DOCSLIB.ORG

Bessarion’Sdateofbirth: Anew Assessment of the Evidence Abstract: the Cardinal Bessarion Was Aforemost Figure of the Italian Renaissance and Late Byzantium

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Bessarion’Sdateofbirth: Anew Assessment of the Evidence Abstract: the Cardinal Bessarion Was Aforemost Figure of the Italian Renaissance and Late Byzantium DOI 10.1515/bz-2018-0017 BZ 2018; 111(3): 641–658 Scott Kennedy Bessarion’sdateofbirth: anew assessment of the evidence Abstract: The cardinal Bessarion was aforemost figure of the Italian Renaissance and late Byzantium. However,some of the details of his life are not yetsecurely established, especiallyhis dateofbirth. Over the lastcentury,scholars have pro- posed dates rangingfrom 1400 to 1408. In this study, Icriticallyinterrogatethe two most commonlyaccepted dates (1400 and 1408). In the past,scholars have relied on the agerequirementsofcanon laworthe testimonyofItalian observers to determine Bessarion’sage.Bycritically examining the validity of these two as- sumptions, Ireprioritize the evidence,approximating the cardinal’syear of birth as 1403. Adresse: Dr.Scott Kennedy,Bilkent University,Main Campus, GBuilding, 224/g, 06800 Bilkent–Ankara, Turkey;[email protected] Striding the boundary between East and West,Greek and Latin, the cardinal Bes- sarion (d. 1472) was amajor figure in the transmission of Greek learning to the Latin West.¹ Born in Trebizond (mod. Trabzon) on the Black Sea coast,Bessarion In preparing thisarticle forpublication, Ihaveincurred adebt of gratitude to anumber of schol- ars. Thanksare due to Anthony Kaldellis forhis usual editorial wisdom and foralerting me of Evangelos Chrysos’sarticle on prematureordinations in the Middle Byzantine period. Alice MaryTalbot helpfully discussed thisarticle with me on multiple occasionsasIprepared my forthcoming translation of Bessarion’sencomium of Trebizond and Panaretos’schronicle of the emperors of Trebizondwiththe Dumbarton OaksMedieval Library. She also shared with me her pioneeringwork on Akakios Sabbaites. Finally,Iowe adebt of gratitude to Byzantinische Zeitschrift’sanonymous reviewers whose comments and corrections much improved this article. Thereisnofull biographyofBessarion in English. Forabrief summary of his life, see A.M. Talbot,Bessarion. ODB , .The standardscholarlybiographies areL.Mohler,Kardinal Bessarion als Theologe, Humanist und Staatsmann. Paderborn ,vol. ;L.Labowsky,Bes- sarione. Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani () –.For his life up to ,E.Mioni, Vita del cardinale Bessarione. MiscellaneaMarciana () –,issuperior.There is also arecentbiographybyG.L.Coluccia,Basilio Bessarione:lospiritogreco el’Occidente. Florence .For abrief outline of his life, M. Zorzi,Cenni sulla vita elafiguradel cardinale Bessar- ione, in A. Cuna /A.Gatti /S.Ricci (eds.), Bessarione el’Umanesimo:catalogo della mostra. Venice , –. Brought to you by | Ohio State University Libraries Authenticated Download Date | 9/23/18 10:51 AM 642 Byzantinische Zeitschrift Bd. 111/3, 2018: I. Abteilung playedakeyrole at the council of Ferrara-Florencein1438 – 1439asaspokesper- son for the Eastern Orthodoxdelegation. After the union of the Orthodox and Catholic Churches was ratified, Bessarion joined the Catholic Church as acardi- nal, and almostbecame pope in 1455. Bessarion wasakeyfigure in the Italian Renaissance. His libraryofrare Greek manuscripts, studiously acquired after the Turkish conquest of Constantinople in 1453, now forms the coreofthe Greek holdingsofthe Bibliotheca Marciana. During the 1460s, Bessarion was also engagedinwhat modern scholars have deemed one of the great literary de- bates of the centurywith George of Trebizond over whether PlatoorAristotle’s philosophybetter conformed to Christian belief. The fruit of this dispute was Bes- sarion’sfamous Refutation of Blasphemies against Plato (In Calumniatorem Pla- tonis), which opened the door to the studyofPlato in the West.² As one of the first bookseverprinted on the printing press,the Refutation profited from the power of this new technology to swaypublic opinion.³ As acentral playerinthe Renaissance,Bessarion has naturallyinspired a large amount of scholarlyinterest.Nevertheless, some issues still remainopen in his biography. The cardinal’sdate of birth has been the subject of considerable scholarlydiscussion over the lastcentury,with datespostulated thatrangefrom 1400 to 1408. Opinion has varied and awide variety of evidence has been mar- shalled in support of each proposal, but no consensus has emerged. This study will criticallyreexamine previous arguments for the cardinal’sdateofbirth through arigorous analysis of the sourcematerial.Inthe first section of this paper,Iwill review the debate up to this point,outlining the major evidence and arguments on which they base their claims. In the following sections, I will then test the strength of these theses against other contemporary data. It will be shown that the two most commonlyaccepted dates for Bessarion’s birth (1400 and 1408) are built on shaky foundations. By reprioritizingthe exist- ing evidence, this paper will suggest abetter approximation of Bessarion’sdate of birth, namely1403. 1. Historyofthe question Since the nineteenth century,scholars have put forward threemajor hypotheses regardingBessarion’sdate of birth. The oldest and now generallyleast accepted L. Mohler,Kardinal Bessarion,vol. .Paderborn .For the debateingeneral, J. Hankins, Platointhe Italian Renaissance. Leiden . Zorzi,Cenni (as footnote above) . Brought to you by | Ohio State University Libraries Authenticated Download Date | 9/23/18 10:51 AM S. Kennedy,Bessarion’sdateofbirth 643 position derivesfrom aLatinobit at the end of Niccolò Capranica’seulogyofBes- sarion that states, “Vixit Nicenus annis 69,mensibus 10,diebus 16.” Based on this calculation, Bessarion’slate-nineteenth-centurybiographer Henri Vast neatlycalculated Bessarion’sdateofbirth as January 2, 1403,given thatBessa- rion died on November 18, 1472.⁴ Thetidiness of this date has acertain appeal about it,and it is what one finds in some of the morereadilyaccessiblereference works,such as volume 1ofLudwigMohler’sseminal KardinalBessarion (1923) and LotteLabowsky’sentry in the Dizionario biografico degliItaliani (1967). But as the twentieth centuryworeon, scholars pushed back against this date. The now most commonlyaccepted position derivesfrom an idea first ad- vanced by PierreIoannou and then independentlydeveloped by Henri Saffrey in an influential article on the autograph manuscripts of Bessarion.⁵ It runs like this. Canon 14 of the Quinisext Council in Trullo (691–692A.D.) forbade men from being ordained deacons or priestsuntil theyhad reached the ages of 25 and 30,respectively,under pain of being removed from office.⁶ Saffrey be- lieved thattwelfth-century Byzantine commentaries on canon lawbyAlexios Aristenos,John Zonaras,and Theodore Balsamon indicatedthatthe Byzantines strictlyenforced and respectedthe canon in the fifteenth century.Theywould not have unlawfullyordained the futurecardinal. Since Bessarion himself, in his curriculum vitae scribbled into Venice, Marc. Zan. gr.14(=Marcianus 395), tells us the dates at which he obtained the deaconship and priesthood (Decem- ber 1425 and October 1430,respectively), then his date of birth must fall in 1399/ 1400.⁷ This date has enjoyedwide acceptance and is even included in the Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium’sentry on Bessarion.⁸ In 1992, John Monfasani assembled and reviewed the vast bodyofdata that Bessarion and his contemporaries provided about his ageinorder to arrive at a new approximation.⁹ Although previous scholarship had doubted the authentic- H. Vast,LeCardinal Bessarion.Paris , . P. Ioannou,Unopuscule inédit du cardinale Bessarion: le panégyrique de Saint Bessarion anachorète égyptien. Analecta Bollandiana () note ;H.Saffrey,Recherches sur quelques autographes du Cardinal Bessarion,in: Mélanges Eugène Tisserant. Vatican City , –. Ed. H. Ohme,Concilium Constantinopolitanum a. / in Trullo habitum. ACC, /.Berlin , . The Greek text is published in Saffrey,Recherches (as footnote above) –;see also P. Schreiner,Die byzantinischen Kleinchroniken I. CFHB, /.Vienna , –. Talbot,Bessarion (as footnote above) . J. Monfasani,Platina, Capranica, and Perotti: Bessarion’sLatin eulogists and his dateof birth, in M. Cortesi /E.V.Maltese (eds.), BartolomeoSacchi Il Platina (Piadena –Roma ): Atti del Convegno internazionale (Trento, – ottobre ). Naples , –. Brought to you by | Ohio State University Libraries Authenticated Download Date | 9/23/18 10:51 AM 644 Byzantinische Zeitschrift Bd. 111/3, 2018: I. Abteilung ity of Capranica’sobit of Bessarion, Monfasani proved that Bessarion’seulogist Capranica or anear contemporary authored the obit.However,hedoubtedthat Capranica actuallyknew how old Bessarion was when he died. Respondingto the Ioannou/Saffrey hypothesis, he argued thatthe canonicalage-requirement would have been followed onlyinanideal society and not the real world of late Byzantium, though he does not offer anyevidence to support this position.¹⁰ Instead, he builds his case upon the evidence of Bessarion’scontemporaries. For example, Bessarion’sfriend and Latin ghostwriter Niccolò Perotti states,inthe prefacetohis translation of Bessarion’sfuneral oration for Manuel II Palaiologos (1391–1425), that Bessarion was not yettwenty (nondum vigesimum aetatis suae annum ingressus)when he wrotethis piece.¹¹ As Perotti was the author of alarge two-volume biographyofBessarion, now lost,this data clearly should not have been neglected in favorofthe Ioannou/Saffrey hypothesis. Under their hypoth- esis, Bessarion would have been approximatelytwenty-five when he wroteMan- uel’sfuneral oration in 1425.The editor of Perotti’spreface, Giovanni Mercati, had alreadynoted this problem and suggested thatBessarion’sdateofbirth probablyfell around 1406.¹² But Monfasani
Load more

Recommended publications
  • World Without End Nicholas of Cusa's View of Time And
    WORLD WITHOUT END NICHOLAS OF CUSA’S VIEW OF TIME AND ETERNITY Matthieu van der Meer* In his preface to the first printed edition of Apuleius’ works, Giovanni Andrea Bussi, librarian of the Vatican Library, praised his former patron Cardinal Nicholas of Cusa (1401-1464) as a connoisseur, not only of authors from an- cient times, but also from the media tempestas.1 Until recently, Bussi’s remark was considered to be the first witness of Renaissance self-awareness.2 No doubt, many authors (e.g. Petrarch, Salutati, Bruni) at that time were striving for the realisation of a new concept of man in which human dependence on God (oratio) and independence through man’s own rational powers (ratio) were united.3 Subsequently, the study of what it means to be human, the studia hu- manitatis, changed the traditional curricula and opened new intellectual hori- zons. Even if Bussi’s phrase media tempestas is less new than it has been pre- sumed to be, it characterises Nicholas of Cusa as a figure at the crossroads of the middle ages and the age of humanism.4 Ever since the renewed interest in * The author wishes to thank Anthony Lewis, Daniel O’Connell and Albrecht Diem for their comments. 1 M. Miglio, Giovanni Andrea Bussi. Prefazioni alle edizioni di Sweynheym e Pan- nartz (Milan, 1978), p. 17: “Vir ipse, quod rarum est in Germanis, supra opinionem elo- quens et latinus, historias idem omnes non priscas modo, sed mediae tempestatis, tum veteres, tum recentiores usque ad nostra temp ora, memoria, retinebat”. 2 T.
    [Show full text]
  • Stony Brook University
    SSStttooonnnyyy BBBrrrooooookkk UUUnnniiivvveeerrrsssiiitttyyy The official electronic file of this thesis or dissertation is maintained by the University Libraries on behalf of The Graduate School at Stony Brook University. ©©© AAAllllll RRRiiiggghhhtttsss RRReeessseeerrrvvveeeddd bbbyyy AAAuuuttthhhooorrr... The Civic Virtue of Women in Quattrocento Florence A Dissertation Presented by Christine Contrada to The Graduate School in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History Stony Brook University May 2010 Copyright by Christine Contrada 2010 Stony Brook University The Graduate School Christine Contrada We, the dissertation committee for the above candidate for the Doctor of Philosophy degree, hereby recommend acceptance of this dissertation. Dr. Alix Cooper – Dissertation Advisor Associate Professor, History Dr. Joel Rosenthal – Chairperson of Defense Distinguished Professor Emeritus, History Dr. Gary Marker Professor, History Dr. James Blakeley Assistant Professor, History St. Joseph’s College, New York This dissertation is accepted by the Graduate School. Lawrence Martin Dean of the Graduate School ii Abstract of the Dissertation The Civic Virtue of Women in Quattrocento Florence by Christine Contrada Doctor of Philosophy in History Stony Brook University 2010 Fifteenth century Florence has long been viewed as the epicenter of Renaissance civilization and a cradle of civic humanism. This dissertation seeks to challenge the argument that the cardinal virtues, as described by humanists like Leonardo Bruni and Matteo Palmieri, were models of behavior that only men adhered to. Elite men and women alike embraced the same civic ideals of prudence, justice, fortitude, and temperance. Although they were not feminists advocating for social changes, women like Alessandra Strozzi, Margherita Datini, and Lucrezia Tornabuoni had a great deal of opportunity to actively support their own interests and the interests of their kin within popular cultural models of civic virtue.
    [Show full text]
  • Cusanus, on Learned Igorance-17Z8dxd
    On Learned Ignorance Harries 1 Karsten Harries Nicholas of Cusa On Learned Ignorance Seminar Notes Fall Semester 2015 Yale University Copyright Karsten Harries On Learned Ignorance Harries 2 Contents 1. Introduction 3 Book One 2. Learned Ignorance 17 3. The Coincidence of Opposites 30 4. The Threat of Pantheism 47 5. The Power of Mathematics 61 6. Naming God 76 Book Two 7. The Shape of the Universe 90 8. Matter and Becoming 105 9. The Condition of the Earth 118 Book Three 10. The Need for Christ 131 11. Death and Resurrection 146 12. Faith and Understanding 162 13. Death, Damnation, and the Church 176 On Learned Ignorance Harries 3 1. Introduction 1 Many philosophers today have become uneasy about what philosophy has become and where it has led us. Nietzsche and Heidegger, Derrida and Rorty are just a few names. Their uneasiness mirrors widespread concern about the shape of our modern culture. As more and more begin to suspect that the road on which we have been travelling may be a dead end, attempt are made to retrace steps taken; a search begins for missed turns and for those who may have misled us. Among these Descartes has long occupied a special place as the thinker whose understanding of proper method helped found modern philosophy, science, and indeed the shape of our technological world. It is thus to be expected that attempts to question modernity, to confront it, in order perhaps to take a step beyond it, should have often taken the form of attempts to confront Descartes or Cartesian rationality.
    [Show full text]
  • Images of Homeric Manuscripts from the Biblioteca Marciana1
    2008 Annual Conference of CIDOC Athens, September 15 – 18, 2008 Christopher W. Blackwell IMAGES OF HOMERIC MANUSCRIPTS FROM THE BIBLIOTECA MARCIANA1 Christopher W. Blackwell Classics University or Organization: Furman University Address: 3300 Poinsett Highway Greenville, SC 29609 USA E-Mail: [email protected] URL: http://chs.harvard.edu/chs/homer_multitext Abstract This paper describes the manuscript Marcianus Graecus Z.454 (=822), the “Venetus A” and the work of capturing high-resolution digital images of its folios. The manuscripts is a masterpiece of 9th Century “information technology”, combing a primary text, the Homeric Iliad, with secondary texts in the form of scholiastic notes, and other metadata in the form of critical signs. Thus the images of this manuscript provide wide access to an invaluable window into two millennia of the history of the Homeric tradition. INTRODUCTION In May of 2007 an international team of Classicists, conservators, photographers, and imaging experts came together in the Biblioteca Marciana—the Library of St. Mark—in Venice, in order to bring to light a cultural treasure that had been hidden away for over 100 years. The Venetus A manuscript of the Iliad (Marcianus Gr. Z. 454 [=822]), the 1 The following paper is about a collaborative project, of which I am one of four primary editors. We have worked together to produce a number of presentations and publications connected to the project over the past year, including the forthcoming book: Recapturing a Homeric Legacy: Images and Insights from the Venetus A Manuscript of the Iliad. For this reason, this paper should be considered to be co-authored by Casey Dué, Mary Ebbott, and Neel Smith.
    [Show full text]
  • Papst Und Kardinalskolleg Im Bannkreis Der Konzilien – Von Der Wahl Martins V
    Sonderdrucke aus der Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg JÜRGEN DENDORFER / CLAUDIA MÄRTL Papst und Kardinalskolleg im Bannkreis der Konzilien – von der Wahl Martins V. bis zum Tod Pauls II. (1417-1471) Originalbeitrag erschienen in: Jürden Dendorfer/Ralf Lützelschwab (Hrsg.): Geschichte des Kardinalats im Mittelalter (Päpste und Papsttum 39). Stuttgart: Hiersemann, 2011, S. 335-397. Papst und Kardinalskolleg im Bannkreis der Konzilien – von der Wahl Martins V. bis zum Tod Pauls II. (1417–1471) von Jürgen Dendorfer / Claudia Märtl Mit der Wahl Kardinal Oddo Colonnas zu Papst Martin V. auf dem Konstanzer Konzil endete im Jahr 1417 die Kirchenspaltung1. Es begann ein neuer Abschnitt in der Geschichte des Papsttums, den die kirchengeschichtliche Forschung mit dem Schlagwort «Restauration» gekennzeichnet hat. Der mühsame Weg zur Wiederge- winnung des Kirchenstaats nach den Entwicklungen der avignonesischen Zeit, vor allem aber der Anspruch, das Papsttum und die Kurie wieder als unangefochtenen Bezugspunkt einer geeinten Kirche zu etablieren, prägen die nachfolgenden Jahr- zehnte. Dieser Prozess der erneuerten Durchsetzung päpstlicher Autorität vollzog sich in spannungsreicher Auseinandersetzung mit korporativ-konziliaren Vorstellun- gen und Praktiken der Kirchenleitung. Die Konzilien von Konstanz, Pavia-Siena und Basel debattierten zum einen grundsätzlich über das Verhältnis von konzi- liarer und päpstlicher Gewalt (potestas), entwickelten zum anderen aber auch Vor- stellungen von der Verfasstheit der Kirche neben und unter dem Papst, die
    [Show full text]
  • Nicholas of Cusa and Modern Philosophy
    //FS2/CUP/3-PAGINATION/HRP/2-PROOFS/3B2/9780521846486C09.3D 173 [173–192] 2.5.2007 8:03AM 9 DERMOT MORAN Nicholas of Cusa and modern philosophy ‘‘Gatekeeper of the modern age’’ Nicholas of Cusa (Niklas Krebs, known as Cusanus, 1401–64), one of the most original and creative intellects of the fifteenth century,1 has been variously described as ‘‘the last great philosopher of the dying Middle Ages’’ (Alexandre Koyre´), as a ‘‘transition-thinker’’ between the medieval and modern worlds (Frederick Copleston),2 and as the ‘‘gatekeeper of the modern age’’ (Rudolf Haubst).3 He is a lone figure with no real successor although he had some influence on Copernicus, Kepler, Bruno, and, tangen- tially, on Descartes. The German Idealists showed some interest in Nicholas of Cusa but the real revival of his thought was stimulated by the neo-Kantian philosopher Ernst Cassirer (1874–1945) who called him ‘‘the first modern thinker’’ and by the existentialist Karl Jaspers.4 Cassirer compared him to Kant for his view that objects have to be understood in terms of the categories of our own thought.5 Other scholars, notably Alexandre Koyre´,6 Hans-Georg Gadamer7 Hans Blumenberg,8 Werner Beierwaltes,9 and Karsten Harries,10 all see him in a certain way as a harbinger of modernity.11 Yet his outlook is essentially conservative, aiming, as Hans Blumenberg has recognized, to maintain the medieval synthesis.12 Cusanus was a humanist scholar, Church reformer – his De concordantia catholica (On Catholic Concord, 1434) included proposals for the reform of Church and state – papal diplomat, and Catholic cardinal.
    [Show full text]
  • Chryssa Maltezou Still More on the Political Views of Bessarion
    Chryssa Maltezou (Venedig) Still more on the political views of Bessarion An imposing universal figure, Bessarion, metropolitan of Nicaea and in later life a cardinal of the Catholic Church, was undoubtedly one of the most important personalities of the 15th century. He played a key role in the renewal of intellectual life in Italy, offering the western community the benefit of his own special perspective on the world and, along with other Byzantine men of letters, familiarising Western Europe with what has aptly been called ‘Proto- Europe’, i.e. the thousand-year-old Byzantine Empire1). The nature of Bessa- rion’s conduct and deeds in general have tended to create an ideologically loaded picture as regards his political conscience: his actions lay beyond the normal pattern of the Byzantine or Western world, suggesting a broader European synthesis. According to his contemporary, the Italian humanist, Loren- zo Valla, Bessarion was “in Rome the most Latin of the Greeks and in Constantinople the most Greek of the Latins” (Latinorum graecissimus, Graeco- rum latinissimus),2) while Bessarion’s protégé, the scholar and scribe Michael Apostoles, considered the cardinal to be among the “last of the Greeks” and the “first of the Europeans” (eön tvqn Graikvqn toiqw uÖstaßtoiw kaöntoiqw prvßtoiw tvqn Euörvpaißvn).3) Modern scholars have since emphasized from time to time either the Greek or the Latin dimension of his personality. His decision to embrace the Latin Church and his stance on the issue of the union of the churches explains why western
    [Show full text]
  • Libraries: Architecture and the Ordering of Knowledge
    Libraries: Architecture and the Ordering of Knowledge English text of March 29, 2009, by J. Connors for “Biblioteche: l’architettura e l’ordinamento del sapere,” with Angela Dressen, in Il Rinascimento Italiano e l’Europa, vol. 6, Luoghi, spazi, architetture, ed. Donatella Calabi and Elena Svalduz, Treviso-Costabissara, 2010, pp. 199-228. All the texts describing ancient libraries had been rediscovered by the mid-Quattrocento. Humanists knew Greek and Roman libraries from the accounts in Strabo, Varro, Seneca, and especially Suetonius, himself a former prefect of the imperial libraries. From Pliny everyone knew that Asinius Pollio founded the first public library in Rome, fulfilling the unrealized wish of Juliuys Caesar ("Ingenia hominum rem publicam fecit," "He made men's talents public property"). From Suetonius it was known that Augustus founded two libraries, one in the Porticus Octaviae, and another, for Greek and Latin books, in the temple of Apollo on the Palatine, where the sculptural decoration included not only a colossal statue of Apollo but also portraits of celebrated writers. The texts spoke frequently of author portraits, and also of the wealth and splendor of ancient libraries. The presses for the papyrus rolls were made of ebony and cedar; the architectural order and the revetments of the rooms were of marble; the sculpture was of gilt bronze. Boethius added that libraries were adorned with ivory and glass, while Isidore mentioned gilt ceilings and restful green cipollino floors. Senecan disapproval of ostentatious libraries, of "studiosa luxuria," of piling up more books than one could ever read, gave way to admiration for magnificent libraries.
    [Show full text]
  • The Story of the Borgias (1913)
    The Story of The Borgias John Fyvie L1BRARV OF UN ,VERSITV CALIFORNIA AN DIEGO THE STORY OF THE BORGIAS <Jt^- i//sn6Ut*4Ccn4<s flom fte&co-^-u, THE STORY OF THE BOEGIAS AUTHOR OF "TRAGEDY QUEENS OF THE GEORGIAN ERA" ETC NEW YORK G. P. PUTNAM'S SONS 1913 PRINTED AT THE BALLANTYNE PRESS TAVI STOCK STREET CoVENT GARDEN LONDON THE story of the Borgia family has always been of interest one strangely fascinating ; but a lurid legend grew up about their lives, which culminated in the creation of the fantastic monstrosities of Victor Hugo's play and Donizetti's opera. For three centuries their name was a byword for the vilest but in our there has been infamy ; own day an extraordinary swing of the pendulum, which is hard to account for. Quite a number of para- doxical writers have proclaimed to an astonished and mystified world that Pope Alexander VI was both a wise prince and a gentle priest whose motives and actions have been maliciously mis- noble- represented ; that Cesare Borgia was a minded and enlightened statesman, who, three centuries in advance of his time, endeavoured to form a united Italy by the only means then in Lucrezia anybody's power ; and that Borgia was a paragon of all the virtues. " " It seems to have been impossible to whitewash the Borgia without a good deal of juggling with the evidence, as well as a determined attack on the veracity and trustworthiness of the contemporary b v PREFACE historians and chroniclers to whom we are indebted for our knowledge of the time.
    [Show full text]
  • Byzantine Empire (Ca 600-1200): I.1
    INSTITUTE OF HISTORICAL RESEARCH ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΙΣΤΟΡΙΚΩΝ ΕΡΕΥΝΩΝ SECTION OF BYZANTINE RESEARCH ΤΟΜΕΑΣ ΒΥΖΑΝΤΙΝΩΝ ΕΡΕΥΝΩΝ NATIONAL HELLENIC RESEARCH FOUNDATION ΕΘΝΙΚΟ IΔΡΥΜΑ ΕΡΕΥΝΩΝ Τομοσ 30 VOLUME EFI RAGIA THE GEOGRAPHY OF THE PROVINCIAL ADMINISTRATION BRIGITA KUKJALKO OF THE BYZANTINE EMPIRE (CA 600-1200): I.1. THE APOTHEKAI OF ASIA MINOR (7TH-8TH C.) THE STUDY OF ANCIENT GREEK TEXTS IN EARLY OTTOMAN CONSTANTINOPLE ΑΘΗΝΑ • 20092020 • ATHENS BRIGITA KUKJALKO THE STUDY OF ANCIENT GREEK TEXTS IN EARLY OTTOMAN CONSTANTINOPLE* INTRODUCTION It is well known that most of the work on ancient Greek texts was transferred to Italy in the period from the conquest of Constantinople by the crusaders in 1204 –when the migration of Byzantine scholars to Western Europe began– to the late 15th century1. However, not all Greek-speaking scholars left Constantinople in the last two centuries of the Byzantine Empire or after its fall to the Ottomans in 1453. Some distinguished Greek learned men remained and continued their intellectual work, including the study of ancient Greek texts. There are several articles which deal with the interest of the Ottoman court in ancient Greek philosophy and art2. They are mainly based on the evidence of Greek manuscripts that were produced in Mehmed’s Greek * This paper is the outcome of a generous research scholarship granted by the Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey (TÜBİTAK) for the academic year 2014–2015 at Boğaziçi University. 1. See J. E. SANDYS, A History of Classical Scholarship: From the Sixth Century B.C. to the End of the Middle Ages, v. 1, Cambridge 1903, 376-428; D.
    [Show full text]
  • The Magnificent Interior
    The Magnificent Interior Emotion, Gender, and Household in the Life of Lorenzo de’ Medici Karen J. Burch Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Royal Holloway, University of London Department of History September 2019 1 Declaration of Authorship I, Karen Burch, hereby declare that this thesis and the work presented in it is entirely my own. Where I have consulted the work of others, it is clearly stated. Signed: Dated: 2 Abstract Though Lorenzo de’ Medici (1449-1492) is one of the most well- studied Florentine figures in history, previous studies have almost exclusively focused on his political life and his contributions as an art patron. Few historians have given time to his emotional life, his relationships with the members of his household, or the ways in which he understood himself as a Medici man. The neglect of this crucial facet of the human experience fails to challenge previous understandings of Lorenzo’s life. This thesis is meant to be a corrective to earlier work in Laurentian history. I approach Lorenzo’s life from a standpoint which incorporates the methodologies of emotions history, gender history, household history, and the history of sexuality. By making a close study of a variety of sources, including letters, poetry, and artwork, I will seek to create a new portrait of Lorenzo which explores his internal life. This, I believe, will give greater context to the decisions and behaviours which shaped his political and artistic career. Additionally, by exploring Lorenzo’s inner life, we will come to a deeper understanding of the ways in which masculinity, sexuality, and household relationships shaped the lives of Florentine men.
    [Show full text]
  • László Bene: Constructing Pagan Platonism: Plethon's Theory of Fate
    1 László Bene: Constructing Pagan Platonism: Plethon’s Theory of Fate and the Ancient Philosophical Tradition 1. The question of Plethon’s Platonism The Stoic theory of fate and the debates it has given rise to in ancient philosophy have been at the focus of interest in recent research.1 We are currently in a better position to assess how Medieval and Renaissance treatments of fate and human autonomy relate to ancient strands of thought. I set out here to examine Plethon’s theory of fate against the background of the ancient philosophical tradition. The particular problems I wish to address are the following. What is the relationship between Plethon’s doctrine of fate and the corresponding ancient Platonic theories? What are his possible motives for adopting a deterministic position? What kind of Platonism does he propound, and how is it related to ancient Platonism? Before turning to the details of Plethon’s doctrine of fate, let me first spell out the last question in some detail. Plethon famously attacked Aristotle and embraced Plato as his primary philosophical authority in a work which initiated a long-standing dispute between Platonists and Aristotelians in Byzantine and Renaissance philosophy.2 That seems in itself to justify his standard classification as a Platonist in scholarly literature. However, given that Platonism is a rich tradition comprising several varieties, there is room for the question as to what ‘Platonist’ means in his particular case. Various suggestions have been formulated concerning his precise philosophical affiliations.3 For instance, Karamanolis argues that Plethon draws on certain Middle Platonists as used by Eusebius.4 He points out that Plethon’s fundamentalist Platonic ideology according to which Plato’s philosophy contains the complete truth, and, therefore, any deviation from it qualifies as error or even apostasy, is reminiscent of Numenius and Atticus.
    [Show full text]