The Phylogenetic Relationships of Adapidae (Primates, Lemuriformes)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE PHYLOGENETIC RELATIONSHIPS OF ADAPIDAE (PRIMATES, LEMURIFORMES) /tRA I? JEFFREY H. SCHWARTZ AND IAN TATTERSALL VOLUME 55 PART 4 ANTHROPOLOGICAL PAPERS OF THE AMERICAN MUSEUM OF NATURAL HISTORY NEW YORK: 1979 ,-,-"..L. ,- -, W,.,-", ," ._',I1, _-. l." -,k- 1.1. ,ill ,'-,X... -,, .'. I ,.-,'. ..,1. ,11" 1, -, l'-f", 1; .-.- ` 1, .-, ,-,,,-,.,.,,.,,I.,.,-.,'A.4. ll,-.lox -."",,.-.. 1. of" ," '%.- -, -,, ,z '. -,""'.;---',i.,.,`-,',- Y .- ,,Y-,",.,Y"F'.,-ji',_,-iv-"i"' 4, ""-,;, -'.'-`.,`.,.. -.,,.'. .'i -.?A, i.,1'3.i`,wl"'"- i'A -,.k ".PI,,,..,.,,,-Xl.tl. II - y.!,C:,J.-.,.`. -.,, ..., ",7.11,.N,,'i,lj.'.ll,_-A.ii:ll".,.,:v"I %10'11 "_...,,.,,"," ',.,-,....'k, * 4--k 4 '.,.,.-.I...,4 .,.. .,-_F.-;Z-.J'.'7.'-.','.t ". -,. .,...., ,.J,., . _1_1 ,Mf, ,,,,4..;7, ..wp ,e' -.,.,-;".-- I,,.,",,--,:,.,-4,,_.-4; ''.., Fi--,.l')-w"',., )l " ,p ,,;4, " ",., .1#1 I1, X, ..1.1.1,I*X'K.P'll -,.." E L.,..,..,...II.Z.. .. i,.-.nl,.,;"-I-,i_,M,J,,--i",,,''it16......,.J., 31;1'.1 .!. ,- "Z',.lz. .I-,'A-4., .)-- ;_..,--;"1,,,-,...-":..-.1I,,...-",",,",..R."1W , 1-1- .,, '-.',.'- --P,.1.4`.,t+t'_I,.- .- --, 1,1- .%_,7ikj._..I,J, ., ?R,, .-,1_,.'-._ I ." _._ -." ,., ,,li; 71.,,-,",--,,.."-'W'.",";G. .t: .,:,_' f%.f.`,'..,., _.,,.-," ._v. _` ...;.,;.5 . ",.,-4,.86"M-Ijll.---- .".`,'j-_.. JX,..m ,7_1 'I"4 .., ,` 1 14, ,4..,4 LI S. ,.. '. _'_'J.' ""',I.,17.451.'A_., ., .--,-.,.,Vl.,*,.,;4,,,-",.l..-V -, .,.,.,I.. rX_:,.-1..I-,---.V4t.,.". ,,,,, ., .i ", .4k.,I 41!. 4!.',Z7S,...",W., ., .,.'.-.' ., M, Z. ...,11 -, 4 .k ,'.,,,,, "I". 't,- ,,-,,!..._, .l.,".:...k.,..,,.. .._,..l ,-,.-4,.'- ril ,.,....--.ik I" ,., 4. _,.i_ 1, '' 14-X .,v,.,,.%.,_-. .. .,,,,'.,-.;.;," _,..x11111 '71' Nk.7A ,',A ?qt. VINIV, "--,SA.,,z,R,l4_" V ..',,..,, - ,,&.,__,,...i,.',.;, .!j - I"'k, .) .,'4'-'.T?`."'lf-.;_e-,'34-L-A, ..., _.4 .I.jj-11,I.4i,WMAVI"I ,!-i, ... -.'. ..- .'Ir,-, .,Z',--f-` ., ., .5 11, , .,..,7,_-,,#.,,',,., "4-,"",".,"-Z. .l .;.--..) x--,,,.1 .,,.2 . I.,.-,J'W11%.1141 f'-,,-,,.11,Zt;;. ,,.,,.,,,,...-.M-. -,., ::.. ii.. ., 1.-,,,,,-., .y'.. I' '-11.1. A,,V_i, -.t II; 1, . " ,,.-11-,;,.,.,-.,,- .,,.`-, 4" .' .w, .k, ,._Vy, .. ..%,N,74 y.,.......,.-.,.;f,...,,,.....,..t,;,-,f", -` _,;..-4,X,r,z,. k..'.., .1 ""-,II.,i 17. I .!. -. 4 ,q,I..-,-1 " IF..-,-t'!,_,s" -, %. ",.'J'V, --,,,",.i, ,. ..'....-, .,!--,-,,.4..!-,i.,,,.,..-.. ,Of.'--'.. -.,..", )%4v__J.J'.-.`,'...',,!, ..I.- ",,X -, .",-W.,,"',_ji.- ..,,.. .,--,..'o"1.1-,,.1'4. "' ,-.. .,,., .1 ".., q, ,,A.'e,.,;. X-R ,-_-.-,,.m--,', ..t-t,-,.!,,..t._`,,,., -. .t.- ",-.1, " -. '.14,.,'.., ,.,,., ,6,", vw,,-..10,..'- 5-.,.',,1, --- .I --. "-.,,,,.-,o -,,,... -, .T -, k.',aN`. ''-,,..,o1- ,::,l.,,,,i,,";.t,..:..,,.,-,i', ,.I,...,."-", :, "-1 ,."-. 2.. I.-,.,,r, -. ., ;._" _",iv.;" -,--V,,'i..-,lv'.,1,4.-4F-,N v -, .,, ,,-.-.1'4.'V.-_.,V.,,,Jl',,.,,-,;_...;."J"-"...,.g,"I .,` *e..'_'..:., i" i;;*,_,.;,._,Y-T, . K.-W., 11. .,- " .f.lI ,..,-,;W-".j, -;,.ll 4".R.-- ,-'.; Y-.,-.,,.,`-,.-...-Al.,;,'pi ..,"',"' , ,,, ,,, -,,-"., -. ,.,. , ...-, ..,.,,.- .i._;A.."- 1,4. ,;,",-,,.'F.,V._',,',,,11 ,,;,"'N-M.90 e._-,',Z).__11_11..,,I,.'4',- 0,--" ,,.,. .,_-,,v-,,,,,.K..- f. .,,.. .,,.,., ...,T. -.."i .#.,.;,.. N.,- ,.,i,."-. ,- --. !,tx.-.-,,",.-I-?-,..,-,-,l rI--.,_ ,-,--;;'l,--l'l-_., ,,,- . ..l.".,11 ".. -.., ,.,:.*. " ,"I,.'.._ .;,, t;, .1'1";..? ,,..',:,._,. 1,.,-, - -. .; _-. .i,. -,.,,v,'.,.`. ----,.....,,j.,- ,,, to 4, ,. &U.,'.. ..,.-.', __,_eI"'y .,"".4",, ', _-,..,4..,I,,;'ll I.41 ",,,,.,'. -...,,, ,.., .-6F,;--;, ',,,.. .N. - --&..1q,..W,,,..,',.,!, 1, A,4,Ol ;.'. _,K "I .i, , 5_, Q, 11 .,-t.,.7. I,A'."-- ,,."",141q'!...,.%.,,-_-,i V-I, --M.,-,,-A4f; '!.,., "." --0, ',..l .- -.,. -,,_, _-., .r., .. -.:..*6 I V. -,. .",.. .. ".I,.'.i.,I_-"; ., ... Y;..j,,'. I ,, I.,,,.X. , .., ..'--, ,f.4.;..,.,3,-, ,iiW.-. , -V. 1.,-tll, ll..-;_-,.-;.,,.!"" .., .I, .':- ,, -,-,--.,:,, .1, ., I-,.ka",-".. K- i,,.;.11;.. ,-,,-,.. ,*. ,'.,., 11.1""; .,._ ', .,.. v .-`'. ."Im., ,.,..1, -: _- -, .,_-_--.,7.,-','Z, .i--,;,,,".. --'l .l ,W;..j.. ", "', 0, ", ,, .--,` '."." ,,--.-..4 ,,I.0_-4,:`,. ,lpIi'lI'll. ,.;*._'_*.'- ,,,"I1;.', ,.A...."'i,--,,-4.11.,-, ,,, .,,'..l_"Wp, ,-.-,-.t-Iv ', 'it, .1,JV',.i".-,"",.0., 10, 1,.h.t,t, ',,I,.", '4. .- ,,.,. .. -t' .11_.... -c."orOx,, 1, -.-,-- I," ,.4..,.4,,..,.I,,. .`..,,",__--,,"'--,-t,,.,4."', -,",,., i 4 .,,K'],,,.,e...,q:,.'i-0 ,;, .,.'-,-, -.. ,; '. ,.*., ,,.,-,,.' y,.11'V,I.,'.,.,.' ,.,.,. ,. ---,.,f,j,.,.. ":!v,,_,.-,-,'?..._ -."4., -,.V.1, . .,;'.,,...4.V",,,,'31)1-rI-". "1'O-',. V.,,,.l.4 I '.,-,1-.. .,,., .P., -, 11,ji .-V ", -._-. -.', .,4.,_,.,,rQ,.,,,.....-., 'j W, ..,v'. 1-1, -, .. .z I..,4., -,-,.,;..,?.,.!':'. 1, I..1.... ._ ", .. .., ," i:-,.'...'.':'- 1" -1.1-...,.ie .1113;4,_.,II ,I`1, A-t 1-. 14.-I.,,., ". "I-.-,--, ,,,6I"., .,.,.,-, 4j.' 1,,i,'..-.-..-;,_,-w-4. 1. " '4.8` ",-.,.,.., ,'.. 1, .;,-'--,-.",-,;-."r,41,.0 v _._--- "'; ..., ." -."'t',,.", .,_., ,V-4, m`_.,.1.. ";,.W,it" -,:,,.' ,., " ,., 4, `. -. ('..;,14. Wl,..".,, ,.,,.,,.'.,.,'.,..,.-.".....,".'.-.- .I'' ... -_,.4....,."I._: Y" "NAr I O -lz.._'.e *._ .jr'...,.,.,,-,_, , :,,",..," .;,,,,..I-.-...!. ,j. Z, .,.".,,.- ._. .?".,,.,.'11'..,,,V-. ...- .'4.i,* ,.,-.II--I.,...l'-111i-.,!_,,-,,,..,,.l--. ...)`.-..:,.;!,.,.,-....k,i,,',,,",.,%,. -P ..- ,. _,..-. ",.%, *- ..,,,,.W_,-_ -.,.,.... - *, ",", ,--, -"".,`.l ."'.'1111.11 "' " 3,. .- ,., .,O, 1- 1'.% I. ,.,,r.:,I.,_*..,. .. .-":-"-.."-c,. ll'w,-.., -,. "'.1,10 -,-. %,i __.I,,,,,,,W."')" -'. .1,14112.4, -11"",.,._I. -'Z- -,.,.,,. ... ll._,,',_.,; .,,.,"' ...I I.;,7 .1_ ....,,-'i--.,,,.1K'1.1_3111.,",.i.-'..'.1.I- k,-, '' . - N-.-- ,-, I.- M; ,7,.,,,--, -1 -,.Pi ,"",-,r',!.,,".t 117, "J"', ,,.-'I.;-. "I .,,;- "I,YX,",""",,.1...,-,,..-*t,,--,.v4C;,Kl.A," ,4,1..,,4- -,k"-,-:.,-,,:."4'e'.,..'..l%,.i,,,,..,_. _-..,k-. ..l ..,..r_.,;i..,,-I" .., ".1,Y 1. .II,; I,-- * ,"0,41.,--'.,t4%,. ",".,.,".i,.l ..).. "O y:.. V, ".4.,;k.,,-V'.,.,.0-,-Al, IV1'.,,",.-", 11.'..I `. .,_,"Yc4.I-;.1- -... 0.1_1,., ".i .,, -,.4,14 1,',.. ,. 7.,"'i.,,.. .,-,.;,,4 ,., '..4'lc ,, .k..,_.-.4,:4: -,.. `fi -ix k,,.11_.",;.A:::`l_,Z,,--.),. 4.,'Z,'.,-r'W", -,.-,;,V,,,.-.:.,.,.,I., 4.--, . ,,,,I..,,- I.. 'W._?.;l I---..00,;.,I:.lI.-, I.,.*I "... 1,.3Y. ,;" .', 'T .,. -_'_., ',.-.,...-wt%-Z. TA..11., -.-*II,.',-'-,fl,,....-,Z'' i ".,...,:,, .,.(i.i` .,., `.;., 1: ..4"o't, .1,v.4."fk"llI_*.,,,"..,.. ,-., -.. ..'i Al llll%'.- N `. Ii. ., .P.,.IAl . ,",-11 1.tI.,1.1-1 "1- i N ..x-,.._",.._ ".._t, .,.k 41 . t) 11.11' ,.'_,-. "i ,. .11 -_.'.-..,.,1, "..-.1,I,-.', ,0,;I-II.,..:. .,., 1.',.,.,,'.'..4'il' " ,T. -.1-..;, 1.'_. ._. W.'N '74.. Ir,l .,.1.q,,f-."-.*4,,,_ .,,. .1.,-"",".,-.",,,',,T".-.,7 ., :,- -';-.'t,, -'7,.I- .-'-u,,, "_',-..N7:,,-, 1%",,.. .1 ,": ..'.I.,4"')A., .,"-, -.,'.F,--,., -j ._' ,pw._.'ll -_rAl ".1.,`......,.., .. ,.,,. Ylf 14 '',", ,""',,,-.I..: I.. ,,...iv _.,;.,F-,,".-1..W,I, 111-1,S......-,.".i,.,."_.., I.,.. 7""t ., -.4-._-'l,", .,-11-1.-,1._IV,4-4,i .,;-.,1...,.l,-)P_',., ie 1...."i.' -.i'._.4..,-:- 7,'... ,.',"l4,, .I,V*_.,.., ,,I,, 77) Ii;.4..!ii,:.-4,N..,.,"..,.Ml, ,.. 4, ._.., Ill ,. ,',,.,.,,...._ ..-..- ,..--;.,-.,!*l-j.11,..*-".4.-,,11,W-W', j, "' 1.,.,"I -.r",".$.j...,,.., ..i--,... ..;,.;WV-4,..!-,7 ''._,-4, ,i,%.--,", ,11.. ,W ,.,,._ -11-,.-f .,,.,.h "."., cl'',.I..,-,,I-.* i'' .'..,7 "' 't" "A"'.-,-,AiI11 ..- -," -F.'''. ."'t. k .i.,o-.1, -,--,'' --_ ,i.,.,f Ni--4 r.,A t," s. ,,.,..7,.,1.1-, ._.11'z -.1 -, 'r-U-1-, ,4. !.,,W, -_,,, ..T.", .,_ -,7 1,p -1. -, . .,..,-.,,.,,"',..t,.I',";,;:"., R-AC,T, __,., '',.:,III.,.. .,,,4,., 1, ".,-,.,-,,.,.,.Z.''*11-. ,..It1",,A,-.4"'.,-., ,*,, .. -. -,.-,,;,.,g T V_.-i.,.,-,-,,211,...,,,.,,'r.,."+6.Y,,4 ,.x .4.-,.,,.".,"I-,_v.),..,, N,,_iV,-,-, _,_!*-, 17T,,'.1,,,,-.-,-,,.-,_,,;.j',"I 1.. ,,. -",I1, A -4,1.;.-,,M','."; .,-,._--A-, ." 1. ,.,."i,,-_:!'-:, ,'7 `.;! -...i.1.,.-,"il.'.,,, "I"..l,'.-,-:;,I,-f ..,,-*1.7..'P_ .`A.%..'';-;' " .Qi,,71A, .1- ,."P.,*g ,.r'-.,_,'_.,.-,-1.,,,. "', , -, i.1;.j -.p.W%._,",....m-,,..-,.-,,,,-1, ,.,,-I',Qr _1_.--`.-"-4i'k 'P-,,- -4..i,,'--j.._..,. 'tI-....__R-.4... 'I, ,,..4.,".,.;,-"'?-",',-..k-.."..,.11'; 4;.., lit ft .; ,I --', ,Y&. ,, ,,_.,A ?. .";,;,.'A ,J,.4.,. .,- ,,,-:i` ,V-1-,K,,-, I QIFT11'13-, _, .,, -..,i.'.Z,`.'_,N_,-.`l__-_ ,-.)r..,_;.1.J_.A..f,-,; .-L,7?.-tVI-- .,,,-.;,.?", _.7(T,7:".", I,'N.1, .-, V. .-",-4.-'..,--..,;.,1- ,,,".,,i,l'.e4,4M,.-.m,M.vc. It. Xle"' '11,,,.''-`..-,..":,.'.p -.,-,q..1."i.,. :"" ,W%7 I,I"4, V;'.,44_.pk.'..A,-,.*..I .- 'k' --k-;,1,- ., 1"vq, I 11,1; 1, 'ei-A, 7'. li.l .';.;,V,"i.'. --.VT,.. ,.I0'-,1-.,..i..M-I.iw, ,,.ig,", ,,, .;, '44 I;". i " .- V4 " 13 I'V ..-,Y--,llll.,,;!..-wX -.";,,,..4,e, ., ."I..'1'1.1"I -,.,T.., .1115.'.l .,,,:K, 1A, --11, .-4.,i. .,.t I'll",V"'.4 ."t.-,-1.. ". ,... ',-,,.,,,,"..,,...--11 W -..,:,.;.,.,,`I.- .1""', .":.. .,"";."., 'i.11.'..I,,V... -iy -. "',,.1..::... ";: ,_. I.-...F.I._,..S .-,,--,,. :.,,Pz'A!",..-,.,-!..,*-; .-,---A-,;'^j..,3,,--P...-t,,,,'W,-34'-.X,l,f',"'.4!-;.`;L,-, 1, "A .G'11_-'-, ;l,M;_'f.'A..,.-L-- .V,..,. ,.,, .- ,^.WN.'.'_, .,j.. ..;. I W',K-A,-, .,.L-. 14", .,,,,, .I.-VII .,-,.r.i,.'.,,,,.t--".L., ,_ I" ._--.-.J'4..". -`,,.'-V4,4, NV..f,,.,."-W1T, 1.I 1.-,,.111"..:..." j-"5..,f.",. .- .',..v" -.'_, ,.,' it! ,,, .f -,a-N,.If.-"''; ,;, " I..".,IA, a ,.. ,4 I ,,_,r.k "e., . .Vrk 471."tL ,-.,ri -.1 "',,-:.:...4-'4",--_:.",,f"-i"_'j.,"__'.. ".-I,.,A ..., ...;...-_ --i",'_t._*4-.'r" .,_1 ".!.."_.._ .,wclo..4,-I,,"., ;11 .,.,,Fll.._-. .1, ,.' ,I#I ,.2 o: ".". .k4.4.__ .ffc&, -, -%, ',I, ,,:-", ..-,.1,", "-11 ,_--,05 11 ..lij It ..?,* *. 4i" ,-_.. ...'_ '.,-M-,.l -.l !1'4,.-f .,_,ik. ;%,L -,.:`kl,