A Comparative Ecocritical Study of Pakistani and American Fiction in English
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TRANSGEOGRAPHICAL ECOSENSITIVITY: A COMPARATIVE ECOCRITICAL STUDY OF PAKISTANI AND AMERICAN FICTION IN ENGLISH By Monazza Nazir Makhdoom NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF MODERN LANGUAGES, ISLAMABAD September, 2016 Transgeographical Ecosensitivity: A Comparative Ecocritical Study of Pakistani and American Fiction in English By Monazza Nazir Makhdoom M. Phil., National University of Modern Languages, Islamabad 2009 A TH ESIS SUBMITTED IN P ARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY In English To FACULTY OF LANGUAGES NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF MODERN LANGUAGES, ISLAMABAD @Monazza Nazir Makhdoom, 2016 ii NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF MODERN LANGUAGES FACULTY OF HIGHER STUDIES DISSERTATION AND DEFENSE APPROVAL FORM The undersigned certify that they have read the following thesis, examined the defence, are satisfied with the overall exam performance, and recommend the thesis to the Faculty of Advanced Integrated Studies & Research for acceptance: Thesis Title: Transgeographical Ecosensitivity: A Comparative Ecoritical Study of Pakistani and American Fiction in English Submitted By: Monazza Nazir Makhdoom Registration # : 396-PhD/Lit/Aug11 Doctor of Philosophy Degree Name English (Literature) Name of Discipline Dr. Munazza Yaqoob ________________________ Name of Research Supervisor Signature of Research Supervisor Prof. Dr. Muhammad Safeer Awan ____________________ Name of DeL) an (FO Signature of Dean (FHS) Maj Gen. (R) Muhammad Jaffar HI (M) ___________________ Name of Rector Signature of Rector __________________ Date iii CANDIDATE DECLARATION FORM I Monazza Nazir Makhdoom Daughter of Makhdoom Nazir Ahmed Registration # 396-PhD/Lit/Aug11 Discipline English Literature Candidate of Doctor of Philosophy at the National University of Modern Languages do hereby declare that the thesis Transgeographical Ecosensitivity: A Comparative Ecocritical Study of Pakistani and American Fiction in English submitted by me in partial fulfillment of PhD degree, is my original work, and has not been submitted or published earlier. I also solemnly declare that it shall not, in future, be submitted by me for obtaining any other degree from this or any other university or institution. I also understand that if evidence of plagiarism is found in my thesis/dissertation at any stage, even after the award of a degree, the work may be cancelled, and the degree revoked ______________________________ ______________ Signature of Candidate Date MONAZZA. N. MAKHDOOM ______________________________ Name of Candidate iv ABSTRACT Thesis Title: TRANSGEOGRAPHICAL ECOSENSITIVITY: A COMPARATIVE ECOCRITICAL STUDY OF PAKISTANI AND AMERICAN FICTION IN ENGLISH This comparative study aims to explore how different cultures understand and represent environment and nature in their respective discourse. Four texts are selected for the study: Moth Smoke, Trespassing, White Noise and A Thousand Acres for an in-depth analysis. Examining the material and discursive areas of environmental exploitation and injustice across different regions, the selected Pakistani and American texts in this study are interpreted in a transgeographical context. It is argued, the difference in perception of environmentalism in different fictions, originate in large-scale political and economic processes that give rise to most social and environmental problems in regions that are in the global south like Pakistan. American environmentalism on the contrary, that is originally founded on deep ecology and nature conservationist paradigm, saw a fundamental shift in the late twentieth century and deviated at a mystifying pace and emerged with a new paradigm with radical environmental criticism of capitalist consumerism and ecological toxic contamination which is manifested in American novels like White Noise and A Thousand Acres. By creating a dialogue between ecocritical and postcolonial theory, the study seeks to address how the selected fictions are interweaved with human and environmental history, thus subtly alluding to ecological and cultural sensibilities and underscore a very different vision of human relationships to the environment in Pakistani and American English fiction. In doing so, the selected texts also foreground that there are significant discrepant political, historical and social features across the variety of environmentalist perspectives. These varying perceptions emphasize a sense of place as a basic prerequisite for environmental awareness. Furthermore, by paying attention to the style, linguistic and visual topographies of the selected texts this comparative study also establishes how environmental degradation manifested as pollution, chemicals toxins, contamination and unbound consumption disrupts the human – ecology, alters the environment, and complicates human and nonlife life forms. I draw upon Lawrence Buell’s notion on “Toxic Discourse” in Moth Smoke and White Noise which are examined to show how enviornmental degradation represent a toxic and fractured world due to consumption and neoliberal capitalism. On the other hand, a planetary and cosmopolitan vision is also explored by focusing on texts like Trespassing and A Thousand Acres which are significant to trace “cultural imagination from a sense of place to a less territorial and more systematic sense of planet” (Hesie 56). Both novels reflect how different communities and individuals negotiate the relationship between what Heise terms as local and global networks of economics and culture while also considering their exposure to risk scenarios. An explication of these various environmental scenarios underscore that the multiple varieties of ecosystems from the global North and the global South in their respective socio-cultural spheres are by no means holistic, utopian or harmonious in any sense, but each, on the contrary, emphasises the possibility of rapidly growing environmental risks affecting the ecology as well those inhabiting that environment. While their similarities are tied together by a thematic unity as manifestations of various environmental visions that communicate a planetary heightened environmental awareness in the contemporary society, their differences accentuate that within each of these competing discourses there exists a fundamental difference that is specific to their historical, cultural and material conditions and require attention when exploring environmentalism in a transgeographical context. v DEDICATION In memory of my parents vi ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS My sincere gratitude and fist and immediate debt is owed to my supervisor Prof. Dr Munazza Yaqoob for her support and guidance. I was also fortunate to have a loving friend and colleague, Dr. Uzma, whose constant unfaltering support, and valuable discussions and encouragement sustained me throughout my research and study. My family and my friend Uzma Anjum can never be forgotten for their patience and constant encouragement, especially my father (late), who always believed that I can do it despite my moments of dejection. I am thankful to all those who were a part of this project. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter ................................................................................... Page THESIS AND DEFENCE APPROVAL FORM ................................................................iii CANDIDATE DECLARATION FORM ......................................................................... iv ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................ v DEDICATION ............................................................................................................... vi ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS ...............................................................................................viii I INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 1 1.1 Statement of the Problem .................................................................... 2 1.2 Research Questions ............................................................................. 3 1.3 Objectives of the Study ....................................................................... 3 1.4 The Criterion for Selecting Texts......................................................... 3 1.5 Delimitation ........................................................................................ 4 1.6 Defining Transgeographical Ecosensitivity ...................................... 5 1.7 Important themes and Focus…………………………………………. 8 1.7.1 Pollution and Contamination…………………………………….8 1.7.2 Consumerism .............................................................................. 8 1.7.3 Ecocosmoplitanism…………………………………. ………… .9 1.7.4 Capitalism and Environment…………………………………… 9 1.8 Background of the Study…………………………………. ………… 10 1.8.1 Discourse on Environment- Pakistan ........................................ 14 1.8.2 Resistance and Imperialism…………………………………… 17 1.9 Anglo-American Nature Paradigm……………………………………20 1.9.1 Pastoral..................................................................................... 20 1.9.2 The American Pastoral Tradition……………………………… 21 1.9.3 The British Pastoral Tradition ………………………………… 22 1.9.4 Wilderness Trope …………………………………. ………… 23 1.9.5 The Contradiction in Wilderness Narrative ............................... 25 1.10 Thesis Breakdown ............................................................................ 28 1.11 Rationale and Significance