Request for Proposals City of Oberlin, Ohio Branding and Cultural Wayfinding Signage Plan
Introduction
The City of Oberlin, Ohio, in association with the Firelands Association for the Visual Arts (FAVA), is seeking proposals from qualified professionals who have proven experience with branding and wayfinding projects. Through this request for proposals (“RFP”) process, a qualified consultant will be selected that will develop a brand identity for Oberlin; and develop and implement a cultural wayfinding system for the City. Ultimately, the wayfinding signage program will be incorporated throughout the main pedestrian, bicycle, and vehicular corridors in and around the City.
The purpose of this request for proposals (“RFP”) is to provide information to prospective consultants detailing the City’s desired services and deliverables, the expectations relative to consultant qualifications and the proposal content. This information is intended to enable consultants to develop branding for Oberlin as an arts destination and to design cultural wayfinding signage.
Project Background
The City of Oberlin
With its small town sense of community, the services of a large city, and the music, art, and science of a cosmopolitan center—all situated in just under five square miles—the City of Oberlin has justifiably earned numerous accolades, including being named one of the “top 20 best small towns to visit” by Smithsonian Magazine.
Founded concurrently with Oberlin College in 1833, the City is famous for its rich and diverse history of progressive thought, innovation, and social activism. The community was a beacon of freedom during the years of the Underground Railroad, and Oberlin College was the first in the country to admit men and women of all races. The City and the College are pioneers in the current environmental movement, and, with the development of a 2013 Climate Action Plan, are committed to becoming “carbon neutral” by 2050.
In addition to the honor bestowed upon the City by Smithsonian Magazine, Oberlin also has the distinction of earning the following titles in the last several years: Ohio Magazine Most Livable College Community 1996 Ohio Magazine Best Hometown 2012 MetLife Foundation Best Intergenerational Community 2012
Geographic Location
The City of Oberlin is located in Lorain County, Ohio, just south and west of the City of Cleveland. Oberlin has a population of 8,286 people (2010 U.S. Census) while Lorain County has a population of 301,356 people (2010 U.S. Census).
Oberlin is strategically located within easy traveling distance of the Ohio Turnpike (I‐80), U.S. Route 20, Ohio Route 2/I‐90, Ohio Route 58, and Ohio Route 511 as well as Cleveland Hopkins Airport (a 30‐minute drive). I‐80 and I‐90 are two of the nation’s most traveled interstates: I‐80 runs east and west from New York City to Los Angeles and I‐90 runs east and west from Boston to Seattle.
Ohio’s “Vacationland”
Oberlin is located in the heart of Ohio’s “Vacationland,” the North Coast of Lake Erie. The area between Lorain County and its neighboring counties to the east and west, Ottawa, Erie, and Cuyahoga, draws more than seven million visitors each year to Lake Erie and its islands, Cedar Point Amusement Park, Kalahari Waterpark, natural areas, wineries, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the Great Lakes Science Center, the Cleveland Museum of Art in Cleveland’s cultural hub, University Circle, and many other attractions.
Project Description
The City of Oberlin is seeking to hire a consultant to develop branding for Oberlin as an arts destination and to design cultural wayfinding signage. Meetings with arts organizations and their constituents will be central to this work. A logo and taglines will be developed, as will marketing materials such as a brochure for print and online use. The consultant will create a comprehensive cultural wayfinding plan, inventorying arts and cultural assets; identifying key sites for signage for vehicular, pedestrian, and bicycle traffic; and developing a signage design and fabrication and installation budget for future plan implementation. The selected consultant will be expected to articulate a process for bid management and implementation.
The wayfinding signage program should meet the needs of residents, students and parents as well as tourists/visitors from out‐of‐town. All transportation modes within the City and along major access thoroughfares (especially Main Street/State Route #58 and Lorain Street/State Route #511) should be considered. Street level vitality, legibility, safety, maintenance, aesthetic and replacement costs are all major concerns in creating an informational, user friendly, wayfinding signage program. The primary focus of the program is to increase and direct customer/visitor traffic to cultural assets in the City and on the Oberlin College Campus.
Maps of the entire City of Oberlin, the Oberlin College Campus and of downtown Oberlin are attached to this document as Appendices A, B and C respectively.
Below are some photographs of existing signage in the City of Oberlin:
The wayfinding signage program should consider an array of sign types that are vandal proof, and easy to update as information changes. The design for the program should provide a branded and unified design that can be used for marketing materials for the downtown and the City. The signage program should take into account the following types of signs:
General directional information and wayfinding for bicyclists and vehicular traffic General directional information and wayfinding for pedestrians, especially downtown Gateway signage Decorative banners for downtown Interpretive signage for historic sites Public art Municipal buildings and parks Future downtown destinations
Project Goals
The project goals for the City of Oberlin Branding and Cultural Wayfinding Signage Program are as follows:
Reflect or strengthen a unique community identity and sense of place that capitalizes on existing local assets, thereby catalyzing a persuasive vision for enhancing the livability of the community; Incorporate the arts into a systemic approach to equitable civic development; Support artists, design professionals, and arts organizations by integrating the arts and design into the fabric of civic life; Expand residents’ awareness of Oberlin’s extensive arts and cultural offerings; Strengthen the community economically, by developing and promoting Oberlin as an arts destination Raise community and visitor awareness of downtown Oberlin and its contents and other historic sites and recreational opportunities; Direct visitors downtown from major transportation arteries including vehicular and bicycle. Enhance visitors’ and residents’ ability to easily navigate around Oberlin and in downtown. Enhance visitors’ ability to find available parking. Increase the success and market potential for retail, dining, arts and entertainment. Enhance the user’s experience. Enhance the public spaces in Oberlin. Visually integrate City wayfinding signage with Oberlin College signage.
Scope of Work
The project will consist of the design services outlined below, resulting in the completion of construction documents suitable to bid the project for fabrication and installation. The consultant may, based on previous experience with a similar project or projects, suggest changes or alternatives in their response to this request for proposals. The consultant may also engage a fabrication team and include their results in the proposal. All deliverables submitted for review should be submitted as specified below and must include a digital version of same in a format acceptable to the City. Materials submitted for this project become the property of the City of Oberlin for its use in presentations and/ or on the City’s website.
Task 1: To formulate a brand identity for the City of Oberlin.
Community Meeting Conduct at least one community meeting to allow residents, businesses and other stakeholders to participate in a group session that will reveal the ideas, themes, and personality that the Oberlin brand should embody. Conduct at least one additional meeting specific to the arts organizations to gather ideas and themes that represent the cultural personality of Oberlin.
Brand/Identity Design Design new graphic elements for the City of Oberlin that will be used in the development of the wayfinding signage program. This should also include recommendations for and incorporation of a tagline or marketing concept based on information gathered at the community meeting.
Present at least three design concepts to the City Wayfinding Signage Committee for review and consideration.
The City will select one desired design concept. Artwork will be provided to the City in common file formats.
Deliverables: Brand identity presentation and marketing strategy recommendations.
Task 2: To develop a wayfinding signage plan for the City of Oberlin.
Wayfinding Audit
Conduct a one day site audit of the City to document the existing conditions (including boundaries, connections, travel paths, decision points, existing signage, and wayfinding challenges.
Wayfinding Plan
Develop a wayfinding plan that illustrates the recommended sign types, locations and types of messages for the new sign program.
Wayfinding Framework
Develop a project framework. This document presents the project mission and goals, programming and aesthetic philosophies, as well as illustrating information collected from the community meetings and wayfinding audit. This presentation will also focus on the value and potential return on investment for a program of this type.
Deliverables:
Wayfinding Plan: includes travel path study, a sign type hierarchy that describes proposed sign types, their function and usage within the program; proposed sign locations and messages.
Wayfinding Framework: an outline of our tailored approach to your project (presented with wayfinding plan).
Task 3: To develop a wayfinding program design.
Preliminary Sign Family Design
Design and develop preliminary concepts for up to three proposed sign types (from initial sign‐type hierarchy) to demonstrate application of chosen identity on potential identification and wayfinding signage. Up to two sign concepts will be presented.
Work with a fabrication consultant during conceptual design to present cost effective solutions and present budget pricing for each concept.
Deliverables:
Preliminary Sign Family Design presentation.
Sign Program Design and Documentation
Develop entire sign program design from selected concept.
Present sign program to governing review boards. Up to two formal City meetings are included.
Develop Bid Documentation Package: to solicit bid pricing from qualified sign contractors for fabrication and installation of the sign program. May include design intent drawings, performance specifications, sign location plans, and sign message schedule. This
Develop a graphic map for use within the Sign Program and other applications deemed necessary by the Client (i.e. website, marketing materials, etc.).
Design Development Presentation: may be used in presenting to government review boards.
Implementation Plan that presents schedule and budget scenarios for the fabrication and installation of the Sign Program.
Proposal Content and Requirements
Proposals shall be bound (8.5” x 11”), so that they lay flat when opened. One original and seven (7) complete copies of the proposal, as well as a digital version of same in PDF format must be submitted to the City of Oberlin by the proposal deadline. The following should be addressed as a minimum with sections tabbed with numbers as follows:
1. Introductory Letter: a. Firm name b. Address c. Contact person d. Telephone number and e‐mail address of contact person e. A clear and concise response as to why the City should select your firm for this work. 2. Statement of Qualifications: Provide a detailed description of similar projects successfully completed by the firm in the past three to five years, and the results of that work; include the name and telephone number of a contact person for each client who can verify the information provided. Describe your firm’s experience with utilizing a public participation process to design a community wayfinding program and design.
3. Firm Personnel Experience: a. Name of project manager. Provide resume and experience record of project manager. Identify the wayfinding projects from the Statement of Qualifications that the project manager has worked on, and describe their role with the project. b. Organizational chart of team personnel who will actually be assigned to perform substantial amounts of the work on this project and the role of each. c. Provide a resume and experience record for each person, including years of experience, education, and anticipated amount of time each will actually work on this project and the location of each person. 4. Sub‐Consultant Personnel Experience: a. Names and addresses of any outside consultants or associates proposed to be involved with this project. b. Include each proposed sub‐consultant’s experience and qualifications as described above for the firm’s personnel experience. 5. Project Approach: A detailed description of how the firm proposes to approach this project. a. Provide a fee schedule for supplemental charges that may be charged for additional unforeseen work tasks, if such services should be required via a future contract addendum such as: fees for conducting additional public meetings, additional meetings with City staff, additional stakeholder or community meetings, additional iterations or revisions, or additional information related to installation, etc. 6. Project Timeline: A timeline including the tasks to be performed by the consultant and the expected time to complete each step. While there is no set deadline for completion of this project, the City desires to have this work completed no later than December 1, 2016. Earlier completion times will be looked upon favorably. 7. City Resources Expected: A list of the resources, personnel, data or other assistance from the City which the proposer expects. City personnel resources are limited, thus these should be kept to a minimum. 8. References: Provide three references from individuals familiar with your work. 9. Price Proposal: The price proposal section of the proposal must include the following information: a. Total Cost. Provide a total not‐to‐exceed fixed fee for the entire project as you have proposed in your response to the Scope of Work. b. Cost Breakdown. Provide a cost for each task identified in the Scope of Work. Include an estimate of the hours necessary to complete the work for each phase. You may provide further detail if so desired. All cost assumptions must be clearly documented in this portion of the submittal. Include a budget for direct expenses such as travel. c. Certification of Price Proposal. The Price Proposal must include a statement signed by an authorized person which includes the total cost of the proposal. The price shall remain in effect for 90 days.
Evaluation of Proposals
The Committee will evaluate the proposals based on the following metrics:
CRITERIA WEIGHT Understanding of the work required, quality and responsiveness of the proposal 10% Professional qualifications related to the scope of work, including quality of comparable 20% experience Proposed methodology for completing the work 20% Design aesthetic 15% References and work sample 10% Fee 25% TOTAL 100%
Submission Deadline
One original, seven (7) complete copies and one digital PDF version of the proposal must be received by the City of Oberlin no later than 4:30 p.m. on June 7, 2016. Late proposals will not be considered. All proposals and documents attached become the property of the City of Oberlin.
Proposals should be submitted in person or arrive by mail to:
Carrie R. Handy, Planning and Development Director City of Oberlin 69 S. Main Street Room 204 Oberlin, Ohio 44074
Selection Process and Schedule
The Committee will review all submitted proposals to determine those firms that will be granted an interview. Following the interviews, staff will attempt to negotiate an agreement with the top ranked firm. If no agreement can be reached with the top ranked firm, that firm will be dismissed, and the Committee will proceed with discussions with the second ranked firm. This process may be repeated as many times as necessary until an agreement can be negotiated that is satisfactory to both parties.
The City of Oberlin reserves the right to reject any or all bids or proposals, waive technicalities, and to be the sole judge of the suitability of the proposed services for its intended use and further specifically reserves the right to make the award in the best interests of the City. The projected schedule for selecting the consultant for this project is as follows:
Activity Dates:
Announce RFP: May 17, 2016 Proposal Deadline: June 7, 2016 Review of Proposals: June 8 to June 24, 2016 Interviews: June 28 – June 29, 2016 Selection of Consultant: On or about July 1, 2016
General Information
Inquiries: If the consultant has any questions in regard to this RFP, please contact:
Carrie R. Handy Planning and Development Director City of Oberlin 69 S. Main Street Oberlin, Ohio 44074 440‐775‐7250 [email protected]
Right of Rejection
The City of Oberlin reserves the right to reject any or all proposals submitted in response to this RFP. The City of Oberlin is not liable for any costs incurred by consultants in preparing proposals in response to this RFP.
Limitations
Deliverables: All deliverables become the property of the City of Oberlin.
Negotiations: A request for proposals does not commit the City of Oberlin to award a contract, to pay any costs incurred in the preparation of the proposal, or to procure or contract for services and supplies. The City of Oberlin reserves the right to accept or reject any or all proposals received as a result of this request, to negotiate with any qualified source, or to cancel in part or in its entirety this request for proposals, if it is in the best interest of the City to do so. The City may require the consultant to participate in negotiations and to submit such price, technical or other revisions of the proposal as may result from negotiations.
This project is supported in part by an award from the National Endowment for the Arts. To find out more about how NEA grants impact individuals and communities, visit www.arts.gov
OBERLIN COLLEGE CAMPUS
1 Allen Memorial Art Museum and Art Building 2 Allencroft (Russian House)
3 Apollo Theatre RTE. 58) (OHIO TO ATHLETIC 4 Asia House (Quadrangle) FIELDS
5 Bailey (French House) NORTH MAIN STREET 6 Baldwin Cottage 7 Barnard House 33 54 STREET PROFESSOR NORTH 8 Barrows Hall 9 Bookstore UNION STREET 10 Bosworth Hall 11 Burton Hall 27 12 Carnegie Building 44 59 35 13 Conservatory of Music PARKING 14 Cox Admin. Building 5 11 30 15 Creative Writing 41 16 Dascomb Hall N 17 Daub House 18 (Bonner Center) North 52 18 East Hall Quad 31 W E 19 Fairchild House 8 7 20 Finney Chapel
WOODLAND STREET S 21 Hales (College Lanes, 4 Cat in the Cream) 22 Hall Annex 58 23 Hall Auditorium 21 12 49 Science 24 Harkness House Quad 50 10 EAST LORAIN STREET 25 Harvey (Spanish House) ELM STREET (OHIO RTE. 511)
26 Hotel at Oberlin TO SERVICE BLDG, STUDENT HEALTH, 48 & Gateway Center COMMUNICATIONS, 15 17 57 20 1 27 International House COUNSELING CTR College Admissions 28 Johnson House 14 (Hebrew Heritage House) Bandstand Wilder 29 Kade (German House) 40 Bowl 43 22 30 Robert L. Kahn Hall Memorial 31 Keep Cottage Arch 23 TAPPAN 32 King Building 56 SQUARE 33 Knowlton Athletics WILLARD COURT Complex TO CHARLES MARTIN 34 Bertram & Judith 26 HALL HOUSE, Conservatory SHANSI Kohl Building HOUSE, AND 16 47 32 Admissions TANK HALL 35 Langston Hall (North) EAST COLLEGE STREET 36 AJ Lewis Center & Annex WEST COLLEGE STREET (Environmental Studies) 24 53 9 3 37 Lewis Center (for Women 55 and Transgender People) 13 38 Lewis House (Ombuds & DOWNTOWN
6 DOWNTOWN Multifaith Resource Center) 36 39 Lord-Saunders 34 (Afrikan Heritage House) WEST LORAIN STREET 40 Mudd Center 19 (Main Library) 38 41 Noah Hall 51 42 Old Barrows 37 43 Peters Hall 44 Philips Phys. Ed. Center South VINE STREET 45 President’s House Quad 25 46 Price (Third World House) 39 47 Rice Hall 45 46 29 48 Safety & Security
49 Science Center FOREST STREET 50 Severance Hall 51 South Hall 2 52 Stevenson Hall 53 Talcott Hall 54 Union Street Housing 55 Ward Alumni Center MORGAN STREET 56 Warner Center 42 57 Wilder Hall 28 (Student Union) OBERLIN ARBORETUM PROFESSORSOUTH STREET STREET MAIN SOUTH RTE. 58) (OHIO 58 Wright Lab of Physics 59 Zechiel House DOWNTOWN SHOPPING, DINING, ENTERTAINMENT
KEY: W. LORAIN ST. E. LORAIN ST. DINING & BARS FOOD SPECIALTIES PARKING ENTERTAINMENT & INFORMATION N SHOPPING ART SHOPS/ GALLERIES & HISTORY
*Denotes Oberlin Business Partnership Member
1 Allen Memorial Art Museum 2 *Brewster’s Pub at the Oberlin Inn - 7 N. Main St. 440-775-1111, www.oberlininn.com 3 *The Garden Restaurant at the Oberlin Inn - PARKING PARKING 7 N. Main St., 440-775-1111, www.oberlininn.com 4 Magpie Pizza 5 Infinite Monkey Comics & Games 6 *Cowhaus Creamery - 55 E. College St., Ste. 4 440-774-5425, www.cowhauscreamery.com 7 *Slow Train Coffee House and Music Café - 55 E. College St., 440-774-7570, www.slowtrain.com PARKING 8 Tree Huggers Café 9 Kim’s Grocery & Carryout 10 Tansu 11 The Oberlin Business Partnership - 23 E. College St. 12 Apollo Theater 26 Black River Café 40 *New Union Center for the Arts - 39 S. Main St. *Firelands Association for the Visual Arts (FAVA) - 13 *Oberlin Bookstore - 37 W. College St. 27 Ade’s Place & Alake Gallery 440-774-7722, www.oberlin.bncollege.com 440-774-7158, www.favagallery.org 28 Subway 14 *Bead Paradise - 29 W. College St., 440-775-2233 41 Main Street Diner www.beadparadise.com 29 Ginko Gallery & Studio 42 *Lorenzo’s Pizzeria & Restaurant - 52 ½ S. Main St., 440-774-0118 15 *Rosen-Jones Photography Studio - 29 ½ W. College 30 Simply Elegant Candle & Gifts 440-935-6342, www.rosenjones.com www.lorenzospizza.com 31 *The Local Coffee & Tea - 23 S. Main St. 16 Tooo Chinoise 43 *The Tuck Shop - 53 S. Main St., 440-774-8825 440-774-1866, www.thelocal.com www.facebook.com/thetuckshop 17 Smith’s Home Furnishings & Floor Coverings 32 Swerve Bike Shop 44 *The UPS Store - 55 S. Main St., 440-774-7447 www.theupsstorelocal.com/4109 18 Gibson’s Bakery & Food Mart 33 Workshop Art Gallery 19 Agave Burrito Bar & Tequilaria 45 Oberlin Farmers Market - 69-85 S. Main St. 34 Watson’s Hardware Open 9am-1pm May – Oct. 20 Carlyle Flower & Gift Shop 35 Asfound Antiques and Gallery 46 *Oberlin Heritage Center - 73 S. Professor St. 440-774-1700, www.oberlinhertiage.org 21 *Woodshed Lesson Studio & Store - 15 W. College St. 36 *The Feve - 30 S. Main St., 440-774-1978 440-775-1808, www.woodshedlessons.com www.thefeve.com 47 Mandarin Chinese Restaurant 22 Ben Franklin & MindFair Books 37 *Ottica Eye Care - 32 S. Main St., 440-775-2010 48 Lupita’s Mexican Restaurant www.otticaeyecare.com 23 *Herrick Jewelry - 7 W. College St., 440-774-4461 49 Campbell House Antiques www.facebook.com/herrickjewelry 38 BMck’s Public House 24 Aladdin’s Eatery 50 *Ratsy’s Store Upstairs - 95 S. Main St. 39 *The Oberlin Market - 22 Carpenter Court 440-774-9172, www.ratsysstore.com 440-774-8401, www.oberlinmarket.com 25 Weia Teia ADDITIONAL OBERLIN SHOPPING, DINING & ENTERTAINMENT
1 Presti’s 13 CVS 2 Dollar General 14 Quick and Delicious 3 Oberlin College Bowling Lanes 15 Main Street Antiques 4 Deichlers Auto & Tire Works 16 *Four Legged Café - 48 W. Lincoln St., 440-774-2222 www.fourleggedcafe.net 5 East Oberlin Nursery (Above) 17 Splash Zone 6 *Locke’s Green Side Up Garden Center - 461 E. Lorain St., 440-774-6981 18 The Shoe Department www.greensideup.info 19 Goodwill N 7 Oberlin IGA 20 Dollar Tree 8 Puffer’s Floral Shoppe 21 *Walmart - 46440 US 20, 440-774-6720 9 Domino’s Pizza www.walmart.com 10 *East of Chicago Pizza - 175 S. Main St. 22 Pizza Hut 440-774-8820, www.eastofchicago.com 23 Advance Auto Parts 11 McDonald’s 24 Totally Floored 12 *Ace Hardware - 291 S. Main St., 440-775-4223 www.acehardware.com 25 Country Skateland
Promoting the sustainable growth & prosperity of the Oberlin Community. We are Positively Oberlin!
For additional information, go to www.oberlin.org.