DOCSLIB.ORG

Nagorno Karabakh Geo-Politics: Interests and Politics of Outsiders

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Nagorno Karabakh Geo-Politics: Interests and Politics of Outsiders The Nagorno Karabakh Conflict. Causes of the conflict and obstacles to conflict resolution. Item Type Thesis Authors Nikkar-Esfahani, Hamidreza Rights <a rel="license" href="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/ by-nc-nd/3.0/"><img alt="Creative Commons License" style="border-width:0" src="http://i.creativecommons.org/l/by- nc-nd/3.0/88x31.png" /></a><br />The University of Bradford theses are licenced under a <a rel="license" href="http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/">Creative Commons Licence</a>. Download date 27/09/2021 12:21:20 Link to Item http://hdl.handle.net/10454/5650 University of Bradford eThesis This thesis is hosted in Bradford Scholars – The University of Bradford Open Access repository. Visit the repository for full metadata or to contact the repository team © University of Bradford. This work is licenced for reuse under a Creative Commons Licence. The Nagorno Karabakh Conflict Causes of the conflict and obstacles to conflict resolution Hamidreza Nikkar-Esfahani Department of Peace Studies University of Bradford Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy October 2009 Table of Contents Abstract ......................................................................................................................... vi Acknowledgments: ...................................................................................................... vii Common Abbreviations ............................................................................................. viii Introduction .................................................................................................................... 1 Chapter 1: Context ....................................................................................................... 15 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 15 Natural Geography ................................................................................................... 16 Political Geography ................................................................................................. 20 Resources of Economy ............................................................................................ 23 Conclusion ............................................................................................................... 25 Chapter 2: Modern History of the Nagorno Karabakh Conflict .................................. 27 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 27 From the Collapse of the Soviet Union to the Present ......................................... 27 Conclusion ............................................................................................................... 46 Chapter 3: The Issues and Positions of the Conflicting Parties ................................... 47 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 47 Policies of the Conflicting Parties............................................................................ 48 Armenia................................................................................................................ 48 Azerbaijan ............................................................................................................ 50 Nagorno Karabakh ............................................................................................... 53 Factors Shaping Azerbaijan’s Policy ....................................................................... 54 Factors Shaping Armenia’s Policy........................................................................... 58 Factors Shaping the Policy of the Proclaimed Republic of Nagorno Karabakh .. 64 The Position of the Parties over the Disputed Issues ............................................... 67 The Occupied Territories ..................................................................................... 67 Lachin .................................................................................................................. 69 Shusha .................................................................................................................. 71 Refugees ............................................................................................................... 73 Security ................................................................................................................ 75 Legal-Political Status of Nagorno Karabakh ........................................................... 77 Conclusion ............................................................................................................... 84 Chapter 4: Nagorno Karabakh Geo-Politics: Interests and Politics of Outsiders ........ 92 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 92 The Russian Federation............................................................................................ 95 Strategic and Security Considerations ................................................................. 99 Economic Considerations .................................................................................. 100 The Caucasus Transportation Role for Russia ................................................... 100 Russians’ Racial Ties in the Region .................................................................. 100 To Fill the Power Vacuum ................................................................................. 101 Russia’s Position regarding the Nagorno Karabakh Conflict ............................ 104 Russia’s Position regarding the Republic of Armenia ....................................... 106 ii Russia’s Position over the Republic of Azerbaijan ............................................ 109 Russian Proposals concerning the Nagorno Karabakh conflcit ......................... 118 The Islamic Republic of Iran ................................................................................. 118 Iranian Goals and Interest in the Caucasus ........................................................ 122 Iran’s Security Goals in the Region ................................................................... 124 Iran’s Economic Goals in the Region ................................................................ 126 Iran’s Cultural Goals in the Region ................................................................... 127 Iran’s Political Goals in the Region ................................................................... 127 Iran’s Position regarding the Conflicting Parties ............................................... 128 Iran’s Position regarding the Republic of Armenia ........................................... 131 Iran’s Position regarding the Republic of Azerbaijan ........................................ 134 Iranian Strategy and the Interests of other Regional & Non-regional Powers .. 139 The Republic of Turkey ......................................................................................... 141 Turkey’s Goals and Interests in Central Asia & the Caucasus .......................... 144 Turkey’s Efforts to Influence the Region .......................................................... 146 Turkey’s Position regarding Both Parties in the NK Conflict ........................... 150 Turkey’s Position Concerning the Republic of Azerbaijan ............................... 151 Turkey’s Position Regarding the Republic of Armenia ..................................... 154 Turkey’s Overall Strategy over Azerbaijan, Armenia & NK ............................ 158 Turkey’s Strategy in Opposition to the Interests of other Outsiders and its Effect on the Conflict.................................................................................................... 160 Turkey’s Proposals for the Settlement of the NK Conflict ................................ 161 The United States of America ................................................................................ 162 The European Union .............................................................................................. 167 Conclusion ............................................................................................................. 172 Chaper 5: Early Mediations and Solutions ................................................................ 175 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 175 Mediation by the Russian Federation and CIS ...................................................... 179 Russia: The First Mediator and the Most Important Player ............................... 179 Evaluating Russia’s Mediating Conduct ................................................................ 186 Mediation by the Islamic Republic of Iran ............................................................ 190 Periodic Shuttling of the Mediating Delegation to the Region .............................. 195 Aspects of Iran's Proposals to the Conflict Parties ............................................ 196 Temporary Ceasefire .............................................................................................. 197 Tehran Summit................................................................................................... 198 Iran's Mediation and Other Players’ Reactions .................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Brief Overview on Karabakh History from Past to Today
    Volume: 8 Issue: 2 Year: 2011 A Brief Overview on Karabakh History from Past to Today Ercan Karakoç Abstract After initiation of the glasnost (openness) and perestroika (restructuring) policies in the USSR by Mikhail Gorbachev, the Soviet Union started to crumble, and old, forgotten, suppressed problems especially regarding territorial claims between Azerbaijanis and Armenians reemerged. Although Mountainous (Nagorno) Karabakh is officially part of Azerbaijan Republic, after fierce and bloody clashes between Armenians and Azerbaijanis, the entire Nagorno Karabakh region and seven additional surrounding districts of Lachin, Kelbajar, Agdam, Jabrail, Fizuli, Khubadly and Zengilan, it means over 20 per cent of Azerbaijan, were occupied by Armenians, and because of serious war situations, many Azerbaijanis living in these areas had to migrate from their homeland to Azerbaijan and they have been living under miserable conditions since the early 1990s. Keywords: Karabakh, Caucasia, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Ottoman Empire, Safavid Empire, Russia and Soviet Union Assistant Professor of Modern Turkish History, Yıldız Technical University, [email protected] 1003 Karakoç, E. (2011). A Brief Overview on Karabakh History from Past to Today. International Journal of Human Sciences [Online]. 8:2. Available: http://www.insanbilimleri.com/en Geçmişten günümüze Karabağ tarihi üzerine bir değerlendirme Ercan Karakoç Özet Mihail Gorbaçov tarafından başlatılan glasnost (açıklık) ve perestroyka (yeniden inşa) politikalarından sonra Sovyetler Birliği parçalanma sürecine girdi ve birlik coğrafyasındaki unutulmuş ve bastırılmış olan eski problemler, özellikle Azerbaycan Türkleri ve Ermeniler arasındaki sınır sorunları yeniden gün yüzüne çıktı. Bu bağlamda, hukuken Azerbaycan devletinin bir parçası olan Dağlık Karabağ bölgesi ve çevresindeki Laçin, Kelbecer, Cebrail, Agdam, Fizuli, Zengilan ve Kubatlı gibi yedi semt, yani yaklaşık olarak Azerbaycan‟ın yüzde yirmiye yakın toprağı, her iki toplum arasındaki şiddetli ve kanlı çarpışmalardan sonra Ermeniler tarafından işgal edildi.
    [Show full text]
  • Ambassador Rudolf V. Perina
    The Association for Diplomatic Studies and Training Foreign Affairs Oral History Project AMBASSADOR RUDOLF V. PERINA Interviewed by: Charles Stuart Kennedy Interview Date: December, 2006 Copyright 200 TABLE OF CONTENTS Background Born in zechoslovakia, raised in Morocco, Switzerland, and the United States University of hicago, olumbia University Foreign Area Fellowship, Munich, (ermany 1970,1972 Marriage .ntered the Foreign Service in 1974 Ottawa, anada0 1otation Officer 1974,1972 Solzhenitsyn visa case 1elations .nvironment State Department0 .uropean Bureau, Military,Political Officer 1972,1978 NATO onference on Security and ooperation in .urope 5 S .6 Belgrade Meeting US and Soviets on Human 1ights Helsinki Final Act 1efuseniks State Department, FSI8 1ussian language training 1978,1979 Moscow, Soviet Union0 Political Officer, .9ternal 1979,1981 Soviet military activities Soviet Afghanistan invasion 1elations Soviets and uba US boycott of Soviet Olympics Sino,Soviet split Harassment Living environment Poland Berlin, (ermany8 Protocol/ Senate Liaison Officer 1981,1985 1 Liaison with Soviets on Berlin Polish aircraft hijackings US Strategic Defense Initiative 1elations with US .ast Berlin .mbassy Terrorist gangs Brussels, Belgium8 NATO Political Officer and Deputy 1985,1987 Political ommittee Nuclear and Space talks Sharing with Soviets SDI and INF deployment National Security ouncil, Soviet issues 1987,1989 Iran ontra fallout 1eagan's "tear down the wall" speech Views on Soviet collapse 1eagan's Moscow visit 1eagan and (orbachev 1omania visit onference on Security and ooperation in .urope 5 S .6 1989 London Information Forum Paris onference on Human Dimension Vienna, Austria0 Deputy Head of US delegation to S .. 1989,1992 Negotiations on onventional Forces in .urope 5 F.6 NATO and Aarsaw Pact Forces Negotiations with Soviets (ermany reunified .uropean Union/US relations The French 1ussians Aarsaw Pact disintegration (ermany and NATO .astern vs.
    [Show full text]
  • DİPLOMATİYA ALƏMİ the Viewsandopinionsexpressedarethoseofthe JOURNAL of the MINISTRY OFFOREIGN AFFAIRS Tel.: 596-91-31;E-Mail:[email protected]
    DİPLOMATİYA ALƏMİ WORLD OF DIPLOMACY JOURNAL OF THE MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN № 55, 2020 EDITORIAL COUNCIL Jeyhun BAYRAMOV Minister of Foreign Affairs (Chairman of the Editorial Council) Hikmat HAJIYEV Assistant to the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan, Head of the Department of Foreign Policy Affairs of the Presidential Administration of the Republic of Azerbaijan Araz AZIMOV Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Mahmud MAMMAD-GULIYEV Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Khalaf KHALAFOV Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Hafiz PASHAYEV Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Ramiz HASANOV Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Fariz RZAYEV Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Huseyn HUSEYNOV Director of the Department for Analysis and Strategic Studies of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Azerbaijan EDITORIAL BOARD Nurlan ALIYEV Department for Analysis and Strategic Studies @ All rights reserved. The views and opinions expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the MFA “World of Diplomacy” journal is published since 2002. Registration №1161, 14 January 2005 ISSN: 1818-4898 Postal address: Analysis and Strategic Studies Department, ORGANIZATION FOR DEMOCRACY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT - GUAM FOR DEMOCRACY ORGANIZATION Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Sh.Gurbanov Str. 50, Baku AZ 1009 Tel.: 596-91-31; e-mail: [email protected] INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION PRIORITIES OF AZERBAIJANI CHAIRMANSHIP IN 2020 PRIORITIES OF AZERBAIJANI GUAM – Japan CHAIRMANSHIP IN 2020 Joint Press Release on the sidelines of the OSCE Council of Ministers 5 December 2019, Bratislava hairmanship in Office of the Republic of Azerbaijan in the Organization for Democracy and Economic Development – GUAM in the year of 2020 will focus on the matters of economic Ccooperation between the Member States.
    [Show full text]
  • Michael S. Gorham P
    Michael S. Gorham P. O. Box 115565 Gainesville, Florida 32611-5565 USA Phone: 352-273-3786 E-Mail: [email protected] Homepage: http://people.clas.ufl.edu/mgorham Last updated: May 2021 EMPLOYMENT Full-time Positions 2015–present Professor of Russian Studies, Dept. of Languages, Literatures and Cultures, University of Florida 2017–2019 University of Florida Term Professor of Russian Studies, Dept. of Languages, Literatures and Cultures, University of Florida 2014-2015 Robin and Jean Gibson Term Professor, Dept. of Languages, Literatures and Cultures, University of Florida 2003-2015 Associate Professor of Russian Studies, Dept. of Languages, Literatures and Cultures, University of Florida 1996-2005 Assistant Professor of Russian Studies, Dept. of Germanic and Slavic Studies, University of Florida Visiting Appointments 2013 Visiting Research Fellow, Uppsala Centre for Russian and Eurasian Studies, Uppsala University, Sweden 2010 Visiting Professor, Department of Slavic Literature and Culture, University of Passau, Germany 2008 Visiting Research Fellow, Department of Foreign Languages, University of Bergen, Norway Editorships 2007-2019 Associate Editor, The Russian Review. (top-tier journal producing 4 issues annually, with international area-studies readership). Primary responsibility for soliciting and vetting manuscripts in Literature (all areas) and Cultural Studies. 2005-2017 Associate Editor, Russian Language Journal. (1 issue annually, with international readership in all areas of Russian language scholarship). Primary responsibility for book reviews and (through to 2014) soliciting and vetting manuscripts in Language Culture, Sociolinguistics, and Language Ideologies. Consulting 2011-present Specialist on the Russian Internet and new media technologies for Oxford Analytica Daily Brief. EDUCATION 1994 Ph.D., Stanford University, Slavic Languages and Literatures 1988 M.A., Bryn Mawr College, Russian Language and Literature 1985 B.A.
    [Show full text]
  • The Soul of Azerbaijan
    A-PDFKarabagh Split DEMO : Purchase from www.A-PDF.com to remove the watermark Shusha Castle. Ganja Gate. 1750-1757 Vagif PIRIYEV Doctor of History, professor Karabagh - the Soul of Azerbaijan arabagh has been an inte- Derbent and from Lake Goycha (to- countered not only on Azerbaijani gral part of Azerbaijan for the day Sevan) to the Caspian Sea. As a territory, but also in the region Kwhole period of history, in- part of the Azerbaijani Safavid State of Kars (Asia Minor), northern cluding the XIII-XIV centuries. As was the country was divided into four Caucasus, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, correctly noted by the prominent Beylarbeyliys: Chuhur-Saad, Ganja Afghanistan and other countries. (3) Russian Orientalist A. Y. Yakubovsky, (Karabagh), Tabriz and Shirvan. In In Azerbaijan there were also locali- by the name Azerbaijan in that pe- this period Karabagh formed part of ties called Surkhab Karabagh, Tabriz riod was meant the present day ter- the historical region Arran and was Karabagh (4) and Karabagh Arran. ritory of South (Iranian) as well as its centre and soul (2), which prima- Marking these localities as Karabagh North (former Soviet) Azerbaijan. (1) ry source information attests to. means people and garden, the great Its borders stretched from Zanjan to The toponym Karabagh is en- garden and excellent place and de- 42 www.irs-az.com Kurachai riv. YEVLAKH v i r i a h c a r u GORANBOY K Chaykand NAFTALAN Tartar riv. K u r BARDA a r Tap Garagoyunlu i v . scribes the beauty of the land and its Fazlullah Rashid ad- Gulustan TARTAR Kalantarli Lev abundance.
    [Show full text]
  • Out of Water Civilizations Emerge Focus on Pre-Islamic Persian Empires
    INFLUENCE OF WATER MANAGEMENT ON EMPIRES 1 Out of Water Civilizations Emerge Focus on Pre-Islamic Persian Empires Festival of the Passing of the Ice Dragon 8 April 2017 Pentathlon Entry - Literary Arts Research Paper INFLUENCE OF WATER MANAGEMENT ON EMPIRES 2 Abstract Water or the lack of it has the power to create or destroy empires. From prehistory to the current time period this has been shown to be true. The civilizations who have been able to harness water, transport it and conserve it are the societies that have risen to power. The Persian Empires, from the earliest to the last, were masters of water husbandry. They developed an underground transport system called qanats that enabled them to become one of the greatest empires the world has ever seen. Not only has their knowledge of water transport enabled the irrigation of fields, it provided water for domestic purposes in their homes, to air- condition their homes and allowed the use of sewage systems which helped to keep disease at bay. INFLUENCE OF WATER MANAGEMENT ON EMPIRES 3 Out of Water Civilizations Emerge – Focus on Pre-Islamic Persian Empires Water has controlled the rise and fall of great empires. Rome became a great power when it was able to harvest the water from the Mediterranean Sea, China’s Golden Age developed after the completion of the 1100 mile long Grand Canal for transport of goods and irrigation. Domination of the oceans by the Vikings gave rise to their success. Civilizations are driving by the way in which they respond to the challenges of their environment.
    [Show full text]
  • Frigg, Astghik and the Goddess of the Crete Island
    FRIGG, ASTGHIK AND THE GODDESS OF THE CRETE ISLAND Dedicated to the goddesses-mothers of Armenia and Sweden PhD in Art History Vahanyan V. G., Prof. Vahanyan G. A. Contents Intrоduction Relations between Frigg and the Goddess of the Crete Island Motifs in Norse Mythology Motifs in Armenian Mythology Artifacts Circle of the World Afterword References Introduction According to conventional opinion, the well-known memorial stone (Fig. 1a) from the Swedish island Gotland (400-600 AC) depicts goddess Frigg holding snakes. The unique statuettes of a goddess holding snakes are discovered on Crete (Fig. 1b), which date to c. 1600 BC1. The depiction of Frigg embodies a godmother with her legs wide open to give birth. In Norse mythology Frigg, Frige (Old Norse Frigg), Frea or Frija (Frija – “beloved”) is the wife of Odin. She is the mother of the three gods Baldr, Hodr and Hermodr. a b Fig. 1. (a) Memorial stone from the Swedish island Gotland (400-600 AC) depicting Frigg holding snakes. (b) Goddess holding snakes, Crete (c. 1600 BCE) The Swedish stone from Gotland island depicts the godmother, who is sitting atop the mountain before childbirth (Fig. 1а). Her hands are raised and she is holding two big snakes-dragons. The composition symbolizes the home/mountain of dragons (volcanic mountain). The composite motif of the depiction on the memorial stone, according to the 1 The findings belong to Crete-Minoan civilization and are found in the upper layers of the New Palace in Knossos. Two items are discovered (Archaeological Museum, Heraklion) authors, stems to the archetypes in the Old Armenian song “The birth of Vahagn” 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Ceasefire Agreement
    Ceasefire Agreement Unofficial translation P. S. Grachev Minister of Defense of the Russian Federation A. V. Kozyrev Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation V. N. Kazimirov Responding to the call for a cease-fire, as set out in the Bishkek Protocol of May 5, 1994, and based on the Protocol of 18 February 1994, the conflicting Parties agreed on the following: 1. Ensure the full cease-fire and cessation of hostilities from 00 hours 01 minutes of May 12, 1994. Relevant orders to cease-fire will be given and communicated to the commanders of military units responsible for their implementation, not later than May 11, 1994. On May 12 until 23.00, the Parties shall exchange the texts of their cease-fire orders with a view to their possible mutual complementarities and further harmonization of substantive provisions of similar documents. 2. Request the Minister of Defense of the Russian Federation to convene in Moscow no later than May 12 an urgent meeting of defense ministers of Azerbaijan, Armenia and Nagorno Karabakh army commander to agree on the lines of troops pullback and other urgent military-technical issues and prepare the deployment of an advance team of international observers. 3. This agreement will be used to complete the negotiations in the next 10 days and conclude an Agreement on Cessation of the Armed Conflict no later than May 22 of this year. 4. This agreement will take effect immediately after the Mediator notifies that he has received from the opposing forces completely identical documents signed by authorized representatives. Minister of Defense of Azerbaijan Minister of Defense of Armenia Nagorno Karabakh Army Commander The text was signed respectively by M.
    [Show full text]
  • Follow-Up on Recommendations in the OSCE PA's Belgrade Declaration
    General Committee on Political Affairs and Security Follow-Up on Recommendations in the OSCE PA’s Belgrade Declaration Interim Report for the 2012 Winter Meeting Prepared by the OSCE PA International Secretariat for the Vice-Chair of the Committee, Ms. Susanne Bratli 2012 First Committee Interim Follow-Up Report on the OSCE PA’s Belgrade Declaration Table of Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 2 Activities beyond the OSCE Area .............................................................................................. 3 Conflict Prevention and Rapid Reaction Capability ................................................................... 6 The Corfu Process ....................................................................................................................... 7 Food Security and Self-Sufficiency ............................................................................................ 8 Protracted Conflicts .................................................................................................................... 9 Re-establishing an OSCE Presence in Belarus and Georgia .................................................... 12 Reforming and Strengthening the OSCE .................................................................................. 13 Strengthening Arms Control and Security Co-operation .......................................................... 15 1 2012 First Committee Interim Follow-Up
    [Show full text]
  • Peace in Caucasus
    APRIL 23, 2016 Mirror-SpeTHE ARMENIAN ctator Volume LXXXVI, NO. 40, Issue 4434 $ 2.00 NEWS The First English Language Armenian Weekly in the United States Since 1932 INBRIEF Gymnast Houry Gebeshian Qualifies for Olympics RIO DE JANEIRO, Brazil — Armenian- American gymnast Houry Gebeshian will be the first female gymnast to represent Armenia at the Olympics, after placing 21st out of 36 competitors and qualifying at the Pre- Olympic Test Event in Rio on April 17. Gebeshian was born in Auburndale, Mass. in 1989, Armenian Genocide Commemoration Billboards Installed in Massachusetts but obtained Armenian citi- zenship in 2010 to be eligi- WATERTOWN — Peace of Art, Inc. continues its annual leaders and dignitaries, including French President Francois ble to compete for Armenia. Armenian Genocide commemoration campaign in various Hollande, Russian President Vladimir Putin, the presidents of She lives in Cleveland, Ohio. Massachusetts cities during the month of April with digital bill- Serbia and Cyprus. Together they placed their roses into the She was admitted to this final qualifier due to boards dedicated to the 101st anniversary of the Armenian main Centennial wreath. It would have been wonderful to see a strong performance at the first round in the Genocide. “On April 24, 2015 at the Tsitsernakaberd Armenian the U.S. president himself in attendance, placing a rose in 2015 World Championships at Glasgow last Genocide memorial in Yerevan, I participated in the 100th memory of the 1.5 million Armenian Christian victims of 1915 October. anniversary of the Armenian Genocide. I witnessed Armenian to 1923,” Said Daniel Varoujan Hejinian, president and Gebeshian has a GoFundMe page children presenting a yellow rose to each of the many foreign founder of Peace of Art, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • SUMGAYIT – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR
    SUMGAYIT – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR Aslan Ismayilov SUMGAYIT - BEGINNING OF THE COLLAPSE OF THE USSR 1 Aslan Ismayilov ЧАШЫОЬЛУ 2011 Aslan Ismayilov Sumgayit – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR Baku Aslan Ismayilov Sumgayit – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR Baku Translated by Vagif Ismayil and Vusal Kazimli 2 SUMGAYIT – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR SUMGAYIT PROCEEDINGS 3 Aslan Ismayilov 4 SUMGAYIT – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR HOW I WAS APPOINTED AS THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR IN THE CASE AND OBTAINED INSIGHT OF IT Dear readers! Before I start telling you about Sumgayit events, which I firmly believe are of vital importance for Azerbaijan, and in the trial of which I represented the government, about peripeteia of this trial and other happenings which became echoes and continuation of the tragedy in Sumgayit, and finally about inferences I made about all the abovementioned as early as in 1989, I would like to give you some brief background about myself, in order to demonstrate you that I was not involved in the process occasionally and that my conclusions and position regarding the case are well grounded. Thus, after graduating from the Law Faculty of of the Kuban State University of Russia with honours, I was appointed to the Neftekumsk district court of the Stavropol region as an interne. After the lapse of some time I became the assistant for Mr Krasnoperov, the chairman of the court, who used to be the chairman of the Altay region court and was known as a good professional. The existing legislation at that time allowed two people’s assessors to participate in the court trials in the capacity of judges alongside with the actual judge.
    [Show full text]
  • European Court of Human Rights
    GRAND CHAMBER DECISION Application no. 40167/06 Minas SARGSYAN against Azerbaijan The European Court of Human Rights, sitting on 14 December 2011 as a Grand Chamber composed of: Nicolas Bratza, President, Jean-Paul Costa, Christos Rozakis, Françoise Tulkens, Josep Casadevall, Nina Vajić, Corneliu Bîrsan, Peer Lorenzen, Boštjan M. Zupančič, Elisabet Fura, Alvina Gyulumyan, Khanlar Hajiyev, Egbert Myjer, Sverre Erik Jebens, Giorgio Malinverni, George Nicolaou, Luis López Guerra, judges, and Michael O’Boyle, Deputy Registrar, Having regard to the above application lodged on 11 August 2006, Having regard to the decision of 11 March 2010 by which the Chamber of the First Section to which the case had originally been assigned relinquished its jurisdiction in favour of the Grand Chamber (Article 30 of the Convention), 2 SARGSYAN v. AZERBAIJAN DECISION Having regard to the observations submitted by the respondent Government and the observations in reply submitted by the applicant, Having regard to the comments submitted by the Armenian Government, Having regard to the oral submissions of the parties and the third party at the hearing on 15 September 2010, Having deliberated on 15, 16 and 22 September 2010 and on 14 December 2011 decides, on the last-mentioned date as follows: THE FACTS 1. The applicant, Mr Minas Sargsyan, is an Armenian national who was born in 1929 and died in 2009. His widow, Lena Sargsyan, born in 1936 and their children, Vladimir, Tsovinar and Nina Sargsyan, born in 1957, 1959, and 1966 respectively, have expressed the wish to pursue the application on his behalf. The applicant is represented before the Court by Ms N.
    [Show full text]