Keith G. Jones, a Shared Meal and a Common Table. Some Relfections

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Keith G. Jones, a Shared Meal and a Common Table. Some Relfections THE WHITLEY LECTURE 1999 A SHARED MEAL AND A COMMON TABLE Some reflections on the Lord's Supper and Baptists Keith G. Jones Whitley Publications THE WHITLEY LECTURE 1999 A SHARED MEAL AND A COMMON TABLE Some renections on the Lord's Supper and Baptists Keith G. Jones Whitley Publications The Author and Whitley Publications 1999 ISBN 0-9528150-4-4 All rights reseaved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission from the Publisher in writing. Whitley Publications c/o Regent's Park College Pusey Street Oxford OXI 2LB England 3 The Whitley Lecture The Whitley Lectureship was first established in 1949, in honour of W.T. Whitley (1861-1947), arguably the first systematic modern Baptist historian. Whitley was a notable scholar and servant of the Church of Christ. He had pastorates in England and Australia. He served the denomination in both countries in many ways, including pursuing historical studies. Whitley was a key figure in the formation of the Baptist Historical Society (1908). He edited its journal which soon gained an international reputation for the quality of its contents. Altogether he made a particularly remarkable contribution to Baptist life and self-understanding, providing an inspiring model of how a pastor scholar might enrich the life and faith of others. The establishment of the Lectureship in his name was intended to be an encouragement to research by Baptist scholars into aspects of Christian life and thought and to enable the results of such research to be published and available to the denomination and beyond. The Whitley Lectureship's Management Committee is composed of representatives of the Baptist Colleges, the Baptist Union of Great Britain, the Baptist Missionary Society, the Baptist Ministers Fellowship and the Baptist Historical Society. Through the years the encouragement towards scholarship has taken different forms, from the full support of the writing of lectures for publication by a designated Whitley Lecturer to the making available of smaller grants to those working at particular research interests. 4 In 1996 the Management Committee of the Whitley Lectureship began a new initiative in keeping with the original purpose. It was agreed to appoint each year a Lecturer to write and deliver a lecture as a contribution to scholarly Baptist thought. Each lecture will be published. We are delighted that the Revd Keith Jones gives the third lecture in this new series. He was a pastor in Bamoldswick from 1975 until becoming the Secretary of the Yorkshire Baptist Association. In 1991 he was appointed Deputy General Secretary of the Baptist Union of Great Britain. He is presently Rector of the International Baptist Theological Seminary in Prague. His lecture topic, while focusing on Baptist thought and practices, is one of concern for all Christian people. Brian Haymes on behalf of the Management Committee THE WHITLEY LECTURE 1999 A SHARED :MEAL AND A COl\lMON TABLE Some reflections on the Lord's Supper and Baptists The organ notes died away. We had just finished singing a fine hymn of commissioning. The minister pronounced the benediction and walked down the right hand aisle to greet any worshippers leaving evening worship. The deacons, the men in their dark Sunday suits, all made of good West Riding woollen cloth, the women in smart coats with sober hats, left their seats and went into the vestry. The organist began to play 'When I survey the wondrous cross'. Some worshippers scurried away, anxious to leave the chapel. Others moved from their seats in the side aisles to the centre, every alternate row. There was no talking, just the sombre organ music. The minister walked back down the aisle, through the vestry door and emerged moments later with the deacons who went and sat on the platform behind the communion table, equal numbers either side. One lady deacon, always a lady, took a large white cloth from the communion table to reveal two trays of tiny glass cups filled with diluted Ribena blackcurrant juice and two silver plates containing small cubes of white processed bread. The minister 'fenced the table' with scriptural sentences and a reading from the Letter to the Corinthians about those who ate and drank unworthily. One deacon then stood and offered a general prayer about the bread. In fact, my memory recalls those prayers as being varied, moving between adoration, confession and intercession with 6 A SHARED MEAL AND A COMMON TABLE dexterity, though not always clarity. The deacons distributed the bread passing up and down the rows of pews. Each person present took a small cube and ate it. The silence was profound, broken only by the occasional sound of a cough. Then another prayer: occasionally this might take the form of a poem, or insight from a popular Christian writer. Thereafter the trays were handed round. Perhaps the organist would play something from 'Olivet to Calvary'. We would be instructed to drink the cup 'until He comes'. The Ribena often irritated the back of a dry throat and there would be a bout of coughing. Remaining seated and singing quietly we would conclude the service with a hymn such as that by Horatius Bonar, 'Here, 0 my Lord'. 1 As a teenager I came to several conclusions from this experience. The occasion was a sombre one. Some people did not like to be present. It was an adjunct to the main service. There was a very strong accent on memorial, on death and on discipline. I also perceived a lack of clarity about the focus of the prayers, which often mirrored those in the 'main', or preceding service, which had been uttered by the minister. I was told, of course, during my discipleship training, that the meal was primarily for believers. It was best not to consume 'the elements' until after baptism and that the meal was a time to remember the death of Jesus on the cross - a 'mere memorial' as earlier Baptist writers had declared. 2 Now, I hasten to say this is my recollection; the images which impressed themselves on my mind as a new first­ generation Baptist coming to terms with faith in the 1960s. I am sure some who were present on those occasions would soon bear testimony to facets I have missed and which would present a more accurate and rounded picture. But I do not think it is untrue of a typical post-war communion THE WHITLEY LECTURE 1999 7 service amongst Baptists, save possibly in the participation of women deacons, which was not so common. Indeed, there are still churches where that pattern exists. Elsewhere, the effects of the work of the late Dr Ernest A. Payne and the Revd S.F. Winward3 had begun to have the effect of encouraging churches to partake of the 'Supper' in the main act of worship. Today, though the music in the rest of worship may have changed, .the 'communion' part of many services has simply been incorporated into a monthly event in the morning. Where an evening service still exists, there might also be a second celebration. All this, despite some significant attempts by leading scholars to open up the debate and encourage a more rounded act of corporate worship. 4 In this Whitley Lecture I cannot hope to address the whole biblical, historical, theological and liturgical debate about the Lord's Supper. I have, therefore, attempted to limit myself to exploring some of the historical roots from which our traditional understanding comes. Then I hope to open up some new insights and to reflect on our theology and practice in the contemporary world. This, in the light of what we are constantly discovering as we engage in dialogue with other parts of the Christian tradition and in the process of reception of ecumenical discussions such as Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry. 5 It is often claimed that Baptists follow the 'third man of the reformation', Huldrych Zwingli, in being 'mere memorialists'. As Dom Gregory Dix said in his monumental work: 6 His doctrine of the sacraments, like that of his colleague of Baste, leaves them no force or efficacy of their own whatsoever. They are bare signs or 8 A SHARED MEAL AND A COMMON TABLE ceremonies by which a man assures other people rather than him of his saving faith in Christ's redemption. In the Eucharist there is but plain bread and wine, a reminder of the salvation achieved long ago on Calvary. In other words, the Eucharistic action consists in a vivid mental remembering of the passion as the achievement of 'my' redemption in the past... Now, this view of Dom Gregory Dix has often been taken as accurate in its portrayal of Zwingli. The comment has reverberated amongst Christian scholars who have presumed it could be safely applied to Baptists in general. My teenage impressions may seek, on first reflection, to bear out the assertion. However, it may be inaccurate and premature to assume either point is right. Was Zwingli really Zwinglian in his Eucharistic theology and have Baptists always been Zwinglian in their understanding of the meal? As to Zwingli, more recent research by scholars, especially around the time of the 500th anniversary of his birth, have re-examined the work of this reformer who was, unfortunately, cut down in his prime, and unlike his illustrious successor, Calvin, was not able to write up his theology in a systematic way. Dr Wayne Pipkin, a noted Zwingli scholar, has suggested several key values from the Eucharistic thinking of Zwingli.7 Firstly, the Eucharistic theology of Zwingli developed over a nine-year period.
Recommended publications
  • Cochrane Street United Church October 1St, 2017
    GATHERING AS GOD’S PEOPLE *please stand as you are able Cochrane Street United Church PRELUDE: 81 Cochrane Street ♦ St. John’s, NL ♦ A1C 3L7 *INTROIT: *WELCOME AND ANNOUNCEMENTS *PASSING OF THE PEACE: Let our hospitality towards each other reflect God's love. The Lord be with you. And also with you. Let us greet one another with the peace of Christ. REFLECTIVE MUSIC MV #14: Where Two or Three Are Gathered Where two or three are gathered in my name, I am there, I am there. CALL TO WORSHIP: For love that offers refreshment to all who drink of it, Light to all who walk in it, Strength to all who hope in it, Healing to all who have need if it, Wholeness to all who live in it, This is the God we serve, The God we worship, st The God we proclaim, October 1 , 2017 This day and all days, with our words and our lives. Minister: Rev. Miriam Bowlby, B.A. (Hons) M.Div PRAYER OF APPROACH: Minister Emeritus: Rev. Eric Hillier Generous God, for all that sustains us; Minister of Music: Patricia Young air to breath, warmth and light, Director of Music: Evan Smith food to eat, water to drink, we offer our thanks and praise. For spiritual gifts that bind us together; (t) 709-722-3023 (f) 709-722-3260 one people, one body [email protected] empowered for service www.cochranestreetuc.com we offer our hands and voices. we offer our hearts in service. Amen *HYMN MV #1: Let Us Build a House Let us build a house where love can dwell and all can safely live, a ASSURANCE OF PARDON: place where saints and children tell how hearts learn to forgive.
    [Show full text]
  • 'It Is Bread and It Is Christ's Body Too': Presence and Sacrifice in The
    ‘It is Bread and it is Christ’s Body Too’: Presence and Sacrifice in the Eucharistic Theology of Jeremy Taylor Paul Andrew Barlow PhD, MA, BSc, PGCE A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Dublin City University Supervisor: Dr Joseph Rivera School of Theology, Philosophy and Music July 2019 ii I hereby certify that this material, which I now submit for assessment on the programme of study leading to the award of Doctor of Philosophy is entirely my own work, and that I have exercised reasonable care to ensure that the work is original, and does not to the best of my knowledge breach any law of copyright, and has not been taken from the work of others save and to the extent that such work has been cited and acknowledged within the text of my work. Signed: ID No.:15212014 Date: 15th July 2019 iii iv And yet if men would but do reason, there were in all religion no article which might more easily excuse us from meddling with questions about it than this of the holy sacrament. For as the man in Phaedrus that being asked what he carried hidden under his cloak, answered, it was hidden under his cloak; meaning that he would not have hidden it but that he intended it should be secret; so we may say in this mystery to them that curiously ask what or how it is, mysterium est, ‘it is a sacrament and a mystery;’ by sensible instruments it consigns spiritual graces, by the creatures it brings us to God, by the body it ministers to the Spirit.
    [Show full text]
  • The Catholic Doctrine of Transubstantiation Is Perhaps the Most Well Received Teaching When It Comes to the Application of Greek Philosophy
    Bucknell University Bucknell Digital Commons Honors Theses Student Theses 2010 The aC tholic Doctrine of Transubstantiation: An Exposition and Defense Pat Selwood Bucknell University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.bucknell.edu/honors_theses Part of the Religion Commons Recommended Citation Selwood, Pat, "The aC tholic Doctrine of Transubstantiation: An Exposition and Defense" (2010). Honors Theses. 11. https://digitalcommons.bucknell.edu/honors_theses/11 This Honors Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Theses at Bucknell Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of Bucknell Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS My deepest appreciation and gratitude goes out to those people who have given their support to the completion of this thesis and my undergraduate degree on the whole. To my close friends, Carolyn, Joseph and Andrew, for their great friendship and encouragement. To my advisor Professor Paul Macdonald, for his direction, and the unyielding passion and spirit that he brings to teaching. To the Heights, for the guidance and inspiration they have brought to my faith: Crescite . And lastly, to my parents, whose love, support, and sacrifice have given me every opportunity to follow my dreams. TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction………………………………..………………………………………………1 Preface: Explanation of Terms………………...………………………………………......5 Chapter One: Historical Analysis of the Doctrine…………………………………...……9
    [Show full text]
  • Different Ways Christians Have Understood Baptism and Eucharist
    4 Ways Christians Have Understood Communion Sacramental Views Eastern Orthodox — “real presence” of unspecified mode Transubstantiation Consubstantiation Receptionism Memorialism the bread is no longer bread, but the bread is not only bread, but the bread is truly the body of the bread is a symbol for us to truly becomes the body of Christ is also truly the body of Christ Christ for those eat with faith remember the death of Jesus Held by Held by Held by Held by Roman Catholics Lutherans, high-church Anglicans Reformed, low-church Anglicans Baptists, nondenominational Big idea Big idea Big idea Big idea When a priest consecrates, the When a priest consecrates, the When a believing person eats Christ doesn’t give us special inner substance of bread and Spirit makes Christ present in the consecrated elements, Christ is grace in Communion; He already wine are transformed into the elements. As in the incarnation, truly present in those people. He gave us grace when we came to body and blood of Christ. The the supernatural does not is neither "in" the elements, nor him in faith. During Communion bread is merely a "veil." exclude the natural. present merely like other times. we remember that. Anglican take Anglican take Anglican Take Official quote Not taught. “After the Accepted. “The true body and Accepted. “The body and blood Not taught. “The members of consecration of bread and wine, blood of Christ are really present of Christ is then, not corporally the Church, by the sacred use of our Lord Jesus Christ, in the Supper of our Lord under or carnally, in the bread and bread and wine, are to true God and true man, is truly, the form of bread and wine and wine; but is really, and commemorate together the really, and substantially are there distributed and spiritually, present to the faith of dying love of Christ; preceded contained in the sacrament of received.” (Augsburg Confession) believers in that ordinance.
    [Show full text]
  • It T S B U R G H G A
    T n N u W a Pennsylvania’s n largest weekly ITTS BURGH G ATH circulation >4798\ Friday, September 30, 1983 139th Year, CXLIV No. 29 15 Cents - DUQUESNE UNIVERSITY olic Newspaper in Continuous Publication a I mR ARI AN __ L O C U S T Cathc P 1 T T S B Catholic Inside educators school in to gather Braddock to dose Oct. 13-14 By STEPHEN KARLINCHAK By STEPHEN KARL1NCHAK One of the oldest, continuously “ Catholic Schools: Rooted in operating Catholic schools ui the Faith, Fashioned by Hope and diocese, St. Thomas District High Expressed in Love,” is the theme School in Braddock. will close at for this year’s Tri-Diocesan the end of the 1982-83 academic J e s u its Catholic Teachers Institute. year. More than 3,500 teachers, The diocesan school board made Jesuits describe their first principals and administrators — the decision to close St. Thomas at ‘Arab’ superior general. Page 6. priests. Religious brothers and iu Sept 20 meeting Students were sisters, and lay persons — from informed of the closing at an the Pittsburgh, Greensburg and assem b ly on Sept. 21. An Altoona-Johnstown dioceses will information meeting for parents attend the two-day conference on to discuss their questions about Thursday and Friday, Oct. 13 and continuing Catholic education for 14, at the Monroeville Merchan­ their children was held on Sept 22 dise Mart/Expo Center. A decline in the potential In addition to the teachers and number of students and the hard- administrators from the three pressed economy affected the dioceses, 40 elementary and school's enrollment said Sister Movie review secondary school teachers and Josephine Macias.
    [Show full text]
  • TAKING IT HOME Taking It Home, Table of Contents
    TAKING IT HOME Taking it home, Table of Contents Congregational wrap up............................................................................... 2 CROSS+GENERATIONAL ENGAGEMENT Workshop Leader’s Guide............................................................................. 4 GLOCAL MISSION 101 Workshop Leader’s Guide............................................................................. 30 RADICAL HOSPITALITY Workshop Leader’s Guide............................................................................. 45 Presentation Scripts & Supplemental materials................................................................................. 54 Ecumenism and the Lutheran Church in America..................................... 55 Communion, Congregations and Communities The Lutheran World Federation – A Communion of Churches................. 89 The Lutheran World Federation – A Communion of Churches Overview Powerpoint Narrative.................................................................... 91 Important Teaching Techniques A quick overview of 16 tips to remember when introducing music from another culture to a singing assembly and other related resources ......................................................................... 108 CongregationAL WRAP UP Congregational TEAM TIME WORKSHEET I and/or members of my congregation’s team attended the following workshops: ___ Cross+Generational Engagement ___ Growing a Missional Congregation ___ Lutheran Immigration and Refugee Service ___ On the Move ___ Mission 101 ___ Mission Interpretation:
    [Show full text]
  • John Wesley and the Means of Grace
    JOHN WESLEY AND THE MEANS OF GRACE: AN APPROACH TO CHRISTIAN RELIGIOUS EDUCATION A Dissertation presented to the Faculty of the Claremont School of Theology In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy by Dean Gray Blevins MAY 1999 Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. © 1999 Dean Gray Blevins ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. This dissertation, written by Dean Gray Blevins____________________ under the direction of Faculty Committee, and approved by its members, has been presented to and accepted by the Faculty of the School of Theology at Claremont in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Faculty Committee Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Permission is given for Methodist Church purposes, for permission to use excerpts of the following: John Wesley and Education, by Alfred H. Body,© 1936 by Epworth Press; The Eucharistic Hymns of John and Charles Wesley, by Ernest J. Rattenbury © 1948 by Epworth Press. Reprinted with the permission of by the Methodist Trustees for Methodist Church Purposes, and by permission of the Methodist Publishing House. In addition, the publishers have generously given permission to use extended quotations from the following works: The Works of John Wesley: Letters 1 & 2, vol. 25-26 of The Works of John Wesley, Bicentennial ed., by Frank Baker, ed. © 1980-82 by Clarendon Press, reprint, Abingdon Press, 1982; The Methodist Societies: History, Nature and Design, vol. 9 of The Works of John Wesley.
    [Show full text]
  • Call to Unity #4 Front Mtr.P65
    CallResourcing the to Church for Unity Ecumenical Ministry Issue 4 July 2005 Style and Substance in the New Ecumenism From the Editor New Ecumenism This issue of Call to Unity brings together three articles that were first presented during “Ministers’ Week” at Phillips Theological Seminary in Tulsa, Oklahoma, on January 11-12, 2005. The theme for the week focused upon understanding the call to Christian unity in a time of transition from the “old ecumenism” of the twentieth century, to a “new ecumenism” marked by new insights and understandings into the nature of unity (William Tabbernee); the empowering concept of common humanity (Ray A. Owens); and a more aggressive ecumenical agenda in the Roman Catholic Church calling for communion, evangelization and conversion (Joseph Bessler-Northcutt). Each of these articles, written from very different theological perspectives and personal histories in the life of the church and the ecumenical movement, offers fresh and challenging insights into the style and substance in the new ecumenism: • A Disciples of Christ seminary president and Professor of the History of Christianity, who lived and taught for many years in Australia, responds to the current and widely-used image of “the winter of ecumenism” by reminding us that “when it’s winter in some parts of the world, it is summer in the opposite hemisphere.” • An ordained minister in the Progressive National Baptist Convention who serves as Assistant Professor of Christian Social Ethics and Black Studies, looks at the ecumenical movement through different eyes to suggest that “people of color have a valuable contribution to make toward the challenge of ecumenism, especially as it is expressed and understood in predominantly white and ‘so-called’ mainline CALL TO UNITY / Resourcing the Church for denominations.” Ecumenical Ministry is published by the Council on Christian Unity of the Christian Church • A lay member in the Roman Catholic Church and Associate (Disciples of Christ), P.0.
    [Show full text]
  • Calvin's Doctrine of the Lord's Supper
    Perichoresis Volume 10. Issue 2 (2012): 137-163 DOI 10.2478/v10297-012-0007-3 CALVIN’S DOCTRINE OF THE LORD’S SUPPER * WIM JANSE Free University of Amsterdam ABSTRACT. In order to pinpoint its proprium , it is necessary to understand John Calvin’s Eu- charistic theology within the wider context of the intra-Protestant debates of his time. As a se- cond-generation Reformer, Calvin developed his ideas explicitly in reaction to and as a middle way between the Lutheran and Swiss Reformed discussions of the 1520’s. To that end this es- say first focuses on the main developments from the Middle Ages onwards, and then presents Calvin from the perspective of the positions taken up by some of his contemporaries, in parti- cular Philipp Melanchthon. Next, some representative texts written by Calvin himself are ana- lysed. Although Calvin’s Eucharistic views were not from the beginning a coherent and unified doctrine but developed only gradually, they may be described in a systematic-synthetic way. With respect to the matter of closed, open, and frequent communion, it is observed that for Calvin a regular celebration is essential to the deepening of the believer’s union with Christ. KEY WORDS: John Calvin, the Lord’s Supper, Eucharistic theology, Reformed sacramentolo- gy, communion Introduction Calvin’s doctrine of the Lord’s Supper is not just any chapter from Calvin’s theology. 1 In his Eucharistic theology we touch upon the core of Calvin’s thought. This is true not only for Calvin, but for all major sixteenth-century * WIM JANSE is professor of historical theology and dean of the Faculty of Theology wi- thin the Free University of Amsterdam.
    [Show full text]
  • Ecumenical Liturgy, Its Possibilities and Problems
    FROM THE EDITOR ECUMENIC A L LITURGY , ITS POSSIBILITIES A ND PROBLEMS Sarah Hinlicky Wilson Editor’s note: An earlier version of this essay was presented at the cal movement came with Vatican II ’s Constitution on the 43rd International Ecumenical Seminar in Strasbourg, France, on the Sacred Liturgy (Sacrosanctum Concilium). Since the faithful theme “The Liturgy as Ecumenical Chance and Challenge.” must “take part fully aware of what they are doing, actively engaged in the rite, and enriched by its effects” (§11), a number of reforms are necessary. There should be “more reading from Holy Scripture, and it is to be more var- The Liturgical Movement and the Ecumenical Movement ied and suitable” (§35.1); preaching is to be emphasized, Already, among the ecumenically-minded, preparations improved, and included in every mass, with its content are underway to celebrate the hundredth anniversary of drawn “mainly from scriptural and liturgical sources, and the World Missionary Conference in Edinburgh in 1910, its character should be that of a proclamation of God’s which is regarded as the birthday of the ecumenical move- wonderful works in the history of salvation” (§35.2); the use ment. What seems to be quite a bit less well-known is that of the vernacular is permitted (§36.2); and “communion this year, 2009, is also a hundredth anniversary celebration, under both kinds may be granted” (§55). Further, though and for a movement that has impacted the Christian world the magisterium reserved to itself the right to approve all every bit as much:
    [Show full text]
  • ABSTRACT in the Early Nineteenth Century, the Church
    ABSTRACT In the early nineteenth century, the Church of England faced a crisis of self- understanding as a result of political and social changes occurring in Britain. The church was forced to determine what it meant to be the established church of the nation in light of these new circumstances. In the 1830s, a revival took place within the Church of England which prompted a renewal of the theology and practice of the church, including the Eucharist. This revival, known as the Oxford Movement, breathed new life into the High Church party. A heightened emphasis was placed on the sacramental life and on the Eucharist as the focus of worship. Adherents of the Oxford Movement developed a Eucharistic theology which promoted a closer connection between the elements and Christ’s presence in the Eucharist than did the earlier Anglican tradition. One of the exponents of this Eucharistic theology was Robert Isaac Wilberforce (1802- 1857). The second son of anti-slavery crusader William Wilberforce, Robert was raised in a family of prominent Anglican Evangelicals. At the University of Oxford he came under the influence of his tutor, John Keble, who was one of the four leaders of the Oxford Movement during its heyday. The Gorham case, whose focus was ostensibly the question of baptismal regeneration, turned into a debate on the state’s control over the established church. Robert 1 Wilberforce was called upon to articulate the sacramental theology of the Oxford Movement, which he did in his three major works, The Doctrine of Holy Baptism: With Remarks to the Rev.
    [Show full text]
  • The Active Role of Christ and the Holy Spirit in the Sanctification of the Eucharistic Elements Edward J
    Theological Studies 45(1984) THE ACTIVE ROLE OF CHRIST AND THE HOLY SPIRIT IN THE SANCTIFICATION OF THE EUCHARISTIC ELEMENTS EDWARD J. KILMARTIN, S.J. University of Notre Dame URING THE LAST two decades several bilateral ecumenical commis­ D sions of Christian churches have issued agreed statements on the subject of the Eucharist. In general they display a striking conformity in the way they speak about how Christ's sacramental presence is realized. In this essay all examples derive from commissions which have Roman Catholic participants and, in individual cases, representatives of the Anglican, Lutheran, Orthodox, or Reformed traditions. Besides the pas­ sages quoted from bilateral commission documents, relevant sections of the Faith and Order Commission's "Lima text" of 1982 are included. This document is the product of the collaboration of representatives of nearly all major Christian denominations along with the five churches mentioned above. The content of these texts is analyzed and compared with the tradi­ tional theologies of these churches. At least superficially, the way of describing the sanctification of the Eucharistie elements corresponds to the language and theological viewpoint of the Orthodox and Reformed Churches. It is less at home with the Anglo-Catholic, Lutheran, and Roman Catholic traditional theologies. This raises the question about the extent to which an ecumenical agreement has actually been attained, particularly between Orthodox and Roman Catholic theologies; for if the latter theologians can use the same language as the Orthodox and, in turn, do accept the same concept of essential change of bread and wine into the body and blood of Christ as the Orthodox, it would seem that full agreement on the theology of the sanctification of bread and wine is in sight.
    [Show full text]