Page 2 The Catholic Journalist June 2012

Newspaper Award Winners

too big. The pilgrimage photo also was very nice and nicely played. Third Place Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “Front Page” by Staff Clean pages. Good strong headline use. Nice play on the photos. Honorable Mention St. Louis Review, St. Louis, Mo., “Resilience Emerges From Tragedy/Retired Religious/Treasure of the Church” by Lisa Johnston

N02a Best News Writing - 1-17,000 Diocesan Paper

First Place Catholic Anchor, Anchorage, Alaska, “Prayer & priests inspire new seminarians” by Patricia Coll Freeman A good discussion - with decent interviews - of the decision of young men to choose the priesthood. Interviews were informative, and put a good face on this topic from a couple of diverse individuals. Second Place The Monitor, Trenton, N.J., “Thousands attend funeral Mass” by Lois Rogers Solid reporting that conveyed the emotion and sorrow of this tragedy. Third Place The Catholic Northwest Progress, Seattle, Wash., “Crisis pregnancy centers under attack” by Kevin Birnbaum Strong coverage of a serious issue. Good political reporting. Award N02a, Best News Writing - 1-17,000 Diocesan Paper, Honorable Mention First Place, Catholic Anchor, Anchorage, Alaska Catholic Anchor, Anchorage, Alaska, “Cloning with ethics” by Effie Caldarola discussion brings hostilities to Orchard Park parish” by Patrick J. Buechi N02b Good coverage of an emotional meeting, that didn’t get Best News Writing - 17,001-40,000 swept away by the reaction of some in the audience. A Diocesan Paper reflection of what happened, and the information that was provided and why. First Place Honorable Mention Award N01a, Best Front Page - Broadsheet, First Place, Rhode Island Catholic, Providence, R.I., “Game nearly The Visitor, St. Cloud, Minn., “’Tight-knit’ Farming parish Pittsburgh Catholic, Pittsburgh, Pa. over for church bingo” by Laura Kilgus celebrates its last Mass” by Sue Schulzetenberg Good enterprise reporting. Well written, timely topic. Catholic San Francisco, San Francisco, Calif., “East Palo Alto mayor, pastor oppose sale of low-income housing” by N01a Second Place The Catholic Miscellany, Charleston, S.C., “Rally at State- Valerie Schmalz Best Front Page - Broadsheet house asks SC legislature for ‘moral budget’” by Christina Lee Knauss N03a First Place I thought the concerns raised by rally participants were Best News Writing - National Event Pittsburgh Catholic, Pittsburgh, Pa., “Pittsburgh Catholic well expressed. I liked too that numerous people were Best Front Page” by Pittsburgh Catholic Staff interviewed. First Place Clear focus on what the editors thought were Third Place Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind., “Catholic women impotant. Good variety in typography The Catholic Miscellany, Charleston, S.C., “Priest protests struggling with infertility form online community” by Second Place coal ash landfill and possible contamination” by Amy Wise Eddie O’Neill Catholic Sun, Syracuse, N.Y., “Best Front Page Entries” by Taylor The writer delicately explores an issue that the Willie Putmon, Jr. I liked how the reporter let the priest explain his mainstream press would not likely think about: How Good use of photos, but perhaps the centerpieces need a decision to become involved in this issue. Thoughtful piece. Catholic women of faith deal with issues of infertility as little more white space. Honorable Mention they struggle to balance their wants with their spiritual Third Place Rhode Island Catholic, Providence, R.I., “Rep: Colleague needs. A compelling topic, written with grace and clarity. Catholic Messenger, Davenport, Iowa, “Best Front Page - trying to bargain on gay marriage issue” by Rick Second Place Broadsheet” by Celine Klosterman, Anne Marie Amacher Snizek St. Louis Review, St. Louis, Mo., “Hope Rises” by Joseph and Barb Arland-Fye Kenny Less clutter and better focus on what’s important would This story does a great job of reminding readers how improve standing. N02c Best News Writing - 40,001+ Diocesan the church was affected by the destruction, and, more importantly, how the community united to rebuild--both N01b Paper physically and spiritually. Best Front Page - Tabloid Third Place First Place Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind., “Study shows the The Catholic Standard & Times, Philadelphia, Pa., “Arch- First Place rise of Catholic megaparishes” by Scott Alessi diocese responds to indictments” by Mathew Gambino and Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind., “OSV Newsweekly” This story did a great job of exploring the rise of staff by Lindsey Riesen and Sarah Hayes megachurches — but from a Catholic perspective. Although Strong coverage of difficult issues and tumult in the Compelling. Great use of typography, photographs and based on a study, the reporter painted a compelling story church community. Good reflection of how the church color. The front page serves as a great window to what’s through the use of diverse sources and clear writing. leaders are responding and how it’s affecting parishioners. inside. Even though the pages are very busy they follow a Second Place clear hierarchy. The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “Job market: Good N03b Second Place news; bad news” by Pat Norby The Leaven, Kansas City, Kan., “The Leaven” by Todd Best News Writing - International Good timely coverage of a critical topic. Well reported Habiger Event and written. Loved the use of the tornado photo. It was a very nice Third Place page even though the initial was perhaps one or two lines First Place Western New York Catholic, Buffalo, N.Y., “Islam-Catholic Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind., “The pope ‘removes’ June 2012 The Catholic Journalist Page 3

Newspaper Award Winners

Amy Kotlarz Good human interest approach to a fresh topic. Writing was very conversational, which made a tricky topic easy to understand. Third Place Denver Catholic Register, Denver, Colo., “Intervention: From fear to empowerment; Experts dispel common myths about intervention” by Julie Filby Strong focus on an important, but little discussed topic. Honorable Mention North Texas Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas, “Ministries that offer families healing after miscarriages and stillbirths are growing in the Diocese of Fort Worth” by Joan Kurkowski-Gillen and Tony Gutierrez North Texas Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas, “Solidarity in Mission” by Juan Guajardo and Tony Gutierrez

N05 Best In-Depth News/Special Reporting

First Place North Texas Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas, “Solidarity in Mission” by Tony Gutierrez and Juan Guajardo Well written, well organized. Compelling story written in a very conversational way. Second Place The Tidings, Los Angeles, Calif., “Using deadly force in the line of duty: How cops cope” by R.W. Dellinger A surprising, fresh topic. Covers all the angles with Award N05, Best In-Depth News/Special Reporting, First honesty and grace. A close second. Place, North Texas Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas Third Place The Catholic Northwest Progress, Seattle, Wash., “‘I was in some bishops, leaves others” by Brian Fraga prison and you visited me’” by Kevin This is a great example of how papers of any size can take Birnbaum and Terry McGuire complex subjects and write them in a way that educates its Well done. Responds to a tragedy with a measured, Award N06a, Best Editorial - 1-17,000 Diocesan Paper, readership. This is the type of story that should run in the balanced approach that challenges readers to see the First Place, The Messenger, Belleville, Ill. mainstream press. It is clear, the subject compelling and it humanity in prison inmates in the wake of a shocking is written with grace. death. superbly combines argument and emotion - in this case, Second Place Honorable Mention disgust - to get readers to act. North Texas Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas, “Martyr’s Crown” North Texas Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas, “Our Lady of Second Place by Maria de Lourdes Ruiz Scaperlanda and Tony Gutierrez Guadalupe: Mother of the Americas” by Maria de Lourdes Tennessee Register, Nashville, Tenn., “Bill would create A great narrative that shines a spotlight on a figure that Ruiz Scaperlanda and Tony Gutierrez more religious intolerance; Follow woman’s example as a deserves attention. The New Vision, Tucson, Ariz., “No greater love” by Deacon Christian steward” by Andy Telli Third Place Ed Sheffer. If lawmakers start criminalizing Muslim beliefs, as The Visitor, St. Cloud, Minn., “Growing in Solidarity some Tennessee solons propose, then tenets of Catholicism through Agriculture” by Sue Schulzetenberg N06a may not be far behind. That strategy - pointing out This is a fine example of what happens when local goes that an attack on one religion holds the seeds of your global. It shows how the world is indeed small and how Best Editorial - 1-17,000 Diocesan own destruction - works well in this editorial. The last good reporting enriches all of us. Paper paragraph is an excellent closer. Third Place N04a First Place The U.P. Catholic, Marquette, Mich., “Letter from the Best Investigative News Writing The Messenger, Belleville, Ill., “Driving Decisions” by Liz Editor - Why write about a priest being removed from the Quirin clerical state?” by John Fee This is great storytelling, and the story, of course, has First Place An editor explains in an admirably reader-friendly way a moral. Topic is off the beaten path. Writer gently, but National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “Coverage why newspapers must publish bad news. The reader comes effectively, brings readers to the editorial point. of Sr. Elizabeth Johnson” by Thomas C. Fox and Joshua J. to better understand the watchdog role of the press. The Second Place McElwee sex-abuse scandal grew big under the veil of secrecy, the Northwest Indiana Catholic, Merrillville, Ind., “Soup A thorough, disciplined job on a complicated but central writer notes. So shedding light on current allegations of sex Kitchens-providing hot meals and warm atmosphere” by topic. Accountability angles were stressed throughout the abuse serves the readers and the church. That argument Steve Euvino reporting, with unflinching writing that described where carries much persuasive power. This is another nice example of editorializing by decisions went awry. storytelling. Writer enlightens the reader by giving an Second Place N06c honest, first-hand account about serving at a soup kitchen. National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “Coverage of The editorial point is stated gently, but effectively. Best Editorial - 40,001+ Diocesan Paper Bishop Robert Finn” by Joshua J. McElwee Third Place A close second. Very detailed account of a difficult story. Catholic Anchor, Anchorage, Alaska, “Restless tourists of First Place Went beyond the surface in a measured, balanced manner. searching pilgrims?” by Joel Davidson The Catholic Review, Baltimore, Md., “Summer crime, This editorial/essay richly communicates the majesty fueled by guns” by Christopher Gunty N04b of God’s creation that’s Alaska, adeptly points out the This editorial is reminiscent of a good old-fashioned Best Analysis/ Background/ Round-Up distinction between tourism and pilgrimage and packs newspaper crusade, where the paper itself pursues a cause a powerful editorial punch when it urges the faithful to for the common good. Commentary resists the temptation News Writing: The Gerard E. Sherry travel as pilgrims, not tourists. to over-promise, but answers question why take action if Award it’s only a drop in the bucket. Second Place First Place N06b The Record, Louisville, KY, “The immigration issue” by National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “Coverage of Best Editorial - 17,001-40,000 Diocesan Glenn Rutherford St. Joseph’s Hospital (see headlines below with dates)” by Paper By using the historical example when immigrant Jerry Filteau, Joshua J. McElwee, Tom Roberts, John L. European Catholics were the butt of the sort of prejudice Allen Jr., Dan Morris-Young and Zoe Ryan First Place aimed at today’s Hispanics, writers packs editorial with Very thorough job on a hot-button topic. The writing took The Boston Pilot, Braintree, Mass, “Maria is still talking” persuasive punch. Quoting Jesus on welcoming strangers a measured, clear approach to laying out the key issues. by Antonio M. Enrique, Gregory L. Tracy adds to the persuasiveness. The closing two paragraphs Fine work. This well written editorial makes forceful argument that make a superb kicker. Second Place doubtless rallied some of the troops to take the course Third Place Catholic Courier, Rochester, N.Y., “Fractured dialogue” by called for in the last paragraph. This textbook editorial The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “Extreme sports, good Page 4 The Catholic Journalist June 2012

Newspaper Award Winners

First Place The Compass, Green Bay, Wis., “It’s not about a personal- ity” by Patricia Kasten This is a thoughtful, illuminating discussion on the cult of personality. It doubtless gives helpful guidance to readers. Second Place The Boston Pilot, Braintree, Mass., “Defend the Defense of Marriage Act” by Antonio M. Enrique, Gregory L. Tracy This well reasoned editorial makes about as good a case as can be made in defense of the Defense of Marriage Act. Third Place Catholic Herald, Diocese of Madison, Madison, Wis., “We can’t lose our hearts” by Mary C. Uhler Writer makes good case against sacrificing the poor on the altar of fiscal restraint.

N07c Best Editorial – National or International - 40,001+ Diocesan Paper

First Place Catholic New York, New York, N.Y., “The Temptations of Fame” by Catholic New York This well crafted editorial provides good analysis of the spectacle that is the Charlie Sheen meltdown. The word choice is superb. The “rubbernecking motorists” metaphor is vivid and apt. Fittingly, the editorial doesn’t tsk-tsk. Rather, it recognizes that Sheen is a human being in need of prayers. Second Place The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “John Paul II’s words Award N08, Best Editorial or Editorial Section, First Place, offer guidance for budget debates” by Joe Towalski National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo. This well argued editorial nicely distills three principles Award N07a, Best Editorial, National or International, politicians should keep in mind to protect the poor while 1-17,000 Diocesan Paper, First Place, The Messenger, Bel- tightening budgets. The editorial is potent enough to give and theological issues of our time, NCR covers it all with leville, Ill. pause to legislators across the land. strong writing and a pleasing graphics presentation. The Third Place articles challenge one’s thinking (Bin Laden, Catholic times and the new evangelization” by Joe Towalski The A.D. Times, Allentown, Pa., “Fill me up!” by Fr. Charities, etc.) and the opinion pieces reflect a broad The Cathedral of St. Paul should be more than a Michael Mullins spectrum of thought. Editorials (gay marriage, budget, backdrop to a popular extreme sport, “ice cross downhill.” This editorial has a lively style and a novel approach, etc.) bring moral considerations to the issues of the day. The church should seize that opportunity to evangelize in drawing parallels between steps to take to travel more Reflections on the scripture readings are particularly a soft-sell way. Readers can only nod an agreement to the efficiently by car and steps to take to travel to heaven. strong, and the book reviews are compelling. writer’s effective argument. Second Place The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “This Catholic Life” N07d by The Catholic Spirit Staff N07a Best Editorial – National or Wow — from history lessons to personal reflections, from Best Editorial – National or International - National Newspaper religious experiences to addressing current topics, the International - 1-17,000 Diocesan Paper Catholic Spirit does it all. Some articles could be tightened First Place (note the letter to the editor indicating the busyness of life First Place National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “Theolo- and difficulty getting to read The Spirit). Congratulations The Messenger, Belleville, Ill., “Troy Davis Is Dead; Do You gians, bishops called to dialogue, trust” by NCR editors on the very creative “Opinions in 140 Characters” in Care?” by Liz Quirin This is a great editorial/dissertation. The writing is the Feb. 3 edition; could that be a regular feature? Very Writer has a nice, friendly style. She compellingly shows elegant and engaging. The topic, though maybe appearing interesting reading. why we should be concerned about the execution of Troy esoteric at first, is fresh and relevant. The ideas are big, Third Place Davis, put to death even though several witnesses had but expressed simply. The call for reconciliation between Catholic News Herald, Charlotte, N.C., “Best Editorial recanted the testimony that had let to his conviction. The theologians and bishops is persuasive. Section” by Catholic News Herald staff death penalty is much debated, but writer seems to bring Second Place Kudos for the short immigration item in the April fresh eyes to that debate. Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind., “Bin Laden’s death” 8th edition, with the strong map graphic and sanserif Second Place by OSV editorial board typeface to draw attention. Other editorials and columns The Monitor, Trenton, N.J., “No moral standing for deny- Jesus’ call to love your enemy is “an almost impossible might benefit from brevity. Good use of varied voices. ing the DREAM” by Rayanne Bennett admonition,” this editorial notes, particularly when that The use of pullout quotes and photo art enhances graphic Writer gives a good explanation of the DREAM Act and enemy has the blood of thousands on his hands. But in presentation. Msg. Marcaccio article on Lent and the makes a compelling case that passing it is the morally right reading this well-written commentary on the death of crucifix particularly well-written. course for Congress. In bringing the reader face-to-face Osama bin Laden, the reader becomes more motivated to Honorable Mention with the ignoble motives for opposing the act, the editorial’s do the almost impossible. Catholic Anchor, Anchorage, Alaska, “On whose authority?” fifth paragraph is particularly effective. Third Place by Joel Davidson Third Place National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “Timely note Catholic Post, The, Peoria, Ill., “Penn State-inspired exam . reflects Catholic vision” by NCR editors N09a . . of conscience” by Thomas J. Dermody This editorial is exceptionally lucid and has a neat wry Best Feature Writing - 1-17,000 By looking at the firing of legendary Penn State football tone when talking about critics of the Vatican’s call for coach Joe Paterno through the lens of the Gospel, this reforming the global financial system. The editorial is an Diocesan Paper editorial/sermonette adds a dimension of understanding. effective rebuttal to those critics. The editorial goes into an insightful, provocative discussion First Place The Catholic Northwest Progress, Seattle, Wash., “A dad about sins of omission. N08 Honorable Mention who talked little about the war finally gets his medal” by The Messenger, Belleville, Ill., “Drawing Lines in Sand for Best Editorial or Editorial Section Terry McGuire Children” by Liz Quirin Author intricately weaves the back story with the current First Place events while exposing the overall meaning to be made in a National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “Opinion & well-written piece with good lay-out. N07b Arts section” by NCR staff and contributors Second Place Best Editorial – National or Interna- From the mundane circumstances of life (clutter) to Catholic Anchor, Anchorage, Alaska, “Losing weight and tional - 17,001-40,000 Diocesan Paper history (papal trips) from stories of personal triumph gaining God” by Patricia Coll Freeman (Winddcheley) to serious discussion of the philosophical Very interesting concept told in clear and engaging June 2012 The Catholic Journalist Page 5

Newspaper Award Winners

and mission to educate their community. Second Place The Criterion, Indianapolis, Ind. , “’They love you uncondi- tionally’: It’s a dog’s world through pet ministry program at St. Vincent Hospital” by John Shaughnessy A cute story about the comfort and healing pets can pro- vide at an area hospital. Well written. Third Place The Catholic Review, Baltimore, Md., “Special report: Deep-rooted Polish faith faces secular challenge” by George P. Matysek Jr. A well documented story that doesn’t forget the human element in a battle between ancient faith and modern life. Honorable Mention Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va. , “Lighter weight, heavier pockets” by Gretchen R. Crowe The Evangelist, Albany, N.Y. , “Biogas project wins prizes” by Angela Cave

N09d Best Feature Writing – National Newspaper

First Place Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind. , “Beyond the num- bers: Faces of homelessness” by Brian Fraga, Maryann Gogniat Eidemiller, Michelle Martin, Woodeene Koenig- Bricker and Tom Tracy Award N09a, Best Feature Writing- 1-17,000 Diocesan Pa- Comprehensive look at the statistics of homeless and per, First Place, The Catholic Northwest Progress, Seattle, the people trapped in a life without a home unless they Wash. are fortunate enough to be embraced by those who care. Thought provoking and alarming. manner. Second Place Third Place Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind. , “Losing a spouse” The Messenger, Belleville, Ill., “Coping With War Wounds: by Emily Stimpson Award N09b, Best Feature Writing- 17,000-40,000 Diocesan Families that must cope daily with post-traumatic stress A well documented look at a need as expressed by those Paper, First Place, Catholic Universe Bulletin, Cleveland, disorder” by Liz Quirin who must fulfill that need and those who cry out that their Ohio Excellent use of media to illuminate issues that can go need be fulfilled. A complicated issue that presents a real unnoticed. Language is solid and piece is logically written. challenge. Honorable Mention N10b Third Place Hawaii Catholic Herald, Honolulu, Hawaii, “Surfer Catholic News Service, Washington, D.C. , “Tweet at St. Best Personality Profile - 17,001-40,000 embraces family’s faith through tragedy” by Darlene Dela Pete’s: What happens when bloggers and the Vatican Diocesan Paper Cruz meet” by Carol Glatz First Place Catholic Anchor, Anchorage, Alaska, “Byzantine bishop Just a fun, well written piece bringing together, well, Catholic Sentinel, Portland, Ore., “Communicating the reflects on effort to heal Christianity’s East-West divide” by almost, two cultures. Perhaps this is the dove meeting the Word of God is his passion” by Ed Langlois Joel Davidson tweet. The writing style, choice of details and use of language Honorable Mention create a beautiful profile of the subject and draw the N09b National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo. , “A safer reader into his world through the atmosphere created. The Best Feature Writing - 17,001-40,000 world; Working toward a new ‘peace culture’” by subject’s various life experiences flow nicely. Joshua J. McElwee Second Place Diocesan Paper National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “New faces The Compass, Green Bay, Wis., “Heller’s pen sketches more of consecrated life in Latin America; Orders than cartoons” by Sam Lucero First Place attract indigenous women” by Barbara Fraser The opening details of this piece give wonderful insight Catholic Universe Bulletin, Cleveland, Ohio, “Under at into the subject’s personality and daily life and work. Other Galician Sun” by Nancy Erikson details about specific cartoons, how they were developed Excellent use of celebrities to frame the value and essence N10a and reaction to them solidifies this personality profile. of the pilgrimage, Nice lay-out, strong writing. Best Personality Profile - 1-17,000 Third Place Second Place Diocesan Paper The Catholic Moment, Lafayette, Ind., “75 years later: ‘It’s Rhode Island Catholic, Providence, R.I., “Strong faith, been a perfect life for me’” by Kevin Cullen prayer help in cancer recovery” by Rick A. Snizek First Place The subject’s faith, sense of purpose and devotion to Beautifully written piece that ties together many of the Catholic Anchor, Anchorage, Alaska, “Unexpected casket teaching truly shine in this article. The choice of quotes complexities of the issue. Strong opener to set the tone. maker” by Joel Davidson gives the reader a great sense of her personality. Third Place The visual details provided through the written word Honorable Mention The Catholic Miscellany, Charleston, S.C., “The Gospel of give a great sense of who the subject is - a down-to-earth Catholic Messenger, Davenport, Iowa, “Bishop Amos Mark” by Christina Lee Knauss man desiring to use his talents to serve others. Excellent visual lay-out really adds to the message. The celebrates 10 years as a bishop” by Barb Arland-Fye Second Place content and the clarity of its language is impressive. Catholic Anchor, Anchorage, Alaska, “Messaging monk Honorable Mention keeps Facebook authentic” by Joel Davidson N10c The Catholic Miscellany, Charleston, S.C., “For theirs is the This article reveals the subject’s personality and desire Best Personality Profile - 40,001+ Kingdom of Heaven” by Amy Wise Taylor for quality human connections and discussions even in the The Colorado Catholic Herald, Colorado Springs, Colo., Diocesan Paper sometimes restricted world of social media through good “ActivPrayer: Innovative theology of the body-based use of details and quotes. wellness program takes New Evangelization into gyms, First Place Third Place health clubs and parks” by Bill Howard The Criterion, Indianapolis, Ind., “’Lost Boy of Sudan’ The Catholic Northwest Progress, Seattle, Wash., “Pastor’s recounts harrowing story of survival” by Mary Ann Wyand illness provides teachable moments” by Terry McGuire This article is an excellent testimony to the power human N09c This profile shows how faith and friends can help in beings have to overcome immense hardship and do good. Best Feature Writing - 40,001+ times of adversity. The use of language, word choice and Without being preachy or even using God as an explanation, Diocesan Paper quotes create a sense of atmosphere for what the subject the writer shares the story of a man who found strength to went through in his illness and the many emotions he felt. fight for those left behind. First Place Second Place The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “Tragedy Trans- Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “A daughter’s formed” by Dave Hrbacek gift” by Katie Collins A stirring and sensitive portrayal of a family’s tragedy This article shows how suffering and compassion can lead to deeper and more profound faith. It speaks to the strength Page 6 The Catholic Journalist June 2012

Newspaper Award Winners

create colorful word pictures, and invite readers into considering how art as a reflection of life can teach about the most profound spiritual realities gracing our world. Second Place Georgia Bulletin, Smyrna, Ga., “Columns by David A. King” by David A. King Top notch and engaging writing captures the attention of readers in these columns. Dipping once again into classics in text and film the reviews remind readers that sacred truths have perennial qualities. Third Place Tennessee Register, Nashville, Tenn., “Reel Life Journeys - During Lent we learn the true meaning of true grit; Harry Potter’s love for his friends triumphs over all; The courage to change deplorable situations can be found within” by Christopher Fenoglio Easy to read and full of insights, these columns bring the “real” to the reel. Honorable Mention Idaho Catholic Register, Boise, Idaho, “The Nez Perce story of creation” by Rosa Yearout

N11b Best Regular Column - Spiritual Life

First Place National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “Jesus calls Award N10d, Best Personality Profile, National Newspaper, us outside of the temple; Life flourishes when we receive First Place, Maria de Lourdes Ruiz Scaperlanda, Norman, Eucharist; A rite’s richness suggests abundant life” by Okla. Melissa Musick Nussbaum These are top- notch well-written columns that teach, Award N11c, Best Regular Column- Scripture, First Place, reflect, and offer a loving critique. Nussbaum’s sacramental of women as caregivers and endurers of unexpected lots. The Tablet, Brooklyn, N.Y. awareness and sensitivity is evidenced in the captivating The article is well-written and offers good detail. stories and well-crafted questions she pens. Third Place Honorable Mention The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “To hell and back” by Second Place The Evangelist, Albany, N.Y., “Seminarian’s diary column Catholic San Francisco, San Francisco, Calif., “N11c - Julie Carroll (Facing discouragement in ministry, Chopping for life, Scripture” by Sister Eloise Rosenblatt, Ph.D. This article frames a powerful story of service and How to cram for an exam)” by Dan Quinn, Brian Slezak courage around respect for all faiths and sincere care for and Scott VanDerveer humanity as a whole. It depicts Catholicism as a way to do N11d The seminarians writing these columns are refreshingly good no matter in which country or to which person. honest. Their theological reflections indicate what they Best Regular Column - General Honorable Mention teach, what they preach and what they believe. Their Catholic News Herald, Charlotte, N.C., “Man on a mission” Commentary writing is clear and the stories make good sense. by SueAnn Howell Third Place First Place The Monitor, Trenton, N.J., “Things My Father Taught National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “Thrift store N10d Me” by Mary Morrell spirituality; Dangers of hero worship; Unsung (and under- Best Personality Profile - National Morrell writes engagingly with a ecumenical spirit. Her paid) heroes of the parish” by Heidi Schlumpf Newspaper openness to the religious sensibilities of others teaches her Beautifully written stories with clearly expressed moral readers truths they might not hear. She tells a story well lessons. Schlumpf finds in her everyday experiences lessons and the stories portray the deeper meanings of faith. of faith. First Place Second Place Scaperlanda, Maria de Lourdes Ruiz, Norman, Okla., ““No Honorable Mention Capecchi, Christina, Inver Grove Heights, Minn., “Twenty Denver Catholic Register, Denver, Colo., “The Catholic Dif- Greater Love, No Greater Sacrifice”” by Maria de Lourdes Something: Giving thanks for ‘all things in good plenty’; ference: Russiona orthodoxy and Lenin’s tomb; Tim Tebow Ruiz Scaperlanda, Our Sunday Visitor Stained-glass spirituality: The power of Christ’s light; and Christophobia; Downsizing-to-grow in Ireland” by This article is emotionally engaging due to a captivating Puppy love, whale watching and St. Francis” by Christina George Weigel opening and good use of detail throughout. It is a Capecchi George Weigel’s columns are informative and thought- testimony to the power of faith in the most threatening provoking. He provides historical background that helps circumstances. readers put current events in perspective, and he builds his Second Place N11c analysis and arguments like a teacher of logic. National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “A prophet- Best Regular Column - Scripture Third Place ic, transforming priest” by Joshua J. McElwee Clarion Herald, New Orleans, La., “‘Sister, why is it easier This article tells a complete and sometimes First Place to get a gun than a job?’” by Peter Finney Jr. uncomfortable story of a man who lives in extremes - first The Tablet, Brooklyn, N.Y., “Sunday’s Scriptures” by Peter Finney is storyteller — a good one. In his stories as a self-righteous defendant of the status quo and then as Father Thomas Catania about Marvin Watts, Walter Bonam and Brian Kelly, he a radical willing to serve jail time for his civil disobedience. Clever introductions using contemporary examples appeals to each of us to look at our own lives. The author uses good detail. tease anxious readers into these well written scripture Honorable Mention Third Place reflections. The author is a strong teacher who leaves Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “The ultimate CHA Catholic Health World, St. Louis, Mo., “Doctor’s the reader wanting more of his interesting and insightful BFFs, The game of life, Vernazza’s buried dream” by mission is modernizing Vietnamese medical care” by Suzy lessons of the scripture. Gretchen R. Crowe Farren Second Place The Boston Pilot, Braintree, Mass., “Where are the angels?, This is an article of international relevance that shows Catholic Exponent, Youngstown, Ohio, “Picnic table is spe- Dr. Bernard Nathanson, R.I.P., Protecting children from the power of people of faith to shape relations between cial place to meet characters; Since the Garden of Eden, toxic education” by Dale O’Leary countries and the destinies of people in need. we’ve all be wandering exiles; It takes growing faith to ‘step out’ of our own boat” by Father James P. Walker N11a These catchy columns are written with colorful language N11e Best Regular Column - Culture and enticing stories with a new twist on understanding the Best Regular Column - Family Life scriptures. The Arts and Leisure Third Place First Place National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “The Word: Tennessee Register, Nashville, Tenn., “(Faithful Marriages) First Place Scripted for Life” by Patricia Datchuck Sanchez Connections online can slide boundaries of proper relation- National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “The devil Datchuck Sanchez writes theologically sound reflections ships; Following path to holiness in marriage takes cour- is back and he’s still mad; Dark knights of the soul; Sports on the weekly scriptures in rich prose full of explanation age; Self-denial is good for your marriage and your soul” by films and faith” by Rose Pacatte and context. John Bosio The author of these columns knows how to tell a story, Strongly written columns on contemporary issues and June 2012 The Catholic Journalist Page 7

Newspaper Award Winners

Athletics are often put on too high of a plain; or seen with disdain via interloping parents. “In Jesus Name We Play,” shows good sports in the light of fatih. Nicely done. Honorable Mention Catholic Standard, Washington, D.C., “Love for teacher with cancer is made in a shave” by Mark Zimmermann Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “Unmasking cultures” by Gretchen R. Crowe

N12b Best Reporting on a Special Age Group Teenagers

First Place The Criterion, Indianapolis, Ind., “‘Called to Glory’: Youths at NCYC honor Christ with electronic ‘holy shout-out’” by Criterion Staff ‘Called to Glory’ shows and tells the excitement of faith. The ‘Holy shout-out’ was hopefully as much fun to read as it was to attend. I was sold when Bishop Coyne called the attendees to pull out their cell phones. Great photos paints an exciting event captured extremely well. It even included teens and the Sacrament of Reconciliation. Second Place The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “Cristo Rey students step out and up” by Pat Norby The story of Gabby DeLuna and Nestor Ramierez is captivating as is the story of the first graduating class at Cristo Rey High School. Third Place Award N13, Best Photo Story Originating with a Newspa- Idaho Catholic Register, Boise, Idaho, “Bishop to youths: per, First Place, Catholic New World, Chicago, Ill. Award N12a, Best Reporting on a Special Age Group- Chil- God’s calling you” by Loretta Gossi, Ann Bixby, Michael dren, First Place, The Evangelist, Albany, N.Y. Brown The details in this article give a wonderful sense of who The story and photo mix is a great read. Bishop Driscoll these sisters are and how their faith and sense of service challenges to marriage. Citations from experts on each tells teens they are called to greatness. Teens pray for continue to drive their actions. topic strengthen the columns. The Questions for Reflection a miracle. The ministry of technology and quoting from Third Place at the conclusion of each column encourage readers’ further Facebook put a new face on the future. Arkansas Catholic, Little Rock, Ark., “Veterans battling for thoughts. Honorable Mention their lives” by Dwain Hebda Second Place The Evangelist, Albany, N.Y., “Special Issue: Catholic The veterans featured in this article come alive on the Catholic News Service, Washington, D.C., “Your Family” by Teens” by staff page through great use of details and language. Their faith Bill Dodds, Monica Dodds also shines through the use of quotes. With a touch of humor, the Dodds offer readers sound practical advice, often in easy-to-read list form. Each N12c column also includes references for more information on the Best Reporting on a Special Age Group N13 topic. - Young Adults Best Photo Story Originating with a Third Place Newspaper The Colorado Catholic Herald, Colorado Springs, Colo., First Place “Family Matters” by Dr. Michael O’Donnell The Catholic Review, Baltimore, Md., “Growing Up Millen- First Place Well-written and easy to read, Dr. O’Donnell’s columns nial” by Matt Palmer Catholic New World, Chicago, Ill., “A ‘place of angels’” by are filled with practical advice for parents. Strong headlines The variety of coverage in this special series is extensive Joyce Duriga and Karen Callaway draw readers into the topic. Number agreement (he or she/ and provides a good sense of young adults, their thought This entry has a story, emotion and a connection between they) in the use of pronouns was problematic. processes, struggles and hopes. The mixture of quotes and the subject and the reader. It has that emotional connection Honorable Mention researched facts blends nicely. that makes me feel the photographer went beyond North Texas Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas, “Graduates are Second Place recording an event and captured the essence of the event. celebrating with joy; Parents make very real sacrifices; The The Tidings, Los Angeles, Calif., “At St. Peter Chanel: ‘Not Second Place stockings were hung” by Kathy Cribari Hamer an ordinary’ group of young adults” by Doris Benavides El Mensajero Catolico, Rochester, N.Y., “Una celebración Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “Modesty The subjects in this piece come alive through the many del quinceañero” by Mike Crupi manifesto, Thank you God, Family dinners” by Barbara details provided; the reader has a sense of sitting in on the A good solid story. Quality of the images could have been Curtis conversation rather than just reading it. Great reporting stronger but the story comes through. Not just a group of on young adults serving young adults. pictures but a story from beginning to end. N12a Third Place Third Place Best Reporting on a Special Age Group North Texas Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas, “Emerging; The Southern Cross, Savannah, Ga., “Bishop Hartmayer’s Reconnect;” by Juan Guajardo, Chris Kastner and Tony Ordination - A pictorial documentation of the Ordination” Children Gutierrez by Paul H. Camp, Michael J. Johnson, Jonas N. Jordan and This special section nicely shows the struggle to connect Daniel D. Mai First Place young adults with the church. The different pieces The photographer went beyond the standard middle The Evangelist, Albany, N.Y., “Catholic School Spotlight complement and flow together well and offer the sense that distant photographs and found angle and viewpoint that series” by Angela Cave more needs to be done. made the images visually exciting. Once again weaving With stories ranging from ‘Cultural Awareness’ to ‘Chess them together in a cohesive story. Club’ this entry shows the breadth and excitement of Honorable Mention youth. The Evangelist shows its care and hopes for our N12d The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “Journey through the children with quality and wide coverage. Best Reporting on a Special Age Group Easter Triduum” by Dave Hrbacek Second Place - Senior Citizens The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “Catholic Schools N14a Week” by The Catholic Spirit Staff First Place The Catholic Spirit discovered ways to bring children Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind., “Staying connected” Best Photograph - Best Feature Photo into our living rooms. And helped us enjoy them. Children by Maryann Gogniat Eidemiller (Black and White or Color) learning Spanish and good business practices are articles The variety of coverage in this special section shows the we want to read. A photo of a business executive talking to vibrancy of seniors’ lives and provides interesting and rel- First Place urban students was enticing. evant material for seniors and for other readers. Catholic Star Herald, Camden, N.J., “Tea time at St. Third Place Second Place Mary’s” by James A. McBride The Catholic Sun, Phoenix, Ariz., “‘In Jesus name we play’: Long Island Catholic, Roosevelt, N.Y., “’Retired’ sisters A nice moment that captures the sense of comradery and Catholic sports league promotes character” by Ambria serve in new ways” by Mary Iapalucci companionship among the subjects. Hammel Page 8 The Catholic Journalist June 2012

Newspaper Award Winners

quake” by Bob Roller Clearly illustrates the closeness and plight of this family. Second Place Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “Portraits of a holy life” by Gerald Martineau Nice use of layering the artist’s paintings around him. Third Place Northwest Indiana Catholic, Merrillville, Ind., “Newly ordained Deacon Ben Ross reads his orders by the window in the chapel at Holy Angels Cathedral following the ordination.” by Michael McArdle Good use of a silhouette.

N14d Best Photograph - Best Scenic, Still Life or Weather Photo

First Place Catholic News Service, Washington, D.C., “Pope Holds Candle at Window Overlooking St. Peter’s Square Christ- mas Eve” by Paul Haring Love the candle lit Pope juxtaposed with the Christmas lights on the tree. Second Place Northwest Indiana Catholic, Merrillville, Ind., “Heavy storm clouds roll through St. John, forcing the dedication of the our Lady of the New Millennium statue indoors.” by Michael McArdle The sky and empty seats give a dark and stormy feel to the dedication ceremony. I like the person taking one last photo before being forced indoors. Award N14b. Best Photograph, Best General News Photo, Third Place First Place, Hawaii Catholic Herald, Honolulu, Hawaii Arkansas Catholic, Little Rock, Ark., “Record snow” by Brian Owens Award N14f, Best Photograph- Best Sports Photo, First Second Place Nice weather image for that part of the country. The Place, The Criterion, Indianapolis, Ind. Catholic Courier, Rochester, N.Y., “Hundreds elect to join footsteps lead you into the stark image. church” by Mike Crupi Classic image that illustrates the good work done by N14e members of the clergy. N15a Third Place Best Photograph - Best Photo Catholic News Service, Washington, D.C., “Boy Holds Illustration Best Multiple Picture Package Origi- Scriptures Aloft during Procession at Catholic Church in nating with the Newspaper - News Kenya” by Nancy Wiechec First Place Good use of framing and capturing the moment. The Catholic Miscellany, Charleston, S.C., “Do you long for First Place Honorable Mention more? National Vocation Awareness Week” by Deirdre C. The Tidings, Los Angeles, Calif., “‘Go forth with confi- Northwest Indiana Catholic, Merrillville, Ind., “Being Mays dence...’” by Victor Aleman brave for St. Baldricks” by Michael McArdle Nice layering and framing with the cross. Nice candid moment, and a good dominant image. Second Place Second Place N14b The Boston Pilot, Braintree, Mass., “Parishes adjust to new One Voice, Birmingham, Ala., “‘A Monumental Disaster’” by Mass translation” by Gregory L. Tracy Mary D. Dillard Best Photograph - Best General News Nice simple image containing a new response in the new Great opening shot. Good variety of “disaster” shots. Photo (Black and White or Color) translation. Third Place Third Place Catholic Voice, Omaha, Neb., “Archbishop ordains four to First Place Northwest Indiana Catholic, Merrillville, Ind., “Married for priesthood” by Lisa Maxson, Ashlee Schuette Hawaii Catholic Herald, Honolulu, Hawaii, “An inmate Llife-The Wedding and After” by Michael Nicely captures “the moment” warmly embraces her son” by Darlene Dela Cruz McArdle Honorable Mention Good emotional images. Well executed and tell the whole Color stands out on a simple straight forward image Catholic News Herald, Charlotte, N.C., “Bishop urges: Be story in one single photograph. representing marriage. witnesses to God’s love” by SueAnn Howell, Ruben Tamayo, Second Place Kate Drinkwater Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “Veterans Day N14f remembrance” by Ann M. Augherton N15b Nice moment in a subject that is full of good Best Photograph - Best Sports Photo opportunities photographer found something a little out of Best Multiple Picture Package Origi- First Place the ordinary. The Criterion, Indianapolis, Ind., “In our hearts: A friend’s nating with the Newspaper - Feature Third Place death leads softball team on emotional journey to champi- El Mensajero Catolico, Rochester, N.Y., “Carrera honra a onship” by Sean Gallagher First Place soldados caídos” by Tamara Tirado Catholic New World, Chicago, Ill., “A ‘Place of angels’” by Great anticipation to capture the faces and emotions of so A little bit of a cliche but the photographer stayed alert Karen Callaway, Joyce Duriga many players. to opportunities and took advantage of it. The best photo stories engage the reader/viewer. This one Second Place Honorable Mention made me smile. Catholic News Service, Washington, D.C., “Tarantulas Catholic San Francisco, San Francisco, Calif., “N14b - Best Player Attacks Ball During Practice in Port-au-Prince” by Second Place general news photo - black and white OR color” by Jose CHA Catholic Health World, St. Louis, Mo., “Street Medi- Bob Roller Luis Aguirre cine in Pittsburgh” by Martha Rial, photographer, Judith Simple concise image on the challenges and desire to play The A.D. Times, Allentown, P.A., “Blaise Eidle, 5, of VandeWater, reporter soccer no matter your physical situation. Wyomissing, helps Bishop Barres hold his staff during a Great images and nicely displayed. Third Place reception after the liturgy” by Ed Koskey Catholic New York, New York, N.Y., “Turf Battle” by Maria Third Place El Mensajero Catolico, Rochester, N.Y., “Eventos destacan R. Bastone las culturas hispanas” by Mike Crupi N14c Great action and tied in the new turf field as material Very fun. Nice variety. Best Photograph - Best Portrait is kicked up by the shoe. Should have cropped it a little tighter. Honorable Mention Catholic News Service, Washington, D.C., “Pantry counts First Place Honorable Mention blessings for food for needy, wishes more could be done” by Catholic News Service, Washington, D.C., “Haitian Family Texas Catholic, Dallas, Texas, “Beating the heat” by Jenna Nancy Wiechec Remains in Tent after House Destroyed in 2010 Earth- Teter June 2012 The Catholic Journalist Page 9

Newspaper Award Winners

N16c Best Use of Art or Graphics - Best Chart or Information Graphic

First Place Catholic Courier, Rochester, N.Y., “Hydrofracking” by Linda Jeanne Rivers This piece is eye-catching, graphically pleasing and informative. The use of a cross-section was a good choice for this graphic, and the information provided complements the article. Second Place National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “Lasallian cross-country journey” by Toni-Ann Ortiz, Joshua McEl- wee This graphic helps the reader to join the riders on their cross-country journey and have an idea of what each day will be like. The background wheel graphic in the piece is quite nice and adds tremendously to the graphic. Third Place Catholic News Service, Washington, D.C., “Extent and History of Sexual Abuse Against Minors by U.S. Catholic Award N16c, Best Use of Art or Graphics- Best Chart or In- Clergy” by Emily Thompsom and Nancy Wiechec formative Graphic, First Place, Catholic Courier, Rochester, This chart provides a wealth of information in visual and N.Y. text form and helps the reader better see the history of this particular issue. Catholic News Herald, Charlotte, N.C., “Seeing God Dogs” by SueAnn Howell, Doreen Sugierski, Tim Reid, Mollie N17 Gordon, Suzanne Konopka, Ryan Murray Best Headline Award N18a, Best Regular Special Supplement, First Place, The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn. N16a First Place Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “Let there be Best Use of Art or Graphics - Art or lights” by Dave Borowski N18b Graphics Gets a recognized religious (Biblical) phrase into a strong Best One-Time Special Issue and informative headline. First Place Second Place First Place Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind., “Beyond the num- Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “The meaning Clarion Herald, New Orleans, La., “A Hero’s Life: Arch- bers: Faces of homelessness” by Lindsey Riesen and Tyler of life, with a side of burritos” by Dave Borowski bishop Philip Matthew Hannan supplement” by Clarion Ottinger Gets a recognized religious/philosophical phrase --plus Herald Staff The use of graphics in this piece convey the atmosphere humor into a strong headline. Scrapbook-style layout is clever and inviting. Highlights in which homeless people live and the fact that it’s a Third Place key aspects or a rich, remarkable life. Very thorough, nationwide issue. This is an excellent use of elements to Catholic Standard, Washington, D.C., “On a wing (or a detailed job. Could put a hard cover on it and sell it in accompany the article. hoof or a paw) and prayer” by Richard Szczepanowski stores. Second Place A strong headline that can be read in two ways and has Second Place Western New York Catholic, Buffalo, N.Y., “Catholic Com- a religious connection. Catholic New York, New York, N.Y., “9/11: Our Shared munications Campaign” by Carolyn Luick Honorable Mention Journey” by Staff of Catholic New York The streams of light in this graphic suggest action Catholic Sun, Syracuse, N.Y., “Preparing to launch: the Took what could have been an obligatory-type assignment and movement of the word of God through multiple new Roman Missal” by Connie Berry and identified fresh, new angles. Well written and communication channels. The graphic is eye-catching for its The Dialog, Wilmington, Del., “Every day is sun day at St. structured. color and its sense of movement. Mary of the Assumption” by Joseph Ryan Third Place Third Place The Leaven, Kansas City, Kan., “Kansas Youth” by Leaven Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “The Way of the N18a staff Cross” by Stacy Rausch Great use of quotes to highlight youth voices. Time and The placement of the stations of the cross along the Best Regular Special Supplement resources spent on this topic are commendable. pathway that wraps in on itself is pleasing, draws the Honorable Mention First Place reader in and serves as a nice guide. Arkansas Catholic, Little Rock, Ark., “A Century of Faith The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “Leading With Faith” in News” by Emily Roberts, Malea Hargett, Phyllis Hemann by The Catholic Spirit Staff Georgia Bulletin, Smyrna, Ga., “Remembering Archbishop N16b Excellent design immediately says this is a special John F. Donoghue 1928-2011” by Georgia Bulletin staff Best Use of Art or Graphics - Best section on leadership. Good use of photos of those honored Original Illustration in which they are shown equally. Second Place N18c First Place The Catholic Spirit, Metuchen, N.J., “Jubilees” by The Best Special Supplement on an Hawaii Catholic Herald, Honolulu, Hawaii, “Hawaii’s Catholic Spirit staff Ordinary’s Transition international clergy” by Patrick Downes A traditional look that demonstrates why it’s traditional. Excellent photo displayed well. This section boldly says This artwork is perfectly suited for the story it First Place what it is, an excellent look. accompanies, is eye-catching, is interesting to view and is Catholic Herald, Milwaukee, Wis., “Love never fails” by Third Place artistically pleasing. Staff Texas Catholic, Dallas, Texas, “Catholic Schools: There’s Second Place A very complete package, from well-designed and inviting An App for That (Catholic Schools Week extra)” by Texas St. Louis Review, St. Louis, Mo., “Filling our conscience the cover to well-planned and executed stories and sidebars. Catholic staff government way” by Lisa Johnston The details were colorful and telling. You could tell the staff This was tough since I liked it best of all, but couldn’t The silhouette against the bright background is pleasing, had fun putting it together. determine whether there really is an app for each of the the artwork nicely conveys the theme of the story it Second Place schools. I couldn’t find one in the iTunes store. Still, very accompanies and the boldness of the entire piece works The Criterion, Indianapolis, Ind., “Our New Auxiliary Bish- imaginative. very nicely. op” by Criterion Staff Honorable Mention Third Place A close second. Strong, unified presentation, thorough The Visitor, St. Cloud, Minn., “World Mission Sunday” by Catholic Standard, Washington, D.C., “Get me to the reporting, clear writing. Staff church on time” by Gloria Marconi Third Place The Observer, Rockford, Ill., “Ashes to Ashes, A Guide to This piece is fun, has personality and provides a quick Catholic New World, Chicago, Ill., “Welcome * Bienvenidos Lent” by The Observer Staff glance into what the article is about. There is also a nice * Witamy” by New World Publications Staff sense of action and urgency in the piece. A unique challenge — two people and two ethnic groups. Page 10 The Catholic Journalist June 2012

Newspaper Award Winners

St. Joe Bruins” by Mississippi Catholic Staff

N20b Best Sports Journalism - Sports Fea- ture or Column

First Place The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “Former NFL QB hands off skills, faith to Pionner team” by Dave Hrbacek Splendid example of how sports can serve the faithful (and not the other way around). Great subject. A story told simply enough to apply anywhere. Good interviews, nice quotes. Second Place Catholic New York, New York, N.Y., “Tender Ceremony at Parish Cemetery Recalls ‘Yonkers Favorite’ Boxer” by Ron Lajoie Great story, well told. Histories - two countries, one neighborhood, one family - interwoven in the Church. Third Place Clarion Herald, New Orleans, La., “CCC: Inspiration, perspiration and hallucination” by Peter Finney Jr. Nice personalized reflection. Ties the Garden of Eden, Lenten asceticism & N’awlins culture into sports. Award N19, Best Special Supplement or Special Issue with Honorable Mention Advertising Emphasis, First Place, Montana Catholic, Hel- Northwest Indiana Catholic, Merrillville, Ind., “Parent’s ena, Mont. faith, girl’s spirit, school support equal winning team” by Steve Euvino Developed a package aimed at Spanish, Polish and English-speaking readers. A very notable effort. N21 Honorable Mention Award N21, Best Seasonal Issue, First Place, North Texas The Tidings, Los Angeles, Calif., “A quarter century of Best Seasonal Issue Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas history” by The Tidings Staff First Place North Texas Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas , “Easter Issue” As They Begin Ministry” by Michael Alexander, Stephen N19 by Jeff Hensley, Tony Gutierrez and Judy Russeau O’Kane and Andrew Nelson Best Special Supplement or Special A bold 4-color cover leads into a strong center section on Trio of biographies interwoven into one solid tapestry. Issue with Advertising Empahsis Christmas with full pages on catechesis, personal stories, Good interviews & well utilized quotes set it apart. and a center double truck on Our Lady Of Guadalupe Honorable Mention The Catholic Review, Baltimore, Md., ““I was lost, but now First Place with a visual guide to the image’s significant elements. Approached from multiple angles, smoothly written staff am found”” by Matt Palmer Montana Catholic, Helena, Mont., “Annual Catholic Appeal” by Brooke Tierney and Renee St. Martin Wizeman stories pick up aspects of the Christmas story including Appeals to logic, emotion and faith create a powerful Simeon. N23 campaign. Second Place Best Coverage of Immigration Second Place The Catholic Register, Toronto, Ontario, Canada “For God The Boston Pilot, Braintree, Mass., “The Boston Pilot: Best so loved the world that He gave His only Son” by Staff First Place Special Issue Women Religious” by Staff Apart from the major Catholic news, every story on every National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo., “Staking An in-depth and well-reported feature rich in fact, page of this issue presents some aspect of Christmas. The their lives; A haven for the injured; Economists project history and details. center section reproduces Christmas art from the school remittance increase; Not enough to stem the tide” by Bar- Third Place children of the diocese along with a 4-page section of lyrics bara Fraser and Alice Popovici Texas Catholic, Dallas, Texas, “March Gladness” by Texas of Christmas carols. As a package, the Register earned a The quote from Jose Maria Ortiz tells the immigration Catholic Staff strong second place. story, almost completely, “Sometimes you make desicions A visually compelling congratulatory campaign. Third Place that don’t seem like the best ones, but you have to try.” The Honorable Mention The Visitor, St. Cloud, Minn., “Christmas” by Staff National Catholic Reporter puts a face on the immigraiton The Boston Pilot, Braintree, Mass., “The Boston Pilot: Best The Christmas issue begins with a major front page story crisis with articles and photos in “Staking their lives” and Special Issue Open House” by Staff on Las Posadas, The Visitor provides a center double truck “A haven for the injured and “Not enough to stem the tide.” of the winners of the children’s Christmas art competition, This section should be put in every pew in every church. strong columns and opinion pieces on the season, including N20a Second Place one on New Year’s Day. The Catholic Sun, Phoenix, AZ, “Church confronts Mexican Best Sports Journalism - Sports News Honorable Mention violence” by J.D. Long-Garcia The Georgia Bulletin, Smyrna, Ga., “Easter 2011” by The Catholic Sun mixes the many sides and voices of the First Place Georgia Bulletin staff immigration issues extremely well. It shows the people on The Compass, Green Bay, Wis., “Priest enjoys Packers’ the front lines in “Pull remains steady; push increases. It success” by Jeff Kurowski N22 discusses the issues before the Arizona senate. It shows the An historic landmark sports franchise. A simple priest. Best Coverage of a Routine violence and how people cope in “Day of the Dead takes on Faith meets glory. Perfectly done. new meaning amid violence in Mexico. Second Place Sacramental Event Third Place The A.D. Times, Allentown, Pa., “ACCHS Vikings bring Tennessee Register, Nashville, Tenn., “History immigration, home first PIAA Class 3A Championship” by Tami A. First Place the whole package” by Theresa Laurence and Andy Telli Quigley The Catholic Spirit, St. Paul, Minn., “2011 Priest Ordina- The Tennessee Register shows the historical impacts of What should a Catholic athlete be? This piece never is tions” by The Catholic Spirit Staff immigration on a wide and well- painted canvas. It talks less than clear. It never minces or mixes words. It never Affords new priests coverage typically reserved for about the Irish legacy, global immigration and how a priest loses focus. Great quotes & good, clean writing set it apart. celebrities, athletes & politicians. Eight-page pullout from India adapts. Third Place package. Great photos. Complete, didactic feature bios & Honorable Mention Catholic News Service, Washington, D.C., “Haitian soccer personalized sidebars. Links to live-broadcast ordinations. Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “Starting from players get their kicks despite being amputees” by Dennis Even vocation ads? scratch” by Katie Bahr Sadowski Second Place Catholic Sentinel, Portland, Ore., “Feast day full of A story that begs for video or photography, & yet ... it North Texas Catholic, Fort Worth, Texas, “Diocese ordains memories for laborers” by Ed Langlois does not suffer the omission. Simply a great subject & good three to priesthood” by Kathy Cribari Hamer and Jeff story, well-told. Hensley Honorable Mention Clean, crisp, clear. Manages to convey event’s sanctity Georgia Bulletin, Smyrna, Ga., “St. Mary’s Welcomes thru color & layout. Solid writing. Great photos. Montana’s “Fighting Saints”” by Michael Alexander Third Place Mississippi Catholic, Jackson, Mass., “Season of firsts for Georgia Bulletin, Smyrna, Ga., “New Deacons Humbled June 2012 The Catholic Journalist Page 11

Newspaper Award Winners

personalization of World Youth Day. Second Place Catholic New York, New York, N.Y., “World Youth Day Coverage” by Juliann DosSantos and Staff of Catholic New York Excellent use of anecdote and detail to tell the story of World Youth Day. Third Place The Catholic Review, Baltimore, Md., “Witness to the World” by Matt Palmer Personalizes World Youth Day with thorough reporting.

N26 Best Coverage of the New Roman Missal

First Place Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind., “We’ll be saying what?” by Emily Stimpson Visually elegant and comprehensive reporting on exactly how and why the Mass has changed. Second Place St. Louis Review, St. Louis, Mo., “Songs of Praise” by Jen- nifer Brinker and Lisa Johnston Creative and detailed coverage of the changes from the Roman Missal. Third Place Award N26, Best Coverage of the New Roman Missal, First The Boston Pilot, Braintree, Mass., “New missal explained Place, Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind. Award N25, Best Coverage of World Youth Day, First Place, at Cambridge pub” by Justin Bell Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va. Unique and accessible take on the Mass changes by presenting it from the perspective of a priest in a pub. Honorable Mention Brinker N24 The Record, Louisville, Ky., “Deaf community prepares for Haunting, moving and powerful. missal” by Marnie McAllister Third Place Best Coverage of the 10-Year The Catholic Register, Toronto, Ontario, “Deacon’s street Anniversary of 9/11 ministry brings hope to prostitutes and dealers on Toronto’s N27 streets” by Sheila Dabu Nonato and Nigel Wheatley First Place Best Regular Column by a Bishop or Incredible first-person stories of healing on the streets. Catholic New York, New York, N.Y., “9/11: Our Shared Archbishop Honorable Mention Journey coverage” by Staff of Catholic New York The Catholic Register, Toronto, Ontario, “Haiti’s churches need healing” by Michael Swan, Nigel Wheatley The quality and breadth of coverage on the 10th First Place anniversary of 9/11 brings a well-deserved top honor for Catholic New York, New York, N.Y., “Lord, To Whom Catholic New York. The memories by Cardinal Eagan, who Shall We Go?” by Cardinal Timothy Dolan N29a tended the flock then to the new shepherd Cardinal Dolan Whether writing in the conversational tone of Best Newspaper Website - Stand-Alone where he quotes Fr. Madigan saying,”we also celebrate a storyteller or the more direct, logically formatted th Septermber 12 ” is journalism at its finest. The memories argument of a master teacher, Cardinal Dolan’s columns Website of other heroes and three men who were called to religious are easy to read and thought-provoking. First Place life, make this a quality package. The photos also serve Second Place Clarion Herald, New Orleans, La., “www.clarionherald.org” as inspiring reminders of faith going into action during The Tidings, Los Angeles, Calif., “Archbishop’s Message” by Lloyd Robichaux tragedy. by Archbishop Jose H. Gomez Stellar redesign - lead rotating stories at the top and Second Place Well-written columns with strong pastoral messages. frequently updated content makes this a site to emulate. The Beacon, Clifton, N.J., “9/11 and a Nation Facing Disas- Each column ends with a call to prayer on a specific topic. Second Place ters” by Bishop Arthur J. Serratelli, Cecile San Agustin, Bishop Gomez’s smiling face at the top of each column and Catholic Courier, Rochester, N.Y., “www.catholiccourier. Richard Sokerka, Marc Stumbo and Michael Wojcik the pullout quotes draw readers in. com” by Staff From its opening spread with the towers of light and Third Place Strong lead stories and a clean design makes this a Bishop Serratelli’s reflection, the Beacon serves its readers The Catholic Moment, Lafayette, Ind., “Palm Sunday and quality website. with insights and information on the anniversary of 9/11. Holy Week, People out of work, Who was I on 9/11?” by Third Place The reflections of pastors at Ground Zero and remembrance Bishop Timothy L. Doherty The Florida Catholic, Orlando, Fla., “www. of Fr. Mychal Judge, who was a chaplain for the fire Bishop Doherty’s columns are pastoral in tone. He thefloridacatholic.org” by Jean Gonzalez, Ann B. Slade, department and lost his life that day are good reads. The teaches and challenges simultaneously, asking direct Michael Carlock, Mary Rose Denaro and Michael Jimenez inclusion of local parish and school activities and the reader questions of his readers that cause one to pause in self- Powerful top stories make this a compelling website. tributes are all nice touches. reflection. Third Place Honorable Mention Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “9/11 The Catholic Review, Baltimore, Md., “Thoughts on Our N29b Anniversary” by Staff Church” by Archbishop Edwin F. O’Brien and Catholic Best Newspaper Website - Online-Only The Arlington Catholic Herald reminds readers that Review Staff the tragedy also hit the Pentagon. The reflections of Fr. The Observer, Rockford, Ill., “Bishop Thomas G. Doran” by Website Stephen McGraw, who arrived on the scene and prayed Bishop Thomas G. Doran and anointed victims, and police officer Michael Dunne are Not Enough Entries to be Judged moving. Honorable Mention N28 N29c Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind., “Ten years later Best Online/ Multi-Media Presentation Best Newspaper Website - we remember” by John Norton, Brittany Doucette, Russell of Visuals Shaw, Mary DeTurris Poust and OSV editorial board Best Interactive Site First Place Not Enough Entries to be Judged N25 Montana Catholic, Helena, Mont., “Behind the Story: The Best Coverage of World Youth Day Diocese of Helena Guatemala Mission” by Eric Connolly and Renee St. Martin Wizeman First Place Amazing cinematography and storytelling. Arlington Catholic Herald, Arlington, Va., “A little model Second Place for life” by Gretchen R. Crowe St. Louis Review, St. Louis, Mo., “Poor Clare professes liv- Comprehensive package that shows the scope and ing the Gospel in poverty” by Lisa Johnston and Jennifer Page 12 The Catholic Journalist June 2012

Newspaper Award Winners

Award N30c, General Excellence, 40,000+ Diocesan Paper, First Place, The Catholic Sun, Phoenix, Ariz. Award N30a, General Excellence, 1-17,000 Diocesan Paper, First Place, The Monitor, Trenton, N.J. Award N30d, General Excellence, National Newspaper, N30a Second Place First Place, National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo. The New Vision, Tucson, Ariz. General Excellence - 1-17,000 Diocesan This paper earned second place with its fresh Paper design, editorial selection of stories, and good writing. significant events and anniversaries in the archdiocese Appropriately for its Catholic readership, New Vision work well because of the writing strength of its staff and First Place provides side by side English and Spanish versions of the prominence of the events, participants and institutions, The Monitor, Trenton , N.J. the bishop’s letter and a special news and feature section such as the 100th anniversary of Maryknoll or Covenant Beautifully laid out, rich in well-written staff pieces, in Spanish. A lively exchange of letters across issues House. Given his international stature, Card. Dolan is a The Monitor covers numerous parts of the diocese and challenging and supporting Bp. Kicanas’ comments about prominent local news figure in each issue. Strong editorial includes special emphasis on the youth programs and con- Rep. Gabby Giffords reflects a policy which encourages the page. The paper has a section in Spanish, news briefs from cerns. The Monitor also excels in the amount and variety paper’s role as the voice of the people of the diocese. local campuses. of national and world news with strong combinations of Third Place photos and text. Simply a rich news portrait and excel- The Compass, Green Bay, Wis. lently edited. The Compass packages a nice blend of diocesan news N30d Second Place briefs, longer local news pieces, and CNS feature stories General Excellence - National The Catholic Northwest Progress, Seattle, Wash. with a well conceived and written editorial page. A Newspaper With an interesting blend solid news, features from dif- Catholic perspective on the Green Bay Packers in an issue ferent corners of the diocese, and well written portraits around the Super Bowl, included a feature on a Rwandan First Place of non-clerical Catholics, the Progress seems fresh and Catholic mission that received a gift of $100,000.00 from National Catholic Reporter, Kansas City, Mo. compelling from issue to issue. The writing is highly pro- Packer Coach Mike McCarthy and the team and another Outstanding news selection presented in a creative fessional, as in a piece on a wheelchair bound priest say- on the team’s Catholic chaplain. design, The Reporter continues to be a leader in news ing Mass that emphasizes his newfound sensitivity to the reporting. The content reflects the fresh reporting approach handicapped. N30c and strong skills of reporters like Zoe Ryan and Jerry Fil- Third Place General Excellence - 40,000+ Diocesan teau. Thoughtful news analysis brings the reader addition- The Valley Catholic, San Juan, Texas al perspectives of experts. The special report from research Written primarily in English with a Spanish section, The Paper on the Millenials was the kind of extra content which Valley Catholic emphasizes longer news feature pieces, makes this an outstanding paper. always with art. With each issue the reader sees different First Place Second Place parts of the diocese and the actions of its Catholics and The Catholic Sun, Phoenix , Ariz. The Catholic Register, Toronto ,Ontario, Canada leaders. The joy of living the faith resonates from stories Strong in graphics will nicely marked sections, the Sun Every page of this paper is a fresh adventure into the on almost every page. takes full advantage of staff writers and their strong writ- complexity of the Church ‘news, history, theological reflec- ing in English and in the Spanish section. The Sun’s pho- tion, culture, and opinions from Toronto.’ A staff of talented N30b tos nicely complement the text, for this is a writer’s paper writers bring a global perspective to the pages without General Excellence - 17,001-40,000 with an emphasis on information and explanation. Com- slighting Canadian church news. Strong photos provide pelling cover stories, e.g., exorcism, a local 9/11 widow, special emphasis. Diocesan Paper draw the reader into the issue. Third Place Second Place Our Sunday Visitor, Huntington, Ind. First Place Catholic San Francisco, San Francisco, Calif. Powerful use of photos to augment impressively written Catholic Herald, Madison, Wis. A delightful combination of photos and text present a feature and news feature stories run through each issue. Excellence marks every issue by providing strong edi- strong package of local news a features, book reviews, In-depth coverage seems particularly strong. Vocation torial content in a strong, clean, and pleasing graphic and The editor takes full advantage of the center double section on Cistecians and Carmelites was excellent. The design. A staff written front page news feature set truck with photo features, e.g., The pope’s declaration of 150th anniversary of the start of the Civil War generated against a strong color background with good photos and A Year of Reconciliation in Africa. A person on the street a section on Catholics in that conflict as well as a special art picks up a major event or issue. What sets the Herald approach to the new Mass provides faces of Catholics at section on digital faith mark the range of OSV’s approach. apart is the view of the diocese provided by well crafted church. The feature and news pieces bring the community stories in “Around the Diocese” and special focus sections to life in its diversity. from rural life through grieving to youth. Church per- Third Place spective on issues like conceal and carry get appropriate Catholic New York, New York, N.Y. attention and play. Catholic New York’s emphasis on detailed stories about