Download File

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Download File Columbia University Graduate School of Arts and Sciences Human Rights Studies Master of Arts Program (Ref)Using Human Rights: Indigenous Activism and the Politics of Refusal in Settler Colonial Contexts Tim Wyman-McCarthy Thesis adviser: Professor Audra Simpson Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts January 2016 © 2016 Tim Wyman-McCarthy All rights reserved Abstract This thesis is a critical history of ideas—or a history of repressed and repressive ideas (and histories)—that analyses how liberal internationalism, in the form of human rights, presses upon, covers over, brushes against, interacts with, or is used instrumentally by Indigenous activism and political life. By situating these interactions between human rights and Indigenous political life in the context of settler colonialism, it aims to bring out the complexity of a politics of (ref)usal that permeates this relationship, in this context. First, the thesis reads critiques of human rights against emerging literature in settler colonial studies, showing how the irreducible element of an eliminatory drive for land, which characterizes settler colonialism, is not accounted for in the existing critical literature on human rights. Second, it presents a critical history of the normative evolution of the right to self-determination in both law and discourse as these relate to Indigenous peoples, showing how the norm is constructed both to make illegible other forms of Indigenous political life and to reify anthropological tropes about Indigenous culture. Third, it tests proposals for ‘saving’ human rights from its colonial-hegemonic past—by repoliticizing it—against writing on settler decolonization, to ask about the role of human rights in/as decolonial politics. The thesis, finally, considers how the normative and historical terrain it has mapped might help us think through the politics of human rights and Indigenous activism (namely, the Idle No More movement) in Canada in light of Justin Trudeau’s election as Prime Minister in October, 2015. Ultimately, the aim of this work is to interrogate the normative political optics of the settler state—what it can and cannot make legible—as it makes use of liberal internationalist discourse to make illegible (to eliminate from view) other, Indigenous, modes of political life which stubbornly (politically) refuse this imposition. i Table of Contents i Contents ii Acknowledgements 1 - 47 CHAPTER ONE: Indigenous Rights, Human Rights, and Settler Colonialism 48 - 89 CHAPTER TWO: The Normative Politics of Self-Determination 90 - 157 CHAPTER THREE: Settler Decolonization and Human Rights 158 - 170 POST-SCRIPT: Idle No More in the Era of Trudeau 2.0 171 Bibliography ii Acknowledgements Many places and people made the writing of this thesis possible. First, I would like to acknowledge two peoples: the Lenape, on whose land now stands Columbia University, where this thesis was largely written; and the Mississauga, on whose land I was raised and still call home, in Ontario, Canada. Hungarian Pastry Shop on Amsterdam Avenue provided an internet- free space where actual thinking could happen; and International House afforded a comfortable and congenial home to return to at the end of the day. Learning from ones friends is perhaps the single most fulfilling part of graduate work, blurring the boundary between work and fun. My first debt is to Alexis Comninos, to whom the ideas in this thesis were originally articulated during long conversations over countless (Milanos) lunches, home-cooked dinners, and study breaks. I am truly grateful for his patience, his insight, his interest in these ideas, and most of all for his friendship. Mille mercis! For their illuminating conversations, and most of all for their friendship and support, I would like to thank all my HRSMA peers, and in particular Trip Carpenter, Caroline Dönmez, Kathryn Herrera, Aisha Onsando, Meaghan Shevell, and the whole Lehman Study Group. At International House, Stephanie Martinez, Stephanie Sodero, and Robert Robinson have kept me sane-ish (for which I am grateful). They are also friends with whom laughter is the default setting—I cannot express how much this means to me. Thanks are also due to the students in Professor Simpson’s “Settler Colonialism in North America” seminar, who helped me remember how exciting and unsettling learning can be. Alison Carey and Renata Colwell, in addition to being dear friends, provided comments on drafts of this work. I thank them profusely for the gift of their time and talents. Kristina Eberbach and Gergana Halpern at ISHR made this Masters program what it is. I am grateful to them for their care and dedication. A number of teachers, past and present, across Canada (Queen’s University), the UK (Oxford University), and the United States (Columbia University), have formed so much of who I am and how I think that it is necessary and important to me that they are acknowledged: Professors Christopher Bongie, Amitava Chowdhury, Saidyia Hartman, Dame Hermione Lee, Edward Lobb, Harold Mah, Mahmood Mamdani, Ankhi Mukherjee, David Scott, Michael Snediker, Elsa Stamatopoulou, and Neferti Tadiar. Whether through teaching a challenging course, displaying a unique style of thought, offering wisdom on life in general, or helping me navigate academia in particular, these individuals have influenced and inspired me—I thank you. Of course, Asha Varadharajan remains my most important teacher, as well as cherished friend, interlocutor, collaborator, and partner in crime! Your belief in me means more than I can say. Professor Audra Simpson, who supervised this thesis, provides an example towards which I will always aspire and inevitably fall short: intellectually generous and rigorous, committed and compassionate, she has taught me invaluable lessons about what academic life can and should do. Her teaching, scholarship, and mentorship have made this work possible, and enjoyable. Above all, I would like to thank my family: my brothers Matt and Nate, my parents Kathryn Wyman and Tom McCarthy, and my grandmother, Dorothy Wyman. I thank you all, so much, and with love. 1 CHAPTER ONE Indigenous Rights, Human Rights, and Settler Colonialism I. Indigenous Rights at the UN The stories that movements, institutions, and peoples tell about themselves matter—they matter because narrating where they came from and where they are in part determines where they might go and what they might become. Such stories also, as Gordon Christie says, “police meaning”: “the stories we tell define who we are and how we think of the world—while they also work to control what can be thought (and so what we can see as ‘possible’ action)” (2011: 338). Stories, the imaginative parameters of thought, and action, are inextricable entwined. The story that the global Indigenous rights movement tells of itself is both specific and general. It usually starts with Cayuga chief Deskaheh (1872-1925), travelling to Switzerland on his Haudenosaunee Confederacy passport in September 1923, walking into the halls of the League of Nations in Geneva, demanding an audience, and creating a space of/for Indigenous activism and engagement in a globalizing world of nation-states.1 Deskaheh’s powerful originary claim to attention, so the story goes, would then develop over the next century, culminating in institutional recognition through the United Nations (UN) Working Group on Indigenous Populations (WGIP) in 1982 and the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues (PFII) in 2000. Between Deskaheh’s intervention and the PFII, the narrative is punctuated by a number of key moments and achievements: International Labour Organization (ILO) Convention 107 (1957) and its revision as ILO Convention 169 on Indigenous and Tribal Peoples (1989); the UN- 1 Two years after Deskaheh’s trip, in 1925, Maori T.W. Ratana made a similar journey to the League to bring international attention to New Zealand’s violation of treaty agreements. A number of scholars, including Aileen Moreton-Robinson (2015), see the actions of these two men, combined, as forming the “political roots” (174) of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. 2 The year 1977 saw the first national or regional meetings of Indigenous leaders in Panama, Ecuador, and Sweden, 2 sponsored International Nongovernmental Organization Conference on Discrimination against Indigenous Populations in the Americas in 1977; the North American regional Indigenous rights movement that developed in the 1970s, having gained advocacy experience from civil rights movements;2 Martinez Cobo’s monumental report on discrimination against Indigenous people presented to the UN between 1981-1983; the UN Conference on the Environment and Development in Rio in 1992; and the naming of 1995-2004 as the first UN Indigenous Decade (Lawlor 172-173).3 This is the specific picture the international Indigenous rights movement paints, its characters, actions, and settings. The broader narrative arc, however, like many origin stories, is moral: it makes an argument for the value and validity of the movement’s existence. In this story, the Indigenous rights movement is one of struggle for a seat at the human rights table—and, above all, the carving out of meaningful space. The battle, the tale goes, was fought by Indigenous peoples in an arena where the deck was stacked against them: states did not want indigenous peoples to succeed; states were threatened by them; states were products, in some cases, of Indigenous dispossession. Thus, the
Recommended publications
  • A BRIEF HISTORY of OUR RIGHT to SELF-GOVERNANCE Pre-Contact to Present
    A BRIEF HISTORY of OUR RIGHT to SELF-GOVERNANCE Pre-Contact to Present A BRIEF HISTORY of OUR RIGHT to SELF-GOVERNANCE Pre-Contact to Present The first nine chapters for this publication were prepared for the National Centre for First Nations Governance (NCFNG) by Professor Kent McNeil in March, 2007. Kent McNeil has taught at Osgoode Hall Law School in Toronto since 1987. He specializes in Indigenous rights, especially in Canada, Australia, and the United States. The Duty to Consult Aboriginal People was prepared by NCFNG research staff. NCFNG supports First Nations as they seek to implement effective, independent governance. The Centre delivers nation rebuilding services to First Nation communities across Canada. NCFNG is an independent service and research organization that is governed and staffed by experienced First Nation professionals. 4 Introduction For thousands of years, the aboriginal people of what is now Canada organized themselves as sovereign nations, with what was essentially gov - ernmental jurisdiction over their lands, including property rights.Those rights — of governance and property — were trampled in the stampede of European settlement, colonization and commercial interests. But they were never lost or extinguished. Read this brief historic account of the rights inherited by citizens of today’s First Nations, Learn about the erosion of property and governance rights through the dark periods of colonization and marginalization, and ultimately, their affirmation in Canada’s constitution and recognition in Canadian
    [Show full text]
  • Will the Federal Government Get It Right This Time? Will the Federal Government Get It Right This Time?
    INDIGENOUS EDUCATION: WILL THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT GET IT RIGHT THIS TIME? WILL THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT GET IT RIGHT THIS TIME? MORE OPTIMISTIC ABOUT THE POTENTIAL FOR POSITIVE CHANGE SIGNIFICANT NEW INVESTMENTS IN K-12 AND PSE BUDGETS OVER LAST TWO FISCAL CYCLES COMMITMENT TO ENGAGEMENT AND PARTNERSHIP BUT, … STILL A LONG WAY TO GO…AND A LEGACY OF GETTING IT WRONG THREE THINGS: SOME HISTORY ON FEDERAL INDIGENOUS EDUCATION POLICY SHARING SOME LESSONS FROM THE B.C. EXPERIENCE THOUGHTS ON THE “WHERE TO FROM HERE?” SOME PRELIMINARY THOUGHTS THE TRANSFORMATIVE POWER OF EDUCATION “CLOSING GAPS” IN EDUCATIONAL OUTCOMES FOR FIRST NATIONS, METIS AMD INUIT STUDENTS REMAINS A PRESSING AND SUBSTANTIAL ISSUE OF NATIONAL IMPORTANCE PROGRESS ACROSS THE COUNTRY HAS BEEN UNEVEN DANGER OF THE “RACE TO THE MIDDLE” AND “ONE SIZE FITS ALL” SOLUTIONS COMPLEX JURISDICTIONAL ENVIRONMENT PROVINCES HAVE “EXCLUSIVE JURISDICTION” OVER EDUCATION - SEC. 93 OF THE CONSTITUTION ACT SCHOOL BOARDS WITH AUTHORITY UNDER PROVINCIAL ENABLING LEGISLATION FEDERAL GOVERNMENT WITH JURISDICTION OVER “INDIANS AND LANDS RESERVED FOR THE INDIANS” - SEC. 91 (27) OF THE CONSTITUTION ACT - EDUCATION OBLIGATIONS IN SOME OF THE NUMBERED TREATIES FIRST NATIONS OPERATING BAND SCHOOLS UNDER AUTHORITY OF THE INDIAN ACT OR PURSUANT TO NEGOTIATED AGREEMENTS LOOKING BACK THE LEGACY OF THE RESIDENTIAL SCHOOLS EXPERIENCE DIAND’S 1969 “WHITE PAPER” ON EDUCATION THE NATIVE INDIAN BROTHERHOOD’S 1972 PAPER ON “INDIAN CONTROL OVER INDIAN EDUCATION” - LATER REVISED AS THE A.F.N.’S “FIRST NATIONS CONTROL OVER FIRST NATIONS EDUCATION” YEARS OF “CONTROL” OVER AN UNDERFUNDED SYSTEM CALLS FOR CHANGE: And Some Lost Opportunities 1988 - IN B.C.
    [Show full text]
  • The Wealth of First Nations
    The Wealth of First Nations Tom Flanagan Fraser Institute 2019 Copyright ©2019 by the Fraser Institute. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief passages quoted in critical articles and reviews. The author of this book has worked independently and opinions expressed by him are, there- fore, his own and and do not necessarily reflect those of the Institute, its Board of Directors, its donors and supporters, or its staff. This publication in no way implies that the Fraser Institute, its directors, or staff are in favour of, or oppose the passage of, any bill; or that they support or oppose any particular political party or candidate. Printed and bound in Canada National Library of Canada Cataloguing in Publication Data The Wealth of First Nations / by Tom Flanagan Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 978-0-88975-533-8. Fraser Institute ◆ fraserinstitute.org Contents Preface / v introduction —Making and Taking / 3 Part ONE—making chapter one —The Community Well-Being Index / 9 chapter two —Governance / 19 chapter three —Property / 29 chapter four —Economics / 37 chapter five —Wrapping It Up / 45 chapter six —A Case Study—The Fort McKay First Nation / 57 Part two—taking chapter seven —Government Spending / 75 chapter eight —Specific Claims—Money / 93 chapter nine —Treaty Land Entitlement / 107 chapter ten —The Duty to Consult / 117 chapter eleven —Resource Revenue Sharing / 131 conclusion —Transfers and Off Ramps / 139 References / 143 about the author / 161 acknowledgments / 162 Publishing information / 163 Purpose, funding, & independence / 164 About the Fraser Institute / 165 Peer review / 166 Editorial Advisory Board / 167 fraserinstitute.org ◆ Fraser Institute Preface The Liberal government of Justin Trudeau elected in 2015 is attempting massive policy innovations in Indigenous affairs.
    [Show full text]
  • Indigenous Perspectives Collection Bora Laskin Law Library
    fintFenvir Indigenous Perspectives Collection Bora Laskin Law Library 2009-2019 B O R A L A S K I N L A W L IBRARY , U NIVERSITY OF T O R O N T O F A C U L T Y O F L A W 21 things you may not know about the Indian Act / Bob Joseph KE7709.2 .J67 2018. Course Reserves More Information Aboriginal law / Thomas Isaac. KE7709 .I823 2016 More Information The... annotated Indian Act and aboriginal constitutional provisions. KE7704.5 .A66 Most Recent in Course Reserves More Information Aboriginal autonomy and development in northern Quebec and Labrador / Colin H. Scott, [editor]. E78 .C2 A24 2001 More Information Aboriginal business : alliances in a remote Australian town / Kimberly Christen. GN667 .N6 C47 2009 More Information Aboriginal Canada revisited / Kerstin Knopf, editor. E78 .C2 A2422 2008 More Information Aboriginal child welfare, self-government and the rights of indigenous children : protecting the vulnerable under international law / by Sonia Harris-Short. K3248 .C55 H37 2012 More Information Aboriginal conditions : research as a foundation for public policy / edited by Jerry P. White, Paul S. Maxim, and Dan Beavon. E78 .C2 A2425 2003 More Information Aboriginal customary law : a source of common law title to land / Ulla Secher. KU659 .S43 2014 More Information Aboriginal education : current crisis and future alternatives / edited by Jerry P. White ... [et al.]. E96.2 .A24 2009 More Information Aboriginal education : fulfilling the promise / edited by Marlene Brant Castellano, Lynne Davis, and Louise Lahache. E96.2 .A25 2000 More Information Aboriginal health : a constitutional rights analysis / Yvonne Boyer.
    [Show full text]
  • Policing Aboriginal Protests and Confrontations: Some Policy Recommendations Edward J
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Directory of Open Access Journals The International Indigenous Policy Journal Volume 3 | Issue 2 Article 1 8-9-2012 Policing Aboriginal Protests and Confrontations: Some Policy Recommendations Edward J. Hedican University of Guelph, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://ir.lib.uwo.ca/iipj Part of the Social Policy Commons Recommended Citation Hedican, E. J. (2012). Policing Aboriginal Protests and Confrontations: Some Policy Recommendations. The International Indigenous Policy Journal, 3(2) . Retrieved from: http://ir.lib.uwo.ca/iipj/vol3/iss2/1 This Policy is brought to you for free and open access by Scholarship@Western. It has been accepted for inclusion in The nI ternational Indigenous Policy Journal by an authorized administrator of Scholarship@Western. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Policing Aboriginal Protests and Confrontations: Some Policy Recommendations Abstract This paper discusses the role of police forces in Aboriginal protests and confrontations. It takes as a case study the Report of the Ipperwash Inquiry, which was released on May 31, 2007. In 1995 Dudley George, a member of the Stoney Point First Nation, was shot by an Ontario Provincial Police officer during a protest at Ipperwash Provincial Park. Five recommendations are proposed in this paper to reduce the inherent tensions in such protests, focusing on methods of mediation and conflict resolution. In particular, it is proposed that during such protests a more extensive use be made of Aboriginal persons with training and skills in mediation and negotiations in order to improve communication between police and First Nations protesters.
    [Show full text]
  • Self-Governance in Arctic Societies: Dynamics and Trends
    International Ph.D. School for Studies of Arctic Societies (IPSSAS) Self-Governance in Arctic Societies: Dynamics and Trends Proceedings of the Fourth IPSSAS Seminar Kuujjuaq, Nunavik, Canada May 22 to June 2, 2006 François Trudel (Ed.) CIÉRA (Centre interuniversitaire d’études et de recherche autochtones) Faculté des sciences sociales Université Laval, Québec, Canada The IPSSAS Steering Committee wishes to thank the following institutions and departments for various contributions to the Fourth IPSSAS Seminar in Kuujjuaq, Nunavik, Canada, in 2006: - Indian and Northern Affairs Canada / Inuit Relations Secretariat - Foreign Affairs and International Trade Canada - Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada - CIÉRA (Centre interuniversitaire d’études et de recherches autochtones), Faculté des sciences sociales, Université Laval, Québec, Canada - CCI (Canadian Circumpolar Institute) and H.M. Tory Chair (Department of Anthropology), University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada - Greenland’s Home Rule, Department of Culture, Education, Research and Ecclesiastical Affairs - Ilisimatusarfik / University of Greenland - The Commission for Scientific Research in Greenland (KVUG) - Makivik Corporation - National Science Foundation of the United States of America - Alaska Native Languages Centre, University of Alaska Fairbanks - Department of Cross Cultural and Regional Studies, University of Copenhagen, Denmark - Institut National des Langues et Civilisations Orientales (INALCO), Paris, France Cover photo: Inukshuit in the outskirts of Kuujjuaq, Nunavik. An inushuk (inukshuit in the plural form) is an arrangement of stones or cairn resembling the shape of a human. The Inuit have used inukshuit for generations for many of their activities, such as a navigational aid, a lure or a marker. Inukshuit also embody spiritual and ancestral connections and have a great symbolic meaning.
    [Show full text]
  • Aboriginal Well-Being: Canada's Continuing Challenge"
    Western University Scholarship@Western Aboriginal Policy Research Consortium International (APRCi) 2008 Introduction: Aboriginal Well-being: Canada’s Continuing Challenge Dan Beavon Jerry White Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/aprci Part of the Social Policy Commons Citation of this paper: Beavon, Dan and White, Jerry, "Introduction: Aboriginal Well-being: Canada’s Continuing Challenge" (2008). Aboriginal Policy Research Consortium International (APRCi). 9. https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/aprci/9 1 Introduction: Aboriginal Well-being: Canada’s Continuing Challenge Dan Beavon and Jerry White Introduction Canada was founded on the principles of peace, order, and good government.1 It would be fair to say that most Canadians view our society as peaceful, civil, and just. As Canadians, we are often shocked or dismayed when we see civil unrest in other countries, particularly when police or military force are used against civil populations in order to quell popular uprisings or to restore order. When we see such events unfolding in the news, we breathe a collective sigh of relief and count our blessings that we live where we do. However, it may be that our collective memories are quite short, and our knowledge of history quite limited, because police forces and the military have intervened thousands of times against many different segments of civil society in Canada. Some of these interventions have been against protestors (e.g., such as the police action during the 1997 Asia- Pacific Economic Cooperation summit meeting in Vancouver), unruly sports fans (e.g., the 1955 Rocket Richard riot in Montreal), unions (e.g., the 1919 Winnipeg general strike), and sometimes against Aboriginal peoples.
    [Show full text]
  • Resources Pertaining to First Nations, Inuit, and Metis. Fifth Edition. INSTITUTION Manitoba Dept
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 400 143 RC 020 735 AUTHOR Bagworth, Ruth, Comp. TITLE Native Peoples: Resources Pertaining to First Nations, Inuit, and Metis. Fifth Edition. INSTITUTION Manitoba Dept. of Education and Training, Winnipeg. REPORT NO ISBN-0-7711-1305-6 PUB DATE 95 NOTE 261p.; Supersedes fourth edition, ED 350 116. PUB TYPE Reference Materials Bibliographies (131) EDRS PRICE MFO1 /PC11 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS American Indian Culture; American Indian Education; American Indian History; American Indian Languages; American Indian Literature; American Indian Studies; Annotated Bibliographies; Audiovisual Aids; *Canada Natives; Elementary Secondary Education; *Eskimos; Foreign Countries; Instructional Material Evaluation; *Instructional Materials; *Library Collections; *Metis (People); *Resource Materials; Tribes IDENTIFIERS *Canada; Native Americans ABSTRACT This bibliography lists materials on Native peoples available through the library at the Manitoba Department of Education and Training (Canada). All materials are loanable except the periodicals collection, which is available for in-house use only. Materials are categorized under the headings of First Nations, Inuit, and Metis and include both print and audiovisual resources. Print materials include books, research studies, essays, theses, bibliographies, and journals; audiovisual materials include kits, pictures, jackdaws, phonodiscs, phonotapes, compact discs, videorecordings, and films. The approximately 2,000 listings include author, title, publisher, a brief description, library
    [Show full text]
  • Policing Aboriginal Protests and Confrontations: Some Policy Recommendations Edward J
    The International Indigenous Policy Journal Volume 3 | Issue 2 Article 1 August 2012 Policing Aboriginal Protests and Confrontations: Some Policy Recommendations Edward J. Hedican University of Guelph, [email protected] Recommended Citation Hedican, E. J. (2012). Policing Aboriginal Protests and Confrontations: Some Policy Recommendations. The International Indigenous Policy Journal, 3(2) . DOI: 10.18584/iipj.2012.3.2.1 This Policy is brought to you for free and open access by Scholarship@Western. It has been accepted for inclusion in The International Indigenous Policy Journal by an authorized administrator of Scholarship@Western. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Policing Aboriginal Protests and Confrontations: Some Policy Recommendations Abstract This paper discusses the role of police forces in Aboriginal protests and confrontations. It takes as a case study the Report of the Ipperwash Inquiry, which was released on May 31, 2007. In 1995 Dudley George, a member of the Stoney Point First Nation, was shot by an Ontario Provincial Police officer during a protest at Ipperwash Provincial Park. Five recommendations are proposed in this paper to reduce the inherent tensions in such protests, focusing on methods of mediation and conflict resolution. In particular, it is proposed that during such protests a more extensive use be made of Aboriginal persons with training and skills in mediation and negotiations in order to improve communication between police and First Nations protesters. It is also evident that government officials need to become more actively involved in resolving land claims, especially before they become flashpoints for violence, and to remove such disputes from the realm of criminal activity to matters of civil litigation.
    [Show full text]
  • The Absence of Democracy in Aboriginal Self
    www.ssoar.info The absence of democracy in Aboriginal self- governance policy Burg, Gina van den Veröffentlichungsversion / Published Version Zeitschriftenartikel / journal article Empfohlene Zitierung / Suggested Citation: Burg, G. v. d. (2009). The absence of democracy in Aboriginal self-governance policy. Federal Governance, 6(1), 1-31. https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:0168-ssoar-46942-5 Nutzungsbedingungen: Terms of use: Dieser Text wird unter einer Basic Digital Peer Publishing-Lizenz This document is made available under a Basic Digital Peer zur Verfügung gestellt. Nähere Auskünfte zu den DiPP-Lizenzen Publishing Licence. For more Information see: finden Sie hier: http://www.dipp.nrw.de/lizenzen/dppl/service/dppl/ http://www.dipp.nrw.de/lizenzen/dppl/service/dppl/ The Absence of Democracy in Aboriginal Self-Governance Policy Gina van den Burg, McMaster University The protracted history of Aboriginal governance policy is ripe with frustrations among First Nations peoples and Canadian governments, the most pronounced aggravation being the federal government. Substantial resistance from Aboriginals often marks each new policy the government introduces. New policies often maintain the paternalistic attitude inherent in government initiatives, which has been very difficult for Aboriginal organizations to eradicate. Although Aboriginal governance policy is currently progressing towards a quasi-cooperative form of policy-making on both sides, this particular policy area continues to encounter significant disparities between policy actors within the Canadian government and Aboriginal organizations. Differences throughout the entire policy process hinder effective policy-making from agenda-setting/problem definition to the outcome/evaluation. This research paper can help explain the reasons behind the continuous failures of such government policies and how the living conditions of Aboriginals can be improved through recognition of their right to self-determination.
    [Show full text]
  • Final Activity Report: a Forum to Explore Best Practices, Policy and Tools to Build Capacity in Aboriginal Business and Economic Development
    Final Activity Report: A Forum to Explore Best Practices, Policy and Tools to Build Capacity in Aboriginal Business and Economic Development Brian Calliou Printed at The Banff Centre Banff, Alberta, Canada April 2007 Copyright © 2007, The Banff Centre Brian Calliou Final Activity Report: A Forum to Explore Best Practices, Policy and Tools to Build Capacity in Aboriginal Business and Economic Development Printed at The Banff Centre Banff, Alberta, Canada April 2007 Copyright © 2007, The Banff Centre Final Activity Report: A Forum to Explore Best Practices, Policy and Tools to Build Capacity in Aboriginal Business and Economic Development P r e f a c e The Banff Centre has been providing inspirational and relevant programs for the Aboriginal community for thirty-four years. Aboriginal Leadership and Management programming has embarked on a new endeavor to broaden its focus to include applied research. This applied research supports program content, that is, it focuses on self-determined community development, good governance, strong leadership and management, as well as, economic and business development. Applied research will assist Aboriginal leaders in identifying models, systems, processes, and best practices for addressing the challenges, threats and opportunities facing Aboriginal communities. Our applied research works towards action learning and works directly with communities to help them and do what they need to do. In other words, applied research is community driven where they identify, work on their problems, document the process
    [Show full text]
  • An Indigenous Understanding of Allyship in North America ______
    Journal of World Philosophies Articles/30 Empowering Relations: An Indigenous Understanding of Allyship in North America _______________________________________ ANDREA SULLIVAN-CLARKE University of Windsor, Canada ([email protected]) Colonization is still present in the lives of Indigenous people in North America, and the threats it underwrites—the possibility of losing federal recognition, the failure to investigate the cases of murdered and missing Indigenous women and girls, and the constant challenges to the Indian Child Welfare Act (to name a few)—comprise the day-to-day demands in Indian Country. While allies in the fight against modern-day colonialism would be welcome, the previous failings and insincerities of putative allies and the existence of an ally industrial complex make it difficult to be a contemporary ally to Indigenous people. In this paper, I address the difficulties associated with allyship and discuss why being an active bystander is not sufficient for the needs of Indigenous people in North America. Taking the lessons learned from the actions of Veterans Stand for Standing Rock and Black Lives Matter during #NODAPL, I present some features of a decolonial ally. A decolonial ally is willing to stand in a relationship with Indigenous people, will seek out this relation while recognizing their privilege and affirming the sovereignty of those they seek to serve, and above all, will learn about the people independently, without imposing a burden on marginalized communities. Given that Indigenous people worldwide face similar colonial threats, I conclude by offering some points for future research regarding global Indigenous allyship. Key words: Indigenous; allyship; relations; #BLM; colonialism; #NODAPL Many non-Indigenous people in North America naively assume that living in a post-conquest society entails living in a post-colonial one as well.
    [Show full text]