A Vision for Lemoine Point
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Vision for Lemoine Point And the Lemoine Point Conservation Area A Vision for Lemoine Point And the Lemoine Point Conservation Area Project Team Members: Michael Fran zolini • En am -ul Hoqu e • M. E l izabeth Meiklejo hn • Matt M urray Stefani No r man d • M alcol m N or wood • Adam Ro bb • M adushi S eneviratne Queen's University School of Urban and Regional Planning Department of Geography and Planning December 2016 Prepared for the Cataraqui Region Conservation Authority For more information contact: Rob McRae Cataraqui Region Conservation Authority [email protected] QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF URBAN AND REGIONAL PLANNING Standard Limitations This report was prepared by students at Queen’s University in the School of Urban and Regional Planning enrolled in SURP 825: Environmental Services Project Course for the account of the Cataraqui Region Conservation Authority. The disclosure of any information in this report is the sole responsibility of the Cataraqui Region Conservation Authority. The material in this report reflects the researchers’ best judgments in light of the information available at the time of preparation. The findings and recommendations herein are the opinions of the researchers and have not been reviewed or endorsed by the Cataraqui Region Conservation Authority. i Acknowledgements The project team would like to thank: The Cataraqui Region Conservation Authority, for working alongside our team and giving us the opportunity to explore the environmental and land use impacts around the Lemoine Point Conservation Area. Rob McRae, for your mentorship, expertise, and constant encouragement throughout the duration of the project. Dr. Graham Whitelaw, for your guidance and support over the course of the project. Dr. David Gordon, our Director, for your valuable expertise and leadership throughout our entire time at the School of Urban and Regional Planning. Stakeholders, who attended our consultation event and provided meaningful feedback and advice for the project. Thank you. ii The Queen's University School of Urban and Regional Planning Project Course Our team is composed of eight second-year Master's of Urban Planning Students from Queen's University. As part of the final year in the graduate program, students are required to complete a project course, which involves working alongside real clients with real budgets to prepare a final report and presentation on a particular planning-related issue. As the Environmental Services Project course (SURP 825), our team was tasked by the Cataraqui Region Conservation Authority to develop a coherent vision for the future of the Lemoine Point area in Kingston, Ontario. With a range of professional and academic backgrounds that include environmental science, economics, political science, history, construction management, and forestry, our group came together and used our unique skills and perspectives to formulate key recommendations for the Lemoine Point area going forward. SURP 825 Environmental Services Project Team From Left to Right: Michael Franzolini, Adam Robb, Madushi Seneviratne, M. Eliz abeth Meiklejohn, Stefani Normand, Malcolm Norwood, Matt Mu rray, Ena m- ul Hoque Absent in photo: Project Supervisor: Dr. Graham Whitelaw Project Coach: Rob McRae, Cataraqui Region Conservation Authority iii Executive Summary Overview The Lemoine Point area, located in the Southwest end of the City of Kingston, currently lacks an overarching framework for its growth and development. Despite its desirable location abutting Lake Ontario, the presence of notable private and public stakeholders, and its significant natural heritage features, the identity of the Lemoine Point area remains ambiguous within Kingston. While the Lemoine Point Conservation Area functions as the primary contributor to the area’s identity, the Lemoine Point area encompasses a number of other land uses with considerable potential to contribute to its future progress. In September, 2016 of the Fall academic term at Queen’s University, the Cataraqui Region Conservation Authority requested a project team from the School of Urban and Regional Planning to conduct research and develop a cohesive vision for the Lemoine Point area. The team was tasked with answer the following research question: What is a coherent vision for the future of Lemoine Point? As a result of a perceived incompatibility between the area’s land uses, and the continued presence of disconnected operations between the various stakeholders, the Lemoine Point area has not yet reached its full potential of a complete community within the City of Kingston. After conducting significant background research, undertaking several analyses, and hosting a stakeholder workshop, the project team has identified the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and challenges of the Lemoine Point area to create a cohesive plan for its future. Lemoine Point For the purpose of the report, the Lemoine Point site area has been identified as the Southwest end of the City of Kingston, bordered by Lake Ontario to the West and South, Bayridge Drive to the East, and Bath Road to the North. The Lemoine Point area consists of the Lemoine Point Conservation Area, the Lemoine Point Farm, Norman Rogers Airport, the Landings Golf Course, Collins Bay Marina, four City parks and parkettes, and low- density residential neighbourhoods. A broader study area was identified to supplement site- specific research. A map of the site area (red) and study area (white) is located below. iv Methodology The project was completed in five major stages: − Background Research/Primary Document Review − Case Study Analysis − Stakeholder Workshop − Needs Assessment − Development of comprehensive vision through thematic recommendations Initial background research, and primary document review was conducted to ascertain the existing conditions of the Lemoine Point area and analyze the past research that had focused on the area. Analyses of local, national and international case studies were then completed to compile innovative land use initiatives relevant to the context of the Lemoine Point. Some examples include: Vegetated waterfront path, South Huron Trail Mobile Bee apiary on airport Alleghany Riverfront, Program, South Huron, ON grounds, Chicago, IL Pittsburgh, PA Natural heritage signage, Multi-modal trail, Cape Inspiration Lakeview Master Perth, ON Breton Island, NS Plan, Mississauga, ON Building on the primary research and case study analyses, a stakeholder workshop was held to generate discussion on the existing conditions of the Lemoine Point area and determine how they envision the area evolving in the future. From this research, six guiding principles were identified to illustrate the major needs that the vision for Lemoine Point area must focus on resolving (shown below). These guiding principles were used to set up the framework for the recommendations and their objectives. From left to right: Identity, Conservation, Climate Change, Partnerships, Access and Accessibility, and Connectivity v Recommendations Feasible recommendations for the Lemoine Point area were developed to effectively meet the needs identified during the initial stages of the visioning process. These recommendations were grouped into three pillars to better reflect the objectives for the Lemoine Point area. The three pillars are: Conservation, Waterfront Access and Sustainable Development. The recommendations are intended to show the stakeholders how modifications in existing land use planning policies, along with stakeholder operations and mandates, can effectively translate into a comprehensive vision for the site area. Notable (12 out of 21) recommendations include: Conservation 6.1 Protect the Natural Assets at the Lemoine Point Farm 6.5 Develop an Educational Community Gardening Program 6.6 Incorporate Non-Conflicting Habitats on Usable Airport Lands 6.10 Establish Conservation Partnerships to Create Sustainable Land Use Areas Waterfront Access 7.2 Implement Shoreline Protection 7.3 Transition the Weatherall Property 7.4 Encourage a Passive Water Recreation Network 7.5 Create Natural Rest Stops Along North Shore Sustainable Development 8.1 Increase Active Transportation Linkages 8.4 Improve Norman Rogers Airport Sustainability 8.5 Increase Transit Coverage within the Lemoine Point Area 8.6 Limit Future Residential Development Through successful implementation of the 21 recommendations, the Lemoine Point Area will become a distinct region with the City of Kingston. It will operate on the values of conservation, waterfront access, and sustainability through co-operative stakeholder partnerships and land use compatibility. vi Table of Contents Part I: Research Methods and Site Analysis 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Introduction to the Lemoine Point Area..............................................................2 1.2 Study Purpose and Vision Statement................................................................ 2 1.3 Research Approach and Methodology............................................................... 3 1.4 Process.............................................................................................................. 4 2.0 Site Background and Context 2.1 Guiding Provincial Policies and Legislation....................................................... 6 2.2 City of Kingston Plans........................................................................................3 2.3 Lemoine Point Conservation Area Plans........................................................... 4 3.0 Site Analysis 3.1 Zoning Analysis................................................................................................19