DOCSLIB.ORG

Turkey and Her Nationalist Leaders As Seen in the 1923 Reports of Louise Bryant1

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Turkey and Her Nationalist Leaders As Seen in the 1923 Reports of Louise Bryant1 CHAPTER THREE TURKEY AND HER NATIONALIST LEADERS AS SEEN IN THE 1923 REPORTS OF LOUISE BRYANT1 Howard A. Reed Few of us know about Louise Bryant’s 1923 eyewitness reports on Turkey’s people and their nationalist leaders. Th at is because her papers were lost and forgotten for decades, only to be rediscovered recently. Th e following account is mainly based on those records of Louise Bryant (1885–1936) which were long thought lost. Fortunately they had been preserved by her only daughter, Ms. Anne Moen Bullitt. Ms. Bullitt donated this collection of her mother’s signifi cant papers as well as those of her father, former Ambassador William C. Bullitt, to Yale University’s Sterling Library in 2004–2005. Th ose archives became acces- sible to researchers only the following year. As one of the fi rst scholars to use Bryant’s reporting on Turkey, it is a privilege to share some of her fi rst-hand sympathetic, yet trenchant views on Turkey in 1923. Louise Bryant seemed forgotten for decades aft er she gave up her notable journalistic career for motherhood and a new married life around 1924. She did so shortly aft er leaving Turkey, where she spent months in 1923 reporting for the International News Service. Aft er retiring from journalism, she faded from view. More recently, however, Ms. Bryant has become the subject of sev- eral biographical treatments. In 1973, Barbara Gelb published So Short a Time: A Biography of John Reed and Louise Bryant (New York: W. W. Norton & Co Inc., 1973). Th at work said little about Bryant’s time in Turkey, instead focusing mainly on her career and brief marriage from 1915 until her husband John Reed’s death in Moscow in 1920. Th e 1981 movie “Reds,” featuring Diane Keaton as Louise Bryant, was based on Gelb’s book. On the other hand, Virginia Gardner’s study, “Friend and Lover:” Th e Life of Louise Bryant (New York: Horizon 1 An earlier version of this paper was presented at a conference on Turkish-American relations co-sponsored by Boğaziçi [Bosphorus] and Harran Universities in İstanbul and Şanlıurfa, Turkey, June 5–10, 2006. 84 howard a. reed Press, 1982) includes data on Bryant’s time in Turkey, but says virtu- ally nothing about her observations as a journalist there. In 1996, Mary V. Dearborn, who published Queen of Bohemia, Th e Life of Louise Bryant (Boston & New York: Houghton Miffl in, 1996) also shed light on Bryant’s career. But neither these books nor the movie “Reds” used Louise Bryant’s papers deposited at Yale.2 Louise Bryant’s Life Louise Bryant was born in California, graduated from the University of Nevada, and began her career as a writer, reporter and suff ragette in Portland, Oregon, early in the twentieth century. She performed as an actress and wrote plays for the famed Provincetown Players in which she acted with her second husband, John Reed, and lover, Eugene O’Neill. Reed would become famous as the author of the classic Ten Days that Shook the World (New York: Boni & Liveright, 1922) on the Russian revolution and O’Neill would emerge as a famed American playwright in his own right. In 1917, Louise Bryant was a foreign correspondent reporting on the Western Front in the First World War. Th en she and John Reed spent several months as eyewitnesses to the Bolshevik revolution in Russia. Th ey both interviewed Kerensky, Lenin, Trotsky, Chicherin, peasants and others. Louise met ladies such as Alexandra Kollontai, Marie Spiridovna, leading artists and dancers like Lunacharski and Stanislavski. Both traveled widely and wrote major books on their experiences in Bolshevik Russia. John Reed died of typhus just aft er his return to Moscow from Baku in October 1920 and was the fi rst of two Americans to be buried in the Moscow Kremlin. In Russia in 1921, Louise Bryant also met several important Turkish fi gures. She became acquainted with Ali Fuat [Cebesoy] Pasha, War College classmate and long time associate of Mustafa Kemal [Atatürk]. Ali Fuat had been appointed Nationalist Turkey’s Ambassador to Moscow in November 1920. He arrived at the Soviet capital in February 1921 and served there until May, when he felt obliged to quit his post in the wake of an incident in which his military attachés were accused of conducting a botched espionage operation against the Bolshevik 2 My thanks to Ms. Cynthia Ostroff , Manager, Manuscripts and Archives, Sterling Library, Yale University, Mr. William Massa, and their associates for their kind help with Louise Bryant’s key papers..
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Nota Bene News from the Yale Library
    Spring 2005 Volume XIX, Number 1 Nota Bene News from the Yale Library The Lost Papers of Louise Bryant The personal papers of the pioneering foreign correspon- dent Louise Bryant arrived unexpectedly at the Sterling Memorial Library at Yale University. Thought to be lost, the papers contain such treasures as Bryant’s notes on what she witnessed in Russia during the communist revolution of 1917 and several poems written by the young playwright Eugene O’Neill, apparently never before published. Louise Bryant lived a remarkable life. Born in 1885, she was one of the earliest women to become a star foreign correspondent. Her reporting on the Russian Revolution appeared in hundreds of American news- papers and, for a brief period, she was one of the lead- ing authorities in the United States on the new Soviet government, publishing two books on the subject. She knew personally and interviewed many of the leading figures of revolutionary Russia including Vladimir Lenin, Leon Trotsky, and Alexandr Kerensky. Bryant filled her personal life with similarly noteworthy individuals. Her second husband was the radical journalist John Reed; her third husband was William C. Bullitt, the first American ambassador to the Soviet Union and later ambassador to France; and she had a short but 1919 intense affair with Eugene O’Neill. Poster advertising a lecture by Louise Bryant, The Bryant papers came to Sterling Memorial Library along with the papers of William C. Bullitt as part of a deposit by Anne Moen Bullitt, the daughter of Bryant and Bullitt. Biographers of Bryant believed her personal Lloyd Richards papers at the papers to be lost, but when the boxes arrived, archi- Beinecke Library vists were astonished by the quantity and quality of the materials relating to Louise Bryant.
    [Show full text]
  • The Triumph and Anguish of the Russian Revolution: Bessie Beatty's
    The Triumph and Anguish of the Russian Revolution: Bessie Beatty’s Forgotten Chronicle Lyubov Ginzburg … only time will be able to attribute both the political and the social revolution their true values. Bessie Beatty, the Bulletin, 25 September 1917 The centennial of the Russian Revolution celebrated two and a half years ago has been marked by a pronounced revival of interest in its origins and impact upon modern history all over the globe. The occasion presented an opportunity to revisit the unprecedented social and political upheaval that convulsed the country in 1917, defined the world order for much of the twentieth century, and continues to reverberate in Russian national and international politics to this day. Along with countless newly revealed primary sources which have gradually found their way into the public domain, this event has been encrusted with novel meanings spawned within a growing number of discourses previously excluded from his- torical scrutiny. An example of such a disparity would be an unfortunate slight to gendered narratives in the understanding and interpretation of one of the most controversial social experiments in human history. In spite of the fact that, as with their male counterparts, foreign female correspondents became chroniclers, witnesses, and, in some instances, participants in the thrilling social drama, there have been few references to their representation of the Revolution(s) in its histori- ography.1 Meanwhile, compelled to understanding Russia, while informing com- 1 Although disproportionally less than their men-authored counterparts, women’s narratives have previously sparked some occasional interest among historians and scholars of journalism and women studies.
    [Show full text]
  • Mirrors of Moscow
    MIRRORS OF MOSCOW MIRRORS OF MOSCOW I BY LOUISE BRYANT With five illustrations by CESARE NEW YORK THOMAS SELTZER 1923 Copyright, 1923, by THOMAS SELTZER, INc. All rights reserued ftiJITED IN THB VIUTED STATBS OF A:U:BR.JCA TO THREE WISE EDITORs- M. KOENIGSBERG BRADFORD MERRILL PHILLIP FRANCIS CONTENTS I'AGJ: FoREWORD x1 LENIN AND His SuBORDINATEs 1 JACOB PETERS, FEDORE S. DZERZHINSKY. AND THE ExTRAORDINARY CoMMISSION . 43 ANATOL VASSILIEVITCH LUNACHARSKY AND RussiAN CuLTURE . 69 MICHAEL JVANOVITCH KALININ AND THE PEASANTS 85 MADAME ALEXANDRA KOLLONTAI AND THE WoMAN's MovEMENT • 109 LEON TROTSKY, SoviET WAR LoRD 129 ENVER PASHA AND THE MOHAMMEDANS 147 TIKON AND THE RussiAN CHuRcH 16 5 TcHICHERIN, CoMMISSAR FOR FoREIGN AF- FAIRS, AND HIS SUBORDINATES 179 MAXIM LITVINOV, AssiSTANT CoMMISSAR, LEONID KRASSIN AND SUBORDINATES 197 ~·· ILLUSTRATIONS Fadn1 Pa1t. LENIN 2 KALININ. 86 KoLLONTAI 110 TROTSKY. ENVER PASHA FOREWORD Revolution I The air is filled with flames· and fumes. The shapes of men, seen through the smoke, become distorted and unreal. Promethean super­ men, they seem,· giants in sin ·or virtue, Sa tans or saviours. But, in truth, behind the screen of smoke and flame they are like other men : no larger and no smaller, no better and no worse: all crea­ tures of the same incessant passions, hungers, vani­ ties and fears. So it is in Russia. And in this book I have tried to show the leaders of the revolution as they really are, as I know· them i.n their homes, where the red glare does not penetrate and they live as other men.
    [Show full text]
  • Studies in Atatürk's Turkey
    Studies in Atatürk’s Turkey Th e Ottoman Empire and its Heritage Politics, Society and Economy Edited by Suraiya Faroqhi and Halil Inalcik Advisory Board Firket Adanir, Idris Bostan, Palmira Brummett, Amnon Cohen, Jane Hathaway, Klaus Kreiser, Hans Georg Majer, Ahmet Yaşar Ocak, Abdeljelil Temimi, Gilles Veinstein VOLUME 40 Studies in Atatürk’s Turkey Th e American Dimension Edited by George S. Harris and Nur Bilge Criss LEIDEN • BOSTON 2009 Cover illustration: Ghazi Mustafa Kemal, Chairman of Turkey’s National Assembly, 24 April 1923. Th is book is printed on acid-free paper. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Studies in Atatürk’s Turkey : the American dimension / edited by George S. Harris and Nur Bilge Criss. p. cm. — (Th e Ottoman Empire and its heritage, ISSN 1380-6076 ; v. 40) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-90-04-17434-4 (hbk. : alk. paper) 1. United States—Foreign relations— Turkey. 2. Turkey—Foreign relations—United States. 3. Diplomats—United States— History—20th century. 4. Diplomats—Turkey—History—20th century. 5. United States—Foreign relations—1923–1929. 6. United States—Foreign relations—1929–1933. 7. United States—Foreign relations—1933–1945. 8. Atatürk, Kemal, 1881–1938. 9. Turkey—Foreign relations—1918–1960. I. Harris, George S. (George Sellers), 1931– II. Criss, Bilge. III. Title. IV. Series. E183.8.T8S78 2009 327.730561—dc22 2009012417 ISSN 1380-6076 ISBN 978 90 04 17434 4 Copyright 2009 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, Th e Netherlands. Koninklijke Brill NV incorporates the imprints Brill, Hotei Publishing, IDC Publishers, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers and VSP. All rights reserved.
    [Show full text]
  • Syllabus Bert Gordon 1 the Course Does Today's Russia Represent a Return To
    Russia from the 1917 Revolutions to the Present - Syllabus 1 Bert Gordon The Course Does today’s Russia represent a return to Cold War days when the world sometimes seemed on the brink of nuclear destruction? Is the regime of Vladimir Putin a 21st century reincarnation of tsarist Russia, as some claim? Our class looks at the development of Russia from the 1917 revolutions to the present, in the context of a long-term view of that country’s history. Throughout we will discuss the relations of Russia and the West: similarities and differences. During our first meeting, we look briefly at the vast geographical expanse that is Russia, then survey the development of the Russian state through Peter the Great, incorporating many non-Russian-speaking areas into the growing empire. Our attention then focuses on a significant turning point, the emancipation of the serfs in 1861 (at almost the same time as the end of slavery in the United States). We next discuss the attempts to restructure Russian society following the emancipation of the serfs and the culture of late Tsarist Russia, the world of Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky. In our second meeting, we turn in more depth to the impact of the First World War, which led to two revolutions in 1917, the first overthrowing the tsar, the second establishing Lenin and the Communists in power. The excitement of witnessing what to many looked like the beginning of a new and more socially just era drew Americans such as John Reed and Louise Bryant to Moscow to write about what they saw as the dawn of a golden age.
    [Show full text]
  • Editor's Introduction.Pdf
    Editor’s Introduction Julia L. Mickenberg “It is a noteworthy fact that a large number of those who have written of the present situation in Russia are women,” the writer Margaret Ashmun notes in a 1919 review essay entitled “Russia Through Women’s Eyes”: The modern woman does not shrink from physical hardships, and her imagination overleaps hunger and danger when she sees an issue at stake. Moreover, this is preeminently the age of woman in revolt: and whoever has the courage to rebel against oppression, in actuality or only in spirit, is an object of intense interest to women in general. Any attempt, however bungling, to right a social wrong wins from them a throb of sympathy, even when their better judgment disapproved both method and result.… This strongly developed social sense in the best type of modern woman explains why they have responded to the appeal of Russia in Revolution.1 Behind the Battle Line: Around the World in 1918 by Madeleine Z. Doty (1918) is among the books that Ashmun discusses, as half of that book is devoted to a discus- sion of the revolution unfolding in Russia. And Doty herself was in many ways the prototypical “modern woman.” Today, both Doty and her account of the Russian Revolution are largely forgotten. However, Doty’s own story and her reporting on the revolution, the latter drawn from Behind the Battle Line and reprinted here for the first time as a stand-alone volume, offer much that is of interest to contemporary readers. Doty arrived in St. Petersburg (then called Petrograd) just days after Lenin and the Bolsheviks launched their coup against the Provisional Government, in Novem- ber 1917.
    [Show full text]
  • Volume Iii, Issue 16 the St. John's Colibge Independent Student Weekly Feb
    THE VOLUME III, ISSUE 16 THE ST. JOHN'S COLIBGE INDEPENDENT STUDENT WEEKLY FEB. 8, 1982 A Serious Question I have recently heard someone say that To The Polity: there are no modern heroes. It i-s-· On Wednesday night, January 27, at corrunon to say "som~thing is good" but about 7 p.m., while Juniors and January how often, in 1982, do we exclaim Freshmen were having dinner together in "he or she is noble!" In Homer, in-old the Dining Hall, a group of students fashioned war, noble passions filled began jumping up and down on the second the lives of the young with the incen­ floor of Randall, in order apparently to tive to be noble. But now our wars make a disturbance by way of welcoming and our culture are very different. the newly arrived students. A distur­ When are you filled by a sense of bance it was. The chandeliers swayed noble passion? Where is it today? ominously, and a number of acoustic tiles came loose from the ceiling and fell down onto tables and floor. Luckily, DH.. Weinstein, ' 82 no one was hurt. Observers in the Dining Hall have described the event as "scary" .. This "welcome", we are informed, is a , a year and a week old. We must add: it is a stupid, pointless tra­ dition, with no saving feature, and is / dangerous and destructive as well. ·we I demand that the "tradition" be terminated I forthwith.. \-./e promise that students in a a future year seeking to repeat a "welcome" of this sort will face stiff fines or suspension or expulsion from the College.
    [Show full text]
  • JOHN REED and the RUSSIAN REVOLUTION Also by Eric Homberger
    JOHN REED AND THE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION Also by Eric Homberger JOHN REED * AMERICAN WRITERS AND RADICAL POLITICS, 190~1939 JOHN LE CARRE THE ART OF THE REAL: POETRY IN ENGLAND AND AMERICA SINCE 1939 EZRA POUND: THE CRITICAL HERITAGE (editor) * THE TROUBLED FACE OF BIOGRAPHY (editor with John Charmley) THE CAMBRIDGE MIND (editor with Simon Schama and William Janeway) * THE SECOND WORLD WAR IN FICTION (editor with Holger Klein and John Flower) * Also published by Macmillan John Reed and the Russian Revolution Uncollected Articles, Letters and Speeches on Russia, 1917-1920 Edited by ERIC HaMBERGER Visiting Professor of American Studies University of New Hampshire with JOHN BIGGART Lecturer in Russian History University of East Anglia M MACMILLAN ISBN 978-1-349-21838-7 ISBN 978-1-349-21836-3 (eBook) DOI 10.1007/978-1-349-21836-3 Editorial matter and selection © Eric Hornberger and John Biggart 1992 Softcover reprint of the hardcover 1st edition 1992 978-0-333-53346-8 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 33-4 Alfred Place, London WClE 7DP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. First published 1992 Published by MACMILLAN ACADEMIC AND PROFESSIONAL LTD Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 2XS and London Companies and representatives throughout the world British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Reed, John, 1887-1920 John Reed and the Russian revolution: uncollected articles, letters and speeches on Russia, 1917-1920.
    [Show full text]
  • A Case Study on the Relationship Between Anarcho-Syndicalists and Bolsheviks in Revolutionary Russia, 19
    THE BOLSHEVIK ILLUSION: A CASE STUDY ON THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ANARCHO-SYNDICALISTS AND BOLSHEVIKS IN REVOLUTIONARY RUSSIA, 1917 A Thesis Presented to the faculty of the Department of History California State University, Sacramento Submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS in History by Kyle Joseph Brislan SUMMER 2018 © 2018 Kyle Joseph Brislan ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii THE BOLSHEVIK ILLUSION: A CASE STUDY ON THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ANARCHO-SYNDICALISTS AND BOLSHEVIKS IN REVOLUTIONARY RUSSIA, 1917 A Thesis by Kyle Joseph Brislan Approved by: __________________________________, Committee Chair Dr. Aaron Cohen __________________________________, Second Reader Dr. Christopher Castañeda ____________________________ Date iii Student: Kyle Joseph Brislan I certify that this student has met the requirements for format contained in the University format manual, and that this thesis is suitable for shelving in the Library and credit is to be awarded for the thesis. __________________________, Graduate Coordinator ___________________ Dr. Rebecca Kluchin Date Department of History iv Abstract of THE BOLSHEVIK ILLUSION: A CASE STUDY ON THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ANARCHO-SYNDICALISTS AND BOLSHEVIKS IN REVOLUTIONARY RUSSIA, 1917 by Kyle Joseph Brislan The revolutionary semblance between anarcho-syndicalism and Bolshevism, amplified by the reemergence of populist ideals among factory workers, engendered a temporary alliance between Russia’s anarcho-syndicalists and Bolsheviks at various times during 1917 and the Civil War. Lenin’s vague and politically elusive concepts of revolution and social organization persuaded some anarcho-syndicalists to join the Bolshevik vanguard. Many of Russia’s anarcho-syndicalists fell victim to the Bolshevik illusion, which necessitated the revolution’s success upon the unification of Russia’s revolutionary forces, either to overthrow the Provisional Government or defeat the Whites in the Civil War.
    [Show full text]
  • Chronology (1901 - 1919)
    EMMA GOLDMAN: A GUIDE TO HER LIFE AND DOCUMENTARY SOURCES Candace Falk, Editor and Director Stephen Cole, Associate Editor Sally Thomas, Assistant Editor CHRONOLOGY (1901 - 1919) 1901 January-March Goldman supports herself by working as a nurse in New York City; helps to arrange a U.S. tour for Peter Kropotkin in March and April. Goldman reestablishes friendship with her former lover Edward Brady. April-July Goldman lecture tour begins with a free-speech battle in Philadelphia when she is prevented from speaking before the Shirt Makers Union. Goldman and the organizations that sponsor her talks, including the Single Tax Society, defy police orders; Goldman speaks in public on at least two occasions. On April 14 she speaks at an event sponsored by the Social Science Club; other speakers include Voltairine de Cleyre. Despite the Social Science Club's opposition to Goldman's anarchist views, it passes a resolution protesting the violation of her right to free speech. Speaks in Lynn, Mass., Boston, Pittsburgh, Cleveland, St. Louis, Chicago, and Spring Valley, Ill., on such topics as "Anarchism and Trade Unionism," "The Causes of Vice," and "Cooperation a Factor in the Industrial Struggle." July 15-August 15 Goldman spends a month with her sister Helena, in Rochester, N.Y., traveling briefly to Niagara Falls and to Buffalo, N.Y., to visit the Pan-American Exposition. Early September Goldman visits Alexander Berkman at the penitentiary in Allegheny, Pa., the first time she has seen him in nine years. 1 September 6 President William McKinley shot by self-proclaimed anarchist Leon Czolgosz in Buffalo, N.Y., at the Pan-American Exposition.
    [Show full text]
  • Manuscript Repositories Newsletter Print This Page
    12/5/2016 Society of American Archivists Go Home The Archives Profession About Us Education & Events Publications Members Groups Log in / Log out Manuscript Repositories Newsletter Print this page Join SAA Spring 2005 Contact us From the Chair Society of The Relationship Between the Program Committee and Sections and American Archivists Roundtables 17 North State Street Director of the Russell Library Recipient of the Scone Foundation's 2004 Suite 1425 Archivist Award Chicago, IL 60602­3315 The Peoples Temple Collection at the California Historical Society's North tel 312/606­0722 Baker Research Library is featured in a new play and a new book about fax 312/606­0728 Peoples Temple and Jonestown toll­free 866/722­7858 University of Iowa Horvat Collection of Science Fiction Fanzines Recently Processed Collections at the Moorland­Spingarn Research Center, Howard University Manuscript Department Home Recently Pprocessed Collections at the Richard B. Russell Library for Annual Meeting Bylaws Political Research and Studies at the University of Georgia Leadership The Louise Bryant Papers, Manuscripts and Archives, Sterling Memorial Newsletter Library Resources The Bancroft Library is Moving! Georgia State University Receives NHPRC Grant The Robert A. and Ruth B. Olson Special Collections Fund at the University of Iowa Libraries Nominations Sought For Section Leadership Leadership and Next Deadline From the Chair Cynthia Pease Miller Suddenly last summer, the winds of change swept through when SAA switched from paper to electronic newsletters for all sections and roundtables. This announcement came too late to include in the Summer 2004 newsletter, the last one to be mailed, or to make the announcement at the section meeting in Boston.
    [Show full text]
  • Enver Pasha, Bolsheviks, and Politics of Anticolonial Muslim Nationalism
    272 THE FIRST wORLD wAR AND ITS AFTERMATH France in times of war. Alexandretta was ceded to Turkey (which renamed it Hatay) to minimise that dispute and improve relations with Turkey. French troops in the region were to be reduced. All of this was done at the expense of the previously autonomous Alawite and Druze areas, which were incorpo- rated into Greater Syria, along with the Kurds. The Kurds were passed over during the 1936 Franco-Syrian Treaty because it went against French interests to grant them a state. Though France had previously been committed to minority protection, their strategic interests in the changing political environment of Europe did not allow them to follow through in this instance. Lebanon was granted autonomy due to France’s deep 16 rooted historical relationship with the Maronites. However, they did not have such a commitment to other minorities, which is why the Alawites and Druze The other jihad: Enver Pasha, were also excluded from gaining states. France could not engage militarily in Bolsheviks, and politics of anticolonial the Levant in the event of a war in Europe. Therefore, it needed to appease the biggest threats to their control over the mandate, the National Bloc and Muslim nationalism during the Baku Turkey. Neither wanted an independent Kurdistan. Ironically, relationships Congress 1920 between the Kurds of Syria and the other two groups were strained, in part, due to the Kurdish nationalists’ strong relationship with France, and the means by which they had solidified that relationship. This decision appeared safe Alp Yenen due to the lack of an armed Kurdish movement against the Syrian mandate.
    [Show full text]