu/ Speleological union of Ireland http://www.caving.ie/ Italian speleological society http://www.ssi.speleo.it/ Speleoklubas aenigma, Lithuania http://www.speleo.lt/ Groupe speleologique luxermbourgeois, http://www.speleo.lu/ Luxembourg Speleoclub abis, Moldova http://www.speleo.md/ Speleo Nederland http://www.speleo.nl/ Norwegian speleological society, Norway http://www.speleo.no/ Caving commitee of polish alpinism association http://www.pza.org.pl/ Federação portuguesa de espeleologia, Portugal http://www.fpe-espeleo.org/ Federatia romana de speleogie, romania http://frspeo.ro/ Slovenská speleologická spoločnosť, Slovakia http://www.sss.sk/ Speleological association of Slovenia http://www.jamarska-zveza.si/ Swedish speleological society http://www.speleo.se/ Schweizerischen gesellschaft für höhlenforschung, http://www.speleo.ch/ Switzerland Speleological Federation of Turkey Ukrainian speleological association http://speleoukraine.org/

MEDIA PARTNERS

Media Web Site Active & Eco http://www.activeandeco.com/ National Geographic - Germany http://www.nationalgeographic.de/ Hike & Trekking Magazine http://www.hikeandtrekking.nl/ Outdoor Markt - Germany's first trade magazine http://www.jahr-tsv.de/ which solely focusses on the outdoor industry Outdoor Review http://www.outdoor-review.co.uk/ OUTDOORSmagic http://www.outdoorsmagic.com/ walkingontheweb http://www.walkingontheweb.co.uk/ http://www.lonelyplanet.com WildLife Extra www.wildlifeextra.com Wild Travel Magazine http://www.wildlifeextra.com/go/world/wild- travel/ Discover Wild Life Magazine www.discoverwildlife.com/ British Wildlife www.britishwildlife.com/ National Wildlife Magazine www.nwf.org

104

ASSESSING AND DEVELO PING THE ECO - TOURISM POTENTIAL OF THE PROTECTED AREAS I N G E O R G I A TOURISM STRATEGY - F INAL

TRADE PARTNERS

Partner Organisations Web Site

BSI - Bundesverband der Deutschen Sportartikel- http://www.bsi-sport.de/ Industrie e.V. IOG - Italian Outdoor Group: promotes growth of http://www.italianoutdoorgroup.it/en/home.htm mountain sports The Outdoor Industries Association http://www.outdoorindustriesassociation.co.uk/

Scandinavianoutdoorgroup http://www.scandinavianoutdoorgroup.com

Russian Outdoor Group http://www.r-o-g.ru/ru/

105