The Kingdom Strikes Back: Ten Epochs of Redemptive History

Ralph D. Winter

an has virtually erased his own story. Human beings as far back as we have any paleological M record have been fighting each other so much that they have destroyed well over 90 percent of their own handiwork. Their libraries, their literature, their cities, their works of art are mostly gone. Even the little that re- mains from the distant past is riddled with evidences of a strange and pervasive evil that has grotesquely distorted man’s potential. This is strange because apparently no other species treats its own with such deadly hatred. The oldest skulls bear mute witness that they were bashed in and roasted to deliver their contents as food for other human beings. An incredible array of disease germs also cuts down population growth. World population in Abraham’s day is estimated at 27 million—less than the population of California in AD 2000. But, the small slow-growing population of Abraham’s day is mute, and ominous evidence exists of the devastating com- bination of war and pestilence, both the relentless impact of the Evil One. World population growth back then was one- sixteenth of today’s global rate. As hatred and disease are After serving ten conquered, world population instantly picks up speed. If years as a mis- today’s relatively slow global growth rate to have happened sionary among in Abraham’s day, our present world population (of 6 bil- Mayan Indians lion) would have been reached back then in just 321 years! in the highlands Thus, in those days, evil must have been much more ram- of Guatemala, Ralph D. Winter was pant than now. called to be a Professor of Missions We are not surprised, then, to find that the explanation for at the School of World Mission at this strange evil comes up in the oldest detailed written Fuller Theological Seminary. Ten records—surviving documents that are respected by Jewish, year later, he and his wife, Roberta, Christian and Muslim traditions whose adherents make up founded a mission society called more than half of the world’s population. These documents the Frontier Mission Fellowship called “the Torah,” by Jews, the “Books of the Law” by Chris- (FMF) in Pasadena, California. This tians, and “the Taurat” by Muslims not only explain the strange in turn spawned the U.S. Center for source of evil but also describe a counter-campaign and then World Mission and the William follow the progress of that campaign through many centuries. Carey International University, To be specific, the first eleven chapters of Genesis consti- both of which serve other missions tute a scary “introduction” to the entire problem, indeed, to working at the frontiers of mission. the plot of the entire Bible. Those few pages describe three He is the General Director of the things: 1) a glorious and “good” original creation; 2) the en- Frontier Mission Fellowship. See trance of a rebellious and destructive evil—superhuman, de- expanded biographical sketch at monic person—resulting in 3) a humanity caught up in that the end of the book. rebellion and brought under the power of that evil person.

Chapter 33 195 197 Chapter 33 THE KINGDOM STRIKES BACK

Don’t ever think that the whole remainder One stirs up hate, distorts even DNA se- of the Bible is simply a bundle of divergent, quences, perhaps authors suffering and all unrelated stories as taught in Sunday School. destruction of God’s good creation. Satan’s Rather, the Bible consists of a single drama: devices may very well include devising viru- the entrance of the Kingdom, the power and lent germs in order to tear down confidence the glory of the living God in this enemy-oc- in God’s loving character. cupied territory. From Genesis 12 to the end Therefore this “blessing” is a key concept. of the Bible, and indeed until the end of time, The English word blessing is not an ideal there unfolds the single, coherent drama of translation. We see the word in use where “the Kingdom strikes back.” This would Isaac confers his “blessing” on Jacob and not make a good title for the Bible itself were it to on Esau. It was not “blessings” but “a bless- be printed in modern dress (with Gen 1-11 as ing,” the conferral of a family name, respon- the introduction to the whole Bible). In this sibility, obligation, as well as privilege. It is unfolding drama we see the gradual but irre- not something you can receive or get like a sistible power of God reconquering and re- box of chocolates you can run off with and deeming His fallen creation through the giv- eat by yourself in a cave, or a new personal ing of His own Son at the very center of the power you can show off like rippling 4000-year period ending in 2000 BC. This is muscles. It is something you become in a per- tersely summed up: “The Son of God ap- manent relationship and fellowship with your peared for this purpose, that He might de- Father in Heaven. It returns “families,” that stroy the works of the devil” (1 Jn 3:6). is, nations to His household, to the Kingdom of God, so that the nations “will declare His glory.” The Bible consists of a single drama: the entrance Preventing the nations of the Kingdom, the power and the glory of the from declaring His glory are any evidences of living God in this enemy-occupied territory. God’s inability to cope with evil. If the Son of This counterattack against the Evil One God appeared to destroy the works of the clearly does not await the appearance of the Devil, then what are the Son of God’s follow- good Person in the center of the story. In- ers and “joint heirs” supposed to do to bring deed, there would seem to be five identifi- honor to His Name? able epochs of advance prior to the appear- This “blessing” of God is in effect condi- ance of Christ as well as five after that event. tioned upon its being shared with other na- The purpose of this chapter is mainly to de- tions, since those who yield to and receive scribe the five epochs after Christ. However, God’s blessing are, like Abraham, those of in order for those later epochs to be seen as faith who subject themselves to God’s will, part of a single ten-epoch 4,000-year unfold- become part of His Kingdom, and represent ing story, we will note a few clues about the the extension of His rule, His power, His au- first five epochs. thority within all other peoples. The theme that links all ten epochs is the grace of God intervening in a “world which The First Half lies in the power of the Evil One” (1 Jn 5:19), of the 4,000-Year Story contesting an enemy who temporarily is “the The story of the “strike back” as we see it in god of this world” (2 Cor 4:4) so that the na- Genesis 12 begins in about 2000 BC. During tions will praise God’s name. His plan for do- roughly the next 400 years, Abraham was ing this is to reach all peoples by conferring chosen, and moved to the geographic center an unusual “blessing” on Abraham and of the Afro-Asian land mass. The time of Abraham’s seed (Abraham’s children-by- Abraham, Isaac, Jacob and Joseph (often faith), even as we pray “Thy Kingdom called the Period of the Patriarchs) displays come.” By contrast, the Evil One’s plan is to relatively small breakthroughs of witness to bring reproach on the Name of God. The Evil the surrounding nations even though the RALPH D. WINTER 197

Ten Epochs of Redemptive History: The First Half 2000 – 0 BC

PatriarchsCaptivity Judges Kings Post-Exile

2000 BC 1600 BC 1200 BC 800 BC 400 BC 0 BC

central mandate to restore God’s control over or without the full cooperation of His cho- all nations (Gen 12:1-3) is repeated twice sen nation. When Jesus appears, it is an in- again to Abraham (18:18, 22:18), and once to criminating “visitation.” He comes to His both Isaac (26:4) and Jacob (28:14,15). own, and “His own receive Him not“ (John Joseph observed to his brothers, “You sold 1:11). He is well received in Nazareth until me, but God sent me.” He was obviously a He refers to God’s desire to bless the Gen- great blessing to the nation of Egypt. Even tiles. At that precise moment (Luke 4:28) an Pharaoh recognized that Joseph was filled with explosion of homicidal fury betrays the fact the Spirit of God (Gen 41:38, TLB). But this was that this chosen nation—chosen to receive not the intentional missionary obedience God and to mediate the blessing (Ex 19:5, 6; Ps 67; wanted. Joseph’s brothers, for example, had Isa 49:6)—has grossly fallen short. There not taken up an offering and sent him to Egypt was indeed a sprinkling of fanatical “Bible as a missionary! God was in the missions busi- students” who “traversed land and sea to ness whether they were or not. make a single proselyte” (Matt 23:15). But The next four periods, roughly 400 years such outreach was not so much to be a bless- each, are: 2) the Captivity, 3) the Judges, 4) the ing to the other nations as it was to sustain Kings and 5) that of the Babylonian Exile and and protect Israel. They were not always dispersion (diaspora). During this rough and making sure that their converts were “cir- tumble, the promised blessing and the expected cumcised in heart” (Deut 10:16, 30:6, Jer mission (to extend God’s rule to all the nations 9:24-26, Rom 2:29). of the world) all but disappear from sight. As a In effect, and under these circumstances, result, where possible, God accomplished His Jesus did not come to give the Great Commis- will through the voluntary obedience of His sion but to take it away. The natural branches people, but where necessary, He accomplished were broken off while other “unnatural” His will through involuntary means. Joseph, branches were grafted in (Rom 11:13-24). But, Jonah, the nation as a whole when taken cap- despite the general reluctance of the chosen tive represent the category of involuntary mis- missionary nation—typical of other nations sionary outreach intended by God to force the later—many people groups were in fact extension of the blessing. The little girl carried touched due to the faithfulness and righ- away captive to the house of Naaman the Syr- teousness of some. These groups come to ian was able to share her faith. Naomi, who mind: Canaanites, Egyptians, Philistines (of “went” a distance away, shared her faith with the ancient Minoan culture), Hittites, her children and their non-Jewish wives. On Moabites, Phoenicians (of Tyre and Sidon), the other hand, Ruth, her daughter-in-law, Assyrians, Sabeans (of the land of Sheba), Naaman the Syrian, and the Queen of Sheba Babylonians, Persians, Parthians, Medes, all “came” voluntarily, attracted by God’s bless- Elamites and Romans. ing-relationship with Israel. Note, then, the four different “mission The Second Half of the Story mechanisms” at work to bless other peoples: The next 2,000-year period is one in which 1) going voluntarily, 2) involuntarily going God, on the basis of the intervention of His without missionary intent, 3) coming volun- Son, makes sure that the other nations are tarily, and 4) coming involuntarily (as with both blessed and similarly called “to be a Gentiles forcibly settled in Israel—2 Kings 17). blessing to all the families of the earth.” In Thus, we see in every epoch the active each case, “Unto whomsoever much is given, concern of God to forward His mission, with of him (of that people) shall much be re- 199 Chapter 33 THE KINGDOM STRIKES BACK

Ten Epochs of Redemptive History: The Second Half 0 – 2000 AD

Ends of RomansBarbarians Vikings Saracens? the Earth

0 AD 400 AD 800 AD 1200 AD 1600 AD 2000 AD quired.” Now we see the Kingdom striking language. Greek was thus understood from back in the realms of the Armenians, the Ro- England to Palestine. mans, the Celts, the Franks, the Angles, the Equally important to our thesis is the less Saxons, the Germans, and eventually even known but empire-wide substratum of obe- those ruthless pagan pirates further north dience and righteousness—the massive and called the Vikings. All these people-basins marvelous presence of diaspora Jews, more will be invaded, tamed and subjugated by respected in their dispersion than in their the power of the gospel, and in turn expected home land! Scholars agree that their numbers to share that blessing with still other peoples had grown to 10 percent of the Roman popu- (instead of raiding them). lation. The virile element within this Jewish But in one sense the next five epochs are presence—those “circumcised in heart”— not all that different from the first five ep- played a large part in attracting many Gen- ochs. Those nations that are blessed do not tiles to the fringes of the synagogues. Many seem terribly eager to share that unique of these Gentiles, like those of Cornelius’ blessing and extend that new kingdom. The household, became earnest Bible readers and Celts are the most active nation in the first worshipers—people the New Testament calls millennium to give an outstanding mission- “devout persons” or “God-fearers.” This way ary response. As we will see—just as in the the faith jumped the ethnic borders! Such Old Testament—the conferral of this unique God-fearers became the steel rails on which blessing will bring sober responsibility, dan- the Christian movement expanded. This gerous if unfulfilled. And we will see re- movement was basically the Jewish faith in peated again and again God’s use of the full Gentile clothing, something—take note— range of His four missionary mechanisms. which was understandably hard for earnest The “visitation” of the Christ was dra- Jews to conceive. matic, full of portent and strikingly “in due How else could a few Gospels and a few time.” Jesus was born a member of a subju- letters from St. Paul have had such a wide- gated people. Yet in spite of her bloody im- spread impact within so many different eth- perialism, Rome was truly an instrument in nic groups in such a short period of time? God’s hands to prepare the world for His Stop and ponder: Jesus came, lived for 33 coming. Rome controlled one of the largest years on earth, confronted His own unenthusi- empires the world has ever known, forcing astic missionary nation, was rejected by many, the Roman peace (the “Pax Romana”) upon was crucified and buried, rose again, and un- all sorts of disparate and barbaric peoples. derscored the same longstanding commission For centuries Roman emperors had been to all who would respond, before ascending to building an extensive communication sys- the Father. Today even the most agnostic his- tem, both in the 250,000 miles of marvelous torian stands amazed that what began in a roads which stretched throughout the em- humble stable in Bethlehem of Palestine, a pire, and in the rapid transmission of mes- backwater of the Roman Empire, in less than sages and documents somewhat like the 300 years was given control of the emperors’ Pony Express on the American frontier. In its palace in Rome. How did it happen? It is a conquests, Rome enveloped at least one civi- truly incredible story. lization far more advanced than her own— Greece. Highly-educated artisans and teach- No Saints in the Middle? ers were taken as slaves to every major city It is wise to interrupt the story here. If you of the empire where they taught the Greek haven’t heard this story before you may con- RALPH D. WINTER 199

front a psychological problem. In church that invasion has taken place. Kenneth circles today we have fled, feared or forgot- Scott Latourette’s History of Christianity ten these middle centuries. Hopefully, fewer gives the fascinating details, a book extend- and fewer of us will continue to think in ing the story beyond the Bible. (A book terms of what may more valuable than any other, apart from be called a fairly the Bible!) Perhaps the most extreme form of Note the pattern in the chart on page 211. spectacular the “BOBO” Latourette’s “resurgences” correspond to theory—that the our “renaissances.” triumph of Christian faith In Period I, Rome was won but did not Christianity in somehow reach out with the gospel to the barbaric “Blinked Out” af- Celts and Goths. Almost as a penalty, the history was its ter the Apostles Goths invaded Rome and the whole western conquest of the and “Blinked On” (Latin) part of the empire caved in. again in our time, In Period II, the Goths were added in, and Roman Empire in or whenever our they and others briefly achieved a new roughly twenty modern “proph- “Holy” Roman Empire. But this new sphere ets” arose, be they did not effectively reach further north with decades. Luther, Calvin, the gospel. Wesley, Joseph In Period III, again almost as a penalty, Smith, Ellen White or John Wimber. The re- the Vikings invaded these Christianized sult of this kind of BOBO approach is that Celtic and Gothic barbarians. In the resulting you have “early” saints and “latter-day” agony, the Vikings, too, became Christians. saints, but no saints in the middle. In Period IV, Europe now united for the Thus, many Evangelicals are not much inter- first time by Christian faith, reached out in a ested in what happened prior to the Protes- sort of pseudo-mission to the Saracens in the tant Reformation. They have the vague im- great abortion known as the Crusades. pression that the Church was apostate In Period V, Europe now reached out to before Luther and Calvin, and whatever the very ends of the earth, but still done there was of real Christianity consisted of a with highly mixed motives; intermingled few persecuted individuals here and there. commercial and spiritual interests was both For example, in the multi-volume Twenty a blight and a blessing. Yet, during this pe- Centuries of Great Preaching, only half of the riod, the entire non-Western world was first volume is devoted to the first 15 centu- suddenly stirred into development as the ries! In evangelical Sunday Schools, children colonial powers greatly reduced war and are busy as beavers with the story of God’s disease. Never before had so few affected work from Genesis to Revelation, from so many, even though never before had so Adam to the Apostles—and their Sunday great a gap existed between two halves of School publishers may even boast about the world. What will happen in the next their “all-Bible curriculum.” But this only re- few years? ally means that these children do not get ex- Will the immeasurably strengthened non- posed to all the incredible things God did Western world invade Europe and America with that Bible between the times of the just as the Goths invaded Rome and the Vi- Apostles and the Reformers, a period which kings overran Europe? Will the “Third is staggering proof of the unique power of World” turn on us in a new series of “Barbar- the Bible! To many people, it is as if there ian” invasions? Will the OPEC nations were “no saints in the middle.” gradually buy us out and take us over? In the space available, however, it is only Clearly we face the reaction of an awakened possible to outline the Western part of the non-Western world that is suddenly beyond story of the kingdom striking back—and our control. What will be the role of the gos- only outline. It will be very helpful to rec- pel? Can we gain any insight from these pre- ognize the various cultural basins in which vious cycles of outreach? 201 Chapter 33 THE KINGDOM STRIKES BACK

Period I: Winning the Romans, ward God. Indeed, as far as the basic purpose A.D. 0–400 of the Mosaic Law is concerned, the Greek Perhaps the most spectacular triumph of believers immediately developed the func- Christianity in history was its conquest of the tional equivalent to it in their own cultural Roman Empire in roughly 20 decades. There is terms while most of them held on as well to a lot more we would like to know about this what is often called the Old Testament. After period. Our lack of knowledge makes much of all, it was “the Bible of the early church” (as it a mystery, and the growth of Christianity well as of the Jews), that had led them to be- sounds impossible, almost unbelievable—es- lief in the first place. pecially if we do not take into account the Jew- We may get the impression that mission ac- ish substratum. Only the early part of the tivity in this period benefitted very little from story starts out emblazoned in the floodlight deliberately organized effort. That may well of the New Testament epistles themselves. be only because its structure was transparent: Let’s take a glance at that. Paul apparently worked within a well-known There we see a Jew named Paul brought up “missionary team” structure used by the in a Greek city, committed to leadership in the Pharisees—even by Paul himself when he was Jewish tradition of his time. Suddenly he is a Pharisee! Paul’s sending congregation in transformed by Christ and gradually comes to Antioch certainly undertook some responsibil- see that the essence of the faith of the Jews as ity. But, basically, they “sent him off” more fulfilled in Christ could operate without Jew- than they “sent him out.” His traveling team ish garments. He realized that an inner cir- had all of the authority of any local church. He cumcision of the heart could be clothed in did not look for orders from Antioch. Greek language and customs as well as There is good reason to suppose that the Semitic! It should have become crystal clear to Christian faith spread in many areas by the everyone that anyone can become a Christian “involuntary-go” mechanism, because Chris- and be transformed in the inner man by the tians were often dispersed as the result of living Christ, whether Jew, Greek, Barbarian, persecutions. We know that fleeing Arian Scythian, slave, free, male or female. The Christians had a lot to do with the conversion Greeks didn’t have to become Jews—undergo of the Goths. We have the stories of Ulfilas physical circumcision, take over the Jewish and Patrick whose missionary efforts were in calendar of festivals or holy days nor even ob- each case initiated by the accident of their be- serve Jewish dietary customs—any more than ing taken captive. a woman had to be made into a man to be ac- Furthermore, it is reasonable to suppose ceptable to God. What was necessary was the that Christianity followed the trade routes of “obedience of faith” (Rom 1:5, 16:26). the Roman Empire. We know that there was a Paul based his work on the radical biblical close relationship and correspondence be- principle (unaccepted by many Jews to this tween Christians in Gaul and Asia Minor. Yet day) that it is circumcision of the heart that we must face the fact that the early Christians counts (Jer 9), and that the new believers of a of the Roman Empire (and Christians today!) new culture did not have to speak the lan- were only rarely willing and able to take con- guage, wear the clothes, or follow all the cus- scious practical steps to fulfill the Great Com- toms of the sending church. This meant that mission. In view of the amazing results in for Greeks the cultural details of the Jewish those early decades, however, we are all the law were no longer to be considered manda- more impressed by the innate power of the tory. Therefore, to the Jews, Paul continued as gospel itself. one “under the law of Moses,” but to those One intriguing possibility of the natural unfamiliar with the Mosaic law, he preached transfer of the gospel within a given social the “law of Christ” in such a way that it unit is the case of the Celts. Historical studies could be fulfilled dynamically and authenti- clarify for us that the province of Galatia in cally in the new circumstances. While to Asia Minor was called so because it was some he appeared to be “without law,” he settled by Galatoi from Western Europe (who maintained that he was not without law to- as late as the fourth century still spoke both RALPH D. WINTER 201 their original Celtic tongue and also the literacy and the studying and copying of bib- Greek of that part of the Roman Empire). lical manuscripts and ancient Greek classics. Whether or not Paul’s Galatians were merely As amazed pagan leaders looked on, the Jewish traders living in the province of cumulative impact of this new, much more Galatia, or were from the beginning Celtic acceptable clothing of biblical faith grew to Galatoi who were attracted to synagogues as prominent proportions by AD 300. We don’t “God fearers,” we note in any case that Paul’s know with any confidence what personal letter to the Galatians is especially wary of reasons Constantine had in AD 312 for declar- anyone pushing over on his readers the mere ing himself a Christian. We know that his outward customs of the Jewish culture and mother in Asia Minor was a Christian, and confusing such customs with essential biblical that his father, as a co-regent in Gaul and faith which he preached to both Jew and Britain, did not enforce in his area the Greek (Rom 1:16). A matter of high mission- Diocletian edicts commanding persecution of ary interest is the fact that Paul’s preaching Christians. However, by this time in history had tapped into a cultural vein of Celtic hu- the inescapable factor is that there were manity that may soon have included friends, enough Christians in the Roman Empire to relatives and trade contacts reaching a great make an official reversal of policy toward distance to the west. Thus Paul’s efforts in Christianity not only feasible but politically Galatia may give us one clue to the surpris- wise. I well recall a lecture by the late Profes- ingly early penetration of the gospel into the sor Lynn White, Jr. of U.C.L.A., one of the main Celtic areas of Europe, comprising a great medieval historians, in which he said belt running across southern Europe clear that even if Constantine had not become a over into Galicia in Spain, Brittany in France Christian, the empire could not have held out and up into the western and northern parts against Christianity more than another de- of the British Isles. cade or two! The long development of the There came a time when not only hun- Roman Empire had ended the local au- dreds of thousands of Greek and Roman citi- tonomy of the city-state and created a wide- zens had become Christians, but Celtic- spread need for a sense of belonging—he speaking peoples and Gothic tribal peoples called it a crisis of identity. At that time as well had believed within their own forms Christianity was the one religion that had no for various versions of biblical faith, both nationalism at its root, partly because it was within and beyond the borders of the Roman rejected by the Jews! It was not the folk reli- Empire. It is probable that the missionary gion of any one tribe. In White’s words, it work behind this came about mainly through had developed “an unbeatable combination.” unplanned processes involving Christians However, this virtue became a mixed bless- from the eastern part of the Roman Empire. ing once it became aligned with the Empire. In any case this achievement certainly cannot Thus, it is the very power of the move- readily be credited to the planned missionary ment which helps to explain why the mo- initiative of Latin-speaking Romans in the mentous imperial decision to tolerate Chris- West. This is the point we are trying to make. tianity almost inevitably led to its becoming One piece of evidence is the fact that the (roughly 50 years later) the official religion of earliest Irish mission compounds (distin- the Empire. Not long after the curtain rises guished from the Latin-Roman type by a cen- on Christianity as an officially tolerated reli- tral chapel) followed a ground plan derived gion, the head of the Christian community from Christian centers in Egypt. And Greek, in Rome turns out astonishingly to be the not Latin, was the language of the early strongest and most trusted man around. churches in Gaul. Even the first organized That’s why Constantine, when he moved the mission efforts of John Cassian and Martin of seat of government to Constantinople, left Tours, for example, came from the East by his palace (the famous Lateran Palace) to the means of commune structures begun in Syria people of the Christian community as their and Egypt. Fortunately, these organized ef- “White House” in Rome. In any case, it is forts carried with them a strong emphasis on simply a matter of record that by AD 375, 203 Chapter 33 THE KINGDOM STRIKES BACK

Christianity had become the official religion centuries of Roman literacy in southern Brit- of Rome. If it had merely been an ethnic cult, ain were soon extinguished by a new form of it could not have been even a candidate as invading barbarians—Angles, Saxons and an official religion of the Empire. Frisians who, compared to the Goths, were Ironically, however, once Christianity be- total pagans, cruel and destructive. What came locked into a specific cultural tradition would happen now? Thus began the “First” and political loyalty, it tended automatically of the two Dark Ages. to alienate all who were anti-Roman. Even being tolerated instantly created suspicion and Period II: Winning the Barbar- then soon widespread slaughter of “Chris- ians, A.D. 400–800 tians” in Arabia and what is now Iran. This It is a fact that when the earlier (Gothic) tribal persecution stopped for three years, when a peoples became Christianized into an antago- Roman emperor (Julian the Apostate) opposed nistic Arian form of the faith, they became a Christianity and tried to roll things back to greater and greater military threat to Rome. the pagan gods! Meanwhile, even in the case All it took for this threat to become a true of anti-Roman populations within the menace was for the feared Huns to punch Empire’s boundaries, as in North Africa, the into Europe from Central Asia. This pushed foundation was laid for people to turn to Is- the panicked Visigoths (and then the lam as an alternative. This in one sense was a Ostrogoths and then the Vandals) inside the cultural breakaway from Christianity just as Empire. In the turmoil and confusion these Christianity had been a breakaway from the tribal incursions somewhat unintentionally Jewish form of the biblical faith. Similarly wrecked the entire network of civil govern- “Black Muslims” today deliberately reject the ment in the West (in today’s Italy, Spain and “white man’s religion.” North Africa). Later they tried seriously to re- Thus, the political triumph of what even- build it. tually came to be known as Christianity was (Was all this something like the post-colo- in fact a mixed blessing. The biblical faith nial chaos in Africa after the Second World could wear other than Jewish clothes; it was War?) In fact, the only reason the city of now dressed in Roman clothes; but if these Rome itself was not physically devastated by new clothes were normative, it would not be the invasions, which arrived finally at the expected to spread far beyond the political gates of Rome in 410, was that these Gothic boundaries of the Roman Empire. It didn’t, Barbarians were, all things considered, really except in the West. Why was that? very respectful of life and property, especially No one questions that when Christianity be- that of the churches! It was a huge benefit to came the official religion of the Roman Empire, citizens of Rome that earlier informal mis- it became ill-equipped by its very form to com- sionary effort—for which Latin Roman Chris- plete the Great Commission with any populace tians could claim little credit—had brought that was anti-Roman. As we might expect, only these peoples into at least a superficial Chris- Christianity of a heretical variety was accepted tian faith. Even secular Romans observed by the Germanic tribes while Rome was still how lucky they were that the invaders held strong militarily. But once the tribal peoples high certain standards of Christian morality. discovered it possible to invade and conquer Not so the Angles and Saxons who invaded the western half of the Roman Empire, the Britain. Catholic and Orthodox forms of the faith be- We are tantalized by the reflection that this came less threatening because the Goths and much was accomplished by informal and al- others could now try to acquire the prestige of most unconscious sharing of the gospel—e.g. the Roman language and culture without being the news and authority of the blessing being dominated by the Roman legions. extended to all Gentile nations. How much Note, however, the domino results of par- better might it have been if the Romans—dur- tially Christianized Gothic barbarians threat- ing that brief hundred years of official flour- ening Rome: the Romans in defense pulled ishing of Christianity (310-410) prior to the their legions out of Britain. As a result, four first Gothic invasion of the city of Rome—had RALPH D. WINTER 203 been devoted to energetic and intentional mis- the country of China denounced both the sionary effort. Even a little heretical Christian- Russians for failing to live up to Communist ity prevented the Barbarians from that total standards and the West for its pornography disregard of civilization which was to be and crime.] shown by the Vikings in the third period. Per- Whether or not the Romans had it coming haps a little more missionary work might have (for failing to reach out), and whether or not prevented the complete collapse of the gov- the Barbarians were both encouraged and ernmental structure of the Roman Empire in tempered in their conquest by their initial the West. Today, for example, the ability of the Christian awareness, the indisputable fact is new African states to maintain a stable gov- that while the Romans lost the western half ernment is to a great extent dependent upon of their empire, the Barbarian world, in a their degree of Christianization (that is, both very dramatic sense, gained a Christian faith. in knowledge and morality). The immediate result: right within the city In any case, we confront the of Rome appeared two “denomi- ominous phenomenon of partially nations,” the one Arian and the Christianized barbarian hordes Benedictine other Athanasian. Also in the pic- being emboldened and enabled to communes ture was the Celtic “church,” pour in upon a complacent, offi- which was more a series of mis- cially Christian empire that had held the Bible sionary compounds than it was a failed effectively to reach out to in awe…and denomination made up of local them. The tribal peoples were churches. Still less like a church quick to acquire Roman military they primarily was an organization called the skills, often serving as mercenar- enabled the Benedictines, which came along ies in the Roman legions. later to compete with the Celts in [These events may remind us Kingdom and establishing missionary com- of our relation to the present-day the power and pounds all over Europe. By the colossus of China. The country of time the Vikings appeared on the China, like the Barbarians north of the glory to be horizon there had spread up Rome, has been crucially affected shared with through Europe over 1,000 such by Christianity even though bit- mission compounds. terly opposed to its alien connec- the barbaric Mission compounds? Protes- tions. And they have gained Anglo-Saxons tants, and perhaps even modern nuclear power. Can you imagine Catholics, must pause at this phe- why they vigorously opposed the and Goths. nomenon. Our problem in under- Pope’s appointment of a Cardinal standing these strange (and much within their midst? After the Second World misunderstood) instruments of evangeliza- War they adopted “Chinese communism” ex- tion is not so much our ignorance of what tensively and profoundly, which was a kind these people did as our prejudice which de- of superficial “faith” embodying a number of veloped because of decadent monks who distinctively Christian ingredients—despite lived almost a thousand years later. It is the often grave distortion of those Christian wholly unfair for us to judge the work of a elements. Just as a modicum of Christian traveling evangelist like Columban or faith in some ways strengthened the hand of Boniface by the stagnation of the wealthy the Barbarians against the Romans, so the Augustinians in Luther’s day—although we country of China today is awesomely more must certainly pardon Luther for thinking dangerous due to the cleansing, integrating such thoughts. and galvanizing effect of the Communist phi- It is indisputable that the chief characteris- losophy and cell (structure which is clearly tic of these “Jesus People” in this second pe- derived from the West, and indirectly from riod, whether they were Celtic peregrini (wan- the Christian tradition itself). You can imag- dering evangelists) or their parallel in ine the Barbarians criticizing the softness and Benedictine communes, was the fact that they degeneracy of the Roman Christians just as held the Bible in awe. They sang their way 205 Chapter 33 THE KINGDOM STRIKES BACK through the whole book of Psalms each week preserved and copied manuscripts (not only as a routine discipline. It was primarily they of the Bible but of ancient Christian and non- who enabled the Kingdom and the power and Christian classics as well), we would know the glory to be shared with the barbaric no more about the Roman Empire today than Anglo-Saxons and Goths. we do of the Mayan or Incan empires, or It is true that many strange, even bizarre many other empires that have long since al- and pagan customs were mixed up as sec- most vanished from sight. ondary elements in the various forms of Many Evangelicals might be jolted by the Christianity that were active during the pe- Wheaton professor who wrote an apprecia- riod of the Christianization of Europe. The tive chapter about these disciplined order headlong collision and ongoing competition structures entitled, “The Monastic Rescue of between Western Roman and Celtic (mainly the Church.” One sentence stands out: of Eastern origin) forms of Christianity un- The rise of monasticism was, after Christ’s doubtedly resulted in an enhancement of commission to his disciples, the most im- common biblical elements in their faith. But portant—and in many ways the most ben- we must remember the relative chaos intro- eficial—institutional event in the history of duced by the invasions, and therefore not Christianity (p. 84).1 necessarily expect to see the usual parish churches that once were familiar in rural Curiously, our phrase Third World comes America dotting the landscape. from those days when Greek and Latin were the first two worlds and the barbarians to Enter: The Orders the north were the Third World. Using this Under the particular circumstances of that phrase, Barbarian Europe was won more by time, similar to many chaotic corners of the the witness and labors of Celtic and Anglo- world today, the most durable structure Saxon converts of the Celts—“Third World around was the order—a fellowship much missionaries”—than by the efforts of mis- more highly disciplined and tightly-knit sionaries deriving from Italy or Gaul. This than the usual American Protestant congre- fact was to bear decisively upon the appar- gation today. Its “houses” came to dot the ently permanent shift of power in Western landscape of Europe. We must admit, fur- Europe from the Mediterranean to northern thermore, that these novel Christian com- Europe. Even as late as AD 596, when Rome’s munities not only were the source of spiri- first missionary headed north (with serious tuality and scholarship during the Middle faintheartedness), he incidentally crossed Ages, but they also preserved the technolo- the path of the much more daring and gies of the Roman industrial world—tan- widely-traveled Irish missionary, Columban, ning, dyeing, weaving, metalworking, ma- one of the scholarly Celtic peregrini who had sonry skills, bridge building, etc. Their worked his way practically to Rome’s door- civil, charitable and even scientific contri- step and who was already further from his bution is, in general, grossly underesti- birthplace than Augustine was planning to mated—especially by Protestants who have go from his. developed unfriendly stereotypes about We are not surprised that Constantinople “monks.” Probably the greatest accom- was considered the “Second Rome” by those plishment of these disciplined Christian living in the East, nor that both Aachen (in communities is seen in the simple fact that Charlemagne’s France) and Moscow were almost all our knowledge of the Roman later to compete for recognition as new world is derived from their libraries, whose Romes by the descendants of the newly silent testimony reveals the appreciation Christianized Franks and Slavs, respectively. they had, even as Christians, for the “pa- Neither the original Rome as a city nor the gan” authors of ancient times. Italian peninsula as a region were ever again Thus, in our secular age it is embarrassing to be politically as significant as the chief cit- to recognize that had it not been for these ies of the new nations—Spain, France, Ger- highly literate “mission field” Christians who many, and England. RALPH D. WINTER 205

Enter Charlemagne pire. This reality underlies Thomas Cahill’s Toward the end of the second period, as with book, How the Irish Saved Civilization. the end of each of these periods, there was a The Celtic Christians and their Anglo-Saxon great flourishing of Christianity within the and Continental converts especially treasured new cultural basin. The rise of a strong man the Bible. Mute testimony to the Bible as their like Charlemagne facilitated communication chief source of inspiration is that the highest throughout Western Europe to a degree un- works of art during these “dark” centuries known for 300 years. Under his sponsorship a were marvelously “illuminated” biblical whole range of issues—social, theological, po- manuscripts and devoutly ornamented church litical—were soberly restudied in the light of buildings. Manuscripts of non-Christian classi- the Bible and the writings of earlier Christian cal authors, though preserved and copied, leaders in the Roman period. Charlemagne were not illuminated. Through the long night was a second Constantine in certain respects, of the progressive breakdown of the Western and his influence was unmatched in Western part of the Roman Empire, when the tribal mi- Europe during a half a millennium. grations reduced almost all of life in the West But Charlemagne was much more of a to the level of the tribesmen themselves, the Christian than Constantine and as such indus- two great regenerating ideals were the hope of triously sponsored far more Christian activity. building anew the glory that was once Rome, Like Constantine, his official espousal of and the hope of making everything subject to Christianity produced many Christians who the Lord of Glory. The one really high point, were Christians in name only. There is little when these twin objectives were most nearly doubt that the great missionary Boniface was achieved, was during Charlemagne’s long, slain by the Saxons because his patron, vigorous career centered around the year 800. Charlemagne (with whose military policies he As one recent scholar put it, did not at all agree) had brutally suppressed In the long sweep of European history, from the Saxons on many occasions. Then, as in our the decline of the Roman Empire to the own recent past, the political force of a colo- flowering of the Renaissance nearly a thou- nial power did not so much pave the way for sand years later, his [Charlemagne’s] is the Christianity, as turn people against the faith. sole commanding presence. Of interest to missionaries is the fact that the No wonder recent scholars call great centers of learning established by Charlemagne’s period the Carolingian Re- Charlemagne were copies and expansions of naissance, and thus replace the concept of a newly established mission compounds deep single lengthy “dark ages” for a more precise in German territory, themselves outposts that perspective of a First Dark Ages early in this were the work of British and Celtic missionar- period, and a Second Dark Ages early in the ies from sending centers as far away to the next period, with a “Carolingian Renais- west as Britain’s Iona and Lindisfarne. sance” in between. Indeed, the first serious attempt at any- Unfortunately, the rebuilt empire (later to thing like public education was initiated by be called the Holy Roman Empire) was un- this great tribal chieftain, Charlemagne, on able to find the ingredients of a the advice and impulse of Anglo-Celtic mis- Charlemagne in his successor; even more sionaries and scholars from Britain, such as ominously, a new threat now posed itself ex- Alcuin, whose projects eventually required ternally. Charlemagne had been eager for his the help of thousands of literate Christians own peoples to be made Christian—the Ger- from Britain and Ireland to man schools manic tribes. He offered wise, even spiritual founded on the Continent. It is hard to be- leadership in many affairs, but did not lieve, but formerly “barbarian” Irish teachers throw his weight behind any kind of bold of Latin (never a native tongue in Ireland) mission outreach to the Scandinavian were eventually needed to teach Latin in peoples to the north. What missionary work Rome. This indicates extensively how the was begun under his son was too little and tribal invasions of other barbarians had bro- too late. This fact contributed greatly to the ken down the civilization of the Roman Em- undoing of the his empire. 207 Chapter 33 THE KINGDOM STRIKES BACK

Period III: Winning the Vikings, and anguish before this spectacle of the A.D. 800–1200 destruction of the Christian people.2 No sooner had the consolidation in Western No wonder the Anglican prayer book con- Europe been accomplished under tains the prayer, “From the fury of the Charlemagne than a new menace appeared Northmen, O Lord, deliver us.” Once more, to peace and prosperity. This new menace— when Christians did not reach out to them, pa- the Vikings—would create a second period gan peoples came after what the Christians of at least semi-darkness to last 250 years. possessed. And once more, the phenomenal These savages further north had not yet power of Christianity manifested itself: the been effectively evangelized. While the conquerors became conquered by the faith of tribal invaders of Rome, who created the their captives. First Dark Ages, were rough forest people, Usually it was they were, for the most part, nominally the monks And once more, the Arian Christians. The Vikings, by contrast, sold as slaves phenomenal power were neither civilized nor even lightly or Christian Christian. There was another difference: the girls forced to of Christianity Vikings were men of the sea. This meant be their wives manifested itself: the that key island sanctuaries for missionary and mistresses training, like Iona, or like the offshore prom- who eventu- conquerors became ontory of Lindisfarne (connected to the land ally won these conquered by the only at low tide), were as vulnerable to at- savages of the tacking seafarers as they had been invulner- north. In faith of their captives. able to attackers from the land. In this new God’s provi- period both of these mission centers were dence their redemption became more impor- sacked more than a dozen times, their occu- tant than the harrowing tragedy of this new pants slaughtered or sold off as slaves. It invasion of barbarian violence and evil which seems unquestionable that the Christians of fell upon God’s own people whom He loved. Charlemagne’s empire would have fared far After all, He spared not His own Son in order better had the Vikings had at least the ap- to redeem us! Thus, again, what Satan in- preciation of the Christian faith that the ear- tended for evil, God used for good. lier barbarians had when they overran In the previous hundred years, Rome. The very opposite of the Visigoths Charlemagne’s scholars had carefully col- and Vandals who spared the churches, the lected the manuscripts of the ancient world. Vikings seemed attracted like magnets to the Now the majority were to be burned by the monastic centers of scholarship and Chris- Vikings. Only because so many copies had tian devotion. They took a special delight in been made and scattered so widely did the burning churches, in putting human life to fruits of the Charlemagnic literary revival the sword right in the churches, and in sell- survive at all. Once scholars and missionar- ing monks into slavery. These depraved ies had streamed in peace from Ireland people even sold into North African slavery across England and onto the continent, and the raided daughters of nearby antagonistic even out beyond the frontiers of Vikings. A contemporary’s words give us a Charlemagne’s empire. Under the brunt of graphic impression of their carnage in these new violent invasions from the north, “Christian” Europe: the Irish volcano which had poured forth a The Northmen cease not to slay and carry passionate fire of evangelism for three centu- into captivity the Christian people, to de- ries cooled almost to extinction. Viking war- stroy the churches and to burn the towns. riors, newly based in Ireland, followed the Everywhere, there is nothing but dead bod- paths of the earlier Irish peregrini across En- ies—clergy and laymen, nobles and com- gland and onto the continent, but this time mon people, women and children. There is ploughing waste and destruction rather than no road or place where the ground is not new life and hope. covered with corpses. We live in distress RALPH D. WINTER 207

There were some blessings in this horrify- “mother” house. The Cluny revival, moreover, ing disguise. Alfred the Great, a tribal chief- produced a new reforming attitude toward so- tain (“king”) of Wessex, successfully headed ciety as a whole. up guerrilla resistance and was equally con- The greatest bishop in Rome in the first cerned about spiritual as well as physical millennium, Gregory I, was the product of a losses. As a measure of emergency, he gave Benedictine community. So also, early in the up the ideal of maintaining the Latin tongue second millennium, Hildebrand was a prod- as a general pattern for worship and began a uct of the Cluny reform. His successors in re- Christian library in the vernacular—the form were bolstered greatly by the Cistercian Anglo-Saxon. This was a decision of monu- revival which went even further. Working be- mental importance which might have been hind the scenes for many years for wholesale delayed several centuries had the tragedy of reform across the entire church, he finally be- the Vikings not provided the necessity which came Pope Gregory VII for a relatively brief was the mother of this invention. period. But his reforming zeal set the stage In any case, as Christopher Dawson puts it, for Pope Innocent III, who wielded greater the unparalleled devastation of England and power (and all things considered, greater the Continent was “not a victory for pagan- power for good) than any other Pope before ism.” The Northmen who landed on the Con- or since. Gregory VII had made a decisive tinent under Rollo became the Christianized step toward wresting control of the church Normans, and the Danish who took over a from secular power—this was the question of huge section of middle England (along with “lay investiture.” It was he who allowed invaders from Norway who planted their own Henry IV to wait for three days out in the kind in many other parts of England and Ire- snow at Canossa. Innocent III not only car- land) also were soon to become Christians. ried forward Gregory’s reforms, but had the The gospel was too powerful. One result was distinction of being the Pope who authorized that a new Christian culture spread back into the first of a whole new series of mobile mis- Scandinavia. This stemmed largely from En- sion orders—the Friars. gland from which came the first monastic Our First Period ended with a barely communities and early missionary bishops. Christian Roman Empire and a somewhat What England lost, Scandinavia gained. Christian emperor—Constantine. Our sec- It must also be admitted that the Vikings ond period ended with a reconstitution of would not have been attracted either to the that empire under a Christianized barbarian, churches or to the monasteries had not those Charlemagne, who was devoutly and vigor- centers of Christian piety to a great extent suc- ously Christian. Can you imagine an em- cumbed to luxury. The switch from the Irish to peror who wore a monk’s habit? Our third the Benedictine pattern of monasticism was an period ends with a pope, Innocent III, as the improvement in many respects, but appar- strongest man in Europe, made strong by ently allowed greater possibilities for the de- the Cluny, Cistercian and allied spiritual velopment of an unchristian opulence and movements which together are called the glitter which attracted the greedy eyes of the Gregorian Reform. The scene was now an Norsemen. Thus, another side-benefit of the enlarged Europe in which no secular ruler new invasions was their indirect cleansing could survive without at least tipping his and refinement of the Christian movement. hat to the leaders in the Christian move- Even before the Vikings appeared, Benedict of ment. It was a period in which European Aniane inspired a rustle of reform here and Christians had not reached out in missions, there. By 910, at Cluny, a novel and significant but they had at least with phenomenal step forward was begun. Among other speed grafted in the entire northern area, changes, the authority over a monastic center and had also deepened the foundations of was shifted away from local politics, and for Christian scholarship and devotion passed the first time beyond anything previous whole on from the Europe of Charlemagne. networks of “daughter” houses arose which The next period would unfold some were related to a single, strongly spiritual happy and unhappy surprises. Would Eu- 209 Chapter 33 THE KINGDOM STRIKES BACK rope now take the initiative in reaching out this sorry movement was an authentically de- with the Gospel? Would it sink in self-satis- vout man, Bernard of Clairvaux, to whom are faction? In some respects it would do both. attributed the words of the hymn Jesus the Very Thought of Thee. He preached the first crusade. Period IV: Winning the Saracens? Two Franciscans, Francis of Assisi and A.D.1200–1600 Raymond Lull, stand out as the only ones in The fourth period began with a spectacular, this period whose insight into God’s will led new evangelistic instrument—the Friars— them to substitute for warfare and violence and after the disaster of the prolonged plague the gentle words of the evangel as the proper would end with the greatest, the most vital, means of extending the blessing God con- and most disruptive reformation of all. How- ferred on Abraham and had always intended ever, the Christian movement had already for all of Abraham’s children-of-faith. been involved for a hundred years in the At this point we must pause to reflect on most massive and tragic misconstrual of this curious period. We may not succeed, but Christian mission in all of history. Ironically, let us try to see things from God’s point of part of the “flourishing” of the faith toward view, treading with caution and tentativeness. the end of the previous period led to disaster: We know, for example, that at the end of the never before had any nation or group of na- First Period after three centuries of hardship tions in the name of Christ launched as ener- and persecution, just when things were appar- getic and sustained a campaign into foreign ently going great, invaders appeared and territory as did Europe in the tragic debacle chaos and catastrophe ensued. Why? That fol- of the Crusades. This was in part the carry- lowed the period we have called the “Classical over of the Viking spirit into the Christian Renaissance.” It was both good and not so Church. All of the major Crusades were led good. Just when Christians were translating by Viking descendants. the Bible into Latin and waxing eloquent in While the Crusades had many political theological debate, when Eusebius, as the overtones (they were often a unifying device government’s official historian, was editing a for faltering rulers), they would not have hap- massive collection of previous Christian writ- pened without the vigorous but misguided ings, when heretics were thrown out of the em- sponsorship of Christian leaders. They were pire (and became, however reluctantly, the not only an unprecedented blood-letting to the only missionaries to the Goths), when Rome fi- Europeans themselves and a savage wound in nally became officially Christian… then sud- the side of the Muslim peoples (a wound denly the curtain came down. Now, out of which is not healed to this day), but they were chaos God would bring a new cluster of a fatal blow even to the cause of Greek/Latin people groups to be included in the “blessing,” Christian unity and to the cultural unity of that is, to be confronted with the claims, privi- eastern Europe. In the long run, though West- leges, and obligations of the expanding King- ern Christians held Jerusalem for a hundred dom of God. years, the Crusaders by default eventually Similarly, at the end of the Second Period, gave the Eastern Christians over to the Otto- after three centuries of chaos during which man sultans. Far worse, they established a the rampaging Gothic hordes were eventu- permanent image of brutal, militant Christian- ally Christianized, tamed and civilized, ity that alienates a large proportion of man- Bibles and biblical knowledge proliferated as kind, tearing down the value of the very word never before. Major biblical-missionary cen- Christian in missions to this day. ters were established by the Celtic Christians Ironically, the mission of the Crusaders and their Anglo-Saxon pupils. In this would not have been so appallingly negative Charlemagnic (actually “Carolingian”) re- had it not involved so high a component of naissance, thousands of public schools led by abject Christian commitment. The great lesson Christians attempted mass biblical and gen- of the Crusades is that goodwill, even sacrifi- eral literacy. Charlemagne dared even to at- cial obedience to God, is no substitute for a tack the endemic use of alcohol. Great theolo- clear understanding of His will. Significant in gians tussled with theological/political RALPH D. WINTER 209

issues, The Venerable Bede became the Jesus Himself came unto His own, and His Eusebius of this period (indeed, when both own received Him not, yet Jesus rather than Charlemagne and Bede were much more the resisting people went to the cross. Per- Christian than Constantine and Eusebius). haps Satan’s evil intent—of removing the And, once again, invaders appeared and messenger—God employed as a judgment chaos and catastrophe ensued. Why? against those who chose not to hear. Strangely similar, then, is the third period. In any case, the invasion of the Bubonic In its early part it only took two and a half plague, first in 1346 and every so often dur- centuries for the Vikings to capitulate to the ing the next decade, brought a greater set- “counterattack of the Gospel.” The “renais- back than the Gothic, the Anglo-Saxon or the sance” ensuing toward the end of this period Viking invasions. It first devastated parts of was longer than a century and far more ex- Italy and Spain, then spread west and north tensive than ever before. The Crusades, the to France, England, Holland, Germany and cathedrals, the so-called Scholastic theolo- Scandinavia. By the time it had run its course gians, the universities, most importantly the 40 years later, one third to one half of the blessed Friars, and even the early part of the population of Europe was dead. Especially Humanistic Renaissance make up this stricken were the Friars and the truly spiri- outsized 1050-1350 outburst of a Medieval tual leaders. They were the ones who stayed Renaissance, or the “Twelfth Century Renais- behind to tend the sick and to bury the dead. sance.” But then suddenly a new invader ap- Europe was absolutely in ruins. The result? peared—the Black plague—more virulent There were three rival Popes at one point, the than ever, and chaos and catastrophe greater humanist elements turned menacingly hu- than ever occurred. Why? manistic, peasant turmoil (often based in jus- Was God dissatisfied with incomplete obe- tice and even justified by the Bible itself) dience? Or was Satan striking back each time in turned into orgies and excesses of violence. greater desperation? Were those with the bless- “The god of this world” must have been ing retaining it and not sufficiently and deter- glad, but out of all that death, poverty, confu- minedly sharing it with the other nations of the sion and lengthy travail, God birthed a new world? More puzzling, the plague that killed reform greater than anything before it. one-third of the inhabitants of Europe killed a Once more, at the end of one of our peri- much higher proportion of the Franciscans: ods, a great flourishing took place. Printing 120,000 were laid still in Germany alone. Surely came to the fore, Europeans finally escaped God was not trying to judge their missionary from their geographical cul de sac and sent fire. Was He trying to judge the Crusaders ships for commerce, subjugation and spiri- whose atrocities greatly outweighed the Chris- tual blessing to the very ends of the earth. tian devotional elements in their movement? If And as a part of the reform, the Protestant so, why did He wait several hundred years to Reformation now loomed on the horizon: do that? Surely Satan, not God, inflicted Chris- that great, seemingly permanent, cultural de- tian leadership in Europe so greatly. Would not centralization of Europe. Satan rather have that happen than for the Cru- Protestants often think of the Reformation saders to die of the plague? as a legitimate reaction against the evils of a Perhaps it was that Europe did not suffi- monstrous Christian bureaucracy sunken in ciently listen to the saintly Friars; that it was decadence and corruption. But it must be ad- not the Friars that went wrong, but the hear- mitted that this re-formation was much more ers who did not respond. God’s judgment than that. This great decentralization of upon Europe then might have been to take Christendom was in many respects the result the Gospel away from them, to take away the of an increasing vitality which—although Friars and their message. Even though to us this is unknown to most Protestants—was it seems like it was a judgment upon the mes- just as evident in Italy, Spain and France as in sengers rather than upon the resistant hear- Moravia, Germany and England. Everywhere ers, is this not one impression that could be we see a return to a study of the Bible and the received from the New Testament as well? appearance of new life and evangelical 211 Chapter 33 THE KINGDOM STRIKES BACK preaching. The Gospel encouraged believers wide movement of scope unprecedented in to be German, not merely permitted Germans the annals of mankind, one in which there to be Roman Christians. Nevertheless, that was greater Christian missionary awareness marvelous insight was one of the products of than ever before. But, having lost non-Roman a renewal already in progress. (Luther pro- Europe by insisting on its Mediterranean cul- duced not the first but the fourteenth transla- ture, the Catholic tradition would now try to tion of the Bible into German.) Unfortunately, win the rest of the world without fully under- the marvelous emphasis on justification by standing what had just happened. faith—which was preached as much in Italy But why did the Protestants not even try to and Spain as in Germany at the time Luther reach out? Catholic missionaries for two hun- loomed into view—became identified and dred years preceded Protestant missionaries. ensnarled with German nationalistic (sepa- Some scholars point to the fact that the Protes- ratist) hopes and was thus, understandably, tants did not have a global network of colonial suppressed as a dangerous doctrine by politi- outreach. Well, the Dutch Protestants did. cal powers in Southern Europe. And, their ships, unlike those from Catholic It is merely a typical Protestant misunder- countries, carried no missionaries. This is why standing that there was not as much a revival the Japanese—once they began to fear the of deeper life, Bible study and prayer in South- Christian movement Catholic missionaries ern Europe as in Northern Europe at the time planted—would allow only Dutch ships into of the Reformation. The issue may have ap- their ports. Indeed, the Dutch even cheered peared to the Protestants as faith vs. law, or to and assisted the Japanese in the slaughter of the Romans as unity vs. division, but such the budding Christian (Catholic) community. popular scales are askew because it was much more a case of over reaching Latin uniformity Period V: To the Ends of the Earth, vs. national and indigenous diversity. The ver- A.D. 1600–2000 nacular had to eventually conquer. The period from 1600 to 2000 began with Eu- While Paul had not demanded that the ropean footholds in the rest of the world. Greeks become Jews, nevertheless the Ger- Apart from taking over what was relatively mans had been obliged to become Roman. an empty continent by toppling the Aztec The Anglo-Saxons and the Scandinavians and Inca empires in the Western hemisphere, had at least been allowed their vernacular to Europeans had only tiny enclaves of power an extent unknown in Christian Germany. in the heavily populated portions of the rest Germany was where the revolt then reason- of the non-Western world. By 1945, Europe- ably took place. Italy, France, and Spain, ans had achieved virtual control over 99.5% which were formerly part of the Roman Em- of the non-Western world. This would not pire and extensively assimilated culturally in last. The peoples inhabiting the colonial em- that direction, had no equivalent nationalis- pires had grown significantly in knowledge tic steam behind their reforming movements and initiative, just as the Goths had grown and thus became almost irrelevant in the po- strong outside the bounds of the Roman em- litical polarity of the scuffle that ensued. pire. The Second World War mightily dis- However—here we go again—despite the tracted the Western nations from their colo- fact that the Protestants won on the political nial hold on the rest of the world. That did it. front, and to a great extent gained the power Nationalism exploded. to formulate anew their own Christian tradi- Twenty-five years later, the Western nations tion and certainly thought they took the Bible had lost control over all but 5% of the non- seriously, they did not even talk of mission Western population of the world. This 1945- outreach. Rather, the period ended with Ro- 1969 period of the sudden collapse of Western man Europe expanding both politically and control, coupled with the unexpected upsurge religiously on the seven seas. Thus, entirely of significance of the Christian movement in unshared by Protestants for at least two cen- the non-Western world, I have elsewhere turies, the Catholic variety of Christianity ac- called “the twenty-five unbelievable years.” If tively promoted and accompanied a world- we compare this period to the collapse of the RALPH D. WINTER 211 CE – 1914 1950 2000 p. 1,478 – The 1815 1914 Evangelical Renaissance – 1750 1815 p. 1,349 CE the Renaissance in fourth epoch, Islam militar- culturally, had become politically, superior to numerically, and even ily, this had ways In many “Christianity.” been true for more than half of the Chris- is not surprising since This tian period. of the expansion Islam built on a much just as Christianity Christian substratum, substratum. a had earlier built on Jewish The 1600 1500 – 1750 Reformation Renaissance & – 1350 1500

A History of p. 1,063 p. 1,001 CE The ) and thus does not consider 1200 Renaissance 12th Century 950 – 1350 One reason Latuorette saw this differ- One reason Latuorette saw In any case, Islam, although starting In any ently is that he was concerned strictly with ently is that he was is not is called “Christianity” (which what illogical in a book entitled Christianity a largely positive the Islamic movement tradition. expression of the same “Judaic” far more illus- became an advance later, upbringing nor- Western trious than our us to realize. By the time of mally allows p. 689 CE 800 p. 601 Carolingian Renaissance 500 – 950 The most important thing revealed by most important thing revealed The Latourette calls “Resurgences” of Chris- represent the shaded ovals while tianity, “Recessions.” this comparison is the fact that all four of “Resurgences” correspond to Latourette’s timeline. upper the “Renaissances” of only significant difference is that he The does not honor the Carolingian Renais- other scholars sance to the extent many do. p. 381 CE 400 p. 269 Renaissance The Classical The AD 0 – AD 500 AD 0 – ROMAN BASIN BASIN GOTHIC BASIN SCANDINAVIAN COASTLANDS GLOBAL THE EARTH ENDS OF

The periods The and pages of Latourette's A History of Christianity CE p. 0 0 The dark-lined upper grid of 400-year line represents the pages lower The As the faith moved in to each new cultural basin it struggled new cultural in to each As the faith moved before gaining acceptance in a flourishing period which called a “Renaissance.” have scholars “epochs” is designed to be easy re- “epochs” member not to determine the reality of the most significant However, history. expansions of the Christian faith are re- More flected at least roughly in this way. “renais- the existence of five importantly, sances” is also highlighted. to the timeline above. Latourette devotes represent what unshaded ovals The Renaissance in Five Epochs in Five Renaissance Pulses in Western Civilization in Western Pulses 213 Chapter 33 THE KINGDOM STRIKES BACK

Western Roman Empire’s domination over its conquered the world. No longer, for example, conquered provinces of Spain, Gaul and Brit- is the long-standing Chinese tradition of inge- ain, and to the breakdown of control over non- nious torture likely to be boasted about in Frankish Europe under Charlemagne’s succes- China nor highly respected anywhere else, at sors, we might anticipate—at least by the logic least in public circles. of sheer parallelism—that the Western world But this worldwide transformation has not itself will soon be significantly dominated by come about suddenly. Even the present, mini- non-Westerners. mal attainment of worldwide Christian moral- With some reason, ever since the collapse of ity on a tenuous public level has been accom- Western power became obvious (during “the plished only at the cost of a great amount of twenty-five unbelievable years”), there have sacrificial missionary endeavor (during the been many who have decried the thought of four centuries of Period Five), missionary la- any further missionary effort moving from the bors which have been mightier and more de- West to the non-Western world. Perhaps they liberate than at any time in 2,000 years. The have confused the inappropriateness of politi- first half (1600-1800) of this fifth period was al- cal control with a need to most exclusively a Roman cut ties of faith in any fur- show. By the year 1800 it ther foreign missions. There will be the defeat of was painfully embarrass- The true situation is ac- Satan’s power holding ing to Protestants to hear tually very different. In Roman missionaries writ- fact, the absence of politi- millions of people hostage ing off the Protestant cal control for the first in thousands of peoples— movement as apostate time in many areas has simply because it was not now begun to allow non- peoples which have too sending missionaries. But Western populations to long “sat in darkness” and by that same year, Roman yield to the Kingdom of missionary effort had been Christ without simulta- who “shall see a great light” forced into sudden decline neously yielding to the (Matt 4:16). due to the curtailment of political kingdoms of the the Jesuits, and the com- Western world. Here we see a parallel to the bined effect of the French Revolution and en- Frankish tribal people accepting the faith of suing chaos which then cut the European eco- Rome only after Rome had lost its military nomic roots of Catholic missions. power. This new openness to Catholic Chris- However, the year 1800 marks the awak- tianity continued among the Anglo-Saxons, ening of the Protestants from two-and-a-half Germans and Scandinavians up until the centuries of inactivity, if not theological slum- time when the emergence of strong papal au- ber, in regard to missionary outreach across thority, mixed with power politics, became a the world. The 1800 to 2000 year period is threat to legitimate national ambitions, and treated in the chapter “Four Men, Three Eras, led to a Reformation which allowed national- Two Transitions: Modern Missions.” During ized forms of Christianity to break away. this final period, for the first time, Protestants The present spectacle of a Western world equipped themselves with organizational flaunting the standards of Christian morality structures of mission comparable to the in more obvious ways than ever may dissuade Catholic orders and began to make up for non-Christian nations from embracing the lost time. Unheralded, unnoticed, and all but Christian faith; but it may also tend to disasso- forgotten in our day except for ill-informed ciate the treasure of Christian ideals from a criticism, Protestant missionary efforts in this Western world which has, until this age, been period, more than Catholic missions, led the their most prominent sponsor. When Asians way in establishing throughout the world the accuse Western nations of immorality in war- democratic apparatus of government, the fare, they are appealing to Christian values, schools, the hospitals, the universities and certainly not the values of any nation’s pagan the political foundations of the new nations. past. In this sense, Christianity has already Rightly understood, Protestant missionaries, RALPH D. WINTER 213 along with their Roman Catholic counter- we have every reason to suppose from past parts, are surely not less than the prime mov- experience that the Christian, biblical faith ers of the tremendous energy that is mush- will clearly survive in one form or another. rooming in the Third World today. Take We can readily calculate that during the China, for example. Two of its greatest mod- 20th century, Westerners dropped from 18% ern leaders, Sun Yat-sen and Chiang Kai- to 8% of the world population. But we cannot shek, were both Christians. Teng Hsiao- ultimately be pessimistic. Beyond the agony P’ing’s “Four Modernizations” were of Rome was the winning of the Barbarians. principal emphases of the Western mission Beyond the agony of the Barbarians was the movement in China. Missions had planted a winning of the Vikings. Beyond the agony of university in every province of China, etc. the Western world we can only pray that But, if the Western home base is now to there will be the defeat of Satan’s power falter and to fail as the tide is reversed holding millions of people hostage in thou- through the rising power of its partially sands of peoples—peoples which have too evangelized periphery (as is the pattern in long “sat in darkness” and who “shall see a the earlier periods), we can only refer to great light” (Matt 4:16). And we can know Dawson’s comment on the devastation that there is no basis in the past or in the wrought by the Vikings—that this will not be present for assuming that things are out of a “victory for paganism.” The fall of the West the control of the Living God. will, in that case, be due in part to a decay of If we in the West insist on keeping our spirit. It will also be due to the pagan power blessing instead of sharing it, then we will, in the non-Western world emboldened and like other nations before us, have to lose our strengthened by its first contact with Chris- blessing for the remaining nations to receive tian faith. It may come as a most drastic pun- it. God has not changed His plan in the last ishment to a Western world that has always 4,000 years. But how much better not to focus spent more on cosmetics than it has on for- on how to retain but to strive intentionally to eign missions—and lately ten times as much. extend that marvelous “blessing”! That way From a secular or even nationalistic point “in you and in your descendants all of the of view, the next years may be a very dark peoples of the world will be blessed.” This is period for the Western world. The normal the only way we can continue in God’s bless- hopes and aspirations of Christian people for ing. The expanding Kingdom is not going to their own country may find only a very slight stop with us (although it may leave us be- basis for optimism. But if the past is any hind). “This Gospel of the Kingdom must be guide at all, even this will have to be dark- preached in the whole world as a testimony ness before the dawn. The entire Western to all peoples, and then shall the end come” world in its present political form may be (Matt 24:14). God can raise up others if we radically altered. We may not even be sure falter. Indeed, the rest of this book indicates about the survival of our own country. But that is already happening.

End Notes 1. Mark A. Noll, Turning Points, Decisive Moments in the History of Christianity (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 1997), p. 84. 2. Christopher Dawson, Religion and the Rise of Western Culture, (New York: Image Books, 1991), p. 87.

Study Questions 1. Illustrate this thesis: “The conferring of the blessing brings sober responsibility, dangerous if unfulfilled.” 2. Explain the cultural and social dynamics behind the Protestant Reformation. 3. Winter contends that history is a “single, coherent drama.” What are the outlines of the “plot”? What themes are repeated? What major lessons are to be observed?