Views: a Sociological Critical
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Joseph Ayers Cheryl Gistenson Joanna Singer Michael Balaban Sviatlana Hantsevich Megan Stemm-Wade Michael Bentley, Jr. Kristin Hicks Laura Tietz Theodore J. Birren Joel Jacobson lya Tolpekina Greg Bruchert Myles Kleeman Andrew Tomenbang Annmarie Carlson Svetlana Kushner Michael Webb Brian Clark Muxiang Liu Tim Whalen Alexander Cox Cindy Loacker Marguerita Whitby Daniel Cox Luz M. Lopez Pilar Wiener Jeffrey Robert Cygan Bob Mackey IV Jessica Wolfe Ashley Fill Hannah McHugh Joanna Yau Penney Gainer Virginia Nye Mary Yoakim Tyler Garms Peggy Rodriguez The Harper Anthology Volume XX Foreword Th e pictures on the.front cover of this Harper Anthology sp eak clearly about one of this publications purposes, that o.fserving as an instructional text in classes at Harper College, particularly those involving the teaching o.f'English composition. Here, in these pictures fr om an evening section o.fEnglish I 02, students from all over the world are reading, together, a research paper published in an earlier edition o.f the Anthology�·as a model.for writing research-based papers of their own. Th e analysis of a student-written text in this fo rmat is invaluable fo r providing direction and inspiring confidence. The Harper Anthology has served in this capacity for twenty years, now, with countless students in Harper classrooms having read the work of hundreds of other Harper students whose papers have graced these pages. Th is latest edition of the Anthology should serve well in continuing this tradition o.fguidance, as it fe atures numerous essays and papers fr om English composition courses, as well as a fe w fr om outside of the English discipline, and a number of papers from Harpers Learning Communities program. Th e richness and diversity of academic study at Harper is evident in this volume, fe aturing papers on ofi-read "ancients" such as Shakespeare and Aristotle, but also incorporating a paper about a comic book series (p. 7 I); an account of a Harper Honors Program trip to Japan (p. 9); an analysis of a novel by a Nigerian author (p. I 44); and an insightful review of Israeli-Palestinian relations (p. 76). Also, the various entries for the "Harper Students on Wr iting"feature thatfollows the Ta ble of Contents are some of the most intelligent com mentaries on writing that I have ever read. Th e evening class in which the cover pictures were taken experienced a process of discovery as they read and outlined another Harper students published work. I can recall the engaged group reading and discussion as being a high point of the semeste1� and the reading and writing experience developing fr om that evening resulted in a high number of questions about "the research paper" being asked and resolved. On behalf of The Harper Anthology committee, I thank all fa culty who have submitted papers to this journal in the past and who use it in their classes, and I encourage more fa culty to incorporate the reading of Anthology essays in their classes. Th ese essays are the finest cross-section o.fthe Harper text and can be extremely valuable for instruction in the classroom. -Kris: Piepenburg, Chair,for The Harper Anthology committee: Charles Brown, Barbara Butler, Te resa Chung, Keith Jensen, Josh Sunderbruch, Anthony Wisniewski Submission Information I Table of Contents Submission Information Table of Contents Joseph Ayers Deadlines Redemption and Revenge in William Shakespeare's Hamlet Submission deadline, 2009 issue: (English 102) 1 January 20, 2009 Michael Balaban Submission deadline, 2010 issue: Laertes: Just a Foil? January 20, 2010 (English 102) 6 Michael Bentley, Jr. To Submit a Student's Manuscript: Despite US Complete the submission forms included in (Humanities 115) 9 the back of this issue, or available at the "Publications" tab of the Harper College English Theodore J. Birren Department website: Polar Views: A Sociological Critical www.harpercollege.edu/libarts/eng/dept. Analysis of John Updike's "A&P" and Toni Cade Bambara's "The Lesson" Send manuscripts (hard copy and disk) along with (English 102) 13 submission forms by campus mail to Kris Piepenburg, English Department, Liberal Arts Greg Bruchert Division, or attach a Microsoft Word file of the Frederic Chopin's Nocturne student paper to an e-mail, and send it to in G minor, Opus 3 7, No. 1 [email protected]. (Music 120) 19 Annmarie Carlson Raymond Carver's "Cathedral" Manuscript Evaluation and Buddhist Ethics and Publication (English 102/Philosophy 115) 22 Student manuscripts are read by the Harper Brian Clark Anthology committee once a year, during the Reasonable Lives: An Overdue winter break. Faculty and students are notified of Analysis of Ancient and Contemporary manuscript acceptance and upcoming publication Philosophies of Happiness in February. Printing takes place in July and (Philosophy 231) 28 August, and a free contributor's copy of the publi cation is mailed to each student writer in Alexander Cox September. The Blind Visionaries (English 102/Philosophy 115) 31 The Harper Anthology Daniel Cox Svetlana Kushner Langston Hughes: Class Distinctions Peace Between Israel and Palestine is and Racial Frustrations Unlikely in the Near Future (History 212/Literature 115)- 38 (English 101) 76 Jeffrey Robert Cygan Muxiang Liu The Darker Side of White Unreachable Blue Sky (English 101) 41 (ESL 067) 80 Ashley Fill Cindy Loacker Assimilation Proclamation Under the Big Top (English 102) 44 (English 102) 82 --- - -- ---- Penney Gainer Luz M. Lopez Elizabeth Bishop Fishes for Truth A New Moral (Literature 105) 48 (English 101) 87 Tyler Garms Bob Mackey IV Strout vs. Fowler The Pseudo-Poetry of Bob4 (Literature 115) 52 (English 222) 90 Cheryl Gistenson Hannah McHugh The Battle of Independence Day Memories of the Church Farm (English 101) 56 (English 101) 95 Sviatlana Hantsevich Virginia Nye Themes and Artistic Techniques in Richard III versus Falstaff James Joyce's "The Dead" (Literature 210) 97 (Literature 115) 58 Peggy Rodriguez Kristin Hicks Puritan Poetry and Worldly Affections Fatal(ly) Flaw(less) (Literature 221) 103 (English 102/Philosophy 115) 62 Joanna Singer Joel Jacobson The Real Value of Thirty-Five Dollars Brando's Magneticism Delivers Dynamic, (English 102/Literature 105) 106 Dramatic Flair to Julius Caesar Megan Stemm-Wade (Literature 112) 67 What The Witch Left: Modern Fantasy Myles Kleeman _ For Every Child The Monomyth in Modern Comics (Literature 219) 108 (English 102) 71 Submission Information I Table of Contents Laura Tietz JoannaYau Soft Grass, Hard Times Graceland: Are People Important? (English 102) 110 (Literature 208) 144 Iya Tolpekina MaryYoakim "Two Years of Shells and Bombs": Metamorphosis in the Samsa Household Posttraumatic Stress Disorder in Erich (English 102) 148 Maria Remarque's All Quiet on the Afterword Western Front and Ernest Hemingway's I Have Made My Life By Writing "Soldier's Home" (Dennis Weeks) 152 (English 102) 114 Submission Forms 153 Andrew Tomenbang Status Stole Her Soul Alternate Table of Contents 156 (English 102) 118 Michael Webb Prufrock Is in the Closet: Why Aristotle Is Concerned Acknowledgments (English 102/Philosophy 115) 120 Tim Whalen Typesetting and page production: Deanna Torres The Men of Alpha Compay (English 102) 126 Editorial Assistance: Becky Creutz Marguerita Whitby Death of a Salesman: Division of Enrollment and What Marx Would Have to Say Marketing/Harper College Print Shop: (English 102/Philosophy 115) 130 Maryellen Riley, Jan Elbert, Matt Nelson, Steve Schwertfeger, Tony Garcia, Tom Gibbons Pilar Wiener The Significance of the American Harper College Liberal Arts Division: Dream in A Raisin in the Sun Dennis Weeks, Tammi Jungdahl, Donna Lannerd, (English 102) 136 Lisa Larson Jessica Wolfe The Tragedy of Blanche DuBois (Literature 112) 142 Harper Students on Writing Joseph Ayers er already knows that these words are my feelingsand beliefs. Writing is an art form unlike any other. Ideas articulated Aside from being just good writing advice, this made me feel verbally vanish in an instant, but ideas committed to paper and empowered. "That is right, these are my words!" Also, I ink are immortalized, forever captured and ready to influence always felt quite awkward starting a paper. I could have the any mind ever willing to read them. Writing is traditionally entire story in my mind, but I never knew how to start the thought of as a way to implant new ideas into the minds of the process. Mr. Andrew Wilson gave me examples of how to public, and it is certainly that, but it also provides an effective begin a paper with a story. This helps to engage the reader, and and oftentimes surprising way for the writer to plumb the further more, set the stage for the story to follow. I believe that depths of his own mind, yielding not simply new ideas, but a student writer is only as good as the instructors at his or her new understanding: new understanding of his consciousness, wmgs. his creative process, and his circumstances in reality. Writing is many things to me. It is a way forme to organ ize my thoughts, forme to enlighten not just my audience, but Brian Clark also myself, and in the case of the work published here, it is Order often has a tendency towards stifling creativity, yet catharsis. In the time this paper was written, my parents were somehow in writing the two are expected to coherently meld. beginning what has become a bitter, acrimonious divorce. The This delicate process has leftme staring at many a blank com task of writing this paper was instrumental in enabling me to puter screen throughout the years, and it can be a toss-up at cope with that trauma. It forced me to immerse myself in the times as to whether this balance will be struck.