90+ REVIEWS THE of BROADBENT SELECTIONS

Radio Lazarus 2015 A.A. BADENHORST 95 pts, Tim Atkin’s Special Report Magnetic North Mountain Makstok 2014 Family Red 2012 95 pts, Tim Atkin’s South Africa Special Report | Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition | 93 pts, 92 pts, Spectator Tim Atkin’s Special Report | 92 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 92 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous Magnetic North Mountain Makstok 2015 96 pts, Tim Atkin’s South Africa Special Report Family Red 2013 94pts Wine Enthusiast, Top 100 Cellar Selection | Silver Medal, Arrow Heart Semillon 2014 Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 94 pts, Tim Atkin’s South Africa Special Report Family White 2012 La Colline Semillon 2015 92 pts, Tim Atkin’s South Africa 2014 Special Report | 90 pts, 95 pts, Tim Atkin’s South Africa Special Report Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Family White 2013 BARBOURSVILLE 94 pts, Tim Atkin’s South Africa Special Report | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Octagon Bordeaux Blend 2010 91 pts, Wine Spectator | Gold Medal, San Francisco IWC Family White 2014 93 pts, Wine Spectator Reserve 2011 Gold Medal, San Francisco IWC Secateurs, 2014 91 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous Cabernet Franc 2010 90 pts, Magazine | Named Virgina’s top wines Secateurs, Chenin Blanc 2015 Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Secateurs, Rose 2015 Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition BEAUMONT WINES Secateurs, Red Blend 2012 Hope Marguerite Chenin Blanc 2012 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 90 pts, Antonio Galloni’s 93 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 2014 Vinous | 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast | Gold Medal, Dallas Morning Hope Marguerite Chenin Blanc 2013 News & TEXSOM competition 90 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous Secateurs, Red Blend 2014 Hope Marguerite Chenin Blanc 2014 90 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 94 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | Gold Medal, Dallas Chateau Ramnasgras 2012 Morning News & TEXSOM competition 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Chenin Blanc 2014 Raaigras 2012 Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 92 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 93 pts, Pinotage 2013 Antonio Galloni’s Vinous 92 pts, Decanter Raaigras Grenache 2015 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report BEESLAAR

ALHEIT Beeslaar Pinotage 2013 96 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | Silver Medal, Dallas Cartology 2013 Morning News & TEXSOM competition 93 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 91 pts, Wine Spectator | Beeslaar Pinotage 2014 91 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous 96 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | Cartology 2014 92 pts, Wine Spectator 95 pts, Tim Atkin’s South Africa Special Report | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Radio Lazarus 2014 97 pts, Tim Atkin’s South Africa Special Report | 91 pts, Wine Spectator

www.broadbent.com // @BroadbentSelections // @BroadbentWines // @broadbentselections 90+ REVIEWS THE WINES of BROADBENT SELECTIONS

Sauvignon Blanc 2014 BROADBENT PORTS & MADEIRAS 93 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 90 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous | Bronze, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM Port 2011 Stonehaven 2013 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 93 pts, ForTheLoveofPort.com Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast Reserve Sauvignon Blanc 2012 Vintage Port 2007 94pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 93pts, Robert 90 pts, Wine Spectator | 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Parker’s Wine Advocate | 92pts, Wine Spectator 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 17.5/20 pts, Jancis Robinson Reserve Sauvignon Blanc 2013 Vintage Port 2003 92pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 94pts, Tim Atkin South 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 90 pts, Wine Spectator Africa Special Report Madeira Terrantez Old Reserve Reserve Sauvignon Blanc 2015 90 pts, Wine Spectator | 95 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Madeira 10 year Malmsey 90 pts, Wine Advocate | 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 17/20 pts, Jancis Robinson, Decanter World Wine Awards 2007 | CASA FERREIRINHA Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Planalto 2014 Madeira Colheita 1996 Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 93 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Quinta da Leda 2012 94pts, CELLAR SELECTION, Wine Enthusiast, 92 pts, Robert Madeira 10 Years Old, Sercial Dry Parker’s Wine Advocate Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Quinta da Leda 2011 Madeira 10 Years Old, Boal Medium Sweet 95 pts, Wine Advocate, 91 pts, Wine Spectator Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Quinta da Leda 2013 Madeira Rainwater 93pts, CELLAR SELECTION, Wine Enthusiast | Bronze Medal, 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate (Only Madeira below $20 Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition to score 90 pts) Esteva Douro Red 2012 Madeira 3 Years Old Fine Rich Reserve Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Gold Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Reserva Especial 2007 Madeira 5 Years Old Fine Rich Reserve 97pts, CELLAR SELECTION, Wine Enthusiast Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Vinha Grande 2013 Madeira 10 Years Old, Verdelho Medium Dry 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast | Gold Medal, Dallas Morning News & Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition TEXSOM competition Auction Reserve Porto DOC Papa Figos 2014 Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 90 pts, Wine Spectator | Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition CAPE POINT Callabriga 2013 Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Isliedh Sauvignon Blanc 2013 92pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition CIRILLIO

Isliedh Sauvignon Blanc 2014 The Vincent 2014 95pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 90 pts, Vinous | Gold Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM Isliedh Sauvignon Blanc 2015 competition 95pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 1850 Grenache 2010 Sauvignon Blanc 2013 93 pts, Vinous | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM 93 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 90 pts, Robert competition | 90 pts, Wine & Spirits Parker’s Wine Advocate | 90 pts, Beverage Dynamics | Silver Medal, 2014 Sunset International Wine Competition | Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition

www.broadbent.com // @BroadbentSelections // @BroadbentWines // @broadbentselections 90+ REVIEWS THE WINES of BROADBENT SELECTIONS

Las Cruces 2013 CHATEAU MUSAR 94 pts, Wine Advocate Alto de Piedras 2013 Rouge 2008 93 pts, Wine Advocate | 91 pts, James Suckling Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Rouge 2007 92 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate DE WETSHOF

Rouge 2004 Bateleur 2012 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 90 pts, Wine Spectator 93 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 91+ pts, Antonio Rouge 2003 Galloni’s Vinous 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Bon Vallon Chardonnay 2013 Rouge 2002 Double Gold, 2013 Veritas Wine Awards | 90 pts, Wine Spectator | 90 pts, Wine & Spirits 91 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Rouge 2001 Bon Vallon Chardonnay 2014 93 pts, Wine & Spirits | 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate 91 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Report | 90 pts, Vinous | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Rouge 2000 92 pts, Wine & Spirits Lesca Chardonnay 2013 92 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 90 pts, Wine Spectator Rouge 1998 | 90 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Lesca Chardonnay 2014 Rouge 1981 Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 93 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Limestone Hill Chardonnay 2014 Rouge 1969 90 pts, Robert Parkers Wine Advocate 92 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Limestone Hill Chardonnay 2015 White 1989 91 pts, Robert Parkers Wine Advocate | Bronze Medal, Dallas 93 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Morning News & TEXSOM competition Hochar Pere et Fils 2011 Limestone Hill Chardonnay 2016 Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 91 pts, Wine Spectator L’Arack NV Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition DELAIRE GRAFF

DE MARTINO Chardonnay 2013 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 91 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Legado Sauvignon Blanc 2015 Vinous 90 pts, Wine Advocte Chardonnay 2014 Legado Malbec 2014 93 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 2015 90 pts, Wine Advocte Sauvignon Blanc 2014 Legado Chardonnay 2014 92 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 2015 | 90 pts, 91 pts, Wine Advocte | 91 pts James Suckling | 90 pts, Decanter Antonio Galloni’s Vinous Viejas Tinajas Cinsault 2014 Botmaskop 2012 91 pts, Wine Advocte 5 Stars, Platter’s Guide | 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Viejas Tinajas Muscat 2013 Report 94 pts, Decanter Botmaskop 2013 Gallardia Cinsault Rose 2014 90 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning 90 pts, Wine Advocate News & TEXSOM competition | 90 pts, Wine Spectator Gallardia Cinsault 2014 Reserve 2011 91 pts, James Suckling 94 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Limavida 2011 Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve 2012 93 pts, Wine Advocate 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report

www.broadbent.com // @BroadbentSelections // @BroadbentWines // @broadbentselections 90+ REVIEWS THE WINES of BROADBENT SELECTIONS

Erdener Prälat Auslese GK 2012 DELAIRE GRAFF (CONT.) 96 pts, Mosel Fine Wines Erdener Prälat Riesling Auslese 2014 Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve 2013 94 pts, Mosel Fine Wines Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition | 91 pts, Wine Spectator Erdener Prälat Riesling Auslese GK 2014 96 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 92 pts, Mosel Fine Wines Reserve White 2013 94 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Erdener Prälat Riesling Beerenauslese Lange GK 2012 96 pts, Mosel Fine Wines | 95 pts, Wine Spectator Chenin Blanc 2013 92pts, Wine & Spirits | 90 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous Erdener Prälat Riesling Auslese 2012 93 pts, Mosel Fine Wines Laurence Gra Reserve 2009 5 Stars, Platter’s Guide Erdener Herzlay Riesling Spatlese GK 2013 Gold Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Laurence Gra Reserve 2011 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Erdener Herzlay Riesling Spatlese GK 2014 93 pts, Robert Parkers’s Wine Advocate Laurence Gra Reserve 2013 97 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Erdener Herrenberg Riesling Eiswein 2012 95 pts, Mosel Fine Wines DR. HERMANN ELDERTON Dr. H Riesling 2014 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast Ashmead Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 95 pts, Wine Advocate Dr. Hermann ‘From the Slate’ O Dry Riesling 2012 Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Ashmead Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 92 pts, Wine Spectator Ürziger Würzgarten Riesling Kabinett 2014 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 90 pts, Robert Parkers Wine Advocate Ashmead Cabernet Sauvignon 2014 95 pts, James Halliday Ürziger Würzgarten Riesling Spätlese 2012 93 pts, Mosel Fine Wines | 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast Command 2009 94 pts Wine Spectator | 94+ Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Ürziger Würzgarten Riesling Auslese GK 2012 92 pts, Mosel Fine Wines Command Shiraz 2010 94 pts, Wine Advocate | 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 93 pts, Wine Ürziger Würzgarten Riesling Auslese 2012 Enthusiast | 94 pts, Vinous | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & 91 pts, Mosel Fine Wines TEXSOM competition | 91 pts, Years Best Shiraz, Wines & Spirits Erdener Treppchen Riesling Spätlese 2012 Command Shiraz 2012 93 pts, Wine Enthusiast, Editors’ Choice | 93 pts, Mosel Fine Wines 97+ pts, Wine Advocate | 93 pts, Wine Spectator Erdener Treppchen Riesling Spätlese GK Herzlay 2012 Command Shiraz 2013 93 pts, Mosel Fine Wines | 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast 97 pts, James Halliday | 93 pts, Wine Spectator Erdener Treppchen Spätlese Riesling 2012 Estate Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 93 pts, Mosel Fine Wines | 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 91 pts Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 90 pts, Vinous | Silver 90 pts, Wine Spectator Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Erdener Treppchen Riesling Kabinett 2012 Estate Cabernet Sauvignon 2014 92 pts, Mosel Fine Wines 94 pts, James Halliday Erdener Treppchen Riesling Kabinett 2014 Estate Shiraz 2012 93 pts, Mosel Fine Wines 92 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 90 pts, Vinous | 92 pts, Erdener Treppchen Riesling Auslese GK 2012 Best Buy & Years Best Shiraz, Wine & Spirits 94 pts, Mosel Fine Wines | 93 pts, Wine Spectator Estate Shiraz 2013 Erdener Treppchen Trockenbeerneauslese 2014 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate 93 pts, Mosel Fine Wines Estate Shiraz 2014 Erdener Pralat Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese GK 2014 94 pts, James Halliday 96 pts, Mosel Fine Wines Shiraz/Cabernet 2013 90 pts, Vinous

www.broadbent.com // @BroadbentSelections // @BroadbentWines // @broadbentselections 90+ REVIEWS THE WINES of BROADBENT SELECTIONS

ELDERTON (CONT.) GUSBOURNE

Shiraz/Cabernet 2014 Brut Reserve 2011 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate 93 pts, Wine Enthusiast GTS Shiraz 2010 Blanc de Blancs 2011 93 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 93 pts, Vinous | 93 pts, Wine Enthusiast 92 pts, Wine Spectator GTS Shiraz 2014 98 pts, James Halliday HUBER CSM Ode to Lorraine 2009 Grüner Veltliner Alte Setzen 2013 93 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 93 pts, Vinous | 92 pts, 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Wine Spectator Grüner Veltliner Alte Setzen 2014 CSM Ode to Lorraine 2012 93 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 90 pts, Vinous 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 92 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Grüner Veltliner Berg 2013 CSM Ode to Lorraine 2013 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 90 pts, Vinous 93 pts, James Halliday Grüner Veltliner Berg 2014 Golden Semillon 2013 92 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast 91 pts, Vinous Grüner Veltliner Obere Steigen 2012 Golden Semillon 2014 91 pts, Wine Enthusiast 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Grüner Veltliner Obere Steigen 2015 Greenock One 2013 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast 91 pts, Vinous | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM Grüner Veltliner Terrassen 2015 competition 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast Riesling Berg 2013 FERREIRA 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 90 pts, Vinous Riesling Berg 2014 LBV 2011 93 pts, Wine Enthusiast 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast Riesling Engelreich 2011 Vintage Port 2007 93 pts, #68 Top 100 Cellar Selections, Wine Enthusiast | 90 pts, Wine Spectator 16.5/20 pts, Jancis Robinson | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & ‘Duque de Braganca’ 20 Year Old Tawny Port TEXSOM competition 93 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 92pts, Wine Spectator | “The Bench- Riesling Eiswein 2013 mark,” Decanter | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast competition Riesling Engelsberg 2015 ‘Quinta do Porto’ 10 Year Old Tawny Port 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast 91 pts, Wine Spectator | “The Benchmark,” Decanter | Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Riesling Terrassen 2015 91 pts, Wine Enthusiast Vintage Port 2011 97 pts, #56, Wine Enthusiast Top 100 Wines for 2013 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 92 pts, ForTheLoveofPort.com | INMAN FAMILY WINES 90 pts, eRobertParker.com | 17.5/20 pts, Jancis Robinson | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Chardonnay Russian River Valley 2012 Dona Antonia White 91pts, Stephen Tanzers IWC Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition OGV 2010 Dona Antonia Reserve Tawny NV 93 pts, Tanzer’s IWC | 91pts, Wine Enthusiast | International 92 pts, Wine Spectator | Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & Women’s Wine Competition, Silver Medal TEXSOM competition Pinot Noir OGV 2011 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 92 pts, Stephen Tanzer’s IWC

www.broadbent.com // @BroadbentSelections // @BroadbentWines // @broadbentselections 90+ REVIEWS THE WINES of BROADBENT SELECTIONS

(CONT.) INMAN FAMILY WINES MT. DIFFICULTY Thorn Ridge Ranch Pinot Noir 2011 Bannockburn Pinot Noir 2013 91 pts Tanzer/Vinous Media 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Pinot Gris RRV 2012 Bannockburn Pinot Gris 2014 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Bannockburn Long Gully Single Pinot Noir 2013 JUSTINO’S 92 pts & Cellar Selection, Wine Enthusiast Roaring Meg Riesling 2014 5 Years Old, Fine, Rich Madeira NV 90 pts, Wine Spectator | Gold Medal Dallas Morning News & Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition TEXSOM competition Fine, Rich Madeira NV Roaring Meg Pinot Noir 2013 Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 10 Years Old, Malvasia Madeira NV Roaring Meg Pinot Noir 2014 Gold Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 90 pts, Wine Spectator Justinos Colheita Madeira 1998 Gold Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition QUINTA DO CRASTO LOUIS GUNTRUM Reserva Old Vines 2012 94 pts, Wine Spectator | #66 of 100, International Wine Report Riesling Niersteiner Trocken 2012 Reserva Old Vines 2013 91 pts, Wine Enthusiast | Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & 94 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 92 pts, Wine Spectator | Gold Medal, TEXSOM competition Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Louis Dry Riesling 2014 Douro Superior 2012 Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Riesling, Spatlese Trocken 2013 Douro Superior 2013 Gold Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 93 pts, International Wine Report | 92 pts, Wine Spectator | 91 pts. Riesling, Auslese 2012 Wine Enthusiast | 91 pts, Years Best Portuguese Red, Wine & Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Spirits | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Riesling, Kabinett 2011 Douro Superior White 2014 Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 90 pts. Wine Enthusiast | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition | 90 pts, Wine Spectator | 90 pts, Nierstein Hipping Grosses Gewachs 2012 International Wine Report 93 pts, Wine Enthusiast | BRONZE- Decanter World Wine Awards Douro Superior 2013 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 91 pts, International Wine Report | MOMENTO 90 pts Wine Spectator Douro Red 2013 Grenache 2015 91 pts, Wine Spectator | Silver Medal, Dallas Morning News & 94 pts, Decanter TEXSOM competition Douro Red 2014 MONTSARRA 90 pts, International Wine Report Douro White 2014 NV Bronze Medal, Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 90 pts, Wine & Spirits Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 2014 Vinha da Ponte 2012 96 pts, Wine Spectator Vinha Maria Teresa 2011 96 pts, Wine Spectator Insider HOT WINES | 96 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 94pts, Wine Enthusiast

www.broadbent.com // @BroadbentSelections // @BroadbentWines // @broadbentselections 90+ REVIEWS THE WINES of BROADBENT SELECTIONS

Columella 2013 QUINTA DO CRASTO (CONT.) 97 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 92+pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous Vinha Maria Teresa 2013 Columella 2014 94 pts, Wine Spectator | 94 pts, International Wine Report | 96 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast Skerpion 2014 Touriga Nacional 2011 96 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 95 pts, Wine Spectator | 95 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 95pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous | 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 93 pts, 93 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 90 pts, Wine & Spirits Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Touriga Nacional 2012 95 pts, Wine Spectator | 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Skerpion 2015 97 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Tinta Roriz 2011 Skurfberg 2014 95 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 91pts, Wine Enthusiast 96 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 94pts, Tinta Roriz 2012 Antonio Galloni’s Vinous | 93 pts, Wine Spectator 93 pts, Wine Spectator Skurfberg 2015 Tinta Roriz 2013 96 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 94 pts, CELLAR SELECTION, Wine Enthusiast | 93 pts, Wine Soldaat 2014 Spectator | 93 pts, International Wine Report 94 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 93 pts, Wine Spec- Vintage Port 2011 tator | 92pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous 95 pts, Wine Spectator | 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast Treinspoor 2014 91 pts, ForTheLoveofPort.com 94 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 91+pts, Vintage Port 2003 Antonio Galloni’s Vinous | 91 pts, Wine Spectator 90 pts, Wine Spectator Pofadder 2014 Vintage Port 2001 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 91+pts, 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast Antonio Galloni’s Vinous | 91 pts, Wine Spectator LBV Port 2011 Pofadder 2015 91 pts, International Wine Report | Bronze Medal Dallas Morning 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report News & TEXSOM competition Mev Kirsten 2014 96 pts & Best of 2015, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 95 pts, Tim SADIE FAMILY Atkin South Africa Special Report | 93 pts, Wine Spectator Mev Kirsten 2015 T’Voetpad 2013 97 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 96 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 95pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate T’Voetpad 2014 SAVAGE 96 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 94 pts, Wine Spectator | 93+pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous White 2012 (Maiden Vintage) 16.5/20 pts, Jancis Robinson | 92 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine T’Voetpad 2015 Advocate | 90 pts, Wine Spectator 97 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report White 2013 Kokerboom 2014 93 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 95 pts, Tim Atkin South 92 pts, Wine Spectator Africa Special Report | 91 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous Kokerboom 2015 White 2014 97 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | Palladius 2013 93 pts, Wine Spectator 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 95pts, Antonio White 2015 Galloni’s Vinous | 94, Wine Spectator 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Palladius 2014 Red 2012 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 95 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report

www.broadbent.com // @BroadbentSelections // @BroadbentWines // @broadbentselections 90+ REVIEWS THE WINES of BROADBENT SELECTIONS

Moyas Pinot Noir 2012 (CONT.) 91 pts, Wine Spectator SAVAGE Moyas Pinot Noir 2013 Red 2013 94 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Report | 92 pts, Wine Spectator 94 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 93 pts, Wine & Spirits Red 2014 TYRRELL’S 93 pts, Wine Spectator Vat 1 Hunter Valley Semillon 2014 Follow The Line Red 2014 97 pts, James Halliday Companion 2016 93 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 92 pts, Wine Spectator Vat 1 Hunter Valley Semillon 2010 95 pts, James Halliday Australian Wine Companion 2016 Follow The Line Red 2015 96 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | Vat 9 Hunter Valley Shiraz 2013 92 pts, Wine Spectator 96 pts, James Halliday Australian Wine Companion 2016 | 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast The Girl Next Door 2015 93 pts, Wine Spectator HVD Hunter Valley Semillon 2010 95 pts, James Halliday Australian Wine Companion 2016 Hunter Valley Semillon 2014 SPY VALLEY 93 pts, James Halliday Australian Wine Companion 2016

Riesling 2014 Hunter Valley Shiraz 2014 Gold Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition | 90 pts 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast Wine Spectator Lunatiq Shiraz 2013 Sauvignon Blanc 2015 90 pts, Years Best Shiraz, Wine & Spirits 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast | 90 pts, Wine Spectator Rufus Stone 2013 91 pts, Wine Enthusiast Pinot Noir 2013 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast | Silver Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition VILAFONTE Pinot Noir 2015 Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Series C 2011 Pinot Gris 2015 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 92 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special 90 pts, Wine Spectator Report, Recommended Wines | 92 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Ad- vocate | 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast Gewurztraminer 2013 Gold Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Series C 2012 94 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 94 pts, Wine Enthusiast Envoy Riesling 2009 | 94 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 2015 | 91+ pts, Gold Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Antonio Galloni’s Vinous Envoy Pinot Noir 2012 Series C 2013 90 pts, Tanzer IWC | Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEX- 95 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | Bronze Medal Dal- SOM competition las Morning News & TEXSOM competition | 91 pts, Wine Spectator Envoy Sauvignon Blanc 2013 Series M 2010 Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 91 pts, Tanzer Review | 90 pts, Wine Enthusiast STORM Series M 2011 95 pts, Tim Atkin SA 2014 Special Report | 92 pts, Wine Spectator Vrede Pinot Noir 2012 | 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 91 pts, Antonio Galloni’s 92 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 91 pts, Wine Spectator Vinous | 91 pts, Wine Enthusiast Vrede Pinot Noir 2013 Series M 2012 92 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Report | 92 pts, Wine 93 pts, Wine Spectator | 93 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Spectator | 90 pts, Wine & Spirits Report | 92 pts, Wine Enthusiast | Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition

www.broadbent.com // @BroadbentSelections // @BroadbentWines // @broadbentselections 90+ REVIEWS THE WINES of BROADBENT SELECTIONS

(CONT.) VILAFONTE Series M 2013 Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Seriously Old Dirt 2012 92 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 2012

WARWICK Estate Cabernet Franc 2010 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 90 pts, Wine Spectator | Platter’s 5 star wines 2014 Estate Cabernet Franc 2011 94 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Estate Cabernet Franc 2012 92 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 91 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous Estate Reserve 2010 91 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate Estate Reserve 2011 94 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Professor Black Sauvignon Blanc Coastal Region 2013 91 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Professor Black Sauvignon Blanc Coastal Region 2014 91 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Professor Black Sauvignon Blanc Coastal Region 2015 Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Three Cape Ladies 2011 91 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report Three Cape Ladies 2012 90 pts, Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate | 90 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report | 91 pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous | Bronze Medal Dallas Morning News & TEXSOM competition Trilogy Estate Reserve 2011 91+ pts, Antonio Galloni’s Vinous Trilogy Estate Reserve 2012 93 pts, Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report

www.broadbent.com // @BroadbentSelections // @BroadbentWines // @broadbentselections