FIRE PROTECTION ENGINEERING | Magazine.Sfpe.Org | Q3 2016 FIRE PROTECTION
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FIRE PROTECTION Q3 2016 / ISSUE #71 Special Hazards Fire Protection Systems DATA CENTER FIRE PROTECTION A CASE STUDY ON OXYGEN REDUCTION FIRE PROTECTION AN UPDATE ON WATER MIST FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS The Official Magazine of SFPE Join Us. JENSEN HUGHES is the largest and unique opportunity to show your “A” game while most experienced specialty engineering consulting challenging yourself. You’re one of the best. frm in the world. When you join us, you’ll use Become one of us, let everyone see it. your talents to save lives and protect property. Visit www.jensenhughes.com/joinus or call us Whether you’re a recent engineering graduate at 410-737-8677 to put your career on the or a seasoned consultant, you’ll have the technical fast track. We are here. Join us. JH-16-2 World Ad 8.5x10.875 R.indd 1 1/6/16 10:58 AM WHATEVER THE HAZARD, WE’VE GOT YOU COVERED PRE-ENGINEERED SYSTEMS ENGINEERED SYSTEMS FOR SMALL SPACES: FOR LARGE SPACES: Detect and suppress fires automatically High-pressure performance in a low pressure system Reacts 10x faster than conventional systems Compatible with “clean” extinguishing agents Compatible with most extinguishing agents Less piping and greater fill density Listings and approvals vary by agent and system type LEARN MORE AT: www.firetrace.com FIRETRACE INTERNATIONAL - WORLD HEADQUARTERS FIRETRACE INTERNATIONAL LTD - EMEA OFFICE 8435 N. 90th St., Suite 2, Scottsdale, AZ 85258, USA. Unit 11, IO Centre, Salbrook Road, Salfords, Surrey, RH1 5DY, UK. Tel: +1 480 607 1218 • Email: [email protected] Tel: +44 (0) 1293 780 390 • Email: [email protected] CONTENTS COVER STORY Special Hazards Fire Protection: 22 Developments Since Halon 1301 It has been nearly 22 years since the production of halon 1301 ceased in the United States and many other developed and developing countries. This article will reflect on that time in history and examine many of the significant developments in fire and explosion suppression that were a direct result. By Jeff L. Harrington, P.E., FSFPE Data Center Fire Protection: Oxygen Reduction An Update on Water Mist 34 Adapting to a Constantly 40 Fire Protection 101: An 46 Fire Protection Systems Changinge Environment Introductioon and Case Study A new technical report from SP Data center designs have become For approximately 20 years, fire (Technical Institute of Sweden) a playground for creative problem protection systems have been presents the results of the solvers and new products. The areas developing a new approach to development of water mist fire of information technology, electrical providing a primary means of fire protection systems over the last power, and equipment cooling—The protection for enclosed spaces. Read few years. This report a) describes Big Three—seem to be reinvented every more about a case study where new technology and presents the five years. This constant reimagining of oxygen reduction systems protect results of confirmatory trials for the data center is driven by the need for the largest cold storage warehouse in various applications, b) describes a larger capacity to address software North America. installation regulations together with test methods and their applications, and data demands as consistently as By Adam Barowy and Scott Creighton, F(PE) possible with zero downtime. and c) presents examples of both good and bad experience from real By Lee A. Kaiser, P.E. installations. By Magnus Arvidson 2 FIRE PROTECTION ENGINEERING | magazine.sfpe.org | Q3 2016 FIRE PROTECTION Q3 2016 / ISSUE #71 EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD MAGAZINE PERSONNEL DEPARTMENTS Carl F . Baldassarra, P .E ., FSFPE TECHNICAL EDITOR Wiss, Janney, Elstner Associates, Inc. Chris Jelenewicz, P .E ., FSFPE From the SFPE President . 4 Don Bathurst, FSFPE MANAGING EDITOR The Most Interesting Luca Fiorentini Maggie McGary Person in the World Tecso EDITORIAL DIRECTOR Kim Howard, CAE Milosh Puchovsky, P.E., FSFPE Russell P . Fleming, P .E . FSFPE International Fire Sprinkler Association ART DIRECTION AND DESIGN BonoTom Studio, Inc . From the Technical Editor . 6 Gavin Horn, Ph .D . www.bonotom.com Education is Key to Raising Illinois Fire Service Institute ADVERTISING Awareness of Fire Safety for High- William E . Koffel, P .E ., FSFPE Brian Marks Rise Timber Buildings Koffel Associates, Inc. SFPE Media and Event Sales Chris Jelenewicz, P.E., FSFPE R . Thomas Long, Jr ., P .E . [email protected] Exponent 410.316.9855 Letter to the Editor . 8 Fire Protection Engineering (ISSN 1524-900X) is published quarterly by Maria B . Marks, CFPS, SET the Society of Fire Protection Engineers (SFPE), 9711 Washingtonian Re: “Halogenated Flame Siemens, Building Technologies Division Blvd, Suite 380, Gaithersburg, MD 20878, 301.718.2910. Copyright ©2016. The mission of Fire Protection Engineering is to advance Retardant use in Residential Kurt Ruchala P .E ., FSFPE the practice of fire protection engineering and to raise its visibility Settings—Are They Safe for Our JENSEN HUGHES by providing information to fire protection engineers and allied professionals. The opinions and positions stated are those of the Health?” Warren G . Stocker, Jr ., FSFPE individual authors and do not necessarily reflect those of SFPE. Albertsons Companies Viewpoint . 12 Special Hazards Fire Protection Systems By Rick Scott Flashpoints . 16 CORPORATE 100 PARTNER PROGRAM The SFPE Corporate 100 Partners Program was founded in 1976 to strengthen the relationship between industry and Member Profile . 18 fire protection engineering community. Membership in the Corporate 100 Partners Program recognize those who A Lifetime of Advice for the Future support the objectives of SFPE and have a genuine concern for the safety of life and property from fire. of the Profession VISIONARIES The Reliable Automatic Sprinkler Company Wiss, Janney, Elstner Associates, Inc. (WJE) FM Global XL Catlin Property Risk Engineering / GAPS Highlights . 52 Hex. Inc. 2016 Fire Protection Engineering JENSEN HUGHES SUSTAINERS Compensation and Benefits Report Koffel Associates, Inc. Siemens Building Technologies, Inc. ACCÉNT Fire Safety Associates Antal & Associates BENEFACTORS Bourgeois & Associates, Inc. Resources/Calendar . 54 DITEK Corporation Aon Fire Protection Engineering FireLink, LLC Arup Fire Fisher Engineering, Inc. Perspective . 63 Honeywell Fire Safety FlexHead Poole Fire Protection Protecting Assets Today with the Foster Engineering & Consulting, LLC Future in Mind SimplexGrinnell Keltron Corporation Telgian Corporation LeGrand Engineering, Inc. TERPconsulting Liberty Mutual Property Ad Index . 64 Tyco Fire and Building Products, Inc. Mexican Association of Automatic Fire Sprinklers Victaulic (AMRACI) Micropack Detection, Inc. PATRONS ORR Protection Systems Go to Automatic Fire Alarm Association (AFAA) Phoenix Fire Systems Bosch Security Systems Professional Loss Control magazine .sfpe .org Code Consultants, Inc. Robert M. Gagnon, P.E., SET, FSFPE Coffman Engineers Rollinger Engineering Inc. ■ To access online versions of Harrington Group, Inc. Seneca Fire Engineering, LLC all articles Hochiki Corporation Sheladia Associates, Inc. HSB Professional Loss Control Slicer & Associates, LLC International Fire Safety Consulting SoniTech Pipe Inspection ■ To access archives of James W. Nolan, Emeritus Stat-X Aerosol Fire Suppress (mfr. by Fireaway, Inc.) Emerging Trends enewsletter (now JBA Consulting Engineers The University of Maryland Online Master’s Degree Mircom Group of Companies Program FPE Extra) National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) Thunderhead Engineering National Fire Sprinkler Association (NFSA) Tom Christman Viking Group, Inc. ■ For information on article Swiss Re The Protectowire Co., Inc. Worcester Polytechnic Institute submission to Fire Protection Engineering Q3 2016 | magazine.sfpe.org | FIRE PROTECTION ENGINEERING 3 FROM THE SFPE PRESIDENT The Most Interesting Person in the World MOST OF US WOULD FEEL A SENSE OF PRIDE OR GRATIFICATION if we heard ourselves described as “the most interesting person in the world.” A variation of this accolade underpinned a successful series of long-run- ning television commercials. The ads amusingly built the image of a fictional but captivating character, one who possesses a range of desirable attributes, such as accomplishment—“He has won the lifetime achievement award, twice”—esteem—“When he visits museums, he’s allowed to touch the art,”—and confidence—“His busi- ness card simply says, I’ll call you.” With strong undercurrents of humor, the marketing strategy importantly, should? How many times have we told someone built a compelling image and convincingly associated a particu- about our career path only to be met with looks of astonishment lar product as a means of realizing such an image. Even though followed by, “I never knew such a career existed. It sounds so the ads were largely portrayed as a joke, they achieved their interesting.” goal of establishing a genuine and powerful connection with an If we rely upon the sale of services or products for our live- intended audience. Solid sales figures over a decade and a ubiq- lihood, we naturally desire to grow and convince the audience uitous web presence punctuated the success of the campaign. of potential buyers. But don’t we also need to reach out to a Watching this commercial prompted me to think of our pro- much broader community about what we do and why we are fession and how fire protection engineers or fire engineers are so uniquely qualified to do it? Shouldn’t the greater populace perceived. What is our image? Who is our audience?