Metro North Inspectors Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
An Bord Pleanála Inspector’s Report Development Metro North – Belinstown to St. Stephen’s Green. Our Ref.: PL6F.NA0003 Application Details Applicant: Railway Procurement Agency Type of Application: Railway Order Planning Authorities: Dublin City Council Fingal County Council Inspector: Kevin Moore __________________________________________________________________________________ PL.06F.NA0003 An Bord Pleanala Page 1 of 690 OBSERVATIONS RECEIVED Submissions from Local Authorities Fingal County Council Dublin City Council Submissions from Prescribed Bodies Dublin Bus National Roads Authority Coras Iompair Eireann Coras Iompair Eireann/Iarnrod Eireann Dublin Airport Authority Department of the Environment, Heritage & Local Government Dublin Transportation Office Public Representative Submissions Bertie Ahern TD Cyprian Brady TD Senator Pascal Donohue Cllr. Mary Fitzpatrick Cllr. Andrew Montague Roisin Shorthall TD Sinn Féin Atha Cliath __________________________________________________________________________________ PL.06F.NA0003 An Bord Pleanala Page 2 of 690 Alternative Route Metro North East Route Alliance Submissions from Area MN101 Mary & John Bond, Belinstown Kevin & Mary Fox, Balheary, Belinstown Barry & Sally Hare, Balheary, Belinstown Una Donnelly, Batter Lane, Belinstown Mary & Des Rainey, Belinstown John Fleming, Belinstown Brian & Ailbhe Doyle, Belinstown Matt & Linda Graham, Belinstown Ger Dwyer & Others, Belinstown Stephen & Heather Joynt, Belinstown John & Ann Graham, Belinstown Padraig Flynn, Belinstown Michael Jones, Magillistown Sylvia Jones & Thomas Guy, Swords James & William Flynn, Belinstown James & Siobhan Flynn, Belinstown Sean & Noel Brangan, Belinstown Michael & Tom Bailey (Bovale Developments Ltd.) (Lissenhall) Michael & Tom Bailey (Bovale Developments Ltd.) (Barrysparks, Swords) Salix Trust Ltd. (Swords) Total Produce Ltd., Swords __________________________________________________________________________________ PL.06F.NA0003 An Bord Pleanala Page 3 of 690 MKN Property Group, Seatown, Swords Fingallians GAA, Estuary Percy Nominees Ltd., Seatown, Swords Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics Manufacturing Ltd., Swords Tempore Ltd., Swords Teba Ltd., Swords Submissions from Area MN102 Tadgh & Maureen O’Scannaill, Pinnock Hill, Swords Nethercross Holdings Ltd., Pinnock Hill, Swords Residents of Carlton Court, Swords Juliana & Joseph Boland, Nevinstown, Swords David Daly, Airside, Swords Irish Property Unit Trust & Irish Life Investment Managers, Fosterstown, Swords Submissions from Area MN103 McComish Ltd., Cloghran, Fosterstown Shaun McComish, Cloughran, Fosterstown Submissions from Area MN104 Irish Food Processors, Dardistown Hainvale Ltd., Dardistown Whitehall Rangers, Dardistown Dunlix Investments (Ireland) Ltd., Ballymun North __________________________________________________________________________________ PL.06F.NA0003 An Bord Pleanala Page 4 of 690 Tesco Ireland Ltd., Ballymun North Cosgrave Developments, Ballymun North The Byrne Family, MetroPark Hugo Byrne, Ballymun North Stephen McEvoy, Ballymun North Submissions from Area MN105 Ballymun Regeneration Ltd. Ballymun Shopping Centre Ltd. Vera Hunt, Ballymun Road Peter Tintari, Ballymun Donal & Linda O’Sullivan, Albert College Na Fianna CLG, Albert College Park Albert College, Ballymun Road & Greenfield Park Residents Association Ballymun Community Organisation Network Submissions from Area MN106 Residents of Hampstead Avenue & The Rise, Glasnevin Dónal Ó Brolcháin, Griffith Avenue Donal O’Donoghue, Griffith Avenue Patricia O’Donoghue, Griffith Avenue Bernadette & Karen Donnelly, Griffith Avenue Brendan Gaffney & Valerie Smith, Griffith Avenue Margaret & Victor Barry, Griffith Avenue Courtland Residents Association __________________________________________________________________________________ PL.06F.NA0003 An Bord Pleanala Page 5 of 690 Philip Reilly, The Rise/Hollybank Rd., Drumcondra Griffith Avenue & District Residents’ Association Alan & Catherine Beirne, Bantry Road, Drumcondra John A. Baushel, Bantry Rd., Drumcondra Michael Walsh, Bantry Road, Drumcondra Pauline Walsh, Bantry Road, Drumcondra Emer & Frank Lawlor, Valentia Rd., Drumcondra Frank & Mary McCormack, Valentia Rd, Drumcondra Susan Taylor, Valentia Rd., Drumcondra Corpus Christi Girls N.S., Drumcondra Francis Doherty & Shane Cryan, Homefarm Rd., Drumcondra Henry & Harry Mannion, Drumcondra Leonard Carty & Others, Homefarm Road, Drumcondra Patricia & Diarmuid Doyle, Ferguson Rd., Drumcondra James Grant, Ferguson Road, Drumcondra Patrick & Kathleen Hassett & Others, Ferguson Rd., Drumcondra Mary McLaughlin, Ferguson Rd., Drumcondra Mary Flanagan, Ferguson Rd., Drumcondra Angela & Carmel Morgan, Ferguson Rd., Drumcondra Róisín Ní Ceallaigh, Ferguson Rd., Drumcondra Jean McLeod & Others, Ferguson Rd., Drumcondra Michael Casey, Millbourne Ave., Drumcondra St. Patrick’s College, Drumcondra Breda & John Walsh, Botanic Ave., Drumcondra Georgina Doyle & Others, Botanic Ave., Glasnevin Elizabeth Hollywood & Charles Earley, Botanic Avenue John & Eva McDermott, Alphonsus Rd, Drumcondra __________________________________________________________________________________ PL.06F.NA0003 An Bord Pleanala Page 6 of 690 Sheila Burke, St. Alphonsus Rd., Drumcondra Christy McCormack, St. Alphonsus Rd. , Drumcondra Rita Hurson, St. Alphonsus Ave., Drumcondra Dawn Mulligan and Ken Lacey, St. Alphonsus Ave., Drumcondra Karen Griffin, St. Joseph’s Ave., Drumcondra Shane McGeary & Orla Canavan, St. Alphonsus Ave., Drumcondra Kieran Carolan, St. Joseph’s Ave., Drumcondra James Hunt, St. Joseph’s Ave., Drumcondra Matthew & Aideen Kelly, St. Joseph’s Ave., Drumcondra Damien Coleman, Lwr. Drumcondra Road John Daly, Whitworth Road, Drumcondra Marie Daly, Whitworth Rd., Drumcondra Maureen Kennedy, Whitworth Rd., Drumcondra Liam O’Doherty, Whitworth Rd., Drumcondra Jim & Rita Maguinness, Gratton Parade, Drumcondra Aidan & Barbara Hynes, St. Ignatius Rd., Dublin 7 Quinn’s Public House, Drumcondra Nathy & Margaret Groarke, Drumcondra All Hallows Area Residents Association, Drumcondra Iona & District Residents Association, Drumcondra Residents Opposed to Option B (R.O.T.O.), Drumcondra/Griffith Avenue Residents for Realignment Ltd., Drumcondra Ruadhan MacEoin, Dublin 1 Brendan Bonass & Others, Drumcondra Peter Sweetman, Drumcondra Leo Residents Association, Dublin 1 __________________________________________________________________________________ PL.06F.NA0003 An Bord Pleanala Page 7 of 690 Mater Private Hospital Mater Campus Hospital Development Ltd. National Paediatric Hospital Development Board Blend Resident’ Committee, Blessington, Eccles, Nelson, Dorset Streets Submissions from Area MN107 Dublin City Centre Business Association Ltd. Dublin Chamber of Commerce National Taxi Drivers Union Dublin Cycling Campaign, St. Stephen’s Green IDA Ireland Stanberry Investments Ltd. Park Rite Ltd. Trinity Street Car Park Ltd. Q-Park Ireland Ltd. The Rotunda Hospital, Parnell Square Gate Theatre, Parnell Square Millennium Theatre Company, Parnell Square Abbey Presbyterian Church, Parnell Square Gaelscoil Coláiste Mhuire, Parnell Square Hotel St. George, Parnell Square Castle Hotel, Parnell Square Highbury Lane Properties Ltd., O’Connell Street __________________________________________________________________________________ PL.06F.NA0003 An Bord Pleanala Page 8 of 690 Cafollas, O’Connell Street Quinn Insurance Ltd., O’Connell Street Irish Life & Permanent, O’Connell Street Chartered Land Ltd., O’Connell Street Upper, Henry St., Moore St. Chartered Land Ltd., Ilac Centre Wynn’s Hotel, Abbey Street Clery & Co. PLC, O’Connell Street Eason & Son Ltd., O’Connell Street Schuh Ltd., O’Connell Street Percy Nominees Ltd., O’Connell Street/Henry Street/Grafton Street Carrolls Irish Gift Stores, Westmoreland Street/O’Connell Street Thomas Lenehan & Co., Capel Street Arnotts Ltd., Henry Street O’Brien’s Sandwich Bar Ltd., Bachelor’s Walk Fliver Investments Ltd., Aston Quay K.S.K. Enterprises Ltd., Westmoreland Street Rehab Group, Westmoreland Street Westin Hotel, Westmoreland Street Dixon Hempenstall Ltd., Suffolk Street Irish Property Unit Trust, Suffolk Street/Grafton Street West Hotel Trading Company Ltd., Grafton Street L’Occitane (Olive Tree Lifestyle), Wicklow Street/Upper Liffey Street Weir & Sons, Grafton Street Glenberg/Peter Mark Group Brown Thomas Ltd. Car park __________________________________________________________________________________ PL.06F.NA0003 An Bord Pleanala Page 9 of 690 Brown Thomas & BT, Grafton St Edmund Ross Studios, Grafton Street Salix Trust Ltd., Grafton St. Thomas Patrick, Grafton Street David, Joanne & Paul Daly, Grafton Street Fitzers Holdings Ltd., Chatham Street/Dawson Street Teresa, Seamus & Phyllis O’Donoghue Appleby Jewellers, Johnson’s Court Salix Trust Ltd., St. Stephen’s Green Kildare Street and University Club, St. Stephen’s Green St. Stephen’s Green Hibernian Club Sunday River Ltd. (Il Posto), St. Stephen’s Green Carrigwood Developments Ltd., St. Stephen’s Green Lisney, St. Stephen’s Green Ampleforth Ltd., St. Stephen’s Green Bank of Scotland Ireland, St. Stephen’s Green Landlords of 124/127 St. Stephen’s Green Irish Life Investment Managers & Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, St. Stephen’s Green The National Concert Hall, Earlsfort Terrace Warren Whitney, St. Stephen’s Green Justin Marden, St. Stephen’s Green __________________________________________________________________________________ PL.06F.NA0003 An Bord Pleanala Page 10 of 690 CONTENTS Page 1.0 DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSED