Echinoderm Research, De Ridder. Dubois, Lahaye & Jangoux (eds) 0 1990 Balkema, Rotterdam. ISBN 90 6191 141 9 Biological control of skeleton properties in echinoderms
Ph. Dubois* Laboratoire de Biologie marine (CP 160), Universitd Libre de Bnucelles, Bnucelles, Belgique
ABSTRACT: Echinoderms have a high-magnesium calcite skeleton whose cristallographic, chemical, and morphological properties make it different from abiotic calcites. The available data show that the single crystal behaviour, the conchoidal fracture properties, the high-magnesium content, and the stereom structure could be partly explained by the properties of the organic nacromolecules associated with the mineral phase. Data suzest that these compounds could produce the stereom properties through stereochemical interactions with calcite.
of CaC03 and MgC03 in a calcite lattice. i.e. a high-magnesium calcite (Chave Echinoderms have a calcitic skeleton of 1952). The RgC03 content ranges from 3.0 mesodermal origin. This skeleton is to 43.5 mole?/, (Schroeder et al. 1969) developed by most postmetamorphic and averages 13.5-16.2 mole% according individuals as well as by larvae of to the class considered (V!eber 1969). echinoids and ophiuroids. The growing Such a concentration would make evidence indicates that the echinoderm skeleton metastable in postmetamorphic and larval skeletons are standard inorganic temperature/ pressure homologous structures (see Emlet 1985, conditions (Lerman 1965). Parks et al. 1987, Drager et al. 1989, Most single ossicles show properties Dubois 6r Chen 1989, Richardson et al. of light polarization and X-ray 1989). The echinoderm skeleton may be diffraction as though they were carved considered as a paradigm of biologically out of a single crystal of calcite even controlled mineralized structures (I.:ann when they are several centimetres in et al. 1989). differing by most of its length (Raup 1959. Nissen 1969. Donnay & properties from abiotically synthetized Pawson 1959). Furthermore, contrary to calcites. what could have been supposed from these Each skeleton element (the so-called properties of the ossicles, trabeculae ossicle) consists of a rounded do not fracture along the usual tridimensional network of trabeculae , rhombohedra1 cleavage of calcite but the stereom, devoid of any apparent show conchoidal fractures (Nichols & crystalline feature (larval spicules Currey 1968, Nissen 1969). correspond to isolated trabeculae) This paper reviews the present (Nichols & Currey 1968). Furthermore, knowledge of the biological mechanisms the stereom surface has the which control and generate the stereom characteristics of a so-called "periodic properties. minimal surface" (viz. a surface that divides space into two interpenetrating regions, each of them being a single multiply connected domain with no connection with the other) (Donnay & Althou~h a few ossicles were Paason 1969). demonstrated to behave optically as The mineral phase is a solid solution polycrystals (Towe 1967, Donnay & Pawson 1969, M5rkel et al. 1971, MZrkel 19791, *. Senior Research Assistant NFSR most of the echinoderm skeleton is made (Belgium) of phenotypically monocrystalline ossicles. Data are only available on the echinoid larval spicules, and (2) that mechanisms which control the it is possible to cause thcir crystallography of the latter. niisali~nment by inhibition of the The properties characteristic of El-glycosylation of proteins, suggesting single crystals can result frorr! either a direct involvement of the an actual monocrystal i.. a intraspicular glycoproteins in crystal crystalline net1.1ork devoid of alignment. discontinuities) or a highly ordered Conchoidal fractures of stereo= polycrystalline aggregate. In a trabeculae are probably also due to the Siomineralization context, the presence presence of ION. Berman et al. (1988) of coherent organic material within the showed that calcite crystals which were skeleton is a steppine stone in the abiotically grown in presence of S?-: denonstration of the polycrystalline contained specifically adsorbed Sil on nature of the mineral phase (Tovre 1972). their (li00)* planes and cleaved ":vith Contrary to previous statements in the difficulty" along a curved surface of literature, the echinoderm stereon does nlassy appearance reminiscent of the - contain organic macromolecules (see !!ilt conchoidal fracture of echinoderm Pt Denson 1933 and Dubois 3 Chen 1989 for stereom. These authors concluded that, review ) . These we classically separated during cleavage, the SII adsorbed on the into EETA-soluble and EDTA-insoluble TOO) planes creates a- continuous constituents, viz. thc soluble and interference with tile (1014) cleavage insoluble matrix; S:.! and I;>:, planes of calcite resulting in no respectively (the functional validity of well-defined cleavage direction, i.e. in this dichotomy is, however, debated; see s conchoidal fracture. Furthermore, the Yheeler S Sikes 1989). The soluble unusually high strength of the components are principally proteins, echinoderm stereom (Weber et al. 1969, several of them being acidic Enlet 1992) is sugnested to result from PJ-slycosylated slycoproteins (Weiner both the qeneral presence of IOt.1 (makin5 1985, Benson et al. 1986, Di Virgilio h the stereom a composite material) and Dubois unpubl.). Addadi G Weiner (1969) from the specific inclusion of S:l: in proposed that these proteins are cleavage-inhibiting planes. intracrystalline and not structured in a Different treatments of the conchoidal coherent framework. They consequently fractures result in a differential suggested that the intrastereomic etching pattern made of whiskered organic macromolecules (ION) only induce structures parallel to the general local discontinuities in the crystalline c-axis of the ossicle (Pearse & Pearse network, dividing the stereom element 1975. Okazaki G Inou6 1976, Oqrieill into mosaic blocks but not into discrete 1981. Dubois & Jangoux 1985). nicrocrystals (that would conpose a true Differential etching patterns of polycrystalline agzregate). However, biomineralized structures may result Addadi .% 1:leiner (ls89) only considered from selective inclusion of organic th~soluble constituents and overlooked material during mineralization (Addadi & the intrastereomic insoluble Yeincr 1989). Dubois (1988, see also constituents. Since morphological Dubois ,& Chen 1989) suggested effective investigations showed that a coherent involvement of 10:: in the generation of organic material occurs in both larvsl the whiskered structures. He showed that spicules and postmetamorphic ossicles calcite crystals, which were epitaxially (Benson et al. 1933, Dubois 1988), it is grown on fractured trabeculae in most likely that this material presence of S11 in an abiotic system, introduces extensive discontinuities in ta!calcification. ions in a supersaturated solution of Growth directions of echinoid larval calcium carbonate results in the final spicules (which me homologous to single precipitation of aragonite (Kitano 1964, trabeculae) follow well-defined Glover & Sippel 1967, Kitano et al. crystallographic orientations (Okazaki 1979). On the contrary, the presence of 1975). Now, echinoid SM selectively some organic compounds (such as adsorbs on (1i00) faces of abiotically glycoproteins) in a precipitating medium growing calcite crystals and, as a containing calcium, magnesium, and consequence, inhibits crystal growth in bicarbonate ions induces the these directions, i .e. in directions precipitation of magnesium calcite perpendicular to the c-axis (Berman et (Kitano 1964, Kitano & Hood 1965). The al. 1988). These data suggest that intrastereomic organic material which is stereom morphogenesis could also be partly composed of glycoproteins could directed by secretion of SM into the thus account for the high magnesium calcifying space and that the SM would concentration of echinoderm calcite. act as an inhibitor in specifically Concordantly, the temperature effect on adsorbing on definite crystalline faces. skeletal magnesium concentration in Addadi & Weiner (1989) proposed that echinoderms, which was emphasized for a this specific adsorption depends on long time, is now considered to be stereochemical factors. limited and the intrastereomic organic Finally, the presence of magnesium in material is suggested to account for the the calcite lattice (a presence which observed variability (see Dubois & Chen could depend on the IOM) may also act 1989 for discussion). upon the trabecular morphology. Okazaki & Inou6 (1976) showed that echinoid larvae reared in magnesium-free sea 4.STEREOM MORPHOLOGY water formed abnormal spicules whose ends correspond to the cleavage faces of Echinoderm stereom is a quite unique a calcite rhomb. On the other hand, three-dimensional structure which shows larvae reared in sea water containing smooth rounded curves without any one-tenth of the normal calcium relationship with its crystalline concentration (with the normal magnesium properties. Three factors may act as concentration) formed spicules whose potential regulators of stereom ends had a globular shape. These morphology: (1) the membrane of the experiments show that magnesium could be calcifying site, (2) selective involved in concealing the crystalline inhibitors of the crystalline growth, faces of echinoderm high-magnesium and (3) the incorporation of magnesium calcite. This suggestion is supported by ions. SEM observations of synthesized The membrane which limits the high-magnesium calcite crystals. These are deprived of crystalline edges and Biomineralization: chemical and some of them show a rounded to spherical biochemical Perspectives, pp.133-156. morphology (Devery & Ehlmann 1981, VCH Verlaggesellschaft: Weinheim. BRD. Bischoff et al. 1987, Koch 1989). Some Benson S., N.Benson & F.Wilt 1986. The of these crystals actually resemble organic matrix of the skeletal spicule trabecular fragments (see Bischoff et of sea-urchin Strongylocentrotus al. 1987: fig.2B). purpuratus embryos. J. Cell Biol. 102: 1878-1886. Benson S. , E.M.E. Jones, N.Crise-Benson & F.Wilt 1983. Morphology of the organic matrix of the spicule of the sea The available data emphasize the urchin larva. Exp. Cell Res. 148: paramount importance of the organic 249-253. macromolecules associated with the Berman A.. L.Addadi & S.Weiner 1988. mineral phase in controlling the Interactions of sea-urchin skeleton properties of the echinoderm skeleton. macromolecules with growing calcite - The evidence suggests that these crystals. A study of intracrystalline compounds act at a stereochemical level. proteins. Nature, Lond. 331: 546-548. as in other calcium carbonate Bischoff W.D., F.T.Mackenzie & biomineralizing systems. F.C.Bischop 1987. Stabilities of Although the importance of the synthetic magnesian calcites in skeleton-f orming cell (in confining and aqueous solution: comparison with framing the calcification site) and of biogenic materials. Geochim. the ion transport systems (in Cosmochim. Acta 51: 1413-1423. qualitatively and quantitatively Blake D.F., D.R.Peacor & L.F.Al1-d regulating the ion delivery to the 1984. Ultrastructural and micro- calcification site) should not be analytical results from echinoderm underrated. advances in our calcite: implications for biomine- understanding of the properties of the ralization and diagenesis of echinoderm skeleton will probably result skeletal material. Micron Microsc. mostly from a better knowledge of the Acta 15: 85-90. stereom associated organic macro- Chave K.E. 1952. A solid solution molecules. Thus, future investigations between calcite and dolomite. J.Geo1. should focus on: (1) the assessment of 60: 190-192. the diversity of IOM and of their exact Devery D.M. & A.J.Ehlmann 1981. role in the calcification process, Morphological changes in a series of (2) the in situ ultrastructure of the synthetic Mg-calcites. Amer. Miner. IOM (this should definitely resolve the 66: 592-595. polycrystal vs mosaic crystal debate ) , Donnay G. & D.L.Pawson 1969. X-ray (3) the molecular identification of the diffraction studies of echinoderm IOM, (4) the in vivo evaluation of plates. Science 166: 1147-1150. abiotic models, especially the Drager B.J., M.A.Harkey, M.Iwata & stereochemical control of crystal- A.H.Whiteleg 1989. The expression of lization. embryonic primary mesenchyme genes of the sea urchin Strongylocentrotus purpuratus in the adult skeletogenic tissues of this and other species of echinoderms. Dev. Biol. 133: 14-23 The author wishes to thank Dubois Ph. 1988. Tissu squelettique et Pmf'.M. Jangoux for critical reading of calcification chez Asterias rubens L. the manuscript and Prof.J.M.Lawrence and (Echinodermata: Asteroidea). These de Dr.A.B.Smith for fruitful discussion. Doctorat, Universit4 Libre de Work supported by FRFC contract Brwelles: Brwelles, Belgique. n02.4527.89. Dubois Ph. & C.P.Chen 1989. Calcification in echinoderms. Echinoderm Studies 3: 109-178. Dubois Ph. & M.Jangoux 1985. The . microstructure of the asteroid Addadi L. & S.Weiner 1989. skeleton (Asterias rubens). In Stereochemical and structural B.F.Keegan & B.D.S.O'Connor (eds), relations between macromolecules and Proceedings of the fifth international crystals in biomineralization. In echinoderm Conference, Galway, S.Mann. J.Webb & R.J.P.Williams (eds), pp.507-512. A.A. Balkema: Rotterdam. Emlet R.B. 1982. Echinoderm calcite: a Mizoguchi A.. T.Mizuochi. Y.Kitazume. mechanical analysis from larval G.Tamura & A.Kobata 1981. Abnormal spicules. Biol. Bull. 163: 264-275. spicule formation induced by Emlet R.B. 1985. Crystal axes in recent tunicamycin in the early development and fossil adult echinoids indicate of the sea urchin embryo. Cell Struct. trophic mode in larval development. Funct. 6: 341-346. Science 230: 937-940. Nichols D. & J.D.Currey 1968. The Glover E.C. & R.G.Sippe1 1967. Synthesis secretion, structure and strength of of magnesium calcites. Geochim. echinoderm calcite. In S.M.McGee- Cosmochim. Acta 31: 603-613. Russell & K.F.A.Ross (eds), Cell Kitano Y. 1964. On factors influencing Structure and its Interpretation, the polymorphic crystallization . of pp. 251-261. Edward Arnold: London. calcium carbonate found in marine Nissen H.U. 1969. Crystal orientation biological systems. In Y.Miyake & and plate structure in echinoid T.Koyama (eds), Recent Researches in skeletal units. Science 166: the Fields of Hydrosphere, Atmosphere 1150-1152. and nuclear Geochemistry, pp. 305-319. Okazaki K. 1962. Skeleton formation of Maruzen Company: Tokyo. sea urchin larvae. IV. Correlation in Kitano Y. & D.W.Hood 1965. The influence shape of spicule and matrix. of organic material on the polymorphic Embryologia 7: 21-38. crystallization of calcium carbonate. Okazaki K. 1975. Normal development to Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 29: 29-41. metamorphosis. In G.Czihak (ed.), The Kitano Y., A.Tokuyama & T.Arakaki 1979. Sea Urchin Embryo, pp. 177-232. Magnesian calcite synthesis from Springe~verlag:Berlin. calcium bicarbonate solution Okazaki K. & S.Inou6 1976. Crystal containing magnesium and barium ions. property of the larval sea urchin Geochim. J. 13: 181-185. spicule. Dev. Growth Differ. 18: Koch B. 1989. Les calcaires en milieu 413-434. marin; syntheses et analyses de O'Neill P.L. 1981. Polycrystalline solutions solides CaC03-MgC03; Btude echinoderm calcite and its fracture de leur solubilit6 dans l'eau de mer mechanics. Science 213: 646-648. en fonction de la pression. Thsse de Parks A.L., B.A.Parr, J.E.Chin. Doctorat, Universit6 de Liege: Liege, D.S.Leaf & R.A.Raff 1987. Molecular Belgique. analysis of heterochronic changes in Lerman A. 1965. Paleoecological problems the evolution of direct developing sea of Mg and Sr in biogenic calcites in urchins. J. evol. Biol. 1: 27-44 light of recent thermodynamic data. Pearse J.S. & V.B.Pearse 1975. Growth Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 29: 977-1002. zones in the echinoid skeleton. Am. Mann S., J.Webb & R.J.P.Williams (eds) Zool. 15:731-753. 1989. Biomineralization: chemical and Raup D.M. 1959. Crystallography of biochemical Perspectives. VCH echinoid calcite. J. Geol. 67: Verlaggesellschaft: Weinheim. BRD. 661-674. M'Srkel K. 1979. Structure and growth of Richardson W., T.Kitajima, F.Wilt & the cidaroid socket-joint lantern of S.Benson 1989. Expression of an Aristotle compared to the hinge-joint embryonic spicule matrix gene in lanterns of non-cidaroid regular calcified tissues of adult sea echinoids (Echinodermata, Echinoidea). urchins. Dev. Biol. 132: 266-269 Zoomorphologie 94: 1-32. Schroeder J.H.. E.J.Dwornik & J.J.Papike MSrkel K., F.Kubanek & A.Willgallis 1969. Primary protodolomite in 1971. Polykristalliner Calcit bei echinoid skeletons. Geol. Soc. Am. Seeigeln (Echinodermata. Echinoidea). Bull. 80: 1613-1616. Z. Zellforsch. 119: 355-377. Twe K.M. 1967. Echinoderm calcite: MZrkel K., U.R5ser, U.Mackenstedt & single crystal or polycrystalline M.Klostermann 1986. Ultrastructural aggregate. Science 157: 1048-1050. investigations of matrix-mediated Towe K.M. 1972. Invertebrate shell biomineralization in echinoids structure and the organic matrix (Echinodermata, Echinoidea). Zoomor- concept. Biomineralization 4: 1-14. phology 106: 232-243. Weber J.N. 1969. The incorporation of Mtirkel K., U.RGser & M.Stauber 1989. On magnesium into the skeletal calcites the ultrastructure and the supposed of echinoderms. Am. J. Sci. 267: function of the mineralizing matrix 537-566. coat of sea urchins (Echinoderrnata, Weber J., R.Greer, B.Voight, E.White & Echinoidea). Zoomorphology 109: 79-87. R.Roy 1969. Unusual strength properties of echinoderm calcite related to structure. J. Ultrastruct. Res. 26: 355-366. Weiner S. 1985. Organic matrix-like macromolecules associated with the mineral phase of sea-urchin skeletal plates and teeth. J. exp. 2001. 234: 7-15. Wheeler A.P. & C.S.Sikes 1989. Matrix-crystal interactions in CaCO biomineralization. In S.Mann. J.Webb 2 R.J.P.Williams (eds), Biomine- ralization: chemical and biochemical Perspectives. pp.95-131. VCH Verlaggesellschaft: Weinheim, BRD. Wilt F.H. 1987. Determination and morphogenesis in the sea urchin embryo. Development 100: 559-575. Wilt F.H. & S.C.Benson 1988. Development of the endoskeletal spicule of the sea urchin embryo. In J.E.Varner (ed.), Symposium of the Society for developmental Biology, vo1 .46, Self-assembling Architecture, pp.203- 227. Alan R. Liss: New York.