DOCSLIB.ORG

Browne and the Department of Defence Re: Bell DHAAT 12 (3 October 2019)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Browne and the Department of Defence Re: Bell DHAAT 12 (3 October 2019) Browne and the Department of Defence re: Bell DHAAT 12 (3 October 2019) File Number 2018/019 Re Mr Neville Browne Applicant And Department of Defence Respondent Tribunal Mr Mark Sullivan AO (Presiding Member) Mr David Ashley AM Ms Jane Schwager AO Hearing Dates 8 July 2019 DECISION On 3 October 2019 the Tribunal decided to recommend to the Minister that the decision of the Chief of Army, Lieutenant General David Morrison AO of 5 May 2015, that no further action be taken to recognise Private Alec Bell regarding his actions as a platoon medic with the 7th Battalion, the Royal Australian Regiment during the Vietnam War, be affirmed. CATCHWORDS DEFENCE HONOUR – Medal for Gallantry – Vietnam - service as a medic –adequacy of training – available evidence LEGISLATION Defence Act 1903 – Part VIIIC – Sections 110T, 110VB (1) Defence Regulation 2016, Section 35. Commonwealth of Australia Gazette No S25 Letters Patent and Regulations for the Australian Gallantry Decorations - dated 4 February 1991. REASONS FOR DECISION Introduction 1. On 28 June 2011, Mr Neville Browne lodged a submission to the Defence Honours and Awards Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) Inquiry into unresolved recognition for past acts of naval and military gallantry and valour, (the Valour Inquiry).1 In his submission, Mr Browne sought recognition, by way of a ‘posthumous bravery award’ for Private Alec Bell, who died of wounds while serving with the 7th Battalion, the Royal Australian Regiment (7 RAR) in Vietnam on 29 January 1968. Mr Browne provided a further submission dated 11 April 2013, and further material dated 27 March 2015. 2. Following the Valour Inquiry, Mr Browne’s submissions were provided to the Chief of Army for consideration. A ‘desk-top’ review was then conducted by Army with the purpose of a recommendation or a course of action. The Chief of Army wrote to Mr Browne on 5 May 2015, stating: ‘Army could not locate any evidence that Private Bell’s actions were not appropriately considered, or that any recommendation was obstructed or unfairly treated in any way. Therefore in the absence of a failure in due process or new authoritative and compelling evidence, Army recommended to the Parliamentary Secretary (for Defence) that no further action be taken to recognise Private Bell. The Parliamentary Secretary has agreed to this recommendation.’ 2 3. On 10 March 2018, Mr Browne applied to the Tribunal for a review of this decision, seeking that Private Bell be posthumously awarded the Medal for Gallantry (MG).3 4. Mr Browne stated in his application for review to the Tribunal that he has based his application ‘on a number of matters’. These matters were: ‘New evidence reveals acts of gallantry by Alec Bell on several occasions’; ‘An act of malfeasance by the Commander 7 RAR in Unit Routine Orders number 239 April 1967 which precluded accurate records being maintained’; and ‘For reasons unknown the number of awards for gallantry to National Servicemen who served in Vietnam is very small for the number of men who served. Plus there are items on statistics that may be of interest to the Tribunal’.4 5. In accordance with the Tribunal’s Procedural Rules, on 29 March 2018, the Chair of the Tribunal, wrote to the Secretary of the Department of Defence seeking a report which 1 Valour Inquiry Submission No. 88, Mr Neville Browne, 28 June 2011. 2 Letter, OCA/OUT/2015/R21045046, Chief of Army to Mr Browne dated 5 May 2015. 3 Application for Review of Decision, Mr Browne to the Tribunal, 10 March 2018. 4 Letter, Mr Neville Browne to the Tribunal, 10 March 2018. 2 refers to the evidence under the Department’s control that is relevant to the application for review.5 6. On 28 June 2018, Defence provided a copy of its report to the Tribunal.6 In its report Defence advised that a merits review of this matter would be undertaken by the Defence Historical Honours Review Board (HHRB).7 7. On 29 June 2018, the Tribunal provided a copy of the Defence Report to Mr Browne and offered him the opportunity for comment.8 8. On 21 August 2018, Mr Browne responded to the Defence Report providing his comments.9 9. After meeting on 31 August 2018 the HHRB, in relation to this matter: ‘agreed that although Private Bell’s actions could be considered courageous, he was doing his job as was expected of a medic at that time. His actions were highly professional, but not of such merit as to deserve retrospective recognition. The HHRB formed the view that the original decision by the then Chief of Army in 2015 to not support retrospectively awarding Private Bell with a Medal for Gallantry, or other honours recognition, should stand’. 10. The Directorate of Honours and Awards of the Department of Defence wrote to Mr Browne on 2 November 2018 advising him of the HHRB’s conclusion. Tribunal Jurisdiction 11. Pursuant to Section 110VB(1) of the Defence Act 1903 (the Defence Act) the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review a reviewable decision relating to a defence honour if an application is properly made to the Tribunal. The term reviewable decision is defined in Section 110V(1) and includes a decision made by a person within the Department of Defence or the Defence Force, to refuse to recommend a person for a defence honour, in response to an application. 12. Section 35 of the Defence Regulation 2016 lists the defence honours reviewable within the Tribunal’s jurisdiction. Included in the defence honours listed in Section 35 is the MG. The Tribunal considered that the Chief of Army’s decision of 5 May 2015 to not recommend Private Bell for the MG in response to Mr Browne’s application constitutes a reviewable decision. Therefore, the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review this matter. 13. The role of the Tribunal is to determine the correct or preferable decision in relation to the application having regard to the applicable law and the relevant facts. In accordance with Section 110VB(1) of the Defence Act, as the matter under review is a defence honour, the Tribunal does not have the power to affirm or set aside the decision but may 5 Letter, DHAAT OUT/2018/126 to the Secretary, dated 29 March 2018. 6 Letter, DGPERS-A/OUT/2018/R34875700 Director General Personnel-Army to the Tribunal, 28 June 2018. 7 Ibid. 8 Letter, DHAAT/OUT/2018/444, to Mr Browne, 29 June 2018. 9 Letter, Mr Browne to the Tribunal, 21 August 2018. 3 make recommendations regarding the decision to the Minister. Under Section 110VB of the Defence Act, the Tribunal must conduct a merits review of a reviewable decision where an application for review has been properly made. Private Bell’s service 14. On 13 July 1966, Alec Ernest James Bell, a 20 year old postal worker from East Victoria Park in Western Australia, was enlisted for two years of national service with the Regular Army Supplement (RAS (NS)). 15. As part of the Third National Service intake he was posted to Alpha Company, 2nd Recruit Training Battalion, at Puckapunyal in Victoria to undertake recruit training. Upon graduation in September 1966, Private Bell was posted to the Infantry Corps Wing of the 3rd Training Battalion at Singleton in NSW where he undertook advanced infantry training. 16. According to his service record, Private Bell was transferred back to Puckapunyal in December 1966 as a rifleman to join the newly-raised 7 RAR. The battalion had just completed the 6th Australian Task Force led Exercise Barra Winga, a final shake-down exercise in preparation for deployment to Vietnam. This one-week intensive battle preparation exercise was held at the Shoalwater Bay training area in Queensland. The purpose of the exercise was to test the Battalion and supporting units in tactics employed by the Viet Cong. Private Bell did not take part in this training and it would appear he did not receive any other battle preparation training.10 17. Although posted to the battalion as a rifleman, Private Bell was also required to perform the duties of platoon medic. In order to do this work he undertook stretcher bearer/medic training which involved subjects on health and basic first aid. 18. On 8 April 1967, Private Bell embarked for Vietnam in HMAS Sydney, disembarking at Vung Tau twelve days later. 19. Private Bell was the platoon medic of 2 Platoon, A Company, 7 RAR. On 29 January 1968, after serving in Vietnam in a number of operations, he was mortally wounded in action during Operation COBURG. Mr Browne’s first submission to the Valour Inquiry was concerned with Private Bell’s service in this operation. The evidence provided by Mr Browne regarding Private Bell was a quote from the book Conscripts and Regulars, with the Seventh Battalion in Vietnam, 11 which stated, ‘When Sergeant (Thomas) Bourke was asked to describe the bravest act he saw in Vietnam he wrote: ‘Private Dinga Bell was platoon medic on the late afternoon of 29th January 1968. In the first few moments the Platoon Commander 2LT O’Brien, and all the NCO’s were wounded including Private Bell who had received a direct hit from a rocket. Even though shockingly wounded Private Bell tried to get to the other wounded. When he could not move he gave orders to another soldier as to how to help them. Even when we finally got him onto the Dustoff stretcher Private Bell was still giving advice as to the care of the other 10 Army Research Report into Request for Review of Category 3 Public Submission 088 – 5714453 Alec Ernest James Bell, R34781467, 27 June 2018.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 3Rd Battalion Royal Australian Regiment
    3rd Battalion Royal Australian Regiment In 1945 Australia sent three units to Japan as part of the British Commonwealth Occupation Force (BCOF). Originally known as the 65th, 66th and 67th Infantry Battalions, they were raised from Australian Divisions stationed in New Guinea at the end of the Second World War. On 23 November 1948, the battalions were renamed the First, Second and Third Battalions, The Australian Regiment, respectively. The prefix “Royal” was granted by King George VI on 31 March 1949. 3RAR was stationed at Woodside in South Australia when it was committed to the Vietnam War. It arrived in South Vietnam throughout December, 1967. Its arrival brought the 1st Australian Task Force (1ATF) up to three-battalion strength. On 29 January, C Company was placed under the command of 7RAR for Operation Coburg (24 January – 1 March 1968). The operation was carried out on the Bien Hoa–Long Khanh border. C Company rejoined 3RAR on February 10, when the battalion relieved 7RAR. 3RAR was joined by W1 Company, Royal New Zealand Infantry Regiment (RNZIR), from 2RAR for the remainder of the operation. It returned to Nui Dat on 1 March. 3RAR next operated outside of Phuoc Tuy during Operation Toan Thang (21 April – 7 June). Toan Thang aimed to block the communist withdrawal following the Tet Offensive. 3RAR was stationed on the Bien Hoa–Bien Nuong border. On 13 May it occupied Fire Support Base Coogee, before moving 5 kilometres north on 24 May to establish Fire Support Base Balmoral. The first attack on Balmoral occurred on 26 May.
    [Show full text]
  • Infantryman April 2017 from the COMMAND POST Near-Future Sale of Clubrooms Averted Have Been Holding Off in Advising Our Membership in the Money
    INFANTRYMAN The Journal of the RAR Association SA April 2017 Keeping the Spirit Alive 3 RAR GROUP & VETERANS VISIT KOREA: From Major Simon Hawkins, Assistant Defence Attaché to Australian Embassy in Seoul: “The trek up the hill with the 3 RAR boys and Korean Army team was also a great experience. We were able to see a good number of the A Company and C Company positions. The guys really enjoyed it. We then played sport with the local Korean Army Recon Unit and stayed overnight on their base before doing some infantry minor tactics training with them the next day. A very worthwhile experience. Here is a photo of the team up on the hill at Gapyeong”. Major Hawkins is in the front row on the left of the unit sign. More page 9. ‘Falling through the Cracks’– A Proposal to Prevent it he RARA has been involved in many discussions __________________________ Ton various committees through the Prime Minister’s Advisory Council (PMAC), the Ex- Service Organisations The proposal is that everyone separating from the Round table (ESORT), DVA’s other consultative forums, ADF is either: State Veterans’ Advisory Councils, with other ESOs (1) provided with a white/silver DVA card which through the Alliance of Defence Service Organisations covers all non-liability mental health issues and (ADSO) and with the serving ADF, in particular serving substance abuse or members of the RAR, about the current separation/ (2) issued with a normal Medicare Card (which transition process and its problems and complexities. everyone is going to need anyway) with a clear The individual who discharges on medical grounds and identifier on that card that the individual is an ex- who is already a DVA client is by all reports well catered member of the ADF.
    [Show full text]
  • Don't Miss the Boat
    HOLDFASTAUGUST 2016 - Number 29 www.tunnelrats.com.au OffICIal NEWslEttER of thE VIETNAM TUNNNEL Rats AssoCIatION INC. DON’T MISS THE BOAT Last chance to get on board for the 50th Anniversary Tunnel Rats Tour to Vietnam, November 3rd to 11th 2016. Full details and booking form on pages 22 to 29 NOSTALGIA PAGES 2 The terrible toll on 1 Troop’s Tunnel Rats Nostalgia Pages Pages of great pics from the past to amaze and amuse. Photo contribitions welcome. Send your favourite Vietnam A Squadron Honour Roll was in place at 1FD SQN HQ at Nui Dat, but the pics (with descriptions, names and ap- Tunnel Rats of 1 Troop respectfully erected an Honour Roll (above) in prox dates) to Jim Marett 43 Heyington their recreation hut to specifically honour the men from their Troop killed Place Toorak Vic 3142 or by email to: in action in Vietnam. The list of 18 names reveals how 1 Troop alone suf- [email protected] fered 50% of the total of 36 Tunnel Rats KIA in Vietnam. The initial Troop of Tunnel Rats in Vietnam in 1965/66 was 3FD TP under CAPT Sandy MacGregor which suffered one KIA in their 12 month tour. For the rest of the War there were three Troops of Tunnel Rats in country at the one time HOLDFASTAUGUST 2016 - Number 29 www.tunnelrats.com.au OFFICIAL NEWSLETTER OF THE VIETNAM TUNNNEL RATS ASSOCIAT ION INC. (1 Troop, 2 Troop and 3 Troop) and they suffered 35 men KIA. 18 of these KIA were from 1 Troop and the remaining 17 were shared between 2 Troop and 3 Troop.
    [Show full text]
  • Australian War Memorial Annual Report 2006–2007 Australian War Memorial Annual Report 2006–2007
    AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL ANNUAL REPORT 2006–2007 AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL ANNUAL REPORT 2006–2007 The Hon. John Howard MP, Prime Minister of Australia, in the Courtyard Gallery on Remembrance Day. Annual report for the year ended 30 June 2007, together with the financial statements and the report of the Auditor-General. Images produced courtesy of the Australian War Memorial, Canberra Cover: Children in the Vietnam environment in the Discovery Zone Child using the radar in the Cold War environment in the Discovery Zone Air show during the Australian War Memorial Open Day Firing demonstration during Australian War Memorial Open Day Children in the Vietnam environment in the Discovery Zone Big Things on Display, part of the Salute to Vietnam Veterans Weekend Back cover: Will Longstaff, Menin Gate at midnight,1927 (AWM ART09807) Stella Bowen, Bomber crew 1944 (AWM ART26265) Australian War Memorial Parade Ground William Dargie, Group of VADs, 1942 (AWM ART22349) Wallace Anderson and Louis McCubbin, Lone Pine, diorama, 1924–27 (AWM ART41017) Copyright © Australian War Memorial 2007 ISSN 1441 4198 This work is copyright. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced, copied, scanned, stored in a retrieval system, recorded, or transmitted in any form or by any means without the prior written permission of the publisher. Australian War Memorial GPO Box 345 Canberra, ACT 2601 Australia www.awm.gov.au iii AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL ANNUAL REPORT 2006–2007 iv AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL ANNUAL REPORT 2006–2007 INTRODUCTION TO THE REPORT The Annual Report of the Australian War Memorial for the year ended 30 June 2007 follows the format for an Annual Report for a Commonwealth Authority in accordance with the Commonwealth Authorities and Companies (CAC) (Report of Operations) Orders 2005 under the CAC Act 1997.
    [Show full text]
  • RUSI of NSW Article
    Jump TO Article The article on the pages below is reprinted by permission from United Service (the journal of the Royal United Services Institute of New South Wales), which seeks to inform the defence and security debate in Australia and to bring an Australian perspective to that debate internationally. The Royal United Services Institute of New South Wales (RUSI NSW) has been promoting informed debate on defence and security issues since 1888. To receive quarterly copies of United Service and to obtain other significant benefits of RUSI NSW membership, please see our online Membership page: www.rusinsw.org.au/Membership Jump TO Article BOOK REVIEW All day long the noise of battle: an Australian attack in Vietnam by Gerard Windsor Pier 9 Murdoch Books: Millers Point, NSW; 2011; 254 pp.; ISBN: 978 1 74196 918 4; RRP $29.95 (paperback) This book is about the action of C Company, 7th artillery and air superiority. Battalion, Royal Australian Regiment (7 RAR), against a To add to the confusion there were anecdotes around bunker system while on Fire Support Base (FSB) after Coburg that, at one stage, every company in the protection on Operation Coburg during the Tet Offensive two deployed battalions of the Task Force was in contact in February 1968. at the same time in quite disparate locations. While that The author, an experienced writer with no military is hard to verify, I do know that, in the period immediately background, became interested in the battle after a before 5 February, the 7 RAR command radio net was so throw-away line by Major General Mike O’Brien frantic that some contacts were reported through the suggesting that a school chum of the author’s, Mark administration net.
    [Show full text]
  • Military History Anniversaries 16 Thru 31 January
    Military History Anniversaries 16 thru 31 January Events in History over the next 15 day period that had U.S. military involvement or impacted in some way on U.S military operations or American interests JAN 16 1776 – Amrican Revolutionary War: African-American Soldiers » It was an uncomfortable fact for many in the colonies that at the same time they were fighting the British for their liberty and freedom they were depriving slaves of that same opportunity. African-American soldiers, in fact, had participated in major Revolutionary War battles from its very start: around 5% of American forces at the battle of Bunker Hill were black. New England units were completely integrated with soldiers receiving the same pay regardless of color. Still, fears of a rebellion of armed slaves tempered official American recognition of the contribution of blacks. On this date General George Washington allowed for the first time for free blacks with military experience to enlist in the revolutionary army. A year later, as the American need for manpower increased, Washington dropped the military experience requirement, allowing any free black who so wishes to enlist. The Continental Congress tried to recruit more African-Americans by offering to purchase them from the Southern slaveholders. Unsurprisingly, few agreed. But enterprising states like Rhode Island made an end run around the slaveholders, announcing any slave who enlisted would immediately be freed. (Rhode Island compensated the slaveholder for the market value of their slave.) The “1st Rhode Island Regiment” was comprised mostly of those freed slaves, becoming the only Continental Army unit to have segregated units for blacks.
    [Show full text]
  • AN/KPQ-1 RADAR South Vietnam Detachment 131 Divisional Locating Battery South Vietnam 1966 - 1970
    2009 AN/KPQ-1 RADAR South Vietnam Detachment 131 Divisional Locating Battery South Vietnam 1966 - 1970 This document records a brief history of the mortar locating radars used by Detachment 131 Divisional Locating Battery in South Vietnam Keith R Ayliffe BEM Ex 131 Div Loc Bty AN/KPQ-1 PART 1 General information This document aims to record the history of the mortar locating radar set AN/KPQ-1 during deployment with 1st Australian Task Force in South Vietnam from April 1966 until June 1970. Although concentrating on the AN/KPQ-1 and the radar operating personnel, the role and input of the other components that completed the Australian mortar locating system cannot be overlooked, and must be mentioned in part to obtain an overall appreciation of the tasks undertaken. The three components of the mortar locating system were: A. The AN/KPQ-1 radar, B. The Task Force Artillery Intelligence Office, and C. The Listening Posts. 1. Introduction. In 1966 131 Divisional Locating Battery prepared a Detachment of troops to join 1 Australian Task Force in their deployment to South Vietnam. The Detachment would be officially known as Detachment 131 Divisional Locating Battery South Vietnam. This was abbreviated to Det 131 Div Loc Bty SVN (for this document Det 131 will be used as identification.) The Detachment comprised; a. Task force Artillery Intelligence Office (TFAIO), b. A Radar Section (comprising two (2) AN/KPQ-1 mortar locating radars), c. An Artillery Survey section, and d. A Royal Australian Electrical and Mechanical Engineers attachment, officially titled, Detachment 131 Divisional Battery Workshops South Vietnam (abbreviated to Det 131 Div Loc Bty WKSPS SVN).
    [Show full text]
  • At the Battle of Fire Support Base Andersen Ten Tunnel Rats Manned an Overnight Listening Post and Only Three Survived the Night Unhurt
    HOLDFASTMARCH 2017 - Number 30 www.tunnelrats.com.au OffICIal NEWslEttER of thE VIETNAM TUNNNEL Rats AssoCIatION INC. At the Battle of Fire Support Base Andersen ten Tunnel Rats manned an overnight listening post and only three survived the night unhurt It’s a battle the history books have ignored for too long NOSTALGIA PAGES 2 Sappers set sail on the mighty Mekong Nostalgia Pages Pages of great pics from the past to amaze and amuse. Photo contribitions welcome. Send your favourite Vietnam pics (with descriptions, names and ap- prox dates) to Jim Marett 43 Heyington Place Toorak Vic 3142 or by email to: [email protected] In 1969 the two Tunnel Rats seen here at the back of the boat were at- tached to 5RAR as a Splinter Team, and as they were water-borne for this operation, they were also tasked with running the boat. The two Sappers are Darryl Lavis and Ted Podlich of 2 Troop 1 FD SQN. The rest of the crew are Grunts from 5RAR. Their role was to patrol river tributaries along the Mekong, and carry out nightly ambushes on river traffic suspected of ferrying weapons and military supplies. “By morning we often found our- selves stranded up in the mangroves like sitting ducks, due to the quick changing tides,” recalls Darryl. “During daytime we transported the infantry patrols into the mangroves looking for possible weapons and food caches. We also searched and inspected fishing vessels,” says Darryl. “If there was a lull in river traffic we tried our hand at fishing - using grenades!” Ziggy catches some Zeeees Holdfast Magazine Written and edited by Jim Marett and published quarterly by the Vietnam Tunnel Rats Association 43 Heyington Place Toorak Vic 3142 Tel: 03-9824 4967 Mobile: 0403 041 962 When you were out on patrol with the Infantry, sleep deprivation was part of [email protected] the deal, so the ability to nap at any opportunity was essential to survival.
    [Show full text]
  • Holdfast 10.Cdr
    HOLDFAST July2007 NUMBER10 OFFICIAL NEWSLETTEROFTHEVIETNAMTUNNEL RATS ASSOCIATIONINC Goooooodmorning Afghanistan! Today’s Sappersgreetanewdayin anoldwaralongwayfromhome WededicateourcoverthisissuetoalltheSapperscurrentlyservingoverseas. Above:CaptainCarlMillerandSapperPeterLawliswithexplosivedetectiondog'Merlin' watchingthesunriseastheypreparebreakfastonanoperationin AfghanistaninMaythisyear. 2 Nostalgia Pages Pagesofgreatpicsfromthe pasttoamazeandamuse. Contributionswelcome.Send GettingSapperstosmileiseasy yourfavouriteVietnam All you have to do to raise a smile out of a good Sapper is stand him in photographsbymailto: front of a few dozen unexploded bombs. If you look closely, some of JimMarett43Heyington these guys are actually drooling with delight. To make things even Place ToorakVic3142 more exciting, it looks like these UXBs have been through a grass fire Or byemailto: as well! John Nulty 3 Troop 68/69 provided the photo, but who are [email protected] these fine young men? If you can help name them, let us know. R & R Bound Dressed up, cashed up and ready Whoarethesetossers? to roll. Tunnel Rats Gerry Who said we never had a social life? Sit in a circle with your mates, Wallbridge (left) and Frank Denley talk bullshit, drink beer, toss the empty can into the drum, open wait at Luscombe Field for their another beer, drink beer, accuse your mate of being a “Pogo”, drink flight to take them on R&R leave. more beer - and so on. Paradise. But who are these guys? And You looked forward to this so much, which Troop, and which year? If you can help identify these Tunnel you really didn’t believe it was going Rats, let us know. It’s obviously early on in the piss-up, as there isn’t to happen till you actually walked a single empty can on the ground.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ordnance Field Park in Vietnam
    TACTICAL PATROLS ORDNANCE AT THE ORDNANCE AT T SHARP END TECHNICAL PARTS HE SHARP END ORDNANCE FIELD PARK NUI DAT SOUTH VIETNAM 1966-72 Historical accounts and experiences from the by R.J. (Bob) Nash BUILDING IN THE VILLAGES men who served with OFP Compiled by R.J. (Bob) Nash UP FRONT WITH THE SHOWER TRUCK KEEPING HEADS DOWN AT FIRE SUPPORT BASES. OUR BOOK Our book is full of stories Of when we done our bit The good times, trials and memories When we were young and fit It’s not for fame and fortune Or laurels, or praise it seeks It gives us inspiration For times when next we meet The winds of life are blowing As they carry us along But age will not discourage us With our book of memories strong Lawrie O’Neill 6 OFP (Det) 1967-68 Printed by Shannon Books Australia Pty Ltd 4 Melrich Road, Bayswater Vic. 3153 With assistance from The author wishes to acknowledge the support of the Australian Government Department of Veterans’ Affairs, which provided a grant to assist publication under the Australian Government’s commemorations program, Saluting their Service. The Department has not participated in the research or production or exercised editorial control over the work’s contents, and the views expressed and conclusions reached herein do not necessarily represent those of the Commonwealth, which expressly disclaims any responsibility for the content or accuracy of the work. and 67 Gower St., Preston Vic. 3072 This book is printed on Sovereign A2, Silk: Cover – 130gsm, Text – 113gsm. The paper to print this book was kindly donated by Ken Doggett of K.W.
    [Show full text]
  • RAA Liaison Letter Spring 2008
    The Royal Australian Artillery LIAISON LETTER Spring Edition 2008 The Official Journal of the Royal Regiment of Australian Artillery Incorporating the Australian Gunner Magazine First Published in 1948 Contents Editors Comment 1 Letters to the Editor 3 Regimental 15 Operations 33 Take Post 43 Around the Regiments 49 Honour Title 59 RAA Coral 40th Anniversary 87 Professional Papers 109 Capability & Training 143 LIAISON Associations & Organisations 151 Next Edition Contribution Deadline LETTER Contributions for the Liaison Letter 2009 – Autumn Edition should be forwarded to the editor at his home postal or email address, by no later than Friday 20th February 2009. ‘Late’ correspondence or submissions after that date Spring Edition should be forwarded to the editor via the School of Artillery 2008 or his defence email address. LiaisonLetterInColourOn-line If you have access to the defence restricted network you can read the Liaison Letter in colour on the Regimental web-site found at:http://intranet.defence.gov.au/armyweb/Sites/RRAA/ Publication Information Front Cover: Top left: 12th Field Regiment AWM Plaque; top right: Colonel Ian Ahearn – GPO 102nd Field Battery; centre left: Combined RAA Band; centre right: Lieutenant Colonel Craig Furini is presented the Coral Honour Scroll by the Governor General; bottom left: Minute Guns; bottom centre: Royal Guard; bottom right: RAA Coral Sub Committee Front Cover Designed by: Corporal Michael Davis, 1st Joint Public Affairs Unit (formerly 8th/12th Medium Regiment) Edited and Compiled by: Major
    [Show full text]
  • Phuoc!Tuy!Province
    PLEASE TYPE THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES Thesis/Dissertation Sheet Surname or Family name: Richardson First name: Thomas Other name/s: Evan Abbreviation for degree as given in the University calendar: PhD School: School of Humanities and Social Sciences Faculty: UNSW Canberra Title: As if we were never there? Pacification in Phuoc Tuy province, Republic of Vietnam, 1966-1972. There is a growing view in the historiography of Australia's war in Vietnam that 1 Australian Task Force (1 ATF) succeeded in defeating the Communist insurgency within Phuoc Tuy, the province in which the Task Force was based, by time it withdrew from Vietnam at the end of 1971. This belief comes against a backdrop of a historiography of pacification that is dominated by works looking to win doctrinal battles within the US military. By examining the conduct of pacification in Phuoc Tuy between 1966 and 1972, this thesis challenges both these perspectives. A detailed case study of a single province puts both the operations of 1 ATF in a wider context, and allows pacification to be examined on its own terms rather than through the prism of contemporary counterinsurgency. By focusing on a single province, this thesis is also able to examine the political, economic and military aspects of pacification and how they influenced one another, rather than focusing on a single program or aspect. By taking this view, this thesis is able to examine how successful pacification was in Phuoc Tuy. Despite a flawed conception and frequent mismanagement, pacification did begin to change Phuoc Tuy's political and economic structure and succeeded in eroding the power of the Communist insurgency.
    [Show full text]