DOCSLIB.ORG

BETWEEN PEOPLE and THINGS Understanding Violence and Theft in Early New Zealand Transactions

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
BETWEEN PEOPLE and THINGS Understanding Violence and Theft in Early New Zealand Transactions BETWEEN PEOPLE AND THINGS Understanding Violence and Theft in early New Zealand transactions A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Anthropology By Annette Wilkes University of Canterbury Te Whare Wānanga o Waitaha Christchurch New Zealand 2013 Table of Contents Acknowledgements.............................................................................................................................................i Abstract .................................................................................................................................................................. ii INTRODUCTION.................................................................................................................................................iii Thesis Aims and Background.......................................................................................................................iii Chapter reviews and thesis structure ...................................................................................................viii CHAPTER ONE..................................................................................................................................................... 1 Theory and the History-Anthropology Frontier.................................................................................... 1 ‘Other’ perspectives on History ................................................................................................................... 5 Dynamic Contexts .............................................................................................................................................. 6 Social agents......................................................................................................................................................... 8 Text, Context, and the Representation oF ‘others’................................................................................ 9 Ethno-historical Methods.............................................................................................................................11 Methodology used............................................................................................................................................15 Phase one: finding the fragments............................................................................................................16 Phase two: interpreting the fragments.................................................................................................17 Phase three: representation.......................................................................................................................17 Summary..............................................................................................................................................................18 CHAPTER TWO..................................................................................................................................................19 Approaches to the Anthropology oF Violence ......................................................................................19 What is Violence?...........................................................................................................................................19 More Recent Approaches.............................................................................................................................23 Violence in History .........................................................................................................................................30 A. Transactions gone wrong: Captains Gatteschi & Cellisi at Florence Italy in 1599.......31 B. Transactions gone wrong: Captain Porter & Chief Gamzdop at Nass River, British Columbia in 1811 ............................................................................................................................33 C. Transactions gone wrong: Captain de Surville & Chief Ranginui, Doubtless Bay, New Zealand 1769..........................................................................................................................................34 Summary..............................................................................................................................................................39 CHAPTER THREE .............................................................................................................................................41 Seeing and Knowing: Mātauranga Māori & ConFlicting Ontological Worlds..........................41 Epistemology and ontology .........................................................................................................................42 The position of the scholar .........................................................................................................................44 Mātauranga Māori............................................................................................................................................47 Structural Restrictions and Empowerment ........................................................................................50 Mana & Tapu....................................................................................................................................................51 Utu.........................................................................................................................................................................55 The Pae, Atua and Tōhunga.......................................................................................................................57 Enlightenment Discourses and Knowledge Frameworks ..............................................................59 The Great Chain of Being – relationships, God & the natural world........................................62 Power, Ownership and Social control....................................................................................................64 The Rules of Transaction.............................................................................................................................67 Navigating the Horizon – a comparison .................................................................................................69 Summary..............................................................................................................................................................72 CHAPTER FOUR ................................................................................................................................................73 Māori Material Records: things as social actors .................................................................................73 Genealogies.........................................................................................................................................................75 Things as Social Actors ..................................................................................................................................84 Impacts on inter-iwi socio-political interactions ...............................................................................90 Perceptions oF objects....................................................................................................................................93 Potential impacts on Māori-European Transactions.....................................................................101 Summary...........................................................................................................................................................105 CHAPTER FIVE ...............................................................................................................................................107 Why did violence happen? A New Zealand case..............................................................................107 Inter-iwi conflict in Te Wai Pounamu ..................................................................................................110 The First battle between Ngāi Tahu and the Ngāti Toa alliance c.1828.................................115 Contextual background and preludes to the Kaiapoi battle..................................................... 115 The first Kaiapoi battle: Transition points....................................................................................... 119 Social actors................................................................................................................................................... 125 Things as social actors .............................................................................................................................. 129 Summary oF First Kaiapoi conFlict...........................................................................................................133 CHAPTER SIX ..................................................................................................................................................137 Violence between Māori and Sealers: Triggers and Transitions..............................................137 Social actors and their actions.................................................................................................................137 Transitional ‘tipping points’ points progressing to violent outcomes...................................140 May 1826. The Brig Elizabeth, sealer, at Open Bay Westland. ..................................................142
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Look Inside 10 Days in the Life of Auckland War Memorial Museum CONTENTS
    Look inside 10 days in the life of Auckland War Memorial Museum CONTENTS Ka puāwai ngā mahi o tau kē, Year in Review Ka tōia mai ā tātou kaimātaki i ēnei rā, Ka whakatō hoki i te kākano mō āpōpō. Sharing our Highlights 2014/2015 6 Board Chairman, Taumata-ā-Iwi Chairman and Director’s Report 8 Building on our past, 10 Days in the Life of Auckland War Memorial Museum 10 Engaging with our audiences today, Investing for tomorrow. Governance Trust Board 14 We are pleased to present our Taumata-ā-Iwi 16 Annual Report 2014/2015. Executive Team 18 Pacific Advisory Group 20 Youth Advisory Group 21 Governance Statement 22 Board Committees and Terms of Reference 24 Partnerships Auckland Museum Institute 26 Auckland Museum Circle Foundation 28 Funders, Partners and Supporters 30 BioBlitz 2014 Tungaru: The Kiribati project Research Update 32 Performance Te Pahi Medal Statement of Service Performance 38 Auditor’s Report: Statement of Service Performance 49 Entangled Islands Contact Information 51 exhibition Illuminate projections onto the Museum Financial Performance Financial Statements 54 Dissection of Auditor’s Report: Financial Statements 88 Great White Shark Financial Commentary 90 Flying over the Antarctic This page and throughout: Nautilus Shell SECTION SECTION Year in Review 4 5 YEAR IN REVIEW YEAR IN REVIEW Sharing our Highlights 2014/2015 A strong, A compelling Accessible Active sustainable destination ‘beyond participant foundation the walls’ in Auckland 19% 854,177 1 million 8 scholars supported by the Museum to reduction in overall emissions
    [Show full text]
  • Te Runanga 0 Ngai Tahu Traditional Role of the Rona!Sa
    :I: Mouru Pasco Maaka, who told him he was the last Maaka. In reply ::I: William told Aritaku that he had an unmerried sister Ani, m (nee Haberfield, also Metzger) in Murihiku. Ani and Aritaku met and went on to marry. m They established themselves in the area of Waimarama -0 and went on to have many children. -a o Mouru attended Greenhills Primary School and o ::D then moved on to Southland Girls' High School. She ::D showed academic ability and wanted to be a journalist, o but eventually ended up developing photographs. The o -a advantage of that was that today we have heaps of -a beautiful photos of our tlpuna which we regard as o priceless taolsa. o ::D Mouru went on to marry Nicholas James Metzger ::D in 1932. Nick's grandfather was German but was o educated in England before coming to New Zealand. o » Their first son, Nicholas Graham "Tiny" was born the year » they were married. Another child did not follow until 1943. -I , around home and relished the responsibility. She Mouru had had her hopes pinned on a dainty little girl 2S attended Raetihi School and later was a boarder at but instead she gave birth to a 13lb 40z boy called Gary " James. Turakina Maori Girls' College in Marton. She learnt the teachings of both the Ratana and Methodist churches. Mouru went to her family's tlU island Pikomamaku­ In 1944 Ruruhira took up a position at Te Rahui nui almost every season of her life. She excelled at Wahine Methodist Hostel for Maori girls in Hamilton cooking - the priest at her funeral remarked that "she founded by Princess Te Puea Herangi.
    [Show full text]
  • Management Guidelines for Surfing Resources
    Management Guidelines for Surfing Resources Version History Version Date Comment Approved for release by Beta version release of Beta 1st October 2018 first edition for initial feedback period Ed Atkin Version 1 following V1 31st August 2019 feedback period Ed Atkin Please consider the environment before printing this document Management Guidelines for Surfing Resources This document was developed as part of the Ministry for Businesses, Innovation and Employment funded research project: Remote Sensing, Classification and Management Guidelines for Surf Breaks of National and Regional Significance. Disclaimer These guidelines have been prepared by researchers from University of Waikato, eCoast Marine Consulting and Research, and Hume Consulting Ltd, under the guidance of a steering committee comprising representation from: Auckland Council; Department of Conservation; Landcare Research; Lincoln University; Waikato Regional Council; Surfbreak Protection Society; and, Surf Life Saving New Zealand. This document has been peer reviewed by leading surf break management and preservation practitioners, and experts in coastal processes, planning and policy. Many thanks to Professor Andrew Short, Graeme Silver, Dr Greg Borne, Associate Professor Hamish Rennie, James Carley, Matt McNeil, Michael Gunson, Rick Liefting, Dr Shaun Awatere, Shane Orchard and Dr Tony Butt. The authors have used the best available information in preparing this document. Nevertheless, none of the organisations involved in its preparation accept any liability, whether direct, indirect or consequential, arising out of the provision of information in this report. While every effort has been made to ensure that these guidelines are clear and accurate, none of the aforementioned contributors and involved parties will be held responsible for any action arising out of its use.
    [Show full text]
  • Autahi Istory
    autahi a moko ises the art form ce of istory "re Tau case. gUlng I ityof apapa Sarah Sylvia lorraine Koher 1917-May 19, 2001 Earlier this year while i ton I visited a remarkable son of Ngai Tahu - Mi aSM. Papaki mai nga hau ate ao ki rungaAoraki, ka rewa nga Mick- from the Picton ~y family - did not have huka hei roimata, ka tere at wa Ki ta Moana- a high profile yet his is a story of extraordinary talent, of nui-a-Kiwa. Tahuri ornata t tf fa bravery, adve uer~d and a life of service to THE NGAI TAHU MAGAZINE 6u Kawai kei te Waipounamu Ngal TOahurf MakaririlWinter 2001 others. Ngati Huirapa, ki a Kati Waewae, Ngai Tahu, If Mickhad aI', he would have EDITOR Gabrielle Huria Mamoe, Waitaha nui tonu. Te hunaonga 0 Rewati Been one of the s Zealand sporting Tuhorouta Kohere raua ko Keita Kaikiri Paratene. Haruru scene. ASSISTANT Adrienne Anderson ana hoki te hinganga 0 te kaitiaki a Rangiatea. Haehae EDITOR At the onset ana te ngakau. Aue taukuri e. editorial playing first-class r CONTRIBUTORS Emalene Belczacki many to be one of Helen Brown GABRIELLE HURIA Black Douglas Waipapa (Flutey) Ross Caiman And so he war, Where in both Egypt and Cook Donald Couch Italy ha Wills resent the New Zealand Army Suzanne Ellison Jane Huria Tana koutou katoa. Ka nui taku mihi ki a koutou i tanei wa a te makariri. team In no He panui tenei ki a koutou. I hinga Blade Jones Wr Ta moko has experienced a renaissance in recent times.
    [Show full text]
  • 2013–2014 Annual Report
    OTAGO MUSEUM ANNUAL REPORT 2013–2014 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction 3 Chairperson’s Foreword 4 Director’s Review of the Year 5 Otago Museum Trust Board 6 Māori Advisory Committee 7 Honorary Curators 7 Association of Friends of the Otago Museum 7 Acknowledgements 8 Otago Museum Staff 9 Goal One – A World-class Collection 12 Goal Two – Engaging Our Community 17 Goal Three – Business Sustainability 21 Goal Four – An Outward-looking and Inclusive Culture 24 Visitor Comments 27 Looking Forward 28 Statement of Service Performance 29 Financial Statements 53 2 INTRODUCTION Leadership at the Otago Museum Each new director builds on the wider community, taking into account is generational, with each Museum legacy of those that have come the many varied functions of the director’s tenure being an average of before. Dr Ian Griffin, trained as a Museum and its obligations to service 18 years. This length of service scientist and physicist, has a passion its stakeholders and communities. invariably defines the culture and for science communication and organisational structure of the informal learning engagement. A strategy planning workshop held institution. Previous directors have He brings a new approach to, and in November 2013 was attended by placed emphasis on building and awareness of, the potential and many sectors of the Museum’s wider inspiring research into the collection, importance of the Museum, not only community, from Museum staff and communicating our region’s history as a visitor attraction but as a centre the Otago Museum Trust Board, to and inspiring our community. for learning. educators and academics, to City, District and Regional Councillors, For the past 20 years, the focus has Our aim is to develop a fit for purpose Kāi Tahu representatives, business been on building the Museum into a repository for the Museum’s collection, operators and community workers major visitor attraction and a strategy address the need to research history in the Otago region.
    [Show full text]
  • Georg-Forster-Studien XIX Utor A
    Georg-Forster-Studien XIX utor A Georg Forster als interkultureller Autor Georg Forster kommt im Hinblick auf das Paradigma Interkulturalität eine exzeptionelle und bislang noch weithin unterschätzte Rolle zu. Wie kaum ein anderer seiner Zeitgenossen hat er die Enge politischer und gesellschaftlicher Lebensverhältnisse schon früh durch weite Reisen überwunden. Diese Erfahrungen artikulieren sich in seinen Texten in unterschiedlichen Modi der Fremdheitserfahrung und -verarbeitung. Fremdheit wird bearbeitet und reflektiert, überschrieben und trans- formiert. Darüber hinaus etabliert Forster noch vor der Herausbildung von nationalen Wissenschaftstraditionen eine auf vielfältigen Studien, Übersetzungs- und Vermittlungsarbeit beruhende interkulturelle Literatur- und Wissenschaftspraxis, die einen europäische und außereuropäische Perspektiven integrierenden Dialog mit anderen Kulturen projektiert. orster als interkultureller als interkultureller orster ISSN 1439-9105 F eorg eorg G ISBN 978-3-86219-778-1 XIX – 9 783862 197781 Herausgegeben im Auftrag der Georg-Forster-Gesellschaft Georg-Forster-Studien XIX Georg-Forster-Studien Herausgegeben im Auftrag der Georg-Forster-Gesellschaft von Stefan Greif und Michael Ewert Band 19 ISSN 1439-9105 Herausgegeben von Stefan Greif und Michael Ewert kassel university press Bibliografische Information der Deutschen Nationalbibliothek Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek verzeichnet diese Publikation in der Deutschen Nationalbibliografie; detaillierte bibliografische Daten sind im Internet über http://dnb.d-nb.de
    [Show full text]
  • H.D. Skinner's Use of Associates Within the Colonial
    Tuhinga 26: 20–30 Copyright © Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa (2015) H.D.Skinner’s use of associates within the colonial administrative structure of the Cook Islands in the development of Otago Museum’s Cook Islands collections Ian Wards National Military Heritage Charitable Trust, PO Box 6512, Marion Square, Wellington, New Zealand ([email protected]) ABSTRACT: During his tenure at Otago Museum (1919–57), H.D.Skinner assembled the largest Cook Islands collection of any museum in New Zealand. This paper shows that New Zealand’s colonial administrative structure was pivotal in the development of these collections, but that they were also the result of complex human interactions, motivations and emotions. Through an analysis of Skinner’s written correspondence, examples are discussed that show his ability to establish relationships where objects were donated as expressions of personal friendship to Otago Museum. The structure of the resulting collection is also examined. This draws out Skinner’s personal interest in typological study of adzes and objects made of stone and bone, but also highlights the increasing scarcity of traditional material culture in the Cook Islands by the mid-twentieth century, due in part to the activities of other collectors and museums. KEYWORDS: H.D.Skinner, Otago Museum, Cook Islands, colonialism, material culture. Introduction individuals, exchanges with museums, private donations and, significantly, the purchase by the New Zealand government During his tenure as ethnologist (1919–57) and, later, of the Oldman collection in 1948, Otago Museum’s Cook director of Otago Museum, Henry Devenish Skinner Islands collection grew to be the largest in New Zealand.
    [Show full text]
  • Waste for Otago (The Omnibus Plan Change)
    Key Issues Report Plan Change 8 to the Regional Plan: Water for Otago and Plan Change 1 to the Regional Plan: Waste for Otago (The Omnibus Plan Change) Appendices Appendix A: Minster’s direction matter to be called in to the environment court Appendix B: Letter from EPA commissioning the report Appendix C: Minister’s letter in response to the Skelton report Appendix D: Skelton report Appendix E: ORC’s letter in responding to the Minister with work programme Appendix F: Relevant sections of the Regional Plan: Water for Otago Appendix G: Relevant sections of the Regional Plan: Waste for Otago Appendix H: Relevant provisions of the Resource Management Act 1991 Appendix I: National Policy Statement for Freshwater Management 2020 Appendix J: Relevant provisions of the National Environmental Standards for Freshwater 2020 Appendix K: Relevant provisions of the Resource Management (Stock Exclusion) Regulations 2020 Appendix L: Relevant provisions of Otago Regional Council Plans and Regional Policy Statements Appendix M: Relevant provisions of Iwi management plans APPENDIX A Ministerial direction to refer the Otago Regional Council’s proposed Omnibus Plan Change to its Regional Plans to the Environment Court Having had regard to all the relevant factors, I consider that the matters requested to be called in by Otago Regional Council (ORC), being the proposed Omnibus Plan Change (comprised of Water Plan Change 8 – Discharge Management, and Waste Plan Change 1 – Dust Suppressants and Landfills) to its relevant regional plans are part of a proposal of national significance. Under section 142(2) of the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA), I direct those matters to be referred to the Environment Court for decision.
    [Show full text]
  • Peter Entwisle, Behold the Moon: the European Occupation of the Dunedin District 1770-1848, Reviewed
    B B REVIEWS (BOOKS) 103 B B Perhaps anxious to avoid concluding on such a grim and depressing note, Puckey instead ends by discussing the modern-day settlement of the Muriwhenua Treaty claims, B a process that has dragged out over more than two decades. The modest re-capitalisation B of far northern iwi is unlikely on its own to prove sufficient to reverse the socio-economic fortunes of Māori in the area. But understanding the origins of a problem can often prove crucial in overcoming it, and in this respect Puckey’s book should be required reading B for all those interested in the future fate of the Far North. B VINCENT O’MALLEY HistoryWorks B B Behold the Moon: The European Occupation of the Dunedin District 1770–1848 (revised edition). By Peter Entwisle. Port Daniel Press with the assistance of the Alfred and Isabel Reed Trust administered by the Otago Settlers’ Association, Dunedin, 2010. 300pp. B B Paperback: NZ price $49. ISBN: 978-0-473-17534-4. DERIVING ITS IMAGINATIVE NAME from a Māori chant transcribed by David Samwell at Queen Charlotte Sound during Cook’s third voyage there in 1777, this book is the B revised version of Peter Entwisle’s 1998 one of the same name. Both books have as their B initial frame of reference a brief contextual description of the wider socio-political and B cultural worlds of Europeans in the time leading up to the arrival of sealers, whalers, B traders and eventually missionaries in the South Island of New Zealand. Supporting B his thesis that the beginnings of the European occupation of the Dunedin district were B inextricably linked with the early arrival of small parties of such people in coastal Otago B and Southland, Entwisle describes their interaction and assimilation into small, dispersed B Māori communities that became nuclei for exchange.
    [Show full text]
  • Review of the Archaeology of Foveaux Strait, New Zealand, by Chris Jacomb, Richard Walter and Chris
    REVIEW OF THE ARCHAEOLOGY OF FOVEAUX STRAIT, NEW ZEALAND CHRIS JACOMB, RICHARD WALTER and CHRIS JENNINGS University of Otago The waters and shores of Foveaux Strait make up one of the coldest, windiest environments in New Zealand and, lying well outside the tropical horticulture zone, could not have been less like the environment of the Polynesian homelands. Yet they contain an extensive archaeological record which includes a low density but wide distribution of sites, as well as some rich artefact assemblages held in private and public collections. The record is not well dated but the few radiocarbon dates and the material culture and economy suggest that occupation commenced as early there as in any other part of the country. In considering why people moved so far south so early, Lockerbie (1959) rejected push factors such as demographic or resource pressures and argued that there must have been some serious attractors (pull factors) in play. Working today with a much shorter chronology, push motives seem even less likely but it is difficult to imagine what the pull factors might have been. Foveaux Strait settlement coincides with the expansion of moa hunting in southern New Zealand but there were never many moa (Dinornithiformes) along the south coast and moa bone is rare in south coast middens. There are resident populations of sea mammals including New Zealand fur seal (Arctocephalus forsterii) and sea lion (Phocarctos hookeri) but these were not restricted to Foveaux Strait (Smith 1989: 208), nor do the sites show high levels of sea mammal predation. Today, one of the most important seasonal resources is the sooty shearwater (mutton bird or titi(Puffinus) griseus) but again, there are no strong archaeological indicators of an early emphasis on mutton birding (Anderson 1995, 2001; Sutton and Marshall 1980).
    [Show full text]
  • 2014–2015 Annual Report
    OTAGO MUSEUM ANNUAL REPORT 2014–2015 TABLE OF CONTENTS Chairperson’s Foreword 3 Director’s Review of the Year 3 Otago Museum Trust Board 4 Māori Advisory Committee 5 Honorary Curators 5 Association of Friends of the Otago Museum 5 Acknowledgements 6 Otago Museum Staff 7 Goal One: A World-class Collection 10 Goal Two: Engaging Our Community 15 Goal Three: Business Sustainability 21 Goal Four: An Outward-looking and Inclusive Culture 23 Giving Back 25 Appendix A: Statement of Service Performance 26 Appendix B: Financial Statements 57 Appendix C: Independent Auditor’s Report 92 2 CHAIRPERSON’S FOREWORD OTAGO MUSEUM TRUST BOARD completed reorganisations within our teams December 2015 is very exciting. It marks to reflect our key areas of focus. We have the start of a major advance in our ability continued to invest in highly-skilled staff to to connect with our communities. This empower these areas. Our financial results development comes on the back of several reflect a successful balance of investment very successful exhibitions staged this year. and sensible management, allowing The great thing about these exhibitions has investment in our key development areas. been the use of our own collection and the leadership and creativity shown by our staff As an institution, we have worked hard at in bringing them to life. building partnership relationships with a large number of organisations. This report I would like to reflect my thanks for the work It is my pleasure as Chairperson to report demonstrates the success of these efforts of the management team and all staff at on behalf of the Board on another very and positions the Museum strongly for future the Otago Museum.
    [Show full text]
  • TE-KARAKA-73.Pdf
    ABOUT NGĀI TAHU–ABOUT NEW ZEALAND–ABOUT YOU KAHURU/AUTUMN 2017 $7.95 73 NOW AVAILABLE TO DOWNLOAD ON APPLE AND ANDROID DEVICES It will tell you the name of the artist and song title as it’s playing LIVE - you can even change the language to te reo Maori DOWNLOAD IT NOW ii TE KARAKA KAHURU 2017 KAHURU/AUTUMN 2017 73 10 WALKING THE TALK At the end of 2016, Tā Mark Solomon stepped down as Kaiwhakahaere NGĀ HAU of Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu. Kaituhi Adrienne Rewi, Mark Revington and E WHĀ David Slack reflect upon his 18 years of service. FROM THE EDITOR 10 In this issue we take the opportunity to acknowledge Tā Mark Solomon on his 18 years as Kaiwhakahaere o Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu (pages 10 - 15). We reflect upon his contribution to Ngāi Tahu, to Māoridom, and in fact to the whole of Aotearoa. Over the last 18 years he has been a constant presence, playing an instrumental role as Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu found its feet post- Settlement, forming strategic relationships with the Crown and other iwi, and guiding Ngāi Tahu through difficult times, such as the Christchurch earthquakes. The years he has dedicated to the iwi, and the affably humble way he has always carried himself, mean he will be missed by many. 16 TE WHAKA A TE WERA On pages 30 - 33 we discuss the issue Paterson Inlet off the coast of Rakiura is the largest mātaitai in the country, of whenua in Tūrangawaewae – Where using customary knowledge of mahinga kai to preserve the fisheries for future Do We Stand? Tūrangawaewae means “a generations.
    [Show full text]