HOUSE OF LORDS BUSINESS & MINUTES OF PROCEEDINGS

Session Commencing 13 June 2017

HOUSE OF LORDS BUSINESS

No. 1 & MINUTES OF PROCEEDINGS

Contents Minutes of Proceedings of Tuesday 13 June 2017 1 Wednesday 14 June 2017 at 2.30pm

†Presentation of Mr Speaker-Elect The House will sit until 7.30pm to enable Lords to take the Oath.

Minutes of Proceedings of Tuesday 13 June 2017

Parliament Met at 2.30pm pursuant to a proclamation dated 3 May 2017. The Lords Commissioners being seated, the Lord Privy Seal (Baroness Evans of Bowes Park) in the middle with the Lord Speaker (Lord Fowler) and Lord Newby to her right hand and Lord Hope of Craighead and Baroness Smith of Basildon on her left, the Commission for opening Parliament dated 13 June 2017 was read. The Commons, being present at the Bar, were directed to proceed to the choice of a Speaker and to present the person chosen for the Royal Approbation. Prayers were read by the Lord Bishop of Chelmsford 1 The Lord Speaker The Lord Speaker, singly, in the first place, at the Table, took and subscribed the oath and signed an undertaking to abide by the Code of Conduct. 2 Oaths and affirmations The following Lords took and subscribed the oath, or made and subscribed the solemn affirmation, and signed an undertaking to abide by the Code of Conduct: Justin Portal Archbishop of Canterbury Natalie Jessica Baroness Evans of Bowes Park Angela Evans Baroness Smith of Basildon Richard Mark Lord Newby James Arthur David Lord Hope of Craighead Items marked † are new or have been altered Peter Michael Lord Imbert [I] indicates that the member concerned has a relevant registered interest. John Francis Lord McFall of Alcluith Sarah Virginia Baroness Brinton David John Lord Blencathra John Derek Lord Taylor of Holbeach John Steven Lord Bassam of Brighton David Andrew Bishop of Birmingham Richard Sanderson Lord Keen of Elie Philip Alexander Lord Hunt of Kings Heath James Donnelly Lord Touhig Minutes of Proceedings

Margaret Beryl Baroness Jones of Whitchurch James Patrick Burgoyne Winthrop Earl of Courtown (Lord Saltersford) Jonathan Neil Lord Mendelsohn Thomas McLaughlin Lord McAvoy Thomas Henry Lord Ashton of Hyde John Eric Lord Gardiner of Kimble Christopher John Lord Lennie Maeve Christina Mary Baroness Sherlock James Richard Lord O’Shaughnessy Stanley Lord Fink Dianne Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town Joyce Anne Baroness Anelay of St Johns Betty Baroness Boothroyd John Lord Wakeham Susan Frances Maria Baroness Williams of Trafford Richard Andrew Lord Rosser Oliver Michael Robert Lord Henley (Lord Northington) Michael Walton Lord Bates Tariq Mahmood Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon John Alfred Stoddard Lord Nash Charlotte Sarah Emily Baroness Vere of Norbiton Peta Jane Baroness Buscombe David Gifford Leathes Lord Prior of Brampton Annabel MacNicoll Baroness Goldie Jane Susan Baroness Campbell of Surbiton John Anderson Lord Cunningham of Felling Alan William John Lord West of Spithead Roger Nicholas Lord Crickhowell Godfrey John Lord Cromwell David George Lord Clark of Windermere John Lord Reid of Cardowan Susan Elizabeth Baroness Garden of Frognal William Armand Thomas Tristan Lord Garel-Jones George Lord Foulkes of Cumnock Andrew Robert George Lord Robathan Jeremy Hugh Lord Beecham Mark Ian Lord Price Jeffrey William Lord Rooker

2 No. 1 Minutes of Proceedings

Raymond Edward Harry Lord Collins of Highbury Margaret Eileen Joyce Baroness Wheeler Denis Lord Tunnicliffe David Arthur Russell Lord Howell of Guildford Beverley June Baroness Hughes of Stretford Michael Wolfgang Laurence Lord Naseby Joyce Gwendolen Baroness Quin Ian Bruce Lord Lang of Monkton Terence Langley Lord Higgins Paul Yaw Lord Boateng John Lord Morris of Aberavon Donald Lord Anderson of Swansea Ivon Anthony Lord Brabazon of Tara Julia Frances Baroness Cumberlege David Lord Trefgarne Lilian Pauline Baroness Neville-Jones Angela Felicity Baroness Harris of Richmond Norman Stewart Hughson Lord Lamont of Lerwick Lynda Baroness Chalker of Wallasey Margaret Ann Baroness Jay of Paddington Alexander Andrew Mackay Lord Irvine of Lairg James Peter Hymers Lord Mackay of Clashfern John Leslie Lord Prescott Ara Warkes Lord Darzi of Denham Stephen Barry Lord Jones Colin MacKenzie Lord Low of Dalston Andrew David Lord Lansley Alfred Lord Dubs Dawn Baroness Primarolo Estelle Baroness Morris of Yardley John Douglas Slim Christopher George Walter Lord Northbourne Michael John Lord Storey William Herbert Lord Laming Navnit Lord Dholakia Malcolm Gray Lord Bruce of Bennachie Benjamin Russell Mackintosh Lord Stoneham of Droxford William Michael Hardy Lord Spicer

No. 1 3 Minutes of Proceedings

Charles Cuthbert Powell Lord Williams of Elvel Meral Baroness Hussein-Ece Roger Mynors Swinfen Lord Swinfen Keith John Charles Lord Bradley Brian Joseph Michael Lord Cotter Ronald Cyril Lord Fearn Josephine Baroness Farrington of Ribbleton John Edward Hollister Earl of Sandwich Robert Lord Walker of Gestingthorpe Merlin Earl of Erroll Robert Douglas Lord Carswell Christopher Samuel Lord Tugendhat Michael Nicholson Lord Framlingham Robert James Lord Mair Hilary Jane Baroness Armstrong of Hill Top Helene Valerie Baroness Hayman Patrick Richard Henry Lord Wright of Richmond Manzila Pola Baroness Uddin Robert Temple Lord Armstrong of Ilminster Clive Lord Brooke of Alverthorpe Peter Keith Lord Levene of Portsoken Sally Baroness Oppenheim-Barnes David Maxim Lord Triesman May Baroness Blood Jonathan Adair Lord Turner of Ecchinswell David Keith Lord Brookman Alan Gregory Clayton Bishop of St Albans David Sydney Lord Rowe-Beddoe Jean Ann Baroness Corston David Julian Lord Richards of Herstmonceux Michael Hastings Lord Jay of Ewelme Haleh Baroness Afshar Michael John Lord Hastings of Scarisbrick Ruth Lynn Baroness Deech Jean Elizabeth Baroness Coussins Paul Leslie Lord Condon Nicholas Power Richard Le Poer Earl of Clancarty (Viscount Clancarty) David Lord Goddard of Stockport

4 No. 1 Minutes of Proceedings

Michael James Lord German David Stephen Geoffrey Vivien Helen Baroness Stern Jonathan Lord Oates Diljit Singh Lord Rana William Brian Lord Jordan Zahida Parveen Baroness Manzoor Anthony Stephen Lord Grabiner David Charles Lord Evans of Watford Anthony James Lord Clarke of Hampstead Maurice George Lord Morrow Stephen David Bishop of Ely Sheila Valerie Baroness Noakes Graham Lord Kirkham Michael John Lord Dobbs Patience Jane Baroness Wheatcroft Jitesh Kishorekumar Lord Gadhia Matthew White James Alexander Lord Selkirk of Douglas Arthur Charles Valerian Duke of Wellington Ilora Gillian Baroness Finlay of Llandaff Jeffrey Maurice Lord Sterling of Plaistow Emma Samantha Baroness Pidding Mark Lord McInnes of Kilwinning Richard Andrew Lord Balfe Qurban Lord Hussain Patrick Thomas Lord Cormack William Manuel Lord Morris of Handsworth Patricia Baroness Morris of Bolton Stuart Lord Polak Philippa Claire Baroness Stroud Jill Elizabeth Baroness Pitkeathley Genista Mary Baroness McIntosh of Hudnall Judith Ann Baroness Wilcox Peter Spencer Lord Bowness Timothy John Robert Lord Kirkhope of Harrogate Angela Frances Baroness Browning Anne Caroline Ballingall Baroness McIntosh of Pickering

No. 1 5 Minutes of Proceedings

William David Lord Trimble Charles Russell Lord Sanderson of Bowden Catherine Mary Baroness Bakewell of Hardington Mandeville John Warren Lord Shipley Mary Teresa Baroness Goudie David Leonard Lord Watts Margot Ruth Aline Baroness Lister of Burtersett Kenneth Wiggins Lord Maginnis of Drumglass Dafydd Wynne Lord Wigley Dafydd Elis Lord Elis-Thomas Narendra Babubhai Lord Patel Charles William Harley Earl of Kinnoull Christine Elizabeth Bishop of Newcastle Emma Harriet Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne Eric Douglas Harvey Lord Hoyle Meghnad Jagdishchandra Lord Desai Charles Henry Lord Plumb Malcolm McEacharn Lord Selsdon Stephen Keith Lord Green of Hurstpierpoint Christopher Lord Holmes of Richmond David Noel Lord James of Blackheath Elizabeth Deirdre Baroness Doocey Michael Cecil Lord Boyce Sally Baroness Morgan of Huyton Julian Charles Roland Lord Hunt of Chesterton Caroline Elizabeth Baroness Chisholm of Owlpen Charles Mark Townshend Viscount Colville of Culross Gabrielle Louise Baroness Bertin Mary Jane Baroness Watkins of Tavistock Benjamin Lloyd Stormont Lord Mancroft Robert Henry Alexander Lord Eames Mohamed Iltaf Lord Sheikh Susan Adele Baroness Greenfield Donald Thomas Younger Lord Curry of Kirkharle Ajay Kumar Lord Kakkar Rosalind Carol Baroness Scott of Needham Market Beeban Tania Baroness Kidron John Alston Lord Maxton

6 No. 1 Minutes of Proceedings

James Robert Lord Wallace of Tankerness David Trevor Lord Shutt of Greetland John Olav Lord Kerr of Kinlochard David Alexander Cospatrick Earl of Home (Lord Douglas) David Terence Lord Puttnam Bryan Lord Davies of Oldham Matthew Hadrian Marshall Lord Carrington of Fulham Gary Andrew Lord Porter of Spalding Philip Charles Lord Harris of Peckham Judith Anne Baroness Jolly Monroe Edward Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Joyce Brenda Baroness Gould of Potternewton Leslie John Lord Griffiths of Burry Port Digby Marritt Lord Jones of Birmingham Edward Lord Rowlands Richard John Grenville Lord Risby Julian Alexander Lord Fellowes of West Stafford Adrian Bailie Nottage Lord Palmer Melvyn Lord Bragg Simon Brooke Lord Tanlaw David Brownrigg Lord Craig of Radley John Peter Michael Scawen Earl of Lytton Shreela Baroness Flather Alan Henry Roy Francis Lord Kennedy of Southwark William John Lawrence Lord Wallace of Saltaire Lynne Choona Baroness Featherstone Graham Eric Lord Stirrup Mark Shuldham Lord Marlesford Elspeth Rosamund Morton Baroness Howe of Idlicote David Clive Lord Wilson of Tillyorn John Richard Earl Attlee David Robert Lord Stevens of Ludgate Hugh John Maxwell Lord Dykes Elizabeth Jean Baroness Barker Jennifer Baroness Hilton of Eggardon Stephen Geoffrey Bishop of Chelmsford Arthur Desmond Colquhoun Earl of Arran (Lord Sudley)

No. 1 7 Minutes of Proceedings

Michael Andrew Foster Jude Marquess of Lothian (Lord Kerr of Monteviot) John Archibald Viscount James Stuart Lord Gordon of Strathblane Dennis Robert David Lord Rogan Francis Richard Lord Dannatt Mervyn Allister Lord King of Lothbury Michael John Lord Brougham and Vaux Roger Lord Skelmersdale Malcolm Ian Earl of Caithness Robert George Alexander Lord Lingfield Sayeeda Hussain Baroness Warsi Evan Mervyn Lord Davies of Abersoch Ranbir Singh Lord Suri Catherine Susan Baroness Fall Gregory Leonard George Lord Barker of Battle Christopher Francis Lord Fox William Waldorf Michelle Georgina Baroness Mone George Islay MacNeill Lord Robertson of Port Ellen Alexander Park Lord Leitch Simon Lord Haskel Kevin Joseph Maximilian Lord Shinkwin David Patrick Paul Lord Alton of Liverpool Richard Hugh Lord Cavendish of Furness Helen Margaret Baroness Newlove Nicholas James Christopher Richard Napier Lord Luce Janet Anne Baroness Royall of Blaisdon Spencer Elliot Lord Livermore Susan Jane Baroness Nye Alexander Charles Lord Carlile of Berriew Olivia Caroline Baroness Bloomfield of Hinton Waldrist Hugh Rosalind Patricia-Anne Baroness Howells of St Davids Katherine Patricia Irene Baroness Adams of Craigielea Anita Baroness Gale Margaret Josephine Baroness McDonagh Alan James Lord Beith

8 No. 1 Minutes of Proceedings

Peter Derek Lord Truscott Meta Baroness Ramsay of Cartvale Winifred Ann Baroness Taylor of Bolton Angela Theodora Baroness Billingham Robert Lord Hughes of Woodside Alastair Colin Leckie Lord Colgrain Robert James Lord Lisvane Alastair John Lyndhurst Lord Aberdare Tessa Ann Vosper Baroness Blackstone Clive Richard Lord Hollick Paul Archer Lord Tyler Dale Norman Lord Campbell-Savours William Jefferson Lord Hague of Richmond Andrew Zelig Lord Stone of Blackheath Ruth Beatrice Baroness Henig Elizabeth Grace Baroness Sugg Alison Mary Baroness Suttie Edward Peter Bertram Savile Earl of Liverpool Ernest Ronald Lord Oxburgh John Dunn Lord Laird Lawrence Lord Sawyer Robin Berry Lord Janvrin Rodney Lord Elton Neil Forbes Lord Davidson of Glen Clova Richard Oliver Lord Faulkner of Worcester Susan Elizabeth Baroness Miller of Chilthorne Domer Robin Lord Teverson Llinos Baroness Golding John Lord Birt Peter Richard Charles Lord Smith of Leigh Jennifer Elizabeth Baroness Randerson Graham Richard Bishop of Norwich Rupert Charles Lord De Mauley Stephen Ashley Lord Sherbourne of Didsbury Mair Eluned Baroness Morgan of Ely Robert Wilfred Lord Stevenson of Balmacara Kate Harriet Alexandra Baroness Rock Kishwer Baroness Falkner of Margravine

No. 1 9 Minutes of Proceedings

David Lawrence Lord Lipsey Elaine Baroness Murphy Diana Mary Baroness Warwick of Undercliffe Jean Lesley Patricia Baroness Drake Julia Elizabeth Baroness Brown of Cambridge Sharon Margaret Baroness Bowles of Berkhamsted Janet Alison Baroness Whitaker Frederick Edward Robin Lord Butler of Brockwell Joan Brownlow Baroness Hanham Paul Roger Bishop of Durham Archibald Gavin Lord Hamilton of Epsom Jonathan Clive Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames Roualeyn Robert Lord Thurlow Dorothea Glenys Baroness Thornton Alan Thomas Lord Howarth of Newport Paul Peter Lord Murphy of Torfaen Jonathan Toby Lord Harris of Haringey Karan Faridoon Lord Bilimoria Christopher Thomas James Bishop of Southwark John Geoffrey Bishop of Worcester Margaret The Countess of Mar Usha Kumari Baroness Prashar John Desmond Forbes James Philip Lord Knight of Weymouth Anthony Fitzhardinge Lord Berkeley (Lord Gueterbock) James Norwich Lord Arbuthnot of Edrom Nicholas Herbert Lord Stern of Brentford Igor Lord Judge Roger John Laugharne Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd Lawrence Antony Lord Collins of Mapesbury Terence James Lord O’Neill of Gatley Daniel William Lord Finkelstein Andrew Simon Lord Feldman of Elstree James George Robert Lord Bridges of Headley John Kevin Lord Sharkey Leopold David Lord Willoughby de Broke Joan Anna Dalziel Baroness Seccombe David James Fletcher Lord Hunt of Wirral

10 No. 1 Minutes of Proceedings

John Ambrose Lord Cope of Berkeley Janric Fraser Jonathan Michael Lord Caine Philip Lord Norton of Louth Thomas Michael Lord Jopling Howard Emerson Lord Flight James Randolph Earl of Lindsay Josephine Clare Baroness Valentine Patricia Lesley Baroness Hollis of Heigham Richard Douglas Lord Harries of Pentregarth Ellen Margaret Baroness Eaton Matthew Owen John Lord Taylor of Goss Moor Christopher John Lord Rennard Robin John Orlando Nicol Ross Lord Stephen Terence Lord Burns Stewart Martin Lord Wood of Anfield Anne Caroline Baroness Jenkin of Kennington John Roddick Russell Lord MacGregor of Pulham Market Bernard Francisco Lord Ribeiro Robert Maurice Lipson Lord Winston Paul Cline Lord Strasburger Anthony Robert Lord Greaves Shaista Ahmad Baroness Sheehan Tom Lord McNally Frank Ashcroft Lord Judd Sheila Clare Baroness Hollins Timothy Eric Lord Boswell of Aynho Rosalind Miriam Baroness Altmann Valerian Bernard Lord Freyberg Helena Ann Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws Patricia Elizabeth Baroness Rawlings Diana Margaret Baroness Maddock William Thomas Lord Rodgers of Quarry Bank Thomas Robin Valerian Lord Glentoran Carys Davina Baroness Grey-Thompson Michael Abraham Lord Levy Michael Bruce Lord Forsyth of Drumlean

No. 1 11 Minutes of Proceedings

Clive Stafford Lord Soley Robert Antony Lord Hayward Thomas Lord Pendry Alec Nigel Lord Broers Francis Anthony Aylmer Lord Maude of Horsham Simone Jari Baroness Finn Peter Lord Temple-Morris John Farquharson Lord Kirkhill Sarah Ann Baroness Ludford Diana Mary Baroness Harding of Winscombe Robert Andrew Lord Stunell Roger John Lord Liddle George Philip Lord Willis of Knaresborough Howard Darryl Lord Leigh of Hurley Charles David Lord Powell of Bayswater Maurice Mark Lord Glasman Alan Robert Lord Haworth Alicia Pamela Baroness Kennedy of Cradley Robin Granville Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts John Lawrence Lord Whitty Archibald Johnstone Lord Kirkwood of Kirkhope James Roger Crompton Lord Lupton Tina Wendy Baroness Stowell of Beeston The House adjourned. The House resumed. 3 Oaths and affirmations The following Lords took and subscribed the oath, or made and subscribed the solemn affirmation, and signed an undertaking to abide by the Code of Conduct: Philippa Marion Baroness Couttie Andrew Lord Turnbull Anthony Lord Giddens Geoffrey Robert James Lord Borwick Michael Fitzhardinge Lord Berkeley of Knighton Anthony Paul Lord Lester of Herne Hill Patrick John Tristram Lord Trevethin and Oaksey Nazir Lord Ahmed Michael David Lord Glendonbrook Jeffrey Howard Lord Archer of Weston-Super-Mare Edward Timothy Lord Razzall Amirali Alibhai Lord Bhatia

12 No. 1 Minutes of Proceedings

Thomas Orlando (Lord Lyttelton of Aldershot) Dolar Amarshi Lord Popat Christopher John Lord Grantchester Nuala Patricia Baroness O’Loan Fiona Sara Baroness Shackleton of Belgravia Rupert Bertram Lord Redesdale (Lord Mitford) Margaret Omolola Baroness Young of Hornsey Peter John Lord Hennessy of Nympsfield Dick Lord Taverne Greville Patrick Charles Lord Howard of Rising Robert Jacob Alexander Lord Skidelsky The House adjourned. The House resumed. 4 Oaths and affirmations The following Lords took and subscribed the oath, or made and subscribed the solemn affirmation, and signed an undertaking to abide by the Code of Conduct: Elizabeth Lydia Baroness Manningham-Buller Stephen Andrew Lord Carter of Barnes David Lindsay Lord Willetts Bernard Lord Donoughue Joanna Baroness Shields Elizabeth Margaret Baroness Smith of Gilmorehill Frances Gertrude Claire Baroness D’Souza Malcolm Everard MacLaren Lord Pearson of Rannoch The House adjourned. The House resumed. 5 Oaths and affirmations The following Lords took and subscribed the oath, or made and subscribed the solemn affirmation, and signed an undertaking to abide by the Code of Conduct: Gordon Joshua Lord Wasserman John David Beckett Lord Taylor of Warwick Frederick Matthew Thomas Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede (Lord Ponsonby of Roehampton) The House adjourned at 7.30pm until Wednesday 14 June at 2.30pm. Ed Ollard Clerk of the Parliaments

No. 1 13