University of Florida Thesis Or Dissertation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INTERCITY GROUND TRANSPORTATION: A FLORIDA CASE STUDY By ANDREW MORRIS A THESIS PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER IN URBAN AND REGIONAL PLANNING UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2019 © 2019 Andrew Morris To my Grandma, Arlene Delman ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I want to thank my parents for supporting me through my time at the University of Florida and for pushing me to get a higher education. I also want to thank my grandma, Arlene Delman. She has always been there for me and always makes time to talk. She is one of the reasons why I went back to school. 4 TABLE OF CONTENTS page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ...............................................................................................................4 LIST OF TABLES ...........................................................................................................................7 LIST OF FIGURES .........................................................................................................................8 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ..........................................................................................................9 ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................................................10 1 INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................11 2 LITERATURE REVIEW .......................................................................................................13 Multimodal Planning for Intercity Travel ...............................................................................13 Intercity Transportation Modes ..............................................................................................16 Intercity Passenger Rail ...................................................................................................16 Highway Travel (Cars and Buses) ...................................................................................21 Air Travel ........................................................................................................................23 Domestic and International Examples of Good Intercity Travel Planning .............................25 International Example: Switzerland ................................................................................25 Domestic Example: California ........................................................................................27 Summary .................................................................................................................................31 3 METHODOLOGY .................................................................................................................34 4 RESULTS ...............................................................................................................................38 Florida Case Study: Interstate 75 Corridor versus Interstate 95 Southeast Florida Corridor ...............................................................................................................................38 General Public Policy Related to Intercity Travel in Florida ..........................................38 A Historic Look at Intercity Travel Public Policies in Florida .......................................39 Florida Corridor Studies: Interstate 75 Corridor ....................................................................42 Interstate 75 Relief Task Force ........................................................................................42 Rail Feasibility Analysis Summary Report .....................................................................46 Overview of Study Area .........................................................................................................50 Counties and Cities located in Study Area ......................................................................50 General Overview of Transportation Facilities and Corridors within Study Area ..........50 Existing Ground Transportation Modes Along Corridor ........................................................51 Intercity Passenger Rail ...................................................................................................51 Highway Ground Transportation .....................................................................................52 Multimodal Connectivity .................................................................................................52 Interstate 95 Corridor in South Florida ...................................................................................53 Overview of Study Area .........................................................................................................53 Counties and Cities located in Study Area ......................................................................53 5 General Overview of Transportation Facilities and Corridors within Study Area ..........54 Existing Ground Transportation Modes Along Corridor ........................................................55 Highway Ground Transportation .....................................................................................55 Intercity Passenger Rail ...................................................................................................57 Multimodal Connectivity .................................................................................................59 5 DISCUSSION .........................................................................................................................68 Existing Limitations ................................................................................................................68 Next Steps to Improve Florida’s Intercity Transportation Network .......................................69 6 CONCLUSION.......................................................................................................................72 LIST OF REFERENCES ...............................................................................................................74 BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH .........................................................................................................80 6 LIST OF TABLES Table page 2-1 FRA Designations for Intercity Passenger Rail Corridors .................................................33 2-2 Amtrak California Overview .............................................................................................33 4-1 Population Estimates for Counties located in Interstate 75 Study Area ............................61 4-2 Population and Median Household Income for Cities in Interstate 75 Study Area ...........62 4-3 Ground transportation intercity travel choices between Jacksonville and Tampa Bay to Northeast Florida study area overview ..........................................................................62 4-4 Ground transportation intercity choices between Jacksonville and Tampa Bay to Northeast Florida multimodal connections ........................................................................63 4-5 Southeast Interstate 95 Corridor County Population .........................................................65 4-6 Southeast Interstate 95 Corridor City Populations, Density, and Median Household Income................................................................................................................................65 4-7 The Southeast Interstate 95 Corridor Intercity Ground Transportation Overview ............66 4-8 Interstate 95 corridor in Southeast Florida intercity, ground transportation multimodal connections .....................................................................................................67 7 LIST OF FIGURES Figure page 2-1 Comparison between High-Speed Rail and Intercity Passenger Rail ................................32 3-1 Overview of Methodology .................................................................................................37 4-1 Map of Interstate 75 Study Area Intercity Ground Transportation Map ...........................60 4-2 An overview map of Southeast Interstate 95 Corridor ......................................................64 8 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS Amtrak The National Railroad Passenger Corporation Caltrans California Department of Transportation CSX A private Class 1 freight railroad that operates in Florida FDOT Florida Department of Transportation JTA Jacksonville Transportation Authority PRIIA Passenger Rail Investment and Improvement Act SFRTA South Florida Regional Transportation Authority 9 Abstract of Thesis Presented to the Graduate School of the University of Florida in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for Master in Urban and Regional Planning INTERCITY GROUND TRANSPORTATION: A FLORIDA CASE STUDY Andrew L. Morris May 2019 Chair: Ruth Steiner Cochair: Stanley Latimer Major: Urban and Regional Planning Intercity ground transportation provides important connections between cities in America. Public policy can have a major influence on intercity travel. The focus of my study is on intercity ground transportation for distances of 100-to 500-miles. Air travel dominates long- distance travel in America, but is not as relevant for short-to medium-distance travel. Intercity passenger rail and express coach services are examples of ground transportation useful for trips of 100-to 500-mile distances. Driving still dominates short-to medium-distance travel in America, but existing challenges with our interstate