journal of jesuit studies 6 (2019) 627-650 brill.com/jjs The Reluctant Martyr: John Hart’s English Mission Mordechai Feingold California Institute of Technology
[email protected] Abstract In chronicles of early Catholic missions to England, John Hart (d.1586) comes across as something of an embarrassment. Slated to be executed alongside Edmund Campion on December 1, 1581, at the last moment Hart chose life over martyrdom. In exchange for his freedom he volunteered to spy on William Allen, president of the English Col- lege in Rheims. Equally embarrassing, in the context of the charged religious and po- litical atmosphere of the early 1580s, when put to the test as a scholar, Hart revealed weakness instead of strength in his conference with John Rainolds. Though this basic story line is known and often summarily retold, few scholars have delved into the intri- cacies of the affair—an omission this article seeks to remedy. Keywords John Hart – Jesuits – English mission – John Rainolds – religious controversies – martyrs In chronicles of early Catholic missions to England, John Hart (d.1586) comes across as something of an embarrassment.1 Slated to be executed alongside Ed- mund Campion (1540–81) on December 1, 1581, at the last moment Hart chose life over martyrdom. In exchange for his freedom he volunteered to spy on William Allen (1532–94), president of the English College in Rheims. Equally embarrassing, in the context of the charged religious and political atmosphere of the early 1580s, when put to the test as a scholar, Hart revealed weakness instead of strength, even conceding to his Protestant antagonist, John Rainolds 1 I wish to thank Mauro Brunello, Victor Houliston, Gerard Kilroy, Thomas McCoog, Carol Magun, Michael Questier, Stefania Tutino, Jonathan Woolfson, and several referees for their helpful comments.