December 2019 ‘IM GOD’ Court Oks License Plate a Federal Court on Nov
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Winning law Reproductive Secularism doesn’t student essays rights are critical destroy society published human rights or moral order PAGES 10-14 PAGES 15-17 PAGE 23 Vol. 36 No. 10 Published by the Freedom From Religion Foundation, Inc. December 2019 ‘IM GOD’ Court OKs license plate A federal court on Nov. 13 cleared the way for a Kentucky man, backed by the Freedom From Religion Foundation and the ACLU of Kentucky, to obtain a personalized license plate reading “IM GOD.” In November 2016, FFRF Member Ben Hart filed a lawsuit after he was denied the personalized license plate. Kentucky Division of Motor Vehicle officials, who have approved several religious personalized plates, refused Hart’s request, initially calling his “IM GOD” license plate message “obscene or vulgar.” Later, the state said the plate was rejected because it was “not in good taste.” While residing in Ohio, Hart had a similar license plate (pictured below). The lawsuit, filed on Hart’s behalf by FFRF and ACLU of Kentucky, challenged the Kentucky Transportation Cabinet’s denial of his plate based on statutory viewpoint restrictions that govern religious, anti-religious or political messages. “The Commonwealth [of Kentucky] went too far,” the U.S. District Court for the Eastern Court of Ken- Cartoon by Steve Benson I’m thankful to finally tucky resoundingly For all we do, this wall’s for you (and everyone) have the same opportunity ruled in favor of Hart. “ “To allow such plates The Freedom From Religion Foundation is proud to help in the fight to keep strong the wall to select a personal message as ‘IM4GOD’ and ‘LU- of separation between state and church. And it’s because of you, our members, that we can for my license plate just VGOD’ but reject ‘IM make a difference, brick by brick, day by day. FFRF wishes you a happy Winter Solstice and a as any other driver. GOD’ belies viewpoint prosperous new year! — Ben Hart neutrality,” the court stated. “Regardless, the court concludes that in this case, [the statute governing such license plates] is an unrea- Charity rating group: FFRF is tops sonable and therefore impermissible restriction on Mr. Hart’s The country’s premier nonprofit charity score. “Less than 1 percent of the thousands of First Amendment rights.” rating organization has just attested that the charities rated by Charity Navigator have earned FFRF celebrated the ruling. Freedom From Religion Foundation belongs to perfect scores,” says the organization’s website. “As the court affirmed, the denial of Ben Hart’s choice an amazingly exclusive club. FFRF is, in fact, only one of three charities in of a license plate was pure discrimination,” says FFRF Co- “We are proud to announce Freedom From the human and civil rights category with a 100 President Annie Laurie Gaylor. “We are delighted that the court Religion Foundation has earned our 10th con- percent rating. realized the bias the state of Kentucky was displaying toward secutive four-star rating,” Charity Navigator Even in comparison with other reputable nonbelievers.” President and CEO Michael Thatcher recently charities, FFRF emerges ahead. For instance, The ACLU of Kentucky also welcomed the judgment. informed FFRF in a letter. “Only 2 percent of it has a better score than either the National “Today’s ruling makes clear that Mr. Hart’s personalized the charities we evaluate have received at least Coalition Against Domestic Violence or the plate request was denied based on reasons that violate the First 10 consecutive four-star evaluations, indicating Electronic Privacy Information Center, both Amendment of the United States Constitution. In light of the that Freedom From Religion Foundation out- highly regarded nonprofits. court’s ruling, we expect the Transportation Cabinet’s license performs most other charities in America. This FFRF is elated at this mark of confidence. See Plate on page 7 exceptional designation from Charity Navigator “We consider ourselves responsible stewards sets Freedom From Religion Foundation apart of our members’ money, and we’re delighted from its peers and demonstrates to the public that Charity Navigator has confirmed that,” says its trustworthiness.” FFRF Co-President Dan Barker. “It’s affirming That’s not all. Charity Navigator has placed to have this assurance for our supporters about FFRF in the tiny fraction of charities attaining how careful FFRF is in utilizing their contribu- a 100 percent accountability and transparency tions for important work.” FFRF saves Wis. county $50K a year Racine County defunds contacted the county to raise constitutional concerns about the funding and to ask for all Christian youth group relevant records pertaining to the religious Racine County in Wisconsin has nixed its boondoggle. funding of a Christian youth group after the In its initial response to FFRF, the county Freedom From Religion Foundation objected defended its funding of Youth For Christ to taxpayer money going to an unambiguously because it stated that “Racine County believes sectarian organization. in a comprehensive and holistic approach Racine County had been bestowing its largesse to rehabilitation and knows that individual Ben Hart shows off his Ohio “IM GOD” license plate. When he on a group called Youth For Christ since 2013 success is based upon all seven dimensions moved to Kentucky, the state would not allow him to use that to the tune of tens of thousands of dollars each of wellness — spiritual wellness being one of phrase because it was deemed “obscene or vulgar.” But on Nov. 13, year ($100,000 from 2013 to 2016 and $50,000 a federal court ruled that the state “went too far” in censoring him. per year since then). In July of this year, FFRF See County on page 7 Page 2 FFRF | FREETHOUGHT TODAY | Madison, Wisconsin | December 2019 FFRF’s signs of the season IN MEMORIAM Suzan Barker was an Unfettered Freethinker FFRF Mem- assistant. ber Suzan Palmer According to her obituary in the Shel- Barker, 71, died ton-Mason County Journal, “She was en- on Oct. 7 by sui- amored with cats, and was the proverbial cide because of ‘cat lady,’ once having 39 in her own per- her depression. sonal ‘no-kill sanctuary.’” She was down to She was born three cats at the time of her death. Nov. 18, 1947, to She loved reading because it “satisfied John Morris and her insatiable curiosities.” The obit Imogene Davis continued, “A fiercely loyal woman to in Oklahoma. her husband and family, she was known Suzan Barker Suzan was mar- to often say ‘at the end of the day, it’s all ried to Darrell about family!’” Barker, brother of FFRF Co-President Suzan was a lifelong atheist and a liberal Photo by Chris Line Dan Barker, for 29 years. She lived Democrat, a member of FFRF, Unfettered FFRF’s annual Winter Solstice exhibit is up in the Wisconsin Capitol in in Shelton, Wash., for the past 10 Freethinkers of South Sound and Olympia Madison for the 24th year. The gilt sign contains a secular note, composed years. She worked as a certified nurse Sunday Assembly. by the late Anne Nicol Gaylor, FFRF’s principal founder, and reads: “At this season of the Winter Solstice, may reason prevail. There are no gods, no devils, no angels, no heaven or hell. There is only our natural world. Religion is but myth and superstition that Teacher, author, farmer hardens hearts and enslaves minds.” And, for the fifth year, FFRF has included its Bill of Rights “nativity” in the Capitol rotunda. The irreverent cutout by artist Jacob Fortin depicts Charles Dedic dies at 83 Founders Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson and George Washington FFRF Member in 1962. He taught high school English gazing in adoration at a “baby” Bill of Rights while the Statue of Liberty Charles Edward and journalism in Newberry and Escana- looks on. Both exhibits are up throughout December. Dedic died on ba, Mich., for more than 30 years, retiring FFRF Legal Fellows Brendan Johnson, left, and Dante Harootunian helped Oct. 19 at the age in 1990. During his entire working career, place the signs in the Capitol, along with FFRF Legal Assistant Whitney of 83. he also operated a family dairy farm. Steffen and Staff Attorney Chris Line. He was born Charles enjoyed writing, hunting, fish- Dec. 20, 1935, in ing, and playing the card game sheeps- Perkins, Mich., on head. He self-published eight books, the farm where many detailed biographical and historical he lived most of short stories, mostly nonfiction. his life. He served Charles is survived by five chil- Charles Dedic on active duty in dren, five grandchildren and nine the Army from great-grandchildren. 1954 to 1957. Af- He was preceded in death by his wife ter returning from the Army, he attended Annette (Engman) Dedic and his daugh- Northern Michigan University, graduating ter, Kimberly (Danny) Long. Steve Hoffman dies at 70 Former FFRF Member Steven Gary Hoffman died May 6. He was born Jan. 7, 1949. His online obituary was short: “Steve made this world a better place. It is a huge loss that he is no longer with us. He has been described by many as a gentle, smart, FFRF is honoring the Bill of Rights in the Granite State this holiday season. witty, loving man, passionate about social justice and For the second year in a row, FFRF members have set up a freethinking philanthropy. He lived in Seattle for 35 years but was holiday display in New Hampshire’s capital. The exhibit, erected outside the originally from Long Island, N.Y.” He is survived by his Capitol building in Concord, is FFRF’s 6-foot-tall Bill of Rights “nativity.” Steve Hoffman partner Judy Blank of California.