Catalysed Oxidation of 4-Oxo Acids by Bromate in Acid Medium: Nonlinear Hammett Plots

RESEARCH ARTICLES Kinetic and mechanistic studies of cerium(III)- catalysed oxidation of 4-oxo acids by bromate in acid medium: nonlinear Hammett plots B. Suresh Babu1, P. Sunitha Manjari2 and Ch. Sanjeeva Reddy1,* 1Department of Chemistry, University College, Kakatiya University, Warangal 506 009, India 2Department of Chemistry, University College of Science, Saifabad, Osmania University, Hyderabad 500 004, India they are independent of each other. However, these com- The kinetic and mechanistic aspects of cerium(III)- pounds exert intramolecular mechanism2 and neighbour- catalysed oxidation of 4-oxo acids by bromate (uncon- 3 taminated with bromine) in an acid medium have been ing group participation . The formation of propanedioic studied. The reaction exhibited first-order each in acid and benzoic acid from enolization and selective oxi- [bromate] and [acid], fractional order each in [oxo acid] dation, makes these substrates attractive and therefore and [cerium(III)], and also showed solvent isotope they possess wide synthetic organic applications4–6. effect of 0.55 (k(H2O)/k (D2O)). The reaction did not induce polymerization and the induction period was not observed. The influence of ionic strength on the rate was negligible, while increase in reaction rate was found by lowering the dielectric constant of the medium. The reaction rate was affected by the presence of substituents in the reaction centre. Increase in the reaction rate by electron releasing substituents and decrease in the rate by the presence of electron-with- drawing substituents were observed. The Hammett plots were characterized by smooth curvature; however, linearity was observed using exalted values. A σ negative value for the reaction constant was observed. The isokinetic relationship was evaluated from the Oxidants such as potassium bromate and sodium bromate Arrhenius and Hammett plots. The formation of a are innocuous, inexpensive, stable solids and easy to handle. ternary complex between oxidant, substrate and cata- Since bromide is the reduction product of bromate oxida- lyst has been proposed in the mechanism. Based on tion, which makes bromate oxidation environmentally the proposed mechanism, the rate law has been deri- benign compared to metal ion oxidations7,8. Cerium(III) ved. The formation of a π-complex between Ce(III) has been used as a homogeneous catalyst in many redox and -ene of the enol form of oxo acid has been pro- reactions including the Belousov–Zhabotinsky (B–Z) oscil- posed. This reaction finds application in the synthesis lating reactions of various organic substrates involving of substituted benzoic acids and involves the pheno- bromate as an oxidant9–11. Generally Ce(III) ion catalysed mena of intramolecular catalysis and neighbouring B–Z oscillating reactions involve the formation of several group participation. organic intermediate free radicals, auto-catalysis and different oxidation states of the catalyst, hence compli- Keywords: Bromate oxidation, cerium(III) catalysis, cated. isokinetic relationships, reaction mechanism, 4-oxo acids. The role of substituents on the rate of reaction can be understood based on the Hammett equation. When the 3-BENZOYL propionic acid (4-oxo-4-phenyl butyric acid) substituents influence the reaction rate in different ways, and its substituted compounds are commonly known as then it results in a nonlinearity in the plot between log k 4-oxo acids or γ-oxo acids. These compounds have versa- and σ (Hammett plot), which is attributed to change in tile synthetic applications; they are the precursors for the mechanism, change in the rate-determining step, or natural products like piperidines, pyrrolidines, lactams change in the nature of the transition state during 1 and substituted γ-butyrolactones . The two functional the reaction, hence interesting to study the substituent groups – carbonyl and carboxy groups – present in these effect. compounds are separated by two carbon atoms, such that The present system (oxidation of 4-oxoacids by Ce(III)) is neither isoenthalpic nor isoentropic, but exhibits a *For correspondence. (e-mail: [email protected]) linear relationship between the activation enthalpy and CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 121, NO. 5, 10 SEPTEMBER 2021 651 RESEARCH ARTICLES activation entropy in accordance with the compensation without nitrogen. Solutions were prepared fresh while law known as isokinetic relationship. performing the kinetic runs. Bromine production due to reaction between bromate and bromide and its further δΔH ‡ reaction with the substrate were completely reduced by = β , the addition of mercuric acetate14. δΔS‡ where ΔH‡ is the enthalpy of activation and ΔS‡ the Stoichiometry and product analysis entropy of activation and β is the isokinetic temperature, i.e. the temperature at which all the compounds have the Reaction mixtures containing different ratios of [bromate] same rate. At the isokinetic temperature, the variation of to [4-oxo acid] with all other reagents, were kept for 12 h substituents has no influence on the free energy of activa- at 40°C. Estimation of [bromate] revealed the stoichiome- tion. In an isoentropic oxidation reaction, the isokinetic try of the reaction according to eq. (1). temperature lies at infinity and is zero for an isoenthalpic series. In the former, only enthalpy of activation deter- mines the reactivity and in the latter, the entropy of acti- vation12. Experimental observations revealed that the reaction of 4-oxo acids with bromate in acid medium without a cata- (1) lyst was slow, but was enhanced by the addition of smaller proportions of Ce2(SO4)3. The present study, therefore will help understand the mechanism of Ce(III)-catalysed oxidation of 4-oxo acids by acidic bromate. The main objectives of this study are to identify the reactive species of the substrate, catalyst and bromate, The observed stoichiometry was the same with all the interpreting a possible mechanism for the reaction, ob- phenyl substituted 4-oxo acids. The oxidation products taining an appropriate rate law, identifying the reaction were analysed. Benzoic acid, after separation by HPLC products, evaluation of related kinetic and thermodynamic (melting point 121°C), was estimated quantitatively (92– parameters, and verifying the linear free energy and 96.6% yield) with a standard curve at 235 nm (λmax). CO2 isokinetic relationships. was identified by bubbling N2 gas through a U-shaped tube containing a saturated Ba(OH)2 solution, which re- sulted in the formation of a white precipitate of BaCO3. Materials and methods Formation of pale-yellow precipitate by the addition of silver nitrate solution confirmed the presence of bromide 3-Benzoyl propionic acid and its substituted compounds ions. Evolution of bromine did not occur, which further (Aldrich, USA) were recrystallized twice from doubly supported the formation of bromide ion. distilled water. All other reagents were used after purifi- It is pertinent to mention here that, under the kinetic cation and their solutions were prepared using double- conditions when [oxo acid] [bromate], the products of distilled water or pure acetic acid. D2O (99.4% pure) was 4-oxo acids upon oxidation are benzoic and malonic acids. obtained from the Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, Malonic acid was identified by its melting point (135°C) Mumbai. The stock solution of Ce(III) was made by dis- and also tested with its characteristic spot test through solving Ce2(SO4)3 ⋅ 8H2O (Merck) in dilute acid and 15 13 conversion into barbituric acid . Identification of the standardized using the method of Jeffery et al. products, namely benzoic and malonic acids was also done by comparing the tr (retention time) values of the authentic samples. Kinetic measurements All the kinetic measurements were studied at pseudo-first Results and discussion order conditions with [oxo acid] [bromate]. Reaction was initiated by adding a known amount of bromate to In acid medium, production of molecular bromine (Br2) due the thermostated reaction mixture. The reaction was moni- to autocatalytic bromate–bromide reaction was eliminated tored by determining the unconsumed [bromate] using the by the addition of Hg(OAc)2, which forms non-ionizable iodometric method. The reaction was followed for at least Hg(II)-bromocomplexes14. No significant change in the 75–80% and rate constants (k, s–1) were obtained by plot- reaction rate was observed, in the concentration range ting log[bromate]t against time. There was no change in 0.001–0.01 M mercuric acetate. An optimum concentra- the observed rate constants in the presence of nitrogen tion of mercuric acetate (0.005 M) was employed to atmosphere and the reported rate constants were obtained avoid all possible reactions due to bromine oxidation 652 CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 121, NO. 5, 10 SEPTEMBER 2021 RESEARCH ARTICLES Table 1. Factors influencing the rate of Ce(III)-catalysed oxidation of 4-oxo acids by bromate in acidic medium at 313 K ka (s–1) × 104 Non-variable constituent Variable constituent –3 –3 (mol dm ) (mol dm ) -H p-OCH3 p-CH3 p-Cl m-NO2 [Bromate] [Oxo acid] = 0.01 5.0 × 10–4 3.82 57.57 7.67 0.77 0.39 –4 [H2SO4] = 1.0 7.5 × 10 3.83 57.56 7.65 0.79 0.38 [Ce(III)] = 0.0001 10.0 × 10–4 3.84 57.57 7.67 0.79 0.38 –4 AcOH–H2O = 1 : 1 (% v/v) 15.0 × 10 3.83 57.58 7.67 0.78 0.38 –4 [Hg(OAc)2] = 0.005 20.0 × 10 3.83 57.57 7.67 0.79 0.38 [Oxo acid] [Bromate] = 0.001 5.0 × 10–3 2.31 35.54 4.45 0.45 0.22 –3 [H2SO4] = 1.0 7.5 × 10 3.02 45.22 5.75 0.62 0.31 [Ce(III)] = 0.0001 10.0 × 10–3 3.83 57.57 7.67 0.79 0.38 –3 AcOH–H2O

Load more