Seiter Timothy 2019URD.Pdf (3.760Mb)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
KARANKAWAS: REEXAMINING TEXAS GULF COAST CANNIBALISM _______________ An Honors Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the Department of History University of Houston _______________ In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Arts with Honors in Major _______________ By Timothy F. Seiter May, 2019 i KARANKAWAS: REEXAMINING TEXAS GULF COAST CANNIBALISM ______________________________ Timothy F. Seiter APPROVED: ______________________________ David Rainbow, Ph.D. Committee Chair ______________________________ Matthew J. Clavin, Ph.D. ______________________________ Andrew Joseph Pegoda, Ph.D. ______________________________ Mark A. Goldberg, Ph.D. ______________________________ Antonio D. Tillis, Ph.D. Dean, College of Liberal Arts and Social Sciences Department of Hispanic Studies ii KARANKAWAS: REEXAMINING TEXAS GULF COAST CANNIBALISM _______________ An Abstract of An Honors Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the Department of History University of Houston _______________ In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Arts with Honors in Major _______________ By Timothy F. Seiter May, 2019 iii ABSTRACT In 1688, the Karankawa Peoples abducted and adopted an eight-year-old Jean-Baptiste Talon from a French fort on the Texas Gulf Coast. Talon lived with these Native Americans for roughly two and a half years and related an eye-witness account of their cannibalism. Despite his testimony, some present-day scholars reject the Karankawas’ cannibalism. Because of an abundance of farfetched and grisly accounts made by Spanish priests, bellicose Texans, and sensationalist historians, these academics believe the custom of anthropophagy is a colonial fabrication. Facing a sea of outrageously prejudicial sources, these scholars have either drowned in them or found no reason to wade deeper. Underneath the swamp of disinformation, historical truth is discernible: the Karankawas practiced a community- oriented, post-mortem, rare, and ritualistic cannibalism that colonizers embellished and used as a mechanism to destroy the Karankawa Peoples. Although some historians believe that “cannibal” is a term too tainted by colonial rhetoric to hold any semblance of truth, to outright deny or overlook this cultural trait washes away Native American history and agency. Fully treating First Peoples as human means that as historians we must recognize that Indians, like Europeans, had cultural practices that are considered stomach-churning. iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This thesis is made possible by my family’s love and support. Mom, Dad, and Chris, thank you. I am also fortunate to have an incredible group of mentors. A constant mentor who I followed from Alvin Community College to the University of Houston, Dr. Andrew Joseph Pegoda transformed my thinking, my writing, and my career path. I first attended Alvin Community College with a spark of interest in History. I am now leaving the University of Houston to pursue a doctorate in History. I owe that, in large regard, to AJP. Dr. David Rainbow pressed me to create clear arguments, to immerse myself in primary sources, and most importantly, to search for the larger picture in the History I produce. His guidance, his humor, and his wonderful analytical critiques are much appreciated. Dr. Matthew J. Clavin, with his remarkable ability to captivate, fanned my curiosity in colonial America and stressed the importance of writing compelling History. Dr. Mark Allan Goldberg withstood my barrage of questions and steered this thesis in a more nuanced direction. Dr. Susan Kellogg got my research on the Karankawas rolling. In March 2017, I learned about the University of Houston’s Summer Undergraduate Research Fellowship only a few days before the deadline. Lacking a mentor in the field of Native American Studies, I cold-emailed Dr. Kellogg who then met with me and agreed to act as my advisor. I could not have been more fortunate. She introduced me to several crucial texts and allowed me to explore the fascinating History of the Karankawas until I reached a subject as significant as this one. A group of artists contributed to making this thesis far more interactive and lively. Taylor C. Ferguson endured third-degree sunburns, mazes of banana spiders, and my endless v talks on the Karankawas all the while producing the impressive photographs found in this research. I am grateful to know such a resilient and talented artist. Noah D. Cain’s incredible mind also bolstered this scholarship. A natural historian and philosophizer, he allowed me to see things in wholly new ways. I gave Michelle Huang portions of my narratives and asked her “to paint whatever most interested her.” The subsequent works she created have amazed me and all others who see them. I thank Britnee Chuor, Vinh Hoang, Dr. Daniel Mendiola, Phillip Pinnell, Joshua Valentino, Samuel Holmes, Mason Patterson, George Pettigrew, Payton Guerrettaz, Livia Garza, Yazia Silva, Brady Nash, and the inaugural Mellon cohort for reading or discussing sections of my thesis and giving helpful comments and critiques. I intend to bug them in the future to read my forthcoming work. They should feel free to do likewise. I also thank Dr. Orellano Norris and Dr. Robert Ricklis for granting me interviews and for discussing details of their respective books. Dr. Karen Weber, Dr. Stuart Long, Dr. Jennifer Asmussen, and Dr. Ben Rayder at the Office of Undergraduate Research ushered me through scholarship applications, graduate applications, summer workshops, and thesis deadlines. I am thankful for all the energy they expend to help their students—such as myself—succeed. I received generous funding from the Mellon Foundation, the Summer Undergraduate Fellowship, and the University of Houston History Department. I am also appreciative of various institutions and their staff: the Dolph Briscoe Center for American History, the University of Houston Special Collections, the Rosenberg Library Special Collections, the University of Houston-Victoria Regional History Center, and the Calhoun County Museum. In particular, John Wheat and other translators at the Dolph Briscoe Center who have vi translated thousands upon thousands of Spanish colonial documents, deserve great laudation for their efforts. The scholarship of Robert A. Ricklis, Robert S. Weddle, William C. Foster, and Kelly F. Himmel guides the Karankawas’ History and this thesis. I am grateful for these historians’ masterful works and feel honored to follow in their footsteps. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS Terms ...................................................................................................................................1 “Cannibalism,” “Anthropophagy,” “Exocannibalism,” “Endocannibalism” ........................1 “History” vs “history” ........................................................................................................1 Why “Karankawas” ...........................................................................................................2 Plurals ...............................................................................................................................3 Who Are The Karankawas? ...............................................................................................3 Notes on Images and Public Scholarship ............................................................................5 Paintings ............................................................................................................................5 Photographs .......................................................................................................................5 Karankawas.com................................................................................................................6 Introduction .........................................................................................................................7 Chapter One: A Series of Abductions: Jean-Baptiste Talon ........................................... 15 Fort Saint Louis: A French Colony on the Texas Gulf Coast ............................................ 16 Encountering the Karankawas .......................................................................................... 21 The Collapse of Fort Saint Louis: The First Abduction and Adoption .............................. 23 The Spanish Discover Ft. Saint Louis .............................................................................. 26 The Talons’ Second Abduction ........................................................................................ 28 The Abduction of Jean-Baptiste Talon and Eustache Bréman ........................................... 31 The French Abduction of Jean-Baptiste Talon, Lucien Jr., and Pierre Talon ..................... 37 Jean-Baptiste Talon’s Testimony of the Karankawas’ Cannibalism .................................. 38 Critiques Against the Talon Brothers’ Interrogation ......................................................... 40 The Overall Account Demonstrates Veracity ................................................................... 41 Did the Talon Brothers Manipulate their Interrogation? ................................................... 44 Chapter Two: Characteristics of Gulf Coast Cannibalism .............................................. 52 Rare and Restricted Cannibalism ..................................................................................... 52 Cannibalism by Necessity and Cannibalism by Delectability ........................................... 61