Social Change, Women, and Work in Alberta: 1970-1993

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Social Change, Women, and Work in Alberta: 1970-1993 University of Calgary PRISM: University of Calgary's Digital Repository Graduate Studies The Vault: Electronic Theses and Dissertations 2020-01 Employing Broad Tactics: Social Change, Women, and Work in Alberta: 1970-1993 Hrynuik, Erin Hrynuik, E. (2020). Employing Broad Tactics: Social Change, Women, and Work in Alberta: 1970-1993 (Unpublished master's thesis). University of Calgary, Calgary, AB. http://hdl.handle.net/1880/111594 master thesis University of Calgary graduate students retain copyright ownership and moral rights for their thesis. You may use this material in any way that is permitted by the Copyright Act or through licensing that has been assigned to the document. For uses that are not allowable under copyright legislation or licensing, you are required to seek permission. Downloaded from PRISM: https://prism.ucalgary.ca UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY Employing Broad Tactics: Social Change, Women, and Work in Alberta: 1970-1993 by Erin Hrynuik A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS GRADUATE PROGRAM IN HISTORY CALGARY, ALBERTA JANUARY, 2020 © Erin Hrynuik 2020 ii ABSTRACT This study analyses how working women in Alberta navigated themselves throughout the change in workforce demographic in the province in the late 1980s and early 1990s. I argue that by employing a variety of tactics in advocating for themselves as full participants in the province’s workforce, the groups studied were successful in bringing the voice of women into Alberta’s labour movement. I assessed the activities and initiatives of three feminist labour activist groups in the province and found that each group was unique in how members tried to implement positive change to create a better environment for working women in the province. Through an analysis of each group’s meeting minutes, correspondence, press releases, and media attention, as well as three oral interviews, I argue that each group advocated for the rights of working women in Alberta. ii iii PREFACE This thesis is original, unpublished, independent work by the author, Erin Hrynuik. The interviews reported throughout the thesis were covered by Ethics Certificate number REB17- 0028_REN2, issued by the University of Calgary Conjoint Faculties Research Ethics Board for the project “Feminist Activism in 1970s and 1980s Calgary: Community Programs in Sexual Health Education, Labour, and Immigrant Advocacy” on March 20, 2017. iii iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This project began with my own general interest in how people – within organizations or as individuals – have tried to advocate for themselves throughout Western Canada’s history. My original project was more closely tied to a previous life of mine, in that I wanted to look at how university students at the University of Calgary advocated for themselves during the heavily studied protest era of the Long Sixties within the twentieth century. As my own life and aspirations changed throughout graduate school, so too did my research interest within this program. My project changed to reflect my post-academic life, that is, one that focuses on working women in the province of Alberta. During the initial phase of my graduate school experience, the support of my former supervisor, Dr. Paul Stortz, was instrumental in laying the foundation for my interest in completing this program. My fellow graduate school colleague, Zach Bates, provided a level of conversation and friendship that was unmatched throughout my time in this program and for that I will be forever grateful. My route to completion has been long and winding but the constant encouragement from my supervisor, Dr. Nancy Janovicek, has been one of the most significant factors in my successful completion of this program. Her unwavering support and belief in my ability to pursue this project will have a lasting impact on my life in so many ways. The three women I was fortunate enough to interview for this project provided a source of inspiration and motivation that I will always remember. Cindy McCallum-Miller, Susan Keeley, and Rosemary Brown, you are all truly role models in the history of this province, and I am grateful for the moments you were willing to share with me. iv v This project also benefitted from the academic and financial support of the University of Calgary History Department, as well as the Queen Elizabeth II Scholarship through the Faculty of Graduate Studies. More importantly, my success also stemmed from the support of my family and friends, especially my parents, who have taught me that the value of hard work and the rewards that follow it are always within my reach. This project is dedicated to the memory of my grandmother, Elizabeth Gillespie. Employed full-time throughout most of her life, she was a single mother of five children who persevered and made it through her years with a constant love for her family. Grandma Betty, for all of us whose lives you touched, thank you for planting the seeds of such a beautiful life. v vi TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................. II PREFACE .................................................................................................................... III ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .............................................................................................. IV TABLE OF CONTENTS ................................................................................................. VI CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................... 1 LITERATURE REVIEW .............................................................................................................. 4 METHODOLOGY .................................................................................................................. 16 CHAPTER 2: ALBERTA LABOUR’S ‘OLD GIRLS’ NETWORK: THE SISTERS FROM HELL .... 27 ON THE PICKET LINE: THE ORIGINS OF THE SISTERS FROM HELL ................................................... 29 “FUN” – RAISING HELL: FUNDRAISING AND BUILDING COMMUNITY ............................................ 36 ALBERTA’S OWN “GUERILLA” THEATRE? ................................................................................. 40 CONCLUSION ..................................................................................................................... 48 CHAPTER 3: ORGANIZED ACTIVISM: THE WOMEN’S COMMITTEE OF THE CALGARY AND DISTRICT LABOUR COUNCIL ...................................................................................... 50 THE WOMEN’S COMMITTEE: BEGINNINGS ............................................................................... 52 ACTION THROUGH NETWORKING ........................................................................................... 60 THE WOMEN’S COMMITTEE AND STRUCTURAL READJUSTMENT ................................................... 64 ADVOCACY AGAINST SEXUAL HARASSMENT AND VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN AND CHILDREN ........... 69 CONCLUSION ..................................................................................................................... 75 CHAPTER 4: “A FELT NEED”: ADVOCATING FOR PAY AND EMPLOYMENT EQUITY IN ALBERTA .................................................................................................................. 77 NATIONAL CONTEXT: THE ABELLA REPORT AND THE EMPLOYMENT EQUITY ACT OF 1986 ................ 79 PAY EQUITY LEGISLATION IN PROVINCIAL JURISDICTIONS ............................................................ 84 ALBERTA’S “FELT NEED” FOR LEGISLATION .............................................................................. 87 WOMEN OF THE 90S: THE PAY AND EMPLOYMENT EQUITY CONFERENCE ...................................... 89 SHIFTING PARADIGMS: RACISM, COLONIALISM, AND ABLEISM IN CANADA’S WORKFORCE ................ 92 “A BAD PAY EQUITY LAW IS NO BETTER THAN NO LAW AT ALL”: EFFECTIVE EQUITY LAWS FOR ALBERTA. 97 “EQUITY IN THE BROADEST SENSE OF THE TERM”: ALBERTA’S PAY AND EMPLOYMENT EQUITY COALITION ..................................................................................................................................... 105 CONCLUSION: “THAT FATEFUL SPRING ELECTION” AND THE END OF THE COALITION ....................... 113 CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSION ....................................................................................... 116 BIBLIOGRAPHY ....................................................................................................... 123 PRIMARY SOURCES ............................................................................................................ 123 SECONDARY SOURCES ........................................................................................................ 125 APPENDIX............................................................................................................... 129 vi vii ORAL HISTORY METHOD OF RECRUITMENT: LETTER OF INITIAL CONTACT – SAMPLE EMAIL .............. 129 ORAL HISTORY METHOD OF RECRUITMENT: PARTICIPANT CONTACT – SAMPLE EMAIL .................... 131 ORAL HISTORY INTERVIEW QUESTIONS ................................................................................. 132 CONSENT FORM ............................................................................................................... 133 vii CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION You know, I think I played a role. Maybe not a huge role, but I think that each person can make a difference. Even if it’s in a small
Recommended publications
  • Ay of Sex Charges Appealed
    QUOTABLE QUOTE "I am not a Native politician. I am a politician who is Native...." - Mike Cardinal, Alberta Social Services Minister See Page 3 January 18, 1993 America's North Leading Native Newspaper Volume IO No. 21 si .00 plus G.ST. where applicable -er_ L ir' !i1 Gambling on the odds Many Canadian bands are looking at on- reserve gambling ventures as a way to become self -sufficient. Leaders also see it as a way to increase the well -being of their people by pouring the profits back into the community. Delegates from all over North America attended a Native gaming conference in Vancouver r To receive Windspeaker 1 S in your mailbox every two weeks, just send your cheque or money ay order in the amount of of sex charges appealed $28 (G.S.T. included) to: By Cooper Langford es sary to ensure public confidence ceeding. lily criticized for handling a high WI Windspeaker Staff Writer in the important service they pro- Meanwhile, Robert Gourlay, number of cases that never get to 15001 vide." the president of the B.C. branch of trial. EDMOI TA O'Connor, former head of the the Canadian Bar Association, has Rick Miller, president of the VANCOUVER now- defunct St Joseph's residen- been appointed to review the Crown Counsel Association of tial school at Williams lake, is the Crown's handling of the case and British Columbia, defended Jones z Legal officials areappealing the highest ranking Catholic official in make the findings public. The against the attacks. He raised the stay of rape and indecent assault Canada to be charged with sex Crown lawyer's actions have been possibility that staffing levels at cr, charges against a Roman Catholic offences.
    [Show full text]
  • Calvin Ssjsffi S!
    1 122 Bussi R 253-3899 Butter M 127HunttiafTiRdNE 274-0394 i Bussi Richard E 39-Ogmo(x1>laceSE 236-0263 BUTCHERS & PACKERS Butter M 2 436 14AVNE 277-8136 B Bushfield—Butt Bussi V 307 1224 14AvSW 244-4552 Butier M D 350Dou9lasbankB3ySE 236-1658 BussiereM 278-3914 SUPPLIES Ofc Butier M J 3 59ComwairisDrNW 289-1796 Bushfield Fred A 226-0385 Bussiere Steve 109 6440CentreStN ... 275-6723 626Manito(itdSE .....287-3770 Butter M L 232 6715HunterviewDrNW .. 274-5362 BushfieM J 1311Roseha>rNW 289-7239 Bussing W A 149Ail)ourRi(l9eCircleNW. .r 241-0920 If Busy Cil 287-9424 Butier Mae 7CedunaPkSW 238-4950 Butter Mark A 286-8482 BushfieU K 493lRundleviewRdNE 280-7670 Bussiinger 8 RR5 279-9296 Fa* Line Tl&JSVTJ Butter Mark A Lawyr Bushfieid K & B RR2 226-1596 Bussikigef J lllSiivercreekGmNW 247-3916 Butchko COff 262-2812 3700 400 3AvSW 267-8192 Bushfield M M 102 5927BownessRdNW 247-8490 Bussfinger Murray W rrs 279-9504 Butchko D 281-8955 Butler Maurice L 282-9734 Bushfieid N R RR2Bitoc 226-0366 Bussiinger R A RR5 279-3144 Bushfield Rod 103 1633 26AySW .... 245-2714 Butchko Jim 3SilverdalePlaceNW 286-4676 Butter May 243aadmerPkSW 249-2907 Bussiinger R A RRS 279-9079 Butchko Jonathon ft Maureen Butter Morris G 5240BarronDrNW 284-3943 Bushfieid Walter R Balzac 226-0368 Bussiinger Wiliam rrs 236-9253 Bushfield Wayne RR2Baizac 226-0349 2615 llAvfW 282-8362 Butter P 104CastlendseRdNE 280-98S7 Bus^mger Wiliam RfiS 279-3487 Butchko S 244-8569 Bushko T IBBraeGlenCrtSW 252-0024 Buskinger Wiliam Shop RR5 279-9129 Butter Pat 2207 16StSE 233-2035 Bushman J M 123DalcaslleCloseNW ..
    [Show full text]
  • M (January 14, 1993) 1
    p PI III I |;l pi MUNICIPAL DISTRICT OF BRAZEAU NO. 77 1 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING I AGENDA 93 01 14 m (January 14, 1993) l'i 9:30 a.m. fp fl 1 £i f] MUNICIPAL DISTRICT OF BRAZEAU NO. 77 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA DATE: 93 01 14 TIME: 9:30 a.m. PLACE: M.D. Administration Building, Council Chambers Page Nos. Call to Order Present 1. Additions to the Agenda 2. Adoption of the Agenda 3. Adoption of Minutes 1-13 (a) 92 12 03 Regular Council Meeting 14 - 24 (b) 92 12 10 Regular Council Meeting 25 - 27 (c) 92 12 18 and 92 12 23 Special Council Meeting 4. Emergent Items 5. Tabled/Referred Items (a) Repayment of M.D. contribution to the Drayton Valley Curling Club Tabled from the 92 11 12 Regular Council Meeting until further information is received. (b) Public Hearings Cynthia Area Structure Plan Violet Grove Area Structure Plan Buck Creek Area Structure Plan - Land Use By-Law Amendments Joint General Municipal Plan (c) Group 2000 Initiatives 28 - 29 Report and Recommendation attached. (d) Submission and Report from the Municipal District Land Review and Policy Development Committee 6. Public Hearing 9:45 a.m. By-Law No. 173-92, being a By-Law to change the Land Use Designation of Pt. of SW 28-49-7 W5M from Agricultural One to Country Residential Restricted 30 - 37 - Report and Recommendation attached. 7. Delegations/Appointments (a) 10:00 a.m. - Mr. Rod Shultz - Union Pacific Resources Property 38 - 42 Letter dated 92 12 10 attached.
    [Show full text]
  • Madam Chairman
    April 13, 1994 Public Accounts 85 Title: Wednesday, April 13, 1994 pa 8:31 a.m. Wednesday, April 13, 1994 feel he’s such an invaluable member that it’s much, much more important to have him with the committee rather than on this side, [Chairman: Mrs. Abdurahman] Madam Chairman. I would be delighted if Dr. Taylor would come, but I could also understand if a majority vote of the MADAM CHAIRMAN: I’d like to call us to order and just committee said he could not leave. I would understand that. I welcome you all. We’ll give the minister a few minutes to get would be saddened; nevertheless, I would understand it. settled. I’m really impressed that the majority of us, in fact all of us, are here - yes, I went to Fort Saskatchewan - after the early MADAM CHAIRMAN: Well, hon. minister, I’m actually morning adjournment of the Assembly. I have to compliment you delighted you’re making the hon. member feel so welcome. I’m on being on time. sure he’ll welcome my decision of last night not to defer this Approval of the agenda, please. Moved by Mike Percy. All in meeting. So I put it to the hon. member: would you care to join favour, say aye. the minister? And would there be any objection from members of Public Accounts Committee? HON. MEMBERS: Aye. DR. L. TAYLOR: Sure, I would be happy to go over there. MADAM CHAIRMAN: Any nays? No. Carried unanimously. Approval of the minutes of the March 30, 1994, committee MADAM CHAIRMAN: The only condition is that you might meeting.
    [Show full text]
  • ' of BRAZEAU NO. 77 P REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING 9411 10
    p P MUNICIPAL DISTRICT ' OF BRAZEAU NO. 77 p REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING 9411 10 9:30 a.m. p MUNICIPAL DISTRICT OF BRAZEAU NO. 77 REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA DATE: 94 1110 TIME: 9:30 A.M. PLACE: MJ>. ADMINISTRATION BUILDING, COUNCIL CHAMBERS p Page No. Call to Order Present 1. Addition to the Agenda pj 2. Adoption of the Agenda 3. Adoption ofMinutes ofthe Regular Council Meeting of94 10 26. Pi 4. EmergentItems 5. Appointments/Delegations 1 (a) 9:30 a.m. - StaffSargeant Doug Bangle -R.C.M.P. 2-6 (b) 10:00 a.m. Public Hearing 0) Request to Permit Undeveloped Road Allowance NorthBoundary ofNW 1/423-49-7-W5M Jerry and Rose Greiner (ii) Request forUndeveloped Road Allowance fora Portion oftheNorthBoundary Pt. ofNE1/432-47-4-W5M f BobMacDonald 7"25 (c) 10:15 a.m.-Drayton Valley GolfCourse-Re: Hwy. 22 Campground Proposal 26-59 (d) 10:30 a.m. -Metis Association Local 888 -Re: Hwy. 22 Campground Proposal P! (e) 11:00 a.m. - Ratepayers Concerns 6. Planning, Development andLandsMatters (a) In-Camera - Enforcement ofSetback Regulations 60"87 (b) Proposal For New Alberta Planning Act - Report attached. 88"103 (c) Summary ofOptions Available to the Municipality in the Performance of its Planning Services - Report and recommendation attached. AGENDA -2- 941110 pi 7. General Matters 104-108 (a) Duplication ofPayment onMobile Home -Scott and Terry Graham - Report and recommendation attached. 109 (b) Utility Accounts - Report and recommendation attached. 110*111 (c) Assessment Proposals - Report attached. pi 112-120 (d) Community Foundation p - Report and recommendation attached.
    [Show full text]
  • REPORT Picture Butte
    1992 GREY CUP KING & QUEEN CONTESTANTS BACK ROW (l-r): Tammy Brassard, Kristin Papworth (Princess), Colleen Jones FRONT ROW (l-r): Jamie McCloud, Carrie Cochran (Queen), Kevin Renning REFILLS HUTCHINGS & PATRICK INC. OTTAWA CANADA FEUILLES DE RECHANGE 41R Picture REPORT Butte Picture Butte, located in the heart of the Lethbridge Northern Irrigation District, is surrounded by a variety of forms of agriculture made possible by irrigation including market gardens, sugar beets, various grain crops, dairy farms and 300,000 feeder cattle. Many of the town's businesses are agriculture-related, but many other services, retail outlets and a hospital also provide employment. "Outstanding Performances!" #1 RURAL RESIDENTIAL MLS REALTORS for 1991 1991 EMERALD CLUB MEMBERS MLS MILLION DOLLAR CLUB MEMBER 1989, 1990, 1991 Lois Nieboer and Alina Stronks invite you to visit "Acreages" FLARE 'N' FLOWER for all of your accessory needs. With their staff, Bertha Vsn Zeggelaar and "Residential" Lida Neels, they will assist you in selecting that 'Commercial" "special something" for yourself, your home, or Eleanor and Gerry Nichol of G 4 E INSURANCE have your friends. served Picture Butte and area for 12 years. With their staff, 'Businesses" "Your Realtors Eleanor Katakami & Shirley Andron they can fill all of your?,- f With Results" • ladies accessories: - wedding flowers & insurance needs, and whether you require personal, com­ handbags, jewelry, wedding arrangements mercial or agricultural coverage, they are professional, effi­ scarves, gloves custom silk & dried cient & up-to-date. • Wedding jewelry • fresh flowers for all arrangements occasions balloons & wicker "Providing Service & Dependability GORDON DAVY 732-4454 HOMELIFE In The Community" 380*0229 334 Highway Ave.
    [Show full text]
  • The Differential Impact of Health Care Privatization on Women in Alberta
    THE DIFFERENTIAL IMPACT OF HEALTH CARE PRIVATIZATION ON WOMEN IN ALBERTA C. M. Scott T. Horne W. E. Thurston PRAIRIE WOMEN’S HEALTH CENTRE OF EXCELLENCE RESEARCHP POLICYP COMMUNITY Administrative Centre: Regina Site: Saskatoon Site: Prairie Women’s Health Prairie Women’s Health Prairie Women’s Health Centre of Excellence Centre of Excellence Centre of Excellence The University of Winnipeg University of Regina Extension University of Saskatchewan 515 Portage Avenue Regina, SK S4S 0A2 Saskatoon, SK S7N 5E5 Winnipeg, MB R3B 2E9 Telephone: (306) 585-5727 Telephone: (306) 966-8658 Telephone: (204) 786-9048 Fax: (306) 585-5825 Fax: (306) 966-7920 Fax: (204) 774-4134 E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected] WEBSITE: www.pwhce.ca The research and publication of this study were funded by the Women’s Health Bureau of Health Canada, the Women’s Health Research Group at the University of Calgary, and the Prairie Women’s Health Centre of Excellence (PWHCE). The PWHCE is financially supported by the Centre of Excellence for Women’s Health Program, Women’s Health Bureau, Health Canada. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent the views of the PWHCE or the official policy of Health Canada. THE DIFFERENTIAL IMPACT OF HEALTH CARE PRIVATIZATION ON WOMEN IN ALBERTA C.M. Scott, T. Horne and W.E. Thurston ©2000 C.M. Scott, T. Horne, W.E. Thurston, and the Prairie Women’s Health Centre of Excellence ISBN 0-9684540-7-0 ORDERING INFORMATION The full text of this report will be available on the PWHCE website at www.pwhce.ca in the summer of 2000.
    [Show full text]
  • REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA June 9, 2014 at 6:00 P.M
    REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA June 9, 2014 at 6:00 p.m. Page 1. Call To Order 2. Emergency Evacuation Procedure 3. Open Microphone 4. Additional Agenda Items 5. Adoption of the Agenda 6. Adoption of Minutes 4-9 a) Regular Council Meeting, May 26 10 b) Committee of the Whole Meeting, May 21 7. BUSINESS ARISING FROM THE MINUTES 8. PUBLIC HEARINGS & DELEGATIONS a) Public Hearing: Hampton Pointe, Bylaw 1640/2014; Amend Land Use Bylaw 1555/2010 b) Tagish Engineering, Infrastructure Study c) Mr. Richard Backs, Secondary Suites Approval 11-13 d) Jazz at the Lake, President Eric Allison, Request for fee waiver regarding ticket sales for 2014 9. PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT 14-33 a) Bylaw Number 1640/2014, to amend Land Use Bylaw Number 1555/2010-Second and Third Reading Page 1 of 187 Page 9. PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT 34-41 b) Bylaw Number 1645/2014 to amend Off-Site Levy Bylaw 1428/2007 10. COMMUNITY SERVICES 42-44 a) Centennial Celebrations Task Force 45-51 b) Tour of Alberta Request 52-54 c) Lease Hold Space-Multiplex 11. PUBLIC WORKS 55-56 a) Award Contract-Pavement Patching 57-101 b) Waste Bylaw, Number 1620/2013-Third Reading 102-103 c) Waste Receptacles (Carts) 104-127 d) Lakeshore Drive-Phase 5 128-142 e) Bylaw Number 1646/2014, Road Closure 48th Street 143-144 f) 35th Street Access 12. ADMINISTRATION a) Appointment of Alternate Councillor for Municipal Planning Committee 145 b) Temporary Foreign Workers Program 146-154 c) Public Interest Disclosure Act 13. FINANCE 14. Upcoming Meetings & Events a) Regular Meeting of Council, June 9 b) Staff Safety Day, Council serving BBQ lunch from 11:00 a.m.
    [Show full text]