Complete Streets Advisory Council Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Complete Streets Advisory Council Report December 31, 2011 Page 1 of 140 Page 2 of 140 Page 3 of 140 CSAC Vision Statement A transportation network that is accessible, interconnected, and multi- modal and that safely and efficiently moves goods and people of all ages and abilities. A process that empowers partnerships to plan, fund, design, construct, maintain and operate complete streets that respect context and community values. Outcomes that will improve economic prosperity, equity, and environmental quality. Page 4 of 140 Table of Contents Status of Complete Streets Policies in Michigan……………………. 6 Summary of Complete Streets Advisory Council Proceedings..……. 10 MDOT Collaboration with Complete Streets Communities………… 24 Sample Policy Language (Preliminary)...…………………………… 27 Appendix……………………………………………………………. 39 A- Additional Resources……………………………………. 40 B - Presentations……………………………………………. 42 C- Public Comments………………………………………… 88 D - Correspondence………………………………..………… 90 E - MDOT’s Collaboration with Complete Streets Communities (by Region)……………………………………………… 96 Page 5 of 140 SSttaattuuss ooff CCoommpplleettee SSttrreeeettss iinn MMiicchhiiggaann Page 6 of 140 Michigan Communities with Complete Streets Policies 41 KEWEENAW Hancock Houghton 24 Ontonagon HOUGHTON 41 45 ONTONAGON BARAGA MARQUETTE GOGEBIC 35 41 Marquette Sault Ste. Marie 42 LUCE Ironwood 36 2 45 8 Ishpeming 39 Munising Newberry 141 IRON CHIPPEWA Gwinn ALGER Crystal MACKINAC 2 SCHOOLCRAFT Falls DICKINSON 75 2 41 DELTA 2 St. Ignace 2 11 Manistique Iron Mountain Escanaba 20 25 Mackinaw City 2 18 23 Cheboygan 31 41 31 MENOMINEE 63 AGENCY EMMET Petoskey Charlevoix 75 CHEBOYGAN PRESQUE ISLE CHARLEVOIX 23 31 Menominee OTSEGO Alpena Gaylord ALPENA ANTRIM MONTMORENCY LEELANAU 131 44 CRAWFORD OSCODA ALCONA BENZIE 2 Traverse 57 City Grayling Mio Frankfort 31 GRAND 47 TRAVERSE KALKASKA 75 31 23 MISSAUKEE OGEMAW IOSCO MANISTEE Manistee WEXFORD ROSCOMMON Cadillac 127 Metro Area ARENAC CLARE 31 GLADWIN 75 MASON 41 LAKE 131 19 HURON 26 Ludington 10 OSCEOLA 75 Auburn Harbor 24 10 Clare Hills 29 59 Beach Pontiac 40 BAY 53 MACOMB 10 Pentwater ISABELLA 59 75 Big Rapids 55 B.R. 150 24 Midland Mount Bay City OCEANA NEWAYGO 75 59 59 43 Pleasant 3 SANILAC MECOSTA Saginaw OAKLAND MIDLAND Troy 131 33 675 TUSCOLA 34 127 51 53 31 24 97 Alma MONTCALM 1 23 5 SAGINAW Frankenmuth 75 Warren St. Clair 54 GRATIOT Shores GENESEE 96 60 Muskegon 696 696 MUSKEGON 7 13 LAPEER ST. CLAIR Farmington 3 KENT 50 Novi Hills IONIA CLINTON B.R. Flint 14 Grand Haven 96 127 69 102 49 Grand Rapids 10 45 Port 46 10 75 27 Huron OTTAWA 32 58 5 94 31 Lansing 96 8 196 15 SHIAWASEE MACOMB 14 96 17 Holland 37 1 75 52 56 23 OAKLAND WAYNE 39 48 LIVINGSTON 375 131 96 153 Charlotte 96 Novi 94 21 BARRY EATON 275 Detroit 9 Brighton 696 INGHAM 62 12 31 69 24 ALLEGAN 127 96 South Haven Battle 16 Kalamazoo Creek Jackson 94 Ann 94 38 94 Arbor 94 Detroit VAN BUREN 6 WASHTENAW 30 19 94 275 75 CALHOUN 4 5 12 53 Taylor Benton Harbor WAYNE JACKSON St. Joseph KALAMAZOO 131 12 275 85 12 23 CASS MONROE 61 BRANCH 69 22 HILLSDALE 75 Hillsdale 94 127 Adrian 24 28 BERRIEN 31 Monroe ST. JOSEPH 12 223 29 12 LENAWEE Page 7 of 140 Communities with Complete Streets Policies As of Novermber 4, 2011 MDOT Agency Region MDOT TSC Policy Type Date of Adoption 1 Lansing University Lansing Ordinance August 1, 2009 Internal Infrastructure 2 Traverse City North Traverse City September 1, 2009 Strategy Policy Planning Commission 3 Midland Bay Mt. Pleasant May 1, 2010 Policy 4 Jackson, County University Jackson Resolution 2006 5 Jackson MPO University Jackson Resolution 2006 6 Jackson, City University Jackson Resolution 2006 7 Novi Metro Oakland Resolution August 1, 2010 8 Sault Ste. Marie Superior Newberry Resolution August 1, 2010 Ingham County 9 University Lansing Resolution August 2, 2010 Road Commission 10 Flint Bay Davison Resolution September 1, 2010 11 Manistique Superior Crystal Falls Resolution September 13, 2010 12 Saline University Brighton Ordinance September 23, 2010 13 Berkley Metro Oakland Resolution October 4, 2010 14 Ferndale Metro Oakland Ordinance October 25, 2010 15 Hamtramck Metro Detroit Resolution November 9, 2010 16 Dexter University Brighton Ordinance November 22, 2010 17 Linden Bay Davison Resolution November 22, 2010 18 Mackinaw City North Grayling Resolution December 2, 2010 19 Taylor Metro Taylor Ordinance December 7, 2010 20 St. Ignace North Newberry Resolution December 6, 2010 21 Allegan Southwest Kalamazoo Resolution December 13, 2010 22 Jonesville University Jackson Policy Statement October 20, 2010 23 Clawson Metro Oakland Resolution December 7, 2010 24 Houghton Superior Ishpeming Ordinance December 22, 2010 25 Escanaba Superior Escanaba Resolution January 2011 26 Oxford Metro Oakland Resolution January 25, 2011 27 Atlas Township - Genesee Co Bay Davison Resolution January 17, 2011 28 Woodhaven Metro Detroit Resolution February 15, 2011 29 Gibralter Metro Taylor Resolution January 24, 2011 30 Ann Arbor University Brighton Resolution March 7, 2010 31 Burt Township - Cheboygan Co North Grayling Resolution March 3, 2011 32 Grand Rapids Grand Grand Rapids Resolution March 23, 2011 33 Union Township - Isabella Co Bay Mount Pleasant Resolution March 23, 2011 34 Milford Township - Oakland Co Metro Oakland Resolution February 16, 2011 Marquette Township - 35 Superior Ishpeming Resolution April 4, 2011 Marquette Co Page 8 of 140 Communities with Complete Streets Policies As of Novermber 4, 2011 MDOT Agency Region MDOT TSC Policy Type Date of Adoption 36 Ispheming Superior Ishpeming Resolution April 6, 2011 Grand / Kalamazoo / 37 Holland Resolution April 21, 2011 Southwest Grand Rapids 38 Allen Park Metro Taylor Resolution December 14, 2010 39 Munising Superior Escanaba Resolution February 23, 2011 Oakland Township - 40 Metro Oakland Resolution April 12, 2011 Oakland Co 41 Ludington North Cadillac Resolution May 9, 2011 42 Marquette Superior Ishpeming Resolution May 9, 2011 43 Lake Isabella Bay Mt. Pleasant Resolution May 18, 2011 Acme Township - 44 North Traverse City Resolution June 7, 2011 Grand Traverse Co 45 Owosso University Lansing Resolution June 6, 2011 46 Northville Metro Oakland Resolution June 20, 2011 47 Frankfort North Traverse City Resolution June 2011 48 Williamston University Lansing Ordinance June 13, 2011 49 Grand Haven Grand Grand Rapids Resolution July 18, 2011 50 Genesee Township - Genesee Co Bay Davison Resolution June 14, 2011 51 Birmingham Metro Oakland Resolution July 11, 2011 52 Otsego Southwest Kalamazoo Resolution August 1, 2011 53 Ypsilanti University Brighton Ordinance August 2011 54 Fremont Grand Muskegon Resolution May 16, 2011 Oakland County 55 Metro Oakland Resolution August 16, 2011 Board of Commissioners 56 Lansing Township - Ingham Co University Lansing Ordinance September 13, 2011 57 Traverse City North Cadillac Resolution October 3, 2011 58 Mundy Township - Genesee Co Bay Davison Resolution October 11, 2010 Pere Marquette Township - 59 North Cadillac Resolution August 9, 2011 Mason Co 60 Lathrup Village Metro Oakland Ordinance September 19, 2011 61 Berrien Springs Southwest Coloma 62 Hamburg Township University Brighton Resolution 63 Pellston North Grayling Resolution November 14, 2011 Page 9 of 140 SSuummmmaarryy ooff CCoommpplleettee SSttrreeeettss AAddvviissoorryy CCoouunncciill PPrroocceeeeddiinnggss Page 10 of 140 Complete Streets Advisory Council Summary of Proceedings for Calendar 2011 The Complete Streets Advisory Council includes 16 voting and two non-voting members, appointed in 2010 according to the requirements of P.A. 135 of 2010. The Council’s members represent a broad cross-section of interest groups concerned about issues including the environment, health, housing, aging, safety, local government, planning and modes of transportation including walking, bicycling, roads, and transit. The council’s charge, according to the law, is to “provide education and advice to the state transportation commission, county road commissions, municipalities, interest groups, and the public on the development, implementation, and coordination of complete streets policy.” The group held its initial meeting in April 2011. At that meeting the members reviewed the requirements of P.A. 135, elected officers, identified topics for discussion at future meetings, and took public comment. The group met three more times, in July, September and November 2011. All meetings were conducted as open meetings. Minutes of the meetings follow this summary. Because of the wide variety of knowledge among the council members, initial meetings focused on presentations intended to help the entire group form a common understanding of the issues surrounding the development of complete streets. Presentations included information on complete streets policy, best practices, funding, and safety. Additional presentations on legal liability, MDOT’s context sensitive approach to project development, and Governor Snyder’s special message to the legislature – “Better Roads Drive Better Jobs” – were also provided. Copies of the presentations are included in Appendix B. The Council members worked together to develop a vision for complete streets in Michigan that would help inform future policy development by the State Transportation Commission (STC). They also researched complete streets policies in other states and submitted sample language for consideration by the STC. The sample language reflects four aspects of complete streets policy as detailed in P.A. 135, including safety, cost, context and functional classification of the