MRS 1161:41 Volume 2

Western Australian Al Planning Commission

January 2011 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

Submissions Volume 2 of 2

Cities of Armada le, Bayswater, Belmont, Canning, Cockburn, Fremantle, Gosnells, Joondalup, Rockingham, Stirling, Subiaco, Swan and Wanneroo, Towns of Bassendean and Kwinana and Shires of Kalamunda, Mundaring and Serpentine-Jarrandale

GOVERNMENT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

Submissions 20-Late

Cities of Armadale, Bayswater, Belmont, Canning, Cockburn, Fremantle, Gosnells, Joondalup, Rockingham, Stirling, Subiaco, Swan and Wanneroo, Towns of Bassendean and Kwinana and Shire of Kalamunda, Mundaring and Serpentine-Jarrandale

ill Western Australian \II Planning GOVERNMENT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA Commission

Volume 2 of 2

January 2011 © State of Western Australia Internet: http://www.wa.gov.au

Published by the Western Australian Planning Commission, Albert Facey House, 469 Wellington Street, Perth Western Australia 6000

MRS Amendment 1161/41 Submissions 20-Late Volume 2 of 2 File 809-2-1-74 Pt 2 Published January 2011

ISBN 0 7309 9707 3

Internet: http://www.planning.wa.gov.au e-mail: corporate @planning.wa.gov.au Phone: (08) 9264 7777 Fax: (08)92647566 TTY: (08)92647535

Copies of this document are available in alternative formats on application to the disability services co-ordinator. Alphabetical Listing of Submissions

MRS Amendment 1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

Submission NumberName 4Armada le, City of 6 Bayswater, City of 16 Belmont, City of 12Canning, City of 17Cityscape Holdings, Greg Rowe & Associates on behalf of 13Cockburn, City of 3 Education and Training, Department of 22 Environment and Conservation, Department of 19 Evans, Peter 10 Fremantle, City of 26 Friends of Dianella Bush land 24Friends of Forrestdale (Inc) 25Gosnells, City of 2 Health, Department of 32 Hill, Alan 8 Housing, Department of 23 Indigenous Affairs, Department of 15Joondalup, City of 34Main Roads Western Australia 18Mundaring, Shire of 5 Perth, City of 37Planning, Department of 28Quinns Rocks Environmental Group 11 Rockingham, City of 9 Serpentine-Jarrandale, Shire of

27Sorgiovanni, C Mr and Philip,I Mr,Landvision on behalf of 35State Development, Department of 21 Subiaco, City of 31 Swan River Trust 36Swan, City of

1 Tourism Western Australia 30 Urban Bushland Council WA Inc 14Vincent, Town of 33Wanneroo, City of 20Water Corporation 29Water Corporation,TPG Town Planning and Urban Design on behalf of 7Water, Department of

Late SubmissionsName Bassendean, Town of Sport and Recreation, Department of Kalamunda, Shire of Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) Form 41 Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41 Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

ISUBMISSION NUMBER To:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 460 Wellington Street Submission 20 Perth WA 6000 e_ f,A 7( D./ Name co -2 c (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) Address Postcode

'ontact phone number Email address

The following proposals are the subject of my submission tv\2_5A44E:NJ- o Re- tu'

Submission (Please attach additional pages if required. It is preferred that any additional information be loose rather than bound)

Ps S a car_

ttsql 0

turn over to complete your submission WAT E CORPORATIORN Your Ref: 809-2-1-74 Pt] DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING Our Ref : JT1 2009 11526 VO1 Enquiries: Brett Coombes Telephone: 9420 3165 2 0 JAN 2010

629 Newcastle Street FILE Leederville 6007 WesternAustralia 15 January 2010 PO Box 100 Leederville 6902 Perth Western Australia Mr Ross Parker Tel (+61 8) 9420 2420 Dept of Planning www.watercorporation.com.au 469 Wellington Street ABN 28 003 434 917 PERTH WESTERN AUSTRALIA 6000

Dear Mr Parker

METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME AMENDMENT 1161 / 41 Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

The Water Corporation offers the following comments with regard toproposals in this amendment.

City of Armadale Proposal 1 (Figure 1) Spinebill Close does not provide a connection to the regional open space. The access appears to be via Water Corporation property(Lot 13) containing the Spinebill Water Tank and associated pipe work.

City of Armadale Proposal 8 (Figure 8) A Water Corporation 1400mm nominal diameter water main traversesthe section of land to be rezoned as parks and recreation. A public purposes reservation isapplicable to the land containing this main.

City of Bayswater Proposal 1 (Figure 1) As Lot 151 is owned by the Water Corporation and contains sewerageinfrastructure a public purpose zoning is considered more appropriate for this lot as per otherexamples in this amendment.

City of Gosnells Proposal 5 (Figure 5) As Lot 5018 is owned by the Water Corporation and contains a 900nominal diameter water main a public purpose (WSD) zoning is considered more appropriate for thislot as per other examples in this amendment. 2

Shire of Mundaring Proposal 5 (Figure 5) Land within this proposal is currently the subject of negotiations between the DEC and the Water Corporation regarding the relocation of a DEC depot and allure Water Corporation infrastructure requirements. A separate submission will be forwarded for this proposal.

City of Rockingham Proposal 5 (Figure 5) As Lot 1531 (part of Reserve 42518 vested in the Water Corporation) contains infrastructure in the form of a cathodic ground bed a public purpose (WSD) zoning is considered more appropriate for this lot. Part of Lot 1530 (part of Reserve 42518 vested in the Water Corporation) shown as proposed parks and recreation zoning contains major sewerage infrastructure. A public purpose Zoning (WSD) is considered more appropriate for this lot.

The Water Corporation has no comment on other proposals within this amendment.

If you have any enquiries on these comments Brett Coombes is available on 9420 3165 or [email protected].

Yours sincerely

Rex Bryant Senior Development Planner

( Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment(Substantial) Form 41

Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment1161/41

Parks and RecreationReservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

SUBMISSION NUMBER

To:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission Submission 21 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000

C C 60,6) aco Name (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) Postcode(00 0 g Address ti!Edojc b3 2-4 10 a 0 birt,)gStAti at() c Dv -a. in ,ontact phone numberV3-7 9 2 2-2 Email address

The following proposals are thesubject of my submission SKeAo,PCctJC Co+ CO Co( S_Van % S.±th triQ.,r6ti-4 Information be loose rather than bound) Submission (Please attach additional pages if required.It is preferred that any additional

DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING

2 1 JAN* .2 DID

FILE

turn over to complete yoursubmission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity topersonally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC. You do not have to attend ahearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered indetermining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer to theamendment report and in particular appendix D. Please choose one of the following: I:(No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign) OR

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: Myself My telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours): Postal address:

I would prefer my hearing to be conducted in: Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation) OR Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committeewill be permitted to attend)

You should be aware that: The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissionsmade to the WAPC may ue subject to applications for access under the act. In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on thesesubmissions, copies of your submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties.

All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, alongwith all written submissions, are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approvethe proposed amendment. The WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissions andtabled in Parliament.

To be signed by person(s) making the submission

Signature Watio \Ns DateV1 kr3 01(24;, eryyticA-1.0.,)1 V c(1,, Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, beingclose of business (5pm) on 29 January 2010. Late submissions will NOT beconsidered.

Contacts: Telephone - (08) 9264 7777; Fax - (08) 9264 7566; Email - [email protected],gov.au; Website -httpthlaww.planning.wa.gov.au All communications should be directed to the Chief Executive Officer

241 Rokeby Road SUBIACO WA 6008 PO Box 270 SUBIACO WA 6904 OF Telephone: 08 9237 9222 Facsimile: 06 9237 9200 BIACO Email: [email protected] Website: www.subiaco.wa.gov.au

Enquiries: Natalie Martin Goode File: NG; sj ; N647-03 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING 14 January 2010 21 JAN 2010 Western Australian Planning Commission Albert Facey House FILE 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000

Dear Sir/Madam

LOT 50 NORTH EAST CORNER OF EVANS ANDHERBERT ROAD SHENTON PARK REZONING OF LAND FROM PARKS ANDRECREATION RESERVE TO PUBLIC PURPOSE (WATER AUTHORITY) RESERVE UNDER THEMETROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME

I refer to your correspondence received on 6October 2009 relating to the development detailed above.

The Western Australian Planning Commissionbe advised that the City of Subiacosupportes the proposal to rezone Lot 50 on the north east corner ofEvans and Herbert Road, Shenton Park (south west corner of Lake Jualbup) from parksand recreation reserve to public purpose (WSD) reserve under the MetropolitanRegion Scheme,

If you have any further queries please contactNatalie Martin Goode of the City's Planning Services on telephone 9237 9268.

Yours faithfully

SUE BURROWS DIRECTOR DEVELOPMENT SERVICES

Printed on Australian made 100 per cent recycled paper. Government of Western Australia Department of Environment and Conservation

Bok Ho DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING Land Administration Officer and Development Act 2005 Division of Parks & Visitor ServicesAmendment (Substantial) 2 5 JAN 2010 Technology Park, 17 Dick Perry Avenue, Kensington Form 41 Post: Locked Bag 104, Bentley Delivery Centre WA 6983 Ph: (08) 9219 8771 Fax: (08) 9334 0556Submission FILEAsloo3 Email: [email protected] www.dec.wa.gov.au wa.gov.auion Scheme Amendment 1161/41 rarks anti Recrea ion Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

ISUBMISSION NUMBER I To:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000 Submission 22 Nametlx30/

Contact phone number ef 7 7/ Email address50/c Ho et, t,cot; 4,4 The following proposals are the subject of my submission

Submission (Please attach additional pages If required.,< It Is preferred that any additional Information be loose rather than bound) r

'14

h4tr,C-ca: .d,(

4)-sa

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunityto personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC. You do not have toattend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered indetermining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer tothe amendment report and in particular appendix D. Please choose one of the following:

XNo, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign) OR

0 Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details) I wilt be represented by: Myself My telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours): Postal address:

I would prefer my hearing to be conducted in: Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation) OR n Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be permitted to attend)

You should be aware that: The WAPC Is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissionsmade to the WAPC may be subject to applications for access under the act. In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on thesesubmissions, copies of your submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties.

To be signed by Derson(s) making the submission ta,fr-A /td-n-41/4"4._ Jar

Signaturefr7* 1)141-4- .Date

Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, beingclose of business (5pm) on 29 January 2010. Late submissions will NOT beconsidered.

Contacts: Telephone(08) 9264 7777; Fax - (08) 9264 7566; Email - [email protected]; Website -http://wm.planning.wa.gov.au Submission23 Government of Western Australia .>,ApAylpttlipt,01

. Department of Indigenous Affairs 114 0 Ilt:4440.

ENQUIRIES PETER RANDOLPH SENIOR HERITAGE OFFICER- Ph 9235 8100

OUR REF: 0910759

YOUR REF: 809-2-1-74 Pt 1 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING

2 7 JAN2010 Mr Tony Evans Secretary FILEge 9'42- 71e7 Western Australian Planning Commission Albert Facey House 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000

Dear Mr Evans

METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME PROPOSED AMENDMENT 1161/41 - PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATIONS FOR PUBLIC LANDS

I refer to your letter dated 5 October 2009 seeking comment on Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) Proposed Amendment 1161/41.

There are many Aboriginal sites associated with the proposed amendment. The attached table indicates those amendments where there are Aboriginal sites known to the Department of Indigenous Affairs (DIA).In addition, many of the areas do not appear to have been examined to identify whether there areplaces with Aboriginal heritage values present.

Itis an offence to disturb an Aboriginal site under section 17 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (AHA) (whether it is known to DIA or not) without the authorisation of the Minister for Indigenous Affairs in accordance with section 18. Any party that proposes an activity that is likely to impact upon an Aboriginal siterisks breaching section 17 unless the consent of the Minister has been obtained in accordance with section 18.DIA recommends appropriate ethnographic and archaeological studies are undertaken to determine whether there are Aboriginalsites unless this has already been done.

1st Floor, 197 St Georges Terrace, Perth, Western Australia 6000 PO Box 7770, Cloisters Square, Perth, Western Australia 6850 Telephone (08) 9235 8000 Facsimile (08) 9235 8088 www.dia.wa.gov.au wa.gov.au I recommend that you draw the attached table to the attention of all parties and urge them to take adequate steps to identify and protect the Aboriginal heritage values of the lands under their management.

Yours sincerely

hristine LsNs Manager Heritage Advice

21 January 2010

2 MRS Proposed Amendment 1161/41List of amendments where known Aboriginal sites are located. Local GovtFigureDIA Site Site Name Site Area Identification Status Neerigen Brook Permanent City of 1 DIA 3714 Armada le 3 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent 4 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent DIA15119 Canning River Scatter Permanent DIA 15975 Turtle Brook Permanent DIA 15976 Abutment Road Stored data DIA 15977 Mc Ness Road Stored data DIA 15978 Canning Dam Road Permanent DIA 16963 Men's Ceremonial Site Permanent DIA 17197 Canning Reservoir 9 Permanent DIA 21318 Canning Dam Isolated Artefacts Stored data DIA 23025 Boulder Rock Lodged 10 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent Town of 1 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent Bassendean 2 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent City of 2 Swan River Permanent Bayswater DIA 3536 5 DIA 3170 Bardon Park Permanent City of 1 Swan River Permanent Belmont DIA 3536 City of 2 DIA 3453 Watts Road Wilson Insufficient Canning information 3 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent 4 DIA 3308 Wilson Rubbish Tip Stored data DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent Permanent 5 DIA 3536 Swan River DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent 6 DIA 3507 Vulcan Road Stored data City of 2 DIA 3709 North Lake & Bibra Lake Permanent DIA 4107 Bibra Lake North Permanent Cockburn 3 DIA 3294 North Lake, N Permanent 5 DIA 4103 Swamp 81 Permanent City of 3 DIA 3264 White Road Orange Grove Permanent Gosnells 4 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent 5 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent DIA 18193 Frog Dreaming Creek Permanent 7a DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent 8 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent 11b DIA 3511 Southern River Permanent 13 DIA 3897 Okey Davies Homestead A-D Permanent

3 MRS Proposed Amendment 1161/41-List of amendments where known Aboriginal sites are locatedcontinued Local GovtFigureDIA Site Site Name Site Area Identification Status City of 18 DIA 3312 Wattle Grove, Perth Insufficient Gosnells information 21 DIA 4078 Nolan Avenue, Upper Swan Stored data 23 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3538 Canning River Permanent City of 3 Permanent Joondalup DIA 3739 Lake Goolelal Shire of 1a DIA 506 Quick's Chalk Pit Permanent DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent Kalamunda DIA 17200 Mundaring Dam 4 Permanent DIA 17202 Mundaring Dam 6 Permanent DIA 22675 Mundaring Weir Corroboree Gr (Booralyn) Insufficient information l b DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent 2 DIA 3197 Mundaring Weir Permanent DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent 3 DIA 3191 Brookton Highway Insufficient information DIA 3570 Bickley Quarry Permanent 4a DIA 3905 Larwood Paddock 1-3 Permanent 4b DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent 8 DIA 22674 Lesmurdie Falls (Jerban) Lodged Shire of 2 Stored data Mundaring DIA 3188 Darling Range 3 DIA 3188 Darling Range Stored data DIA 3413 O'Connor Road/Pine Hill Permanent DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent DIA 4297 Bourke's Gully Insufficient information 5 DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent DIA 22675 Mundaring Weir Corroboree Gr (Booralyn) Insufficient information 6 DIA 3197 Mundaring Weir Permanent DIA 3576 Mt Hall Insufficient information DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent 7 DIA 3518 Dinner Camp Stored data DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent DIA 3967 Helena River A-C Permanent DIA 3974 WA Salvage Ant Hill A,B & C Insufficient information DIA 4337 Midland/Helena Valley Roads Insufficient information 8a DIA 504 Helena Valley Quarry Permanent DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent 8b DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent 9 DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent City of 5 DIA 352 Lake Richmond Stored data Rockingham DIA 15974 Lake Richmond Permanent Shire of 2 Stored data Serpentine DIA 24991 Beenyup Brook Jarrandale

4 MRS Proposed Amendment 1161/41-List of amendments where known Aboriginal sites are located-continued Local GovtFigureDIA Site Site Name Site Area Identification Status City of 4 Stirling DIA 3585 Herdsman Lake Permanent 5 DIA 3585 Herdsman Lake Permanent 6 DIA 3585 Herdsman Lake Permanent City of 1 Subiaco DIA 3764 Fringecamp Stored data DIA 3794 Shenton Park Lake Permanent City of 1 b Swan DIA 3452 Bullsbrook Camp Insufficient information 2 DIA 3525 Ellen Brook: Upper Swan Permanent DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3825 Brigadoon 32 Permanent DIA 3826 Brigadoon 33 Permanent DIA 3830 Buyat Cullung Permanent DIA 3831 Tjitti - Tjitti Permanent DIA 3833 Bald Hill Permanent DIA 3834 Bells Rapids/Waugal Rocks Permanent DIA 3881 Childrens Stone Permanent DIA 3882 Millendon 12 Permanent DIA 3883 Millendon 11 Permanent DIA 4072 Millendon 04 Insufficient information DIA 17688 Copley Road Wayit Koolong Site Permanent 3 DIA 3824 Brigadoon 31 Permanent DIA 3960 Millendon 01 Permanent DIA 4070 Millendon 02 Stored data DA 4071 Millendon 03 Permanent DIA 4073 Millendon 05 Permanent 4 DIA 3832 Waugal Lagoon Permanent 5 DIA 3527 Upper Swan Camp Permanent DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3932 Yagan Permanent DIA 17838 Yagan Skirmish Area Permanent 6 DIA 3525 Ellen Brook: Upper Swan Permanent DIA 3535 Ellen Brook Artefacts Permanent 7 DIA 3525 Ellen Brook: Upper Swan Permanent DIA 3932 Yagan Permanent DIA 17838 Yagan Skirmish Area Permanent 8 DIA 3525 Ellen Brook: Upper Swan Permanent DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent 9 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent 10a DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent 10b DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent 11 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3622 Turtle Swamp Permanent DIA 3699 Jane Brook Camp 1 Insufficient information DIA 3768 Bishop Road Camp Permanent 12 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 4004 Roxton Street Stored data 13 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3720 Blackadder & Woodbridge Ck Permanent 14 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3795 Woodbridge Showground? Stored data DIA 3796 Blackadder & Woodbridge Ck Stored data DIA 21504 Turtle Dreaming Site Stored data

5 MRS Proposed Amendment 1161/41List of amendments where known Aboriginal sites are locatedcontinued Local GovtFigureDIA Site Site Name Site Area Identification Status City of 15 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent Swan DIA 3769 Barkers Bridge, Guildford Permanent DIA 3840 Bennett Brook: Camp Area Permanent (cont'd) 17 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent 18a DIA 3415 Farrell Road Insufficient information DIA 3649 Jane Brook Camp 3 Insufficient information DIA 3759 Jane Brook Permanent DIA 20594 Wexcombe Artefact Scatter Insufficient information 18b DIA 3188 Darling Range Stored data DIA 3415 Farrell Road Insufficient information DIA 3564 Jane Brook North Permanent DIA 3759 Jane Brook Permanent DIA 20594 Wexcombe Artefact Scatter Insufficient information 18c DIA 3188 Darling Range Stored data DIA 3759 Jane Brook Permanent 19 DIA 3518 Dinner Camp Stored data DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent DIA 4012 Trough & Dead Sheep Paddock Insufficient information 20 DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent 21 DIA 3758 Helena River Permanent 22 DIA 3692 Bennett Brook: In toto (Duplicate for DIA Permanent 22159) DIA 22159 Little Creek/One Hundred Year Creek Stored data 24 DIA 3188 Darling Range Stored data 25 DIA 3536 Swan River Permanent DIA 3802 Brigadoon 09 Stored data DIA 3805 Brigadoon 12 Permanent DIA 3806 Brigadoon 13 Permanent DIA 3810 Brigadoon 17 Permanent DIA 3823 Brigadoon 30 Permanent DIA 17514 Creek Insufficient information 26 DIA 3525 Ellen Brook: Upper Swan Permanent 28a DIA 3315 Murray's Cave Permanent DIA 3618 Whitemans Cutting Insufficient information DIA 3692 Bennett Brook: In toto (Duplicate for DIA Permanent 22159) DIA 4044 Landsdale Permanent DIA 22159 Little Creek/One Hundred Year Creek Stored data City of 6 Wanneroo DIA 3396 Lake Adams Stored data 7 DIA 3741 Lake Mariginiup Permanent 9 DIA 3740 Lake Joondalup Permanent 10 DIA 3567 Mindarie Waugal Permanent 11 DIA 1018 Doogarch Permanent

6 Submission 24

DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING

Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) 28 JAN2010 Form 41 Submission FiLEgivo33 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

SUBMISSION NUMBER b:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000 rgiaor o7t JameDO 5EcA-E77my Aeensi-P4-4 (Atc) PRINT CLEARLY) kddress Postcode 6/72., (5)6 /el-74 eco.edetatt )ontact phone number1317487# Email address 'he following proposals are the subject of my submission C A/t AWM MI14fRop4S/)Z,S Gat{7 submission(Please attach additional pages If required. lured that any additional Information be loose rather th bound) artSecrftit .617.4:904 ftfredn.. eltiottoh taia 744.e eeeasizAe -tear Areas- ,..tr-reae74

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC. You do not have to attend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D.

Please choose one of the following:

11No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)

O Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: Myself My telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours): Postal address:

You should be aware that: The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be subject to applications for access under the act. In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties. All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment. The WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissions and tabled in Parliament.

To be signed by person(s) making the submission

Signature Date24-/c/0

Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of business (5pm) on 29 January 2010. Late submissions will NOT be considered.

Contacts: Telephone - (08) 9264 7777; Fax - (08) 9264 7566; Email mrs @planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://wvAv.planning.wa.gov.au Submission 24 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING

2 8 JAN 2010

Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) F1,07003 Form 41 Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

SUBMISSION NUMBER To:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000 tap 0/ 5 L-57 int/PjDF tcAAT57-X:),4rz. (/NG) (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) Address11 19-6 44/11/416 Cat 'eriPeriegelaVePostcode 67/2-

Contact phone number939, 18 71- Email address/1 /7110 ecq. e444

The following proposals are the subject of my submission c /TyOF 6054/11-66 OP0,4t, /S

Submission(Please attach additional pages if required. It is prof rred that any additional information be loose rather than bound) SiXtre . 00c /01--4 "aeotitetti04- 40th teenne oe-renterved,.2eve- ai- of.,,eoiedit 4-74

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC. You do not have to attend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D.

Please choose one of the following:

EiNo, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign) OR

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: MyselfMy telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours): Postal address:

You should be aware that: The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may br subject to applications for access under the act.

_ - In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making ite report oh these submissions, copies of your submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties, All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment. The WAPC recommendations are similarly published In a report on submissions and tabled in Parliament.

To be stoned by person(s) making the submission

Signature Date 1//ha

Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of business (5W) on 29 January MO. Late submissions will NOT be considered.

Contacts: Telephone (08) 9264 7777; Fax - (08) 9264 7566; Email - [email protected]; WebsIte - http://www.planning.wa.gov.au Submission 24 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING

28 JAN2010 Planning and bevelopment Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantialil Form 41 fFiLERje5/00 5(-5 Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161141 Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE. ONLY

SUBMISSION NUMBER To:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street 5. Perth WA 6000

Name Gire-4'r Atenv5 oc/SA)cE5-7734ve (I/W.) (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)

Address"'PAe114 Al cxher reA5C45SPostcode.

Contact phone number .72.8 74- Email address viNe/fg)ecq.eth4 44

The following proposals are the subject of my submission 511/<4 5.841Peiv7-7411. mAgek-H40,4m feato.54-4-

Submission(Please attach additional pages if required. it.is preferred that any additional information be loose rather than bound) 44244 ),eAve4re ,14 %rarer": 4f-t-fre4a4

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personallypresent the basis of their submission to a sub-committee ofthe WAPC. You do not have to attenda hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining therecommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearingsprocess, please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D.

Please choose one of the following:

ErNo, I do not wish to speak at thehearings. (Please go to the bottom ofthe form and sign)

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings.(Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: Myself My telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours): Postal address:

I would prefer my hearing to be conducted in: Public.(members from the general public may attendyour presentation) OR Private (only the people nominated byyou or the hearings committee will be permitted to attend)

You should be aware that:

The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 andas such, submissions made to the WAPC may be subject to applications for access under the act.

In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its reporton these submissions, copies of your submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties.

All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along withall written submissions, are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governorapprove the proposed amendment. The WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissions and tabledin Parliament.

To be signed by nerson(si making the submission

Signature Date47/10

Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of business (5pm) on 29 January 2010. Late submissions will NOT be considered.

Contacts: Telephone (08) 92e4 7777; Fax- (08) 9264 7566; Email - [email protected]; WebsIta - http://ww.v.planning.wa.gov.au LAsz -2-`1 Submission24 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING

Planning and Development Act 2005 2 8 JAN 2010 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) Form 41 ALAS/0030 Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

SUBMISSION NUMBER To:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000

NameitelOPebet*57r EtIONP,. of fele'? 57at (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) AddresS Pe-titisi MO"frier; raVeg.55773WE.,Postcode64 eCe edtf.9Gf Contact phone number939 17243 74- .Email address ; bkfr

The following proposals are the subject of my submission C/ 0-F COCK5CeeN fiRefi054-c-5 / aatt

Submission(Please attach additional pages If required. It is preferred that any additional information be loose rather than bound) t(02-e, /70004. 11/06(4771/2 -frae-nyt Meden42"oe-ec irate0 &eh.) f triterlex-e- talcic 4-0;4 ov-edor:

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC. You do not have to attend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D.

Please choose one of the following:

.1217No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: Myself My telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours): Postal address:

To be sinned by person(s) making the submission

0 Signature Datez,

Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of business (5pm) on 29 January 2010. Late submissions will NOT be considered.

Contacts: Telephone - (08) 9264 7777; Fax - (08) 9264 7566; Email - [email protected]; Weicsite - http://wvAv.planning.wa.gov.au Submission 25

2120 Albany Highway Gosnells WA 6110 08 9397 3000 Mail to: PO Box 662 Gosnells WA 6990 F 08 9397 3333 E [email protected] W www.gosnells.wa.gov.au ABN 18 374 412 891 29 January 2010

The Secretary ference: 809-2-1-74 Pt 1 ENT OF PLAN Western Australian Planning Commi RTM nquin s: Mr Jeremy Hofland 469 Wellington Street 9397 3170 PERTH WA 6000 0 2 FEB 2010

Attention: Vicki Evans FILE0,8 OD 33

Dear Madam

Submission on Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment No.1161/41 - Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

I refer to your correspondence dated 5 October 2009, regarding the above matter.

The City advises that it has no objection to the 23 proposals contained within the document which are within the City of Gosnells. However, the transfer of land within Proposals 2, 4, 7, 9 and 11 16 to the Parks and Recreation reservation has potential to affect the use and distribution of Public Open Space (POS) within the City, as outlined below.

The City of Gosnells is currently preparing a POS Strategy for the municipality. As part of this process, advice was received from the Commission in November 2008 that land reserved for Parks and Recreation under the MRS cannot be included in the 10% POS calculation. Although it is understood that the function and appearance of these POS areas will not change as a result of the Amendment, the amount of POS included in the Strategy will be reduced.This may negatively affect the Strategy as it would not provide an accurate representation of POS sites originally created and used for local recreationpurposes, which couldpotentially compromise theCity'sabilityto rationalise/dispose of any land considered to be unsuitable for recreation purposes.

In accordance with Clause 3.3.2 of the Commission's DC Policy 2.3 - Public Open Space in Residential Areas (May 2002), the City advises that it will be preparing a formal request for the Commission to support the retention of land within the POS Strategy, where it was created through the subdivision process under Section 152 of the Planning and Development Act 2005.

\Should you wish to discuss this further please contact the undersigned on 9397 3170.

Yours faithfully

Jeremy fclofland Manager Planning Implementation Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) Form 41 Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41 Parks and Recreation Reservations for Pub HoLends

. .

OFFICE USE ONLY

81.113/415SiON NUMBER To;Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Weningtan Street Perth WA 6000

Name dleasemitir stemma Address 7-5-62- skt IVA Postcode 7q0

Contact phone number Erimil address

The following proposals are the subject of mysubmission

tie-% Cr of C-04-,44, fly Proito5at 23 . 4L

Submission (Please attach additional pages if :squired. It is preferred that any additional information bo loose rather than bound)

See aJ-1-ac-ktor

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personally presentthe basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC. You do not have to attend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment,

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D.

Please choose one of the following:

12:1 No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: Myself My telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours) Postal address'

You should be aware that:

submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties. .

All hearings are recorded and transcribed, The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment. The WAPC recommendations are similarly published In S report on submissions and tabled In Parliament.

To be signed by person(s) making the submission

Saitkh 1-16-P Hof kla Artn,t4c;11-,yoles,f0dollov Signature. Date 1-q17 / I 0

No. Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of business (5pm) on 29 January 2010. Late submissions will NOT be considered, contacls: Telephone - (08) 92647777; Fox (08) 9204 Thee; small - [email protected]; Minns - tinplAmy.planntroma.govau "2? Submission26

DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING Planning and Development Act2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) 2 9 JAN 2810 Form 41

Submission 00 63.5 Metropolitan Region SchemeAmendment 1161/41 Parks and Recreation Reservationsfor Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

To;Secretary SUBMISSION NUMBER Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000

Name -SA hi IS so rJ T

(PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) Address z 6 LA 1/4/TWOt e - PJ e Stt-/ 01t- A Al A RAPostcode. Contact phone number q 3 4-4- 2-8`1- Email address L4 bl+ 0 aet e4- 6, it The following proposalsare the subject of my submission PK. OPoS A L_

Submission (Please attach additionalpages if required. It is preferred that any additional information be loose rather than bound) h behalfof- +tve rrnt.e.INdsof b ia vue,11 ar.d, W01-4.14 1;kt +0 c_ohAd;+lovian supOrli°+toe. app e,. on for4-he rea,Son_s /"3Ite4 0 vex'eq.

turn over to completeyour submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personallypresent the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of theWAPC. You do not have to attenda hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will beconsidered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment,

For information about the submission and hearingsprocess, please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D.

Please choose one of the following:

121 No, I do not wish to speak at thehearings. (Please go to the bottom of the formand sign)

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings.(Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: MyselfMy telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours): Postal address:

I would prefer my hearing to be conducted in: Public (members from the general publicmay attend your presentation) OR Private (only the people nominated byyou or the hearings committee will be permitted to attend)

You should be aware that:

The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 andas such, submissions made to the WAPC may be subject to applications for access under the act. In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies ofyour submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to thirdparties.

All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of allhearings, along with all written submissions,are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governorapprove the proposed amendment. The WAPC recommendations are similarly published ina report on submissions and tabled in Parliament.

To be signed by person(s) making the submission

Signature. Date 2-1I.(0

Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertisedclosing date, being close of business (5pm) on 29 January 2010. Late submissions will NOTbe considered.

Contacts: Telephone - (08) 9264 7777; Fax - (08) 9264 7566; Email - [email protected]; Wehsite- httplAwAv.planning.wa.gov.au PROPOSAL 3

To (i) transfer lot 56 Venice Court, Diane lla from the urban zone to the parks and recreation reserve and (ii) include it in Bush Forever site 43.

The Friends of Dianella Bushland was instrumental in the initial acquisition of Bush Forever site 43 and supports its subsequent management by the City of Stirling as a regionally significant bushland reserve. The Friends of Dianella Bushland is a volunteer community group conducting educational walks and events in the Cottonwood Crescent bushland (Site 43), and assists the City of Stirling in the management of the reserve.

We support (i) the transfer of Lot 56 Venice Court to P&R reservation and conditionally support (ii) its inclusion in Bush Forever site 43 with the following comments:

The area is not suitable for housing or development because of its irregular elongated shape and position in the landscape adjacent to the sump, the road and Bush Forever site 43.

The area considered on its own does not qualify for inclusion in Bush Forever as it does not meet the criteria for regionally significant bushland. Being adjacent to a Bush Forever site however, it has important value as abuffer zone to a Bush Forever site and as an ecological connection to Cottonwood Crescent reserve, the Water Corporation Sump and to the Channel 9 bushland.

Although in poor condition, the area itself does have some important bushland vegetation values (eg Jarrah habitat, native orchid habitat, kangaroo habitat) making it worthy of retention and management as bushland contiguous with the Cottonwood Crescent reserve.

The area is highly disturbed due to the extensive plantings of invasive woody weeds including Victorian Tea-tree, Calothamnus, lupins and veld grass. If added to Bush Forever these weeds will all need to be removed and the area revegetated with local species native to this landform and soil type - ie using only plants which belong in this habitat

The topography of the area has been grossly altered by the tunnel structure under the road and accompanying site works (limestone retaining walls).

From the proposal it appears the tunnel will exit into the bushland, and cut off pedestrians and cyclists from the pathways bordering Dianella Drive, negating the original purpose of the tunnel to transfer residents safely from one side of a busy road to the other. This will need to be changed so that pedestrians and cyclists have easy access to the roadside pathway but so that kangaroos do not have open access to the road. New fencing will be necessary given the area is habitat for up to 20 Western Grey Kangaroos.

SUMMARY

Our support to the amendment is subject to the following conditions being added to the addition of lot 56 Venice Court to the Parks and Recreation Reservation:

1. The area be managed by the City of Stirling as a bushland conservation site with a budget allocation to re-fence and rehabilitate the site as below

2. All woody and grassy weeds be removed and the area be properly rehabilitated and revegetated with local provenance species which belong to the native plant community of the site.

3. The area be re-fenced so that kangaroos have controlled access to the area but not the road, and pedestrians using the underpass have easy access to the roadside footpath

4. The City of Stirling provide operational budget allocation each year for management of the area as a bushland conservation area.

5. The area be added to Bush Forever after the initial weed removal and rehabilitation is completed

S e., Treasurer

Fr;endS of7 /.49. Vt A 3 14-414-4,41 Submission 27 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING

2 9 JAN 2010

Planning and Development Act 2005 5tion 41 Amendment (Substantial) FIL@CAS10 Form 41

Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1181141

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

SUBMISSION MOWER To:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000

NameMr. Trevor Moran (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) AddressSuite 5,16 Nicholson Road SUBIACO Postcode6008 (08) 9388 8181 trevorrrglandvi s ion . com . au Contact phone number Email address

The following proposals are the subject of my submission

Submission (Please attach additional pages If required, Ills preferred that any additional Info lion be loose rather than bound) Please refer to attached

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC. You do not have to attend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D.

Please choose one of the following:

No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: MyselfMy telephone number (business hours): or Et A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson:Mr Trevor Moran Contact telephone number (business hours)*(08) 9388 8181 Postal address: Suite 5,16 Nicholson Road, SUB IACO

I would prefer my hearing to be conducted in: Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation) OR El Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be permitted to attend)

You should be aware that: The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be subject to applications for access under the act. *In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties. All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment. The WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissions and tabled in Parliament.

To be signed by persons) making the submission

Signature Date MP

Note: Submissions MUST he received by the advertised closing date, being close of business (5pm) on 29 January 2010. Late submissions will NOT be considered.

Contacts: Telephone- (08)9264 7777; Fax - (08) 9264 7666; Email - [email protected]; Webslie - httplIymplannIng.v(ogov.au Land Planning, Development & Mapping Consultants ABN No. 52 058 714 480 Our Ref: 1489

SUBMISSION ON MRS AMENDMENT

1161/41 PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATION FOR PUBLIC LANDS

The stated purpose of the amendment is to;

`include within the parks and recreation reservation of the MRS various pieces of publicly owned land toreflect their regional significance. Additionally, some properties are proposed to be rezoned to better reflect their current use and purpose within the MRS'.

This submission is made by Landvision on behalf of Mr. C Sorgiovanni the owner of Lot 40 River Avenue Maddington, and Mr. I Philp the owner of adjoining Lot 41, Maddington both of which are not included in the Amendment but which we submit fall into the category of relevant land as described above.

Indeed we note that the amendment proposes to do exactly what Mr. Sorgiovanni and Mr. Philp have requested on several occasions since 2004 for their properties on Lot 1129 (Proposal 13City of Gosnells)directly opposite their properties ie. Lot 1129 has been transferred from the Parks and Recreation reservation to the Urban Zoneto provide a more manageable boundary' (p.20) (see Figure 1).

Other amendments to the MRS boundary have occurred twice before on either side of Mr. Sorgiovanni's property, one being on Mr. Philps (MRS Amendment No. 768/33A and MRS Amendment 1028/33)

In particular in 1990 MRS Amendment No. 768/33A was approved by the Minister which reduced the reserve on Lot 41, River Avenue so as to avoid the owners' home and improvements.

In Mr. Sorgiovanni's case, the MRS Parks and Recreation Reserve boundary is an arbitrary 50 metres from the centre of the Canning River. It cuts across Mr. Sorgiovanni's orchard and bears no relationship to the floodplain or the vegetation or the river vista. The attached submission clearly indicates this.

Landvision has been acting on behalf of both owners of Lots 40 & 41 River Avenue in respect to progressing the subdivision and development of their respective landholdings.

In this context Landvision on behalf of Mr. Sorgiovanni since 2004 and Mr. Philp since 2007 has made numerous requests to the WAPC and City of Gosnells to rationalise the boundary of

FAOperatonsUOBS11489 Soroltwanrt A 8 C re Sow Maddin91ont1489 Scrolovanni Stntsston Ctly of Gosnes to Amendment! TPS.doc

Suite 5, 16 Nicholson Road Sublaco WA 6008 Telephone: (08) 9388 8181 Facsimile: 9388 8185 Email: [email protected] PAGE 2 the Parks and Recreation reserve boundary on their properties with no tangible response from either party (positive or negative).

In November 2004 the owners of Lot 40, River Avenue made a submission to the WAPC in respect to proposed Amendment No. 1082/33 which sought to impose a special control area over the property which was co-independent with the MRS reserve on their property(See Attachment No. 1). No response from the WAPC to their submission was ever received.

In February 2006, Landvision on behalf of the Sorgiovannis' lodged an application for subdivision for Lot 40 with the WAPC. The subdivision proposal incorporated the modified MRS reserve which was proposed through the owners submission on Amendment No. 1082/33. The subdivision proposal has yet to be determined (WAPC Ref 130533).

The subject land was then zoned rural but was intended to be rezoned under proposed City of Gosnells TPS No. 21 to Residential R17.5. The plan incorporated in proposed TPS No. 21 indicated a road mining through the middle of Lot 41 then along the foreshore terminating at the eastern boundary of Lot 40.

Subsequently progress on TPS No. 21 was abandoned and in September 2006 submissions were called for from the public by the City of Gosnells either supporting or objecting to a replacement system of ODP's.

This was supported by the Sorgiovannis (See Attachment No. 2) and it became evident that the relevant planning precinct for their land would be confined to Lots 40 and 41. This is a result of River Avenue and the Canning River and development to the north providing a distinctive precinct. Subsequently, Landvision has also been acting for the owner of Lot 41 (Mr. Philp) which makes up the balance of the precinct.

In determining an appropriate foreshore reserve for the ODP, Landvision prepared a foreshore concept plan comprising a series of walk trails (a foreshore road being inappropriate and largely impractical) to access this secluded stretch of river.

It was apparent that a narrowing of the foreshore reserve in this area did not jeopardise public access and enjoyment and would benefit from appropriately designed adjoining development and have significant savings for the public purse.

The concept was forwarded to the WAPC in October 2006 for consideration.

The chronology of submissions made on behalf of Mr. Sorgiovanni and more recently Mr. Philp (most of which have had no meaningful response) are listed below;

November 2004 May 2005 Submission and attendance at WAPC hearing for MRS Amendment No. 1082/33 (Bush Forever and Related Lands (See Attachment No. 1)) requesting an adjustment to the MRS, P & R Boundary (No Response from the WAPC). February 2006 Subdivision application (WAPC Ref 103533) which adopted the proposed modified P & R

FSOpeda5onsUOBS11489 Sotgiovannl A & C ra Subd Maddington 1469 Sorglovannl Submissbn City of Gosnets to Amendmend TPS dot 20/01110 13:37

Suite 5, 16 Nicholson Road Subiaco WA 6008 Telephone: (08) 9388 8181 Facsimile: 9388 8185 Email: [email protected] PAGE 3

Boundary (deferred by the WAPC). September 2006 Submission on proposed planning framework to replace Draft TPS No. 21 in which a concept plan was proposed for the river foreshoreconsistentwiththeproposed modification (See Attachment No. 2). October 2006 August 2007 Letters to DPI and the City of Gosnells requesting a modification to the P & R boundary as part of the recently approved ODP process to replace former TPS No. 21 (See Attachment No. 3) (No response). October 2007 RequestforDPIforliftingof urban deferment including a request to modify P & R boundary (Response was to refer proposal to City of Gosnells and effectively prepare an extensive report). June 2008 Preparation of report requesting lifting of urban deferment which notes that the WAPC should consider modifying the P & R boundary on the subject land. August 2009 Submission to the City of Gosnells on the Central Maddington ODP, highlighting the impractically of a through road in Lots 40 and 41RiverAvenueandtheneedfor rationalisation of the MRS P & R reserve boundary inthisarea witha proposed modified boundary. (See Attachment No. 4)

The attached documents bear evidence to these futile attempts and provide the details of our position.

Notwithstanding the above we have prepared the attached report for your consideration for a modification to the amendment requesting a modification to the P & R Reserve boundary in respect to Lots 40 and 41 in a similar manner to the proposals contained in the amendment and if possibly included as part of this amendment.

Yours faithfully,

Trevor an Director, Planning Services LANDVISION

F:\OperafionsUOBS1489 Sorgiovannl A & C re Subd Madcington 1489Sorgiovanni SubmissionCity of Gosnells to ArnencimendTPS.doo 28/91/1913:37

Suite 5, 16 Nicholson Road Subiaco WA 6008 Telephone: (08) 9388 8181 Facsimile: 9388 8185 Email: [email protected] PROP0SAL13

arks andRecreation Reservations forPublic Lands Oinoths - proposed major as advertised amendment Figure 13 Proposed; Legend parks and recreation reservation

urban zone

public purposes reservation (VVSD)

FI GVItt

Data Barth. Depict..violParrinp int Irtiehan Western ,..ohdtovek.,,c.sramunntresmkisas,ranaxzz Australian .Z.11% IPlanning Scala 1:3030 ail Commission PROPOSAL TO SUPPORT THE RATIONALISATION OF THE METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME (MRS) RESERVE BOUNDARY LOTS 40 & 41 RIVER AVENUE, MADDINGTON

PREPARED BY LANDVISION

JUNE 2008 TABLE OF CONTENTS

1.0 INTRODUCTION 1 2.0 THE SUBJECT LAND 1 3.0 LAND USE 1 4.0 THE CANNING RIVER ENVIRONMENT 4

4.1 TOPOGRAPHY 4 4.2 SOILS AND VEGETATION 7 4.3 SURFACE WATER AND DRAINAGE 7 4.3.1 Water Quality 7 4.3.2 Drainage 8 4.3.3 Wetlands and Groundwater 8 5.0 RATIONALISATION OF THE MRS PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVE BOUNDARY 10

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1: The Subject Land 2 Figure 2: Metropolitan Region Scheme Zones and Reserves 3 Figure 3: Canning River Foreshore showing Floodway, Flood Fringe, Riparian Vegetation and Topography 5 Figure 4: The Effect of the Parks and Recreation Reserve Boundary on the Subject Land 6 Figure 5: The Subject Land Showing Conceptual Road Layout & Pathway System 11 Figure 6: Proposed MRS Boundary Modification 14 Figure 7: Foreshore Concept PlanCanning River/Helm Street M.D 15 to INTRODUCTION

The purpose of this report is to describe and provide justification for an amendment to the Metropolitan Region Scheme in respect to the boundary of the Parks and Recreation Reserve along the Canning River where it abuts Lots 40 and 41 River Avenue, Maddington.

2.0 THE SUBJECT LAND

The subject land abuts the Canning River and is affected by an MRS reserve along the river with a matching Bush Forever designation (see Figures 1 and 2).

For the subject land the MRS reserve is approximately 50 metres wide.

The current operative Town Planning Scheme for the City of Gosnells is Town Planning Scheme No. 6 gazetted in 2002.

In TPS No. 6 the majority of the subject land is zoned rural with a Parks and Recreation reserve abutting the Canning River (see Figure 3).The Parks and Recreation reserve matches that of the MRS.

The subject land is also within an area subject to the Central Maddington Outline Development Plan (ODP) which provides the justification for the lifting of urban deferment for the area with a requirement for Detailed Area Plans being prepared for planning precincts within the ODP area, in order;

"to enhance, elaborate and expand on the details and provisions contained in the ODP prior to subdivision and development."

Lot 40 River Avenue is in the ownership of Cosimo and Maria Sorgiovanni (C/T 2086/422) and comprises 1.7515ha and extends into the Canning River.

Lot 41 River Avenue comprises 2.7646ha and is in the ownership of Ian and Betty Philp (C/T 1565/473).

3.0LAND USE The precinct is part of an area described as "Area B" in the Central Maddington ODP. Area B is described as follows:

Area BThis area is located to the south of Albany Highway and is generally bound by Albany Highway, Olga Road/Burslem Drive,the "Arcadia Waters' aged persons development, the Regional 'Parks and Recreation" reserve abutting the Canning River, and the Perth to Armadale railway reserve.

FeOperations \JOBS 1489 Sorgiovanni A & C re Subd Maddington Report02.docl Landvision 27/01/2010 CC Co CD O

CO O I-O -aZD CO .17r

M it RESERVED LANDS PARKS AND RECREATIONPESTPic191>P11011C ACCESS I RAILWAYS STATEPORT INSTALLATIONS FORESTS CIVICWATER AND CATCHMENTS CULTURAL WATERWAYSROADS MIMEMOM OTHERPRimmynolouALRoAns MloloNAL ReP os HSH PUBLIC PURPOSESRICHHOSPITALDENOTED SCHOOL AS POLSOW0c CPTS COMMONWEALTHUNIKROITYCARTECHNICAL PARK SCHOOL 00VIIIINSISNT WEDSECSUCO WATERSPOONSSTASI WORDY PIRTHORRY USES COMMISSION OF WA ?ONES PRISON oN\Es scPe URBAN DEFERRED CENTRALINDUSTRIAL CITY AREA RURALSPECIAL INDUSTRIAL RURALPRIVATE - WATER RECREATION PROTECTION abliunw WOW FIGURE 2 terelPlavin.bWenRXNmodal kin ECU I ibrIfipOgraillO TOT11.10101111011One MO0.1an0011011111S DV *Won PSI METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME ZONES AND RESERVES o 100 200 11cm Lintell9Zandre.aintau LOTS 40 , 41 ANDADJOINING LAND HOLDINGS, RIVERAVENUE, MADDINGTON FILE ONDabTlennInD114139mtaloRI2008-081REPORT ZI4B94102-00044 (E) Area B consists of land zoned both 'Urban" and "Urban Deferred" in the MRS, inaddition to land reserved for 'Parks and Recreation", "Waterways' andRegional Road purposes. Under TPS 6, Area B is predominantly zoned 'Residential R17.5", with smaller areasof land being zoned "Residential R30", "Highway Commercial", "MixedBusiness" and "General Rural".

The subject land abuts the Canning River and is affected by a generally 50 metrewide reserve for Parks and Recreation in the Metropolitan RegionScheme.

The ODP area has already undergone significant urban development. Historicallyhowever, this development has been constrained by prevailing environmental conditions, andthe absence of reticulated sewerage and an adequate drainage network (Brown & Root 2001a). A number of these constraints have however diminished over time with theprogression of various State and local government programs.

Approximately 35 percent of Area B (including the subject land) consists of non-urbanised land abutting the Canning River "Parks and Recreation" Reserve.Most of these landholdings are used for small-scale horticultural pursuits, such as orange orchardsand market gardens, or are vacant.

The ODP area is well served by existing retail, commercial and communityfacilities, all having sufficient capacity to cater for future population increases.The Maddington Shopping Centre, adjacent to the ODP area, is a designated Regional Centre underthe WAPC's State Planning Policy No. 9Metropolitan Centres Policy Statement for the Perth. Metropolitan Region.

4.0 THE CANNING RIVER ENVIRONMENT

4.1Topography

Topographically, land throughout the ODP area is flat and low-lying, with a range of 6 to 9 metres AHD. The exception to this is the Canning River valley containedwithin the foreshore reservation, which contains steep riverbanks. Aesthetically, views of theDarling Range are available from most parts of the ODP area, and this, together with theriverine environment of the Canning River, provides significant visual landscape assets that contribute to residential amenity.

The majority of the subject land is flat at AHD 9m before dropping sharply over adistance of 25 metres to the Canning River to the south and 50 metres to the west (see Figure3).

The MRS Parks and Recreation reserve boundary bears no relevance to thetopography of the site, particularly Lot 40 where the Canning River is in a well defined valley andwhere the 50 metre reserve boundary crosses the owners orchard and includes anexisting residence.

The MRS reserve boundary has previously been amended twice in this area, once onLot 41 to avoid improvements, and on a second occasion to the SerenityCourt subdivision to rationalise the boundary. A site examination reveals that the 50 metre uniform reserve boundary cuts through the orchard area of Lot 40 on flat land, well removed fromthe distinctive river valley, its riparian vegetation and the flooding regime (see Figure 4).

FAOperations1JOBS11489 Sorgiovanni A & C re Subd Maddington Report02.doc4 Landvision 27/01/2010 . , 150 FLO D \ N N N ''' \ i , r LOT 401.7515h 4296 , A \ P -r. 456:y As <., LOT28099ha 41 . A3/4,-. '' SC(Py < FV ,--° . 5.00 .... 40 . AlaCROSED , \ N -- - - Arr --- a....._ \ FLOODWAY \ \ ,./ Ni / ' RIPARIAN -I _5A 40 \ .00000061/4 ------6 ____------'N'N'--.- .,.. Foaturo Survey Infonnalon DjIocofAAOOoolotoo FIGURE 3 tigainrIrUdatt.,LnOtmironwol. zr. covtbr.nnAlam: TOOMOIV nmth81 CANNING RIVER FORESHORE SHOWING FLOODWAY, FLOOD FRINGE, RIPARIAN VEGETATION AND TOPOGRAPHY M911011mono lr - LOTS 40 , 41 AND ADJOINING LAND HOLDINGS, RIVER AVENUE, MADDINGTON 00,01...... \ ,s . no: ogiolOWnlinmageadd / 4.2Soils and Vegetation Soils of the Guildford formation occur throughout the study areawith clayey sandy silt, sand, and sandy silty clay all evident. Typically soils inthis area are silty clays.

WAPC Planning Bulleting 64Metropolitan Region SchemeAcid Sulfate Soils Mapping indicates that the property has moderate to low risk of acidsulfate soils occurring within three metres of the natural soil surface.

Historical maximum groundwater levels at the site are approximately6m AHD to 8m AHD, however May 2003 groundwater levels show thegroundwater levels to be approximately 3.0m AHD (source: Perth Groundwater Atlas)this meaning there may be some dewatering required.

The ODP area includes a number of pockets of remnantvegetation considered to have high conservation value. Of these, the two most significant areas areconsidered to be the land adjacent to the Canning River, included in Bush Forever Site246, and the land either side of the Helm Street Main Drain An amendment to the MRS to create aspecial control area over the Bush Forever Site whichmatched the MRS Parks and Recreation Reserve was initiated in 2006 but has not progressed.

The subject land contains no remnant vegetation except thatfringing the Canning River.

4.3Surface Water and Drainage The subject land is located within the Lower Canning andHelm Street Catchments of the Swan-Canning River system.

4.3.1 Water Quality

Consultants Brown and Root prepared a Drainage and NutrientManagement Plan (DNMP) for the area in 2001 to provide guidance on the water quality of stormwater

The Helm Street Main Drain discharges into theCanning River upstream of the subject land. The DEC Geomorphic Wetlands Swan Coastal Plan Datasetidentifies this area as a Conservation Category Wetland. A local green space reserveis recommended surrounding the area but with some rationalisation to better accommodate thefringing native vegetation and buildings adjacent to the watercourse.

The Helm Street Main Drain is managed by the WaterCorporation, which has indicated that the drain will be retained as a natural watercourse; this beingconsistent with the drain's designation as a Conservation Category Wetland.

Similarly, the Department of Environment and Conservation(formerly the Department of Environment, Department for Environmental Protectionand the Water and Rivers Commission) has indicated an expectation that water qualityenhancement principles be applied throughout the ODP area. In this regard, itshould be noted that the opportunity to implement a number of best practice measures is limited bythe amount of existing development and fragmentation of ownership, as well asthe soil and groundwater conditions of the ODP area (Brown and Root 2001). The clay natureof the soils, coupled

FAOperationstIOSS11489 Sorgiovenni A & C re Subd Maddington1Repod02.dac7 Landvision 27/01/2010 with a high groundwater level reduces opportunities for infiltration, and land available for this purpose is limited.

Approximately 70 percent of ODP area currently utilises an existing piped drain system. Much of this system is however considered inadequate to cater for any additional runoff that may result from increases in residential density.

The difficulty is the level of suitable space to accommodate the range of alternative techniques.

4.3.2 Drainage The City proposes to engage engineering consultants to review the proposed Central Maddington ODP to determine whether there are any changes necessary to drainage upgrades recommended in 2005 for former draft TPS No. 21.

Other than source control methods, the consultants recommended the use of Humeceptors and continuous deflective separators which are types of gross pollutant traps and can be easily retro-fitted into existing systems.

4.3.3 Wetlands and Groundwater

The Canning River and Helm Street Main Drain are both identified in the Department of Environment and Conservation's Geomorphic Wetlands Swan Coastal Plain Dataset as Conservation Category Wetlands, and as such their protection from development related impacts is seen as a high priority.Given the Helm Street Main Drain's Conservation management category, and the intention of the Water Corporation to maintain it as a natural watercourse, it is considered appropriate to plan for and manage the drain and the land adjoining it as a conservation feature.

A shallow water table provides an additional constraint, with the potential for increased urban development to give rise to surface waterlogging or flooding, as well as other possible impacts arising from excessive groundwater extraction and potential groundwater contamination.

The Environmental Protection Authority recommends a minimum 50m buffer between Conservation Category Wetlands and residential development.However the Central Maddington ODP recognises that due to the infill nature of future development and extent of development that has already occurred within and in close proximity to the wetland, the provision of a 50m buffer may not be achievable. In response to this situation, the ODP proposes a balanced and considered response whichisenvisaged to have a net environmental benefit, potentially greater than that provided by a standard 50m buffer.

Present rural land uses surrounding the wetland, including orchards, vineyards, market gardens, and other small-scale rural/agricultural pursuits are in all likelihood considerable contributors of pollutants to both surface and ground water. Well-planned land use change from rural to residential in this instance would significantly reduce nutrient (nitrogen and phosphorus) contamination.The subsequent improvement in surface and groundwater quality will likely assist in protecting and enhancing the ecological value and function of

FAOperations1JOBS \ 1489 Sorgiovanni A & C re Subd Maddington RepadOadoce Landvislon 27/01/2010 the wetland. The provision of a controlled drainage system with infrastructure toimprove water quality will also aid in this.

To expedite this change in land use, the potential to develop rural landfor residential purposes must be made more attractive andviable.In some instances, the provision of a 50m buffer could significantly compromise or preclude such positive land usechange.

As the width of the buffer is considered constrained, it is recognised that there is aneed to supplement the degree of protection afforded to the wetland. The ODP achieves this by:

Supplementing and buffering the recommended conservation/open space reserve with additional provision of public open space. Creating a "hard edge between the conservation/open space areas and residential development where practical given the existing topography of the land and the desire to retain riparian vegetation.

Furthermore, it is envisaged that a Wetland Management Plan be prepared at theprecinct- level, in conjunction with a Detailed Area Plan. Such a management plan wouldlikely seek to protect and enhance the ecological value and function of the wetlandby:

Specifically defining the wetland boundary and buffer (where applicable). Setting methods to protect ecological values and functions. Identifying revegetation and rehabilitation requirements. Identifying compatible and non-compatible recreational activities and facilities. Defining access points. Identifying methods to maintain hydrological regime and water quality. Developing a monitoring program, implementation program and contingency actions.

A number of existing buildings fall within the area identified by the Departmentof Environment and Conservation's Geomorphic Wetlands Swan Coastal Plain dataset as Conservation Category Wetland and its immediate surrounds including one on Lot 40 (the MRS was amended in 1990 to exclude the residence on Lot 41). The ODPrecognises that many of these buildings are substantially sizedand relatively new.Their removal or redevelopment in the short-term is therefore unlikely.

Also whilst it may be desirable to construct a road as a "hard edge" between thesebuildings and the open space area, the ODP recognises that this is not always possibledue to the topography of the area due to the often steep terrain and the need to clear significant amounts of riparian vegetation, which is considered inappropriate.

Whilst the area identified in the ODP to protect the wetland is not entirely consistentwith the Environmental Protection Authority's recommended 50m buffer (and the MRS reserve), it is believed to respond practically to the conditions of the subject site and present a balanced, considered and compromise response with potential net environmental benefits.

At most stages in the planning and development process, it is envisaged thatdiscussions with the Water Corporation, Swan River Trust and the Department of Environmentand Conservation will be required in relation to the drain, wetland boundaries and buffers.

FACIperationsWOBS \ 1489 Sorglovannt A & C re Subd Maddington \Repor102.doc9 Landvision 27/01/2010 5.0RATIONALISATION OF THE MRS PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVE BOUNDARY

The current reserve and the subject land are shown in Figures 1 and 2.

The MRS boundary has been amended twice previously in this area.

In 1990 MRS Amendment No. 768/33A rationalised the boundary of the MRS Parks and Recreation Reserve as it affected Lot 41 River Avenue.

The South East Omnibus Amendment No. 5 further rationalised the MRS boundary in respect of then Pt Lot 153 abutting Lot 40.Furthermore the Central Maddington ODP anticipates further possible modifications.

The boundary for both lots appears to be an arbitrary 50 metres from the river and bears any relationship to the topography of the land.

The landowners made a submission to this effect to the WAPC early in 2005 and requested a boundary change but to date have not received advice on the outcome.

As can be seen from the attached photograph (see Figure 4) and feature survey (see Figure 3), the subject land slopes steeply down to the river where the riparian vegetation is located. The width of the flood plain on the subject land ranges from 025 metres in width which means that the MRS reserve largely occupies high land unconnected to the river's natural setting.

The 100 year flood level is 5.60m AHD which equates to a level approximately halfway up the embankment

The proposed modified reserve boundary for Lots 40 and 41 approximates the 7 metre AHD contour which is the top of the river bank on Lot 40 and is well clear of the 100 year flood level of 5.60 metres AHD.

Importantly for the landowners the rationalised boundary allows for the retention of their house on one of the proposed lots, which would otherwise have to be acquired from them at public expense as it lies within the current MRS reserve (See Figure 5).

In 1992 the owner of Lot 41 had subdivision plans prepared by BSD Consultants. This was done independently of the owner of Lot 40 but it is noteworthy that the subdivision concepts assumed a rationalised reserve boundary generally corresponding to the top of the Canning River Valley (ie. approximately 7m 8m AHD).

Draft TPS No. 21 showed a potential river front road in this area that cannot extend eastwards from the property and terminates at the Lot 40 boundary and thereby serves no public purpose.

An examination of this section of the river foreshore suggests that a river front road will be difficult to achieve elsewhere and that in any event this section of river would be more suited to passive recreation based upon a series of walktrails with recreation nodes sited at convenient locations.

FAOperations1JOBS11489 Sorgiovanni A 8 C re Subd Maddington \ Repor102.docl 0 Landvision 27/01/2010 4...... <<, we 4. * 1 % ********* 1;pir + II % * t#50

The lack of adequacy of the current reserve boundaries has also beenrecognised by the EPA.

In 2005 the then Minister for Environment in addressingissues raised in the draft Environmental Protection (Swan Coastal Plain Wetlands) Policy andRegulations wrote to the owners of Lot 40 advising of the appointment of a panel toprovide further advice to her on the "social, economic and environmentalissues associated with the revised draft policy".

The EPA's report to the Minister for the Environment recommendedinter alia that further scientific assessment would be undertaken of those wetlands set asidefrom the draft Wetland Register and listed in Appendix 4 to its report. Appendix 4lists wetland number 81-1409 which affects the subject land.

Also in 2005, MRS amendment 1082/33 was being processed whichsought to impose a special control area which aligned with the MRS boundary as partof implementing the Bush Forever program. This amendment has not been progressed.

Volume 1 of Bush Forever Part B indicates that the boundaries of some areasto be protected may require further on-site identification and confirmationand may also require adjustments (p 9).

For Bush Forever sites in MRS reserves, some adjustments maybe required to give full protection and long term security possibly including adjustments tothecontrol, management and purpose of the reserve (p 12).

In respect to Lot 40, the fringing vegetation on Lot 40 occupies only asmall proportion of the site, whereas the MRS reserve appears to be a uniform and arbitrary 50 metresetback line.

It is unreasonable to use the MRS reserve boundary as the basis for aspecial control area where clearly the significant bushland has not been mapped nor an appropriatebuffer determined.

A site investigation reveals that the MRS reserve in this area does not recognisethe narrow extent of the flood plain and the riparian vegetation in this area. Indeedthe MRS reserve takes in a significant part of Mr Sorgiovanni's orchard which is on high groundwell above the flood plain. Its continuation on to Lot 41 also seems to be excessive.

In particular the MRS reserve does not follow the flood plain in this areaand includes high land which has no relationship to either the remnant riparian vegetation northe flood plain.

There is no logical reason why this land should be included in thespecial control area particularly asitcontains a residence as well as Mr Sorgiovanni's orchards. Mr Sorgiovanni has a very long family attachment to the house and wishes it toremain in the family.

F:lOperationskJOBS11489 Sorgiovannf A & C re Subd Maddingtan1Report02.d0C1 2 Landvision 27/01/2010 In sununary the owner sought to modify both thespecial control area boundary and MRS boundary to match the distinctive flood plain in this area,and remove from consideration the area outside the flood plain which containsMr Sorgiovanni's residence and orchards and which has no physical link with the riverine andbush environment.

This submission proposes a modified MRSboundary which recognises the natural topography and the extent of the riparian vegetation(see Figure 6).

The attached plan indicates how this conceptmight be applied to this stretch of river (see Figure 7).

As a result of this, we believe road connections alongthe riverfront would be undesirable as it would destroy this peaceful stretch of the CanningRiver.

Given the above it is requested that the WAPC re-examinethe MRS boundary in this area to reflect the topography (the flood plain)and protection of riparian vegetation including the extension of open space along the Helm StreetMain Drain to Albany Highway.

Landvision FAOperationAJOBS \ 1489 Sorgiovanni A & C re Subd MaddinglonReport02.doci 3 27101/2010 Flood100 Way Year Flood Plain and Level LEGEND SIJESDIVISON EXISTING ProposedEdgeExisting of amendmentVegetationMRS Reserve to _MRS_Reserve L NI\ _ _ _._..5.45 : \ N RecreationProposed Path, Node, Existing Foot Bridge Path 0 N. .--- f.---' . '-* ..- 1 N 'f \ \ ---1.. N \/ / / .,>' \ ''`. \\v/ \/ \\ \ \\NA:\ ; \ \ / / / 7 'i this area through MRSAmendment Boundary NO.relocated 1028/33 in \7 \ \ \\ \ '-'- 7 / / / / / / / \/ 7.-----.1. :>7./ / \ - .\ / / ....;\ / / / 40 / .;\''*\-/..,,._.\ ( c,_------> - N \ / V \\,,,\ )) A445660 / ,/ / \ / .60 PROPOSED FORESHORE RESE \ throughMRS Boundary Amendment relocated NO. 768/33Ain this area FIGURE 6 JOIN...WPMoeu,nty IDA SCALE tRoo, (MI /.1 UndpinivieleinepPtConzubsraLerMILdian..0040VM00 PROPOSED MRS BOUNDARY MODIFICATION 05 00 40m Mon%Gesluileselinhlohmame.TOO XIX 0101 LOTS40,41ANDADJOINING LAND HOLDINGS, RIVER AVENUE, MADDINGTON PLEONnmMwn141480m4Inc 01345 WRim4B053S0oPo004 elk": loud Way00 Year Flood Plain _ - RIPARIAN VEGETATION PROTECTIONTO RIVER FLOOD PLAIN MRSAND RESERVE SURPLUS ProposedRecreation Patli.Local Nob°, ExlatIng Opon Fool Space_BrlOgo - -. e"-Th00 00 AreMilsrrICA FIGURE 7 tociabnP1041Landlinnha&11509mosfrilley tonefrii SCALE113000CAZI Me0.10141thelsoPse100248105iluithoWtearle m®1110 FORESHORE CONCEPT PLAN- CANNING RIVER I HELM STREET MD Ulm (1,1. loom N rerpunmanatitttairn$ LOTS 40, 41 AND ADJOINING LAND HOLDINGS, RIVERAVENUE, MADDINGTON FILE: MIDataTImlindll19rtmdclinglau1200449REPORTZ14B9-11g.FC.P.000.dgn ATTACHMENT NO. 1 SUBMISSION ON MRS AMENDMENT NO. 1082/33 ATTACHMENT TO SORGIOVANNISUBMISSION This submission is made by Landvision on behalf of Mr C. Sorgiovanni theowner of Lot 40 River Avenue.

Mr Sorgiovanni objects to the impositionof a special control areaon his property which in this instance aligns with the MRSboundary.

Volume I of Bush Forever Part B indicatesthat the boundaries ofsome areas to be protected may require further on-site identification and confirmation and may also requireadjustments (I) 9).

For Bush Forever sites in MRSreserves, some adjustments may be requiredto give full protection and long term security possibly including adjustments to the control,management and purpose of the reserve (p 12).

In respect to Lot 40, the fringing vegetation on Lot 40 occupies only a small proportionof the site, whereas the MRS reserve appears to be an arbitrary 50 metre setbackline. We believe it unreasonable to use the MRS reserve boundary as the basis fora special control area where clearly the significant bushland has not been mapped nor an appropriatebuffer determined.

In particular the MRS reserve does not follow the flood plain in thisarea and includes high land which has no relationshipto either the remnant riparian vegetationnor the flood plain.

There is no logical reason why thisland should be included in thespecial control area particularly as it contains an inhabited residence as well as Mr Sorgiovanni'sorchards.

We submit that if the WAPC wishesto match the special controlarea with the MRS reserve then both should be modified in this area to coincide with the physical topography ofthe land. Consistent with the above Mr Sorgiovanni is prepared to waive his rightsto a payment for the acquisition of the modified reserved land provided he can retain the houseas indicated in the attached sketch. Thereason for this is that Mr Sorgiovanni hasa very long family attachment to the house and wishes it to remain in thefamily.

In summary we seek to modify both the special control area boundaryand MRS boundary to match the distinctive flood plain in thisarea, and remove from consideration thearea outside the flood plain which contains Mr Sorgiovanni's residence and orchardsand which has no physical link with the natural riverineand bush environment.

Trevor :G. Moran Landvision ATTACHMENT NO. 2 SUBMISSION ON ODP PLANNING FRAMEWORKTO REPLACE DRAFT TPS NO. 21 Chief Executive Officer City of Gosnells PO Box 662 GOSNELIS WA 6990

Attention: City Planning

Dear Sir/Madam

Proposed Planning Framework to replace Draft Town Planning Scheme No. 21

I/we would prefer the City to proceed with:

A) Draft TPS 21 (tick as appropriate)

B) An Outline Development PlanRe7 instead of Draft TPS 21.

Other Comments:

sce PrITAWty

Please note: If this matter requires a Council decision then the details you provide on this form will be included in the relevant Council Agenda and therefore be publicly available unless reasons are otherwise provided on this form for this fo not occur.

(Please tick) Owner Occupier

Signed: Date: 5.06 Print Name: IMO ft- Ph) 4 LA-WOVISIOA., ortet: Postal Address: Properly Address: 76 61.1VelktristavElMfrOWN6M0 Daytime Phone No: anTIT! Linvov[ioN) Please_NoietSubmission's -must :be.-received by-Councillay- not later-tharikiOriday 29 Septernber 2006 Office Use Oni Assessment No: Street: Lot No.:

http9iwv.vi.gosnells.wa.gov.autuploadigosnells,F155E0A13FBF4DACAFC4934F2090CAAA.doc SUBMISSION ON PROPOSED PLANNING FRAMEWORK TO REPLACE DRAFT TOWN PLANNING SCHEME NO. 21

1.INTRODUCTION

This submission is made by Landvision on behalf of Mr and Mrs Sorgiovanni of 78 River Avenue, Maddington and Mr A. Sorgiovanni of 9 Serenity Court, Maddington.

The submission is in two parts. The first is in response to the Council's proposal to replace draft Town Planning Scheme (TPS) No. 21 with an outline development plan and the second relates to Lot 40 River Avenue owned by Mr and Mrs Sorgiovanni and for which a subdivision application has been made to the WAPC.

2.PROPOSED OUTLINE DEVELOPMENT PLANS TO REPLACE DRAFT TPS NO. 1

The proposed replacement of draft TPS No. 21 with an outline development plan is supported.

However we believe the City should pursue the rezoning of the area subject of draft TPS No. 21 to "Residential Development" now and introduce provisions into the residential development zone to make the development of an area subject to an approved Outline Development Plan rather than require the preparation of an ODP prior to the rezoning.

The early rezoning of the area will give all of the affected landowners confidence with the requirements of the Residential Development zone and will give some conclusion to the work carried out to date in preparing draft TPS No. 1.

Following rezoning, precincts to which ODP's apply need to be identified. This may relate to physical entities or in some cases to a cadastral land parcel where groups of landowners have combined to prepare a comprehensive plan across individual lot boundaries.

3.LOT 40, RIVER AVENUE, MADDINGTON

The above property is currently subject to an application to subdivide (WAPC Ref No. 130533).

The subdivision application was made in anticipation of the finalisation of TPS No. 21.If TPS No. 21 is to be replaced by an ODP then we submit that the precinct to which the ODP applies in this case need only incorporate Lot 40 and possibly adjoining Lot 41 as land to the east has already been subdivided and the river foreshore reserve and River Avenue form a natural dividing line from other precincts.

F:10peralions WOMI489Submission2.doc 3/10/2006 It was noted in the subdivision application that the MRS reserve in this area does not recognise the narrow extent of the flood plain and the riparian vegetation in this area. Indeed the MRS reserve takes in a significant part of Mr Sorgiovanni's orchard which is on high ground well above the flood plain. Its continuation on to Lot 41 also seems to be excessive.

Accordingly the subdivision application proposes a modified MRS boundary which recognises the natural topography and the extent of the riparian vegetation (see attached).

In addition the subdivision proposes a cul de sac similar to the approved subdivision to the east. This varies from proposals in draft TPS No. 21 which show a potential river front road in this area that cannot extend eastwards from the property and terminates at the Lot 40 boundary and thereby serves no public purpose.

We have taken the liberty of demonstrating how this concept might be applied to this stretch of river (see attached plan).

As a result of this, we believe road connections along the riverfront would be undesirable as it would destroy this peaceful stretch of the Canning River.

As indicated in the subdivision application, my clients are prepared to cede the land contained in the reduced MRS reserve, free of cost to the Crown should the modified reserve be acceptable to the City and the WAPC.

4. SUMMARY

Given the above we submit that, at the strategic level:

(I)the City seek the Minister's consent to amend their scheme to include the land subject of TPS No. 21into the Residential Development zone subject to the subsequent preparation of outline development plans for identifiable precincts;

(2)identify Lots 40 and 41 as an identifiable precinct;

(3)request the WAPC to re-examine the MRS boundary in this area to reflect the topography (the flood plain) and protection of riparian vegetation including the extension of open space along the Helm Street Main Drain to Albany Highway;

FAOperations \JOBS \ 1489!Submission2.doc 3/10/2006 and at the subdivision level:

(4)re-assess the subdivision application for Lot 40 (WAPC Ref No. 130533) in the context of a reduced MRS reserve and a foreshore management plan based on a recreational trail network and passive recreation nodes;

Thank you for the opportunity to make a submission

TREVOIT G. MORAN Manager, Planning Services Landvision On behalf of Mr and Mrs C. Sorgiovanni 78 River Avenue, Maddingtou & Mr A. Sorgiovanni 9 Serenity Court, Maddington

F:lOperationsJOBS11489 \Subrrissfon2.doc 3/10/2006 (cadastralExisting not Subdivision shown)

FloodLEGEND Wan 1 MRS1001 oarResene Flood PIA,' gErlata pLannIngMaddIngtor920019090DrawingData: 29-Soa.06 No.: W417 14:07 489410-004. On ODOM Mop Foopollon M0094 - Zone SO Jab Na . 1409 TO RIVER FLOOD PLAIN ANDMRS RESERVE SURPLUS RiparianRemotionPrenatalUrban Vegetation Area Path, Nod., Existing Foot Bridge Palk 00 00 TSublaaoVVAGOODsub I W 5.1E Walal81 Monahan Road a P90190 &Mopping Consaltena 111 RIPARIAN VEGETATION PROTECT' 0 ProponodPropeical Legal ODP Open Roads, Spats deleted ---)000090( EF 05I apiquiresaborivisionoproto OWB2.109 I 1/1,#41k.1 FORESHORE CONCEPT 4111111111111.1.11.1 aelCANNING RIVER / HELM FOR PASSIVE STREET M.D. RECREATION ATTACHMENT NO. 3 CORRESPONDENCE TO WAPC AND CITY OF GOSNELLS 20062007 Job No. 1489

9 October 2006

The Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission Albert Facey House 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000

Attention: Ms Lindsay Baxter

Dear Sir/Madam,

RE: PROPOSED SUBDIVISION LOT 40 RIVER AVENUE, MADDINGTIN (WAPC REF: 130533)

Further to our site visit of June 8, wherein the applicants were afforded the opportunity to justify their request for a modified MRS reserve in respect to their property, we attach a foreshore concept for passive recreation for this stretch of the Canning River.

It became evident in preparing the above plan that the opportunity for a foreshore road in this area is minimal due to existing subdivision and development and in any event, highly undesirable given the attractive and secluded features of the area which would be diminished through easy vehicular access.

The attached concept plan was part of a submission made to the City of Gosnells in respect to progressing an ODP for the area instead of draft TPS No. 21. The full submission is attached for your information.

We would be pleased if you would review the MRS reserve along the lines suggested and assess the subdivision application accordingly.

Please do not hesitate to contact me if you require further information to progress the matter.

Yours faithfully

TREVOR G. MORAN Manager, Planning Services

FOOperations1JOBS14891t05.doc 9/10/2006 Job No. 1489 ANDVISION Land Planning, Development & Mapping Consultants ABU No. 52 058 714 aeo 6 August 2007

The Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission Albert Facey House 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000

Attention: Ms Jacqui Holmes

Dear Sir/Madam,

RE: PROPOSED SUBDIVISION LOT40 RIVER AVENUE, MADDINGTON (WAPC REF: 130533)

The above application was lodgedon February 17, 2006 and we understand has been deferred by the DPI pending the outcome ofother related matters whichare relevant toits consideration.

One of the outstanding issues is the boundaryof the Metropolitan Region SchemeParks and Recreation Reserve in thisarea.

On behalf of the owners of Lot 40 RiverAvenue, I andvision has made submissionsinitially to the WAPC in response to proposed Amendment 1082/33 and then to the.City ofGosnells- in response to theit proposalto disband proposed Town Planning SchemeNo 21 and replace it with an ODP.

On both occasions we soughtan amendment to the MRS boundary in respectto Lot 40. The basis for both submissions was that the existing MRS boundary does not reflectthe topography, the flooding regime and theriparian vegetation in thisarea, and is so excessive that the landward boundary topographicallybears no relationship to the river environment. The subdivision application was lodged between the two submissions referredto above in anticipation of a favourable consideration by the WAPC in respect to thesubmission made on Amendment No. 1082/33 and without any knowledge of the City of Gosnells proposedaction to disband TPS No. 21.

F:10peralonsUOBS114881510.0x 6054)7 15:45

Suite 5, 16 Nicholson Road Subiaco WA Torpnhnne ft1111 o'ana<34 n -._ . _ 6008 PAGE 2

Now that this has occurredwe note that under the new ODP proposal, landowners are to prepare individual ODPs for identifiable planning entities.In this respect we believe the planning entity for Lot 40 involves adjacent Lot 41only. These are the only two landholdings on this side of River Avenue and are otherwise bound by theriver reserve and already subdivided land to the north east.

In view of the above decision by the City ofGosnells and further to our previous submission, we seek the WAPC's favourable consideration toa modified MRS boundary for Pt Lot 40 and to Lot 41 as part of the ODP for thisarea which will allow the riverine environment to be retained but removes unnecessary and excessiveland currently included in thereserve on both properties.

This inclusion of Lot 41 in the aboveconsideration has of necessity resulted ina modified subdivision design for Lot 40 and in theevent that this submission is supportedwe would propose to replace the current subdivision application with the modifiedplan attached.

The subdivision of the land to the north east of Lot 40prevents a foreshore road being located in this area which in any eventwe believe to be undesirable for this secluded part of the river. In its place we propose a pathway system whichprovides for public access at River Roadon Lot 41 and from the opposite side of the riverto Lot 40.

It should be noted that the MRSreserve was previously amended on Lot 41 to avoid the owners house and improvenienti bin otherwiseappears not .to have taken account of the topography. Additionally the. MRSreserve 6 the east of Lot 40 Was also amended (MRS Amendment 1028/33), so there is evidence tosuggest that the initial boundary was perhaps arbitrarily established rather than the resultof detailed investigation:

The proposed modifiedreserve boundary for Lots 40 and 41 approximates the 7metre AHD contour which is the top of the river bankon Lot 40 and is well clear of the 100year flood level of 5.60 metres AHD.

Accordingly we seek your considerationto the above proposal and the initiation ofan MRS Amendment to reflect the modified boundary,after which the subdivision applicationcan be progressed (modified if necessary).

We would be pleased to discuss theintegrated :development of this planning precinctwith both the WAPC and the City of Gosnellsat your Convenience.

Yours faithfully

I/(01-,-/ TREVOR MORAN Manager, Planning Services c.c. City of Gosnells c.c. Ian Philp

FaenelocatIOSSMaLIMSx tiOn7 15:45

Suite 5, 16 Nicholson Road SubiacoWA 6008 Telephone: (08) 9388 8181 Facsimile: 9388 8185 Email: enquides©landvision.com.au Job No. 1489 Land Planning, Development &Mapping Consultants AIM No. 52 058 714 480

20 August 2007

The Chief Executive Officer City of Gosnells PO Box 662 GOSNELLS 6990 WA

Attention: Mr L Gibson

Dear Sir/Madam,

RE: REQUEST FOR MRSAMENDMENT, LOT 40 AND 41 RIVERAVENUE, MADDINGTON requesting an amendment to the Please find enclosed a copy ofcorrespondence sent to the WAPC application for subdivision of Lot MRS boundary on the above propertiesin association with a current 40 being considered by the WAPC.

of Lots 40 and 41 over a It occurs to us that the opportunityexists for the matters raised by the owners the MRS boundary on their property period of time in relation initially toTPS No. 21 and in relation to lift the urban deferred status of could properly be dealt with nowgiven Council's recent resolution to Avenue, Phillip Street, the CanningRiver and Arcadia Waters. the land bounded by River Lots 40 and 41 to Urban in the Accordingly we request Council toconsider a concurrent rezoning of interests of orderly planning for the MRS to complete the regional contextfor this discrete area in the area. automatically trigger a comparableamendment to TPS No. 6 with A single MRS amendment would 7.2.1 of TPS No. 6) where the requirement for the subsequentpreparation of an ODP (under Clause for Lots 40 and 41. A single there will be adequate opportunity forpublic input on the future planning the City and landowners. amendment will enable administrativeefficiencies and cost savings to both

We look fonvard to your favourableconsideration.

Yours faithfully

TREVOR G. MORAN Manager, Planning Services

FAOperOonsIJOBS%14891.112.00c 20'08/07 17:02

Suite5, 16 Nicholson Road Subiaco WA6008 Telephone: (08) 9388 8181 Facsimile:9388 8185 Email: [email protected] Job No. 1489 Land Planning, Development & Mapping Consultants ABN No. 52 058 714 480

11 October 2007

The Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission Albert Facey House 469Wellington Street PERTH WA6000

Attention: Ms Jacqui Holmes

Dear Sir/Madam,

RE. LIFTING OF URBAN DEFERMENT, LOTS 40 AND 41 RIVER AVENUE, MADDINGTON

We understand that the City of Gosnells has requested the lifting of urban deferment for a parcel of land bounded by River Avenue, Phillip Street, the Canning River and the Arcadia Waters retirement village.

The above area (Land parcel "A" on the attached plan) represents approximately65%of a pocket of urban deferred land in this area. The remaining35%is made up of Lots40and41 River Avenue (Land parcel "B") and an existing subdivided area to the north (Land parcel "C").

Given that Lots40and 41 River Avenue will be the only remaining undeveloped parcel of urban deferred land in this vicinity Landvision, on behalf of the owners of Lots40and41, requests that these lots together with the land already developed to the north be included in the lifting of deferment.

We have written to the City of Gosnells with the above request who have responded by referring us to the WAPC's "Guidelines for the Lifting of Urban Deferment" the main requirements of which are:

1) The capability of the land of being serviced 2) Planning is sufficiently advanced to depict an acceptable overall structure plan to guide future development 3) The proposal represents a logical progression of development 4) Regional requirements are satisfied 5) Any constraints to urban development can be satisfactorily addressed.

F3Operatom11085114891_1134oc 12/10/0713:M

Suite 5, 16 Nicholson Road Subiaco WA 6008 Telephone: (08) 9388 8181 Facsimile: 9388 8185 Email: [email protected] PAGE2

We also note that such applications are to be determined bythe Commission and that for small amendments a comprehensive structure plan may not be required.

Given the limited land area subject of the urban deferred zone in this area andthe fact that it is already surrounded by and partly developed for urban purposes it isevident that the lifting of urban deferment is a logical progression for urban development.

Infrastructure can be extended easily to service the subject area. In addition, a structureplan has been prepared for Lots 40 and 41 as part of an earlier submission to theWAPC in respect to the adjustment of the regional open space boundary on Lots 40and 41 (see attached). When combined with the proposed outline development plan for the land north of RiverAvenue we believe all the main requirements for the lifting of urban deferment have been met.

The owners of Lots 40 and 41 are supportive of the proposal as evidenced by ourearlier approach to the City of Gosnells on their behalf.

Environtnental issues are only relevant in respect to the modified regional open space boundary on Lots 40 and 41 for which a separate amendment has been requested (refer our previous correspondence of August 6, 2007 attached).

We would be pleased to meet with you to discuss the above and clarify our clients position.

Yours faithfully

TREVOR MORAN Manager, Planning Services

F501.t. ; U085114818113.6oc 12/10/07 13:50

Suite 5, 16 Nicholson Road Subiaco WA 6008 Telephone: (08) 9388 8181 Facsimile: 9388 8185 Email: enquiriesclandvision.com.au ATTACHMENT NO. 4 SUBMISSION ON CENTRAL MADDINGTONODP AND AMENDMENT NO. 89 Submission on Central Maddington GDP and Amendment No. 89 to the City of Gosnells TPS No. 6

This submission is made on behalf of Mr C Sorgiovanni, the owner of Lot 40,River Avenue, Maddington.

Lot 40 is in the area denoted "Subject to Further Detailed Planning"in the draft Central Maddington ODP and is excluded from the Residential Development zone in proposedamendment No. 89 to the City's TPS No. 6.

Currently lot 40 together with the balance of the land within the above area issubject to a submission to the City and the WAPC to have the deferment lifted on its urbandeferred zoning.

When this occurs (anticipated during the submission period for the ODP)the status of the land will be the same as that opposite on River Avenue and facing Phillip Street whichis shown as Residential R30 in the Central Maddington ODP.

Further as part of the submission made for the lifting of urban deferment anoutline development plan was prepared at a similar level of detail as provided for the landopposite.

Accordingly we submit that the notation on the ODP should be reviewedfor this area and that the area be included in the Residential areasimilar to the land opposite.

Also we note that both the subject land and the land opposite are excludedfrom the residential development zone in proposed amendment No. 89. This seems to be unnecessary asboth land parcels, once the urban deferment is lifted, will be of equal status to theadjoining urban land.

The exclusion of the subject land from a residential zone is even moredifficult to understand given the long planning history of the land and communication with theCity and the WAPC over recent years.

The recent planning background is as follows;

May 2005 Submission and attendance at hearing by the WAPC into an MRS Amendment (No. 10821/33 Bush Forever and Related Lands) which sought to designate a Bush Forever site over a significant proportion of lot 40 outside the floodplain of the Canning River and covering Mr Sorgiovannis' orchard. No determination has yet been made on the submission or the amendment asfar as we know

February 2006 Subdivision application lodged with the WAPC in anticipation of finalisation of TPS NO. 21. Application assessed by the City of Gosnells and adetermination deferred by the WAPC.

September 2005 -Decision by Council to replace draft City of Canning TPS No. 21 with an ODP Attendance by the owner at Councils meeting to support change to ODPand lodgement of submission expressing the above view.

June 2007 Agreement with the adjoining owner to prepare a precinct plan for Lots 40& 41 in accordance with the ODP framework.

FAOperations \JOBS \ 1489 Sorgiovanni A & C re Subd Maddington \Submission on Central Maddington ODP.doc August 2007 Request to City of Gosnells to lift urban deferment on Lots 40 & 41 River Avenue

June 2008 - Lodgement of submission to City of Gosnells and WAPC for lifting of deferment

All of the above communications clearly set out the owner's intention to seek subdivision of the land and contained concept layouts. A site visit was attended by a City planning officer but otherwise no other input has been provided by the City.

Given that the City has all the required documentation and has had ample time to consider the matter we believe it is now opportune for the City to include the subject land in the residential area of the Central Maddington ODP and the Residential Development zone of the City's Town Planning Scheme No. 6 as a precursor to the adoption of a precinct plan to the City's satisfaction.

We submit that it is unreasonable to subject the landowner to go through further unnecessary planning amendments in the future to both the ODP and TPS No. 6 when his intentions have been clearly known and documented and can be assessed by the City at this time in co-operation with the landowner.

Signed T.G. Moran

FAOperat ons \JOBS \ 1489 Sorgiovanni A & C re Subd Maddington \Submission on Central Maddington ODP.doe Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) Form 41 Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41 Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

ISUBMISSION NUMBER I ToSecretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000 Submission 28

Name OLfu\ RocQz &tr\OICONt-ke.r\ts.kGap (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) Addressipts4. keitt2:4( C)41^^ Roct4 Postcode 0020 clitra ,Su.>a e. go Com. els/ Contact phone number S'-°5- etnr Email address The following proposals are the subject of my submission ja.mr tAhArknecop fro ficgal (19

Submission (Please attach additional pages If required, it is preferred that any additional Information be loose rather thanbound)

L FtNer fide Zal ;ctl"$ echt,ifat(co}Attki()Nil en 4- Q (3 V cOcc fe.AfjeSelf ldnetc etr1/4"6. eigo-t et eocanmilien ...... tit+

41/4, c,,a zecre.don...... 01/4- ifttgAio rZ 4,3fe Iv ne caNtetn.Aerra/4 0Ar 1"-+ Nk>, L4-1( k old- gjv fit, r-Cco-liak ..)e.T.O.:Ap--tEnt t pdf,Irc, ,ptcy-to, so(snligN CV 114 ctreca, t4141

kite Ca"lek40^/ L a- o.pp. \ k

.QL(P.D.. u(C/or tope. 'deft fere'e, (cotpeti- .1" Nti3Ot 4-6 frod- ci" OP." eat.. (4Ocit/t.s CF0(4,ef Otr.S-ik-etaINS. TC(JA 4a t4/`J 4 csilikVat-) turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC, You do not have to attend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D.

Please choose one of the following:

ElNo, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign) OR

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following detallS) I will be represented by; Myself My telephone number (business hours) or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hourS): Postal address:

I would prefer my hearing to be conducted In: Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation) OR Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be permitted to attend)

You should be aware that:

The WAPC Is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be subject to applications for access under the act. In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making Its report on these submissions, copies of your submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties. All hearings are recorded and transcribed, The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are tabled In Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment. The WAPC recommendations are similarly published In a report on submissions and tabled In Parliament.

To be sinned by person(s) making the submission

atmgr. 2©(0 Signature k\c) WU, Date On 6etsoir np Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of business (5pm) on January 2010. Late submissions will NOT be considered.

Contacts: Telephone - (046 9204 7777; nem - (08)9264 7566; Erna - [email protected]; VVebsitehttp://vossv.pte nntngsvatov.au Submission 29

PERTH MELBOURNE SYDNEY DEPARTMENT FOR PLANNING ANDINFRASTRUCTURE

2 9 JAN ZOW

Our Ref: 710-152

29 January 2010

Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission TOWN PLANNING Albert Facey House AND URBAN DESIGN 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000

Attention: Ross ParkerPolicy and Projects Officer, Property Management Services

Dear Ross SUBMISSION ON METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEMEAMENDMENT 1161/41 PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATIONS FOR PUBLIC

I refer to the above proposal and our related discussions and meeting.Following on from the discussions at the recent meeting, TPG Town Planning and Urban Design(TPG) have prepared a submission on behalf of the Water Corporation relating toMetropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) Amendment 1161/41 Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands (MRS Amendment 1161/41).

The submission specifically relates to the Shire of Mundaring Proposal 5,Part (iii) (Figure 5) of MRS Amendment 1161/41 and seeks the withdrawal of part of Lot 1Allen Road and Lot 376 Mundaring Road (the subject land] from the current MRS amendmentproposal.

The Shire of Mundaring Proposal 5, Part (iii) relates to properties that aremanaged as an extension of the adjoining State Forest, with the current MRS amendmentproposal seeking to extend the State Forest reservation to include all the lots andrecognise the current use and status in the MRS.

The request for the withdrawal of the Subject Land from the currentMRS Amendment 1161/41 relates to the future intention to use this land as part of a new WaterCorporation Water Treatment Plant (WTP) associated with the Goldfields and AgriculturalWater Supply (CAWS).

Itis also intended that the Subject Land will be included in a futurestand alone MRS amendment proposal that will appropriately designate both the SubjectLand and the adjoining lot 375 Allen Road, Mundaring that forms part of the future WTP site, as a'Public Purposes Water Authority of WA reservation under the MRS. In this instance it isconsidered that the 'State Forest' reservation as proposed under MRS Amendment 1161/41 for the SubjectLand, is not the most appropriate reservation purpose for its future intended useand development.

PERTH OFFICE The Planning Group WA Pty Ltd Level 7, 182 St Georges Tce PO Box 7375 Cloisters Square Telephone +61 8 9289 8300 Perth Western Australia 6000 Perth Western Australia 6850 Facsimile +61 8 9321 4786 ABN 36 097 273 222 Secretary Western Australian Nanning Commission

SUBMISSION ON METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME AMENDMENT 1161/41- PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATIONS FOR PUBLIC

It is understood that the Department of Environment and Conservation(DEC) have lodged a separate submission seeking the withdrawal of both theSubject Land and the remainder of Lot 1 Allen Road from the proposal on the basis that the MRSamendment is unnecessary because the current 'Rural* zoning adequately reflects the DEC's currentmanagement of this land. This is a matter to be resolved with the DEC and does notform part of this submission, however it is noted that the southern portion of Lot 1Allen Road is intended to accommodate the relocation of the existing DEC Perth Hills DistrictOffice and associated depot facility.

It is understood, based on discussions held with yourself, that theDepartment of Planning is receptive to the withdrawal of the Subject Land from MRS Amendment1161/41 in recognition of the proposed future use and in order to avoid any delays in thefinalisation of the remainder of the MRS amendment.

In order to formalise the submission process, please find attached thefollowing:

1. A completed Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41Amendment (Substantial) Form 41. You will note on the form that I have indicated thatI would wish to be involvedinany hearings,however, depending on the ultimate response tothe submission this may not be necessary,

2. Three (3) unbound copies of a comprehensive report prepared by TPGTown Planning and Urban Design (TPG] to support the submission.

We look forward to your consideration of the submission and should youhave any queries in relation to the above, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned.

TPO TOWN PLANNING AND URBAN DESIGN

-7L

Murray Cassel on Associate

Encs.

Cc. Water CorporationSimon Maughan

2 Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) Form 41 Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

SUBMISSION NUMBER To:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000

Name MurraY.Casselton.:-.TRO.Town.Planoing and.W.ban.Design (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)

AddressPO Box 7375, Cloisters Square Perth WA Postcode 8850

Contact phone number (0.8).9289.83.00 Email address [email protected]....

The following proposals are the subject of my submission

M.etropolitan.Region.SchemeAmendment 1.16:1141 Shire of IVlundating. toposal 5, Part f Figure 5)

Submission (Please attach additional pages if required. It is preferred that any additional information be loose rather than bound)

Please refer to attached submission made on behalf of the Water Corporation.

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC. You do not have to attend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining therecommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer to the amendment reportand in particular appendix D. Please choose one of the following:

0 No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: MyselfMy telephone number (business hours): (Q8).9289.8300 or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours): Postal address:

I would prefer my hearing to be conducted in: Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation) OR

131 Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be permitted to attend)

You should be aware that: The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC maybe subject to applications for access under the act. in the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties. All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposedamendment. The WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissions and tabled in Parliament.

To be signed by person(s) making the submission

Signature Date 29. January 20.10

Note: Subrnissi (1ST he received by the advertised closing date, being close of business (5pton 29 January 2010. Late submissions will NOT be considered.

Contacts: Telephone - (08) 9264 7777; Fax - (08) 9264 7566; Email - [email protected]; Website - http://www.planning.wa.gov.au lOWN PLANK NU, AND ilR13414

ICI

LOT 1 ALLEN ROAD AND LOT 376, MUNDARING WEIR ROAD, MUNDARING

LLB- MISSION ON METROPOLITAN REGION J SCHEME AMENDMENT 1161/41 PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATIONS FOR PUBLIC LANDS

/ID H2 !AMORY 211In

perth sydney DOCUMENT CONTROL

Document ID: PLANNING/PG 201D/71D-152/ Final Report/ Final Document/ MRS Submission WTP Facility Issue Date Status Prepared by Approved by Name Initials Name Initials

1 28.01.10Final Michael Kevill Murray Casselton

This report has been prepared for the exclusive use of the Client, in accordance with the agreement between the Client and TPG ('Agreement'). TPG accepts no liability or responsibility whatsoever in respect of any use of or reliance upon this report by any person who is not a party to the Agreement or an intended recipient. In particular, it should be noted that this report is a qualitative assessment only, based on the scope and timing of services defined by the Client and is based on information supplied by the Client and its agents. TPG cannot be held accountable for information supplied by others and relied upon by TPG. Copyright and any other Intellectual Property arising from the report and the provision of the services in accordance with the Agreement belongs exclusively to TPG unless otherwise agreed and may not be reproduced or disclosed to any person other than the Client without the express written authority of TPG. 0

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

TPG Town Planning and Urban Design ITPG1 Purposes - Water Authority of WA' reservation have prepared this report on behalf of the under the MRS. In this instance it is considered Water Corporation as part of a submission on that the 'State Forest' reservation as proposed Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS] Amendment under MRS Amendment 1161/41 for the Subject 1161/41 Parks and Recreation Reservations Land, is not the most appropriate reservation for Public Lands (MRS Amendment 1161/41). purposeforitsfutureintendeduseand development. The submission specifically relates to the Shire of Mundaring Proposal 5, Part (iii) (Figure 51 ItisunderstoodthattheDepartmentof of MRS Amendment 1161/41 and seeks the EnvironmentandConservation(DEC]have withdrawal of part of Lot 1 Allen Road and Lot lodgedaseparate submission seeking the 376 Mundaring Road (the subject land) from the withdrawal of the Subject Land, the remainder current MRS amendment proposal. of Lot 1 Allen Road and other DEC landholdings in the locality from the proposal on the basis The Shire of Mundaring Proposal 5, Part Rill thatthe MRS amendmentisunnecessary relates to properties that are managed as an because the current 'Rural' zoning adequately extension of the adjoining State Forest, with the reflects the DEC's current management of this current MRS amendment proposal seeking to land. This is a matter to be resolved with the extend the State Forest reservation to include DEC and does not form part of this submission, all the lots and recognise the current use and however it is noted that the southern portion of status in the MRS. Lot 1 Allen Road is intended to accommodate the relocation of the existing DEC Perth Hills The request for the withdrawal of the Subject District Office and associated depot facility. Landfromthecurrent MRS Amendment 1161/41 relates to the future intention to use It is understood, based on discussions held with this land as part of a new Water Corporation the Department of Planning (DP), that the DP is Water Treatment Plant (WTP) associated with receptive to the withdrawal of the Subject Land the Goldfields and Agricultural Water Supply from MRS Amendment 1161/41 in recognition (SAWS]. of the proposed future use and in order to avoid any delays in the finalisation of the remainder Itis also intended that the Subject Land will of the MRS amendment. be includedinafuture stand alone MRS amendment proposal that will appropriately designate boththeSubject Land and the adjoining lot 375 Allen Road, Mundaring that forms part of the future WTP site, as a 'Public CONTENTS

1.0 INTRODUCTION 1 1.1 Preamble 1 1.2 Background 1

2.0 THE SUBJECT LAND 4 2.1 Introduction 4 2.2 Property Description 4 2.3 Site Context 5

3.0 EXISTING PLANNING FRAMEWORK 9 3.1 Metropolitan Region Scheme 9 3.2 Shire of Mundaring Town Planning Scheme No. 3 9 3.3 State and Local Planning Policies 9

4M PROPOSED FUTURE DEVELOPMENT 11 4.1 Site Development 11 4.2 Land Use and Amenity 11 4.3 Environmental Referrals, Vegetation Clearing and Replanting 13 4.4 Consultation 14

5.0 CONCLUSION 15

APPENDIX 1 17 Mundaring WTP Site New Lot and Easement Boundaries Plan 17

APPENDIX 2 19 Certificates of Title 19 0

1.0 INTRODUCTION

the Subject Land and the 1.1 PREAMBLE designate both adjoining lot 375 Allen Road, Mundaring that TPG Town Planning and Urban Design (TPG) forms part of the future WTP site, as a 'Public have prepared this report on behalf of the Purposes Water Authority of WA' reservation Water Corporation as part of a submission on under the MRS. In this instance it is considered Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) Amendment that the 'State Forest' reservation as proposed 1161/41 - Parks and Recreation Reservations under MRS Amendment 1161/41 for the Subject for Public Lands (MRS Amendment 1161/411. Land, is not the most appropriate reservation purposeforitsfutureintendeduseand The submission specifically relates to the Shire development. of Mundaring Proposal 5, Part pill (Figure 51 of MRS Amendment 1161/41 and seeks the It is understood, based on discussions held with withdrawal of part of Lot 1 Allen Road and Lot the Department of Planning (DP), that the OP is 376 Mundaring Road (the Subject Land! from receptive to the withdrawal of the Subject Land the current MRS amendment proposal. from MRS Amendment 1161/41 in recognition of the proposed future use and in order to avoid The Shire of Mundaring Proposal 5, Part (iii] any delays in the finalisation ofthe remainder relates to properties that are managed as an of the MRS amendment. extension of the adjoining State Forest, with the current MRS amendment proposal seeking to extend the State Forest Reservation to include 1.2 BACKGROUND all the lots and recognise the current use and By way of background, the Mundaring Weir was status in the MRS. developed in 1902 by the State's Engineer in Chief of Public Works CY O'Connor in response REFER TO FIGURE 1 - MRS AMENDMENT1161/41 to the need for a stable supply of waterfor the FIGURE 5 booming population in the Goldfields region of The request for the withdrawal of the Subject inland Western Australia. The weir was built to would Landfromthecurrent MRS Amendment create a 21 gigalitre water reservoir that 1167/41 relates to the future intention to use be pumped the 557 kilometres via pipeline to this land as part of a new Water Corporation service the prospecting areas of Coolgardie and Water Treatment Plant (WTP) associated with Kalgoorlie. The weir has created a large body the Goldfields and Agricultural Water Supply of water known as Lake CY O'Connor with a (SAWS). current capacity of 63.6 gigalitres, and this body of water remains the sole water source for the Itis also intended that the Subject Land will Goldfields and Agricultural Region of Western beincludedin afuture stand alone MRS Australia through the SAWS. amendment proposal that will appropriately Recent concerns regarding the quality of the water and the nature of the treatment facilities dispersed along the pipeline has ted the Water Corporation to investigate the opportunities for creating a consolidated WTP in close proximity tothe water source. Aftera lengthysite selection and community consultation process initiated in 2006, the Subject Land and Lot 375 Mundaring Weir Road have been chosen as the most suitable to accommodate the proposed infrastructure. Lot 375 and a portion of the Subject Land is the current location of the Department of Environment and Conservation [DEW Perth Hills District Office and associated depot facility which is intended to be relocated to an alternative nearby location within the southern potion of Lot 1 Allen Road where a modern, compact and upgraded facility can be developed, releasing the existing DEC Facility land on Lot 375 for the creation of the new WTP.

Itis understood that the DEC have lodged a separate submission seeking the withdrawal of the Subject Land, the remainder of Lot 1 Allen Road and other DEC landholdings in the locality from the proposal on the basis that the MRS amendment is unnecessary because the current 'Rural' zoning adequately reflects the DEC's current management of this land. This is a matter to be resolved with the DEC and does not form part of this submission. BM hot - II

MSc Blab 1. rest INV ..""ifir No 1. iiIIIMMIIMINIUM611117ctourrum,9\ 1011111111110111MMENINIMIar MIISIIMINEMENINEMEILIMMIP MMMMM 111111111111111111211911121EIMENISEMISIMEM 11111 ,AMISSMISKIMallatronnelit MMMMMMM aiNMMNE , rniiraOr SPMTREL MISIIMIWOM MMMM i 111101MINEMS.111112112111111111111tnitn MMMMMM 1111111111111121161111411111111161111. .. MMMMM AIIIIIMMUMMEIBM1161 lik. NMI El 411M1018 k amimm 11111111 RnoaSE MIIIIIT A saAonnntemiatauna ansingothomm, 111111111: _AIMENI inin II ' 41 LI! 2.0 THE SUBJECT LAND

2.1 INTRODUCTION Lot Deposited FolioArea Owner Details No. plan

The futureWaterCorporation WTPwill 45619 2585 6.6820ha Department of predominantlybe locatedwithinLot375 Conservation and Land Management Allen Road, part of Lot 1 Allen Road and Lot (DEC) 376 Mundaring Road, Mundaring. Lot 376 is 7815m2 State Forest WED) currentlyanunconstructedgazettedroad reserve that has been closed. The Subject Land is bounded by an unconstructed gazetted road reserve tothe Itis proposed that as part of a wider land east (Lot 3771 and Mundaring Weir Road to the rationalisation strategy within the area that west. Lot 375 incorporating the main portion of consolidatedlotswill be created thatwill the existing DEC facility abuts the Subject Land differenttitles and amalgamate several to the north and Lot 21 lies directly to the east. incorporatethe futureWaterCorporation

WTP and relocated DEC facility on separate REFER TO APPENDIX 2 - CERTIFICATES OF TITLE independent sites. Whilst this strategy is yet to be formalised and approved, for the purposes of REFER TO FIGURE 2 - SITE PLAN this report it will be assumed that independent development sites have been created. TheSubjectLandischaracterised by a graduated fall east to west across the site, from REFER TO APPENDIX 1 MUNDARING WTP SITE NEW around 235 metres to 200 metres AHD. This LOT AND EASEMENT BOUNDARIES PLAN topography will be likely to require some re- contouring in order to accommodate the future Water Corporation WTP. 2.2 PROPERTY DESCRIPTION As indicated above, the Subject Land upon which the development of the Water Corporation WTP CURRENT SITE DEVELOPMENT is proposed encompasses Lot 375 Allen Road, The Subject Land currently accommodates part of Lot 1 Allen Road and Lot 376 Mundaring a proportion of the DEC Perth Hills District Road, Mundaring. This submission however, Office and associated depot facility with the only relates to the relevant part of Lot 1 Allen remainder being undeveloped, and containing Road and Lot 376 Mundaring Road, which are remnant native and non-native vegetation. The includedinMRS Amendment 1161/41. The existing site development includes a number of Subject Land encompasses a total of 3.1665 buildings related to the historical and current hectares out of the total 12.5165 hectare WTP usage of the area. site. The certificateof titledetails for the Subject Land are providedinthe following REFER TO FIGURE 3 AERIAL PHOTOGRAPH table: 2.3 SITE CONTEXT The Subject Land is located approximately 5.5 kilometres south of the Mundaring Town Site, and approximately 30 kilometres directly east of the Perth CBD. The Subject Land falls within the Shire of Mundaring local government area.

Located directly across Allen Road to the south are camping facilities associated with the Bee lu National Park recreational bushland that ties within the catchment area for the Mundaring Weir water supply. A historic outdoor cinema and associated buildings are located on the reserved land to the south of the Subject Land.

Further to the south west are various tourism and recreation related uses that are associated with the national park, the Weir and the surroundingnaturalbushlandenvironment. Some buildings of heritage significance such as the Mundaring Weir Hotel and historical infrastructure relating to the original Goldfields water supply pipeline are located within close proximity. The area has a number of picnic and nature appreciation opportunities, as well as walking and mountain biking tracks that wind through the State Forest reserves in the area.

REFER TO FIGURE 4 LOCATION PLAN 0

FIGURE 2 - SITE PLAN

DP 35098 37 41 FI3 518605 P552

125

101 19 32

e273

376 85 55

35098 594 51

5505 5' P1577 50 MUNDARING 403 87 ski,0P

, 413 42

Lot 376 423 88 7 al 5M2

***1%OM (3.165ha)

`RS4 ®4r Lot 377 1.6847ha Lott 6.6820ha

SAWYERS VAL Y

Source lantlgate t

.. 0

FIGURE 4 - LOCATION PLAN

Dapi pyirnnmen, dnd Datiesavatisri Subject Site

F YHA ; betel:

The Hills Fattest "--cOuldnanC-nema (Dept ct Enm torment N./ 1,m0,, and Consentation,l ftf4c,\- °tonna =renal

Mandating View $hire, Mtipdaring

1-V .{11)11rt' SourceLendoat 3.0 EXISTING PLANNING FRAMEWORK

3.1 METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME The Subject Land is currently zoned 'Rural' under the MRS, as is the land directly abutting the site to the east and west. Directly to the south and north of the site is 'State Forest' reservation,andlocatedacross Mundaring Weir Road the land is reserved for 'Parks and Recreation'. MRS Amendment 1161/41 seeks to reclassify certain other DEC controlled land in the locality as State Forest reservation.

3.2 SHIRE OF MUNOARING TOWN PLANNING SCHEME NO. 3 The Subject Land is currently zoned 'Rural Landscape Living' under the Shire of Mundaring Town Planning Scheme No. 3(TPS3). The objectives of this zone relate principally to the protection of the 'rural environment and landscape',andareparticularly concerned with amenity and retention of environmentally significant vegetation and fauna.

REFER TO FIGURE 5 TPS 3 ZONING

3.3 STATE AND LOCAL PLANNING POLICIES Due tothe nature of the proposed future development itis considered that there are unlikely tobe any Statelevel or Shireof Mundaring planning policies of relevance to the proposal. 'N 4.0 PROPOSED FUTURE DEVELOPMENT

The following section provides a brief 4.2 LAND USE AND AMENITY commentary on the nature of the future WTP Asthefuturedevelopment wouldbefor and a summary of the statutory design and use thepurposesofaccommodating a Water requirements that are likely to be applicable in Corporation WTP facility, in terms of TPS3 the terms of the future assessment of the proposal. future land use would be likely to fall within the definition of 'Civic Use' as follows: 4.1 SITE DEVELOPMENT "The use of any land or building by a Government The Water Corporation WTP is proposed to Department, an instrumentality of the Crown, for address recent concerns regarding the quality administrative, recreational or other purpose." of the water and the nature of the treatment Whilst of limited relevance given the role of the facilities dispersed along the GAWS. WAPC in determining any future development The future development will ultimately application, uses permitted within the 'Rural comprise the following: LandscapeLiving'zone asdetailedunder 'Schedule 1' of TPS3 show that the 'Civic Use' A water treatment plant. is an 'SA' use. Ordinarily under the provisions of Clear water storage tanks and treated water TPS3 this would mean that the proposal would pump station. be subject toadvertising requirements and Operationandadministrationbuildingand special approval from the Shire of Mundaring workshop. Council, however as the development would involve public works undertaken by a public Sludge treatment facilities and drying beds. authority, these requirements would not apply. Interconnecting pipe work with the existing twin mains. Notwithstanding the above, the future Additionalinformation in respectto the development of the WTP facility would need to operational characteristics, staffing and consider the objectives of the zoning as detailed attendance and traffic access and car parking within TPS3. This includes the following: facilitiesassociatedwill be collatedand The protection and enhancement of the natural provided in due course but are not considered to environment is to be achieved via means of be required for the purposes of this submission. offset planting and extensive landscaping; The future clearing of vegetation on the Subject Land being offset via offsite plantings of a much larger scale, resulting in a net environmental benefit for the area; and Large setbacks, landscaping and on-site revegetation helping to reduce any impact of the built form on the amenity of the area. 0

OTHER DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS SETBACK REQUIREMENTS A number of requirements that would be of The objectives for building setback relevance to the assessment of the future WTP requirementsare aimedatpreservingthe facility are located within Section 4 of TPS3, as amenity of surrounding land uses. Building follows. setbacks are used to createconsistent streetscapes, and to ensure appropriate visual and acoustic buffering.Itisa requirement GENERAL REQUIREMENTS of Section 4.17(5) of TPS3 that buildings are TPS3 details a number of general development required to have a minimum setback of 20 requirements that relate to development within metres from the road unless varied by Council. land zoned 'Rural Landscape Living' in Section This will need to be considered as part of the 4.17. In terms of the future development, these future WTP proposal. requirements are addressed as follows:

The future WTP facility being developed to try PLOT RATIO AND SITE COVER and minimise any impacts on the 'scenic value' There are no specific provisions relatingto of the area. plot ratio and site cover set out under TPS that The future WTP facility not impeding on any would be of relevance to the future WTP facility. ridge or sight lines, and consideration being given tomaximisingthescreeningeffect utilising ofexistingmature vegetationand SCREENING, LANDSCAPING AND USE OF SETBACK additionallandscapingplantingsthatwilt remain between the development and the AREAS adjoining road network; The objectives for screening and landscaping Fencingfor thefuturedevelopmentbeing under the provisions in Section 4.19 of TPS3 are set well back from the adjoining roads, with as follows: remnant vegetation and landscaping screening it from casual observation while maintaining a.to maintain a comfortable, pleasant and relaxing security of the Subject Land and equipment; environment;

Natural vegetation that is to be removed as a b.to maximise privacy within individual lots; part of the future development being offset by c.to minimise theeffect of headlight glare, large scale additional plantings; and reflected heat and glare from parking areas; Wherepossible,excavationandfillbeing and minimised as much as is practically possible. d.to encourage the retention and replanting of indigenous vegetation. Itis anticipated that the future setback area 4.3 ENVIRONMENTAL REFERRALS, will largely consist of remnant vegetation and VEGETATION CLEARING AND additional landscaping and plantings to further REPLANTING shieldthefacilityfromcasualobservation The Water Corporation has referred the from passing road users. This will ensure a proposal for the WTP to the Commonwealth comfortable, pleasant and relaxing environment Department of Environment, Water, Heritage and address the matter as set out in the objective and theArts (DEWHA) fordetermination above. under the Environmental Protection and BiodiversityConservation Act1999andthe BUILDING HEIGHT State Environmental Protection Authority Existing TPS3 provisions (Section 4.36) indicate (EPA) under the Environmental Protection Act that no building should exceed two storeys or nine 1986. The proposal has been determined to metres in height. Variations to this requirement be Not a Controlled Action if undertaken in a are likely to be required for elements of the particular manner' under the Commonwealth future WTP facility. environmental assessment and 'Not Assessed Public Advice Given and Managed under Part V of the EP Act (Clearing(' under the State MOTOR VEHICLE ACCESS AND PARKING environmental assessment. Whilst TPS3has no specificcarparking requirement for the form of civic use that will While vegetation will be retained on the Subject be proposed, Section 4.28(3) states that where Land where possible, the development of the there is no car parking provision specified, the WTP facility will necessitate the clearingof requirement shalt be 'as determined by Council'. nativeandnon-nativevegetation.Thereis evidence of cockatoo activity at site and several Access arrangements, the future provision of of the trees have been identified as being suitable car parking and the design of the proposed nestinghabitatsfortheendangeredBlack car parking areas will respond to the parking Cockatoo species. To offset this clearing the demand and access requirements relevant to Water Corporation will conserve and revegetate the nature of the WTP facility. The car parking a property at Lot 8 Abercorn Road, TheLakes, will be constructed, drained and landscaped to a which is situated approximately 20 kilometres standard consistent with Council requirements. eastof theSubjectLand. Therevegetation process may take up to five years and willconsist HERITAGE CONSIDERATIONS of an initial 24 month comprehensive program of weed control, followed by local tree and shrub WhilstLot 1 contains buildingsthatareof species planting and progressive rehabilitation. designated heritage significance, heritage DEWHA have found that potential environmental considerationsarenot consideredtobe of issues such as Black Cockatoo habitat loss can relevance to this submission. be effectively managed via this offset package. Notwithstanding, the above, the area of clearing A series of community forums conducted by is unlikely to be considered to be significant in an independent facilitator where anumber of site options for the WTP were examined by the relation to the forested hills surrounding the community in conjunction with sustainability Subject Land. principles. Attendances at these community forumsdeclinedmarkedly whenitwas confirmed that the Water Corporation would not 4.4 CONSULTATION acquire private land for the WTP.

The Subject Land has been the subject of Inconjunction with the forums, community consultation and engagement throughout tours were conducted of prospective WTP sites thecomprehensivesiteselectionprocess and water treatment plants of similar size associated with the proposed Mundaring WTP. elsewhere in the metropolitan area. This process included consultation with the At a community forum in November 2006 a community of Mundaring on a suitable location formal assessment was undertaken by the potential sites for the WTP for the proposed WTP for a two-year period attendees of 11 using a PreliminaryMulti-CriteriaAnalysis from February 2006 through to February 2008. (MCA], which resulted in four site options being The consultation process consisted of a number identified for further analysis. of community forums in order to develop and Further detailed assessments of the four sites consider site selection criteria for the location were undertaken by the Water Corporation, ofthe WTP.Thistookintoconsideration inclusiveofdetailedconsultationwithkey technical, social, environmental and economic stakeholders. issues. Based on the detailed assessments and issues associated with the location of a chlorine storage The consultation and site selection activities facility, six alternative locations, using the four undertaken can be summarised as follows: sites were identified for the consideration of the WTP position. Development of a framework for community detailedsustainabitityassessment was consultation by anindependentfacilitator A through liaison with various local community conducted of all these sites using the MCA approach. Community members also indicated groups. their preferred site using a voting system. An initialpublic meeting attended by over 150peoplefollowing wide advertisingand Based on the resultsof the detailed MCA the distribution of a background information study, community voting preferences and in brochure. consideration of economic,environmental A second public meeting attended by andsocialcriteria,the Water Corporation approximately 170 people where interested recommended that the Subject Land is the stakeholders from various groups joineda most suitable location for the proposed WTP. representative consultative forum. This recommendation has held'inprinciple' approval from Government and the DEC. 5.0 CONCLUSION

TPG Town Planning and Urban Design have It is understood, based on discussions held with prepared this report on behalf of the Water the Department of Planning IDPJ that the DP is Corporation as part of a submission on MRS receptive to the withdrawal of the Subject Land Amendment 1161/41 Parks and Recreation from MRS Amendment 1161/41 in recognition Reservations for Public Lands. of the proposed future use and in order to avoid any delays in the finalisation of the remainder The submission specifically relates to the Shire of the MRS amendment. of Mundaring Proposal 5, Part (iii) (Figure 51 of MRS Amendment 1161/41 and seeks the Based on the above, it is respectfully requested withdrawal of part of Lot 1 Allen Road and Lot that the Western Australian Planning 376 Mundaring Road from the current MRS Commission approve the withdrawal of the amendment proposal. Subject Land from consideration as part of MRS Amendment 1161/41. The request for the withdrawal of the Subject Landfromthecurrent MRS Amendment 1161/41 relates to the future intention to use this land as part of a new Water Corporation water treatment plantassociated withthe Goldfields and Agricultural Water Supply.

ItisintendedthattheSubject Land will be includedin a future standalone MRS amendment proposal that will appropriately designate boththeSubjectLand and the adjoining lot 375 Allen Road, Mundaring that forms part of the future WTP site, as a 'Public Purposes Water Authority of WA' reservation under the MRS. In this instance it is considered that the 'State Forest' reservation as proposed under MRS Amendment 1161/41 for the Subject Land, is not the most appropriate reservation purposeforitsfutureintendeduseand development, APPENDIX 1

MUNDARING WTP SITE NEW LOT AND EASEMENT BOUNDARIES PLAN LEGEND 50 7010 Covent Land Tenure I lil 1 011tr T l V la Rose= State Forest! DEC 3506m1EASEM g DEC Depot i 0 ShireWater of Corporation Mundaring i 4/C4 / CONSERV RESERVE' erA4 4 / / 0 Public Road the 17> Unallocated Crown Land / fW3 2, I r eehold Lot , odl 790 -- N... N., 1/2002. N. N. (100m2) Part Lot Area '" `.2./ 2, EASEMENT 1,82707a IA '0 ° 04 N. N I 3.5072ha New LotArea ' A couOM Or ' 1 I/ I/ ., 2 EASEMENT 60 , EASEMENT2720ehr, I (29 Mesta)/I DEC LOT 33 6550ha COMMATII$M014 0...94M061.011 MUNDARING 1 I rewam.,. m. =-- ,,, _ 00 tce MUNDARINGINTP LOT 12 5165ha / I/7 20722222.2420200, 20 0 20 moms 40 LIO 00 -- " WEIR VI LLATGE_ - IJC.4 R5 VOL 4t EASEMENT 25m321 . ,u I I I all 252 50-4' /II I 1 I 4042 REFERJ11200212013 SO PartDEC NowDEPOT DEC SITE Lot na' 17° ,,,,qr,s, OROPOS- PC.IS 0 e.,.... I (4 6185ha) \ \ at \ Imo Mb I \ \ oWATi.. \ \ NewBoundariesMundaring Lot & Easement WTP Site Figure 11.1 APPENDIX 2

CERTIFICATES OF TITLE REGISTER NUMBER 1/DP45619 DUPLICATE DATE DUPLICATE ISSUED EDITION WESTERN AUSTRALIA 1 30/5/2005

VOLUME LIO RECORD OF CERTIFICATE OF TITLE 2585 8 UNDER THE TRANSFER OF LAND ACT 1893

The person described in the That schedule is the registered proprietor of an estate in fee simple in the land described below subject tothe reservations, conditions and depth limit contained in the original grant (if a grant issued) and to the limitations, interests, encumbrancesand notifications shown in the second schedule.

REGISTRAR OF TITLES

LAND DESCRIPTION: LOT 1 ON DEPOSITED PLAN 45619

REGISTERED PROPRIETOR: (FIRST SCHEDULE)

THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTMENT OF CONSERVATION & LANDMANAGEMENT OF 50 HAYMAN ROAD, COMO (AF 1184964) REGISTERED 16 FEBRUARY 2005

LIMITATIONS, INTERESTS, ENCUMBRANCES AND NOTIFICATIONS: (SECOND SCHEDULE)

I. SAVE AND EXCEPT THE RIGHTS TO MINES OF COAL OR OTHER MINERALS

Warning: A current search of the sketch of the land should be obtained where detail of position, dimensions or area of the lot isrequired. * Any entries preceded by an asterisk may not appear on the current edition of the duplicate certificate of title. Lot as described in the land description may be a lot or location.

END OF CERTIFICATE OF TITLE

STATEMENTS: The statements set out below are not intended to be nor should they be relied on as substitutes for inspection of the land and the relevant documents or for local government, legal, surveying or other professional advice.

SKETCH OF LAND: DP45619 [SHEET 1]. PREVIOUS TITLE: 2112-98. PROPERTY STREET ADDRESS: NO STREET ADDRESS INFORMATION AVAILABLE. LOCAL GOVERNMENT AREA: SHIRE OF MUNDARING.

LANDGATE COPY OF ORIGINAL NOT TO SCALE Mon Jan 11 11:13:30 2010 JOB33631970 REGISTER NUMBER 375/D6300 DUPLICATE DATE DUPLICATE ISSUED EDITI ON WESTERN AUSTRALIA N/A N/A

VOLUME FOLIO RECORD OF QUALIFIED CERTIFICATE LR3012 151 OF CROWN LAND TITLE UNDER THE TRANSFER 013 LAND ACT 1893 AND THE LAND ADMINISTRATION ACT 1997 NO DUPLICATE CREATED The undermentioned land is Crown land in the name of the STATE of WESTERN AUSTRALIA, subject to the interests and Status Ordersshown in the first schedule which are in turn subject to the limitations, interests, encumbrances and notifications shown in the second schedule.

REGISTRAR OF TITLES

LAND DESCRIPTION: LOT 375 ON DIAGRAM 6300

STATUS ORDER AND PRIMARY INTEREST HOLDER: (FIRST SCHEDULE)

STATUS ORDER/INTEREST: VESTED UNDER STATUTE

PRIMARY INTEREST HOLDER: CONSERVATION COMMISSION OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA OF CARE OF DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION, LOCKED BAG 104, BENTLEY DELIVERY CENTRE. (XE L075814) REGISTERED 16 SEPTEMBER 2009

LIMITATIONS, INTERESTS, ENCUMBRANCES AND NOTIFICATIONS: (SECOND SCHEDULE)

1. STATE FOREST NO 7. 2. L075814 VESTED. PURSUANT TO SECTION 7(1) OF THE CONSERVATION AND LAND MANAGEMENT ACT 1984. REGISTERED 16.9.2009.

Warning: (1) A current search of the sketch of the land should be obtained where detail of position, dimensions or area of the lot is required. Lot as described in the land description may be a lot or location. (2) The land and interests etc. shown hereon may be affected by interests etc. that can be, but are not, shown on the register. (3) The interests etc. shown hereon may have a different priority than shown.

END OF CERTIFICATE OF CROWN LAND TITLE

SKETCH OF LAND: D6300 [SHEET I]. PREVIOUS TITLE: THIS TITLE. PROPERTY STREET ADDRESS: NO STREET ADDRESS INFORMATION AVAILABLE. LOCAL GOVERNMENT AREA: SHIRE OF MUNDARING.

LANDGATE COPY OF ORIGINAL NOT TO SCALE Mon Jan 11 11:13:30 2010 JOB 33631970 Seals; Civil/learn tit n/c4-4 Aite4ber anal Pad _Land is mt/ed Area- Ain't arDiottriell or location.. Honk. Matto to Orni./465 1201.,322... 101.1013....t-A. R. P. /9.9. 429 . /.I /bald 467 2/ 314(AN : /3/ Goss .946,1,itflit . 86/ lighliippi 0'lefippp7tyirpprpr9ppfipiqq.7 \\\\ N% \ \ \\ NNIV V \\ " \t \\ N . let> 1 N\ V>0 a

..;., Thee Pub&.-Prorks.,;461 /902:

:L.). Mundaig rig forestry,57a77onlbsuildingi; \'...<: To beisesumeti.-: 44 Plan. showing land -.. 11

DIA 6300 10

28 "

2.60

0.e ed

CIL

9 /0 // /2 3

re APFADVALIOF LOOM. AUTHORITY CERTIFICATE ...... I hereby certify that this survey wasperformed by me' personally (or under ,my own personalsupervision; <. striitoccordance -. Coe., Tirrig n inspection, and flelacheck), in 10 1923 with the Regulations for theguidance of Surveyers, 127', c and that this plan is in all respectsaccdrate..

. . DATE 'r. LICENSED SURVEYOR DIAGRAM N? ON APPROM PY''Arti,e t PLAN '.4-102 Nencton 0? PugsnoqUIWZYS D !?, gr.f.' 04...... 6300 11 14:1: LAI\IDGAMt-01'ut GIIG7itJ.0 I m'SUALt Mon7a7:7111:13:3U2611)Jt/1033;119/U DIMENSIONSMAY NOTTHE AVAILABLE REPRESENT DIMENSIONS FROM THE SHOWN PRECEDINGSURVEY MOST RECENTON RECORDS THISFOR PLAN AND THE DOCUMENTS LOT(S) SHOWN HEREON DP 236080 UCL P 1977 HELD BY DUIN DIGITAL ICP RESUMPTION 83) SF No.DP 7 203397(EP 3397) FORM ONLY

SF No.DP 7 203397A 6203(CP 3397) TYPE FREEHOLD COMPILED FROM TOWNSITELOCALDISTRICT AUTHORITY SWAN SHIRE OF MUNDARING FILE INDEXRECORDED 8034 (10) 75ON ARE INALLSCALE METRES DISTANCES (PAI 1:2000 0 10 40 DO BD TN PLANPURPOSE OF CONVERSION PD 410912808 LOCALITY THIS PLAN CREATED FOR CERTIFICATE MUNOARING PUBLIC [SD REFERENCE DART-CSOLOP4S619.CSO DEPOSITED. PLAN RE. LOT 1 TWOOS FORMER TENURE THIS PLAN PROVIDES A GRAPHIC REPRESENTATION OF THE EXISTING LOINS) OF TITLE LAND DESCRIPTION PURPOSES % Department of Land Information SHEET 1 OF 1 CHECKEDRP.PREPARED BY BY 102,2005 DATEDATE C/TBALANCE 2112/913 OF OFAND PAPER ALLOCATES CERTIFICATES A WHOLE OF LOT(S) TITLE AND TO THEDESCRIPTION DIGITAL REGISTER. FOR THE CONVERSION EDITION 45619 1 VERSION DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING

29 JAN 2010 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING

FILE iCl,6fro(36 Planning and Deve oprnent mc( 01 FEB 2010 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial)antial) Form 41 FILE Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OPiWE use OM/

To:Secretary Western AesiraLdri Planning C0110114SSIOn 489 Wellington afro& Submission 30 Para WA 6000

Name (Aft0 ,gMALP)Ni)CCIUNCA\-- LA (tvu (FLEASS FRKCLeAL'I) Address90 6( .32,-G LkSV (A16 Postcode 612-

Contact phone number R2-1 k 51 31 E Jail address 0(90 OCA, (CU 2- 0 1 2- 1 - 9it ecc&5e The following proposals ard the subject of my submission

OV oC c(ANOA,

Submission (Paf'e Oath additional pages if dqufred. It is preferred that any addefenel infoanatiOn be loose rather than bound) 8o-QA1oAtek

turn over to complete your submission r an Bushland MRS Amendment 1161/41 Council WA Inc PROPOSAL 3 City of Stirling

To (i) transfer lot 56 Venice Court, Dianella from the urban zone to the parks and recreation reserve and (ii) include it in Bush Forever site 43.

The Urban Bushland Council acknowledges the role of the Friends of Dianella Bushland in the initial acquisition of Bush Forever site 43 and its subsequent management by the City of Stirling as a regionally significant bushland reserve. The Friends of Dianella Bushland is a volunteer community group conducting educational walks and events in the Cottonwood Crescent bushland (Site 43), and assists the City of Stirling in the management of the reserve.

We support (i) the transfer of Lot 56 Venice Court to P&R reservation and conditionally support (ii) its inclusion in Bush Forever site 43 with the following comments:

The area is not suitable for housing or development because of its irregular elongated shape and position in the landscape adjacent to the sump, the road and Bush Forever site 43.

The area considered on its own does not qualify for inclusion in Bush Forever as it does not meet the criteria for regionally significant bushland. Being adjacent to a Bush Forever site however, it has important value as a buffer zone to a Bush Forever site and as an ecological connection to Cottonwood Crescent reserve, the Water Corporation Sump and to the Channel 9 bushland.

The topography of the area has been grossly altered by the tunnel structure under the road and accompanying site works (limestone retaining walls).

PO Box 326, West Perth 6872 Western Australia Street address: Lotteries House 2 Delhi Street, West Perth Phone: (08) 9420 7207 Fax: (08) 9420 7208 Email: ubc @iinetnet.au A.B.N: 50 595 076 388 From the proposal it appears the tunnel will exit into the bushland, and cut off pedestrians and cyclists from the pathways bordering Dianella Drive, negating the original purpose of the tunnel to transfer residents safely from one side of a busy road to the other. This will need to be changed so that pedestrians and cyclists have easy access to the roadside pathway but so that kangaroos do not have open access to the road. New fencing will be necessary given the area is habitat for up to 20 Western Grey Kangaroos.

SUMMARY

Our support to the amendment is subject to the following conditions being added to the addition of lot 56 Venice Court to the Parks and Recreation Reservation:

1. The area be managed by the City of Stirling as a bushland conservation site with a budget allocation to re-fence and rehabilitate the site as below

2. All woody and grassy weeds be removed and the area be properly rehabilitated and revegetated with local provenance species which belong to the native plant community of the site.

3. The area be re-fenced so that kangaroos have controlled access to the area but not the road, and pedestrians using the underpass have easy access to the roadside footpath

4. The City of Stirling provide operational budget allocation each year for management of the area as a bushland conservation area.

5. The area be added to Bush Forever site 43 after the initial weed removal and rehabilitation is completed

C Mary GrayVL 1-j President 28th January 2010 Submission 31 SWAN RIVER ab TRUST

Your Ref 809-2-1-74 P11 Our Ref DEC14298 Enquiries Jasmine Tothill

Tony Evans Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission Albert Facey House 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000

Attn: Ross Parker

Dear Mr Evans

PROPOSED MRS AMENDMENT 1161/41 PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATIONS FORPUBLIC LANDS

Thank you for your letter of 5 October 2009 in which youinvite comment from the Swan River Trust on proposed Metropolitan Region Schemeamendment 1161/41 to update zones and reservations as they relate topublic lands. Of the 155 amendment proposals, 60 will potentiallyimpact upon foreshore areas of the Swan and Canning rivers and their associatedtributaries, including land within or abutting the Trust's Development Control Area (DCA). The Trust supports the majority of the proposedchanges which seek to formalise existing public foreshore areas, excise unrelatedpublic utility sites and road reserves and correct minor boundary anomalies. There are several changes, however, that are stronglyopposed by the Trust. These include two amendments within the City of Bayswaterand the City of Gosnells which propose to reduce public foreshore reserverequirements over private properties and two amendments within the City of Canning andthe City of Swan which propose to excise bridge structures from Parks and Recreation (P&R)reserved land The Trust has requested some further modifications tothe amendment having regard to long term planning objectives for the river,including protection of the environment and public access and amenity considerations. An outline of the Trust's comments on the relevantamendment proposals is outlined below: Local ProposalProposal Swan River Trust Comment GovernmentNo.

Armada le 3(0 Reserve 27572, 28293, 28353 SUPPORTED and Lot60Collins Rd, Immediately abuts the Canning River. Roleystone Transfer from Rural and Urban to P&R Check accuracy of Lot and Reserve numbers listed in the Amendment report.

CARING FOR THE SWAN AND CANNING RIVERS Level IFlyon Centre 20 !some Rood Fos! Perth Western Australia 6004 PO Box 6740 Hay Shed East Perth 6892 Telephone (08) 92780900 Fox toe) 9325 7149 1WNI. swanriveitrusl.wo.gov.ou 300 Lot 3 Croyden Rd & Lot 15 SUPPORTED Wymond Rd,Roleystone Transfer from Rural to P&R Immediately abutsthe CanningRiver. Acquired by WAPC for foreshore purposes.

12 Lot 66 & portionLot 123SUPPORTED StockerRd,Roleystone Transfer from Rural to P&R Near Canning River but not contiguous with foreshore reserve. Will form a small connecting: pocketof P&Rbetween foreshore and Darling Range. Regional Park.

Bassendean 1 Lots 11 & 12 North Rd, SUPPORTED Bassendean Transfer from Urban to P&R Forms part of Pickering Park owned by the Town of Bassendean. Will provide an extension of existing foreshore reserve. Lots are partly zoned/ partly reservedwill correct anomaly. Check property address. Is showing as Bassendean Pde on amendment maps not North Rd,

2(i) Reserve 47628 Guildford Rd SUPPORTED Transfer from Urban to P&R Comprises an existing public recreation reserve, contiguous with foreshore of the Swan River.

200 Reserve 3987 Earisferry Ct,NO OBJECTION Bassendean Transfer from Urban to Railways Abuts DCA. Reflects existingcadastral boundary of railway reserve.

Bayswater 1 Lot 105 & portion Lot 156NO OBJECTION Milne Si, BayswaterTransfer from Urban to P&R Lot 105 contains a heritage building (Ellis House) listed inCouncil's Municipal Heritage Inventory. Lot 106 is owned by Water Corporation and Is a corridor for local sewer infrastructure. Query rationale and whether Lot 105 is requiredto form a regional recreation function.

2 Portion of Lot 503 Swan View Terrace, May lands- Transfer from P&R to Urban

2 3(i) Lot 50 Wyatt Rd, Bayswater NO OBJECTION Transfer from P&R to Public Purpose Lot 50 has been created for sewerage infrastructure purposes. Rezoning will reflect the intended purpose.

3H) Portion of Wyatt Rd Reserve NO OBJECTION Transfer from P&R to Urban The proposal will reflect the location of the constructed road reserve.

4 Lot 820 Stone St, Bayswater NO OBJECTION Transfer from P&R to Urban The subject lot is located within the Trust DCA, No objection provided that the City of Bayswater is satisfied sufficient access will be maintained to the Baigup Wetlands for management purposes.

5 Lot 7124 Fourth Ave, NO OBJECTION Maylands, Transfer from P&R to Public Purposes Contains an existing sewer pump station in ownership of the Water Corporation. Will reflect established use.

Belmont 1 Portion of Swan River betweenSUPPORTED Garvey Park and Ron Courtney Island & portion ofWithin the Trust DCA. Reflects existing Lot 604 from P&R tocreated waterway channel. Waterways

2 Crown Reserve 46532 and LotNO OBJECTION 14549 Great EasternHwy, Reflects existing recreational use and will AscotTransfer from Urban to P&R form a logical extension of established foreshore reserve.

3 Part of Lot 6 and Lots 21 and NO OBJECTION 24 Great Eastern Hwy, BelmontTransfer from Adjoins Trust DCA boundary. Will form a Urban to P&R logical extension of established foreshore reserve.

4 Crown Reserves 48673, SUPPORT 12237 & 48685 & portion Lot Trustsuptiorts this 809 Great Eastern Hwy, NOTE:, The thebasisofthe RivervaleTransfer from modificationon Urban to P&R Amendment as advertised. It Is noted that the amendment report indicates

that a reduction, in the area of this reserve may be considered through the submission process, The Trust strongly objects to any further reduction the Midgal portion of Hardy Park whIcli formsa contiguouspartofthe foreshore reserve at this location, The. Trust has made a Separate submission on this matter, as: pad of alocal government scheme amendment, _a copy of which Is provided at APPENDIX 1.

3 5 Part Crown Reserve 45534SUPPORT and Pt Lots27 & 28 RiversdaleRd,Riverva le The subject land forms part of Cracknell Transfer from Urban to P&R Park within The Springs° redevelopment area and is contiguous with the existing foreshore reserve. The lots are partly zoned and partly reserved. The amendment wilt correct this anomaly. canning Portion of Fern Rd, WilsonSUPPORT from P81 to Urban The proposal will exclude a constructed road reserve, providing a logical foreshore boundary at this location.

2 Crown Reserve 41808 NO OBJECTION Bywater Way, Wilson Transfer from Urban to P&R Query whether the landholdings will serve a regional recreational functionat this location.

3(i) & 3(ii) Portion of Lot 801 Fern Rd SUPPORT Wilson Transfer from Urban to P&R andinclude in Accords with the expanded Canning River Bushforever Regional Park area, The amendment maps do not appear to reflect existing cadastral boundaries within the Regional Path. The amendment map numbers do not correlate to the amendment report

Portion of Fern Road Reserve Wilson & RivertonTransfer from P &R to Urban nu fi)

) -,-xcjot;' liI. ntr ta, }yls9,r :) t t tn trLAti .1)8.- )1i)11 1110(

j\IIY I( Afj, 1" I))clip; 121):1 Ili

OfiliWIti VP/) 11

711

)))110..))))).1);) 11: flown to nit i.1( ',ilk'. it

11110Inn 17 itti Gorr; lbito I') or 4 Portion of Centenary Ave and NO OBJECTION Leach Hwy interchange, Wilson Transfer from Urban Query whether the landholdings will serve a regional recreational function at this to P&R location, being primarily associated with established road infrastructure and drainage.

Lots 3000, 30001, 3002, 3003NO OBJECTION and 3005 Wilson Transfer from Waterways to P&R Reflects islands within the Canning River which form part of the Canning River Regional Park.

4 Fremantle 10) Portionsof Reserve 33051 NO OBJECTION (Lot 385 & 388) North Fremantle Transferfrom Urban and Public Purposes to P&R

1(11) Lots 9 & 111 Johannah St & SUPPORT Lot 112 Stirling Hwy, North FremantleTransfer from Public Purposes to P&R 1010 Portions of Johannah St, North NO OBJECTION Fremantle Transfer from Public Purposes & P&R toComprises an existing constructed road Urban reserve.

Gosnells 2 Reserve 48076 Rushton Rd,SUPPORT MartinTransfer from Rural to P&R In the vicinity of a tributary of Ellis Brook. The reservation will assist in the protection of the drainage line and incorporate It into the adjoining reservation.

4 Reserve47096 & 48360SUPPORT Connell Ave, Martin & Lots 5029, 801 and 802 AlbanyForms part of the foreshore of the Canning River. Reflects long term Intent of providing Hwy, Gosnells (i) Transfer from Rural to P&R and (ii)for recreation, public access and foreshore adjust boundary ofprotection. Bushforever site Recommend that WAPC include Lot 9002 (Reserve 49297) in amendment. Refer Location Plan - APPENDIX 2.

50) Lots 823 & portion Lots 5015, SUPPORT 5017 & 5018 Broadhurst Rd, Gosnells and Lot , Reserve Forms part of the foreshore of the Canning 34476 and portion of road River. Reflects long term Intent of providing reserve Lockhart Place, for recreation, public access and foreshore Gosnells(I) Transfer from Protection. Rural to P&R and (II) adjust Recommend that WAPC include Lot 9002 Bush Forever boundary (Reserve 49297) in amendment. Refer APPENDIX 2.

60) Lot 201 Astley St, Gosnells -SUPPORT Transfer from P&R to Urban Will correct P&R anomaly, reflect existing lot boundary and Trust DCA boundary.

601) Lot 100 Astley St, Gosnells NO OBJECTION Transfer from P&R to Public Purposes Contains existing sewer Infrastructure In the ownership of the Water Corporation. Will reflect established use.

7(I) Portion of Lot 4898 KenwickNO OBJECTION Link, Beckenham -Transfer from P&R to Primary RegionalReflects existing infrastructure associated with the Primary Regional Road Reserve. Road The amendment map numbers do not correlate to the amendment report.

5 PortionofReserve48292 NO OBJECTION Holley Place, Beckenham, Portion Reserve 28247Recommend that WAPC investigate Highbury Cres, Beckenham &inclusionofReserve44575In the Reserve 34179 HesterSt, proposed amendment. Langford TransferfromThe amendment map numbers do not Urban to P&R correlate to the amendment report.

8(1) Portionof Lots 35 & 802 1.101 3UPP1)R Osmond St andPortionof try.rip ...i tart DarelClose Road reserve, Cirri 1)& t kr 'liltI Xit. Y. Kenwick Transfer from P&R irrit9 H r.1-Jerrnia.trrrl with ill'i' `rl,of to Urban Deferred 1111.111irrirliry "kook mirl (-1,,iirrii8rr )?iv iii ifeletirrl Inurrl fall:, !within tilt;r"rir /1"., 1-12-1A

111: )10/1r)-rani (41:111rJr1111r)il'l VI 1101 ba.,1-id 11) /IY moor I/10'1(1111c/ r11111/11C11) -r1rtlic11-111Y:11" -ii

,Any orririnbriri Or-,) 'rry"rel- 11111,:rtiirjrict :amid( hs rxrririir lino!! a pair ); in.ui 1013'llnhich ti11;1InkLini .1,Joja rtit:lifit)(1:10 j:;.10 t:0!. 3/1'il tiara/1(11, "r)rovicic* buifirr- iilo inrl-rirelorirriurriout <,})i)ofttit-II?it),;, )1

ohlort1011 I,rir-in I ,.cub1.) r irrira of 1)1t (211 ;11';'11 ,;()1111i111;tr 11:1(1 111 Ur,

8(11) Portion Lot 17 Osmond St,SUPPORT Kenwick Transferfrom Urban Deferred to P&R

Reserve 45399 AldingaSt, NO OBJECTION Kenwick (I) Transfer from Urban to P&R and (II) IncludeQuery whether the landholdings serve a atthis in Bush Forever regionalrecreationalfunction location,

10 Portion Reserve 47074 Mills SUPPORT Rd, Gosnells(i)Transfer from urban to P&R and (1i) Include The proposal will extend reservation to the in Bush Forever cadastral boundary of Reserve 47074 and formalise public access to the Canning River from Mills Road West.

PortionReserve38939 &SUPPORT portion Lot 681 Anaconda Dr & Michel Cres, Gosnells Will rationalise P&R reserve boundary to Transfer from Urban to P&R match existing cadastral boundaries and extendtoedgeofconstructed road reserves.

PortionJenkinsonStroadNO OBJECTION reserve, Gosnells from P&R to Urban Comprises an existing constructed road reserve.

12 Reserve 43367 Heron P1, NO OBJECTION MaddingtonTransfer from Urban to P &R Query whether the landholding serves a regionalrecreationalfunctionatthis location.

6 130) Reserve37270 &Lot4 NO OBJECTION Homestead Rd, Gosnells Transfer from Urban to P&R Modification associated with Lot 4 will realign the P&R to accord with the existing cadastral boundary. Although inclusion of Reserve 37270 would result in an irregular P&R boundary,thereserve otherwise appears to be landlocked and it may be reasonabletoincorporateitintothe adjoining foreshore reserve.

13(ii) Portion Lot 1129 and part ofNO OBJECTION Foreshore Place road reserve Transfer from P&R to Urban The proposed changes will provide for a more regular P&R boundary and reflect an existing constructed road reserve.

13011) Lot 10 Homestead Rd,NO OBJECTION Gosnells from Urban and P&R to Public Purposes Contains existing sewer infrastructure in the ownership of the Water Corporation. Will reflect established use.

14 Reserve 47210 Shannon SUPPORTED. Ramble, Southern River @Transfer from Urban to P&R Will provide a logical extension of the reserve,providing a and (ii) include in Bush publicforeshore constructed road interface. Forever 15 Portion Crown Reserve 39815SUPPORTED and41487 Chandilla St. Southern River (I) TransferWill provide a logical extension of the from Urban to P&R and (10publicforeshorereserve,providing a include in Bush Forever constructed road interface

23 Crown Reserve31925 NO OBJECTION Transfer from P&R to Railways Reflects the alignment of the Kenwick- reserve Thornlie railway line.

Kalamunda 4 Portions of RidgeHilland NO OBJECTION Helena Valley Roads, the alignment of existing GooseberryHill TransferReflects from P&R to Rural constructed road reserves.

Mundaring 7 Portion Lot 240 Helena ValleySUPPORT Valley Road, Helena extent of Lot 240 Transfer from Rural to P&R Will reserve the full previouslyacquiredby the WAPC in associationwiththe foreshoreof the Helena River.

SUPPORT 8(0 Portion Helena Valley Road Transfer from P&R to Rural Reflects the alignmentof existing constructed road reserves.

8(11) Crown Reserve 8007 VictorSUPPORT Road, Darlington and portion of alignment of the HelenaImmediatelyabutstheHelenaRiver. Reflects long term Intent of providing for RiverTransfer from Rural to recreation, public access and foreshore P813 protection.

7 Swan 1 Portions of Lot 120 and Lot 1 SUPPORT O'Brien Road, Gidgegannup Transfer from Rural to NA WillincreasetheareaofWalyunga National Park.

2 Portion Lot 1018 Coptey Road, SUPPORT BrigadoonTransfer from theareaof Walyunga Rural to P&R Willincrease National Park.

3 (i) Lot 25 Cathedral Avenue NO OBJECTION and Crown Reserve 39975 oftheState Camargue Drive, Brigadoon Lot31comprises pad Transfer from Rural to P&R Equestrian Centre. Proposed P&R reserve and Lot 31 Cathedral Avenue, accords with established use. BrigadoonTransfer from Query whether Lot 25 and Reserve 39976 Rural to P&R (Restricted serve a regional recreational function at Access) this location.

40) Portion 801 St Albans Road, SUPPORT Upper Swan Transfer from Swan River. Rural to P&R Immediately abutsthe Reflects long term Intent of providing for recreation, public access and foreshore protection.

4(10 Portion Lot 800 St Albans NO OBJECTION Road, Upper Swan from P&R Will rationalise reservation to align with to Rural existing cadastral boundary.

6(i)(ii) Portion Lot 39 West Swan SUPPORT Road, Belhus - Transfer from Other Regional Road and Lot Portion of Lot 39 is surplus to regional road widenestablished 73 Great Northern Highway requirements. Will from Rural to P&R and (10 foreshore reserve and protect an existing Include Lot 73 in Bush Forever stand of trees. Theamendment mapnumbersand associated legend do not correlate to the amendment report.

5(iii) Rationalise zoning of the Swan SUPPORT River by the transfer of areas accord with in the P&R and Rural zone to Willrationalisezoningto existing cadastral boundary of the Swan Waterways river.

Theamendment map numbers and associated legend do not correlate to the amendment report.

6 Crown Reserves 43874 (Lot SUPPORT 12361)& 44905 (Lot 12535) theregional The Vines and Belhus The proposalrecognises Transfer from Rural to P&R significance of the Ellen Brook and will and (II) extend portion of Bush provide appropriate long term planning Forever Site to cadastral controls for the affected foreshore areas. boundary of Lot 12535

8 7 Crown Reserves 39936, SUPPORT 47798 and miscellaneous regional drain reserves and Lots 81 The proposalrecognisesthe Mi ['house road and 149 significance of the Ellen Brook and will Corana Way, Belhus (I) provide appropriate long term planning Transfer from Urban to P&R controls for the affected foreshore areas. and (ii) include in Bush The amendment report Incorrectly states Forever that the land is to be rezoned from Urban to P&R rather than Rural to P&R as shown on the amendment maps provided.

8(i) Crown Reserve 34525 SUPPORT Burgess Crescent, Belhus Transfer from Rural to P&R Immediatelyabuts the SwanRiver. Reflects long term intent Of providing for recreation, public access and foreshore protection.

8(0(11) (ii)Rationalise the zoning of theSUPPORT Swan River by Transfer of areas in the Rural zone to Willrationalisezoningtoaccord with Waterways and (ill) align the existing cadastral boundary of the Swan boundary of Bush Forever Siteriver. where It Iles within the reserve with the reserve's upland cadastral boundary 9(i) Crown Reserve 34528 West SUPPORT Swan Road, Henley Brook and portion Padbury Avenue road Reserve 34528 immediately abuts the reserve, Herne Hill Transfer Swan River.Reflects long term intent of from Rural to P&R providing for recreation, public access and foreshore protection. The affected portion of Padbury Ave is unconstructed and formsa logical extension of existing regional open space.

9 (II) Rationalise the zoning of the SUPPORT Swan River by transfer of areas in the rural zone to the Willrationalisezoning to accord with waterways reservation existing cadastral boundary of the Swan river.

100) Crown Reserve 46918 and Lot SUPPORT 97 Barrett Street, Herne Hill, River. portion of Barrett Street road Immediatelyabuts theSwan reserve and portion of Douglas Reflects long term intent of providing for Street, Henley Brook and recreation, public access and foreshore Crown Reserve 44044 protection. Lennard Street, Herne Hill Transfer from Rural to P&R 1000 Rationalise the zoning of the SUPPORT Swan River by transfer of areas in the rural zone to the Willrationalise zoningtoaccord with waterways reservation existing cadastral boundary of the Swan river. It may be appropriate to include other sections at the termination of Barrett Street and Douglas Street which do not appear to correlate with the river reserve boundary.

9 11 Lots 3 and 5 Middle Swan SUPPORT Road, part of Middle Swan Road road reserve, portion of Immediatelyabutsthe SwanRiver. Lot 1 and Lot 50 Harris Road, Reflects long term intent of providing for Caversham - Transfer from recreation, public access and foreshore Rural to P&R protection. The Trust rrequests that consideration be given to Widening of the foreshore reserve proposed across Lot 1 to align with the adjoining bridge abutment. This would allow for Improven interconnection, withtheforeshore reserve tq;the. north. The >reposed 35 metro reserve width currently proposed is not based on any clear planning rationale or biophysical analyals.

12(1)(l1) Crown Reserve 33618, Lot 5 SUPPORT Maxwell Road and Lot 216 Middle Swan road, Caversham ImmediatelyabutstheSwan River. (1) Transfer from Rural to Reflects long term intent of providing for P&R and (ii) align the recreation, public access and foreshore boundary of Bush Forever site protection. where it lies within the subject The amendment map numbers do not properties with their cadastral correlate to the amendment report. boundaries

12(11i) Portions of Lots 9357 and 216 SUPPORT from Rural to Waterways Willrationalisezoningtoaccord with existing cadastral boundary of the Swan River.

The amendment report description incorrectly states that portions of Lots 9357 and 216 will be rezoned to Waterways. The report should state that this relates to the adjoining river reserve lot. The amendment map numbers do not correlate to the amendment report

13W Lot 2 Caversham Avenue, SUPPORT Portion of Caversham Avenue road reserve and a section of Immediately abutstheSwan River. Crown land adjacent to Lot Reflects long term intent of providing for 2972 Hamersley Road, recreation, public access and foreshore CavershamTransfer from protection. Rural to P&R 1301) Portions of Lot 2 and Crown SUPPORT landTransfer from Rural to Waterways Willrationalise zoning to accord with existing cadastral boundary of the Swan River.

The amendment report description incorrectly states that portions of Lot 2 and Crown land will be rezoned to Waterways. The report should state that this relates to the adjoining river reserve lot.

10 14(i) Lots 66 and 11336 and portionSUPPORT Crown Reserve 33481 Hamersley Road, Caversham immediately abuts the Swan River and will Transfer from Rural to P&R reflect the long term Intent of providing for recreation, public access and foreshore protection. The Trust requests that a foreshore reserve a(so he designated along the river frontage of the Governor Stirling, Senior High 'Scheel site (Lot 6566 third _ . Ave Woodbridge) to connect! With an existing:reservation along the frontage Of Weedbriclge House. The High School site IS currently the subject of a major redevelopment proposal being., progressedbytheDepartmentof Education The creation of a fOreshore reserve across this public landholding Is critical In ensuring., protecting of the river embankment and Providing future puliilc access between thehistoric Woodbridge House and the nearby Swan Reglitnel Riverside Park.

14(11) Transfer various small portionsSUPPORT of these properties from Rural to Waterways Will rationalisezoningto accord with existing cadastral boundary of the Swan river.

The amendment report description Incorrectly states that portions of Lots 66 and 11336 will be rezoned to Waterways. The report should state that this relates to the adjoining river reserve lot.

15 Portion Crown Reserve 46665 SUPPORT West Swan Road, Caversham Transfer from Rural to P&R Willcorrect existing anomaly. It would appear that portions of the site may also be affected by a Regional Road Reservation under theMRS.This land should also be transferred to P&R If it Is no longer required for road purposes.

16 Lots 125 and 126 Meadow SUPPORT Street, GuildfordTransfer from P&R to Urban Will correct anexistinganomaly and realign the P&R reserve to match cadastral boundaries, ItIs appropriate that the portion of "Urban!" zoned land along the western boundary of lot 125, protruding into Lot 601. be maned to P &R as part of the amendment.

11 17 Portion Crown Reserve 25845 SUPPORT and Lot 504 Loder Way and portion of the Loder Way road Reserve 25845 and Lot 504 will provide a reserve, Crown Reserves logicalextensionof the existing P&R 31421, 47091 and Lot 123 reserve.Theremainingreservesare Beverley Terrace, South associated with an existing watercourse GuildfordTransfer from (Limestone Creek) which forms part of a Urban to P&R wider drainage system which channels water from the Perth Airport Northern Main Drain to the Swan River. The creekline is associated with a listed Aboriginal heritage site (3536). The proposal will provide for the long term protection of the creekline.

18 Crown Reserve 45303, Lots SUPPORT 515, 3000, 8003, 13657, 13658, 14335, Crown The proposalrecognisestheregional Reserves 41216, and 46945 insignificance of the Jane Brook and will the locality of Jane Brook provide appropriate long term planning Transfer from Urban and Rural controls for the affected foreshore areas. to P&R 19 Portion of Lots 21, 22 and 300 SUPPORT Stirling Crescent, Hazelmere from Rural to P&R Theproposalwillprovidealogical extension of the existing foreshore reserve extending to the road interface with Stirling Crescent.

20(I) Portion Lot 815 Montreal Road SUPPORT and portion Archer Street road reserve, Woodbridge Theproposalwillprovidealogical Transfer from Urban to FIR extension of the existing foreshore reserve extendingtotheroadInterfacewith Montreal Road and Archer Street

20(16 Portion Lot 815Transfer SUPPORT from Rural to P&R Will rationalise zoning to accord with the existingcadastralboundary. The map numbers do not correlate to the Amendment report.

20(i11) Portion Lot 816 Stirling SUPPORT Crescent, Woodbridge Transfer from P&R to Rural Will rationalise zoning to accord with the existingcadastralboundary. The map numbersdo not correlate to the Amendment report.

21(i) Portion of Water Street road reserve, GuildfordTransfer from P&R to Urban II I 1 11I, ;[(t l'f1011 hl i.I!. lyu faun) yuutil tu th" fig cull(

41 11h ,t)I Oa 1 orprir of

rri r Airy, Err.-1? triIIr II I HVa7 il+ nth., if, ul !quirt]tormat It

12 2101) Portion Bushmead Road road NO OBJECTION reserve from P&R to Rural No objectionreflectsthe alignment of existing at grade constructed road reserve.

25 Crown Reserves 42601 SUPPORT Campersic Road, Brigadoon - Transfer from Rural to P&R The proposal represents a public recreation reserve set aside as part of the BrigadoonEstate,associatedwitha tributary of the Swan River.

27 Portion Lots 101 and 103 SUPPORT Market Street, Guildford P&R Transfer from P&R to Urban Theproposalwillrealign the boundary to accord with existing cadastral boundaries of adjoining residential properties.

In light of the significance of the proposed amendment as it relates to foreshore areas of the Swan and Canning Rivers, the Trust requests attendance at a hearing to make further submission on the issues outlined above. A copy of the completed Hearing request form is attached. Should there be any queries regarding this matter, please contact JasmineTothill, Senior Environmental Officer on 9278 0944. Please ensure the Trust's reference number is quoted in any correspondence concerning this proposal. Yours sincerely /a Rod Hughes /(4.--/General Manager

29 January 2010

13 Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC. You do not have to attend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D. Please choose one of the following:

No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign) OR

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: 1273 09 ,1O MyselfMy telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours): Postal address:

You should be aware that: The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of InformationAct 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be subject to applications for access under the act. In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties. All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment, The WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissions and tabled in Parliament.

To be signed by person(s) making the submission

Signature Date'21701/1°

Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of business (5pm) on 29 January 2010. Late submissions will NOT be considered.

Contacts: Telephone - (08)9264 7777; Fax - (08)9264 7566; Email - [email protected]; Webslte - http://vonplanning.wa.gov.au savi( oi APPENDIX 1 SWAN RIVER TRUST

Your Ref 1161123 & P/TAN.6-10 Our Ref 6270-04 Enquiries Jasmine Tothill

Dr Shayne Silcox Chief Executive Officer City of Belmont LMB 379 CLOVERDALE WA 6985

Attention: Janet Lankester

Dear Dr Silcox

AMENDMENT NO. 60 TO TOWN PLANNING SCHEME NO. 14

Thank you for your letter dated 9 November 2009 inviting commentfrom the Swan River Trust on the above scheme amendment.

I understand that the amendment seeks to:

1) rezone a portion of Hardey Park from local 'Parks and Recreation'reservation to 'Mixed Use'; 2) rezone a portion of Lot 14005 from 'Mixed Use' to 'Local Roads' reserve 3) rezone a portion of Lot 14004 from 'Mixed Use' to 'Local Roads' reserve; and 4) delete Item 7 of Schedule 2 (thereby removing the maximumresidential density allocation and associated floor area restrictions for Lot 14004),

Itis unclear from the amendment report as to the area of land intended tobe transferred between the respective lots/ zonings. Reference Is made in the report to the excision of a 7 metre wide strip of land from Lot 14000 although this appearsto conflict with the WAPC resolution to support excision of the difference between12 metres and 18 metres, which equates to only 6 metres. The amendment report needs to clearly Identify the land areas Involved. The escarpment and ridgeline along this sectionof the Rivervale foreshore represents an important landscape feature as the river bends aroundthe Maylands peninsula, offering panoramic views northwards and providing an attractive backdrop when viewed across the Maylands foreshore. Due to the steep nature and narrow width of the foreshore reserve along this section of the river, the residual portionof Hardey Park represents one of the few remaining areas where a rangeof recreational opportunities can be accommodated above the escarpment. The further narrowing of the reserve and subsequent encroachment of high rise developmentwill limit recreational opportunities, result in increased overlooking and privatisation ofthe reserve, impact upon future public amenity and thebroader river viewscape.

By letter dated 3 October 2007 the Trust provided detailed commentsobjecting to a proposal to realign the boundary between Location 14004 and Hardey Park(copy attached). Further correspondence was received from the Department forPlanning and Infrastructure shortly thereafter which also indicated that the excision of aportion of Hardey Park in the manner proposed was not supported on planning grounds (copy attached).

CARING FOR THE SWAN AND CANNING RIVERS

Level 1Hyatt Centre 20 Terrace Rood Eost Perth Western Australia 6004 PO Box 6740 Hay Street East Perth 6892 Telephone (08) 9278 0900 Fox (0819325 7149 en nv, swonrivertiust.wo.gov.ou The Trust has received no further correspondence onthis matter and Is now surprised to read as part of the amendment reportthat the Western Australian Planning Commission has recently resolved to support areduction in the reservation, contrary to the position articulated in 2007. The Trustwould be interested to obtain further information on the background associated withthis change, particularly in the absence of any further liaison with the Trust.

As outlined in previous correspondence itremains the Trust's position that those benefiting from the widening of Tanunda Driveshould contribute towards the necessary road upgrading requirements aspartof any futuresubdivision/ development proposal, The widening of TanundaDrive is, in part if not wholly, justified by virtueof the incremental increasein density permissible on the development site. It is noted that the current amendment nowseeks to remove any remaining density restrictions that apply.

The amendment appears to be promoted In thecontext of an offset arrangement that will see upgrading of the residual portion of HardeyPark in exchange for the excision of land from the A Class reserve. Thisincludes reference to a legal agreement entered into between the City of Belmont and the ownerof Lot 14004 to undertake landscaping, foreshore rehabilitation, pathways,lighting, seating, BBQ facilities, drinking fountains and viewing decks. It is important tonote that any development within the area of Hardey Park will require considerationby the Trust under Clause 30A(2)a(i) of the Metropolitan Region Scheme. TheTrust has not been consulted on the specific details of the landscaping plan, norhas it given any indication that the nature of the works outlined will be acceptable.

It is the Trust's expectation that improvementswithin the reserve be undertaken as part of the adjoining development, irrespectiveof any arrangements associated with the widening of Tanunda Drive. It is understoodthat the nearby Hill 60 development was required to cede land forinclusion in the foreshore reserve as part its public open space contribution and to undertakelandscaping as part of broader developer obligations. The amendment report does notadequately address developer obligations to contribute towards public open space orlandscaping consistent with adjoining developments. The scheme report makes reference to thedegraded nature of Hardey Park arising from its use for temporary parking. The Trustsupported temporary use of the reserve for a limited period of 12 months only, as reflectedin the planning approval issued by the Western Australian Planning Commission on2 November 2007. The Trust's support was conveyed on the basis that the reservewould be appropriately managed by the City and the site remediated following the12 month approval period. The Trust wrote to the City on two occasions advisingof its concerns relating to the poor management of the site, non-compliance withplanning conditions and consequential damage that was occurring to the reserve andassociated vegetation, No response on this matter has beenforthcoming. The Trust strongly objects to the suggestion that the degraded nature of the reserveprovides justification for excision and use as part of a private commercial development.

A separate Metropolitan Region SchemeAmendment 1161/41 is currently being progressed which proposes to rezone the entire areaof Hardey Park to "Parks and Recreation" in recognition of the regional significanceof the site. The Trust intends to lodge a separate submission on the MRSamendment in response to a statement within the report that indicates the further excisionof land from Hardey Park will be considered as part of the public submission process.It is considered premature to proceed with Amendment 60 ahead ofthe associated MRS Amendment and approval being granted to the excision ofsuch land from the A Class reserve, In conclusion, the Trust remains opposed to any further reduction in the areaof Hardey Park. This reserve remains contiguous with the public foreshore reserveand provides a unique opportunity to establish a useable area of public open space above the steep escarpment. Any further reduction in the width of the reservewill result in the further encroachment of high density development closer to theridgeline to the detriment of the future public use and enjoyment of the reserve andthe river viewscape. The excision of such land is not considered conducive to theoperational requirements of the public reserve. Should there be any queries regarding this matter, please contact Jasmine Tothitl, Senior Environmental Officer on 9278 0944, Please ensure the Trust'sreference number is quoted in any correspondence concerning this proposal. Yours sincerely c3,4estio___,

/.0../ Rod Hughes GENERAL MANAGER 22 December 2009

3 SWAN RIVER 412:j.TRUST

Your RefTanunda Drive SRTIN 8915

Our NesRef Jasmine Tothill Enquiries

Mr John Rouphael Director Cityscape Holdings Ply Ltd PO Box 369 CLOVERDALE WA 6985

Dear Mr Rouphael

PROPOSED BOUNDARY AMENDMENT LOC 14004 TANUNDA DRIVE,ASCOT

Thank you for your letter of 12 July 2007 and the accompanying community consultation report outlining a proposal to realign the common boundary between. Location 14004 and Location 14000 (Reserve 12237 - Hardey Park) by 8.7 metres.

It is understood that the boundary realignment is Intended to facilitate widening of Tanunda Drive from its current 12 metre reservation to a width of 18 metres. Although no Mention has been made in your covering letter, it would also appear that an additional land contribution Is being sought In order to compensatefor road widening requirements associated with Great Eastern Highway. .

The Swan River. Trust seeks to ensure that the river and adjoining foreshore areas are maintained for the benefit of the river landscape; preservationof ecosystems and to provide opportunities for public access and recreation. In this regard land use and development adjacent to the river should achieve urban design and architectural outcomes which are conducive to protecting the character and landscape setting of the river and do not dominate or overshadow public areas and views.

It is noted that prior land swap arrangements associated with Hardey Park have resulted In a substantial reduction in the size of the original reserve, permitting development to encroach closer to the river escarpment. Any further reduction in the width of Reserve 12237, particularly in the context of the density of development permissible on adjoining Location 14004, Is not considered to be conducive to the preservation of the riverscape in this locality.

In this regard the Trust's position remains that those benefiting from the widening of Tanunda Drive, namely adjoining residential and commercial development, should contribute towards the necessary upgrading requirements as part of any future subdivision/ development proposal. It is not acceptable that the sole contribution for widening of Tanunda Drive and Great Eastern Highway be borne by Reserve 12237 given that such upgrading Is not associated with the operational requirements of the reserve.

From the information provided it would appear that the boundary realignment has been promoted in the context of an offset arrangement which would see upgrading and landscaping of the residual portion of the reserve. The Trust does not accept that improvements to this reserve are dependent upon the boundary adjustment proceeding in the manner promoted by Cityscape Holdings.. Itis the Trust's expectation that, regardless of any boundary adjustment, future development over Location 14004 would contribute towards the upgrading of the foreshore having

CARING FOR THE SWAN AND CANNING RIVERS

Level 1Hyatt Centre 20 Terroce Road East Perth Western Australia 6004 PO Box 6740 Hay Street East Perth 6892 Telephone 081 9278 0900 Fax (08)9325 7149 sw,v.swonrivertrustmo.govou regard to the nexus between such development and the likely increased use/ pressures placed upon the reserve, This would be consistent with similar contribution requirements Imposed on the adjoining Hill 60 development,

Should there be any queries regarding this matter, please contact Jasmine Tothill, Senior Environmental Officer on 9278 0944. Please ensure the Trust's reference number is quoted in any correspondence concerning this proposal.

Yours sincerely

Rod Hughes ByGENERAL MANAGER

3 October 2007

cc, City of Belmont APPENDIX 2 Reserve 49297

Investigate inclusion for rezoning to P&R

LEGEND Perth Metropolitan Area renw, FUSral R.14. frwaYegte Frorn1:12 1.25n kzigRaanumn, O5pteul trateitrill South 2,0

Department of Environment or cc s at &lad Data is denoted by asterisk Th's data henna been gunny assured. Please contact map author for deta7s. Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) Form 41 Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161141 Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

MICE icrr. ONLY

TrySecretary Western Australian Planning Com-11185ton 469 WellingtOrt Street Submission 32 Perth WA 6060

Name 11\r--4)1.-A t--) It_ L.- .PRE4SE PRINT CLEARL'n ...:Ct n C.: 0-j'Y Ii Li-- Address ; tC 11/4:4 I C. C.- 1'1/43 t ) Postcode .

Contact phone number 2S1 117 `11 Email address .

The following proposals are the subject of my submission

Submission (Nose attach additional pages it required It is preferred that any adOonal Information be loose rather than bound;

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC. You do not have to attend a hearing,The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For Information about the submission and hearings process. please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D. Please choose one of the following:

No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)

I will be represented by: < -7 B Myself - My telephone number (business hours): ...... or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson' Contact telephone number (business hours): ......

Postal address: ......

You should be aware that: The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of information Act 1992 and as such submissions made to the WAPC maybe subject to applications for access under the act. In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making as report on these submissions. copies of your submission or the substance of that submission. may be disclosed to third padres. All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment The WAPC recommendations are sim ilarly published in a report on submissions and tabled in Paroament

To be signed by person(s) making the submission

.",1 C. C.- Signature Date

Note Submissions kr.d Fir be agcor, vtl ay the ad:orbs:ea stcs-ng date. bbei close business iSprm on 29 January 2C10. s e: )11, A..t, NC: ;1;17503:T(1,

Conies' Telephone 00 92547777. Fax (99:9264 7566 Email mrsT..plar oleo wn pev au: Websile heeviveaw planning wa you da Radley, Steven

From: Alan L Hill [[email protected]] Sent: Friday, 29 January 2010 4:58 PM

To: 1711S Subject: MRS 116/41 Alan Hill Submission Attachments: MRS116141 Alan Hill 1 003.png; MRS116141 Alan Hill 1.png

Alan Hill 50 Girrawheen Drive Gooseberry Hill WA 6076

January 29 2001

MRS Amendment 116/41

1. Please find scanned signed Section 41 form 2. Thankyou for the opportunity to comment 3. The parks and recreation zoning is considered important for the future of Perth 4. Proposal 7. The addition to the existing P&R Zone is supported. This area is one of Perth's most important archaeological and ethnographic sites. The area's artefacts from the super trench under the Roe Highway Bridge have been dated 28400 years by Madge Schwede for her PhD in the 1980's. The whole of the Bellevue farm property is all State heritage listed for heritage value. The heritage listed high area to the north of the existing P&R Zone extending to and including Elder Park should also be added to the P&R Zone. The whole area should be zoned P&R as suggested in the 1970's by the Planning Committe and System6 study, and placed in the Swan River. This area was where Yagan's father Midgegoroo was captured before being being taken to Perth and shot unfairly. His spears were broken and he called loudly for Yagan (Green (1984) Broken Spears. This whole area should be in the Swan River Park area and celebrated for its cultural value. Three dreaming tracks are known to pass through this site (Mundjallina Epic along river, Stathams Quarry up to Gooseberry hill and green frog across from Munday Swamp (O'Connor, 1989; HGM, 1991; Bropho pers. comm. HRCG Meeting 1) 5. Proposal 12 Maida Vale Reserve, Kadina Brook Reserves, Bee eater Creek Reserves to be added to P& R. Bushmead should also be added with the adjacent walk adjacent to Helena Valley RD added to P&R to allow network of walk tracks again to Gooseberry Hill.

Alan Hill

1/02/2010 to*cApv

C-6"t-c--c s ccc'' A-0-6,-Crof2 (A AI (4-1

Jao,

<(,,k re-ssAjatesy_,en,./ dtc_cc. 0 c,A,c12.4Asko._ orw--9 e-tv) 4-t)

?oats"\pc-A-3 ch. fe) 62- .vosV soot° (21-3-01 A014-tAlore- ki...aock t- can oin.,

ct /V& tsJQf IA&&Link-r--42,--

2.(AsNyi-3 ocal-Qq)-1) 400 tt-d 1\0.fre. (.00,4 bcon)-t-ia u-A-Ls-A

DEPAFiTMENrOF PLANNING

7:4 MAY

E 80To? r N

DEPARTmcHT 117-a-i77OF PLANNING

24 MAY2010

PILE9, 9/°2,7(rBel Aim To persuade the committeetherebyCatchmentheritage to protect include in the and parks and recreation zone value lands of the Ridge Hill the high natural and cultural TrenchHelena Archaeological River and Bellevue site (28400 floodplainMajor years wetlands Perth's components Super of Catchment Ridge Hill second floodplainoldestBellevueBushmeadBellevue best Farm andFloodplain located Rifle buffer with Range on high Wetlands attractive andland heritage and and floodplain) views Kadina areas Brook GooseberryReservesKadinaHuntley Brook St Hilllink reserves National to Kalamunda Park and National Quenda Park Creekbushland considered Perth's best ne Ridge Hill catchment is remaining natural catchment and stream 104

a I Remarkably Undisturbed Catchment Flora (350-700 turtle, tiger snakes, quenda, little eagle and Carnaby Black species) and Fauna (including Cockatoos) 0 2 0 0

Reams

Uro fiSEIBIEHEEI CCM Bushmead and Indigenous sites oxo-' we? ETHNOGRAPHIC REPORTED SURVEY BOUNDARY BUSHMEAD RIFLE RANGEFIG.1 - LOCATION OF SURVEY AREA co C co Please also include these Ridge Hill Catchment HeritagehighlandBellevue Lands rockfarm featuresinto including the Metropolitanand valuable Elder Park attractive Region Reserve parkScheme Parks and Recreation Zoning KadinaBellevueBushmead Brook toand RifleMundaring Bushmeadfloodplain Range and wetland, railway Gooseberry reservesHelena Hill Valley that link Road catchmentHuntleyHillKadinaMaida Vale Brook St reserves reservesReserve and Beeto Gooseberry Kalamunda Eater Creek Hill National reserves (links Ridgepark) Gooseberry Hill

Submission33 07 City of Wanneroo File Ref: 827/0099 Your Ref: 809-2-1-74-Pt 1 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING Enquiries: John Corbellini 9405 5544

0 4 FEB 2010 29 January 2010 FILE as0033

Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000

Dear Sir/Madam

SUBMISSION ON METROPOLITANREGION SCHEME PROPOSED AMENDMENT 1161/41 - PARKS ANDRECREATION RESERVATIONS FOR PUBLIC LANDS

Please find attached a copy of the City ofWanneroo's submission to the Department of Planning on the above-mentionedamendment. We request that the Western Australian Planning Commission take therecommendations of this submission into consideration when finalising the MetropolitanRegion Scheme Amendment

Yours faithfully

inthis CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER

Form 41 Attach: 1. Proposed Amendment 1161/41 - Parks and 2. City of Wanneroo Submission on Metropolitan Region Scheme Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

::0DMAIPCDOCSIC0111881980l2

DundebarRoad, Wanneroo WA 6065 5°1-909cked Bay! 1, Wannecoo W A 69 46 Websitewww.wanneroo.vva.gov.au Telephone (08) 949405 5000 Facsimile (08) 9405 Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) Form 41 Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFR E ONLY

SUDMISOIONNIMEIER To:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000

A RR EW-0 Name CVC/ or (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) Address Postcode

Contact phone numberctLos ss LLE Email address:$14 c ii\CAt).e Ly-mveo .Ln

The following proposals are the subject of my submission

1....41400.po ?Q_OFees ALS S. ICI 1 1'( 13. (rr ofSij.414 ?aeposhd._ Q2

Submission (Please attach additional pages if required. It is preferred that any additional intenmuon be loose rather than bound)

J.P SG ser-c- ctitk %C.kbpA ,ssjon.

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment has the opportunity to personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the MPG, You do not have to attend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process, please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D.

Please choose one of the following:

12(No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom Of the Wm and sign)

DI Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details) I will be represented by: MyselfMy telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: Contact telephone number (business hours): Postal address:

I would prefer my hearing to be conducted in: O Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation) OR Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be permitted to attend)

You should be aware that: The WAPC Is subject to the Freedom of infonnattoo Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be subject to applications for access under the act.

® in the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your submission OE the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties.

O All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment, The WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissions and tabled in Parliament.

To be signed by person(s) making the submission

Signature Date

Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of business (5pm) on 29 Januasy 2010. Late submissions will NOT be considered.

contacts: Telephone -,(06)92647777; Fax (0$) 92647566; Entail- mrs @planning.wa.gov.au; Website-http://vplanning.wa.gov.au City of Wanneroo Submission on Metropolitan Region Scheme Proposed Amendment 1161/41 - Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

The City of Wanneroo offers comment and recommendations on the following proposals contained in the Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) Proposed Amendment 1161/41Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands.

Proposal Summary Administration Comment and Recommendation City of Reserve 42745 Neaves Administration supports the Wanneroo Road, Mariginiup, currently reservation of Reserve 42745 for Proposal 6 zoned Rural, is proposed to Regional Parks and Recreation, be reserved for Parks and however, it is recommended that Recreation. Reserve 36496 also be included in this amendment proposal, as it provides access to Reserve 42745. City of The amendment report text, Reserve 20561 is already reserved for Wanneroo on pages 51 and 52, states Parks and Recreation, and therefore it Proposal 10 that Reserve 20561 is assumed that, as is illustrated on Marmion Avenue, Mindarie,Figure 10, it is actually proposed that currently zoned Urban, is Reserve 35890 be reserved for Parks proposed to be reserved for and Recreation, not Reserve 20561. Parks and Recreation. Administration supports the Figure 10 illustrating this reservation of Reserve 35890 for amendment does not show Regional Parks and Recreation, as is Reserve 20561, but instead shown on Figure 10. Administration shows Reserve 35890 recommends that the amendment Marmion Avenue, Mindarie,report text be amended to reflect the as being reserved for Parks proposal illustrated on Figure 10. and Recreation. City of Reserves 31236 Wanneroo Administration supports the Wanneroo Road, and 46727 Bernard reservation of Reserves 31236 and Proposal 11 Road, Carabooda, currently 46727 for Regional Parks and zoned Rural, are proposed toRecreation however, it is be reserved for Regional recommended that Lots 6265 and 6155 Parks and Recreation. also be reserved for Parks and Recreation, as they are also part of Bush Forever Site 129, and this would better protect the conservation values of the site. City of Portion Lot 3 Crabtree Administration strongly recommends Wanneroo Street, on the corner with Lathat the WAPC consult with adjacent Proposal 13 Salle Road, Alexander landowners regarding this proposal Heights, currently reserved and defers its position until this has for Public Purposes (HS), is been undertaken. proposed to be zoned Urban. City of SwanTonkin Highway Road The final North West Corridor Proposal 28 Reservation, north of Structure Plan ReviewStrategic Hepburn Avenue, currently Assessment of Regional Transport reserved as Primary Requirements, commissioned by the

::0DMATCDOCS \COWN882185 Regional Roads; and Department of Planning, identifies the Beechboro Road need for an additional north-south Reservation, currently regional road east of East Wanneroo as reserved as Other Regional a key prerequisite for the planned Roads; and a number of lotsgrowth of the North West Corridor. in Cullacabardee currently The draft East Wanneroo Structure zoned Rural, are proposed toPlan includes this as a possible be reserved for Parks and northern extension of Tonkin Recreation. Highway, to link with the Neerabup Industrial Area and beyond.

Proposal 28 for Swan proposes that the Tonkin Highway Road Reserve and the surrounding Rural land be reserved for Parks and Recreation. This is considered premature due to the recommendations of the above- mentioned reports. It is recommended that this proposal be deleted from this MRS Amendment. Once the matter of the detailed alignment of the major north-south Primary Road has been determined, the MRS amendment to reserve the land for the road can then also be included in the proposed Parks and Recreation reserve for this Cullacabardee area.

All other proposals contained in the MRS Proposed Amendment 1161/41 - Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands are supported by the City of Wanneroo.

::0DMATCDOCS \COW\882185 nign 1 . FEB . 2010 17 25 MAIN ROADS WA 08 NU.YU r.1 / ?EN MAIN ROADS VIA Submission 34 oat- Government or %MAIN ROADS BEMIS gir Western lin Australia Western Australia ABN: 50 860 676 021 nq tildes: John Van Luyn on (08) 9323 4130 Our Ref: 09/4578 1 February 2010 Your Rat 809.2 -1 -74 Pt 1

The Secretary DEPARTMENT Western Australia-1 Planning Commission OF PLANNING 469 Wellington Street (Cnr Forrest Place) Perth WA 6000 0 2 FEB 2010

ATTENTION; ROSS PARKER FILE (-90,3 3 Dear Sir

METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME PROPOSED AMENDMENT 1161/41 PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATIONS FOR PUBLIC LANDS.

Thank you for your latter dated 5 October 2009, requesting Main Roads comments on the above amendment, I apologise for the slight delay In responding.

Main Roads has reviewed the proposed amendment and would like to provide the following comments:

City of Armadale

o Proposal 1 Main Roads does net support this proposal as the land is affected by a requirement for the future widening of the Albany Highway reservation. A copy of Main Roads Land Protection Plan 8021-17-2 is enclosed for your information. Proposal 2No comments. Proposal 3No comments. Proposal 4Main Roads does not support this proposal as the reservation for Brookton Highway is currently under review by the Department for Planning. Consequently, the exact road reservation although dedicated is still to be defined. Proposal 5 No comments, o Proposal 6 No comments, Proposal 7 No comments. Proposal 8No comments. Proposal 9Main Roads does not fully support this proposal as the reservation for Brookton Highway Is currently under review by the Department for Planning, Whilst the exact road reservation through lot 101, although dedicated, is still to be defined and cannot' be supported, Main Roads would however support the proposal on Lots 486, 600, 192, 356, 2 & 100. Proposal 10 No comments. o Proposal 1'I No comments. Proposal 12No comments. o Proposal 1;5No comments,

Don Aitken Centre, Waterloo Crescent, East Perth or Po Box 6202 EAST PERTH Western Atlqtrella 6892 Telephone; (08) 9323 4111 Facsimile: (08) 0323 4547 TM (03) 9426 2230 daniehroads.wa.nov,au Wobsite: www,r4a1nroads.wa.gov,au 1.FEB,201017:25 MAIN ROADS WR 08 932:41547 NU.70 MAIN ROADS NIA

Town of Bassencloan

Proposal No comments, Proposal 2No comments.

City of Bayswater

Proposal 1 No comments. Proposal 2No comments. Proposal 3. No comments. Proposal 4No comments. Proposal 57 No comments.

City of Belmont

a Proposal 1 No comments. Proposal 2No comments. Proposal 3No comments. Proposal 4No comments, Proposal 5 No comments.

City of Canning

Proposal 1 No comments. Proposal 2 No comments. Proposal 3 No comments. Proposal 4Main Roads does not support this proposal as the land currently forms part of the Leach Hwy/Centenary Avenue interchange, Including on and off ramps. Main Roads suggests that this proposal be protected as Primary Regional Road reservation. A copy of an aerial photo with cadastral overlay is enclosed for your information. Proposal 5No comments. Proposal 6No comments. Proposal 7No comments.

City of Cockburn.

Proposal 1 No comments. Proposal 2Main Roads cannot support this proposal until the Primary Regional Road reservation for Roe Highway extension, west of Kwinana Freeway is defined. Proposal 3No comments, Proposal 4Main Roads cannot support this proposal until the Primary Regional Road reservation for Roe Highway extension, west of Kwlnana Freeway is defined. This will include a direct connection to Murdoch Drive. Proposal 5No comments. Proposal 6No comments. a Proposal 7 No comments. Proposal 8No comments.

Don Aillosn Centre, Waterloo Crescent, Fast Perth or PO Sox 6202 EAST PERTH Western Australia 6892 Telephone: (08) 9323 4111 Facsimile: (08) 9323 4547 TTY: (09) 0429 2230 Email: dacQmainroads.wa.gov.au Websits: www.mainroade,tva.gov.au

Page 2 of 7 I. FEB.201017:25 nun KOHD5 lAH aid 'Jae:9454( no. rye r.ory MAIN ROADS WA

City of Fremanti

Proposal f- No comments.

City of Gosnells

Proposal 1: No comments. Proposal Z No comments. Proposal 3, No comments, Proposal 4, No comments, Proposal a No comments. Proposal 6No comments. Proposal 7No comments. Proposal fi' No comments. Proposal R No comments. Proposal ip - No comments. Proposal 11 No comments. Proposal 12No comments. Proposal 15No comments, Proposal 14No comments, Proposal 15No comments. Proposal lip - No comments. Proposal 1'7This proposal requires further liaison between Main Roads and the Departmen't for Planning, Investigations noted that the proposal includes a significant portion of longitudinal pipeline easement whereas Main Roads general policy is not to include longitudinal easements within Primary Regional Road reservations. Proposal 13N6 comments, Proposal 19No comments. Proposal 29No comments, Proposal 21 No comments, Proposal No comments, Proposal 23No comments.

City of Joondaluri

Proposal 1 7 No comments. Proposal 2 P No comments. Proposal 3 7 No comments, Proposal 4'r No comments. Proposal 5 7 No comments.

Shire of Kalanunda

Proposal 1 7 No comments. Proposal 2 No comments.

Don Altken Centre, Waterloo Crescent, East Penh or PO Box 6202 FAST PERTH Western Australia 6892 Telephone: (08) 9323 4111 Facsimile; (06) 9323 4547 TTY: (08) 9428 2230 0:100Mainroads.wa,gov.au Website: twatrimainroads.waigoviau

Page 3 of 7 1 . FEB.2010 17:26 MH1N ROADS WH IOU id-thfcs;b4 ( 1113.(70 r.4/7

MAIN ROADS WA

Proposal 3Main Roads recommends that further advice on this proposal be sought from the Department of PlanningUrban Transport Systems as a previous DPI study recommended an assessment needed to be undertaken to identify any improvements that may be required on Canning Road. Any improvements are likely to require an increase in the reservation width of Canning Road which may affect the proposal, Proposa 4No comments Proppsa 5' No comments. o Proppsa 6' No comments. Proppsa 7, No comments. Proposa 8, No comments, Proposa 9. No comments. o Proposa 10No comments. Proposa 1 Main Roads recommends that further advice on this proposal be sought frorp the Department of PlanningUrban Transport Systems as a previous DPI study recommended that an assessment needed to be undertaken to identify any Improvements that may be required on Welshpool Road. Any improvements are likely to require an increase in the reservation width of Welshpool Road which may affect the proposal. Main Roads supports the portions of the proposal that are not adjacent to,Welshpool Road. Proposal 12No comments, Proposal 13No comments. Proposal No comments. Proposal 15Main Roads recommends that further advice on this proposal be sought from the Department of PlanningUrban Transport Systems as a previous DPI study recommended that an assessment needed to be undertaken to Identify any improvbments that may be required on Canning Road, Any improvements are likely to require an increase in the reservation width of Canning Road which may affect the proposal. Main Roads supports the portions of the proposal that are not adjacent to:Canning Road.

Town of Kwinana'

Proposal 1 r Main Roads cannot support this proposal as the Primary Regional Road reservation for the FremantleRockingham Highway (Gilmore Avenue) is currently under review by the Department for Planning. The WAPC should liaise with Mohsin Muttaqui at the Department for Planning Urban Transport Systems. Proposal 2 H Main Roads cannot support this proposal. Main Roads is aware that the Westera Trade Coast Group desire a portion of this land for heavy industrial development, The WAPC should to liaise with John Chortis at the Department for Planning,

Shire of Mundaririg

Proposal 1 ri No comments, Proposal 2No comments. Proposal 3 r Main Road does not support the proposal adjacent to the Great Eastern Highway reservation. Main Roads is aware that the reservation for Great Eastern Highway west of, and through the Sawyers Valley Townsite will require future widening for heavy freight vehicles. The WAPG should liaise with Richard Cullen at the Department for Planning. Main Roads does support the portions of the proposal that are not adjacent to the Great Eastern Highway reservation.

Don Aitken Centre, Waterloo crescent, Gast Perth or PO Box q02 EAST PERTH Western Australia 6892 Telephone: (08) 9323 4111 FaeelMlle: (00) 9323 4547 TTY: (08) 9428 2230 Fritall: deo @mainroads.wa.gov.au WebsIte: www.rnainroadsms.gov.au

Page 4 of 7 1. FEB.201017:26 MAIN ROADS WA 08 93e:1.4547 nu.reJ r. .)'r' MAIN ROADS WA

Proposal 4No comments. Proposal 5No comments. Proposal 6No comments. Proposal 7Main Road does not support the proposal. Main Roads is aware that the proposal may be affected by options for the Midland Freight Rail Realignment. The WAPC should liaise with Richard Cullen at the Department forPlanning Urban Transport Systems. Proposal 9No comments, Proposal 9 - No comments.

City of Rockingham

Proposal 1 Main Roads cannot support this proposal as the Primary Regional Road reservation for the Fremantle Rockingham Highway is currently under review in this vicinity by the Department for Planning. The WAPC should liaise with Mohsin Muttaqui at the Department for PlanningUrban Transport Systems. Proposal 2 No comments, Proposal 3No comments. Proposal 4 No comments. Proposal 5No comments.

Shire of Serpentine - Jarandalo

Proposal 11 No comments. Proposal 2No comments. Proposal 3 No comments. Proposal 4 No comments. Proposal 5Main Road does not support the proposal adjacent to Anketell Road. Whilst Anketell Road is not currently a road under Main Roads control, Anketell Road has been identified as a potential future major freight route which may require reservation protection and future widening (dual carriageway) for heavy freight vehicles. A Road Network Study will need to be undertaken to confirm Anketell Road as a uture heavy vehicle freight route, which will require further liaison between Main Roads and the Department for Planning.

City of Stirling

Proposa1 No comments. Propose2No comments. Proposa31 No comments, Proposa4 No comments, Propose5No comments. Propose No comments.

City of Subieco

Proposal 1 - No comments.

City of Swan

Proposal 1 - No comments.

Don Mean Centro, Waterloo Crescent, East Perth or PO Box 6202 EAST PERTH Wastam AuAtralla 6892 Telophono: (08) 9323 011 Foqrmiler (OR) 9323 4547 TTY: (00) 9420 2230 Email: ciao ©mainroadatva,govAtt Webeltel Imm,mainroadsma.00v.aLl

Page 5 of 7 1 FEB. 2010 1727 MAIN ROADS WA OH 13:32:14547 NU. ("*1 F.b /3

MAIN ROADS WA

Proposa 27 No comments. Proposa 3No comments, Proposa 4No comments, Propose 5No comments. Proppsa BNo comments. Proppsa 7, No comments. Proppsa 8No comments. Proposa 9No comments. Proposa 16No comments. Proposa 11 Main Roads does not support thp northern portions of this proposal located adjacent to Middle Swan Road. The northern portions will be greatly affected by the Primary Regional Road reservation for Reid Highway which is currently under review by the Department for Planning. The WAPC should liaise with Mike Sjepcevich at the Department for PlanningUrban Transport Systems. Main Roads supports the southern portion of the proposal located between Bassett and Harris Roads, Proposal 12 No comments, Proposal 13 No comments. Proposal 14 No comments, Proposal 1.. No comments, Proposal 16 No comments. Proposal No comments. Proposal 113 No comments. Proposal 19Main Road does not support the proposal, Main Roads is aware that the proposal is affected by options for the Midland Freight Rail Realignment. The WAPC should liaise with Richard Cullen at the Department for Planning Urban Transport Systems. Proposal 20No comments. Proposal 21 No comments. Proposal 28No comments. Proposal 23No comments, Proposal 24No comments, Proposal 25No comments. Proposal 2(3No comments. Proposal 27No comments. Proposal 28(Figure 28a) Main Roads is aware that the proposal is affected by options for the proposed new North-South road in thp at Wanneroo Structure Plan. The WAPC should liaise with Andrew Montgomery at the Department for Planning arid Mohsin MuttaquiUrban Transport Systems, Proposal 26(Figure 28b) Main Road does not support item (iv) as it is not logical for future rail station parking to be proposed Primary Regional Roads reservation as the precinct is well away from the Perth-Darwin National Hwy Primary Regional Road reservation. Main Roads suggests future rail station parking should be shown as Public Pprposes reservation in figure 28b,

City of Wanneroo.

Proposal 1 , Main Roads is aware that the proposal may be affected by options for the proposed new North-South road In the East Wanneroo. The WAPC should liaise with Andrew Montgomery at the Department for Planning and Mohsin Muttaqui Urban Transport Systems.

Don AINen Centre, Waterloo Crescent, Eaet Perth or PO pox 6202 EAST PERTH Western Australia 6892 Telephone: (08) 9323 4111 Facsimile: (09) 9323 4547 TTY: (08) 9428 2280 Emall: decOmainroals.wmpv.au Website: wymmainroads.wamov.au

Page 6 of 7 1 . FEB. 20 017: 27 MAIN ROADS NA OS 93E31547 NO. 7'30 P 7/13 MAIN ROADS WA

Proposal 2Main Roads is aware that the proposal may be affected by options for the proposed new North-South road in the East Wanneroo. The WAPC should liaise with Andrew Montgomery at the Department for Planning and Mohsin Muttaqui Urban Transport Systems. Proposal 3Main Roads is aware that the proposal may be affected by options for the proposed new North-South road in the East Wannerqo. The WAPC should liaise with Andrew Montgomery at the Department for Planning and Mohsin Muttaqui Urban Transport Systems. Proposal 4Main Roads is aware that the proposal may be affected by options for the proposed new North-South road in the East Wanneroo. The WAPC should liaise with Andrew Montgomery at the Department for Planning and Mohsin Muttaqui Urban Transport Systems. Proposal 5 Main Roads is aware that the proposal may be affected by options for the proposed new North-South road in the East Wanneroo, The WAPC should liaise with Andrew Montgomery at the Department for Planning and Mohsin Muttaqui Urban Transport Systems. a Proposa 6No comments. Propqsa 7 d No comments, Propose - No comments. a Propqsa 9 No comments. a Proposa 11)No comments. Proposa No comments. Proposa 12No comments. Propose 13No comments. Proposa 14No comments. Propose 15No comments.

If you require any further information please contact John Van Luyn on (08) 9323 4130. In reply please quote file reference 09/4578.

Yours faithfully

Lindsay Broadhurst MANAGER ROAD PLANNING

Don Altken Centre, waterloo Craocont, East Perth or po pox 6202 EAST PERTH western Australia 5892 Telephone: (08) 9323 4111 Facsimile: (08) 9323 4.547 TTY: (08) 9428 2230 Email: dactneinreedstwa.gpv,au Website: www.rnainroads.vva.gov,au

Page 7 of 7 oOET.BrJUr.IT47:4 .cYW4 94." ?lc a0r -"Ili HOPZESSSPETNITTEDACCESSPERKETEE--... LEBEND CUICTSONS SUBJECT TO suavcr Gu Ss+, G,B.ce CroBV-Bc ocomovantwu.tinenvamt,...... n.GGAGGaGma Oat".0.0.4TTTT, a X SW7111:11472 , 420 487 Go o oo Ina RtM.1;10t" BEDFO01W4E ALBANY HIGHWAYLAND Hi PROTECTION PLANMILL MAIN ROADS DEPARTMENTURBAN W.A. PLANNING SECTION mum 1.1 1 ,PRIOYED Les:$5, am To ow :am spzrr ;143; at """nc "a7 ....--- nr+m , .,..i, .. 'a" .4 54,'."`""''' 04,.. Wteli' --7:44'4ubcAL ...pity 70. u7....11.0 71/43-21' 07-07 8021-17 -2 "" I I :-.1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 t t II' t11 i

I I t 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 iji 1 I =t 1 1 it,, it, 1'1 k l 1 It Submission Government of Western Australia 35 Department of State Development

Your ref: 809-2-1-74 Pt1 Our ref: 80089/200902 Enquiries: Dave Coggin - Ph 9222 3340 Email: [email protected]

Mr Tony Evans Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission Albert Facey House 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000

Dear Mr Evans

METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME PROPOSED AMENDMENT1161141 PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATIONS FOR PUBLICLANDS CITY OF ROCKINGHAM PROPOSAL 1 (FIGURE 1)

Thank you for your letter of 5 October 2009 inviting theDepartment of State Development (DSD) to comment on the above proposedamendment.

While generally supportive, DSD opposes the proposedrezoning of the "Cityof RockinghamProposal 1 (Figure -0In particular, we are concerned that:

the subject land is designated industry in the RockinghamIndustry Zone (RIZ) Structure Plan; Strategic industrial area land is scarce in the south of theState, and particularly in the Perth Metropolitan Area; 70ha of land in the RIZ has already been designatedfor conservation under the current Strategic Environmental Assessment; and the subject land is adjacent to the railway and is thusstrategically placed for a future industrial purpose;

Itrust that the Western Australian Planning Commissionwill consider DSD's submission and alter the amendment as required.I would like the opportunity for DSD to present to the hearing regarding this amendment.

Yours sincerely

DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING

0 5 FEB 2010

Anne Nolan Director General

February 2010

Level 6, 1 Adelaide Terrace, East Perth, Western Australia 6004 Telephone +61 8 9222 0555 Facsimile +61 8 9222 0505 www.dsd.wa.gov.au wa.gov.au ABN 90 199 516 864 Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) Form 41 Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161141 Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

SUBMISSION NUMBER To:Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000

Name 4N14 Not A-NI (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) 4,o0 LA" vE-ent Address kfte eirs Postcode olsott wee. ov, 414--1 Contact phone number 92nz 0l¢oo Email addressOnoeirl0lane

Submission (Please attach additional pages if required. It Is preferred that any additionalInformation be loose rather than bound) ited kite4r .

turn over to complete your submission Hearing of submissions

Anyone who has made a written submission on theamendment has the opportunity to personally present the basis of their submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC.You do not have to attend a hearing. The comments presented by you in this written submission will beconsidered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment.

For information about the submission and hearings process,please refer to the amendment report and in particular appendix D. Please choose one of the following:

a No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of theform and sign) OR

Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the followingdetails) I will be represented by: MyselfMy telephone number (business hours): or A spokesperson

Name of spokesperson: AlicKy Cuetuo27?-/ Contact telephone number (business hours): 922 2 0910 0 (9/71 Postal address: IApEI- 4i a e. ICE.,..ENT ..e .

would prefer my hearing to be conducted in: Public (members from the general public may attend yourpresentation) OR Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearingscommittee will be permitted to attend)

You should be aware that: The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of information Act 1992and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be subject to applications for access under the act. In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, ormaking its report on these submissions, copies of your submission or the substance of that submission, may bedisclosed to third parties.

All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcriptsof ell hearings, along with all written submissions, are tabled in Parliament and published as public records shouldthe Governor approve the proposed amendment. The WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissionsand tabled in Parliament.

To be signed by nersonfs) making the submission

to Signature (IL Date Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertisedclosing date, being close of business (5pm) on 29 January 2010. Late submissions willNOT be considered.

Contacts: Telephone- (08) 9264 7777; Fag- (08)0264 7566; [email protected]; Webslte - http://www.plannIng.weoov.au -27 Li 1 nonnriment of StateDevelopro

1 i 1 t i

1 i i i 4-55 1 9004 t LEDA i 1

1 1 i i t \ \ U 1 X\\ Re 0ina 4332 1 II/k 1 tea t 11/44 A...0 41 4/461- _...110102414111 AMINOR ; ApronstIIIIMIENWilin 1 Nt ARNIM/41Ill.".. 1 4141NRIRIAIR / EAST ROCKING NININI/44=11. 9002 rf 71/410/11/14 / 74151111WASS: / -waransAtamgani.:3sate'lls r / Sarak i Nw441214/1 9001 . `4NIGNINI 'Mit 4333 r4112VIM / 45t 'RIK 'Ilk IC," PROPPSAL v-"St 'Rommel-1m St.e'\ .4 gipPt -- GOgip

si X12 "- 1

HI-LMN ,'" , , -

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment as advertised 8 July 2008 Figure 1 Legend Proposed: Illrolli parks and recreafion msas reservation Notice of delegation <<> Bush Forever area

tocn-Q-us AWestern Z-f.';''''-i 2SMat2DA Australian Seale I 6000 ProElest/I&G.FDS'ID-Ench.C.4M,11.-tPa-rulgann-fra"...ra j'es:j 7< iPlanning 0 200 On tadol V. nee,tas..gencticranr.sr,* PaA GOA -Liccartv'INelratv.rataLaninPtari SL242.-cS 2 oF "3Commission I t 1 metres

as ewa e, -1 1 1 I RectaimaVo I oo . CO 00 en op lance 88 00 CO oa Ngs, oo 00 00 -B 00 OD 88 BFTRefi CKBURN SOUND 00 00 88 ooco 00 0000 Nu one Aust 0 00 ED NuFarm Gong

male Mt model acil

000 01 I Kvemana Bulk O Handling Jetty

otetb nne Frm rs Agee 0C en

0 at ocr

WELLA

,:4 Wesling Coternrpor n

CeMary A + M nr(lp . IMOe h I Is EAST ROC NGHAM 00(it. INDUSTRIA ZONE v n o$

Lo 0 Austreffan F sod Materials aste Water &QM T eatrne t Site Advancedatenals Park

Jandako Wool VV shers

HILLMAN]

AM COOLOONG P O 86 sn000mE 84

REFERENCE DATA D Transmission line Service corridors Solo Residential (future) Thave

r - Wrier nindan Welateiri Power oa Oa 34 a -, Reckunsalm I 00 oo 00 co en op len 00 88 a/ 00 00 B gg 88 oo D 00 00 00 0. 88 BESTIMI% COCKBURN SOU D 00 OD DO 0000 0000 00 00 0 00 0000 OD N arm Ana

000 1 1 NuFanu Coop

O Int 0t7,

csfm--J Nyman° Bulk 000 De 1, 7 Handing Jetty GA 32 noo mo eigee en gialtucal 0 O O 000 0 O 0

Western kin ng Corpor h n Ce etery A

I M nniu a TIM e EAST ROC NGHAM INDUSTRIA ZONE 30

n Austr lion u F sedatenI aste 81/41-RIEC Water T eatme t / Advanced Medals Park Site

Jandako Wool W shwa

Ori

HILLMAN

HAM COOLOONGI

882080E 84

REFERENCE

Transmission line Service corridors Industry Residential (future) Submission 36

Your Ref: DW1522539 Enquiries: Jarrod Ross E-mail: [email protected] city of swan Fax: 9267 9444 2 Midland Square, Midland PO Box 196, Midland WA 6936 T: (08) 9267 9267 Monday 8th February 2010 F: (08) 9267 9444 www.cityofswan.corn

The Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING Albert Facey House, 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000 11 FEB 2010

FILEkgi(90:3 Dear Sir/Madam

RE:METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME AMENDMENT 1161/41 PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATIONS FOR PUBLIC LAND This letter is in response to your request for comment regarding theabove Metropolitan Region Scheme amendment proposal. Please note that the matter wasconsidered by Council at the Ordinary Council Meeting of 3 February 2010, at which Council made thefollowing resolution:

1. Endorse the City's comments with respect to the 28 proposals foramendments to the Metropolitan Region Scheme within the City of Swan with emphasis onthe City's opposition to Proposal 3 (Figure 3) for which the City believes the currentrural zoning shall remain. 2.Forward the City's comments to the Western Australian PlanningCommission for assistance in their consideration of the proposed amendments. The Council minutes for the above agenda item are attached for yourinformation. Should you require any further information or clarification on any of the abovepoints, please do not hesitate to contact Mr Jarrod Ross on 9267 9126 or emailjarrod.rossswan.wa.clov.au. Yours sincerely

Steve Tan Principal Planner Development Services Ordinary Meeting of Council 3 February 2010

3.1 METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME AMENDMENT 1161/41 - PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATIONS FOR PUBLIC LAND

(All Wards) (Development Services)

KEY ISSUES

A proposal has been received for an omnibus amendment to the Metropolitan Region Scheme to address a number of sites across the Perth metropolitan area that are currently or intended to be reserved for Parks and Recreation purposes. The amendment includes 28 proposals for changes tothe zoning and reservation of land under the Metropolitan Region Scheme within the City of Swan. The Western Australian Planning Commission has requested the City's comment be referred on or before 8 February 2010:

City staff have reviewed each of the 28 amendment proposals for the City of Swan and provided their position and comment on each. It is intended that these comments be referred to the Western Australian Planning Commission upon Council's endorsement.

It is recommended that Council endorse the comments and recommendations made in this report and refer the comments to the Western Australian Planning Commission to assist in their consideration of the proposed Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41.

BACKGROUND

The City of Swan received the subject proposed Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) amendment in October 2009, with a subsequent request for comment and a request to display copies of the documentation at the front counter of the City's offices between 6 October 2009 and 29 January 2010. The amendment proposals for the reservation of landwill have the effect of automatically amending the City's Local Planning Scheme 17 (LPS17) with no further action required by the City. The zoning of land under the MRS, however, will require the City to amend LPS17 to ensure that it remains consistent with the MRS.

REPORT Within the City of Swan, the amendment is largely intended to address a number of mapping anomalies and inaccuracies, particularly relating to the cadastral boundary of the Swan River and various existing Parks and Recreation reserves. In addition to this, there are a number of proposals to reserve significant areas of native vegetation that

Page 1 Ordinary Meeting of Council 3 February 2010 have been acquired by the WAPC through sub-division or other methods, as well as proposals to reserve land for roads and utility services.

The City has reviewed each of the proposals for their potential impact on the City of Swan operations and on City of Swan land. The City has no fundamental objections to the proposals, although some recommendations for modifications have been made to ensure that the zoning reflects the long term use of the subject land.

Each of the proposals is identified visually in Appendix I, and described by the Western Australian Planning Commission in Appendix II. Each proposal is numbered within the two appendices, and the City's comments listed below are numbered accordingly Proposal 1: The subject sites, currently owned by the WAPC, are to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) for inclusion within the Darling Range Regional Park.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan Proposal 2: The subject sites, currently owned by the WAPC, are to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to protect the regional significance of the native vegetation of Jumbuck Hill.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan

Proposal 3: The subject sites, currently identified as Crown reserves vested with the City of Swan, are to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regional significance of the Swan River and complement adjacent Parks and Recreation reserves.

City of Swan officer position: Objection

Comment: Lot 31 is owned freehold by the City of Swan and is currently leased to the State Equestrian Centre. Similarly Lot 25 is owned freehold and is currently used for the East Swan Fire Station. It is considered that the current rural zoning should remain to enable greater flexibility for land uses bearing in mind that these properties are Council assets.The City is opposed to the proposed rezoning to Parks and Recreation. The current rural zoning is to remain.

Proposal 4: Subject site 1, currently owned by the WAPC, is to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regional significance of the Swan River. Subject site 2, currently privately owned, is to be included within the MRS 'Rural' zone as it is not within the boundary of the Parks and Recreation area.

City of Swan officer position: No objection Comment: Subsequent amendment to LPS17 will be required for subject site 2 to rezone the Pt Lot to 'General Rural'.

Proposal 5: Subject sites 1, currently owned by the WAPC, are to be put within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation). Subject sites 2, currently part of the Swan River, are to be put within the Waterways Reservation. Subject sites 3, currently

Page 2 Ordinary Meeting of Council 3 February 2010 reserved for other regional roads, are to be put within the MRS'Rural' zone. Subject sites 4, currently owned by the WAPC, are to be includedwithin Bush Forever Site 302.

City of Swan officer position: No objection Comment: Subsequent amendment to LPS17 will berequired for subject site 2 to rezone the Pt Lot to 'General Rural'. Proposal 6: Subject site 1, currently a Crown reserve, is tobe included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regionalsignificance of the Ellen Brook. Subject site 2 is to be included within Bush Forever site 300.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan Proposal 7: Subject sites 1, which is currently a Crown reservemanaged by the State and the City of Swan, is to be included withinthe MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect their important landscape and environmentalvalues. Subject site 2 is to be included within Bush Forever Site 300.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan Proposal s8: Subject site 1, currently a Crown reserve, is tobe included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regionalsignificance of the Swan River. Subject site 2 is to be included within the WaterwaysReservation. Subject site 3 is to be included within a Bush Forever site.

City of Swan officer position: No objection Comment: There is a need to address accessibility tothis site and the agency responsible for management. Proposal 9: Subject site 1, currently a Crown reserve, is tobe included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regionalsignificance of the Swan River foreshore. Subject site 2, currently part of the Swan River,is to be included within the Waterways Reservation as it forms part of the SwanRiver foreshore.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan

Proposal 10: Subject site 1, currently Crown Reserves and City of Swanland, is to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflecttheir importance as pedestrian linkages along the Swan River. Subject site 2,currently part of the Swan River, is to be included within the MRS Waterways Reservation asit forms part of the Swan River foreshore.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan

Page 3 Ordinary Meeting of Council 3 February 2010

Proposal 11: Subject site 1, currently owned by the City of Swan and the WAPC, are to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regional importance of the Swan River. Subject site 2, currently part of the Swan River, is to be put within the MRS Waterways Reservation as it forms part of the Swan River foreshore.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan Proposal 12: Subject site 1, currently reserved for public purposes and the Swan River, is to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regional significance of the Swan River foreshore. Subject sites 2, currently within the Swan River, are to be included within the MRS Waterways Reservation. Subject site 3 is to be included within Bush Forever site 302.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan

Proposal 13: Subject site 1, representing Crown land and property owned by the City of Swan, is to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) reflect the regional significance of the Swan River. Subject site 2, currently part of the Swan River foreshore, is to be put within the MRS Waterways Reservation.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan Proposal 14: Subject site 1, currently Crown land, is to be put with the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regional significance of the Swan River. Subject site2, currently within the Swan River foreshore,isto be put within the MRS Waterways Reservation.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan

Proposal 15: Subject site 1, currently part of the Lilac Hill reserve, is to be put within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to correct a mapping anomaly.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan

Proposal 16: Subject site 1, currently privately owned, is to be zoned 'Urban' under the MRS to correct a mapping anomaly.

City of Swan officer position: No objection Comment: The City of Swan will be required to zone the subject sites 'Residential' through a formal amendment to Local Planning Scheme 17.

Page 4 Ordinary Meeting of Council 3 February 2010

Proposal 17: Subject site 1, currently representing Crown reservesand land owned by the City of Swan, is to be put within the MRS Reserve(Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regional significance of the Swan River.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan

Proposal 18: Subject site 1, which represents Jane Brook reserve,is to be put within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect theregional significance of the Jane Brook river system.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan Proposal 19: Subject site 1, currently owned by the WAPC, is tobe put within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regionalsignificance of the Helena River area.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan

Proposal 20: Subject site 1, currently owned by the WAPC,is to be put within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to removethe potential for the area to be developed. Subject site 2 is to be zoned 'Rural' under the MRS.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: Subject site 2 will require an amendment toLPS17 to zone the subject site `General Rural'. Proposal 21: Subject site 1, representing the Water Streetroad reserve between Guildford and Woodbridge, is to be zoned 'Urban' under the MRS.Subject site 2 is to be zoned 'Rural' under the MRS.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: Both subject site 1 and 2 are within the Road Reserveunder LPS17 and as such will not require amendments. Proposal 22: Subject site 1, representing a section of the reservefor Marshall Road, is to be zoned 'Urban Deferred' under the MRS.

City of Swan officer position: Objection Comment: This section of Marshall Road is alreadyconstructed, and the 'Urban Deferred' land to the east is the subject of an MRSamendment proposal to lift the `Urban Deferred' zoning (DoP Reference 812-2-21-21). The Cityquestions the logic of zoning this section of road to 'Urban Deferred' and wouldinstead suggest that the subject site be zoned 'Urban'. A rezoning will not be required toLPS17 in any case as the subject site is currently within a Road Reserve!

Page 5 Ordinary Meeting of Council 3 February 2010

Proposal 23: Subject site 1, which forms part of the Reid Highway, is to be put within the MRS Primary Regional Roads Reserve. Subject site2, currently within the Camboon road reserve,isto be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation). Subject site 3, also within the Camboon Road Reserve, is to be included within the Bush Forever Area. Subject site 4, also currently located within the Camboon Road Reserve, is to be excluded from the Bush Forever area.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: Reserve 46410 (Subject site 1) is currently managed by the City of Swan.

Proposal 24: Subject site 1, currently owned by the WAPC, is to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect their important landscape and conservation values. Subject site 2 is to be included within the Bush Forever site.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan Proposal 25: Subject site1, a Crown reserve containing a creek line,is to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflectits important landscape and conservation values.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan

Proposal 26: Subject site 1, currently owned by the WAPC, is to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflect the regional significance of the area and the conservation values of the wetland. Subject site 2 is to be included within a Bush Forever site.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan Proposal 27: Subject site 1, currently owned by the WAPC, is to be zoned 'Urban' under the MRS to correct a mapping anomaly.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: A subsequent amendment to LPS17 will be required to zone subject site 1 'Residential'. Proposal 28a: Subject site 1, representing the Cullacabardee area, is to be included within the MRS Reserve (Parks and Recreation) to reflectits important native vegetation and water catchment areas. Subject site 2 is to be included within the public purposes (Special Use) reservation for the substance abuse rehabilitation centre known as Cyrenian House.

City of Swan officer position: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City of Swan

Page 6 Ordinary Meeting of Council 3 February 2010

Proposal 28b: Subject site1, currently owned by the Western power,is to be included within the Reserve (Public Purposes)for the purposes of a Western Power sub-station. Subject site 2, also currently ownedby the Water Corporation, is to be included within the Reserve (Public Purposes) forthe purposes of a Water Corporation pumping station. Subject site 3, currentlyowned by the WAPC, is to be included within the Reserve (Public Purposes) for the purposesof a possible future railway station. Subject site 4, also currently owned by the WAPCis to be included within the Primary Regional Roads reservation to serve as parkingfor the possible future railway station.

City of Swan officer comment: No objection

Comment: No implications for the City ofSwan

ATTACHMENTS

Parks and Recreation ReservationsCity of Swan Figures 1-28

MRS Scheme Amendment 1161/41City of Swan Amendment Report

STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS A number of the proposals will requirethe zoning of land under the Metropolitan Region Scheme that is currently within a Reserve.This zoning of land will require a subsequent rezoning of Local Planning Scheme 17 to ensurethat it remains consistent with the Metropolitan Region Scheme.

STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT

Minor costs will be incurred in preparing andadvertising LPS amendments.

FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS

Nil

RECOMMENDATION

That the Council resolve to:

1) Endorse the City's comments with respect tothe 28 proposals for amendments to the Metropolitan Region Scheme withinthe City of Swan with emphasis on the City's opposition to Proposal 3 (figure3) for which the City believes the current rural zoning shall remain.

2) Forward the City's comments to the WesternAustralian Planning Commission for assistance in their consideration of theproposed amendments.

Page 7 Ordinary Meeting of Council 3 February 2010

CARRIED

Page 8 Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

City of Swan Figures 1 - 28 IDGEGANNUP

BRIGADOON

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands- proposed major amendment

0 July 2008 as advertised Figure 1 legend Proposed: Existing: litlEpacks and recreation reservation rural zone

railways reservation

parks and recreation reservation

Western Austrtaiion Conning Ecal8150011 itxbeas.ere, Commission 7.11 I I P IMENEL's qi B NW UPPER SWAN IMEM EMIR'. IINF iiiks MI a LIP." II

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed majoramendment

Figure 2 8 July 2008 as advertised Legend Existing: Proposed: parks and recreation filialzone MILAN reservation waterways reservation

railways reservation parks and recreation reservation primary re0110 *ad* resonation western LNG Augpon seta I ZaTY) 0.3PNX

kaiak.

Parks and Recreation Resentat lone for Public Lands proposed major amendment as advertised 8 Juttr2008 Figure 3 Legend Proposed: Exis Ong: parks son remotest reservation ruralsoon

waterways reservation

ratwaysresenration

parks and recreation reservation

Western :sat 12= 904 CAtorstronatonOraron ts.rel SILO PLACE

UPPER SWAN

AMR!, PROPOSAL 4 /MEW, .2011116 SWAN I SENN ANEW / '010 WW1 z"111111111111

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

8July MOB as advertised Figere 4 Legend Proposes Etslins. Perks art recreates rural zone resewallen

anal zone wa/anvays reservation

parks and recreation reSerrathen

GNP erai.1300 _agoORPNWIROW-2"-4 Arrisailre re- Jr/1.-n AT `a

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

8 July 2008 as advertised Figure 5 Legend Proposed: Existing: Existing: parks and recreation primary rajoinal roads al reservation rural zone reservation

waterways reservation waterways reservation other regional roads "Ifir reservation rural zone rattrays reservation Notice of delegalion parks and recreation Bush Forever area Wi31 reservation

Western AusirgFOo ode1;7509 '1/41.1 Pionning Commission It, li stet Gie ow,44' alis eaIlt, 0 0 3 et1j0 101 1 GtAnkh L XIA 11/ Or Alla Wialii# 13256 MMI AN S f CA44905 vv. /NW # AMO' 12535 ,,,,,,. 11/1/07 2 ME THE VINES II," 0 war ell 1... , UPPER SWAN 'in ...tar llif la SW. 111114Mt 4/4710 al r fratin1111 '''' t WWI EiGinariMain! 27 innNWse I IP I IS* 1 a13874 vti..S) a .1. # 12361 28 t une- it ea issmaSS' linr= wit 0 am 1 " 0 mum mum Is% 41,. iii 11111= 111tr = 1 1 writ 32 bd. t / .1, Aram 1 11111§6 RIIIL.1.1.11 r4,1! i a As '11 -6111zar. Mt I an. 140,,,,a nur,rAir 4,4-7mar 6IngIII =TA : II APi --.. .Nallow..,ta. Ill Mt Lirattilves...,A a A Parks and Recreation,.... Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

8 July 2008 as advertised Hum 8 Legend Eidshrig Proposed. urban mid lea Pl4s-ligrlecreau°1 ruts! zone Notice of deIegallan Val Bush Forever area flays reservation parrs end reaatitm restivarsin primary regnnal roads reservation We: sip ZITC ALOttr 0 eb .0.000 .,0,0.0 _00-.,.0,0 k0....0, 00.0..0 Cornndsdon 1 4:Li.' ---.,= asSi fp wa OWarsI. ,-t affil At THElir VINES illAMR& All Air lit i iff titiltipley 0 :Cti'2,1:11111111 AMP s22 ME.'Ai miwn/MMI :ILAIIIIIIII CR litritiEni 621 14.2121GEEITO . ,w2k 'TERMr 44 RV, -MR aAPME nal, 4.109 IMAM Awsnn,ArrapriagittOrc347798 -4 ...A.,2ERRY R. AMERFTWO'I!'.REW'AATa- dMROv' 14922 raz, trmsawOar' - -eaurtri-s. 158 111 115 I t3 157 !ti ROA0 `VI. mg,awns CRUSE OAD X ... lai%AKS &1.,t3.3 . 15441 0 omeRiiir STORM PROPOSAL 7 > EKOn'T 11032M1 155 ---44. ar..anworeI rists , 11201(.402mrrei 23 SELMA Eggs zir veasitb.anIx ifii voringe. Iwarci m y 0 MEPaahi - TalT/jIiN o icy UPSRAITA. UPPER SWAN 4WOWS. g IMMERREG, --,nrivalamEr -negnr)7. e rot^ 09CP it te teit is,A. bec az,D. 0 i .11111.14Allill-.I MIME. .i.= Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands- proposed major amendment

B July 2003 as advertised Fiore7 Legend prpposed: Diming: Eros parks and recreation fri-fit.V..ir urban zone Primary regional roads ma.AN reservation reservation Notice ol ristegation m at2440 . other regional roads Ka Bush Forever area teSeNaliOn waterways reservation

ptitezz,1 parks and recreation nines, F reservation

mil Western N ,....,,,e,c;,....L.,..--,,t...,,-,a-,..o.»..-...,. ,,, Australian commas Planning -,,...... ?..-,.nnt-t-,,,a.aru'mwv.,-"`ZZ:c.., .24,, 60/1 \ Commission o reo t notr I Opp '41:: 0O-

r- UPPER SWAN m m nI- 0 .14 rn b 40 CA34525 9594 iii BEEHUS ottirmentetike,.... ii K e 0) 4 ,a4 tilllyaid() we tt, PROPOSAL 8 ea4 MI iitilN. 2 51 _dr sirl4 .44: c.io n ..---mgar04095, 4% pro. Aro -..sel ill Ill I Al 5/ cAusas o.gpi MEMORIAL AVENUE 7.1 95 94 Ar

HENLEY BROOK BASKERVILLB

1.117lia\*.16Ab.-ALI Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed majoramendment as advertised Figure 8 B Juitt 2005 Legend Exiscmg: Proposed: urban zone 114111 pailand recreation 01.-al reservation r 1 ruralZone iffly4 walemays reservation tsafetways reservafian Notice ofdalagaRto parks and recreation Ka Bush Forever area b; reservation other regional roads - reSenratital Western ...' itThN ,-14-ta Ausfigron &a %AWN Sessiirccory445-41...arcivectaxIl.P.Wken.n.us -ca 0=1/0o I I J tr===== OA a nplAs HENLEY BROOK

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

8 July 2008 as advertised Figure

nd Proposed: Erjating: parka and recreagon 1:41 resenraron noel zone

WM; Waterways resewaVon waterways reservatIon

parks and recreation re-ervatron

Western LNG eastroton sea rsen "SW fularrn9a QPA raatttleeta Cormlwien 4 HENLEY BROOK 4.$, eo Ofb MM/ 99 133 40 DOUGLAS digtmocc air am lopBs 36 sot CA469I8 Ifn 14455 C:t

2906 14

PROPOSAL 10I

I SWAN

14 WEST SWAN

HERNE HILL 2910 09,440.14 Gm 12347

1 ,

1 III 92 (2- II et. itil10 2912 / Etnosite STR

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

8 July 2008 as advertised Figure 10 Legend Proposed Existing: 1111511 pees and recreation mat zone litr-ms reservation

isv waterways reservation I waterways reservation

Western Ziti'S 2 in.vetesoets tots Australian arreossoo co nine PlonnIng it sic P.PAi ConernIsolon I ,e,,, Pt I I 6) AMIIEIMMIIIIMIalh.-,.y. lqiIiini .- ...... "111111..i.- Sri ------___ Al Dmie v02 150 ------SWAM

iregfi.AI Vs Vs 2 CAVERSHAM

[PROPOSAL 11 I 0 214 LSWAN 1 3 IF

Alf0 AM InM. M/ ar,AMA, I AI' 0 6 AMP' I 41M/ I /NW

''' .'111.02011"474 e e

L,A * I. to ..., MIDDLE SWAN qo

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

8 July 2008 as advertised Fiume ti

tegmcI Exisfing: Proposed: 115J1 parksand recreation urban zone reservation zone TINO waterways reservation Industrial zone

waterways reservation

Omani cantonal roads reservation

.a u. Western -='. "-N.' rtstrt, sarria,iscsissapasipa ;e Austrothen sarstazza La.L. rrazint-""ctl r, rasa,. a A Mnnow& ion Common i i 15 ',win PtLoo. L 2/5

CAVERSHAM po ireirial PROPOSAL 12I atealirdi

I SWAN I .v/E ON As, 7i 213 AgoAdmr...... s tet4t*P'181 .042*NiSEILIZIP" Sondottord 10 Wines Sir 0 aawainir1101101" . s/K11111118- f111 MM e". APAR, le..91

/OrE'0 Mr de VAT eg gg, El( Ni llfte d'1 E4:1

19 Le^ GASS618 mt e 936? As - 1as ), sits y.4 2 , a\ ttl'e!

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands proposed majoramendment

8 July 2008 as advertised !gum 12 Legend Proposed: Edging. mBsiA:ItatV., ; e 0 a e tb n filurban zone

TMwaterways reservation rural zone

ntuce adelegatIon 1 waterways reservation 17/0/2Bush Forever area I;i't-til trseaseddivrticidnrectedion

Western Z.--..'N \ ewavtv4. Austraton ads ISX0 teace,eawawsewe.-e-wewegeatwan \If Manning o In b.,-;,,,ann-Lue,r,...x....wtra,,,,...,,aten..4''''',4^n. 61A "" Commission ""'"` /14:1 CAVERS

PROPOSAL 13 [ SWAN

CAVSRSHAM

2972

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands proposed major amendment a July 20E3 as advertised Figure 13

Legend Proposed: Existing: II/51 parks and recreation reservation ruralzone tit walersvays reservation watenvayereservation parks andrecreation reservation

Western 1::"SH '14PlAtatiationanning Cominsion car. WOODWARD

CAVERSHAM

Fa% IMMOSTENT9 mmmmmm IMNIMQ4k4A111 IMMEMAIT

2978 70

PROPOSAL 14

GUILDFORD

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment as advertised B Jury 2003 Figura Legend Proposed: Existing: pubtio purposes (he a Cu) parks and recreaton urban zone reservation reservation paths and recreation waterways reservation rural zone reservation primary regional roods ratiosys reservation reservation

water-nays reservation

Western Ausnorion 5.4a WSW '1,b Running If= (24.rd ORA CommKtfon

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed majoramendment

as advertised Figure 16 JIM y 201)8

Proposed: urban zone urban zona nonal zone

waterways reservation parks and recreation reservanon other regional roods Nation Western Anshan Sts; LIMO Flanc ing Commission Itgr PAKMt V vissittitrIfilettriall 5W 43' 4,

LIS .Y. UR Pl'aba.a. ca.b.maoAlg -0 . ,, 44- OF -1 AAA Y "' -',

...... :.: c. P OPOSAL 17 IV' , ir, riAt 'It SWAt4 arxammrv.8118, ' "ta 2 1 1 W .. of e 11 "r I ' Is A 8-

ei 4 44, 4---.,-Apis tv.i, N atVW .z.-818111 ts

1.4kir1GOPCI ''''$! SPAMS S G1-10 eff8PS 4-

PERTH AIRPORT S9a ,--,. Cs dtst Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands proposed major amendment

8July2008 as advertised Figure17 Legend Proposed Existing: Existing: ?eisaireksivnlareCrealion :nadirs anti recreation Egg r` 1 urban tone reservation

Primarygreservation regional roads j Industrial zone

waterways reservation 1 public purposes (cg} I ratervaten Ng=Western 41"-- --t-d-iza,-,---,=-Irm.,",-.4.= 4A vs ..,...,... -cOmm. ., MIDDLE SWAN ckoP A ii Eta

,t floe, 0 _mailik .481151511111151118lit, 553Efi.E&1Xt1Xl8lt1I3nk l; - ,.e8fI51Fg6EAEli1Eti5l8IiEIMX')i:i, eak 15- "Pi 45e 488111581121811Thrst01.13MUlpendiall& 271115101181811M5518565to1119:554111581IMP ?ea 48111/311111BaltiZiaiThiliMMITIM5111111188N18MP - AilakrAWrIMWAW":41"1101PROPOSAL 84V,,, i ez 415iNturyPio 111511 SWAM 5'-gram, 611181ffirtil1188118reitgaTgell 4't 11 --tigtmeite-1.815g8MalgWI, :tPt_5P:PdpgF":-z1Vt- t:' 1470E1491118U&Ftita1511%re. ...,watatigfrednit...4 a -I Niti RfeVdDltifVFMAIM1:: . --, eentItgAttpill -wt PISI El tat 4-tzt,g-a 9 ail o gm Sart 4 1111M gif FIV el :- 47' ,, MB . ISO -111 k 146.muma an- tag . Re -b.. am eily ar totem iffinsi ..es446 a 4'1(kbask 4610,# Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands proposedmajor amendment as advertised Figure 183 8July 2008 legorld Proposed: gnisPng ntiperks and reoteatlon urban zone 1E11%11 reservation .vial zona

Ornery regional roads reservation

..,:t.,.... Western 4- 51 .1, Aushettron s Igtoa ot..e.....,,,4=PaNyc.,,,,,At.,,,,,y," pa ,c.,..c.,,,,,,,,,,,,n I:0 .-,-... I .ow ASIOMIErrilli...11011\ralirMilaMMI24 NEI C aillillill asmpg ®E E WS r inenite1141 mg MIPSralIMM MaV741* as allillrilaeigilftlana SIM PATot, IBM wompii salallRIMMIMI iii-ta --ranNuAgM Inlirio giq1 EMINZsayMIEN ESEEUm Bali Nsmag riismKIMgra 0 AtliMIME WIMPMK nlidin1014.'itBINMiladillniimMI Ipprip40 WASimMEN* IS mis- St® '®irss-rnami.INaim11111311 egoFirmiltillenti tribu DRIVerEs,. Illming , 94/Mg"IIIINININNIN mulerimak- IVNIAloom IiibRailli -5,.Mar. 2 fgsguir IMMOtanENIP On. IIIIIRSEIMMAMMI=a L.§ xyki 181(811M/Refitri, $1111MINNLWOHRITO ERNmemwhit IMA1:8131110n22 tiERF3MtrsiSiV.Vaagirlat.t PROPOSAL. 18 , , .....--°risitEanillilli _JMITZEIWAL,P1AS -..-- Vif JP, SWAN anal i- 4..ligrammairmarat MEN qiiii AIZIElittegairkiiiiIiiMili...rSAN Mila y- MEMO WrVeRPNAMENIMPOW Eigir - r 'LiMMOONEWIMILam. IIPMInl cl, a4 IThl- lignailltif@i8121311200taiRe"allianniMiragellri "cialBriommmimmusimummm_, L9681191i8VEIMMINIer -Imo- Is... L.. : 47441.004411:11"::;:at :

'WM1101040 Figi 1 ya saar* war - , .jfy}TTO Wif ,

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands- proposed major amendment a July 2008 asadvertised Figure leo Legend Proposuri: Existing: trill parks and recreation INIMIN resurvalion ultan zone

... primary rug:lanairoads reservalon

we:iern at .:( n mmoron swY ISM

- corrwrIon 1 di502 III Mo67,37Q V11471ri1MImmmmmmmk. a, alimybk- in Eft nekag a. JANE BROOK athM .70MLvr 1141 , qt8t.t.- 2002 411. *4447-iiii&latIn b ittrAtit, ilkolgan, WWI ,wo Y L t.: N NE1113610. 1 PROPOSAL IS 1 1514-081 mares mmmm sk I SWAN .6 wainmmmmma. 5 84 11:1015E115.M.OJIIMS. Mir IfIllefliM mmmmm NPF1151/0. t 1 a krainfg 505 .._Fic -a-. WWallIMBRIEPOMINS a ilmn4m. ImpMma m140 1.o.. ss a 507 IA ERP't-eia so -`=,_ `v wensum... alga 'efliumfrurinana- Untrillibli anzionelunght, C.A 216 INIIIIRW Qiiiis SE C 12978 > 6 NM WWI=en 8 111111111,11ittlism SWAN VIEW INNERS°at maimm9 aalum mumdgfaltiti 0 IS Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed majoramendment

Figure 18o 8 July 2008 as advertised Legend gropwaLL Edsttrig: gpAn parks and recreation tztgn zone 1118an resgrvagon

rural zone

Wegtern -Z-11/- 1C austrcaon =1 ,,,,....,,, --,,,,.....:-....i.,,,,o., 14Plonntig '''" `-t-s"r-^,cd'm'' MI Cornrntdon b.-. liAZELMEfiE

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

8 July 2008 as advertised Figure 19 Legend Proposed: Existing: parks and recreefion reservation rural zone

Industrialzone

parksand recreation reservation primaryregional roads reservation Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

8 July 2008 as advertised Figure 20 Legend Proposed: Existing: parks and recreation urban zone reservation 1=1rural zone rural zone industrial zone

paths and reeretation reservation

Western GNP tter-sor qua-09ton "AtPio/ming ditty Commission IPS anm 'gmal alma '- . o .I I IM .1. '0 II

11i11. gal Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

31July 2008 as advertised Figure 22 Whom! Proposed: Ern urban deferred zone urban zone

when deferred zone

paths and recreation reservation

Waslarn 411"..' Australian Svhlao Planning, qoA 4ansaraiha NORANDA

GEMEM_ Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

8 July 2008 as advertised figure 23 Legend Proposed: ExIsting: primary regional roads primary regional roads reservation urban zone reservation

1111,51 parks and recreation other regional roads IMILIN1I reservation industrial zone reservation Node° 0 delegation public purposes Os) Bush Forever area reservation parks and recreation fro Bush Forever removal reservation Western AusIngbon GcTs ICIV)) Flortrand a CornmWda 0,3 ... -a

502 HERNE HILL PROPOSAL 24 SWAN -64 lioffirpimprmra g oranim41PIII2 r..

.:i

DA GETY ROAD

FIE0 HILL

Px1 .s.. o

a--4, ^, .s.9

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed majoramendment

8 July 2008 as advertised Figure 24 Legend Proposed: Existing: 'rip i parks and recreation I j rural zone allha reservation Nonce of delegation parks and recreation ri*. i re sery ation Si") Bush Forever area

Western ZINIS: .ti< Austrotevo Scav ta,00 ..P i Goosing a vs ...... ,trtr""''''' ...... ,...,ka,asast MI- . Corrunstion tri. xii!sr IMO jai

1 PROPOSAL 25 I i SWAN I allils.._ -411FMTBMIN. 2 ...... tai 7 AIME& -,vg !,_(D 14 11 1111111.19s, ... =awnhim _. 0 m ---.... 290 z 283282 te /imager , c, , -'- .. SS Zarin 07SrCLOS r.tri LaS G

wil MIL

ml :. 2 zur lik II an 00.z ilfra4.1*,100 rictio s SWwas- hana. alt All Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment

8 July 2008 OSadvertised Figure 25

Legend Proposed: aiming: HIM ws eitrvs and recreation 16411reonati rural zone

I raestiaatigriect"ik A

Western 114, einholen sr, 0 s Soak Irir/.0 hit Planning g 3>3 t.r ..,-..,-, PR4 Cemneslon I L yens1 2154 --nonarceirdP026 WA" ir liltara'014,1040 16767,0201.0 %Gsteomordos W0Z0510740 SPRP1/0270$ 800 TIOZT'AOZek )z 6606o60 A072019%,P1 50,401.0Arearpe ZOIZOMPArt WIZOKAAPKU wei,vitumwWIOWYMOViggi vv.boKozohsror. 9:02% WarMIZA 803 0Y.060094 '.9)359.59'69, / 106,7424 6in0651 'WOW% BULLSBROOK 1.057rozA767,6 PROPOSA1.26I '

PINE

ROAD 10

i 1i 'VFAVES

Parks and Recreation Reservations forPublic Lands - proposed major amendment as advertised 8July 2000 Figure 26 Legend Proposed: Existing: Iraniparks and remoter] nral zone IS reservation Nolte of nelagation

d2gPozh Forevonacen

..a.n Wester -4,1/4/- kgrer.it, S:,4111,CCO .."' 0 ILS Mtnr.:4-r''71-ntr OA I t -a,=---...1 nn....Z.4...4:11s,,,,.., aega,t ComM;s8on 1 ,,,...A, mats, 1km NM

,....i. ME IIIE c t....,- 01(0FoRD.:, ...... MEM MA 'Pik,..

'' II_ _ ,

4. tiIJQ ril .,,, r5 S, . PROPOSAL 27 SWAN -.rt..

tsz .t ,,.. .-,

fl.,... ga.,, 84.

-44 ., SY 1- __- ni)..

OP e ir v, NI y`e

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands proposed major amendment

8 July 2003 as advertised Figure 27 Legend Propixed: Exisnn IINIurbanzone p. :I urban zone

Ert-t4611 retstsvaart'igojnre"e"Qn

Western 2-7I's r S.* IltS0 .ta...vsau..-n.:, n == .. Q94 a4...., ., m.upa Ceomni o n I ..10 cirnr""11 . Mat MO.MM.Mkmiflarlik , - 1 gm/Pram:1n=flintMLMVMMM. tm ... .. MMMMMMMMMM...... 1...AA...... moRkA . ... . nOWA0200000W00W201"flir...... _=.1 -- ""." II ma e 4a-,w. t. 1I altmyimmilrair AoriZoAM 042 ...... swim MMMMM millEISSIBmsmx la omormr...... -Eriammarimmmminw Ain mu MMMMMM11 maim i 4 e . I OWOMMWMEMMOMMOMMMUFEMMMEmtvalm FaMMFAMOMM MMMMM MMMMMM2MMUMMEDIMMEMMLIMM4AM: MMOMMMIMMOY-IMI - mollaire MERV, I MOPEMACAMMOMMMMMILMOWVIMEMMM7MM3MMMWMCEMP" MMMMMM ZUMMEMMMWMEMImitImmormmormormursmPHEMMIMMIMM,MArIM/MMMMMMM kerrogsgre am AI mmmetamemmpigA MAMMNSIMM2MMIMM pir '1 IMIBIII1I mli MMMMM mac MMMMMMM1aagg MMMMMLisAmm4m UMMUMMLEMLMILISMAI 1 mommebmpompl WM=mmiiimi minnikMUERAJ MMMMMMMMMMMMMM 1 manAMMAINLMMIMMSRME=mounoncv.....sm. MMMMMM SMMILMMILMm MMMM AMR =MP imam1....mpui "MMM incing6 %II=nancron ...... 'MMEMONmilimoinnornumisimm. . ___--r.....Wr saMMXIMUSWOMINS/I I" SSPSEOM I M MMMMM Ilia"MmmiCA r MMIPOMM9 1 rung w Wnciimmm,ftMMMMMM moot sr,. PI , r 'mapmmmOR AMA r Mae& mrsormireme' c , 1 . lammasmummw0 I t % 1 OatHai i( - No 1 tun Imermomm.1i massomme - -X; ' Ica= 1 2,..lor:glanatAk i WIN i'' P WA Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands - proposed major amendment as advertised slily204A Egure 28a Leg-ti Proposed: rota (uw) ElisVng, wirea mPutsenn 4c 17-=. roan zc rf""iignr'n Fth,PurPts3r=d) Ofirt resarrativq, pi/wry arcnal ixidsr I1 iron, non/m=5n KV° WrPat'a, taN ra5s-vatiq gate losmx iewarasno I 741iii`aer math pirnanfiedonl mad, isseivalion I 1 Pub..ePthnosn (su) Inate csichowm roscoalfin I e-even

I'Vestern Austraton ..qhf Planning Commr:sion Submission 37

Government of Western Australia Department of Planning

State Strategic Policy internal Me or ndurn

TO: Ross Parker

DATE: 24 January 2010

FROM: Rachel Williams FILE NO: 809-2-1 -74Pt1 Reservations for SUBJECT MRS Proposed Amendment 1161/41 - Parks and Recreation Public Lands

Thank you for providing the above proposed MRS Amendmentfor comment.

This MRS Amendment seeks to update zones andreservations in the Metropolitan Region Scheme in relation to.publIc lands. A number of Bush Forever areas areaffected by the proposed reionings; however, as this is In accordance with previousBush Forever advice, there are no objections to the MRS Amendment.

further queries please contact me on Itrust this information Is of assistance. If you have any extension 7772.

Regards

Rachel Williams Senior Environmental Planner LateSubmission

DSR file 2008/1052-2 Government of Western Australia Enquiries Julie Rutherford Department of Sport and Recreation Phone 94929832 Email Julie [email protected]

The Secretary DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING Western Australian Planning Commission 569 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000 2 FEB 2010 Asa5/00&3

Dear Sir / Madam

METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME AMMENDMENT 1161/41

Please find enclosed a submission from the Department ofSport and Recreation in relation to MRS Amendment 1161/41. The Department welcomes this opportunity and truststhat our comments will be considered in preparation of the final proposal.

For further discussion please contact Julie Rutherford,Facilities Consultant on 9492 9832 or [email protected]

Yours sincerely

Rob Didcoe Director, Facilities and Camps

28 January 2010

246 Vincent Street Leederville Western Australia 6007 PO Box 329 LeedeMlle Western Australia 6903 Telephone (06) 9492 9700 Facsimile (08) 9492 9711 Email [email protected] Web vvmdsr.wa.gov.au Building stronger, healthier, happier and safer communities Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial) Form 41

Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

To: Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission SUBMISSION NUMBER 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000

Name: Department of Sport and Recreation Address: PO Box 329 LEEDERVILLE WA 6903 Contact Phone Number: 9492 9832Julie Rutherford Email Addresss: [email protected]

Submission The Department of Sport and Recreation (DSR)supports amending the Metropolitan Region Scheme toinclude withinthe parks and recreation reservation land of regional significance.It is noted that all of the proposed amendments are seeking to retain land for the purposesof environmental preservation or passive recreation.It is of concern that consideration has not beengiventoreservingregionalopen space withanactivefunction. Subsequently, DSR encourages WAPC to contact ourLeederville office to discuss further the need for regional parks andrecreation reserves with the capacity to accommodate active recreation and inparticular playing fields.

The Department is particularly supportive of proposedamendments which seek to facilitate community participation in physical activityand community access to the natural environment. As such, management practicesadopted within parks and recreation reserves should support passive recreationopportunities as opposed to the adoption of an exclusion policy.

The Department supports proposed amendmentswhich seek to enhance or extend trail networks.

The Department supports proposed amendmentswhich seek to facilitate public access to river systems. Late Submission

David Tomlinson - 9257 9928 Enquiries: shire of Our Ref: PG-MRS-013 kalamunda Your Rd 809-2-1-74 Pt1 2 Railway Road, Kalamunda Dale: 29 January 2010 Western Australia 6076 PO Box 42, Kalamunda 6926

Tel: (08) 9257 9999 Fax: (08) 9293 2715

kalarnunda.wa.gov.au Western Australian Planning Commission DEPARTMENT OFPLANNING Albert Facey House 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000 0 2 FEB 2010

Attention: Ross Parker FILEgig40.03

Dear Sir

Metropolitan Region Scheme Proposed Amendment 1161/41 Parks and Recreation Reservations for Public Lands

Thank you for your letter received on 9 October 2009 regarding the above.

Please be advised that there is no objection to the proposals as they relate to the Shire of Kalamunda.

In relation to proposal 8 (Lot 1 Falls Road, Lesmurdie), it is requested that the Commission concurrently amend Local Planning Scheme No. 3, by zoning the subject portion of the land to Residential R5 so as to bring it into conformity with thebalance of the lot.

If you wish to discuss the matter further, please contact the Shire's Manager of Statutory Planning, David Tomlinson, on 9257 9928.

Yours faithfully

ayton Higham Director Planning & Development Services 48 Old Perth Road, Bassendean WA 6054 PO Box 87, Bassendean WA 6934 Late Submission Tel (08) 9377 8000 Fax (08) 9279 4257 Email mail@bassendean wa gov au Website www bassendean wa goy au ABN 20 347 405 108

Our ref: OLET-1299310 OFPLANNING LUAP/ZNNG/1: BR DEPARTMENT Your ref: 809-2-1-74PT1 0 9FEBnt

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION FILE 469 Wellington Street PERTH WA 6000

Dear Sir/Madam METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME PROPOSED AMENDMENT1161/41 PARKS AND RECREATION RESERVATIONS FOR PUBLICLANDS

I refer to the above proposed amendments to theMetropolitan Region Scheme and enclose a copy of the Town's submission on the proposal

Should you wish to discuss any aspect of this matter further, I maybe contacted on 93778005.

Yours faithfully

&Ail(eat?

BRIAN REED MANAGER DEVELOPMENT SERVICES 27 January 2010

Advancing Perth s Eastern Region r3 Planning and Development Act 2005 Section 41 Amendment (Substantial)I Form 41

Submission Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment1161/41

Parks and Recreation Reservationsfor Public Lands

OFFICE USE ONLY

SUBMISSION NUMBER To: Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission 469 Wellington Street Perth WA 6000

Name Brian Reed, Manager DevelopmentServices Town of Bassendean (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)

Address 35 Old Perth Road BassendeanWA 6054 Postcode

Contact phone number 9377 8005Email address ..breed @bassendean.wa.gov.au

The following proposals are thesubject of my submission

at its meeting held on 19 The above matter was considered bythe Council of the Town of Bassendean Western Australian Planning January 2009. At the meeting it wasresolved that Council advises the Commission that:

Bassendean Parade being including theParks 1 that Council objects to Lots 11 and 12 and Recreation Reserve and states thatit is interested in pursuing development on 10 the land reserved for Parks and Recreationunder the Local Planning Scheme No. and zoned Urban under the MetropolitanRegion Scheme.

2 that the Town of Bassendean supports: A Crown Reserve 47268 (Lot 7)Guildford Road being included in theParks and Recreation Reserve; and lies in the B That part of Crown ReserveLot 103 Earlsferry Court that currently Urban Zone being included in the RailwaysReserve Hearing of submissions

the opportunity to personallypresent the Anyone who has made a writtensubmission on the amendment has do not have to attend ahearing. The basis of their submission to asub-committee of the WAPC, You considered in determining therecommendation comments presented by you in thiswritten submission will be for the proposed amendment. please refer to the amendmentreport and in For information about thesubmission and hearings process, particular appendix D.

Please choose one of the following:

of the form and sign) I do not wish to speak at thehearings. (Please go to the bottom

You should be aware that: submissions made to the WAPC maybe The WAPC is subject to the Freedomof Information Act 1992 and as such, subject to applications for accessunder the act. its report on these submissions,copies of your In the course of the WAPCassessing submissions, or making disclosed to third parties. submission or the substance ofthat submission, may be with all written submissions, are recorded and transcribed. Thetranscripts of all hearings, along » All hearings are public records should the Minister approve presented to the Minister for Planningand Infrastructure and published as similarly published in a report onsubmissions. the proposed amendment. TheWAPC recommendations are

To be signed by personsmaking the submission

Signaturegrutu4 ocad Date 27 January 2010

date, being close of Note: Submissions MUST bereceiyed by the advertised closing business (8pm) on 29 January 2010,Late submissions will NOT beconsidered.

Website - http://www.wapawamov.au Contacts: Telephone - (08) 9264 7777;Fax (08) 9284 7568; Erna mrsVmapc.wa.qov.au;