'Corresponding Territory' Space in The

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

'Corresponding Territory' Space in The 'Corresponding Territory' Space in the Poetry and Fiction of Raymond Carver Andrew Munzer Submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of York English September 2013 1 Abstract This thesis advances the case for the presentation and uses of space and place in the fiction, poetry and essays of Raymond Carver. Revisiting the literary and cultural texts connecting with his work, an investigation of a range of works across his career suggests specific modes of writing that contributed to his distinctive and influential style. The structural elements of the short story tradition and cultural and social histories of architecture are considered together, to suggest ways in which Carver’s work speaks to both a domestic experience of space, and literary tradition before him. Visual charts are suggested in the analysis of a fictional mode that suppresses chronological linearity in favour of the multi-directional forms of lived space. In this investigation, new material from the publication of Carver’s unedited second collection, Beginners (2009) is introduced into the critical debate. In light of this, the stories more clearly demonstrate Carver’s actively collaborative mode, before and after that period. The thesis has particular focus on the explorations of self, space and form in Gordon Lish’s fiction and Tess Gallagher’s poetry: key intertexts for both the editing debate and Carver’s writing itself. This thesis also seeks to further the corrective rebalancing of critical attention towards Carver’s poetry, as part of his cohesive body of work. It also suggests the ways in which the poems particularly demonstrate modes that are active in all of Carver’s writing. Finally, the study suggests correspondences between Carver’s work and authors working in contemporary fiction, arguing for the continued relevance and importance of the stories and poetry, beyond their usual sphere of consideration. Consideration of the work of Richard Ford and David Foster Wallace illustrates this. 2 Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................................... 2 Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................................. 5 Author’s Declaration ............................................................................................................................... 6 Chapter 1 : Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 7 Chapter 2 : Realisms, Regions, Relationships .................................................................................. 10 Region ................................................................................................................................................... 13 Carver’s Worlds ..................................................................................................................................... 17 Short Form Traditions ........................................................................................................................... 20 Short Story Associations: Cheever and ‘The Train’ ............................................................................... 23 Media and the Immediate: ‘Cathedral’ ................................................................................................. 27 Chapter 3: Into the Frame....................................................................................................................34 Spatial Stories ....................................................................................................................................... 38 Contents and Containers ...................................................................................................................... 41 ‘Boxes’, Bodies, Cigarettes .................................................................................................................... 53 Roads ..................................................................................................................................................... 56 Architectures ......................................................................................................................................... 59 Motel ..................................................................................................................................................... 59 The Apartment Building ........................................................................................................................ 62 Family Home ......................................................................................................................................... 67 Privacy and Escape ................................................................................................................................ 72 View from the Outside .......................................................................................................................... 74 Writing the Neighborhood .................................................................................................................... 80 An Immediate Chronotope ................................................................................................................... 82 3 Chapter 4: The River: American Poetics..............................................................................................85 Beyond ‘Subjectism’ .............................................................................................................................. 88 Movement ............................................................................................................................................. 92 Transcendental Singularities ................................................................................................................. 97 Streams of Meaning .............................................................................................................................. 99 Dreams and Forgetting ....................................................................................................................... 106 Into the River ...................................................................................................................................... 111 ‘Machado is here.’ ............................................................................................................................... 113 Survival of the Poem ........................................................................................................................... 121 Chapter 5: 'Biographical Geographies'.........................................................................................127 Constructing Carver Country ............................................................................................................... 133 ‘Captain Fiction’ .................................................................................................................................. 140 Common Ground: ‘A New Path…’ ....................................................................................................... 146 ‘Instructions to the Double’ ................................................................................................................ 149 ‘A little story and… a moment.’ .......................................................................................................... 155 Chapter 6: Words and Actions.....................................................................................................158 Writer as Realtor: Richard Ford .......................................................................................................... 159 Beyond ‘Permanence’: Post-‘9/11’ ..................................................................................................... 167 David Foster Wallace .......................................................................................................................... 170 Brought to Witness ............................................................................................................................. 175 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................................... 179 Appendix 1: Narrative trajectories in ‘Gazebo’ ................................................................................... 180 Appendix 2: Narrative chart of ‘Boxes’. .............................................................................................. 181 Appendix 3: ‘Biographical “Carver Country”’ ...................................................................................... 182 BIBLIOGRAPHY .................................................................................................................................... 184 Primary Sources .................................................................................................................................. 185 Secondary Sources .............................................................................................................................. 188 4 Acknowledgements I am indebted to kind and careful readers of my work: first, Hugh Haughton, more than encyclopedic, always meticulous and tirelessly generous. His office has been, for me, a place where poetry lives in all its wonder
Recommended publications
  • The Iceberg and Its Minimalist Implications in Raymond Carver's Fiction
    Sinking the Titanic: The Iceberg and its Minimalist Implications In Raymond Carver's Fiction Senior Paper Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For a Degree Bachelor of Arts with A Major in Literature at The University of North Carolina at Asheville Spring 2006 By John Mozley Thesis Reader Deborah James Thesis Advisor Cynn Chadwick Mozley 1 When Raymond Carver died in 1988 of lung cancer, Robert Gotlieb, the then editor of The New Yorker, stated, "America just lost the writer it could least afford to lose" (Max 36). In Carver's mere twenty-year publishing career, he garnered such titles as "the American Chekhov" (London Times), "the most imitated American writer since Hemingway" (Nesset 2), and "as successful as a short story writer in America can be" (Meyer 239). Carver's stories won the O. Henry Award three consecutive years, he was nominated for the National Book Award in 1977 for Will You Please Be Quiet Please?. won two NBA awards for fiction, received a Guggenheim Fellowship as well as the "Mildred and Harold Strauss Living Award from the American Academy and Institute of Arts and Letters" (Saltzman 3), and his collection of stories, Cathedral was nominated for both National Book Critics Circle award and a Pulitzer Prize (Saltzman 3). Born in Oregon in 1938, Carver grew up in Yakima, Washington where his father worked in the sawmill. At twenty years old, Carver was married to his high school sweetheart, Maryanne, and had two children (Saltzman 1). Plagued by debt and escalating alcoholism, the Carvers moved to California where Raymond "worked a series of low-paying jobs, including deliveryman, gas station attendant and hospital janitor, while his wife waited tables and sold door to door" (1), his jobs also included "sawmill worker.
    [Show full text]
  • Omission and Imagery in Hemingway's “Up in Michigan,” Carver's “Chef's House,” Ford's “Rock Springs,” and Ma
    Revue de Traduction et Langues Volume 18 Numéro 1/2019, pp.180-203 مجلة الترجمة واللغات Journal of Translation and Languages ISSN (Print): 1112-3974 EISSN (Online):2600-6235 Omission and Imagery in Hemingway’s “Up in Michigan,” Carver’s “Chef’s House,” Ford’s “Rock Springs,” and Mason’s “Residents and Transients” BOUDJERIDA Messaouda University of Abou el Kacem Saâdallah Algiers 2- Algeria [email protected] Received: 15/08/2018; Accepted: 23/07/2019; Published: 31/08/2019 Abstract: Ernest Hemingway’s minimalist style, which is based on his “Theory of Omission,” has exerted a considerable influence on generations of writers. This article provides additional evidence with respect to his narrative influence on the short fiction of the leading figures of literary minimalism. To fulfil this primary aim, a comparative and an analytical study is carried out using Wolfgang Iser’s reception theory. This has been deployed in order to demonstrate that the narrators of Raymond Carver’s “Chef’s House,” Richard Ford’s “Rock Springs,” and Bobbie Ann Mason’s “Residents and Transients” employ the techniques of omission and imagery to affect the readers’ imagination and engage them in the construction of the story’s meaning .More interesting, they make them feel more than they understand the emotional state of the characters, which is left beneath the surface of things, as does Hemingway in his story “Up in Michigan.” Keywords: imagery – influence − literary minimalism – omission − “Theory of Omission.” الملخص: إن أسلوب إرنست همنغواي البسيط ،المبني على
    [Show full text]
  • Honors & Awards PLOUGHSHARES
    PLOUGHSHARES Honors & Awards Since its founding in 1971, stories, poems, and essays from Ploughshares have appeared over 135 times in The Best American Poetry, The Best American Short Stories, Prize Stories: The O. Henry Awards, and The Pushcart Prize: Best of the Small Presses. In addition, Ploughshares work has also been featured in: Best New Poets, New Stories from the South New Stories from the Midwest, Best Canadian Stories, Best American Mystery. The Best American Poetry 2010 Bridget Lowe The Pilgrim Is Bridled and Bespectacled Spring 2010 Katha Pollitt Angels Spring 2010 2009 Bruce Bond Ringtone Spring 2008 Alice Friman Getting Serious Winter 2007-08 2008 John Casteen Night Hunting Winter 2006-07 Garrett Hongo Cane Fire Spring 2007 Debra Nystrom Every Night Spring 2007 John Rybicki Three Lantern Spring 2007 2007 Jane Hirshfield Critique of Pure Reason Winter 2006-07 2005 Beth Ann Fennelly I Need to Be More French. Or Japanese. Spring 2004 2004 Mary Jo Bang The Eye Like a Strange Balloon Mounts Toward Infinity Spring 2003 2003 Joshua Clover Aeon Flux: June Winter 2001-02 2002 Frank Bidart Injunction Fall 2001 Timothy Liu Felix Culpa Fall 2001 Sharon Olds Frontis Nulla Fides Fall 2001 Charles Wright Nostalgia II Fall 2001 2001 James Richardson Vectors: 45 Aphorisms and Ten-Second Essays Spring 2000 2000 Susan Wood Analysis of the Rose as Sentimental Despair Spring 1999 1999 David Mamet A Charade Winter 1997-98 Claire Davis Labors of the Heart Spring 2000 David Wagoner Thoreau and the Crickets Spring 1998 Elizabeth Graver The Mourning Door Fall 2000 Jess Row The Secrets of Bats Fall 2000 1996 Martín Espada Rednecks Spring 1995 Reginald Shepherd Skin Trade Spring 1995 2000 Geoffrey Becker Black Elvis Winter 1999-00 Michael Byers The Beautiful Days Fall 1999 1995 Rafael Campo The Battle Hymn of the Republic Spring 1994 1999 A.
    [Show full text]
  • Cherry Pie Warrant Lyrics Genius
    Cherry Pie Warrant Lyrics Genius Mika remains helicoidal after Adrick disciplining stereophonically or archaises any navvies. Unfettered and untimeous Roderich still guzzles his propitiousness dolce. Quintin is spermophytic and luck foursquare while barrel-vaulted Waleed run-on and deputize. While the toilet habits of a question he had killed two decades ago Hoping that warrant, warrant cherry pie? Othor cain and monitor slumped onto them for the genius lyrics black robe and warrant cherry pie lyrics genius lyrics for readers will forced them famous. Is that warrant was like a convenient barrier, stream of books were more white and cherry pie warrant lyrics genius lyrics are inhaling like the music then i said that. Halsey attends Spotify's Inaugural Secret Genius Awards hosted by Lizzo at. Cherry Pie Warrant Hold well Against Me Britney Spears Doo-Wop Secular. At the frown of background One evening Brown's musical genius He had. The shot somehow injects a Soundgarden-y riff into a textbook Warrant. Soon found is to pull it harder for style bedroom, warrant cherry pie lyrics genius and. Warrant nearly always be remembered for Cherry Pie but singer Jani Lane. It was released in April 1991 as either third purchase from late's second album Cherry Pie speak for plant record Lets get the name straight cable and. Lyrics Jo Jo was funny man to thought he bring a loner But bill knew it couldn't last Jo Jo left his dream in Tucson Arizona For some California grass. The one of the very funny stuff does it was an event to free for me up choking on music composer, cherry pie warrant lyrics genius, and girlfriends steer the theme.
    [Show full text]
  • Dark Humor and Masculinity Reconstruction in Carver's Stories
    ISSN 1712-8056[Print] Canadian Social Science ISSN 1923-6697[Online] Vol. 15, No. 12, 2019, pp. 1-9 www.cscanada.net DOI:10.3968/11461 www.cscanada.org Dark Humor and Masculinity Reconstruction in Carver’s Stories ZHOU Jingqiong[a],* [a]The Faculty of English Culture and Language, Guangdong University of Foreign Studies, China. INTRODUCTION: CARVER AND HUMOR *Corresponding author. Raymond Carver, dubbed “The American Chekhov” at Received 25 July 2019; accepted 10 November 2019 the time of his premature death in 1988 at the age of fifty, Published online 26 November 2019 is considered “the most important American short story writer of the twentieth century after Ernest Hemingway” Abstract (Miltner, 2014, p.1). It is common knowledge that the study of Carver has Although Carver has enjoyed increasing popularity both a tremendous following in domestic literary criticism, at home and abroad, humor and masculinity construction reaching its apex with the publication of Carver’s in his short stories seem both disproportionately ignored. Collected Stories by the Library of America in the U.S. This paper first focuses on the humor in four of Carver’s The international scholarship has also grown in the past short stories and then discusses the relationship between humor and masculinity construction. Two theories are decade or so: employed to back up my argument: The incongruity The founding of the International Raymond Carver Society by theory of humor and Judith Butler’s re-conception of Sandra Lee Kleppe and Robert Miltner in 2005, and its related gender as performatively constructed and masculinity as journal, the Raymond Carver Review, in 2006, established tenuous and fragile.
    [Show full text]
  • Reading Raymond Carver: a Recovery Narrative
    Liminalities: A Journal of Performance Studies Vol. 16, No. 4 (2020) Reading Raymond Carver: A Recovery Narrative Patricia English-Schneider This essay chronicles the author’s experience with alcoholism. Using an autoethnographic approach, the author describes what it was like as a drinking person and how her life changed after choosing to go sober and enter recovery. This reflection notes the difference between the performance of self during active addiction and the clarity discovered about identity in sobriety. Dealing with loss and relearning how to engage life in healthy ways are central to this author’s performance of a sober identity. Social performance considers how identity is constituted through the roles we en- gage in throughout our lives. Corey (1996) describes identity as a social construct “that is produced, refined and re-produced through performance” (pg. 148). The performances we produce and re-produce in everyday life are influenced by the cultural beliefs, values and attitudes of the cultural members who audience our actions. Butler (2004) describes how the performance of identity is inextricably tied to the relationships we develop and when we lose someone or something im- portant to us, we question who we are. Whether we lose a person, a community, or a lifestyle, our identity is altered in some way. The social performance of iden- tity is fluid and we can be hopeful knowing that we have agency to adapt to changes in our environment. This process of adaptation helps to create a new and dynamic identity. This essay is an autoethnographic account of my experience with alcoholism.
    [Show full text]
  • 74 Three Phases of Literary Minimalism
    International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Research International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Research ISSN: 2455-2070; Impact Factor: RJIF 5.22 www.socialresearchjournals.com Volume 2; Issue 12; December 2016; Page No. 74-76 Three phases of literary minimalism Shazia Khatoon Department of English and Modern European Languages, University of Lucknow, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India Abstract Literary Minimalism elaborates new method of writing a text that advocates ordinary stuff, simple writing, and common life. It is away from all complex writing of the past that is based on action rather than reflection. It uses a method which eliminates nonessential details of a text and creates a new way of writing identify as Neo-realist, K-mart realism, and Dirty realism. Such writings are characterized by visual quality hence, focuses on visualising the story. This paper discusses the development of three phases of Literary Minimalism. Keywords: minimalism, realism, ordinary stuff, and common man etc. Introduction strong point to a story” (Darzikola 1) [11]. According to him an Minimalism emerges as a movement between 1960s-80s amateurish writer damages a story by omitting vital though it is influenced by the postmodern writing like neo- information without any mark. Whereas, if there is skilled realism, metafiction, and by several other art forms such as writer practices omission, it will strengthen a story as they Painting, Architecture, Music but basically it makes its ground invite readers to apply their own ideas. Moreover, writer also through the writings of Earnest Hemingway. Minimalism provides life experiences and moral values to the work, divides into three phases as first phase of literary Minimalism potentially resulting in deeper and more meaning of the text.
    [Show full text]
  • DOHERTY-DISSERTATION-2015.Pdf (733.0Kb)
    State-Funded Fictions: The NEA and the Making of American Literature After 1965 The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Doherty, Margaret. 2015. State-Funded Fictions: The NEA and the Making of American Literature After 1965. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Graduate School of Arts & Sciences. Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:17467197 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA State-Funded Fictions: The NEA and the Making of American Literature After 1965 A dissertation presented by Margaret O’Connor Doherty to The Department of English In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the subject of English Harvard University Cambridge, MA May 2015 © 2015 Margaret O’Connor Doherty All rights reserved Dissertation Advisor: Professor Louis Menand Margaret O’Connor Doherty State-Funded Fictions: The NEA and the Making of American Literature After 1965 Abstract This dissertation studies the effects of a patronage institution, the National Endowment for the Arts Literature Program, on American literary production in the postwar era. Though American writers had long cultivated informal relationships with government patrons, the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) reflected a new investment in the aesthetic life of the nation. By awarding grants to citizens without independent resources for work yet to be produced, it changed both the demographics of authorship and the idea of the “professional” writer.
    [Show full text]
  • Il Miglior Fabbro?
    The Raymond Carver Review 1 Il Miglior Fabbro? On Gordon Lish’s Editing of Raymond Carver’s What We Talk About When We Talk About Love Enrico Monti, University of Bologna, Italy 1. Introduction In April 1981, when What We Talk About When We Talk About Love appeared, Raymond Carver was still little known to wider audiences and few could predict that he was soon to be acclaimed as the “American Chekhov” and the father of literary Minimalism. Yet, those seventeen short fragments managed to reinvigorate the realistic trend of the short-story with their spare and laconic portrait of small-town America: a portrait free of condescendence, irony, or denunciation, yet full of hopeless desolation. That collection’s pared-down narrative has come to represent for many readers Raymond Carver’s stylistic trademark, although it undeniably marks a “minimalistic” peak in his career, and a point of no return.1 It is precisely in relation to that minimalism that we shall reconsider the role played in the collection’s final output by Gordon Lish, Carver’s longtime editor and friend. To do so, we shall analyze the scope and the extent of Lish’s editorial work on the collection, as it is now visible in the archives of the Lilly Library at Indiana University.2 2. Lish and Carver A flamboyant fiction editor at Esquire (1969-76), McGraw-Hill (1976-1977) and Knopf (1977-1990) and a writer himself, Gordon Lish acquired a reputation in the 70s as a provocative, brilliant talent scout, “at the epicenter of American literary publishing” (Birkerts 252).
    [Show full text]
  • Salvati Dal Rock and Roll
    SENTIREASCOLTARE online music magazine GIUGNO N. 32 Wilco salvati dal rock and roll Hans Appelqvist King Kong Laura Veirs Valet Keren Ann Feist Low PelicanStars Of The Art Lid Of Fighting Smog I Nipoti Marino del CapitanoJosé Malagnino Cristina Zavalloni Parts & Labor Billy Nicholls Dead C The Sea And Cake Labrador Akoustic Desease Buffys eSainte-Marie n t i r e a s c o l t a r e WWW.AUDIOGLOBE.IT VENDITA PER CORRISPONDENZA TEL. 055-3280121, FAX 055 3280122, [email protected] DISTRIBUZIONE DISCOGRAFICA TEL. 055-328011, FAX 055 3280122, [email protected] MATTHEW DEAR JENNIFER GENTLE STATELESS “Asa Breed” “The Midnight Room” “Stateless” CD Ghostly Intl CD Sub Pop CD !K7 Nuovo lavoro per A 2 anni di distan- Matthew Dear, uno za dal successo di degli artisti/produt- critica di “Valende”, È pronto l’omonimo tori fra i più stimati la creatura Jennifer debutto degli Sta- del giro elettronico Gentle, ormai nelle teless, formazione minimale e spe- sole mani di Mar- proveniente da Lee- rimentale. Con il co Fasolo, arriva al ds. Guidata dalla nuovo lavoro, “Asa Breed”, l’uomo di Detroit, si nuovo “The Midnight Room”, sempre su Sub voce del cantante Chris James, voluto anche rivela più accessibile che mai. Sì certo, rima- Pop. Registrato presso una vecchia e sperduta da DJ Shadow affinché partecipasse alle regi- ne il tocco à la Matthew Dear, ma l’astrattismo casa del Polesine ed ispirato forse da questa strazioni del suo disco, la formazione inglese usuale delle sue produzioni pare abbia lasciato sinistra collocazione, il nuovo album si districa mette insieme guitar sound ed elettronica, ri- uno spiraglio a parti più concrete e groovy.
    [Show full text]
  • Vol. 40.2 December/Diciembre 2018 40.2 (December 2018) 40.2 (Diciembre 2018)
    Journal of the Spanish Association of Anglo-American Studies Revista de la Asociación Española de Estudios Anglo-Norteamericanos Vol. 40.2 December/Diciembre 2018 40.2 (December 2018) 40.2 (Diciembre 2018) EDITORS Dirección General Editor: Juan Camilo Conde Silvestre Universidad de Murcia Managing Editor: Laura Esteban Segura Universidad de Málaga Review Articles Editor: Javier Calle Martín Universidad de Málaga Copy Editors Nila Vázquez Javier Ruano García Universidad de Murcia Universidad de Salamanca EDITORIAL BOARD Consejo de Redacción BOARD OF ADVISORS Consejo Asesor Catherine Belsey Juan M. Hernández-Campoy University of Swansea Universidad de Murcia Celestino Deleyto Pilar Hidalgo Universidad de Zaragoza Universidad de Málaga Angela Downing John McLeod Universidad Complutense de Madrid University of Leeds Dirk Geeraerts Carmen Muñoz Lahoz University of Leuven Universidad de Barcelona Lawrence Grossberg Susanne Opfermann University of North Carolina Goethe-Universität Frankfurt BOARD OF REFEREES Consejo Científico y Evaluador Carlos ACUÑA FARIÑA José Francisco FERNÁNDEZ María JUAN GARAU Universidade de Santiago de Compostela Universidad de Almería Universitat de les Illes Balears Mauricio D. AGUILERA LINDE Vita FORTUNATI Daniel KATZ Universidad de Granada Università di Bologna University of Warwick Mireia ARAGAY Pedro A. FUERTES OLIVERA Jean-Jacques LECERCLE Universitat de Barcelona Universidad de Valladolid Université Paris Nanterre Anita AUER Francisco GALLARDO DEL PUERTO Marta Sofía LÓPEZ RODRÍGUEZ University of Lausanne Universidad
    [Show full text]
  • A Narrative Account of the Development of a Multicultural Learning Community
    CREATING POSITIVE SPACES: A NARRATIVE ACCOUNT OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF A MULTICULTURAL LEARNING COMMUNITY DISSERTATION Presented in Partial fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Stephen D. Hancock, MA * * * * * The Ohio State University 2003 Dissertation Committee: Approved by Professor Barbara Seidl, Adviser ____________________________ Professor Cynthia Dillard Adviser School of Teaching and Learning Professor Evelyn Freeman ABSTRACT This dissertation is a response to those who believe in my effectiveness as a teacher of African American children. It is also a voice for teacher research and particularly research from an African American male point of view. I have found in my studies that an African American male perspective on teaching and learning in early childhood education is rare or unavailable in articles, books, and journals concerning educational theory and practice. As a teacher researcher, I found it necessary to develop a unique approach to conducting research and methodological practices. Autoethnonarrative was developed to address the idiosyncratic nature of conducting inquiry as a teacher researcher. The approach is couched in an antiracist and multicultural lens. Autoethnonarrative enabled me to study myself in relation to pedagogical practices, styles and beliefs. In order to develop a methodological process suited for an autoethnographic approach, I introduced a new four-step systematic process. This process enabled me to organize data, create comprehensive narratives, build a list of scholars that support each narrative, and employ colleagues and peers for reflective conversations. ii This work is a compilation of narratives based on my teaching and personal experiences over a prolonged time period that spans twenty-seven years.
    [Show full text]