DOCSLIB.ORG

Green Jobs Myths

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Green Jobs Myths UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS LAW AND ECONOMICS RESEARCH PAPER SERIES NO. LE09-001 GREEN JOBS MYTHS ANDREW P. MORRISS H. Ross and Helen Workman Professor of Law & Professor of Business University of Illinois [email protected] WILLIAM T. BOGART Dean of Academic Affairs and Professor of Economics York College of Pennsylvania [email protected] ANDREW DORCHAK Head of Reference and Foreign/International Law Specialist Case Western Reserve University School of Law [email protected] ROGER E. MEINERS John and Judy Goolsby Distinguished Professor of Economics and Law University of Texas-Arlington [email protected] This paper can be downloaded without charge from the Social Science Research Network Electronic Paper Collection: http://papers.ssrn.com/pape.tar?abstract_id= Page 2 Morriss, Bogart, Dorchak, & Meiners Green Jobs Myths Andrew P. Morriss,* William T. Bogart,** Andrew Dorchak,*** & Roger E. **** Meiners Abstract A rapidly growing literature promises that a massive program of government mandates, subsidies, and forced technological interventions will reward the nation with an economy brimming with “green jobs.” Not only will these jobs improve the environment, but they will be high paying, interesting, and provide collective rights. This literature is built on mythologies about economics, forecasting, and technology. Myth: Everyone understands what a “green job” is. Reality: No standard definition of a “green job” exists. Myth: Creating green jobs will boost productive employment. Reality: Green jobs estimates include huge numbers of clerical, bureaucratic, and administrative positions that do not produce goods and services for consumption. Myth: Green jobs forecasts are reliable. Reality: The green jobs studies made estimates using poor economic models based on dubious assumptions. Myth: Green jobs promote employment growth. Reality: By promoting more jobs instead of more productivity, the green jobs described in the literature encourage low-paying jobs in less desirable conditions. Economic growth cannot be ordered by Congress or by the United Nations. Government interference – such as restricting successful technologies in favor of speculative technologies favored by special interests – will generate stagnation. Myth: The world economy can be remade by reducing trade and relying on local production and reduced consumption without dramatically decreasing our standard of living. Reality: History shows that nations cannot produce everything their citizens need or * H. Ross & Helen Workman Professor of Law and Professor of Business, University of Illinois; Senior Scholar, Mercatus Center at George Mason University; & Senior Fellow, Property & Environment Research Center, Bozeman, Montana. A.B. Princeton University; J.D., M.Pub.Aff., University of Texas; Ph.D. (Economics) Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of the Institute for Energy Research, our respective institutions, and Terry Anderson and Bruce Yandle, who offered helpful comments. All errors are, of course, our own. ** Dean of Academic Affairs and Professor of Economics, York College of Pennsylvania; B.A., Rice University; A.M., Ph.D. (Economics) Princeton University. *** Head of Reference and Foreign/International Law Specialist, Case Western Reserve University School of Law; M.L.S. 1994, Kent State University; Honors B.A., 1988, Xavier University. **** John and Judy Goolsby Distinguished Professor of Economics and Law, University of Texas-Arlington; Senior Fellow, Property & Environment Research Center, Bozeman, Montana. B.A., Washington State University; M.A., University of Arizona; Ph.D. (Economics) Virginia Tech; J.D., University of Miami. Green Jobs Myths Page 3 desire. People and firms have talents that allow specialization that make goods and services ever more efficient and lower-cost, thereby enriching society. Myth: Government mandates are a substitute for free markets. Reality: Companies react more swiftly and efficiently to the demands of their customers and markets, than to cumbersome government mandates. Myth: Imposing technological progress by regulation is desirable. Reality: Some technologies preferred by the green jobs studies are not capable of efficiently reaching the scale necessary to meet today’s demands and could be counterproductive to environmental quality. In this Article, we survey the green jobs literature, analyze its assumptions, and show how the special interest groups promoting the idea of green jobs have embedded dubious assumptions and techniques within their analyses. Before undertaking efforts to restructure and possibly impoverish our society, careful analysis and informed public debate about these assumptions and prescriptions are necessary. Contents! I.! Envisioning a World of Green Jobs ...................................................................................... 10! II.! Defining “green” jobs ........................................................................................................... 14! A.! What counts as “green” .................................................................................................. 15! B.! What counts as a “job” ................................................................................................... 22! C.! Forecasting ..................................................................................................................... 24! 1.! Small base numbers .................................................................................................... 25! 2.! Huge growth rates ....................................................................................................... 26! 3.! Selective technological optimism ............................................................................... 29! 4.! Unreliable underlying statistics .................................................................................. 31! 5.! False precision masking large variations across estimates ......................................... 36! 6.! Summary: unreliable forecasts ................................................................................... 38! D.! The inappropriate use of input-output analysis .............................................................. 38! E.! Promoting inefficient use of labor .................................................................................. 43! F.! Assessing green job estimates ........................................................................................ 48! III.! Mistakes in economic analysis........................................................................................... 49! A.! Rejecting comparative advantage ................................................................................... 49! B.! Consumer surplus ........................................................................................................... 52! C.! Mandates vs. markets ..................................................................................................... 54! D.! Neglecting opportunity costs .......................................................................................... 59! E.! Ignoring incentive effects ............................................................................................... 61! 1.! Iron and Steel .............................................................................................................. 66! 2.! Aluminum ................................................................................................................... 67! 3.! Ammonia .................................................................................................................... 68! 4.! Pulp and Paper ............................................................................................................ 69! 5.! Appliances .................................................................................................................. 69! F.! Market hostility .............................................................................................................. 74! Page 4 Morriss, Bogart, Dorchak, & Meiners IV.! Ignoring technical literatures ............................................................................................. 75! A.! Mass transit .................................................................................................................... 75! B.! Biofuels. ......................................................................................................................... 79! C.! Electricity Generation .................................................................................................... 89! 1.! Wind power ................................................................................................................ 89! 2.! Solar power ................................................................................................................. 91! 3.! Nuclear power............................................................................................................. 93! V.! Conclusion ............................................................................................................................ 95! The solutions to environmental and economic problems, domestically and internationally, are often tied together. The assertion that “green jobs” can be created to improve environmental quality while reducing unemployment is behind an aggressive push for a “green economy” in the United States and elsewhere. For example, a recent report from
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Review of International Experience with Policies to Promote Wind Power Industry Development
    A Review of International Experience with Policies to Promote Wind Power Industry Development FINAL REPORT Prepared by: Joanna Lewis, Consultant to the Center for Resource Solutions Ryan Wiser, Consultant to the Center for Resource Solutions Prepared for: Energy Foundation China Sustainable Energy Program March 10, 2005 Table of Contents Executive Summary...................................................................................................................... 4 1. Introduction........................................................................................................................... 9 2. Strategies for Localization ................................................................................................. 11 2.1. Models for wind turbine manufacturing ........................................................................ 11 2.2. Models for technology acquisition: purchasing versus internal development............... 11 2.3. Incentives for technology transfers................................................................................ 12 2.4. Implications.................................................................................................................... 12 3. Potential Benefits of Localization...................................................................................... 14 3.1. Domestic economic development and employment ...................................................... 14 3.2. International exports.....................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Planning for Wind Energy
    Planning for Wind Energy Suzanne Rynne, AICP , Larry Flowers, Eric Lantz, and Erica Heller, AICP , Editors American Planning Association Planning Advisory Service Report Number 566 Planning for Wind Energy is the result of a collaborative part- search intern at APA; Kirstin Kuenzi is a research intern at nership among the American Planning Association (APA), APA; Joe MacDonald, aicp, was program development se- the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), the nior associate at APA; Ann F. Dillemuth, aicp, is a research American Wind Energy Association (AWEA), and Clarion associate and co-editor of PAS Memo at APA. Associates. Funding was provided by the U.S. Department The authors thank the many other individuals who con- of Energy under award number DE-EE0000717, as part of tributed to or supported this project, particularly the plan- the 20% Wind by 2030: Overcoming the Challenges funding ners, elected officials, and other stakeholders from case- opportunity. study communities who participated in interviews, shared The report was developed under the auspices of the Green documents and images, and reviewed drafts of the case Communities Research Center, one of APA’s National studies. Special thanks also goes to the project partners Centers for Planning. The Center engages in research, policy, who reviewed the entire report and provided thoughtful outreach, and education that advance green communities edits and comments, as well as the scoping symposium through planning. For more information, visit www.plan- participants who worked with APA and project partners to ning.org/nationalcenters/green/index.htm. APA’s National develop the outline for the report: James Andrews, utilities Centers for Planning conduct policy-relevant research and specialist at the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission; education involving community health, natural and man- Jennifer Banks, offshore wind and siting specialist at AWEA; made hazards, and green communities.
    [Show full text]
  • Of Ecological Modernisation?
    JOBS & ENVIRONMENT: THE ‘DOUBLE DIVIDEND’ OF ECOLOGICAL MODERNISATION? Kate Crowley School of Government, University of Tasmania Published as “Jobs & Environment: the Double Dividend of Ecological Modernisation” International Journal of Social Economics, Vol 26, No. 7/8/9, pp. 1013-1026. AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL NOTE Dr Kate Crowley is a lecturer in environmental policy and public administration in the School of Government, University of Tasmania; GPO Box 252-22, Hobart, Australia, 7001; Ph 61 3 62 262364 Fax 61 3 62 240973; [email protected] ABSTRACT This paper reviews the emergent literature on ecological modernisation and considers its theoretical utility in terms of assessing environmental employment opportunities in Australia. It explores the potential for ecologically modernist policy to offer a way beyond ‘jobs versus environment’ obstacles to greener employment. The future development of post industrial economies is said by ecological modernists to depend upon an ability to produce high value, high quality products with stringent enforcement standards. In these terms, environmental amenity becomes a superior good, and environmental protection not an economic burden, but an opportunity for enhanced growth and job creation (Weale, 1992). The employment impact of such claims is examined in the Australian context. KEYWORDS environment; employment; green jobs; green industry; ecological modernisation; Australia. INTRODUCTION There is a growing body of literature on ecological modernisation as an emergent concept in environmental policy analysis which has both theoretical and practical policy applications (Spaargaren & Mol, 1992, p. 334). Although it remains essentially contested (Boland, 1994, p. 140) this literature has immense utility, I argue, for environmental employment analysis. In an uncritical sense, ecological modernisation does seem to offer both economic promise and green employment creation prospects in Jacobs’s (1994) sense of a ‘double dividend’ below.
    [Show full text]
  • Ge Renewable Energy News
    Ge Renewable Energy News How dihedral is Barton when recriminative and round-table Shelden yipped some isoantigens? Yves remains deleterious: she reburies her authenticateevertor skite tooso convincingly. aslant? Substituent Byron somersault creamily while Tann always burgles his mallemucks attirings judicially, he His job creation, applications and additive manufacturing process the website in order to the wind farm in hillsdale county than energy news. Before other renewable energy news gathering as wind turbines. Mw version of renewable energy limited, located near future? GE Renewable Energy REVE News stop the wind sector in. GE annual report shows struggles and successes quantifies. The recent policy-flow that its US competitor GEhas been selected for. Additive is pushing for new york, and cooled down. GE Renewable Energy Latest Breaking News Pictures Videos and Special Reports from The Economic Times GE Renewable Energy Blogs Comments and. Missouri plant has occurred, the virus continues to determine the longest running republican senator in. GE Renewable Energy International Hydropower Association. The state by late january wind power grid businesses to putting our sites. Cookie and new nrc chair in the end, or dismiss a hub for ireland at factories and water challenges for? DOE taps GE Renewable Energy for 3-D printed wind turbine. It comes to Secondary Sources Company's Annual reports press Releases. The new offshore wind turbine Haliade-X unveiled in this wind energy news direct by GE in March 201 is 260 meters high from destination to blade tipsand its. GE Renewable Energy said Monday it was exempt the largest wind turbine rotor test rig of its rich in Wieringerwerf the.
    [Show full text]
  • LESER References
    LESER References Industries and Customers Projects OEMs Prequalifications Global Approvals The-Safety-Valve.com Content Company Facts & Figures Page Introduction to LESER | General Information 4 ■ Founded 1818 Company Facts & Figures 3 ■ Number of employees: more than 800 Product Range 6 ■ Net sales: > 100 Mio EUR Key Customer Benefits 10 ■ Production capacity: more than 150.000 SV / a Customer Requirements 12 ■ Installed based: > 2.000.000 SV ■ More than 5 Mio EUR investments in technology and processes every year Recognition in the Market 15 ■ Inventory in raw material and components: > 20 Mio EUR in the factory and subsidiaries Industries & Customers 15 a. Spotlight 16 b. Region: Americas 20 c. Region: Europe / Africa 26 d. Region: Germany 32 e. Region: Asia 36 Projects 44 Net sales per region Net sales per product group Strong presence in all regions PED and ASME-oriented product groups Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) 52 have equal weight Customer Approvals | Prequalifications 55 Other Compact America Oil & Gas 56 Performance High Efficiency Germany 4% Chemical 58 4% 12% Clean 6% Petrochemical 59 Service 20% Pharmaceutical and Food & Beverage 60 32% Modulate 9% Action Technical Gases 60 26% Asia Marine 60 24% 32% 61 Power 30% LNG / LPG 61 API High Performance Europe Other 61 Global Approvals 62 Global Approvals 62 2 3 Introduction Welcome to LESER With more than 800 employees, LESER is the largest manufacturer of safety valves in Europe and a leader in its market worldwide. LESER safety valves are used by leading companies in industries such as chemical, petro- chemical, industrial gases, oil and gas production, and machine building, as well as the food and pharmaceutical industry.
    [Show full text]
  • Measuring Green Jobs?
    TemaNord 2012:534 TemaNord Ved Stranden 18 DK-1061 Copenhagen K www.norden.org Measuring green jobs? An evaluation of definitions and statistics for green activities Measuring green jobs? An evaluation of definitions and statistics for green activities The report reviews the different initiatives aiming to measure aspects of “green” sectors, jobs and technologies. The report discusses whether the statistics collected under the present initia- tives aimed at measuring these aspects increase insights into the fundamental questions motivating the initiatives. An alternative framework is suggested, as it appears fundamentally impossible to make consistent frameworks for a division of the economy into “green” and “non-green” activities. The analysis has been carried out during the period September 2011 – March 2012 by Vista Analysis AS, Gaia Consulting Oy and University of Aarhus. Gaia Consulting Oy is responsible for the chapters 5.2., 5.3, 6.2, 6.3 and 7.2 only. The project was commissioned by the Working Group on Environment and Economy under the Nordic Council of Ministers. TemaNord 2012:534 ISBN 978-92-893-2370-3 http://dx.doi.org/10.6027/TN2012-534 TN2012534 omslag.indd 1 23-07-2012 07:27:21 Measuring green jobs? An evaluation of definitions and statistics for green activities Annegrete Bruvoll and Karin Ibenholt (ed.), Sanna Ahvenharju, Marika Bröckl, Louise Martinsen and Marianne Zandersen TemaNord 2012:534 Measuring green jobs? An evaluation of definitions and statistics for green activities Annegrete Bruvoll and Karin Ibenholt (ed.), Sanna Ahvenharju, Marika Bröckl, Louise Martinsen and Marianne Zandersen TemaNord 2012:534 ISBN 978-92-893-2370-3 http://dx.doi.org/10.6027/TN2012534 © Nordic Council of Ministers 2012 Cover photo: Photodisc; ImageSelect Print: Kailow Express ApS Copies: 260 Printed in Denmark This publication has been published with financial support by the Nordic Council of Ministers.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Wind Resource Assessment for the State of Wyoming
    WIND RESOURCE ASSESSMENT FOR THE STATE OF WYOMING Performed by Sriganesh Ananthanarayanan under the guidance of Dr. Jonathan Naughton, Professor, Department of Mechanical Engineering University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY 82071 1 Table of Contents LIST OF FIGURES ............................................................................................................ 2 LIST OF TABLES.............................................................................................................. 2 INTRODUCTION: ............................................................................................................. 3 ANALYSIS......................................................................................................................... 5 RESULTS ........................................................................................................................... 7 Wind resource reports....................................................................................................... 11 CONCLUSION:................................................................................................................ 11 FUTURE WORK:............................................................................................................. 12 REFERENCES ................................................................................................................. 13 APPENDIX 1: WIND ROSE FOR EACH MONTH FOR LARAMIE ........................... 14 APPENDIX 2: WIND RESOURCE ASSESSMENT FOR CHEYENNE....................... 17 APPENDIX
    [Show full text]
  • GE Wind Plant and Industry Overview Ronald J Brzezinski: Commercial Manager GE Energy September, 2009 2008 US Wind Industry Highlights
    United States Energy Association GLOBAL WORKSHOP ON GRID CONNECTED RENEWABLE ENERGY GE Wind Plant and Industry Overview Ronald J Brzezinski: Commercial Manager GE Energy September, 2009 2008 US Wind Industry Highlights •1.25 percent of US electricity in 2008 •Could be 20 percent by 2030 •Over 40% of new capacity installed (8,500MW) •$17 Billion invested in economy •USA surpassed Germany - most Wind Capacity •25,000MW total US installed in 35 States •85,000 people employed in US Wind Industry •Up from 50,000 people in 2007 Source: American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) 2 / USEA Presentation / September, 2009 Key to Industry Growth: Policy, Policy, Policy (or lack of Policy) Source: 3 / USEA Presentation / American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) September, 2009 The Past… Small industry trying to grow into mainstream Wind turbine generators required to go off-line if grid anomaly 4 / USEA Presentation / September, 2009 The Present… Moving to the mainstream Large global companies have entered wind industry Transitioning from wind turbines to wind plants Utilities understanding and Investing in wind FERC, NERC, ISOs creating requirements for Wind Units required to remain on-line if grid anomaly Making wind plants behave like conventional plants Stabilizing, Standardizing Technology 5 / USEA Presentation / September, 2009 The Future… Integrate generation portfolio mix Refine wind generation scheduling & forecasting (dispatch) Adapt regulatory mechanisms to accommodate Wind (for example, Renewable Energy Credits) Institutionalize education/training
    [Show full text]
  • General Electric Wind Energy Chooses Globalstar to Safeguard
    General Electric Wind Energy chooses Globalstar's SPOT Gen3 to Safeguard Workers in EMEA and Asia Highlights: • General Electric Wind Energy will equip its employees in Pakistan and Morocco with Globalstar’s SPOT Gen3 safety devices, followed by deployments in further new markets across Europe, Middle East and Africa • Following a rigorous selection process, SPOT Gen3 was chosen for satellite tracking, one-touch SOS capability, superior reach and reliability • SPOT system, including GEOS International Emergency Response Coordination Centre 24/7, performed flawlessly in drills with emergency services in Spain, UK and Pakistan Dublin, Ireland, November 30, 2016 – Globalstar Europe Satellite Services Ltd., a wholly owned subsidiary of Globalstar Inc. (NYSE MKT: GSAT) and a leader in satellite messaging and emergency notification technologies, today announced that its SPOT Gen3 safety device is being deployed by major international wind technology provider, General Electric, to track and protect GE Wind Energy (GEWE) workers as they install, operate and maintain onshore wind power installations in emerging markets across EMEA and Asia. Globalstar’s value added reseller, Crambo Wireless S.A., initially provided GEWE with over 70 SPOT Gen3 devices to safeguard crews working at wind power installations in Pakistan, Morocco, Saudi Arabia and Egypt, among other locations. As GEWE expands into new territories it will deploy SPOT Gen3 devices to protect its workers in Ghana, Kenya, and elsewhere in Africa, as well as Central Europe and the Balkans. By mid-2017, GEWE personnel working at approximately 70 wind farms in EMEA and Asia are expected to have enhanced safety thanks to SPOT. Any major construction project comes with operational hazards.
    [Show full text]
  • Wind Power Today
    Contents BUILDING A NEW ENERGY FUTURE .................................. 1 BOOSTING U.S. MANUFACTURING ................................... 5 ADVANCING LARGE WIND TURBINE TECHNOLOGY ........... 7 GROWING THE MARKET FOR DISTRIBUTED WIND .......... 12 ENHANCING WIND INTEGRATION ................................... 14 INCREASING WIND ENERGY DEPLOYMENT .................... 17 ENSURING LONG-TERM INDUSTRY GROWTH ................. 21 ii BUILDING A NEW ENERGY FUTURE We will harness the sun and the winds and the soil to fuel our cars and run our factories. — President Barack Obama, Inaugural Address, January 20, 2009 n 2008, wind energy enjoyed another record-breaking year of industry growth. By installing 8,358 megawatts (MW) of new Wind Energy Program Mission: The mission of DOE’s Wind Igeneration during the year, the U.S. wind energy industry took and Hydropower Technologies Program is to increase the the lead in global installed wind energy capacity with a total of development and deployment of reliable, affordable, and 25,170 MW. According to initial estimates, the new wind projects environmentally responsible wind and water power completed in 2008 account for about 40% of all new U.S. power- technologies in order to realize the benefits of domestic producing capacity added last year. The wind energy industry’s renewable energy production. rapid expansion in 2008 demonstrates the potential for wind energy to play a major role in supplying our nation with clean, inexhaustible, domestically produced energy while bolstering our nation’s economy. Protecting the Environment To explore the possibilities of increasing wind’s role in our national Achieving 20% wind by 2030 would also provide significant energy mix, government and industry representatives formed a environmental benefits in the form of avoided greenhouse gas collaborative to evaluate a scenario in which wind energy supplies emissions and water savings.
    [Show full text]
  • Creating an Environment for Growing Green Jobs
    CREATING AN ENVIRONMENT FOR GROWING GREEN JOBS: Community Colleges Shaping State and Local Energy Policies Policy changes at the state and local levels likely will be the strongest determinants of where green jobs will flourish. Right now, across the country, hundreds of cities and states are considering new renewable standards, building code changes, incentive packages for energy-related firms, and other measures that will drive demand for green industry workers with relevant and up-to-date skills. Community colleges can be a critical voice in advancing policies that create specific opportunities for students to access and complete programs in an evolving and promising green world. About AACC’s Green Action Plan Series This action plan series includes practical and actionable steps that colleges can take to not only prepare a skilled workforce, but also to become change agents in regional efforts to develop a green economy. About SEED The American Association of Community Colleges’ Sustainability Education and Economic Development (SEED) initiative aims to advance sustainability and green workforce development practices at community colleges. With more than 425 college members, SEED identifies and shares promising models and resources and builds the capacity of college leaders, faculty, and staff. This program is consistent with AACC’s commitment to access and completion as part of the national goal to increase the number of students who complete degrees, certificates, and other credentials with value in the work place. More information can be found at www.theseedcenter.org or by contacting [email protected]. AACC Green Action Plan Series – www.theseedcenteer.org 1 Acknowledgements The American Association of Community Colleges (AACC) is the primary advocacy organization for the nation’s community colleges.
    [Show full text]
  • Guaranteed Green Jobs: Sustainable Full Employment
    Working Paper No. 722 Guaranteed Green Jobs: Sustainable Full Employment by Antoine Godin* University of Pavia May 2012 *E-mail: [email protected]. I thank Marco Missaglia, Stephen Kinsella, and Codrina Rada, and the participants in the “17th Workshop on Alternative Economic Policy in Europe” for helpful conversations and comments. All errors remain mine. The Levy Economics Institute Working Paper Collection presents research in progress by Levy Institute scholars and conference participants. The purpose of the series is to disseminate ideas to and elicit comments from academics and professionals. Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, founded in 1986, is a nonprofit, nonpartisan, independently funded research organization devoted to public service. Through scholarship and economic research it generates viable, effective public policy responses to important economic problems that profoundly affect the quality of life in the United States and abroad. Levy Economics Institute P.O. Box 5000 Annandale-on-Hudson, NY 12504-5000 http://www.levyinstitute.org Copyright © Levy Economics Institute 2012 All rights reserved ISSN 1547-366X ABSTRACT In most economies, the potential of saving energy via insulation and more efficient uses of electricity is important. In order to reach the Kyoto Protocol objectives, it is urgent to develop policies that reduce the production of carbon dioxide in all sectors of the economy. This paper proposes an analysis of a green-jobs employer-of-last-resort (ELR) program based on a stock- flow consistent (SFC) model with three productive sectors (consumption, capital goods, and energy) and two household sectors (wage earners and capitalists). By increasing the energy efficiency of dwellings and public buildings, the green-jobs ELR sector implies a shift in consumption patterns from energy consumption toward consumption of goods.
    [Show full text]