DOCSLIB.ORG

Department of English Faculty of Graduate Studies London, Ontario

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Department of English Faculty of Graduate Studies London, Ontario "But Clear As Words Can Make Revealing? Arnold's Language and the Struggle for Transparency Dan S. Kline Department of English Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Faculty of Graduate Studies The University of Western Ontario London, Ontario August 1997 @ Dan S. Kline 1997 National Library Bibliothèque nationale (*m ofCanada du Canada Acquisitions and Acquisitions et Bibliographic Services services bibliograohiques 395 Wellington Street 395. rue Wellington Ottawa ON KIA ON4 Ottawa ON K 1A ON4 Canaûa Canada Your Çk, Votie reierenw Our fi& Noire retarence The author has granted a non- L'auteur a accordé une licence non exclusive licence allowing the exclusive permehant à la National Library of Canada to Bibliothèque nationale du Canada de reproduce, loan, distribute or sel1 reproduire, prêter, distribuer ou copies of this thesis in microfom, vendre des copies de cette thèse sous paper or electronic formats. la forme de microfiche/fih, de reproduction sur papier ou sur format électronique. The author retains ownership of the L'auteur conserve la propriété du copyright in ths thesis. Neither the droit d'auteur qui protège cette thèse. thesis nor substantial extracts fkom it Ni la thèse ni des extraits substantiels may be p~tedor otherwise de celle-ci ne doivent être imprimés reproduced without the author's ou autrement reproduits sans son permission. autorisation. Abstract In the 1853 "PrefaceN to the Poems, Matthew Arnold argues that the poet should adopt the "grand style" to assist in the production of a type of poetry that is content-driven. The precise nature and meaning of the "grand style" remains one of the more elusive problems in Arnold scholarship. Despite Arnold's conviction that the idea escapes definition, 1 argue, in this thesis, that the ambiguous and unstable concept of the "grand style" is involved with Arnold's belief in an ideal language characterized by transparency. The poetry of Matthew Arnold is, in many ways, a record of his struggle with this transparent linguistic ideal. Arnold's realization of the need for greater transparency in language and his attempts to achieve it are inf ormed by the work of John Locke in An Essay concerning Human Understanding and Of the Conduct of the Understanding respectively. Locke's sceptical attitude towards language as an effective medium of communication parallels Arnold's discovery of the human, arbitrary, and opaque nature of language in his first volume of poetry, The Strayed Reveller, and Other Poems. However, Arnold's later exposure to Locke's heavily qualified endorsement of particular tropes in Of the Conduct of the Understanding has important implications and consequences for an understanding of the varied use of the simile in Arnold's poetry from the 1850s and 1860s. key words: Matthew Arnold, language, John Locke, simile iii Acknow ledgements I wish to express my deepest gratitude and appreciation to my supervisor, Professor Donald S. Hair. Dr. Hair's patience, erudition, and guidance provided continual assistance and consLant reassurance at every stage of this thesis. It has been a privilege to study with such a mode1 teacher-scholar. Also, 1 am deeply indebted to Professor J. Douglas Kneale, the second reader of this thesis, for his remarkably efficient and helpful editorial advice, as well as his thought provoking questions and suggestions. Finally, 1 am immeasurably grateful to my family for their love and unflagging support and encouragement. TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Certificate of Examination Abstract Acknowledgements Table of Contents Introduction Chapter One: Arnold, Locke, and Language Chapter Two: Fragments Cnapter Three: Tensions Chapter Four: Strategies Chapter Five: '1Thyrsis19 Conclusion Notes Works Cited Vita Introduction The year 1850 is the annus mirabilis for nineteenth- century literature. The appearance of The Prelude and In Memoriam offers readers the seminal poems of the Romantic and Victorian periods respectively. In June of that same year Fraser's Magazine printed a poem entitled t'Mernorial Verses: April 1850t1 by the author of a small, largely unnoticed, volume of poetry published the previous year. The volume was The Strayed Reveller, and Other Poems and its author, the semi-anonymous VIt of the title page, was in the midst of consolidating an embryonic collection of ideas into a coherent and controversial poetics. 1850 is also a critical year for Matthew Arnold in ways 1 shall demonstrate in the next chapter. tlMemor~alVersest' does not share the reputation of poems such as IfThe Forsaken Merman," l'The Scholar Gip~y,~'or ItDover Beach,ttbut it is an important text nevertheless because of Arnold's own comments about it. In a letter to Clough prior to the poem'ç appearance, Arnold mentions that frustratingly elusive and unstable concept which lies at the very centre of his theories of poetry and language: "1 have at Quillinants sollicitation [sic] dirged W. W. in the grand style & need thy rapture therewithu (Lang 172). The "grand style'' remains one of the more ambiguous of Arnold's ideas, a fact which Arnold hirnself acknowledges in On Translating Homer: 2 Alas! the grand style is the last matter in the world for verbal definitionto deal with adequately. One may Say of it as is said of faith: 'One must feel it in ordex to kriow what it is. ' (Super 1: 188)' David Riede has noted the rhetorical inqenuity with which Arnold shifts his own feelings of guiit and responsibility ont0 the reader (22), and even when Arnold does resort to definition the result is unsatisfactory: "1 think it will be found that the grand style arises in poetry, when a noble nature, poetically gifted treats with simplicity or with severity a serious subject'l (Super 1: 188) . 1 would suggest that the most effective way of approaching the "grand style" is through the alembic of Arncld's interest in lanquage. Arnold l s connection with some of the leading linguistic theorists and philoloqists of the day is amply demonstrated by his letters which refer to figures such as F.D. Maurice and Trench and indicate a persona1 acquaintance with Furnivall. Julius Hare was a frequent visitor to Dr. Arnold's widow at Fox How, and Arnold himself cultivated a friendship and correspondence with the German Sanskrit scholar Max Mueller. There are many places in the Arnoldian canon where one might initiate an investiqation into Arnold's language and its relationship to his poetics and the "grand style." David Riede, for example, begins his study of Arnold's language with a close, but not exclusive, analysis of the later religious 3 prose pieces as qlArnold'smost rigorous, rational, systematic thought about languagel' (21) . Riede argues, parsuasively, that Arnold's wdeconstruction of Biblical language makes explicit a distrust of his medium that had undermined his poetry even early in his career" (12). As an alternative to Riede's retrospective approach, 1 prefer to begin in medias res, as it were, throuqh an examination of Arnold's letters and early critical prose. The key texts are the I1Preface1'to the 1853 edition of the Poems, the often passionate polemic about poetry and language he carried on with Clough through their correspondence, and On Translating Honier. 1 think that initiating an investigation of Arnold's lancjuage frorn the early 1850s is im2ortant for many reasons. In the remaininy pages of this Introduction and the chapter that follows 1 hope to demonstrate that the ideas of the 1853 "Preface" and the somewhat later advice of the Homer lectures assume an important place within a particular contour of Arnold's eclectic thought, namely British empiricism and, particularly, the philosophy of John Locke. Additionally, 1 want to emphasize that this particular contour was by no means stable and was itself underqoing a major shift in these years. The usefulness of beginning at precisely the moment of this shift in Arnold's thinking is that it encourages us to look, with a degrce of flexibility, back to the earlier poetry of the 1840s and forward to some of Arnold's greatest poetic triumphs and failures in the next two decades. This particular shift is 4 itself part of a larger turn in both Arnold's poetics (which is inaugurated by the "Preface'?) and biography.' On the eve of the publication of Culture and Anarchy (1869) Arnold wrote to his mother: My poems represent the main movement of mind of the last quarter century, and thus they will probably have their day as people become conscious of what that movement of mind is, and interested in the literary productions which reflect it (Russell 2: 9). It is certainly possible to reduce this "rnovement of mindl to Arnold's career itself by dividing it into periods of poetry and various types of prose. We can even chart certain movements within Arnold's poetry. The publication of The Strayed Reveller, and Other Poems in 1349 primarily collected Arnold's lyrics from the previous decade while the next ten years would witness al1 of his major works in dramatic and narrative poetry, including Empedocles on Etna, Tristram and Iseult, Sohrab and Rustum, Balder Dead, and Merope. In the 1860s Arnold would again concentrate on the lyric mode. These generic and chronological divisions are noteworthy but far from absolute. Indeed, the transitions within this tripartite structure are often characterized by a nebulosity, and some of Arnold's greatest lyric accomplishments, such as "Stanzas from the Grande Chartreuse, "Dover Beach, and IlThe Scholar Gipsy," appear concurrently with the longer works in other genres. The llPrefaceMto the Poems and On Translating Homer are situated in the midst of Arnold's Ifmovement of mind, l1 and it is dif f icult to know how to read them.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Ttu Mac001 000057.Pdf (19.52Mb)
    (Vlatthew flrnold. From the pn/ture in tlic Oriel Coll. Coniinon liooni, O.vford. Jhc Oxford poems 0[ attfiew ("Jk SAoUi: S'ips\i' ani "Jli\j«'vs.'') Illustrated, t© which are added w ith the storv of Ruskin's Roa(d makers. with Glides t© the Country the p©em5 iljystrate. Portrait, Ordnance Map, and 76 Photographs. by HENRY W. TAUNT, F.R.G.S. Photographer to the Oxford Architectural anid Historical Society. and Author of the well-knoi^rn Guides to the Thames. &c., 8cc. OXFORD: Henry W, Taunl ^ Co ALI. RIGHTS REStHVED. xji^i. TAONT & CO. ART PRINTERS. OXFORD The best of thanks is ren(iered by the Author to his many kind friends, -who by their information and assistance, have materially contributed to the successful completion of this little ^rork. To Mr. James Parker, -who has translated Edwi's Charter and besides has added notes of the greatest value, to Mr. Herbert Hurst for his details and additions and placing his collections in our hands; to Messrs Macmillan for the very courteous manner in which they smoothed the way for the use of Arnold's poems; to the Provost of Oriel Coll, for Arnold's portrait; to Mr. Madan of the Bodleian, for suggestions and notes, to the owners and occupiers of the various lands over which •we traversed to obtain some of the scenes; to the Vicar of New Hinksey for details, and to all who have helped with kindly advice, our best and many thanks are given. It is a pleasure when a ^ivork of this kind is being compiled to find so many kind friends ready to help.
    [Show full text]
  • The Hero in the Poetry of Matthew
    THE HERO IN THE POETRY OF MATTHEW ARNOLD APPROVED: v - ~ ' /X / TC. let >»- >- r y\ .. / ' tt: (,ic i f Major Frofessor Minor (Professor Director of eparturient, of English Dean of the Gradual.e Sch<x THE HERO IN THE POETRY OF MATTHEW ARNOLD THESIS Presented to the Graduate Council of the North Texas State University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS By Judith Dianne Mackey, B. A, Denton, Texas August, 1967 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Chapter I. FROM SCEPTICISM TO THE HEROIC CONCEPT: THE QUEST FOR INTELLECTUAL SECURITY .... 1 II. THE GENESIS OF A NEW SYNTHESIS 6 III. MATTHEW ARNOLD: THE EVOLUTION OF A STOIC 35 IV. MATTHEW ARNOLD: THE STOIC SYNTHESIS 62 V. CONCLUSION 113 BIBLIOGRAPHY 123 in CHAPTER I FROM SCEPTICISM TO THE HEROIC CONCEPT: THE QUEST FOR INTELLECTUAL SECURITY The nineteenth century constitutes, in the history of Western ideas, a period during which old beliefs and methods of thinking were questioned and criticized, and new intel- lectual and emotional responses to life were not yet firmly established. "Old institutions were undermined, new scien- tific discoveries appeared to be destroying the foundations of the Christian faith, as it was then conceived, and doubt -i like a grey mist spread over the whole field of thought." Evolutionary theories and Marxian Socialism shook the faith of the educated, and the Oxford Movement vainly attempted to create a new religious sentiment which could withstand the . 2 stress of these revolutionary ideas. In the wake of the destruction of old beliefs and ideas, violent and varying reactions occurred, primarily among the intelligentsia of the day.
    [Show full text]
  • The Scholar-Gipsy Study Material
    The Scholar-Gipsy Study Material Summary “The Scholar-Gipsy” was written by poet and essayist Matthew Arnold in 1853. The poem is based on a story which was found in The Vanity of Dogmatizing (1661), written by Joseph Glanvil. The poem tells the story of a poor and disillusioned Oxford student who leaves university to join a group of traveling “gipsies” (Romani people). The Scholar-Gipsy wants not only to withdraw from his studies but also to withdraw from the modern world. He is so welcomed and becomes such a part of the "gipsy" family that they reveal some of their secrets to him. When he is discovered by two of his former Oxford peers, he tells them of how the Romani have their own unique way of learning. He plans to stay with them to learn as much as he can from them. He will then share their wisdom with the world, although he does not wish to return to that world himself. Arnold begins his poem by describing a rural setting just outside of Oxford. The speaker watches as a shepherd and reapers work in a field there. The speaker remains, enjoying the view of the fields and Oxford in the distance until the sun sets, his book lying beside him. Although the story (1661) was written two hundred years before the poem (1853), local people still claim to see the scholar-gipsy walking on the Berkshire moors: This said, he left them, and return'd no more.— But rumours hung about the country-side, That the lost Scholar long was seen to stray, Seen by rare glimpses, pensive and tongue-tied, In hat of antique shape, and cloak of grey, The same the gipsies wore.
    [Show full text]
  • Unit 5: Matthew Arnold: “Literature and Science”
    Unit 5 Matthew Arnold: “Literature and Science” UNIT 5: MATTHEW ARNOLD: “LITERATURE AND SCIENCE” UNIT STRUCTURE 5.1 Learning Objectives 5.2 Introduction 5.3 Matthew Arnold: Life and Works 5.4 Explanation of the Text 5.5 Major Themes 5.6 Style and Language 5.7 Let us Sum up 5.8 Further Reading 5.9 Answers to Check Your Progress 5.10 Model Questions 5.1 LEARNING OBJECTIVES After reading this unit you will be able to: • describe the life of Matthew Arnold • explain the context of the essay “Literature and Science” • analyse Arnold’s style and language • examine the contributions of Matthew Arnold as an essayist 5.2 INTRODUCTION This unit will give you an introduction to Matthew Arnold and provide you with a detailed study of the man, his life and his works. A detailed synopsis of the essay has also been included in this unit for a better understanding of the interrelation of literature and science. Over and 60 Alternative English (Block 1) Matthew Arnold: “Literature and Science” Unit 5 above, this unit aims to acquaint you with the themes that form a crucial part of the essay. Besides this, the unit shall also discuss the style and the language used by Arnold. 5.3 MATTHEW ARNOLD: LIFE AND WORKS Matthew Arnold has always been rated very highly among English essayist. It was through his essays that Arnold asserted his greatest influence on literature. His writing on the role of literary criticism in society advance classical ideas and advocate the adoption of universal aesthetic standards.
    [Show full text]
  • GIPE-002678-Contents.Pdf (76.15Kb)
    Dhananjayano Gadgil Library Ilumm~u~lmmIIID GIPE-PUNE-002671 POETICAL WORKS 0' MATTHE\V ARNOLD POETICAL WORKS OF MATTHEW ARNOLD l..onbon MACMILLAN AND CO. AND NEW YORK Fl',st Complete Edition printtd September 1890 Rejrz'Hled Novellilur Ilna Dtctmkr 18go. July 18gl, 1892 0/11, I frl'L'2-}( , C. '') (,......,....-- .. ~b7g CONTENTS EARLY POEMS SONNETS- PAGE QUIET WOIlK To A FIlIEND SHAKESPKAIlK WRITTEN IN EMERSON'S ESSAYS 3 WRITTEN IN BUTI.ER'S SERMONS 4 To THB DUKB OF WEI.LlNGTON 4 IN HARMONY WITH NATURE, S To GEORGI!. CRUIKSHANK 6 To A REPUBLICAN FRIEND, 1848 6 CONTINUED 7 RELIGIOUS ISOLATION, 8 MYCERINUS, 8 THE CHURCH OF BROU­ I. TilE CASTI.It 13 II, THI!. CHURCH 17 III. THB TOMB 18 A MODERN SAPPHO 20 REQtJI ESCAT 21 YOUTH AND CALM. 22 viii CONTENTS PAGB A MEMORy-PICTURE 23 A DREAM 25 THE NEW SIRENS 26 THE VOICE _ 36 YOUTH'S AGITATIONS 37 THE WORLD'S TRIUMPHS 38 STAGIRIUS _ 38 HUMAN LIFE 40 To A GIPSY CHILD BY THE SEA-SHORE " 41 A QUESTION 44 IN UTRUMQUE PARATUS 45 THE WORLD AND THE QUIETIST _ 46 HORATIAN ECHO 47 THE SECOND BEST._ 49 CONSOLATION 50 RESIGNATION 52 NARRATIVE POEMS SOHRAB AND RUSTUM THE SICK KING IN BOKHARA BALDER DEAD- 1_ SENDING 101 2. JOURNEY TO THE DEAD III 3. FUNERAL 121 TRISTRAM AND ISEULT­ I. TRISTRAM -. 2. ISEULT OF IRELAND 3. ISEULT OF BRITTANY CONTENTS SAINT BIlANDAN •165 ,liE NECKAN ~;;;~ THE FORSAKEN MEllMAN 170 SONNETS AUSTEIlITY 0 RACHEL:• I, II, III WORLDLY PLACE EAST LoNDON WEST LoNDON EAST AND WEST Tlllt BETTER PART THE DIVINITY IMMORTALITY TilE Goon SHEPHERD WITH THE Km MONICA'S LAST PRAYER /' LYRIC POEMS SWITZEIlLAND- I.
    [Show full text]
  • Thyrsis Matthew Arnold (1822-1888) Is an English Poet and Critic Whose Works Represent the Victorian Intellect. He Was the Forem
    British Literature IV: Unit 3 – Poetry: Thyrsis Matthew Arnold (1822-1888) is an English poet and critic whose works represent the Victorian intellect. He was the foremost literary critic of his age. His poems are written in an elegiac, meditative mode. They cover a wide range of issues like the drawbacks of philosophy, war, death and the downfall of education. Some of his best poems are “The Scholar-Gipsy” (1853) and “Sohrab and Rustum” (1867). “The Study of Poetry” (1880) is his best critical essay in which he explains the Touchstone Method. “Thyrsis” (1866) is a pastoral elegy on the death of Arthur Hugh Clough, poet and his friend who died in 1861. “Thyrsis” is counted one of the best elegies alongside Milton’s Lycidas (1638) and Shelley’s Adonais (1821). A similar pastoral elegy is “Elegy Written on a Country Churchyard” by Thomas Gray. Arnold has borrowed the death of Thyrsis from Virgil’s Seventh Eclogue. In this classical poem, shepherds Thyrsis and Corydon enter a singing contest, in which Corydon wins. Defeat breaks the heart of Thyrsis and he dies. Virgil blames the gods but Arnold believes that Thyrsis made a mistake by taking Corydon as an opponent. Arnold’s Thyrsis is none other than his friend Arthur Hugh Clough, who made a similar mistake of searching for the truth. Arnold begins the poem with an environmental concern. Once his friend Thyrsis and he visited Oxford country and it was green and beautiful. Now, the beautiful landscape is replaced with a busy city. He searches for an elm tree that had been their meeting spot.
    [Show full text]
  • Matthew Arnold's Five Long Poems: a Di Al Ecti Cal Readi N G
    • Matthew Arnold's five long poems: a di al ecti cal readi n g N :l.'ih ira ]\('sl1 av j('t' • ]) (' p!lrtm PH t of English !vleGill University, !\1ontrcal 0('10 he'1' 1fHl:! J\ 'l'IWS1:'' subml1f('d to the fa culty of Graduale Studies and U C8ca rel! in partial fulfillment of tJte 1'cquircmcnt9 fo1' the dcgree of i\L\STEH OF' .ABTS • • 1\lattlH'w .\l'Ilold·~ 11\(, IO!l!!. P('l'lll~ \1('1\' (lIddi"hvd \1,'I\\\'t'11 l~:)~ :111" l~li;. III the:::,e pOl'Il1!"> (/;lrll)t'd()c/('.~ 011 /o;t//tI, li,..... //II/11 Il/Id I.,({,Il. ,"'·Ollll[l! 1[/11/ NlI ..... tIl1/l, Baldcl Deal! and j\ll'/olle) _'\1'1101<1 tlil':"" tu :\ld~/,' :1 1IIlIIlI'I'l' 1'1' 1111'1111':"". li"l' Il:1- Lul'P. IIl0/,;!I \'alul':-..... !)(ll'tk",. :tild thl' pl:II'I' ,dO 'Illtlt(lril~ ill .... (),·\('I~'. III" :\ll:d~:--i .... i:-­ dia\cet.i(,:11, alld OIII' 1l()lin· .... )!,1'l':tI dl .... II'(' ........ :111.1 :111 III'IIl\lit.\ l,) 1\· .... ,,111· thl, .... t· i" sues. 'l'hi!:, t.h('~b l'XilIlliJ\{'!') :\l'Ilo\<J':-, mil! Il:-..i\lll. ;\", \\,t·11 ;l,.... iIh t'\ t' Iltll:ll (':1111\ :t('­ cepiancc of lire ill ail it.s ('01l11'1ldktiol\:--. It ('Olll·llltlt'''' ... lIh .... (·l(IIt'lltl.,· Ih:1t Arnold has a genulue d('sire tn lilld IWI'SI)}lnl dinlC'ctil':\1 ~Ylltl}('s(':-, \\ !t('1'1' [H),-;'nhk . • • HLSL\!L l,l';, ('ITJ<j l()lI~,,~, pfJ('lfl(~<) df' !\1HUIlf'W Arllold t'l1rf'lIt pllhljp~ entre lS,')~ et 1807.
    [Show full text]
  • Sch00l of Distance Educat10n
    UNIVERSITY OF CALiCUT 14 SCH00L OF DISTANCE EDUCAT10N STUDY MATERIALS M.A.ENGLISH (PREVIOUS) (1 997 Adnlissio甲 ) | PAPER Ⅲ BRITISH LITERATURE SURVEV:FROM THE ViCTOR:AN‐ AGE T0 1940 ,Copy Bights Reserued (」 UP/3031/05/1ⅨЮだDE‐ 1 4 B.DRAMA f.力χおルr Sr2の 加D′ralJ PAPER‖ :BR:TiSH L:TERATURE SURVEY IS E‖ ot Murder in The Cathedral FROM THE ViCTOR:AN AGE T0 1940 2.2xお ル ″G′″´rar S餞ゥ G B Shaw St.Joan Max Marks:120 」.M Synge Riders to the Sea Sean O'Casey Juno and the Paycock A POETRY Cristopher Fry The Lady is not for Burning f.■潔Jars滋 のiZ`′ガJ C.PROSE AND FlCT:ON Alfred,Lord Tennyson "The Lotos Eaters" Robert Brown!ng "Andrea Del Sarto" l. Texts for Sturly in detail Matthew Arnold "Dover Beach" Virginia Woolf Modern Fiction Thomas Hardy "The Darkling Thrush" 2. Texts for General Study G M Hopkins 1 . "The Windhover" Matthew Arnold Pretace to 1853 poems 2. "No Worst, there is none" Emily Bronte Wuthering Heights W B Yeats 1."Easter1916" Charles Dickens Hard Times 2. "Among Schoolchildren" George Eliot The Mill one the Floss 3. "Byzantium" Thonas Hardy Mazor of Casterbridge IS E‖ ot "The Love-Song of Alfred Joseph Conrad Heart o, Darkness "Little Gidding" James Joyce A portrait o{ the Artist as a Young Man W H Auden "The Shield of Achilles" D.H.Lawrence Sons and Lovers 2.ル名おル (ル り Virginia Woolf To the Lighthouse 「 "araI Sa“ Robert Browning "Porphyria's Lover" Arno:d "The Scholar-Gypsy" c M Hopkins "Felix Randal" W B Yeats "Lapis Lazuli" Break up: 4 Annotations + 3 Essays + ssh.
    [Show full text]
  • MATTHEW ARNOLD the HEROIC DIMENSIONS THESIS Presented to the Graduate Council of the North Texas State University in Partial
    37/ MATTHEW ARNOLD THE HEROIC DIMENSIONS OF MAN'S BEST SELF THESIS Presented to the Graduate Council of the North Texas State University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS By Connie J. DeShane, B. S. Denton, Texas December, 1973 TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter Page I. INTRODUCTION.. ........ ., 1 The Problem Definition of Terms Sources of Data Method of Procedure Significance of the Problem II. INDUSTRY AND SOCIETY IN THE NINETEENTHCENTURY .. .... ... 13 Scientific and Technological Advances The Social and Political Milieu III. RELIGION AND PHILOSOPHY. 31 The Decline of Traditional Beliefs The Search for New Meaning IV. ROMANCE AND REASON-... .-...... -a 51 V. THE COLLECTIVE SELF. .. 6 7 BIBLIOGRAPHY. , . 80 iii CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION The Problem Matthew Arnold instructed his friend Arthur Hugh Clough: "resolve to be thyself." The quotation is from one of Arnold's own poems of 1850 censuring Clough for his ambiva- lence. The phrase is a synthesis of Socrates' "Know thyself" and Thomas Carlyle's "Know what thou canst work at." In Sartor Resartus Carlyle refuted the possibility of the Socratic imperative, but Arnold's eclecticism permitted him to vary the original in order to accommodate both theories. A study of the poetry reveals what Lionel Trilling calls Arnold's "eclectic and dialectical method."1 This practice of taking the best from existing theories while formulating his own permeates the works of Matthew Arnold. Unlike Clough, who doubted his own teachings and was in a constant flux of opinion, Arnold managed a certain flexi- bility that allowed him to reassess a changing world without nullifying his own basic assumptions.
    [Show full text]
  • Psychological Depths and "Dover Beach" Author(S): Norman N
    Psychological Depths and "Dover Beach" Author(s): Norman N. Holland Source: Victorian Studies, Vol. 9, Supplement (Sep., 1965), pp. 4-28 Published by: Indiana University Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3825594 Accessed: 26-06-2016 20:16 UTC REFERENCES Linked references are available on JSTOR for this article: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3825594?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contents You may need to log in to JSTOR to access the linked references. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://about.jstor.org/terms JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Indiana University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Victorian Studies This content downloaded from 137.99.31.134 on Sun, 26 Jun 2016 20:16:25 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms Norman N. Holland PSYCHOLOGICAL IDEPTHS AND "DOVER BEACH" SYCHOANALYSIS AND LITERARY ANALYSIS have mingled uneasily ever since 15 October 1897, when Freud simultaneously found in himself and in Hamlet "love of the mother and jealousy of the father." Psychoanalysis, it turned out, could say many interesting things about plays and novels. Unfortunately, it did not do at all well with the analysis of poems. In the symbolistic psychoanalysis of 1915 or so, poems became simply assemblages of the masculine or feminine symbols into which psychoanalysis seemed then to divide the world.
    [Show full text]
  • Norse Mythology
    N O R S E M Y T H O L O G Y N E I L G A I M A N W. W. NORTON & COMPANY Independent Publishers Since 1923 New York • London FOR EVERETT, OLD STORIES FOR A NEW BOY. C O N T E N T S An Introduction THE PLAYERS BEFORE THE BEGINNING, AND AFTER YGGDRASIL AND THE NINE WORLDS MIMIR’S HEAD AND ODIN’S EYE THE TREASURES OF THE GODS THE MASTER BUILDER THE CHILDREN OF LOKI FREYA’S UNUSUAL WEDDING THE MEAD OF POETS THOR’S JOURNEY TO THE LAND OF THE GIANTS THE APPLES OF IMMORTALITY THE STORY OF GERD AND FREY HYMIR AND THOR’S FISHING EXPEDITION THE DEATH OF BALDER THE LAST DAYS OF LOKI RAGNAROK: THE FINAL DESTINY OF THE GODS A Glossary A N I N T R O D U C T I O N It’s as hard to have a favorite sequence of myths as it is to have a favorite style of cooking (some nights you might want Thai food, some nights sushi, other nights you crave the plain home cooking you grew up on). But if I had to declare a favorite, it would probably be for the Norse myths. My first encounter with Asgard and its inhabitants was as a small boy, no more than seven, reading the adventures of the Mighty Thor as depicted by American comics artist Jack Kirby, in stories plotted by Kirby and Stan Lee and dialogued by Stan Lee’s brother, Larry Lieber. Kirby’s Thor was powerful and good-looking, his Asgard a towering science fictional city of imposing buildings and dangerous edifices, his Odin wise and noble, his Loki a sardonic horn-helmeted creature of pure mischief.
    [Show full text]
  • Matthew Arnold (1822-88)
    Matthew Arnold (1822-88) Life and character.- Matthew Arnold was born at Laleham, Middlesex, on December 24, and was educated at Winchester, Rugby, and Oxford. In 1847 he became private secretary to Lord Lansdowne, and in 1851 was appointed to an inspectorship of schools, which he held till 1885. From 1857 to 1867 he was professor of poetry at Oxford. He lectured in America in 1883 and 1886. He died on April 15, 1888. Arnold long figured in popular imagination as a superior person, a dilettante apostle of culture, and an elegant and spurious Jeremiah., who was not to be taken too seriously. Certain mannierisms of his prose writings were, in part at least, responsible for this legendary perversion of his personality. He was in fact an earnest, sincere, hard-working, and thoroughly sympathetic man. Works.- His publications in verse are: Poetry.- The Strayed Reveller (1849) Empedocles on Etna (1852) Poems, second series (1855) Merope (1858) New Poems (1867) Prose.- Theoretical: Essays in Criticism (1855 and 1888) Mixed Essays (1879) Discourses in America (1885) On Translating Homer (1861-2) Celtic Literature (1867) Political: English and Italian Question (1859) Culture and Anarchy (1869) Friendship’s Garland (1871) Irish Essays (1882) Religious: Literature and Dogma (1873) St. Paul and Protestantism (1870) God and the Bible (1875) Last Essays on Church and Religion (1877). Views.- In his general conception of poetry the ethical element was in the ascendant. For a poet to be great it is necessary that he shall handle sound subject matter in a spirit of high seriousness. Poetry is “a criticism of life under the conditions fixed for such criticism by the laws of poetic truth and poetic beauty.
    [Show full text]