1 Introduction: Representing Madness 6
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“THE AX FOR THE FROZEN SEA WITHIN US”: REPRESENTATIONS OF MADNESS IN THE WRITINGS OF ANNE SEXTON SHERI KRISTEN KWEE HWA GOH DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH AND COMPARATIVE LITERATURE A THESIS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF MPhil Goh 2 SIGNED STATEMENT This thesis is the result of my own independent investigation and all authorities and sources which have been consulted are acknowledged in the bibliography. Goh 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thanks to: Prof Chris Baldick and Dr Gail McDonald, my thesis supervisors, for all their advice and support. Prof Helen Carr, my previous thesis supervisor, who helped me to start this work. Dr Michael Simpson, for all his help and understanding. The University of London Central Research Fund, whose financial grant made it possible for me to undertake the research trip to the Harry Ransom Center at the University of Texas at Austin. Lily Chua, my mother, for all the help with childcare, and for all the love and support. I really could not have done this without you. E, who loves unconditionally. And K, who is patient. Goh 4 ABSTRACT This dissertation examines how Anne Sexton wrote about and represented madness in her poetry and prose as well as in her public persona. Although Sexton began writing as a therapeutic exercise after a mental breakdown, and although she became a successful writer because of her brand of “asylum poetry,” it is my assertion that her writing and public persona were symbolic representations through which she explored the concept of madness. Much effort has been put here on not reading the writings as evidence of Sexton’s psychopathology, but instead focusing on madness as one of many themes in her writing, her personal experiences a springboard from which she explored what she felt were universal issues. Sexton represented madness in her poetry first through the use of fixed verse forms as she learnt and mastered the craft of writing, but later in her career varied the style to use free verse and other experimental forms to explore madness in different ways. The mad poet was one of the first and major personae that she assumed in her writings, but there were other personae. Sexton invented and assumed the masks of other characters, such as family members, the witch/crone, characters in exile, and inanimate objects to explore what she referred to as greater “poetic truths.” She also examined the problematic task of communication, especially the limitations of language in the conveyance of meaning. This is especially evident, I show, in the poems about her psychiatrist or where her personae address doctors. In addition to employing Sexton’s published writings and the work of other scholars and critics, this dissertation analyses Sexton’s archived materials at the Harry Ransom Center at the University of Texas at Austin, and includes insights drawn from her unpublished writings, off-Broadway play, unpublished letters and lecture notes. Goh 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS Signed Statement 2 Acknowledgements 3 Abstract 4 Chapter 1 Introduction: Representing Madness 6 Chapter 2 “A Certain Sense of Order”: Methods to the Madness 15 Chapter 3 “Her Kind”: Becoming Anne Sexton 37 Chapter 4 “The Speaker in This Case”: Anne Sexton’s Persona Poems 63 Chapter 5 Constructing the Persona of the “Mad Poet” 93 Appendix A 131 Appendix B 132 Appendix C 136 Bibliography 137 Goh 6 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION: REPRESENTING MADNESS It can be said that all writers, to some extent, write to make sense of their lives. Anne Sexton, however, had a exceptionally chaotic life as she struggled with mental illness (most likely that of manic depression, or bipolar disorder as it is currently known in psychiatric terms), which pitched her moods between extremes of highs and lows, from which she struggled from the age of twenty-eight to her death at forty-six. However, it is not my concern in this thesis to diagnose the mental illness from which she suffered, as my interest is in her writings, and I am not trained in psychiatry or psychology. Neither it is my intention to use her writings as evidence of her psychopathology. Rather, in this thesis, I intend to examine the ways in which Anne Sexton represented madness in her writings, as well as how she used the personae in her writings to do so. She was a very public personality at the height of her success – a poetic celebrity – and it is my assertion that her focus on her career and her use of madness as subject material led her to develop and maintain the public persona of “mad poet” in order to further her success as a writer. Yet the mad poet was not her only persona. It is my assertion that the writing of her madness enabled her to “enquire further” on universal issues, as she proposed in a seminal poem, “For John, Who Begs Me to Enquire Further” (BP). Many critics and readers view her poetry to be confessional, and thus truthful, but a closer study of some of the other personae in Sexton’s poetry reveals that she was tremendously adept at the adoption and wearing of masks. She was a masterful performer, in her poetry as well as in the many readings and lectures that she gave. However, of all her personae, “mad poet” was the most successful one, and an in-depth study of this persona reveals that language and communication were primary concerns in Sexton’s representations of madness. The various formal structures of her poetry and her changing writing style also played a part in how Sexton conveyed her poetic philosophy through her writings. As her career progressed, she viewed poetry less as therapy and her mental condition less as something from which she sought to recover. Instead, she revelled in her madness, since identifying with madness was a successful element in her poetic career. In this study, I draw not only from what has been published and is available in the public domain. The title of The Complete Poems is a misnomer, since there is no Goh 7 way to completely collect all of an artist’s works. I draw also in great part from Sexton’s archived materials to which I was privileged to gain access during my research trip to the Harry Ransom Centre (HRC) at the University of Texas at Austin, a trip which was made possible by a grant from the Central Research Fund of the University of London. However, even if Sexton were alive, and I had managed to interview her, or even if I had complete access to all of Sexton’s manuscripts, worksheets, personal papers, video recordings and psychiatric tapes/notes, it would be impossible for me or any critic to be able to fully understand the motivations behind why and how she wrote. I have, however, had access to Sexton’s HRC material, which is more than the average postgraduate Sexton scholar has had. I have had the opportunity to view Sexton’s unpublished lectures notes from the Crawshaw series of lectures that she delivered to Colgate University while she was professor there in 1972. As these lectures were delivered in the later part of her career, she had by then the opportunity to look back at how her career had developed, and to better understand her own writing philosophy. Mercy Street, her 1969 off-Broadway play, has never been published in its final form, but I was able to read versions of its drafts. I was also able to study many unpublished poems, prose works, notes and letters, as well as earlier drafts of published poems. These have given me a unique insight into Sexton as a poet and person that many other Sexton scholars have not. I thus have a greater access to the persona(e) that the poet was trying to present. In attempting to understand the ways in the ways in which Sexton wrote about her mental state, I will be studying these personae; Sexton presented to her reading audience a “mad poet” who went “to Bedlam” but only made it “part way back,” as suggested by the title of her first collection of poetry. She was a poet who was unashamed, even flamboyant, about her madness. It is with this understanding of Sexton and her relationship with madness that I study the representations of madness in Sexton’s writings, and in her career. The poetic persona In The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat, neuropsychologist Oliver Sacks explains the importance of identity: We have, each of us, a life-story, an inner narrative – whose continuity, whose sense, is our lives. It might be said that each of us constructs and lives a “narrative,” and that this narrative is us, our Goh 8 identities. […] Each of us is a singular narrative, which is constructed, continually, unconsciously, by, through, and in us – through our perceptions, our feelings, our thoughts, our actions; and, not least, our discourse, our spoken narrations. […] A man needs such a narrative, a continuous inner narrative, to maintain his identity, his self. (116-17)1 Whether one has a psychological disorder of excess or deficit, or even if one is considered psychiatrically “normal,” a recurrent theme in Sacks’ collection of case files is how his patients strive for a unity and completeness of narrative. Where this completeness is lacking, the human mind inexplicably struggles to construct it. Where there is disturbance, the psyche struggles to make objective sense out of it. Some of Sacks’ patients, when faced with psychic difficulties, turned to music, drama, or art in order to make a fractured world more logical. Sexton, it can be said, made sense of the world through her writings, especially her poetry.