DOCSLIB.ORG

Grand Jury to Get JFK Film Film JFK Get to Jury Grand

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Grand Jury to Get JFK Film Film JFK Get to Jury Grand Grand Jury to Get JFK Film SHAW RULING FRIDAY Ruth Paine said she is "not terribly keen" about coming Criminal Judge Edward A. Haggerty said today, after The film was sold by Zapruder to Life magazine. Gar- to New Orleans to testify before the grand jury. hearing oral arguments, that he will rule Friday on a bid rison previously asked that it be subpenaed from Time Inc. Mrs. Paine, a friend of Lee Harvey Oswald and his wife, to have the Kennedy assassination conspiracy trial of Clay in New York for viewing by the grand jury. Marina, was subpenaed yesterday to appear before the jury L. Shaw moved at least 100 miles from New Orleans. Alcock said today that he has been notified by Time April 18 and 19 in the assassination probe . The 55-year-old Shaw is charged with conspiracy to that the film will be sent here for delivery to the jury Thursday. murder the late President John F. Kennedy. His lawyers ASKED ABOUT a part of the subpena that alleges she say he cannot get a fair trial here because of the publicity THE ORIGINAL film never was shown to the Warren look Oswald's gun—which the Warren Commission says surrounding the Shaw case and other facets of District At- killed Kennedy—from New Orleans to Dallas, Mrs. Paine torney Jim Garrison's assassination probe. Commission, which used copies in its investigation of the president's death. said: "Sure, I carried all of Oswald's worldly possessions Garrison contends the original film will show that the MEANWHILE, ASSISTANT DA James L. Alcock said from New Orleans to Dallas in 1963. For all I know, the president was shot from the front; the commission said he today that a motion picture film of the Kennedy assassina- rifle was in there." tion taken by Abraham Zapruder will be turned over to was shot from the back. the Orleans Parish Grand Jury. On another front of the probe, in Irving, Tex., Mrs. (See PROBE—Page 6) prospective jurors, has been influenced. Wegmann said that one of the problems that will be en- countered if Shaw is tried Probe- here is getting a jury. Continued from Front Page "We will be here ad In- finitum . we will be pick- However, she maintained ing people off the streets," that she couldn't tell the jury he said: He noted that dial- anything that was not included lenging jurors for cause can in the Warren Report. have a prejudicial effect on During the oral arguments the defense case. on the Shaw change of venue WEGMANN SAID the courts motion before Judge Haggerty have ruled that a change of today, defense attorney Wil- venue ought to be available liam Wegmann argued that even though individually each the questioning of 80 prospec- juror cannot be challenegd tive jurors in court last week for cause if there are over- proved one thing: riding circumstances in the "THEY HAVE BEEN in- community that prevent a fair fluenced by the controversy trial. surrounding this case. There It was his contention that has been so much publicity such circumstances exist be- and controversy that these cause of the controversial and people are incapable of an- unusual nature of the entire swering the questions put to Garrison probe and the inter- them." est it has aroused. The jurors were asked On a second point, Weg- whether they could give Shaw mann insisted that Shaw is a fair trial and whether they due a change of venue be- had any opinions or impres- cause at least one witness the sions about the case. Most defense feels is necessary to testified they felt they could its case has refused to come give him an impartial hear- to New Orleans to testify, ing, but many admitted to professing fear. have some impressions about WHETHER the fear is jus- the case. tified or not, he said, the wit- WEGMANN CITED a num- ness will not come to New ber of cases in which the Orleans. "If I can get this courts have ruled that the de- witness to testify elsewhere," fendant did not receive a fair he said, "then the trial should trial because pretrial publicity be moved elsewhere." was not effectively curtailed. Alcock answered for the "And it certainly has not been state briefly, saying that he effectively curtailed in this feels that the ordinary per- case," Wegmann added. son simply is not as interest- Wegmann said that from ed in the case as the defense the first moment Clay Shaw contends and that the 80 mem- was arrested and charged bers of the jury panel ques- with conspiracy to murder the tioned proved his point. president, the case became a He said the state would .cause celebre. Like other have brought its own change cases which have been over- of venue motion if it believed turned because of too much a fair trial here for the state publicity, Wegmann said, the was impossible and would whole community has "be- have joined the defense in its come interested in the morbid motion if it believed that a details surrounding the case." fair trial for Shaw were im- AT ONE POINT Judge Hag- possible. gerty noted that "the pub- The state, he said, is spend- , licity runs both ways" and ing a lot of money on this Wegmann said, "That's just case and "wants it decided the point . the whole thing with finality." The state, he has become a publicity bat- said, does not want to con- ' tle." Wegmann said he was tribute in any way to the not contending that the pub- possibility of a reversal. licity has been more favor- Alcock contended that a fair able to one side than the trial for both the state and other, but simply that there Shaw can be had right here. has been an extreme amount Judge Haggerty said he will deliver a written judgment by of publicity and that the com- 10 munity as a whole, including a.m. Friday. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The President Has Been Shot Excerpt
    m1899_presidenthas_INT_FNL.indd 1 6/7/13 3:21 PM SCHOLASTIC PRESS | NEW YORK m1899_presidenthas_INT_FNL.indd 2 6/7/13 3:21 PM THE ASSASSINATION OF JOHN F. KENNEDY JAMES L. SWANSON m1899_presidenthas_INT_FNL.indd 3 6/7/13 3:21 PM Text copyright © 2013 by James L. Swanson All rights reserved. Published by Scholastic Press, an imprint of Scholastic Inc., Publishers since 1920. SCHOLASTIC, SCHOLASTIC PRESS, and associated logos are trademarks and/or registered trademarks of Scholastic Inc. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without written permission of the publisher. For information regarding permission, write to Scholastic Inc., Attention: Permissions Department, 557 Broadway, New York, NY 10012. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Swanson, James L., 1959– “The president has been shot!” : the assassination of John F. Kennedy/by James L. Swanson. — First edition. pages cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-545-49007-8 (hardcover :alk. paper) 1. Kennedy, John F. (John Fitzgerald), 1917–1963 — Assassination — Juvenile literature. I. Title. E842.9.S95 2013 973.922092 — dc23 2012041167 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 13 14 15 16 17 Printed in the U.S.A. 23 First edition, October 2013 The display type was set in Gotham. The text was set in Adobe Garamond. Book design by Phil Falco m1899_presidenthas_INT_FNL.indd 4 6/7/13 3:21 PM FOR ANDREA AND MY FATHER, LENNART m1899_presidenthas_INT_FNL.indd 5 6/7/13 3:21 PM TABLE OF CONTENTS m1899_presidenthas_INT_FNL.indd 6 6/7/13 3:21 PM BEGINNINGS – IX – • PART ONE • INTRODUCTION TO JOHN F.
    [Show full text]
  • Ruth Hyde Paine Papers on Marina Oswald RG5.109 FHL Staff
    Ruth Hyde Paine Papers on Marina Oswald RG5.109 FHL staff. Last updated on May 14, 2021. Friends Historical Library of Swarthmore College Ruth Hyde Paine Papers on Marina Oswald Table of Contents Summary Information....................................................................................................................................3 Biography/History..........................................................................................................................................4 Scope and Contents....................................................................................................................................... 5 Arrangement...................................................................................................................................................5 Administrative Information........................................................................................................................... 6 Related Materials........................................................................................................................................... 6 Controlled Access Headings..........................................................................................................................7 Collection Inventory...................................................................................................................................... 8 Ser. 1. Correspondence, 1963-1966.......................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Lee Harvey Oswald, Life-History, and the Truth of Crime
    Ghosts of the Disciplinary Machine: Lee Harvey Oswald, Life-History, and the Truth of Crime Jonathan Simon* It seems to me important, very important, to the record that we face the fact that this man was not only human but a rather ordinary one in many respects, and who appeared ordinary. If we think that this was a man such as we might never meet, a great aberration from the normal, someone who would stand out in a crowd as unusual, then we don't know this man, we have no means of recognizing such a person again in advance of a crime such as he committed. The important thing, I feel, and the only protection we have is to realize how human he was though he added to it this sudden and great violence beyond- Ruth Paine' I. INTRODUCTION: EARL WARREN'S HAUNTED HOUSE Thirty-four years ago, the President's Commission on the Assas- sination of President Kennedy, popularly known as the Warren Commission, published its famous report. The Commission's most * Professor of Law, University of Miami; Visiting Professor of Law, Yale Law School. I would like to thank the following for their comments on earlier drafts of this paper Anthony Alfieri, Kristin Bumiller, Marianne Constable, Rosemary J. Coombe, Thomas Dumm, John Hart Ely, Patrick Gudridge, Christine Harrington, Austin Sarat, Adam Simon, and especially Mark Weiner for exceptional editorial assistance. All errors of fact or judgment belong to the author. I would also like to thank the University of Miami School of Law for providing summer research support.
    [Show full text]
  • The Testirnony of Marina Oswald Before the Orleans Parish Grand,Olury
    The Testirnony of Marina Oswald Before the Orleans Parish Grand,olury BySteve Jones Over the years Marina Oswald has been an told, After some confusion as to the exact na- would continue to leave in the moming as if enigma to many JFK assassination research- ture ofthis connection,Assistant DA Andrew going to work and wouldn't retum home un- ers. She has been accusedof being a Soviet Sciambraasked, " In other words, you were til dinner time, or sometimesnot until late in agent,a pawn of U.S. intelligence,or simplya left with the distinct impressionthat shewas the evening. Was Oswald simply too embar- confused and fiightened young woman who in some way connected to the CIA?" "Yes," rassed to tell his wife that he had lost his iob was caught up in an overwhelming national Marina answered. and was spending his days looking for anorirer tragedy.Her Statementsregarding the assas- Marina testified that while living in Dallas one? Was he enjoying his newfound freedom sination have contradicted themselves at vari- she had an English tutor by the name of and having fun exploring the sights and ous times ald she has vacillated back and fonh George "Boja," clearly a transcription error for soundsof the Big Easy?If so, how did he sup- as to whether she believes her husband Lee George Bouhe. And to my knowledge, the fol- port his family with no visible source of in- was guilty or innocent of the assassinationof lowing is new information. Garrison tells come? Or was Oswald involved in undisclosed PresidenrKennedy. Her Warren Commission Marina that Bouhe's next door neighbor is intelligence acdvities? Remember that it was testimony has been closely scrutinized by none other than Jack Ruby.
    [Show full text]
  • Amending America Exhibition Resource Guide
    Special Exhibit – Amending America: The Bill of Rights Resource Guide Collections Items – Books – Apps – Websites – eBooks – Online Exhibits – Podcasts – YouTube Reading Room Library Catalog Collection Items Discover how events surrounding the assassination of President Kennedy relate to and help illustrate issues raised in the Bill of Rights. The Museum’s curatorial team has connected each amendment to primary source artifacts from the Museum’s collection, with the exception of Amendments 3 and 9. Follow the links to see the object in detail and learn more. First Amendment - Freedom of Religion, Speech, and the Press Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, or abridging the freedom of speech or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble and to petition the government for a redress of grievances. Anti-Kennedy ad by the American Fact-Finding Committee http://emuseum.jfk.org/view/objects/asitem/items@:27620 This full-page ad titled "Welcome Mr. Kennedy” ran in The Dallas Morning News on the morning of Friday, November 22, 1963. Instead of welcoming the president, however, the ad asks a series of questions illustrating the authors’ disagreement with many of President Kennedy’s words and actions. At the beginning of the ad the authors refer to the first amendment, claiming their right to “address their grievances” and to question, criticize and disagree with their president. The publication of this unwelcoming and accusatory ad in a prominent city newspaper the day the president was to visit Dallas is a clear demonstration of the exercise of freedom of speech.
    [Show full text]
  • Warren Commission, Volume XVII: Contents
    Contents Commission Exhibit No . Page 392 . 1-22 Medical reports from doctors at Parkland Hospital, Dallas, Tex., concerning treatment of President Kennedy at that hospital on November 22, 1963. 35)3 . 23-24 Coat worn by President Kennedy at time of assassination. 394 . 2c5-26 Shirt worn by President Kennedy at time of assassination. 39:~ . 27 Tie worn by President. Kennedy at time of assassination. 396. 28 Frame from the Zapruder film depicting motorcade shortly before first bullet struck President Kennedy. 397 . 29-48 Comdr. James J. Humes' handwritten autopsy report on President Kennedy and certificates regarding disposition of working papers and preliminary drafts of the autopsy report. 398 . ., . 49 Frame from the Zapruder film depicting motorcade immediately after first. bullet struck President Kennedy. 399. 49 Bullet found on stretcher at Parkland Memorial Hospital, Dallas, Tex. 400 . 50 Chart showing conclusions of Lt. Col. Pierre A. Finck on perforat- ing missile «'ound on human skull. 401 . 51-62 Calendar used by Ruth Paine as a diary and to record appointments . 402. 63-79 Address book of Ruth Paine. 403 . 80 Diagram of the ground layout of the premises at 4907 Magazine Street in New Orleans, drawn by Ruth Paine. 404 . 81 Note from Marina Oswald to Ruth Paine. dated 'March 4.1963. 404-A . 81 Envelope in which Commission Exhibit No. 404 was transmitted. 405 . 82-83 Draft of undated note from Ruth Paine to Marina Oswald . 406 84-85 Draft of a letter from Ruth Paine to Marina Oswald, dated March 26, 1963. 407 . 86-87 Undated note from Marina Oswald to Michael and Ruth Paine.
    [Show full text]
  • The Rambler Man
    THE RAMBLER MAN One wouldn't consider it much of an obituary. A life reduced to eleven paragraphs in The Dallas Morning News. The commentary is not remarkable for a person of the prominence of ex-deputy sheriff Roger Craig. Not for the employee the Dallas County sheriff's office proclaimed "Man of the Year" in 1960. Roger Craig's popularity grew among Kennedy assassination investigators when he maintained he witnessed an event involving a Nash Rambler station wagon in Dealey Plaza on November 22, 1963. He spoke freely about the incident, disputed details of the assassination with superior officers, lost his job, aided in Jim Garrison's probe of Clay Shaw, became the friend of several researchers' and died by his own hand on May 15, 1975. Sadly, Craig's father discovered the body in a back bedroom of the small house on Luna Road in Dallas, this a few minutes after the old man had returned from mowing his lawn. There was a note. The physical and mental anguish resulting from a car wreck in 1973 and a shotgun wound to the shoulder sustained in 1974 was too much. Roger was sorry for what he had to do but he just "couldn't stand the pain." In the quiet of the Dallas Public Library I reviewed the eighteen year old obituary. I remembered the story of Craig's sighting of the Nash Rambler station wagon in front of the Texas School Book Depository on November 22nd. His account became important when a claim arose that Marina Oswald's friend and confidant, Ruth Paine, owned a similar vehicle.
    [Show full text]
  • Mrs. Tippit Marguerite Oswald Ruth Paine Jack Ruby Dr. Malcolm Perry Dr
    Story on assassination anniversary, 1964, by Sid. Moody Abraham Zapruder Marina Oswald Amos Lee Euins Roy Truly A.C. Johnson Warrn Reynolds Mrs. Tippit Marguerite Oswald Ruth Paine Jack Ruby Dr. Malcolm Perry Dr. Charles Carrico Father Oscar Huber Sgt. Patrick Dean . Gov. John B. Connally 15 Nov. 1964 (advance)) 14 Nov. 1964 1105 PES A143 (AC YS AND RADIO OUT ADVANCE FOR Ai S SUNDAY NOV. 15 --NOTE DATE—FROM AP NEWSFEATURES DALLAS pLUS, YlAi-,1 APN PRINT SUBSCR7 7 s WILL BEmAILED ILL L'S EDITGRIS NOT:---THE SHOTS THAT KILLED JOHN FITzGERALD KENNEDY -CHANGED A WORLD FOR MANY_OTHERS, TOO; TWO i:IDOWS, GRIEVE, ANOTHER HAS 17"C.UND A NEW LIFE; A MOTHER RAGES AT FAT:1.A MILER PLAYS DOMINOES /. 0ICES, A SALESEAN LIVES IN 7EAR1 A WOAN ZONDERS...ONE YEAR HAS PASSED, BUT THAT TERRIBLE DAY IS NOT YET OVER. , .,1::C.17ZATU:-..IfS 'WRITER (ADVAN CE) DALLAS, NOV..14 (AP) -THE SORROWFUL YEAR HAS PASSE AND THE- TORCADE. HAS TURNED TI:= =IN:n AND VANISHED; INTO THE SHADES OF HISTORY. 'LIE SHOTS THE HEART. THE YELLOT; LIG= OF THE CLOON SIGN BUILDING ARE WINKING ANOTHER TIME NOW, BUT.FOR SOME THE HOUR IS SIGNALS IS STILL 12:30 NOVEMBER 22, 13.63—THE MOMENT THEIR SEPARATE LIVES COLLIDED AT THAT FATED CROSSROADS. THEIR. LIVES HAVE GONE.ON, :UT THEY THE SA::E. LEE HARVEY OSWALD SAM TO THAT. NOT THE FOR THE CA ERA HOEBYIST-WHO MUST STEEL HIMSELF TO LOO'S THROUGH THE EYE OF A ZOOM LENS WHERE ONCE HE SAW SUDDEN BLOOD, NOT FOR THE WIDOW MISTY WITHGRIEF AT THE SIGHT OF THE FAMILY STATION WAGON IN THE DRIVEWAY--EMPTY.
    [Show full text]
  • Ruth Paine, 4-18-68, Orleans Parish Grand Jury
    ORLEANS PARISH GRAND JURY APRIL 18, 1968 SPECIAL INVESTIGATION PRESENT: MR. JIM GARRISON, DISTRICT ATTORNEY, MESSRS.. JAMES ALCOCK, ANDREW SCIAMBRA, ALVIN OSER AND NUMA BERTEL, ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEYS, and THE ORLEA& PARISH GRAND JURY MRS. RUTH HYDE PAINE Reported by: Maureen B. Thiel Secretary Orleans Parish Grand Jury -: - i MRS. RUTH HYDE PAINE, witness herein, after being duly sworn by the Foreman of the Orleans Parish Grand Jury J was questioned and answered as follows: P MR. ALCOCK: (Mrs. Paine requested permission to tape her answers, which permission was denied by Mr. Alcock. Mrs. Paine did not understand the secrecy of the Grand Jury, this was explained to her, and upon her request Mr. Alcock permitted the word 'affirm' to replace the : word 'swear' in the oath.) Q* Please.state,your name for the record. A. Ruth Hyde Paine. Q* I am going to advise you of your Constitutional rights. You do not have an attorney? ‘r. A. No. You know that anything you say here could be used against you in a court of law, however under the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of Louisiana, you have a right to refuse to answer any question that you feel will incriminate you or tend to incriminate you, in the commission of any crime. And if you feel like a question like that is asked and pu would like a judicial ruling on it whether or not you have to answer, all you have to do is say I refuse to answer on the ground that said answer may tend to incriminate me.
    [Show full text]
  • HSCA Volume XII: George De Mohrenschildt
    GEORGE DE MOHRENSCHILDT Staff Report of the Select Committee on Assassinations U.S. House of Representatives Ninety-fifth Congress Second Session March 1979 (47) CONTENTS Paragraph Foreword ________________________________________________________________ (1) 1. De Mohrenschildt's background__________________________________________ (1) II. Allegations of de Mohrenachildt Nazi activity____________________________ (10) III. Knowledge of Oswald's possession of the rifle______________________________ (19) IV. Allegations of de Mohrenachildt intelligence connections____________________ (29) V. De Mohrenschildt activities in Haiti_____________________________________ (37) VI. De Mohrenachildt military connections__________________________________ (80) Page Appendix : Manuscript by George de Mohrenschildt, "I am a Patsy! I am a Patsy!"-- 69 (48) FOREWORD (1) The Warren Commission concluded that Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone in the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, that he was not tied to any intelligence agency, and that none of his associates were tied to the assassination. Nevertheless, speculation continued to center about one of Oswald's associations : George de Mohrenschildt and de Mohrenschildt's background. The Warren Com- mission concluded about de -Mohrenschildt The Commission's investigation has developed no signs of subversive or disloyal conduct on the part of either of the de Mohrenschildts. Neither the FBI, CIA, nor any other wit- ness contacted by the Commission has provided any informa- tion linking the, de Mohrenschildts to subversive or extremist organizations. Nor has there been any evidence linking them in any way with the assassination of President Kennedy. (1) (2) Despite this disclaimer of any subversive or disloyal activity on the part of de Mohrenschildt by the Warren Commission, de Dfohrenschildt was rumored to have had ties with the intelligence communities of several countries.
    [Show full text]
  • Ruth Paine: Social Activist Or Gontra Support Networker? Ty Carof Eewett, Bcrbar.Isnlo[Lca E Stene.Tonea
    Ruth Paine: Social Activist or Gontra Support Networker? ty Carof Eewett, Bcrbar.Isnlo[lca e Stene.tonea Committee claim that no effort was ever form of a donation to CORE, for the four made to coordinate the correspondence of black school girls who had been killed in a persons participating in the pen-pal activ- church bombing just three days before.e ity, nor were any records made of persons More interesting, however, is an FBI who took pan in this program, or with whom document which chronicles Ruth's one- they corresponded.a This reflects a strange woman crusade to advanceracial integra- lack ofprocedure for an organization whose don in Dallas,Texas,after the assassination. ftqffimotivate her to shelter Marina Oswald,t How- main goal is to make personal, and presum- According to a Mr. Smith, the Regional Di- eve4,many researchershave suggested that ably lasting contact with Soviet youth. Other rector for the Federal Housing Administra- Ruth's activism and altruism are grourded gods of the East-West Contact Cornmittee don, he was telephonically contacted at least in a role as informalt, casud or otherwise, were to encouragestudents to "prepare them- three times by a Mrs. Ruth Paine who, for some aspect of US intelligence. The fol- selvesd[ough studyofliterature, modem his- "asked him for the identities of Negro lowing is arr overview of Ruth's political ac- tory economics and Russian language for families who might be interested in buy- tivities gleaned fiom FBI documents, grand eventual contact ing housing in jury testimony and first-hand reports.
    [Show full text]
  • The Many Mysteries of Lee Harvey Oswald
    Digital Commons @ Georgia Law Popular Media Faculty Scholarship 12-24-2014 The aM ny Mysteries of Lee Harvey Oswald Donald E. Wilkes Jr. University of Georgia School of Law, [email protected] Repository Citation Wilkes, Donald E. Jr., "The aM ny Mysteries of Lee Harvey Oswald" (2014). Popular Media. 203. https://digitalcommons.law.uga.edu/fac_pm/203 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty Scholarship at Digital Commons @ Georgia Law. It has been accepted for inclusion in Popular Media by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Georgia Law. Please share how you have benefited from this access For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Many Mysteries of Lee Harvey Oswald By Donald E. Wilkes, Jr. Photo Credit: U.S. House of Representatives Select Committee on Assassinations Lee Harvey Oswald as a Marine. Oswald is the most complicated individual ever to be charged in a major political assassination case in the United States.––Philip H. Melanson, Spy Saga: Lee Harvey Oswald and U.S. Intelligence (1990). President Lyndon B. Johnson famously remarked that Lee Harvey Oswald, the 24-year-old ex- Marine accused of assassinating Johnson’s predecessor, John F. Kennedy, in Dallas, TX, on Nov. 22, 1963, “was quite a mysterious fellow.” Johnson was right. Even now, over 50 years since Oswald was murdered under suspicious circumstances while in Dallas police custody on live, nationwide television, mysteries continue to abound with respect to the full truth about his political beliefs and activities, his military service, his defection to the USSR, his stays in Ft.
    [Show full text]