DOCSLIB.ORG

Commitment to Communism)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Commitment to Communism) Genesis And Growth Of Nehruism Volume I (Commitment to Communism) Sita Ram Goel 1 Contents Foreword by Philip Spratt 3 First Preface 6 II ......................................... 7 III ........................................ 13 IV ........................................ 16 V ......................................... 20 VI ........................................ 21 VII ........................................ 21 Second Preface 23 II ......................................... 25 III ........................................ 30 IV ........................................ 35 In Sear of a Culprit 36 A Pilgrim to the Soviet Paradise 42 Historian With Communist Glasses 49 An Indefatigable Soviet Enthusiast 56 An Incurable Soviet-Addict 63 An Apologist for Soviet Sins 70 A Persistent Pro-Soviet Speaker 76 A Devoted Disciple of Stalin 83 A Fellow-Traveller of Soviet Foreign Policy-1 92 A Fellow-Traveller of Soviet Foreign Policy-2 100 A Fellow-Traveller of Soviet Foreign Policy-3 108 A Fellow-Traveller of Soviet Foreign Policy-4 116 A Fellow-Traveller of Soviet Foreign Policy-5 124 A Fellow-Traveller of Soviet Foreign Policy-6 132 2 A Fellow-Traveller of Soviet Foreign Policy-7 140 A Fellow-Traveller of Soviet Foreign Policy-8 151 A Promoter of the Communist Party 159 Postscript (1993) ................................ 167 Sappers and Miners of Communism 175 II ......................................... 182 Choosing Between Usa and Ussr 188 II ......................................... 190 III ........................................ 193 IV ........................................ 196 3 Foreword by Philip Spratt Why is there so much puzzlement about the politics of Jawaharlal Nehru? As Goel reminds us, and every newspaper reader can recall, he himself frequently says that he agrees in principle with the Communists. Why is he not taken at his word? We do not take him at his word, because he says and does many other things, and so we do not realise how closely the relevant parts of his policy accord with this particular avowal. When I read the articles in this book, I was quite surprised. He is a very much more faithful Communist than I had realised. But the principal reason why we do not fully accept his own statements that he is a Communist is that our image of the Communist is so different. We think of the Communist as a man with no interests ourside politics, a fanatic working furiously for the cause, an offensive, truculent person, or if he has to indulge in camouflage, a wily deceiver, and at all times a docile follower of the party line. That is not a false picture, but there are many whom it does not fit. Many Communists are also ambitious; many have a liking for the fleshpots; some have serious interests outside politics, though their theory assures them that there is nothing outside politics; no doubt there are some who do not accept the more abstract parts of the Communist theory, as there are certainly many who ignore it; and there are some, even within the party, who are not slavish followers of the party line. Nehru is a Communist in this broader sense. He accepts increasing governmental power, socialisation and mechanisation, as both inevitable and desirable. He is strongly attached to the existing Communist governments, and when they clash with other governments he almost invariably supports them. He is in a sense aware of the dark side of Communism as it has existed up to now, but he neutralises this awareness by the Communist procedure of considering history in block-stages. The “bourgeois era” is thus made responsible for all the unpleasant things that have happened in the past few centuries, and the facts that some bourgeois systems have outgrown many of the old evils, and that it appears possible to achieve a bourgeois world system which would be much preferable to the Communist world system, are ignored. The Marxian scheme of block-stages does not contemplate such facts. Here, it is true, Nehru may deviate somewhat from the orthodox Communist posi- tion. The bourgeois world system was sketched by Woodrow Wilson. It provides for substantially independent nations, running their internal affairs in their own way, under a very limited world authority, like the League or the U.N. The Com- munists insist on substantial uniformity, through a Communist Party monopoly of power, in the internal affairs of all nationas, and until the rise of “polycentrism” they contemplated a highly centralised world government. Wisdom may be dawn- ing on them now, but we do not yet know how far they will go. In this controversy Nehru no doubt stands with the revisionists, but that is a matter 4 of little immediate importance. On the questions that arise now, though helooks so different he is a Communist in practice. The figure in world politics who most resembles him is Castro. Castro got into power on false pretences. i.e. as a libera- tor, not as a Communist, but within a year or so he had liquidated his opponents and built up the Communists so far that he was able to drop the mask. Nehru got into power on the same false pretences, i.e. as a liberator, not as a Communist, and he has proceeded in the same direction, but far more cautiously. Castro succeed Batista; Nehru succeeded Gandhi on the one hand, and the legalistic British regime on the other. The two legacies between them have cramped his Communist style. Nehru has sometimes sighed for a cadre such as Mao Tse-tung built up during the Long March. With such a cadre he might not have lagged so far behind Castro. But such a cadre, while it might have enabled him to enforce Communism, would not have made it any more congenial to India. Communism is the policy of a small group of intellectuals, who are building a governing machine with a vested interest in Communism, but it remains wholly alien to this conservative, religious, individ- ualistic, property-conscious, peasant-minded country. Just as in Russia and China, Communism can be forced upon India only by a usurper regime. When I have argued in this way, people object that Nehru has made no attempt to impose the Communist policy in regard to religion, education, freedom of opin- ion, personal liberty, and so on. The Gandhian legacy has been too strong; ifhe had tried he would have been overthrown. But through a series of constitutional amendments, he has systematically cut down the right to property, which most the- orists regard as a necessary bulwark, in the long run, of the other freedoms. As for civil, religious and intellectual liberty, the Communists always profess to respect them. They are fully provided for in the Soviet constitution. Stalin himself claimed to recognise the necessity for discussion and the clash of opinions. But in prac- tice Communists concentrate all power in the hands of the government, leaving no countervailing force to balance it. Consequently, the libertarian provisions of their constitution cannot be enforced. They are totally ignored in practice, and it ismore than anyone’s life is worth to protest. Nehru’s attitude in this matter is, therefore, in accordance with the abstract theory of Communism. What he would have done if he had enjoyed total power is anyone’s guess. An item of his policy which, I believe, testifies to Nehru’s Marxist feeling, though it is no longer Communist orthodoxy, is his tolerance of corruption. Before the revolution the Bolsheviks obtained their funds by organising a prolonged campaign of dacoities, by seducing heiresses, and by taking big subsidies from the German Government. The last was kept quiet, though it has been proved recently from German Foreign Office documents, but the other two were well-known, and the party leaders had not objection: why bother about bourgeois financial prejudices? Nehru has the same bohemian attitude towards audit objections: they belong to the fussy bourgeois era of Gokhale and Gandhi. 5 Nehru’s Communism is revealed in the extraordinary favour he shows to the Com- munist Party, as contrasted with his marked coolness towards the socialists who put democracy first, like the PSP. He allows the Russian Government, and appar- ently the Chinese too, to subsidise them. It has been admitted in Parliament that the Home Department knows about some of these foreign funds. No other ruler in the world tolerates this kind of thing. Why does Nehru? His Communism has been clearly revealed in his foreign policy. He cannot go wholly over to the Communist bloc, but he will not take the protection of the free countries, so India remains defenceless. China’s big attack came a year after Goel’s articles, and fully bore out his warning. It even moved Nehru for the moment, but he quickly went back to the policy which made the attack possible. His Communism is also shown in his economic policy. Its deficiencies in Russia and China have become generally known in recent years, but he still persists with it. He is not even disabused of collective farming, despite its spectacular failure everywhere. This over-centralised, one-sided, state-controlled economy is building up a great vested interest, political and bureaucratic and indeed capitalistic, which he doubtless relies upon to keep it going when he has stepped down. Ten years ago the Congress Party was by no means socialistic. When the reso- lution on the socialistic pattern was passed at Avadi, an important Congressman compared it to the Emperor Akbar’s Din Ilahi. Socialism, he said, is Nehru’s per- sonal fad, which will quickly be forgotten when he passes from the scene. It seemed a shrewd judgement at the time, but it overlooked the attraction of socialism for a ruling party of hungry careerists. The experience of socialism in the nine years since than has won many Congressmen over. But there are still many who oppose it, and its continuance in the future is not yet assured.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Communism and Religion in North India, 1920–47
    "To the Masses." Communism and Religion in North India, 1920–47 Dissertation zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades doctor philosophiae (Dr. phil.) eingereicht an der Kultur-, Sozial- und Bildungswissenschaftlichen Fakultät der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin von Patrick Hesse Präsident der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin Prof. Dr. Jan-Hendrik Olbertz Dekanin der Kultur-, Sozial- und Bildungswissenschaftlichen Fakultät Prof. Dr. Julia von Blumenthal Gutachter: 1. Michael Mann 2. Dietrich Reetz Tag der mündlichen Prüfung: 20. Juli 2015 Abstract Among the eldest of its kind in Asia, the Communist Party of India (CPI) pioneered the spread of Marxist politics beyond the European arena. Influenced by both Soviet revolutionary practice and radical nationalism in British India, it operated under conditions not provided for in Marxist theory—foremost the prominence of religion and community in social and political life. The thesis analyzes, first, the theoretical and organizational ‘overhead’ of the CPI in terms of the position of religion in a party communist hierarchy of emancipation. It will therefore question the works of Marx, Engels, and Lenin on the one hand, and Comintern doctrines on the other. Secondly, it scrutinizes the approaches and strategies of the CPI and individual members, often biographically biased, to come to grips with the subcontinental environment under the primacy of mass politics. Thirdly, I discuss communist vistas on revolution on concrete instances including (but not limited to) the Gandhian non-cooperation movement, the Moplah rebellion, the subcontinental proletariat, the problem of communalism, and assertion of minority identities. I argue that the CPI established a pattern of vacillation between qualified rejection and conditional appropriation of religion that loosely constituted two diverging revolutionary paradigms characterizing communist practice from the Soviet outset: Western and Eastern.
    [Show full text]
  • Olitical Amphlets from the Indian Subcontinent Parts 1-4
    A Guide to the Microfiche Edition of olitical amphlets from the Indian Subcontinent Parts 1-4 UNIVERSITY PUBLICATIONS OF AMERICA fc I A Guide to the Microfiche Collection POLITICAL PAMPHLETS FROM THE INDIAN SUBCONTINENT Editorial Adviser Granville Austin Associate Editor and Guide compiled by August A. Imholtz, Jr. A microfiche project of UNIVERSITY PUBLICATIONS OF AMERICA An Imprint of CIS 4520 East-West Highway • Bethesda, MD 20814-3389 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publicaîion Data: Indian political pamphlets [microform] microfiche Accompanied by a printed guide. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 1-55655-206-8 (microfiche) 1. Political parties-India. I. UPA Academic Editions (Firm) JQ298.A1I527 1989<MicRR> 324.254~dc20 89-70560 CIP International Standard Book Number: 1-55655-206-8 UPA An Imprint of Congressional Information Service 4520 East-West Highway Bethesda, MD20814 © 1989 by University Publications of America Printed in the United States of America The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences-Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1984. TABLE ©F COMTEmn Introduction v Note from the Publisher ix Reference Bibliography Part 1. Political Parties and Special Interest Groups India Congress Committee. (Including All India Congress Committee): 1-282 ... 1 Communist Party of India: 283-465 17 Communist Party of India, (Marxist), and Other Communist Parties: 466-530 ... 27 Praja Socialist Party: 531-593 31 Other Socialist Parties:
    [Show full text]
  • New Orientation
    i NEW ORIENTATION M.N. ROY Lectures delivered at the Political Study Camp held at Dehradun from May 8th to 18th, 1946 FOREWORD BY PHILIP SPRATT 1982 NEW ORIENTATION ii © Indian Renaissance Institute First Edition, 1946 First Reprint, 1982 by AJANTA PUBLICATIONS (India) Jawahar Nagar Delhi 110007 Distributors: AJANTA BOOKS INTERNATIONAL 1 U B Jawahar Nagar Bungalow Road Delhi 110007 Printed by M R Prints, 1829 Rajgarh Colony at Giani Press Delhi 51 iii CONTENTS Publisher's Note iv Introduction to the Author v Preface xi Foreword xv 1. Scientific Politics 1 2. A New Ideology 9 3. The Two Psychoses 21 4. Lessons of Contemporary History 40 5. Radical Attitude to Marxism 107 6. Radicalism in India 112 7. Our Future 136 8. A New Orientation 154 NEW ORIENTATION iv PUBLISHER'S NOTE The lectures which make up the contents of this book (first published in 1946) were delivered by M.N. Roy at a. Political Study Camp of the Radical Democratic Party in May, 1946. This book is about the nature of the revolution of our time. Roy indicates a new orientation of the Socialist movement which in both its divergent branches—social democracy and communism—has reached a dead end. The direction in which it can look for remedies is organised democracy. "No public man I know of, whether practical politician or mere observer", writes Philip Spratt in the Foreword to the book, "has been a more consistently correct prophet than M.N. Roy." 26. 7. 82 —S. Balwant v INTRODUCTION To the Author M.N. Roy was in many ways a unique person.
    [Show full text]
  • Marxism and Beyond in Indian Political Thought: J
    MARXISM AND BEYOND IN INDIAN POLITICAL THOUGHT: J. P. NARAYAN AND M. N. ROYfS CONCEPTS OF RADICAL DEMOCRACY Submitted by Eva-Maria Nag For the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy London School of Economics and Political Science University of London 2003 1 UMI Number: U183143 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U183143 Published by ProQuest LLC 2014. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 F S20<? lot 5 7 3 S Abstract This project aims at a re-interpretation of the work of two Indian political thinkers and activists - M. N. Roy (1887-1954) and J. P. Narayan (1902-1979). In light of their early affiliation with and later rejection of communism, Marxism and nationalism, they have often been reduced to representing an idealistic anti-Marxist strand of the Indian left of the immediate pre-independence and post-independence era. However, their case for radical democracy can and should be revised. Not only does their work run parallel to some important trends within the history of the European left and thus contributes to the history of left thinking in the early to mid 20th century, it may also have a lasting impact.
    [Show full text]
  • Indian Politicalintelligence (IPI) Files, 1912-1950
    Finding Aid Indian PoliticalIntelligence (IPI) Files, 1912-1950 Published by IDC Publishers, 2000 • Descriptive Summary Creator: India Office Library and Records. Title: Indian Political Intelligence(IPI) Files Dates (inclusive): 1912-1950 Dates (bulk): 1920-1947 Abstract: Previouslyunavailable material on the monitoring of organisations and individualsconsidered to be a threat to British India. Languages: Language ofmaterials: English, with a few items inUrdu and Hindi. Extent: 624 microfiches; 767 files on 57,811 pages. Ordernumber: IPI-1 - IPI-17 • Location of Originals Filmed from the originals held by: British Library, Oriental & IndiaOffice Collections (OIOC). • History note Indian Political Intelligence was a secret organisation within the IndiaOffice in London, charged with keeping watch on the activities of Indiansubversives (communists, terrorists and nationalists) operating outside India.It reported to the Secretary of State for India through the India Office'sPublic & Judicial Department, and to the Government of India through theIntelligence Bureau of the Home Department. It worked in close collaborationwith the British Government's Security Service (MI.5) and Secret IntelligenceService (MI.6). • Scope and Content The files contain a mass of previouslyunavailable material on the monitoring of organisations and individualsconsidered to be a threat to British India. They include surveillance reportsand intercepts from MI.6, MI.5 and Special Branch, and a large number ofintelligence summaries and position papers. The main thrust
    [Show full text]
  • Andrew Whitehead's Blog
    2/19/2020 Chennai 3: Dosas at dawn - ANDREW WHITEHEAD ANDREW WHITEHEAD Search Andrew Whitehead's Blog 33 Share Tweet Share Shares Chennai 3: Dosas at dawn 24/2/2019 0 Comments https://www.andrewwhitehead.net/blog/chennai-3-dosas-at-dawn 1/19 2/19/2020 Chennai 3: Dosas at dawn - ANDREW WHITEHEAD ANDREW WHITEHEAD If anything typies Tamil cuisine it's the dosa - a pancake made from fermented batter. Rice and black gram are traditionally the main ingredients of the batter. In dosa joints in London, the dosa is usually crisp and outsize, and wrapped around aloo (potato) masala - that's the famous masala dosa. In Chennai, more often the dosa isn't crisp but soft, a little like an appam from neighbouring Kerala. It's eaten above all at breakfast time with coconut chutney, often homemade, and sambar, a lentil-based curried vegetable dish, a bit like a spicy vegetable stew. And yes - it's good! On the Madras Inherited heritage walk I've just been on around Royapettah in downtown Chennai, we all were invited in to a suite of old houses - only to discover this elderly woman cheerfully cooking dosas. Lots of them! It was barely seven in the morning and she was presiding over quite a production line - as you can see ... Making dosas in Royapettah Feb 2019 https://www.andrewwhitehead.net/blog/chennai-3-dosas-at-dawn 2/19 2/19/2020 Chennai 3: Dosas at dawn - ANDREW WHITEHEAD ANDREW WHITEHEAD Three houses here shared a courtyard and at rst I imagined that she was cooking dosas for everyone in these households.
    [Show full text]
  • Salt Satyagraha the Watershed
    I VOLUME VI Salt Satyagraha The Watershed SUSHILA NAYAR NAVAJIVAN PUBLISHING HOUSE AHMEDABAD-380014 MAHATMA GANDHI Volume VI SALT SATYAGRAHA THE WATERSHED By SUSHILA NAYAR First Edition: October 1995 NAVAJIVAN PUBLISHING HOUSE AHMEDABAD 380014 MAHATMA GANDHI– Vol. VI | www.mkgandhi.org The Salt Satyagraha in the north and the south, in the east and the west of India was truly a watershed of India's history. The British rulers scoffed at the very idea of the Salt March. A favourite saying in the barracks was: "Let them make all the salt they want and eat it too. The Empire will not move an inch." But as the Salt Satyagraha movement reached every town and village and millions of people rose in open rebellion, the Empire began to shake. Gandhi stood like a giant in command of the political storm. It was not however only a political storm. It was a moral and cultural storm that rose from the inmost depths of the soul of India. The power of non-violence came like a great sunrise of history. ... It was clear as crystal that British rule must give way before the rising tide of the will of the people. For me and perhaps for innumerable others also this was at the same time the discovery of Gandhi and our determination to follow him whatever the cost. (Continued on back flap) MAHATMA GANDHI– Vol. VI | www.mkgandhi.org By Pyarelal The Epic Fast Status of Indian Princes A Pilgrimage for Peace A Nation-Builder at Work Gandhian Techniques in the Modern World Mahatma Gandhi -The Last Phase (Vol.
    [Show full text]
  • Profiles in Courage : Dissent on Indian Socialism
    Profiles In Courage: Dissent on Indian Socialism Parth J Shah Edited by CENTRE FOR CIVIL SOCIETY B-12, Kailash Colony New Delhi-110048 Phone: 646 8282 Fax: 646 2453 E-mail: [email protected] Edited by Parth J Shah Website: www.ccsindia.org Rs. 350 CCS Profiles In Courage Dissent on Indian Socialism Edited by Parth J Shah CENTRE FOR CIVIL SOCIETY Centre for Civil Society, December 2001 All rights reserved. ISBN: 81-87984-01-5 Published by Dr Parth J Shah on behalf of Centre for Civil Society, B-12, Kailash Colony, New Delhi - 110 048. Designed and printed by macro graphics.comm pvt. ltd., New Delhi - 110 019 Table of Contents Introduction i Parth J Shah Minoo Masani: The Making of a Liberal 1 S V Raju Rajaji: Man with a Mission 33 G Narayanaswamy N G Ranga: From Marxism to Liberalism 67 Kilaru Purna Chandra Rao B R Shenoy: The Lonely Search for Truth 99 Mahesh P Bhatt Piloo Mody: Democracy with Bread and Freedom 109 R K Amin Khasa Subba Rau: Pen in Defence of Freedom 135 P Vaman Rao A D Shroff: The Liberal and the Man 159 Minoo Shroff About the Contibutors 179 179 About the Contributors R K Amin Professor R K Amin was born on June 24, 1923, in Ahmedabad district in Gujarat. He holds a BA (Hons) and MA from Bombay University and a BSc and MSc in economics from the London School of Economics and Political Science. Professor Amin started his career as a Professor of Economics at the L D College of Arts in Gujarat University and then worked as Principal of a commerce college affiliated to Sardar Patel University at Vallabh Vidyanagar.
    [Show full text]
  • Communist Party of India and Congress Socialist Party
    UNIT 27 GRO F THE LEFT: ARTY OF THE CONGRESS Structure 27.0 Objectives 27.1 Introduction 1 27.3 Formation of the ia and its Early History 27.3.1 M.N.Rov 27.3.3 M.N.Roy at Tas 27.3.4 Early Communis 27.3.5 Formation of the 27.5 Communist Influence on 27.6 Meerut Conspiracy Case 27.7 Formation of the Congre 27:7.1 The Early Socialists 27.7.2 Brief Sketches of the Ear 27.7.3 Towards All India Congr 27.8 The Program 27.9 The Impact of the Congre alists' Programme upon National Politics 27.10 Let Us Sum Up 27.11 Key Words 27.0 OBJECTIVES rlFI After reading this unit you will the historical background of ce of left in India explain the ideology and pro f the leftist parties and groups in India during the freedom struggle, and show to what extent the left ced the socio-political life of India in the pre-independence era. 27.1 INTRODUCTION /,I ' Before going into the history oft ement in India, let us discuss the historical and ideological significance of t '. During the period of the French revolution, in the National Asse France, there were three groups - a conservative group which supp arch and nobility and did not want to reduce their powers, a liberal ted limited ieforms in the government, and a radical group which wan s in the system of government, such as the adoption of a constitution the powers of monarch. Within the assembly the conservatives sat on ide of the speaker, the radicals sat to his left, and the liberals sat in the cen then, in the political vocabulary, the word 'Left' has been used to mean ovements which stand for radical reforms in the government a omic order keeping in mind the interests of the unprivileged and o d sections of the society.
    [Show full text]
  • Mass Struggle : 1935-40 Module XVIII
    Mass Struggle : 1935-40 Module XVIII Module XVi: Towards Mass Nationalism 1935-40 Module XVI:Modern Towards History: Module Mass XVIII Nationalism - (Mass Nationalism: 1935 1935--4040) Module XVi: Towards Mass Nationalism 1935-40 Module XVI:Modern Towards History: Module Mass XVIII Nationalism - (Mass Nationalism: 1935 1935--4040) Left Movement Formation ● Among the communist groups, the Communist Party of India was formed in 1920 in Tashkent (Uzbekistan) by M.N. Roy, Abani Mukherji & others after the 2nd Congress of Commintern. ● M.N. Roy was also the 1st to be elected to the leadership of Commintern. ● 1925: Indian Communist Conference at Kanpur formalized foundation of the CPI. Module XVi: Towards Mass Nationalism 1935-40 Module XVI:Modern Towards History: Module Mass XVIII Nationalism - (Mass Nationalism: 1935 1935--4040) ● After some time, S.V. Ghate emerged as the general secretary of the party. ● CPI called upon all its members to enroll themselves as members of the Congress, form a strong left-wing in all its organs, cooperate with all other radical nationalists, & make an effort to transform the Congress into a more radical mass-based organization. Module XVi: Towards Mass Nationalism 1935-40 Module XVI:Modern Towards History: Module Mass XVIII Nationalism - (Mass Nationalism: 1935 1935--4040) Conspiracies ● Already in 1922-24, Communists trying to enter India from the Soviet Union had been tried in a series of conspiracy cases at Peshawar & sentenced to long periods of imprisonment. ● In 1924, many communists— S.A. Dange, Muzaffar Ahmed, Shaukat Usmani, Nalini Gupta —were jailed in the Kanpur Bolshevik conspiracy case. ● All 4 were sentenced to 4 years of imprisonment.
    [Show full text]
  • EDITORIAL: China Is Angry with India Dalai Lama-A Headache B,Y S
    Price 25 N aye Paise Incorpo AN INDEPENDENT JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC AND PuBLIC AFFAIRS WE STAND FOR FREE ECONOl\IY AND LIBERTARIAN DEMOCRACY MAKE ENGLISH THE LINGUA FRANCA OF INDIA IN TIDS ISSUE May 15. 1959 Vel\ II No .• ~ PAGE rAGE EDITORIAL: China Is Angry with India Dalai Lama-A Headache b,Y S. Ramanathan 12 From Lhassa to De_lhi b}} Anihon,Y Ellenjimittam 13 AFTICLES The Impact of the Plan on the Common Man .•• 14 Humpty-Dumpty Nehru's Fall b}} M. N. Tholal 4 Congress Needs a New Leadership Limits of State Action b}} M.A. Venkata Rao . · · 6 b:y K. Kumar Sekhar 20 That Silly Question b}} H. V. Kamalh 9 Book Reviews 21 Diamat b.:y Philip Spratt 21 The Free Will and the Market Place b:y Franlr Chadarov 10 Natural Economic Order b:y Silvio Gesell EDITORIAL Also, he should have known what value to set on CHINA IS ANGRY WITH INDIA OVER TIBET Chou En-lai's assurance to him that he would respect rr HE statements of the Prime Minister about the Tibetan autonomy and would let the Dalai Lama Sino-Tibetan conflict and the clear policy of retain his traditional position of national and spiritual friendship with China, desire for the autonomy of leadership. Tibet as a buffer state between her and India and There is one defect in the policy statements of the sympathy with the sufferings of the Tibetan people Prime Minister, and that is the absence of a clear under the reforming zeal of the Reds have been res­ charge against the Chinese that they had broken the trained and tactful.
    [Show full text]
  • Communist Movement and Communal Question in India, 1920-1948
    COMMUNIST MOVEMENT AND COMMUNAL QUESTION IN INDIA, 1920-1948 ABSTRACT y/y OF THE ,__ /< 9<,, THESIS ^Jp SUBMITTED FOR THE AWARD OF THE DEGREE OF ^^A'Sottor of pijilo^opJjp x\\ f^ IN ^' \-\ i ' HISTORY J f. \ \ ^'- '• i.. v-€f\.>-^. s^. <j »•> BY . ./ - ,j / « HABIB MANJAR Under the Supervision of DR. ISHRAT ALAM CENTRE OF ADVANCED STUDY DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY ALIGARH MUSLIM UNIVERSITY ALIGARH (INDIA) 2008 ABSTRACT OF THESIS In colonial and post colonial India, the question of communalism is/ has been a vexing question. It was/ is the communists who addressed this question more comprehensively than any other political formation. Precisely because of this, a study of the "Communist Movement and Comruinal Question in India, 1920-48" holds great importance. The present study, consisting of 6 chapters, has made an enquiry into the question dividing its developt^ent in various phas^a It has elaborated ipon how the Communist Party of India perceived Hindu-Muslim problems vis-a­ vis its role in the National movement during these years. The first chapter is an introduction to the study which has analysed and scrutinized the existing major works e.g. M.R. Masani, John H. Kautsky, Gautam Chattopadhyay, Bipan Chandra, B.R. Nanda, Bhagwan Josh and Suranjan Das. These works have not focused adequately on the communal question/Hindu-Muslim relations. Some of these works ue confined to specific regions, that too addressing only marginally on ihe communal question. The 'Introduction' of the present study therefore attempts to look into the relationship of the League, Congress and Communists on the one hand and the Communist Party's attitude towards the question of 'Pakistan', on the other.
    [Show full text]