Diuretic Treatment of Hypertension
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
HYPERTENSION Diuretic Treatment of Hypertension 1 3 EHUD GROSSMAN, MD FABIO ANGELI, MD cerebrovascular disease, combination 2 4 PAOLO VERDECCHIA, MD, FACC, FAHA, FESC GIANPAOLO REBOLDI, MD, PHD, MSC 1 therapy of a diuretic (indapamide) and ARI SHAMISS, MD ACE inhibitor (perindopril) reduced the risk of stroke by 43% compared with pla- cebo. Perindopril alone, despite lowering systolic BP by 5 mmHg, decreased stroke lthough thiazide and thiazide-like multiple-drug combinations in patients risk only by a nonsignificant 5%. diuretics are indispensable drugs in with resistant hypertension. The main Several studies attested to the supe- A fi the treatment of hypertension, their argument that will be discussed is the rior ef cacy of diuretic therapy over other role as first-line or even second-line drugs place of diuretics as first-line drugs or add- antihypertensive agents in reducing the is a provoking debate. on drugs in the context of the available risk for stroke (4–6,8,10,11). In the Sec- The European Society of Cardiology/ antihypertensive armamentarium. ond Australian National Blood Pressure European Society of Hypertension (ESC/ The pro side of the controversy will Study (ANBP2) (10), fatal stroke occurred ESH) guidelines recommend that thiazide argue that diuretics should remain the two times more in patients treated with an diuretics should be considered as suitable preferred drugs for initial treatment in ACE inhibitor than in patients treated as b-blockers, calcium antagonists, ACE many hypertensive patients, whereas the with a diuretic. In the Antihypertensive inhibitors, and angiotensin receptor cons side will contend that emerging and Lipid-Lowering Treatment to Prevent blockers for the initiation and mainte- evidence from outcome-based studies is Heart Attack Trial (ALLHAT) (4,5), chlor- nance of antihypertensive treatment (1). casting doubt on the role of these drugs as thalidone was superior to the a-blocker Another European position, en- first-line and even second-line antihyper- doxazosin mesylate in the prevention of dorsed by the British Hypertension Soci- tensive treatment. stroke and was superior to the ACE inhib- ety, is that diuretics and calcium channel itor lisinopril in the prevention of stroke blockers should be first-line drugs in THE PRO SIDE—Lowering blood in black individuals. In the Medical Re- hypertensive patients aged $55 years pressure (BP) has been shown to reduce search Council (MRC) study in 1985, or black patients of any age, whereas the risk of cardiovascular (CV) morbidity bendrofluazide was documented to be al- ACE inhibitors (or angiotensin receptor and mortality. The main benefitoflow- most three times as efficacious as the blockers in the case of intolerance to ering BP is due to the reduction in the risk b-blocker propranolol hydrochloride in ACE inhibitors) should be first-line of stroke and heart failure (HF). In many preventing stroke (8). In the MRC trial drugs in hypertensive patients younger trials in which a reduction in CV events in elderly patients (6), hydrochlorothia- than 55 years of age (http://nice.org.uk/ was documented, antihypertensive ther- zide and amiloride reduced the risk of CG034guidance). apy was diuretic-based (3–8). stroke, whereas b-blockers failed to re- The Seventh Report of the Joint Na- duce the risk of stroke despite a similar tional Committee (JNC VII) on Prevention, Effect of diuretic treatment on lowering of BP. In the International Nifed- Detection, Evaluation, and Treatment of stroke morbidity and mortality ipine GITS Study: Intervention as a Goal High Blood Pressure recommends that In the era of placebo-controlled trials, in Hypertension Treatment (INSIGHT), thiazide diuretics should be preferred several studies attested to the efficacy of 25 mg hydrochlorothiazide plus amiloride drugs in “most” hypertensive patients, ei- diuretics in reducing stroke morbidity 2.5 were as effective as 30 mg nifedipine for ther alone or combined with drugs from and mortality (6,7). In a recent published preventing stroke (12). other classes (2). study from China, indapamide given to In a large meta-analysis, including The present review does not intend to patients with a history of stroke or tran- 48,220 patients, Psaty et al. (13) found negate the important role of diuretics in sient ischemic attack reduced the risk of that high-dose diuretic therapy reduced certain groups of patients (blacks, salt- stroke by 31% (3). In the Perindopril the risk of stroke by 51%, whereas ther- sensitive patients, concomitant heart Protection Against Recurrent Stroke apy with b-blockers reduced the risk by failure) or to underestimate their role in Study (PROGRESS) (9) in patients with only 29% (P = 0.02). Klungel et al. (14) showed that among 1,237 single-drug ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc users with no history of CV disease, the From the 1Internal Medicine D and Hypertension Unit, The Chaim Sheba Medical Center, Tel-Hashomer, adjusted risk of ischemic stroke was 2 to affiliated with the Sackler School of Medicine, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv, Israel; the 2Divisione di Me- 2 1/2 times higher among users of dicina, Ospedale di Assisi, Assisi, Italy; the 3Struttura Complessa di Cardiologia, Ospedale S. Maria della b-blockers, calcium antagonists, or ACE Misericordia, Perugia, Italy; and the 4Dipartimento di Medicina Interna, Università di Perugia, Perugia, Italy. inhibitors than among users of a diuretic Corresponding author: Paolo Verdecchia, [email protected]. alone. Interestingly, even in patients with This publication is based on the presentations at the 3rd World Congress on Controversies to Consensus in Diabetes, Obesity and Hypertension (CODHy). The Congress and the publication of this supplement were CV disease, diuretics still conferred a lower made possible in part by unrestricted educational grants from AstraZeneca, Boehringer Ingelheim, Bristol- stroke risk than other drugs, although Myers Squibb, Daiichi Sankyo, Eli Lilly, Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Generex Biotechnology, F. Hoffmann-La the difference was considerably smaller. Roche, Janssen-Cilag, Johnson & Johnson, Novo Nordisk, Medtronic, and Pfizer. The recent Avoiding Cardiovascular DOI: 10.2337/dc11-s246 © 2011 by the American Diabetes Association. Readers may use this article as long as the work is properly Events Through Combination Therapy cited, the use is educational and not for profit, and the work is not altered. See http://creativecommons.org/ in Patients Living With Systolic Hyper- licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ for details. tension (ACCOMPLISH) trial showed care.diabetesjournals.org DIABETES CARE, VOLUME 34, SUPPLEMENT 2, MAY 2011 S313 Diuretics in hypertension that a combination of the ACE inhibitor studies showed the efficacy of diuretics and that this protective effect disappears benazepril with hydrochlorothiazide was in reducing CV morbidity and mortality within 4 months after use is discontinued. less effective in lowering the risk of the in the elderly (6,7,16,19). In the Systolic Thus, in addition to their use to lower BP, predefinedprimaryendpointsthanthe Hypertension in the Elderly Program thiazide plays a major role in the preven- combination of benazepril with amlodipine (SHEP) (7), chlorthalidone reduced in el- tion of osteoporosis and fractures. (15). However, analysis of the benefitfor derly patients with isolated systolic hy- Diuretic therapy can transform non- the individual components of the pri- pertensiontherateoftotalstrokeby dippers to dippers and thereby offer an mary end points showed that, for stroke 36%, the rate of major CV events by additional therapeutic advantage of re- prevention, hydrochlorothiazide and 32%, and the rate of all-cause mortality ducing the risk of CV complications (25). amlodipine were the same. Thus, for stroke by 13%. We have shown in a meta-analysis prevention, a diuretic is superior to some that in the elderly, diuretics are more ef- Diuretic-induced glucose elevations antihypertensive agents. fective than b-blockers in lowering BP Several studies showed that use of thia- (20). Moreover, only diuretics reduced zide diuretic increases glucose levels Effect of diuretic treatment on HF the risk of coronary heart disease and all- (4,12,26), but in these studies, the second Thiazide diuretic is very effective in pre- cause mortality (20). The ALLHAT study, drug was a b-blocker that impaired glu- venting the development of HF in hyper- which showed superiority of diuretics cose metabolism. The Atherosclerosis tensive patients. In a large meta-analysis over other antihypertensive agents in Risk in Communities (ARIC) study as- that included 18 long-term placebo- some secondary end points (see above), sessed the incidence of new-onset diabe- controlled randomized trials, high-dose was not defined as a study of the elderly, tes (NOD) after 3 and 6 years in 12,550 diuretic therapy reduced the risk of HF by but 57.5% of the participants were age adults who did not have diabetes. Patients 83% and low-dose diuretic reduced the $65 years; therefore, this study is con- who received thiazide diuretics were not risk of HF by 42% (13). In the Hyperten- sidered a study in the elderly (4,5). The at greater risk for the subsequent devel- sion in the Very Elderly Trial (HYVET), only exception was the ANBP2 study, in opment of diabetes than the subjects with indapamide reduced the rate of HF by which treatment with an ACE inhibitor in hypertension who were not receiving any 64% in very elderly patients with hyper- older subjects, particularly men, led to antihypertensive therapy (27). In this tension (16). In INSIGHT, diuretic was better outcomes than treatment with di- study, only subjects with hypertension more effective than nifedipine in prevent- uretic agents, despite similar reductions who were taking b-blockers had a 28% ing nonfatal HF (12). In the ALLHAT of BP (10). It is noteworthy that the design higher risk of subsequent diabetes. In study, chlorthalidone was superior to of the ANBP2 study was less rigorous than the ACCOMPLISH study, the effects of doxazosin, lisinopril, and amlodipine in other studies, since it was a prospective, the two treatment arms on glucose levels preventing HF (4,5).