DOCSLIB.ORG

Relational Narratives, Suffering, and Counselling Psychology

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Relational Narratives, Suffering, and Counselling Psychology Relational Narratives, Suffering, and Counselling Psychology Susan Kinyany-Schlachter Portfolio for the Professional Doctorate in Counselling Psychology City University London Department of Psychology September 2017 Table of Contents List of Diagrams ....................................................................................................... 6 Research Study ................................................................................................................. 13 Professional Practice ........................................................................................................ 14 Writing for Publication ...................................................................................................... 14 Reflections & Summary .................................................................................................... 15 Part 1: Research ..................................................................................................... 17 Abstract ................................................................................................................... 18 1 Chapter One: Introduction ............................................................................ 19 1.1Background .................................................................................................................. 19 1.2Overview of the Research Study ................................................................................. 21 1.3Context of Caregiving: Glioblastoma Multiforme (GBM) ........................................... 21 1.4A priori Personal Reflexivity ........................................................................................ 23 1.5Literature Review ......................................................................................................... 24 1.5.1 Psychosocial Experiences of Brain Tumour Caregivers ................................. 26 1.5.2 Psychosocial Needs ....................................................................................... 27 1.5.3 Psychosocial Impact ...................................................................................... 31 1.5.4 Psychosocial Support .................................................................................... 35 1.6Rationale for the Research .......................................................................................... 38 1.6.1 Gaps in the Literature Review ........................................................................ 39 1.6.2 Feminist Perspectives .................................................................................... 40 1.6.3 Narrative Perspectives ................................................................................... 41 1.6.4 Counselling Psychology Perspectives ............................................................ 41 1.7Research Aims & Questions ....................................................................................... 44 2 Chapter Two: Methodology ........................................................................... 46 2.1Overview ....................................................................................................................... 46 2.2Research Positionality ................................................................................................. 46 2.3Research Design .......................................................................................................... 48 2.3.1 Rationale for Qualitative Research ................................................................. 49 2.3.2 Rationale for Narrative Inquiry ....................................................................... 50 2.3.3 Illness Narratives ........................................................................................... 56 2.3.4 Rationale for Dialogical Narrative Analysis (DNA) .......................................... 56 2.3.5 Congruence between Counselling Psychology & Narrative Inquiry ................ 58 2.4Ethical Approval ........................................................................................................... 59 2.5Procedure ..................................................................................................................... 60 1 2.5.1 Recruitment ................................................................................................... 60 2.5.2 Participants .................................................................................................... 61 2.5.3 Sample .......................................................................................................... 62 2.5.4 Inclusion Criteria ............................................................................................ 62 2.5.5 Briefing .......................................................................................................... 63 2.5.6 Informed Consent .......................................................................................... 63 2.5.7 Confidentiality ................................................................................................ 64 2.5.8 Debriefing ...................................................................................................... 65 2.5.9 Online Stories as Data ................................................................................... 65 2.5.10 Email Interviews as Data ............................................................................... 65 2.5.11 Participant Feedback and Email Communication as Data .............................. 65 2.6Data Analysis ............................................................................................................... 67 2.6.1 Practising Dialogical Narrative Analysis (DNA) .................................................. 67 2.6.2 Research Q.1: What kinds of stories do GBM caregivers narrate online? ...... 67 2.6.3 Research Q. 2: What happens as a result of storytelling? .............................. 73 2.7Ethical Considerations ................................................................................................ 74 2.7.1 In Situ: Methodological Reflexivity ................................................................. 75 2.7.2 Recruitment of Bereaved Caregivers ............................................................. 75 2.7.3 Online Stories as Research Data ................................................................... 76 2.7.4 Email interviews as Research Data ................................................................ 76 2.7.5 Illness Narratives as Research Data .............................................................. 77 2.8Evaluation of Qualitative Narrative Inquiry ................................................................ 79 3 Chapter Three: Findings ............................................................................... 83 3.1Overview of Chapter .................................................................................................... 83 3.2Introduction to the Caregivers .................................................................................... 83 3.2.1 Sharma: He was my rock… ........................................................................... 83 3.2.2 Anna: I would have walked through molten lava for him…. ............................ 83 3.2.3 Heather: We were a team, united in love…. ................................................... 84 3.2.4 Jasmine: It was a gift and honour to have been part of (his) life … ................ 85 3.2.5 Rosemary: He was my knight in shining armour… ......................................... 85 3.2.6 Lilly: His last kiss was 1 minute before he passed… ...................................... 85 3.2.7 Helen: He was precious…. our only child… ................................................... 86 3.3Presentation of Findings ............................................................................................. 86 3.3.1 What kinds of stories do GBM caregivers narrate online? .............................. 86 3.3.2 Subjective Stories .......................................................................................... 87 3.3.3 Sharma: No Suffering Plz… ........................................................................... 88 3.4Collective Story Typologies ........................................................................................ 94 3.4.1 Narratives of Disruption ................................................................................. 95 3.4.2 Embodied Narratives ..................................................................................... 99 2 3.4.3 Narratives of Moral Dilemma ........................................................................ 102 3.4.4 Narratives of Destruction ............................................................................. 108 3.4.5 Narratives of Silence .................................................................................... 110 3.5Core Narratives .......................................................................................................... 114 3.5.1 The Suffering of Caring ................................................................................ 114 3.5.2 Woman as Healer ........................................................................................ 115 3.6What happens as a result of narrating stories online? ........................................... 117 3.6.1 The Storytelling Landscape .......................................................................... 118 3.6.2 Relational Narratives ...................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Subverting Value Chains Through Liberatory Cultural Production
    Cultural De-commodification: Subverting Value Chains Through Liberatory Cultural Production Luam Kidane Department of Art History and Communication Studies McGill University, Montreal April, 2016 A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Master of Arts © Luam Kidane, 2016 1 2 Abstract Freedom is a perpetual process, which can neither be defined nor predetermined. Any attempt at freedom is therefore an improvisation, an experimentation. Cultural production can act as a site for this improvisation to take root: a viaduct from which experimentations in colour, sound, form, movement and letters allows for dialogue and explorations of liberation practices. Liberatory cultural production is a process through which interventions, provocations, modifications, and proposals are made for the purposes of expressing, understanding, shaping, and interrogating political, cultural and social frameworks. This includes music, writing, movement, language, visual art, performance, as well as other forms of expression meant to inform and create how we relate to culture. These sites of cultural production which improvise freedom challenge the commodification of cultural production because they force a conceptualization of value outside of money, utility, exchange and labour. This thesis interrogates the relationship between value, liberation and cultural production through Marxist theory, Black Radical Thought, and a case study of Senegalese hip-hop from 1980-2012 in order to assert that cultural production which is a site for the improvisation of freedom has a liberatory value which subverts the law of value at the heart of the capitalist economy. 3 Résumé La liberté est un processus perpetuel qui ne peut ni être définie ou prédéterminée.
    [Show full text]
  • A Luta Continua: Children and Youth in Mozambique’S Struggles
    Chapter Two A Luta Continua: Children and Youth in Mozambique’s Struggles Ana Leão The focus of this chapter is a historical glimpse of youth involvement in Mozambican political change, where child soldiers seem to fall into a well- established pattern of youth involvement and youth mobilisation. The need for a historical perspective arises from the reality that children and youth comprise the largest demographic group in Africa and yet are the ones we know the least about. Research on young people has tended to focus on specific human security issues, such as child soldiers and HIV/AIDS, but there have been few attempts to profile youth socially, politically and economically. Having said this, youth is not a homogenous group; young people belong to different social economic strata and have different economic roles and political agendas. Concepts such as childhood, adolescence and adulthood vary according to different social, cultural and economic settings. In many African societies, age was and still may be defined not by the year of birth but rather by the ability of the individual to perform certain tasks and carry particular respon- sibilities. African children and youth have established their social identity and position through their contributions to the household and community. Fetching wood or water, cultivating, tending livestock, hunting and fishing are some of the tasks through which rural youngsters, for example, establish themselves as productive members of their community. But, although Africa’s young people are not immune to historical changes, little is known about how concepts of childhood and youth have adapted to the changing conditions of African societies.1 Over the course of our research, former child soldiers, none of whom had undergone any rituals of initiation in the traditional sense, were asked how age was defined in their community and none could really answer.
    [Show full text]
  • A Discussion Guide
    a discussion guide for the film The Africa Information Service (A.I.S.) is an organiza­ tion of Africans, African-Caribbeans and African­ Americans who share a commitment to Third World anti-imperialist struggles. We prepare, catalog, and distribute information on African liberation movements and on the struggles to achieve economic independence by the people in those parts ofAfrica recognized as independent political states. We also provide the people ofAfrica with information on various struggles being waged by Third World peoples in the Western Hemisphere. Africa is ou r focal point, but we recognize that the African struggles do not exist in isolation. They are themselves part of a larger movement by Third World peoples. a discussion guide forthefilm UA CONTENTS 2. Film Data 2. Credits 2. Distributors 3. Basic Statistics 3. Map of Africa 4. The Struggle in Mozambique 7. Suggested Questions For Discussion 8. Suggested Action in Support of FRELIMO, MPLA, AND PAIGC 9. Partial List of Organizations Working on Issues Related to Southern and Colonized Africa 11. Suggested Bibliography Books Periodicals LU C TINU (the struggle continues) FILM DATA Color 16 mm Optical Sound - English Narration Running Time: 32 minutes Footage: 1286 Filmed in the liberated areas of Mozambique (Niassa Province, September & October, 1971) CREDITS Producer/Director Robert F. Van Lierop Ci nematographer/Director Bob Fletcher Film Editor Richard Skinner Sound Editor George Copeland Sound Robert F. Van Lierop Animator Richard Skinner Map Cheryl Brown Voice Effects (Proclama­ tion of War & Eduardo Mondlane Filipe Nhancle Written and Narrated by Robert F. Van Lierop DISTRIBUTORS Tricontin.ental Film Center 244 West 27th Street New York, New York 10001 Africa Information Service 112 West 120 Street New York, New York 10027 2 BASIC STATISTICS (The Three Colonie) Angola area 485,000 sq.
    [Show full text]
  • Herbert Shore Collection in Honor of Eduardo C
    HERBERT SHORE COLLECTION IN HONOR OF EDUARDO C. MONDLANE INVENTORY Subgroup I. Historical Files relating to Herbert Shore’s interests in the Arts and Culture Series 1. Council on the Arts, Culture, and Technology (TACT), 1962-63, 1971-84, 1991, n.d. (1 architectural drawing) Box 1 TACT General Information Aboriginal Culture, Aboriginal Art from Papunya, Central Australia, Dec. 12, 1977 Ad-hoc panel in view of the preparation of the Second World Conference on Cultural Policies, Dec. 15–19, 1980 Annual Report to U.S. NATCOM, Sept. 30, 1980 Art and Education, Mar. 5, 1971 Art and the Future, 1978-80 Art in a Technological Society, Report by Herbert Shore, 1980 Art in a Technological Society, Workshops, Jan 24-25, 1980 (4f) The Arts and the Technological Challenge, 1982 Desmond E. Berghofer, The Development of Educational Policy in the Context of Lifelong Learning: A Discussion Paper, Mar. 2, 1983 The Black Art Revolution in the United States and Its Possible Relevance to Africa, Report to the Ford Foundation by Ulli Beier, n.d. The Communications Explosion, (1972?) Correspondence, 1978-80 Cultural Development and Policies, 1975-82, n.d. Cultural Policy and Unesco, 1979-1981, n.d., (3f) Cultural Transformations and the Human Scale of Time and Space, Ludwik Bielawski, n.d. Cultural Values, n.d. Culture & Technology, 1978, 1982, n.d. (4f) Development of a New Instrument of Percussion –The Two-Manual Vibraphone, Ronald M. George, n.d. Economic Order, Moving Towards Change, 1976 Education, Department of, 1976-1983 (5f) Educational Film Center, Storytellers, 1977-1979 Educational Research. Mozambique, 1980, n.d.
    [Show full text]
  • A Journal of African Studies
    UCLA Ufahamu: A Journal of African Studies Title Front Matter Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/7rw7c61p Journal Ufahamu: A Journal of African Studies, 12(1) ISSN 0041-5715 Author n/a, n/a Publication Date 1982 DOI 10.5070/F7121017181 eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California U F A H A M U AFRICAN ACTIVIST ASSOCIATION AFRICAN S~JDIES CENTER UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90024 Editor-in-Chief: Kyalo Mativo Editorial Board: Kofi Afriyie, C. Orlando X. Bonner, Marc Arthur Chery, Pierre Hermann L. m!sir, Fassil Demissie, Steve Harmon, Dovi Kuevi, Jacqueline Magro, Olusegun Oyekunle. Production Editor: Anita Pfouts Editorial Advisory Board: J. Ndukaku Amankulor, !.N.C. Aniebo, Louis D. Armmand, Kandioura Drame, Teshome H. Gabriel, Niko M. Ngwenyama, Edward C. Okus, Renee Poussiant, Kipkorir Aly Rana, Nancy Rutledge. Technical Advisor: Alice McGaughey CONTRIBUTIONS UFAHAMU will accept contributions from anyone interested in Africa and related subject areas. Contributions may include scholarly articles, political-economic analyses, commentaries, film and book reviews and freelance prose and poetry. Manuscripts may be of any length, but those of 15-25 pages are preferred. (All manuscripts must be clearly typed, double­ spaced originals with footnotes gathered at the end. Contributors should endeavor to keep duplicate copies of all their manuscripts.) The Editorial Board reserves the right to abbreviate any manuscript in order to fit page requirements. All correspondence--manuscripts, subscriptions, books for review, inquiries, etc.,--should be addressed to the Editor-in­ Chief at the above address. SUBSCRIPTIONS Individuals in U.S . and Canada $8.00/volume(3 issues);~ $3.50/issue.
    [Show full text]
  • COFA 01 Thom 2020 Annotation
    COFA 1 : DR J THOM Description: Two creative outputs commissioned by Iwalewahaus, The Centre for African Studies at the University of Bayreuth, Germany and published in: ‘Art of Wagnis: Christoph Schlingensief's crossing of Wagner and Africa’, pp128-131, edited by Lehmann, F., Vierke, U. & Siegert, N. 2017. 1. Title: Aluta Continua (Victory etc.) Medium: Site-specific intervention in mixed media commissioned by Iwalewahaus, The Centre for African Studies at the University of Bayreuth, Germany Date: 2017 Dimensions: Variable Annotation: Full annotation provided in accompanying pdf. This artistic intervention is based upon a creative re-reading of the political slogan ‘A luta continua, vitória é certa’ (The struggle continues, victory is certain). Historically this political slogan is associated with Mozambique’s armed struggle for independence from Portugal from the early 1960s until 1975. To be specific, the slogan is considered the political rallying cry of Samora Machel, the erstwhile leader of the Frente de Libertação de Moçambique or Frelimo. During the recent student protests against the rising costs of tertiary education in South Africa this slogan was often appropriated by students and their various supporters, appearing in social media on handmade posters in shorthand form simply as “A luta continua”. In this particular form, the slogan does not make explicit the possibility of victory, leaving instead the rather dispiriting possibility of a never-ending struggle. However, I think it may well be argued that the obverse is also true – that contemporary South African students are deeply aware of just how naive any hope for singular and total victory appears today.
    [Show full text]
  • Interview with Bob Van Lierop
    Interview with Bob Van Lierop "[Our film A Luta Continua ] was smuggled into Portugal by Frelimo. They used it there. It was also smuggled into South Africa. And prior to the Soweto uprising it was shown by the Black Consciousness Movement and others in South Africa. And they began to use some of the slogans-a luta continua [the struggle continues], which was, of course, as you know, the way Eduardo [Mondlane] always signed his letters." - Bob Van Lierop Introduction Bob Van Lierop doesn't know how many copies of his film A Luta Continua were made, or how many times it was shown. And it is probably impossible to track exactly how much influence it had in making the Portuguese-language slogan from the Mozambique Liberation Front (Frelimo) a rallying cry in South Africa and for allied movements around the world. But there is no doubt that for many in North America and Europe it provided the definitive visual imagery that made identification with African liberation struggles come alive in the 1970s. This short film portraying Mozambican guerrillas fighting against Portuguese colonialism was filmed in 1971 and was widely distributed throughout the 1970s. A sequel, O Povo Organizado , was filmed shortly after Mozambique's independence in 1975 and released in 1976. Bob Van Lierop, who produced these two films which deeply impacted black independent cinema in the United States in this period, was not a filmmaker by training. He was a progressive African American lawyer based in New York who launched the project in solidarity with Frelimo, and decided to do the film himself when he was unable to locate a filmmaker willing to take on the task.
    [Show full text]
  • Explorations Into Genocide and Other Forms of Mass Violence
    no. 50 | december 2008 Revisiting the heart of darkness – Explorations into genocide and other forms of mass violence The history of mass violence since colonial times – Trying to understand the roots of a mindset Jacques Depelchin .................................................................................................................13 Violence, legitimacy and dynamics of genocide – Notions of mass violence examined Reinhart Kössler ....................................................................................33 Contextualising violence in colonial Africa – European national development, empire and lineages of conflict Gerold Krozewski ............................................................................................53 Colonialism and genocide – Raphael Lemkin’s concept of genocide and its application to European rule in Africa Dominik Schaller ..........................................................................................................75 Colonialism and the holocaust – Towards an archeology of genocide Jürgen Zimmerer ...................................95 Do we need an alternative to the concept of genocide? Anthony Court .........................................................125 Lineages of racism in genocidal contexts – Lessons from Hannah Arendt in contemporary African genocide scholarship Ulrike Kistner .................................................................................................. 155 Hotel Rwanda – The challenges of historicising and commercialising genocide Mohamed Adhikari
    [Show full text]
  • International Shaping of a Nationalist Imagery? Robert Van Lierop, Eduardo Mondlane and a Luta Continua1 Alba Martín Luque
    International Shaping of a Nationalist Imagery? Robert van Lierop, Eduardo Mondlane and A luta continua1 Alba Martín Luque 115 Introduction In 1967, two opponents of United States foreign policy met by chance in Nairobi, at a dinner that an exiled African National Congress (ANC) activist couple was hosting in their flat: Robert van Lierop, a young African-American lawyer, anti-Vietnam campaigner, and active member of the radical strain of the US civil rights movement, and Eduardo Mondlane, President of the Frente de Libertação de Moçambique (FRELIMO), the armed movement that was directly challenging colonial rule over Mozambique by one of the United States’ NATO allies, Portugal’s autocratic Estado Novo (‘New State’).2 By the end of dinner, an enduring collaboration between these two strangers had been born. When van Lierop landed in Dar es Salaam two days later, Mondlane would introduce him to the inner workings of FRELIMO’s Department of Information and Propaganda (DIP). The young lawyer would go on to become one of Mondlane’s principal collaborators in the mobilization of American public opinion against the United States’ backing of Portugal. Five years later, this transatlantic collaboration materialized in what would become one of FRELIMO’s most famous propaganda films. The utopian representation of FRELIMO’s International solidarities and the liberation of the portuguese colonies armed struggle in 1972’s A luta continua (‘The Struggle Continues’) proved to be the most effective mean of winning the hearts and minds of American audiences. A luta continua is the American version of the more than 10 propaganda films made behind the front lines of the war in Mozambique between 1967 and 1973.
    [Show full text]
  • UCLA Ufahamu: a Journal of African Studies
    UCLA Ufahamu: A Journal of African Studies Title South Africa's Marionettes of Destabilisation Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/92p399xb Journal Ufahamu: A Journal of African Studies, 12(1) ISSN 0041-5715 Authors Fauvet, Paul Gomes, Alves Publication Date 1982 DOI 10.5070/F7121017182 eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California SOUTH AFRICA'S MARIONETTES OF DESTABILISATION* By Paul Fauvet and Alves Gomes To ensure its own survival, South Africa's apartheid regime is determined to maintain its grip over all the independent states in the region. Those independent states, working through the mechanism of the Southern Africa Development Coordination Conference (SADCC), are equally determined to break the ties of dependence that bind them to Pretoria. South Africa hectors, threatens and attE!IIIpts to destabilise its neighbours. Outright milit~ attacks alternate with econ­ omic pressure, with funding subversive activities, and with the occasional shot at bribery. ''MOZAMBIQUE NATIONAL RESISTANCE" This article looks at the main instrument now in use in efforts to destabilise Mozambique -- the so-called ''Mozambique National Resistance," (MNR) . When the leaders of the six Front Line states met in Maputo in early March, they stressed in their final communique that the South African regime was resorting to "the preparation, training and financing of armed bandits to destabilise the independent countries of southern Africa." The Front Line leaders can hardly not have bad in mind the group calling itself the "Mozambique National Resistance", and its increased activities in recent months, directed particularly against Mozambique's transport routes, so vital for the whole project of the Southern Africa Development Coordination Confer­ ence (SADCC) to break with the region's dependence on South Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • International Conference “A Luta Continua, 40 Years Later”: Entangled Histories and Legacies of Empire in Southern Africa
    International Conference “A Luta Continua, 40 years later”: Entangled Histories and Legacies of Empire in Southern Africa Date: 5-6 November 2015 Place: French Institute of South Africa 62 Juta Street, Braamfontein Johannesburg, South Africa Organizing Institutions: French Institute of South Africa Wits Institute for Social and Economic Research (WiSER) Institutional and Financial Support: Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation Cinemateca Portuguesa Pierre Du Bois Foundation for Current History Head of the Initiative: Caio Simões de Araújo, International History Department, Graduate Institute, Geneva Summary of the Initiative: This international conference will examine the histories and living legacies of the Portuguese empire in Southern Africa, 40 years after decolonization. It will encourage historians to debate the entangled trajectories of the region, in the past, present and future. The conference will furthermore invite scholars from the social sciences and humanities to reassess the Southern African postcolonial condition in its complex manifestations. The term “legacy” is understood in its broadest sense, to indicate the impact decolonization had on the subsequent postcolonial period, but also its material and immaterial heritage, ranging from architecture, literature, cinema, to the arts. Image: Constitutional Hill, Johannesburg. Photo by Caio Simões de Araújo. Call for Papers 2015 marks forty years of Portugal’s imperial withdrawal from Southern Africa. In the aftermath of a lengthy military conflict and a complicated negotiation process, the liberations of Mozambique and Angola in 1975 had a strong impact on neighbouring countries. On the one hand, these events deeply reconfigured power relations in the region. For instance, they had a decisive role in supporting the liberation struggles in Zimbabwe and Namibia and, in so doing, deepening the political deterioration of the apartheid regime, which eventually fell in 1994.
    [Show full text]
  • Samora Machel in Beira, June 19751
    Political Rhetoric in the Transition to Mozambican Independence: Samora Machel in Beira, June 19751 COLIN DARCH Democratic Governance and Rights Unit, University of Cape Town DAVID HEDGES Departamento de História, Universidade Eduardo Mondlane In late May 1975, Samora Machel crossed the Tanzanian border and began a month- long ‘Triumphal Journey’ down the whole length of Mozambique from north to south, finishing in Lourenço Marques (now Maputo). During the journey, he addressed crowds in the former liberated zones, as well as in urban centres such as Nampula, Quelimane and Beira, where Frelimo had had no public presence during the libera- tion struggle. A few days before national independence he made a lengthy speech in Portuguese to a large crowd in a football stadium in an outlying black suburb of Beira, Mozambique’s second city. This speech ranged widely over such topics as colo- nial racism, economic exploitation, and the tasks of reconstruction that lay ahead. It was the first time that the population of Beira had seen the Frelimo leader, soon to be the country’s first president. With no television stations, censored radio broadcasting, and only a few Portuguese-language newspapers with limited circulation, Frelimo needed to rely heavily on mass meetings and speeches to get its message across. This article breaks new ground in Mozambican studies by combining historical and socio- linguistic techniques to analyse an accurately reconstructed text of this particular speech, a recording of which is available online. It focuses on the historical context of Beira as a centre of colonial and settler resistance to FRELIMO’s struggle, as well as the speech’s content, its linguistic register and the rhetorical devices used to compel agreement and to persuade listeners of the correctness of Frelimo’s political line.
    [Show full text]