Albrecht Dürer's Personal Underweysung Der Messung
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Ghent University Academic Bibliography Word & Image A Journal of Verbal/Visual Enquiry ISSN: 0266-6286 (Print) 1943-2178 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/twim20 Albrecht Dürer’s personal Underweysung der Messung Noam Andrews To cite this article: Noam Andrews (2016) Albrecht Dürer’s personal Underweysung der Messung, Word & Image, 32:4, 409-429, DOI: 10.1080/02666286.2016.1216821 To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02666286.2016.1216821 Published online: 15 Nov 2016. Submit your article to this journal Article views: 10 View related articles View Crossmark data Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=twim20 Download by: [Thomas J. Watson Library, The Metropolitan Museum of Art] Date: 02 December 2016, At: 11:34 Albrecht Dürer’s personal Underweysung der Messung NOAM ANDREWS Abstract The article discusses the handwritten revisions and drawn additions by Albrecht Dürer in his own copy of the treatise on geometry, Underweysung der Messung (1525). Situating Dürer’s interest in mathematics within the scholarly milieu of Renaissance Nuremberg, the article addresses the shifts in style and content that Dürer proscribes and offers new perspectives on the artist’s relation to his own late work. The article concludes by displaying several drawings bound into the edition by Dürer that illustrate variations on perspectival apparatuses. These lesser known drawings illuminate the evolution of Dürer’s conceptualization of the dynamics between artist and subject, as well as the tools used to facilitate this interaction. Keywords Albrecht Dürer, editing, geometry, measurement, perspective, Platonic solids Albrecht Dürer’s(1471–1528) most important contribution to six- ratios as a means of determining the human body—asetof teenth-century geometry remains the first of his two major treatises theoretical concerns that potentially tracks back more easily to on measurement and proportion, Underweysung der Messung his artistic œuvre. Many of Dürer’s extant working drawings of (1525), a text which synthesized the internal structure, principles, figures are designs for prints in Vier Bücher von menschlicher and precision of Euclid’s Elements with various classical and con- Proportion, which show Dürer grappling with generating geome- temporary geometrical texts available to him in his home city of trical ratios of body proportions using a compass, though he 1 Nuremberg. Beginning with Euclidean principles and spreading eventually moves towards systems of ratios that balanced the into a diverse set of “mixed-mathematical,” or applied-geometrical dimensions of body parts to each other, sometimes even survey- 4 applications, such as column design, sundials, calligraphy, the ing the ratios of the body’s parts together in elaborate detail. modeling of polyhedra, and perspective, Underweysung systematically Perhaps the relative lack of interest in divining the permu- organizes a wealth of knowledge accumulated over a lifetime of tations of Dürer’s first geometrical work explains the scarcity artistic practice, and was intended, as Dürer declared in of scholarship on Dürer’s extraordinary personal copy of Underweysung’s introduction, to be “not only for painters, but also Underweysung der Messung, which has been located at the for goldsmiths, sculptors, stonemasons, carpenters, and all those for Bayerische Staatsbibliothek in Munich since 1839 and can 2 5 whom using measurement is useful.” Envisioned more as a peda- be consulted under the call number 4° L.impr.c.n.mss. 119. gogical provocation than a personal dissection of his own creative Still, this fascinating volume deserves another look. The book process, Underweysung would go on to form the theoretical base upon is a complete rendition of Dürer’s own edits and additions to which the next generations of German artists built their approach Underweysung, made sometime after its 1525 printing and to geometrical research and experimentation. Artists like Augustin before his death on April 6, 1528. The volume includes Hirschvogel (1503–53), Wenzel Jamnitzer (1507/8–85), Heinrich numerous unpublished geometrical diagrams (some of which Lautensack (1522–90), Lorentz Stöer (c.1530–after 1621), and others have been reproduced in this article) as well as two very developed proficiencies in geometricality by adopting the physical- significant, yet widely unknown, drawings of figures that 6 ity and tactility of Dürer’s geometry, in the process altering the have nearly escaped attention. Dürer’s notes, marked directly nature of geometrical knowledge from the abstract and theoretical in the margins in his own hand, bound together as separate discussions of Euclid into an intimate and approachable field of pages, and contained on small scraps of paper glued onto the investigation. This in turn generated new geometrical objects pages they reference, attest both to Dürer’s prolonged and intended to be touched, handled, and manipulated, such as the passionate engagement with the treatise even after its initial many three-dimensional polyhedral solids that appear in sixteenth- publication and to the authority he commanded as an 7 century German print culture and decorative arts. author. There is no “range of interpretive possibilities” for Nevertheless, Underweysung never became as popular with the workshop of Hieronymous Andreae (d. 1556)—the printer historians as Dürer’s second major treatise, the posthumously of the first and second posthumous 1538 edition of published Vier Bücher von menschlicher Proportion (1528), which had Underweysung as well as Dürer’s monumental Triumphal Arch been conceptualized as a more advanced treatise on drawing to (first printed 1526) for Emperor Maximilian I (1459–1519); no be studied after Underweysung and deployed geometry as a leeway to “schreibt hrein, was Ir wollt,” as has been discussed 3 stereometric aid in the representation of the human body. in relation to the blank sign in Dürer’s drawing The Recording 8 After all, Vier Bücher von menschlicher Proportion reveals Dürer’s of the Thoughts of the Pious and the Wicked (c.1500–15). All Dürer’s 9 developing and experimental interest in the use of proportional edits were carried over and faithfully reproduced. WORD & IMAGE, VOL. 32, NO. 4, OCTOBER–DECEMBER 2016 409 http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02666286.2016.1216821 # 2016 Taylor & Francis Tracing the contours of Dürer’s acute investment in his During this time, the “Regiomontan-Waltersche Bücherei” geometrical treatise provides a yet untapped access into the became an intellectual resource and reference library for a new mind of the artist in the last years of his life, and, moreover, generation of Nuremberg-based scholars such as Johannes indicates a route towards extrapolating more general conclu- Werner (1468–1522), who worked on spherical trigonometry sions about how Dürer’s revisions and edits are at once and conic sections; Dürer’s close friend the humanist reflective, and in excess, of the cultural expectations and Willibald Pirckheimer (1470–1530); Joachim Camerarius material practices of the Renaissance print workshop. By (1500–74), the classical scholar, Dürer’s biographer, and the triangulating between all three versions of Underweysung—the first translator of Dürer’s Underweysung into Latin; the influential 1525 original, Dürer’scopy,andthe1538 second edition—it is globe-maker and cosmographer Johannes Schöner (1477–1547), 13 possible to reconstruct the evolution of the treatise and and others. It was only in 1519, after a failed attempt to sell Dürer’s thoughts on it; to confirm the extent to which the books to Elector Friedrich the Wise of Saxony, that a Dürer’s edits and proscriptions were posthumously followed portion of the books was sold for the sum of 150 gulden, most by the printing house; and their relation to the numerous of which went to Pirckheimer, who recorded the purchase in 14 fragments of preparatory material for Underweysung scattered his personal manuscripts. throughout the world, as well as direct attention to the Dürer’s status as Nuremberg’s most celebrated artist would 10 numerousdrawingsin4°L.impr.c.n.mss.119. Beginning have been sufficient to provide him with access to the by contextualizing Dürer’s lifelong interest in geometry, and Regiomontanus-Walther library, irrespective of his close asso- Euclid in particular, the article centers on the corrections ciation with Pirckheimer and the other Nuremberg scholars. and insertions that Dürer made to his personal copy of But given his direct connections to Walther, he may even have Underweysung der Messung, commencing with the fastidious edit- had access to the library while Walther was alive. His parents ing of the text he undertook and concluding with his first had known Walther personally and Walther’s wife had been drafts for his famous perspectival scenes printed in the 1538 the godmother to Dürer’s sister Christina, who was born in edition. As Dürer himself notes in a handwritten inscription 1488. That Dürer was intimately familiar with the house itself is on the title page of 4°L.impr.c.n.mss.119: attested to by the fact that in 1509, five years after Walther’s death, he purchased the house from Walther’s heirs and moved I have properly corrected this book. If one wants to print a into it with his wife Agnes (1475–1539), living there until his further new copy then close attention should be paid to the 1528 corrections and care taken throughout to properly arrange death in when he was said to have been found with books 11 15 the old and new diagrams relative to the appropriate text. from the library scattered near him. Perhaps some of these books were those he had bought in 1523 from the library ’ Let us begin by accepting Durer s invitation. because of their “usefulness to painters,” when he had paid 16 ten florins for a selection of ten.