Plant-mediated interaction: a first record of thrips feeding on Hartigiola annulipes (Diptera: ) galls

Sebastian PILICHOWSKI1*, Manfred R. ULITZKA2, Radosław JAGIEŁŁO3 and Marian J. GIERTYCH1, 3

1 Faculty of Biological Sciences, University of Zielona Góra, Prof. Z. Szafrana 1, 65-516 Zielona Góra, Poland 2 Thrips-iD, Straßburger Straße 37A, 77652 Offenburg, Germany 3 Institute of Dendrology, Polish Academy of Sciences, Parkowa 5, 62-035 Kórnik, Poland *e-mail: [email protected] (corresponding author)

ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT Research note Galls formed by can act as sinks for nutrients and attract other herbivores to feed on gall tissues, which initiates interspe- Pol. J. Ecol. (2019) 67: 168-173 cific competition, sometimes nurturing the herbivorous insects and restraining the gall-inducing , particularly when this received after revision competition is plant-mediated. Here, to our knowledge, we pro- April 2019 vide the first evidence of a close relationship between a gall insect, Hartigiola annulipes (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae), and a sap-sucking, doi Liothrips setinodis (Thysanoptera: Phlaeothripidae). The thrips 10.3161/15052249PJE2019.67.2.007 were observed feeding on young H. annulipes galls, formed on the common () leaves during spring. Among randomly chosen beech trees, 100 current-year shoots were sur- key words veyed to determine the number of H. annulipes galls and the pres- ence of thrips on the leaves. Our results show that L. setinodis Cecidomyiidae specimens were found significantly more frequently on leaves in- co-occurrence fested by the galler than on uninfested leaves. The consequences of galls feeding thrips at the site of gall formation are not known yet, but it thrips can be supposed that they are unfavourable to the gall insects and Phlaeothripidae therefore could be beneficial for the host plant.

The influence of galling insects on the host’s et al. 1995, Petersen and Sandstrom 2001, biochemical properties has been shown in Qureshi and Michaud 2005) and can be af- numerous studies concerning distribution fected by environmental conditions (Foote et of galls and defensive mechanisms of the al. 2017). host plants (Petersen and Sandstrom 2001, Hartigiola annulipes (Hartig, 1839) (Dip- Koyama et al. 2004, Pascual-Alvarado et al. tera: Cecidomyiidae) is a gall midge species 2008,). Since galls may act as sinks for nu- producing one generation per year. Females trients (Koyama et al. 2004, Compson et al. lay eggs in April/May on the abaxial side of 2011, Castro et al. 2012), they may attract the common beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) leaves, other herbivores. In contrast, the galling pro- and the larvae develop in hairy, single cham- cess may also increase the defensive response bered galls occurring on the adaxial leaf side of the host plant and hence decrease the nu- (Rohfritsch 1971). trient availability, thus discouraging other During field studies, it was noticed that herbivores to feed (Koricheva et al. 1998, leaves bearing galls of H. annulipes in an Pascual-Alvarado et al. 2008), and this can early stage of development were frequently lead to a state of stand-off that promotes the visited by adult phlaeothripids (Thysano- suboptimal development of both the host and ptera: Phlaeothripidae). These thrips later the herbivore (Furstenberg-Hagg et al. 2013). on were identified asLiothrips setinodis Interspecific competition between herbivore (O. M. Reuter, 1880), a common European insects appears to be plant-mediated (Inbar species found on the bark and leaves of vari- Thrips feeding onHartigiola annulipes galls 169 ous trees (Gauss 1960, Moritz 2006, Kucharc- 15°34’20.2”E) in a managed Scots pine forest zyk and Stanisławek 2010). The fact that adults with several years old common beech trees of L. setinodis had been observed feeding on growing in the understory. Secondly, on 15- young-gall tissues (approximately 4 weeks 09-2016, 15 understory beech trees in the old, Fig. 1) raised questions about a potential same area were randomly chosen to observe relationship between these thrips and the gall whether the galled leaves bear living galls. midge. To our knowledge, this is the first time To determine the thrips species, 17 speci- such a relationship between L. setinodis and mens were collected. This material, preserved H. annulipes is described. Our observation in ethanol, was macerated in KOH (5%) and led to the following hypothesis: the thrips slide-mounted in Canada balsam according are attracted by young H. annulipes galls and to Ulitzka (2018). Species was determined ac- mainly feed on galled leaves. This hypothesis cording to Schliephake and Klimt (1979). was tested by confronting the number of galls A generalized linear model with mixed and thrips on randomly chosen beech leaves effects (GLMM, function glmer.nb (in lme4 in the place where H. annulipes are common. package), was used for modelling the rela- To determine whether beech leaves with tionship between the presence of thrips and young galls of H. annulipes are more often galls on leaves (Bates et al. 2015). The pres- chosen by the thrips, thrips were counted on ence of thrips was approved as a dependent leaves without and with galls. All leaves (up variable with a binomial response (0 – absent, to 2 m above the ground) from one hundred 1 – present), and the presence of galls was randomly chosen current-year shoots (10 per modelled as a fixed factor (nominal with two each of 10 beech trees) were observed regard- levels, 0 – absent, 1 – present). Tree and shoot ing the occurrence of thrips. If thrips were nested within trees were included as random noticed, their presence on the adaxial and factors. The model was fit by maximum likeli- abaxial leaf surface was noted, as well as any hood (Laplace approximation) and binomial noticeable feeding actions. These observa- distribution with the logit link function. The tions were carried out on 27-06-2016 between full GLMM model was compared with the 12 p.m. and 13:30 p.m. in western Poland null model containing only intercept and (Zielona Góra-Stary Kisielin, 51°55’57.0”N, McFadden ρ2 calculated (Domencich and

Fig. 1. Adult Liothrips setinodis individuals. A, C – thrips feeding on young Hartigiola annulipes galls; B – a female and mating pair on a beech leaf, D – an adult thrips feeding on a gall developing on a purple common beech tree. 170 Sebastian Pilichowski et al.

McFadden 1975). The analysis of deviance face of the leaves, 42.6 and 57.4%, respec- was conducted to test for significance (Wald tively, and 44% of the thrips were observed Chi-square test) of the fixed effect (function feeding on gall tissues. Anova(car), (Fox and Weisberg 2011). Calcu- The generalized linear model with mixed lations of the GLMM were conducted in the effects showed that the presence of thrips R environment (R Development Core Team and H. annulipes galls is positively related (ρ2 2019), and the functions and packages of = 0.30). The results indicate a significantly their origin are given in brackets. (Wald χ2 = 39.4, P < 0.0001) higher probabil- The linear regression was used to test the ity for the occurrence of at least one thrips on relationship between the mean number of an infested leaf (estimate = 3.46 ± 0.55 SE for galls and thrips occurring on leaves of each presence of galls – fixed effect) (Fig. 2). tree. The linear regression was performed in The linear regression also showed a posi- SAS JMP® 11.2.0. tive relationship between the number of galls The maximal number of leaves per shoot and the number of thrips (Fig. 3; Mean (N ranged from 3 to 8, and the mean number thrips) = 0.068 + 0.356 × Mean (N galls), P = of leaves per shoot was 4.14. A total of 277 0.0002, r2 = 0.844). thrips and 713 galls were counted, and 160 Moreover, during late-summer field ob- leaves of 414 (39%) were infested by H. an- servations in Zielona Góra-Stary Kisielin in nulipes. On three studied beech trees, no 2016, no living H. annulipes galls were found galls were noticed. The highest number of on 15 randomly chosen beech trees growing thrips (69) was counted on the tree with the in the understory. In September, the leaves highest number of galls (227). Thrips were initially bearing H. annulipes galls exhibited found on both the adaxial and abaxial sur- brown necrotic spots instead of galls.

Fig. 2. Frequencies of observed absence (0) or presence (1) of thrips (Liothrips setinodis) and galls (Hartigiola an- nulipes) on leaves. Each point represents observation from an individual leaf, n is equal to the sum of surveyed leaves with and without examined herbivores. Generally, model estimate for intercept indicated very low prob- ability for thrips occurrence (-4.08 ± 0.52 SE), but when gall was present, this probability increased significantly (estimate 3.46 ± 0.55 SE). Thrips feeding onHartigiola annulipes galls 171

Fig. 3. The linear regression test showing relationship between mean number of Hartigiola annulipes galls on the common beech leaves and mean number of Liothrips setinodis thrips found on leaves. Mean (N thrips) = 0.06784 + 0.3562 × Mean (N galls), P = 0.0002, r2 = 0.8442.

Liothrips setinodis is a sap-sucking thrips possibilities which might explain why thrips frequently found in Europe on common beech had not been found on beech leaves during trees (Kucharczyk and Stanisławek 2010). The summer observations. The common beech observations discussed here indicate that this trees are known to fight with gall-inducers by species is attracted to leaves infested by H. means of hypersensitive reaction (Fernandes annulipes. Adult thrips were observed while et al. 2003, Pilichowski and Giertych 2017) feeding on gall tissues on the adaxial leaf sur- leading to the death of a high percentage of face. According to Rohfritsch (1971), H. an- galls and larvae living inside them. Although nulipes lays eggs on abaxial leaf surface, but the reason of failure of development of the the galls are created on adaxial surface; thus, H. annulipes galls where we studied them re- the nutritive tissue forms above the . In mains unclear, it might have been connected June, the H. annulipes galls are in an early with 1) the hypersensitive reaction of the stage of development and look similar to rings host plant triggered by two herbivore species emerging from the upper leaf surface. Plant stressing the host plant; 2) hypothetical tran- galls may act as sinks by storing more nutri- sition of an endophytic fungi by L. setinodis ents and assimilates than do the surround- between beech leaves, what led to death of H. ing plant tissues (Koyama et al. 2004, Kaplan annulipes; or 3) the asymmetrical interspecific et al. 2011, Castro et al. 2012); however, the competition. Herbivores like galling-insects content of various chemical compounds can modify the nutrients flow in the host plant change during the maturation of a gall (Castro leading to local increase of nutrients what et al. 2012). It seems possible that the thrips benefits the gall tissues and developing insects are attracted by nutrients flowing to the gall inside. There might occur a competition be- tissues, supplying the gall midge larva. How- tween insects and their galls due to activity ever, it remains unclear whether the thrips of more than one galler. For example, Kaplan and galling species compete or enhance the et al. (2011) studied potential sink competi- sink effect. According to Ferrière (1958), the tion between gall-inducing nematodes and an population of L. setinodis mainly seems to be aphid species. These authors did not find any regulated by parasitoids such as Entedonas- negative impact of one species on the other. tichus gaussi (Loomans and Lenteren 1995). However, this result could be connected to the We did not study such relationship, thus we different distant organs they fed on: the nema- can only take it into consideration as one of todes galled the root, and the aphid species 172 Sebastian Pilichowski et al. is a vascular-feeding herbivore. On the other galls. Although this relationship is statistically hand, Inbar et al. (1995) proved the existence confirmed, this needs further research using of a plant-mediated interspecific competition various methods: ecological study of the co- occurring between two aphid species galling occurrence of both insect species, chemical leaves of Pistacia palaestina Boiss. Further- analysis of leaf components and field observa- more, the relationship found between those tions of the gall development. two galling aphids was assymetrical – one of It is worth noting that the relationship be- them was more successful in the influence on tween L. setinodis and H. annulipes seems to the phloem-transport of nutrients what can be advantageous for the thrips reproduction lead to a high rate of mortality of the second success. Specimens attracted by galls share species. Similarly, two aphid species (Monel- common leaves, and therefore, the chance of lia caryella Fitch, 1855 and Melanocallis cary- finding mating partners increases. aefoliae Davis, 1910) feeding on the pecan Carya illinoensis (Wangenh.) K. Koch) com- ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: The present study pete indirectly: M. caryaefoliae is able to in- was supported by the National Science Centre, crease amino acid concentrations in infested Poland (no. 2013/11/N/NZ9/00106). leaves, while M. caryella inhibits this ability (Petersen and Sandstrom 2001). The competi- tion between sap-sucking insects representing REFERENCES different species can affect their development. Nonetheless, the occurrence of certain species Bates D., Machler M., Bolker B.M., Walker S.C. together on the same plant organ can give var- 2015 – Fitting linear mixed-effects models ious outcomes, depending primarily on the using lme4 – J. Stat. Softw. 67: 1–48. species composition and stage of the develop- Castro A.C., Oliveira D.C., Moreira A.S.F.P., ment, not their population density (Qureshi Lemos J.P., Isaias R.M.S. 2012 – Source- and Michaud 2005). Furthermore, such rela- sink relationship and photosynthesis in tionships can be also influenced by the plant’s the horn-shaped gall and its host plant water-stress so they may be modified by the Copaifera langsdorffii Desf. (Fabaceae) – environmental factors (Foote et al. 2017). Lar- S. Afr. J. Bot. 83: 121–126. son and Whitham (1997) proposed that the Compson Z.G., Larson K.C., Zinkgraf M.S., competition between organs acting as natural Whitham T.G. 2011 – A genetic basis for sinks (buds) and those produced by galling in- the manipulation of sink-source relation- sects should be examined to explain distribu- ships by the galling aphid Pemphigus ba- tional patterns of phloem-feeding herbivores tae – Oecologia, 167: 711–721. on the host plant. Moreover, these authors Domencich T.A., McFadden D. 1975 – Sta- showed that such competition has an impor- tistical estimation of choice probability tant impact on the success of gall-forming functions (In: Urban travel demand: A aphids – less competing sinks ensure develop- behavioral analysis, Eds: D. W. Jorgen- ment of the remaining sinks, including galls. son, J. Waelbroeck) – North-Holland Koyama et al. (2004) found that leaves with Publishing Company, New York, pp. galls can contain a five-fold increase of amino 101–125 acids compared to ungalled leaves. Since in Fernandes G.W., Duarte H., Luttge U. 2003 our study there were more thrips feeding on – Hypersensitivity of Fagus sylvatica L. leaves with H. annulipes galls than on ungalled against leaf galling insects – Trees-Struct. leaves, we can suppose that young developing Funct. 17: 407–411. galls change the chemical content of the beech Ferrière C. 1958 – Un nouveau parasite de leaves, making them more attractive for other thrips en Europe centrale (Hym. Euloph.) herbivores such as thrips. Nonetheless, we – Mitteilungen der Schweizerischen En- suspect that the thrips may trigger defensive tomologischen Gesellschaft, 31: 320–324. mechanisms of the host plant which results Foote N.E., Davis T.S., Crowder D.W., Bosque- in mortality of H. annulipes larvae. Our paper Perez N.A., Eigenbrode S.D. 2017 – Plant describes a previously unknown observations water stress affects interactions between of thrips feeding on developing H. annulipes an invasive and a naturalized aphid spe- Thrips feeding onHartigiola annulipes galls 173

cies on cereal crops – Environ. Entomol. S. Maini, J. Riudavets) – Wageningen, 46: 609–616. Agricultural University. Wageningen, pp. Fox J., Weisberg S. 2011 – An R Companion 90–201. to Applied Regression. SAGE Publica- Moritz G. 2006 – Thripse. Westarp Wissen- tions. schaften Verlagsgesellschaft mbH, Hoh- Furstenberg-Hagg J., Zagrobelny M., Bak S. enwarsleben. 2013 – Plant defense against insect herbi- Pascual-Alvarado E., Cuevas-Reyes P., Que- vores – Int. J. Mol. Sci. 14: 10242–10297. sada M., Oyama K. 2008 – Interactions Gauss R. 1960 – Über Nahrungspflanzen- between galling insects and leaf-feeding Wechsel bei Insekten – Zeitschrift für insects: the role of plant phenolic com- Angewandte Entomologie, 45: 313–316. pounds and their possible interference Inbar M., Eshel A., Wool D. 1995 – Interspe- with herbivores – J. Trop. Ecol. 24: 329– cific competition among phloem-feeding 336. insects mediated by induced host-plant Petersen M.K., Sandstrom J.P. 2001 – Out- sinks – Ecology, 76: 1506–1515. come of indirect competition between Kaplan I., Sardanelli S., Rehill B.J., Denno two aphid species mediated by responses R.F. 2011 – Toward a mechanistic under- in their common host plant – Funct. Ecol. standing of competition in vascular-feed- 15: 525–534. ing herbivores: an empirical test of the Pilichowski S., Giertych M.J. 2017 – Gall sink competition hypothesis – Oecologia, abundance and leaf size as factors affect- 166: 627–636. ing the hypersensitive reaction in the Koricheva J., Larsson S., Haukioja E., Kein- common beech (Fagus sylvatica) – Baltic anen M. 1998 – Regulation of woody For. 23: 608–611. plant secondary metabolism by resource Qureshi J.A., Michaud J.P. 2005 – Interactions availability: hypothesis testing by means among three species of cereal aphids si- of meta-analysis – Oikos, 83: 212–226. multaneously infesting wheat – J. Insect Koyama Y., Yao I., Akimoto S.I. 2004 – Aphid Sci. 5: 1–8. galls accumulate high concentrations of R Development Core Team 2019 – R: A lan- amino acids: a support for the nutrition guage and environment for statistical hypothesis for gall formation – Entomol. computing – R Foundation for Statisti- Exp. Appl. 113: 35–44. cal Computing, Vienna, Austria. http:// Kucharczyk H., Stanisławek K. 2010 – [Thrips www.R-project.org (Thysanoptera) of mountainous areas in Rohfritsch O. 1971 – Developpement cecidi- Poland] – Wiad. Entomol. 29: 53–64 (in en et role du parasite dans quelques galles Polish, English summary). d’Arthropodes – Marcellia, 37: 233–339. Larson K.C., Whitham T.G. 1997 – Competi- Schliephake G., Klimt K. 1979 – Fransenflü- tion between gall aphids and natural plant gler (In: Die Tierwelt Deutschlands 66, sinks: Plant architecture affects resistance Ed: F. Dahl – VEB Fischer, Jena, 477pp. to galling – Oecologia, 109: 575–582. Ulitzka M.R. 2018 – Thrips-id.com – Die Loomans A.J.M., Lenteren J.C.v. 1995 – Bio- Thysanopterenseite von Dr. Manfred R. logical control of thrips pests: a review Ulitzka. Fang & Präparation, http://www. on thrips parasitoids (In: Biological con- thrips-id.com/de/sammlung/praeparati- trol of thrips pests, Eds: J.C. v. Lenteren, on/ A.J.M. Loomans, M.G. Tommasini,