DOCSLIB.ORG

Reposs #11: the Mathematics of Niels Henrik Abel: Continuation and New Approaches in Mathematics During the 1820S

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Reposs #11: the Mathematics of Niels Henrik Abel: Continuation and New Approaches in Mathematics During the 1820S RePoSS: Research Publications on Science Studies RePoSS #11: The Mathematics of Niels Henrik Abel: Continuation and New Approaches in Mathematics During the 1820s Henrik Kragh Sørensen October 2010 Centre for Science Studies, University of Aarhus, Denmark Research group: History and philosophy of science Please cite this work as: Henrik Kragh Sørensen (Oct. 2010). The Mathematics of Niels Henrik Abel: Continuation and New Approaches in Mathemat- ics During the 1820s. RePoSS: Research Publications on Science Studies 11. Aarhus: Centre for Science Studies, University of Aarhus. url: http://www.css.au.dk/reposs. Copyright c Henrik Kragh Sørensen, 2010 The Mathematics of NIELS HENRIK ABEL Continuation and New Approaches in Mathematics During the 1820s HENRIK KRAGH SØRENSEN For Mom and Dad who were always there for me when I abandoned all good manners, good friends, and common sense to pursue my dreams. The Mathematics of NIELS HENRIK ABEL Continuation and New Approaches in Mathematics During the 1820s HENRIK KRAGH SØRENSEN PhD dissertation March 2002 Electronic edition, October 2010 History of Science Department The Faculty of Science University of Aarhus, Denmark This dissertation was submitted to the Faculty of Science, University of Aarhus in March 2002 for the purpose of ob- taining the scientific PhD degree. It was defended in a public PhD defense on May 3, 2002. A second, only slightly revised edition was printed October, 2004. The PhD program was supervised by associate professor KIRSTI ANDERSEN, History of Science Department, Univer- sity of Aarhus. Professors UMBERTO BOTTAZZINI (University of Palermo, Italy), JEREMY J. GRAY (Open University, UK), and OLE KNUDSEN (History of Science Department, Aarhus) served on the committee for the defense. c Henrik Kragh Sørensen and the History of Science De- partment (Department of Science Studies), University of Aarhus, 2002–2010. The dissertation was typeset in Palatino using pdfLATEX. First edition (March 2002, 7 copies) was copied and bound by the Printshop at the Faculty of Science, Aarhus. Second edition (October 2004, 5 copies) was printed and bound by the Printshop at Agder University College, Kris- tiansand. This electronic edition was compiled on October 28, 2010. For further information, additions, corrections, and contact to the author, please refer to the website http://www.henrikkragh.dk/phd/. The picture on the front page is a painting of NIELS HENRIK ABEL performed by the Norwegian painter JOHAN GØRB- ITZ during ABEL’s time in Paris 1826. It is the only authentic depiction of ABEL and is reproduced from (Ore, 1957). The picture on the reverse shows a curlicue frequently used by ABEL in his notebooks to mark the end of manuscripts. It is reproduced from (Stubhaug, 1996). Contents Contents i List of Tables vii List of Figures ix List of Boxes xi List of Theorems etc. xiii Summary xv Preface to the 2004 edition xvii Abel’s mathematics in the context of traditions and changes . xvii Recent literature....................................xviii Preface to the 2002 edition xxi Layout .........................................xxi Acknowledgments ..................................xxii I Introduction1 1 Introduction3 1.1 The historical and geographical setting of ABEL’s life ........... 4 1.2 The mathematical topics involved....................... 4 1.3 Themes from early nineteenth-century mathematics............ 7 1.4 Reflections on methodology.......................... 9 2 Biography of NIELS HENRIK ABEL 17 2.1 Childhood and education ........................... 18 2.2 “Study the masters”............................... 20 2.3 The European tour ............................... 26 2.4 Back in Norway................................. 36 i 3 Historical background 39 3.1 Mathematical institutions and networks................... 39 3.2 ABEL’s position in mathematical traditions ................. 41 3.3 The state of mathematics............................ 43 3.4 ABEL’s legacy .................................. 44 II “My favorite subject is algebra” 47 4 The position and role of ABEL’s works within the discipline of algebra 49 4.1 Outline of ABEL’s results and their structural position........... 50 4.2 Mathematical change as a history of new questions............. 53 5 Towards unsolvable equations 57 5.1 Algebraic solubility before LAGRANGE .................... 59 5.2 LAGRANGE’s theory of equations....................... 65 5.3 Solubility of cyclotomic equations....................... 72 5.4 Belief in algebraic solubility shaken...................... 80 5.5 RUFFINI’s proofs of the insolubility of the quintic.............. 84 5.6 CAUCHY’ theory of permutations and a new proof of RUFFINI’s theorem 90 5.7 Some algebraic tools used by GAUSS ..................... 95 6 Algebraic insolubility of the quintic 97 6.1 The first break with tradition ......................... 99 6.2 Outline of ABEL’s proof ............................100 6.3 Classification of algebraic expressions ....................101 6.4 ABEL and the theory of permutations.....................108 6.5 Permutations linked to root extractions....................110 6.6 Combination into an impossibility proof...................112 6.7 ABEL and RUFFINI ................................122 6.8 Limiting the class of solvable equations ...................124 6.9 Reception of ABEL’s work on the quintic...................125 6.10 Summary.....................................139 7 Particular classes of solvable equations 141 7.1 Solubility of Abelian equations.........................142 7.2 Elliptic functions.................................152 7.3 The concept of irreducibility at work.....................157 7.4 Enlarging the class of solvable equations...................160 8 A grand theory in spe 163 8.1 Inverting the approach once again ......................163 8.2 Construction of the irreducible equation...................165 ii 8.3 Refocusing on the equation ..........................171 8.4 Further ideas on the theory of equations...................176 8.5 General resolution of the problem by E. GALOIS . 181 IIIInterlude: ABEL and the ‘new rigor’ 189 9 The nineteenth-century change in epistemic techniques 191 10 Toward rigorization of analysis 193 10.1 EULER’s vision of analysis...........................193 10.2 LAGRANGE’s new focus on rigor .......................197 10.3 Early rigorization of theory of series .....................198 10.4 New types of series...............................204 11 CAUCHY’s new foundation for analysis 207 11.1 Programmatic focus on arithmetical equality . 207 11.2 CAUCHY’s concepts of limits and infinitesimals . 209 11.3 Divergent series have no sum.........................210 11.4 Means of testing for convergence of series..................212 11.5 CAUCHY’s proof of the binomial theorem ..................214 11.6 Early reception of CAUCHY’s new rigor ...................218 12 ABEL’s reading of CAUCHY’s new rigor and the binomial theorem 221 12.1 ABEL’s critical attitude.............................223 12.2 Infinitesimals...................................228 12.3 Convergence...................................229 12.4 Continuity ....................................233 12.5 ABEL’s “exception”...............................238 12.6 A curious reaction: Lehrsatz V . 241 12.7 From power series to absolute convergence . 246 12.8 Product theorems of infinite series ......................251 12.9 ABEL’s proof of the binomial theorem ....................254 12.10Aspects of ABEL’s binomial paper.......................260 13 ABEL and OLIVIER on convergence tests 265 13.1 OLIVIER’s theorem ...............................265 13.2 ABEL’s counter example ............................269 13.3 ABEL’s general refutation ...........................271 13.4 More characterizations and tests of convergence . 272 14 Reception of ABEL’s contribution to rigorization 277 14.1 Reception of ABEL’s rigorization .......................277 iii 14.2 Conclusion....................................281 IVElliptic functions and the Paris mémoire 283 15 Elliptic integrals and functions: Chronology and topics 285 15.1 Elliptic transcendentals before the nineteenth century . 286 15.2 The lemniscate..................................289 15.3 LEGENDRE’s theory of elliptic integrals....................292 15.4 Left in the drawer: GAUSS on elliptic functions . 296 15.5 Chronology of ABEL’s work on elliptic transcendentals . 297 16 The idea of inverting elliptic integrals 299 16.1 The importance of the lemniscate.......................299 16.2 Inversion in the Recherches . 300 16.3 The division problem..............................313 16.4 Perspectives on inversion ...........................319 17 Steps in the process of coming to “know” elliptic functions 321 17.1 Infinite representations.............................321 17.2 Elliptic functions as ratios of power series..................325 17.3 Characterization of ABEL’s representations . 328 17.4 Conclusion....................................330 18 Tools in ABEL’s research on elliptic transcendentals 331 18.1 Transformation theory .............................331 18.2 Integration in logarithmic terms........................339 18.3 Conclusion....................................345 19 The Paris memoir 347 19.1 ABEL’s approach to the Paris memoir . 347 19.2 The contents of ABEL’s Paris result and its proof . 351 19.3 Additional, tentative remarks on ABEL’s tools . 371 19.4 The fate of the Paris memoir . 375 19.5 Reception of the Paris memoir . 376 19.6 Conclusion....................................377
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Differential Calculus and by Era Integral Calculus, Which Are Related by in Early Cultures in Classical Antiquity the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus
    History of calculus - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia 1/1/10 5:02 PM History of calculus From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia History of science This is a sub-article to Calculus and History of mathematics. History of Calculus is part of the history of mathematics focused on limits, functions, derivatives, integrals, and infinite series. The subject, known Background historically as infinitesimal calculus, Theories/sociology constitutes a major part of modern Historiography mathematics education. It has two major Pseudoscience branches, differential calculus and By era integral calculus, which are related by In early cultures in Classical Antiquity the fundamental theorem of calculus. In the Middle Ages Calculus is the study of change, in the In the Renaissance same way that geometry is the study of Scientific Revolution shape and algebra is the study of By topic operations and their application to Natural sciences solving equations. A course in calculus Astronomy is a gateway to other, more advanced Biology courses in mathematics devoted to the Botany study of functions and limits, broadly Chemistry Ecology called mathematical analysis. Calculus Geography has widespread applications in science, Geology economics, and engineering and can Paleontology solve many problems for which algebra Physics alone is insufficient. Mathematics Algebra Calculus Combinatorics Contents Geometry Logic Statistics 1 Development of calculus Trigonometry 1.1 Integral calculus Social sciences 1.2 Differential calculus Anthropology 1.3 Mathematical analysis
    [Show full text]
  • Programme 2009 the Abel Prize Ceremony 19 May 2009 Procession Accompanied by the “Abel Fanfare” Music: Klaus Sandvik
    Programme 2009 The Abel Prize Ceremony 19 May 2009 Procession accompanied by the “Abel Fanfare” Music: Klaus Sandvik. Performed by three musicians from the Staff Band of the Norwegian Defence Forces Their Majesties King Harald and Queen Sonja enter the hall Soroban Arve Henriksen (trumpet) (Music: Arve Henriksen) Opening by Øyvind Østerud President of the Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters Eg veit i himmerik ei borg Trio Mediæval, Arve Henriksen (Norwegian folk tune from Hallingdal, arr. Linn A. Fuglseth) The Abel Prize Award Ceremony Professor Kristian Seip Chairman of the Abel Committee The Committee’s citation His Majesty King Harald presents the Abel Prize to Mikhail Leonidovich Gromov Acceptance speech by Mikhail Leonidovich Gromov Closing remarks by Professor Øyvind Østerud President of the Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters Till, till Tove Trio Mediæval, Arve Henriksen, Birger Mistereggen (percussion) (Norwegian folk tune from Vestfold, arr. Tone Krohn) Their Majesties King Harald and Queen Sonja leave the hall Procession leaves the hall Other guests leave the hall when the procession has left to a skilled mathematics teacher in the upper secondary school is called after Abel’s own Professor Øyvind Østerud teacher, Bernt Michael Holmboe. There is every reason to remember Holmboe, who was President of the Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters Abel’s mathematics teacher at Christiania Cathedral School from when Abel was 16. Holmboe discovered Abel’s talent, inspired him, encouraged him, and took the young pupil considerably further than the curriculum demanded. He pointed him to the professional literature, helped Your Majesties, Excellencies, dear friends, him with overseas contacts and stipends and became a lifelong colleague and friend.
    [Show full text]
  • EVARISTE GALOIS the Long Road to Galois CHAPTER 1 Babylon
    A radical life EVARISTE GALOIS The long road to Galois CHAPTER 1 Babylon How many miles to Babylon? Three score miles and ten. Can I get there by candle-light? Yes, and back again. If your heels are nimble and light, You may get there by candle-light.[ Babylon was the capital of Babylonia, an ancient kingdom occupying the area of modern Iraq. Babylonian algebra B.M. Tablet 13901-front (From: The Babylonian Quadratic Equation, by A.E. Berryman, Math. Gazette, 40 (1956), 185-192) B.M. Tablet 13901-back Time Passes . Centuries and then millennia pass. In those years empires rose and fell. The Greeks invented mathematics as we know it, and in Alexandria produced the first scientific revolution. The Roman empire forgot almost all that the Greeks had done in math and science. Germanic tribes put an end to the Roman empire, Arabic tribes invaded Europe, and the Ottoman empire began forming in the east. Time passes . Wars, and wars, and wars. Christians against Arabs. Christians against Turks. Christians against Christians. The Roman empire crumbled, the Holy Roman Germanic empire appeared. Nations as we know them today started to form. And we approach the year 1500, and the Renaissance; but I want to mention two events preceding it. Al-Khwarismi (~790-850) Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn Musa Al-Khwarizmi was born during the reign of the most famous of all Caliphs of the Arabic empire with capital in Baghdad: Harun al Rashid; the one mentioned in the 1001 Nights. He wrote a book that was to become very influential Hisab al-jabr w'al-muqabala in which he studies quadratic (and linear) equations.
    [Show full text]
  • Oslo 2004: the Abel Prize Celebrations
    NEWS OsloOslo 2004:2004: TheThe AbelAbel PrizePrize celebrationscelebrations Nils Voje Johansen and Yngvar Reichelt (Oslo, Norway) On 25 March, the Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters announced that the Abel Prize for 2004 was to be awarded to Sir Michael F. Atiyah of the University of Edinburgh and Isadore M. Singer of MIT. This is the second Abel Prize awarded following the Norwegian Government’s decision in 2001 to allocate NOK 200 million to the creation of the Abel Foundation, with the intention of award- ing an international prize for outstanding research in mathematics. The prize, amounting to NOK 6 million, was insti- tuted to make up for the fact that there is no Nobel Prize for mathematics. In addi- tion to awarding the international prize, the Foundation shall contribute part of its earnings to measures for increasing inter- est in, and stimulating recruitment to, Nils Voje Johansen Yngvar Reichelt mathematical and scientific fields. The first Abel Prize was awarded in machine – the brain and the computer, break those rules creatively, just like an 2003 to the French mathematician Jean- with the subtitle “Will a computer ever be artist or a musical composer. Pierre Serre for playing a key role in shap- awarded the Abel Prize?” Quentin After a brief interval, Quentin Cooper ing the modern form of many parts of Cooper, one of the BBC’s most popular invited questions from the audience and a mathematics. In 2004, the Abel radio presenters, chaired the meeting, in number of points were brought up that Committee decided that Michael F. which Sir Michael spoke for an hour to an Atiyah addressed thoroughly and profes- Atiyah and Isadore M.
    [Show full text]
  • Formulation of the Group Concept Financial Mathematics and Economics, MA3343 Groups Artur Zduniak, ID: 14102797
    Formulation of the Group Concept Financial Mathematics and Economics, MA3343 Groups Artur Zduniak, ID: 14102797 Fathers of Group Theory Abstract This study consists on the group concepts and the four axioms that form the structure of the group. Provided below are exam- ples to show different mathematical opera- tions within the elements and how this form Otto Holder¨ Joseph Louis Lagrange Niels Henrik Abel Evariste´ Galois Felix Klein Camille Jordan the different characteristics of the group. Furthermore, a detailed study of the formu- lation of the group theory is performed where three major areas of modern group theory are discussed:The Number theory, Permutation and algebraic equations the- ory and geometry. Carl Friedrich Gauss Leonhard Euler Ernst Christian Schering Paolo Ruffini Augustin-Louis Cauchy Arthur Cayley What are Group Formulation of the group concept A group is an algebraic structure consist- The group theory is considered as an abstraction of ideas common to three major areas: ing of different elements which still holds Number theory, Algebraic equations theory and permutations. In 1761, a Swiss math- some common features. It is also known ematician and physicist, Leonhard Euler, looked at the remainders of power of a number as a set. All the elements of a group are modulo “n”. His work is considered as an example of the breakdown of an abelian group equipped with an algebraic operation such into co-sets of a subgroup. He also worked in the formulation of the divisor of the order of the as addition or multiplication. When two el- group. In 1801, Carl Friedrich Gauss, a German mathematician took Euler’s work further ements of a group are combined under an and contributed in the formulating the theory of abelian groups.
    [Show full text]
  • The History of the Abel Prize and the Honorary Abel Prize the History of the Abel Prize
    The History of the Abel Prize and the Honorary Abel Prize The History of the Abel Prize Arild Stubhaug On the bicentennial of Niels Henrik Abel’s birth in 2002, the Norwegian Govern- ment decided to establish a memorial fund of NOK 200 million. The chief purpose of the fund was to lay the financial groundwork for an annual international prize of NOK 6 million to one or more mathematicians for outstanding scientific work. The prize was awarded for the first time in 2003. That is the history in brief of the Abel Prize as we know it today. Behind this government decision to commemorate and honor the country’s great mathematician, however, lies a more than hundred year old wish and a short and intense period of activity. Volumes of Abel’s collected works were published in 1839 and 1881. The first was edited by Bernt Michael Holmboe (Abel’s teacher), the second by Sophus Lie and Ludvig Sylow. Both editions were paid for with public funds and published to honor the famous scientist. The first time that there was a discussion in a broader context about honoring Niels Henrik Abel’s memory, was at the meeting of Scan- dinavian natural scientists in Norway’s capital in 1886. These meetings of natural scientists, which were held alternately in each of the Scandinavian capitals (with the exception of the very first meeting in 1839, which took place in Gothenburg, Swe- den), were the most important fora for Scandinavian natural scientists. The meeting in 1886 in Oslo (called Christiania at the time) was the 13th in the series.
    [Show full text]
  • All About Abel Dayanara Serges Niels Henrik Abel (August 5, 1802-April 6,1829) Was a Norwegian Mathematician Known for Numerous Contributions to Mathematics
    All About Abel Dayanara Serges Niels Henrik Abel (August 5, 1802-April 6,1829) was a Norwegian mathematician known for numerous contributions to mathematics. Abel was born in Finnoy, Norway, as the second child of a dirt poor family of eight. Abels father was a poor Lutheran minister who moved his family to the parish of Gjerstad, near the town of Risr in southeast Norway, soon after Niels Henrik was born. In 1815 Niels entered the cathedral school in Oslo, where his mathematical talent was recognized in 1817 by his math teacher, Bernt Michael Holmboe, who introduced him to the classics in mathematical literature and proposed original problems for him to solve. Abel studied the mathematical works of the 17th-century Englishman Sir Isaac Newton, the 18th-century German Leonhard Euler, and his contemporaries the Frenchman Joseph-Louis Lagrange and the German Carl Friedrich Gauss in preparation for his own research. At the age of 16, Abel gave a proof of the Binomial Theorem valid for all numbers not only Rationals, extending Euler's result. Abels father died in 1820, leaving the family in straitened circumstances, but Holmboe and other professors contributed and raised funds that enabled Abel to enter the University of Christiania (Oslo) in 1821. Abels first papers, published in 1823, were on functional equations and integrals; he was the first person to formulate and solve an integral equation. He had also created a proof of the impossibility of solving algebraically the general equation of the fifth degree at the age of 19, which he hoped would bring him recognition.
    [Show full text]
  • Michael Kühn Detlev Auvermann RARE BOOKS
    ANTIQUARIAT 55Michael Kühn Detlev Auvermann RARE BOOKS 1 Rolfinck’s copy ALESSANDRINI, Giulio. De medicina et medico dialogus, libris quinque distinctus. Zurich, Andreas Gessner, 1557. 4to, ff. [6], pp. AUTOLYKOS (AUTOLYCUS OF PYTANE). 356, ff. [8], with printer’s device on title and 7 woodcut initials; a few annotations in ink to the text; a very good copy in a strictly contemporary binding of blind-stamped pigskin, the upper cover stamped ‘1557’, red Autolyci De vario ortu et occasu astrorum inerrantium libri dvo nunc primum de graeca lingua in latinam edges, ties lacking; front-fly almost detached; contemporary ownership inscription of Werner Rolfinck on conuersi … de Vaticana Bibliotheca deprompti. Josepho Avria, neapolitano, interprete. Rome, Vincenzo title (see above), as well as a stamp and duplicate stamp of Breslau University library. Accolti, 1588. 4to, ff. [6], pp. 70, [2]; with large woodcut device on title, and several woodcut diagrams in the text; title a little browned, else a fine copy in 19th-century vellum-backed boards, new endpapers. EUR 3.800.- EUR 4.200.- First edition of Alessandrini’s medical dialogues, his most famous publication and a work of rare erudition. Very rare Latin edition, translated from a Greek manuscript at the Autolycus was a Greek mathematician and astronomer, who probably Giulio Alessandrini (or Julius Alexandrinus de Neustein) (1506–1590) was an Italian physician and author Vatican library, of Autolycus’ work on the rising and setting of the fixed flourished in the second half of the 4th century B.C., since he is said to of Trento who studied philosophy and medicine at the University of Padua, then mathematical science, stars.
    [Show full text]
  • Éclat a Mathematics Journal
    Éclat A Mathematics Journal Volume I 2010 Department of Mathematics Lady Shri Ram College For Women Éclat A Mathematics Journal Volume I 2010 To Our Beloved Teacher Mrs. Santosh Gupta for her 42 years of dedication Preface The revival of Terminus a quo into E´clat has been a memorable experience. Eclat´ , with its roots in french, means brilliance. The journey from the origin of Terminus a quo to the brilliance of E´clat is the journey we wish to undertake. In our attempt to present diverse concepts, we have divided the journal into four sections - History of Mathematics, Rigour in Mathematics, Extension of Course Contents and Interdisciplinary Aspects of Mathematics. The work contained here is not original but consists of the review articles contributed by both faculty and students. This journal aims at providing a platform for students who wish to publish their ideas and also other concepts they might have come across. Our entire department has been instrumental in the publishing of this journal. Its compilation has evolved after continuous research and discussion. Both the faculty and the students have been equally enthusiastic about this project and hope such participation continues. We hope that this journal would become a regular annual feature of the department and would encourage students to hone their skills in doing individual research and in writing academic papers. It is an opportunity to go beyond the prescribed limits of the text and to expand our knowledge of the subject. Dootika Vats Ilika Mohan Rangoli Jain Contents Topics Page 1) History of Mathematics 1 • Abelia - The Story of a Great Mathematician 2 • Geometry in Ancient Times 6 2) Rigour in Mathematics 10 • Lebesgue Measure and Integration 11 • Construction of the Real Number System 18 • Fuzzy Logic in Action 25 3) Extension of Course Contents 29 • Continuum Hypothesis 30 • Dihedral Groups 35 4) Inter-disciplinary Aspects of Mathematics 41 • Check Digits 42 • Batting Average 46 1 History of Mathematics The history behind various mathematical concepts and great mathemati- cians is intriguing.
    [Show full text]
  • Mathematics People
    Mathematics People Codá Marques Awarded CMS G. de B. Robinson Award Ramanujan and TWAS Prizes Announced Fernando Codá Marques of the Instituto Nacional de Teodor Banica of the University of Toulouse, Serban Matemática Pura e Aplicada (IMPA) in Rio de Janeiro, Bra- Belinschi of Queens University, Mireille Capitaine of zil, has been named the recipient of two major prizes for the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), 2012: the Ramanujan Prize of the International Centre for and Benoît Collins of the University of Ottawa have Theoretical Physics (ICTP), the Niels Henrik Abel Memorial been awarded the 2012 G. de B. Robinson Award of the Fund, and the International Mathematical Union (IMU); and Canadian Mathematical Society (CMS) for their paper the TWAS Prize, awarded by the Academy of Sciences for titled “Free Bessel laws”, published in the Canadian Jour- the Developing World (TWAS). nal of Mathematics 63 (2011), 3–37, http://dx.doi. The announcement from the ICTP/IMU for the Ra- org/10.4153/CJM-2010-060-6. The award is given in manujan Prize reads in part: “The prize is in recognition recognition of outstanding contributions to the Canadian of his several outstanding contributions to differential Journal of Mathematics or the Canadian Mathematical geometry. Together with his coauthors, Fernando Codá Bulletin. Marques has solved long-standing open problems and ob- tained important results, including results on the Yamabe —From a CMS announcement problem, the complete solution of Schoen’s conjecture, counterexamples to the
    [Show full text]
  • Unsolvable Equation
    Unsolvable Equation 1 Évariste Galois and Niels Henrik Abel Niels Henrik Abel (1802-1829) • Born on August 5, 1802, the son of a pastor and parliament member in the small Norwegian town of Finnø. Father died an alcoholic when Abel was 18, leaving behind nine children (Abel was second oldest) and a widow who turned to alcohol • Abel was shy, melancholy, and depressed by poverty and apparent failure • Completely self-taught, Abel entered University of Christiania in 1822 • Norway separated from Denmark when Abel was 12, but remained under Swedish control. Only 11,000 inhabitants in Christiania at the time (a backwater) • 1823: Abel incorrectly believes that he has solved the general equation of the fifth degree • After finding an error, proves that such a solution is impossible • To save printing costs, paper is published in a pamphlet at his own cost, with the result in summary form • 1824: This result together with a paper on the integration of algebraic expressions (now known as Abelian integrals) led to him being awarded a stipend for study trip abroad • Abel hoped trip would allow him to marry fiancee who remained in Norway as governess (Christine Kemp) • Abel travels to Berlin, where he stays from September 1825 to February 1826 • Encouraged and mentored by the August Leopold Crelle, a promoter of science. • Crelle founds Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik (also known as Crelle’s Journal), the premiere German mathematical journal, and the very first volume includes several works by Abel • Impossibility of solving the quintic equation by radicals • Binomial series (contribution to the foundation of analysis) • One of the results is Abel’s Theorem on Continuity in complex analysis, which clarified and corrected some foundational results of Cauchy • In July 1826 went to Paris where remained until the end of the year • Isolated in Paris’s more elegant and traditional society; impossible to approach the great men of the Académie, e.g.
    [Show full text]
  • Reflections on the Pragmatics of the Illustrated Perspective Treatise Performative Failures and (Pre-) Romantic Innovations Eduardo Ralickas
    Document generated on 09/25/2021 8:06 a.m. Intermédialités Histoire et théorie des arts, des lettres et des techniques Intermediality History and Theory of the Arts, Literature and Technologies Reflections on the Pragmatics of the Illustrated Perspective Treatise Performative Failures and (Pre-) Romantic Innovations Eduardo Ralickas exposer Article abstract displaying This essay reconsiders visual demonstrations contained in a selection of Number 15, printemps 2010 illustrated perspective treatises. Based on a fundamental distinction made in the field of pragmatics, the author argues that the images designed to URI: https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/044680ar demonstrate/teach/instantiate the perspectival system are plagued by a DOI: https://doi.org/10.7202/044680ar contradiction between the conceptual “content” of perspective and the figurative means deployed to display such content. In all cases, this aporia, which defines the teaching of perspective by means of images, arises when the See table of contents figurative discourse of perspective attempts to integrate a representation of its user within the system itself. In closing, the author suggests that the perspective treatise’s “pragmatic unconscious” allows one to shed new light on Publisher(s) the pictorial innovations of German romanticism, particularly in the work of Caspar David Friedrich, which is tied to fundamental (and hitherto unforeseen) Revue Intermédialités (Presses de l’Université de Montréal) ways to the “failures” of the classical age. ISSN 1705-8546 (print) 1920-3136 (digital) Explore this journal Cite this article Ralickas, E. (2010). Reflections on the Pragmatics of the Illustrated Perspective Treatise: Performative Failures and (Pre-) Romantic Innovations. Intermédialités / Intermediality, (15), 163–185.
    [Show full text]