Charlie Rose's Elite Meet-And-Greet
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Special Issue: FAIR Studies PBS’s Top News Shows U.S./CANADA $4.95 NOVEMBER 2010 Vol. 23, No. 11 Can Need to Know Replace Now? Who Owns NewsHour? Charlie Rose’s Insiders Inside-the-Beltway Week Extra!The Magazine of FAIR—The Media Watch Group Taking the Public Out of Public TV Extra! Contents Volume 23, Number 11 November 2010 The Magazine of FAIR—The Media Watch Group 3 SoundBites EDITOR Jim Naureckas MANAGING EDITOR Julie Hollar 4 Letters to the Editor PUBLISHER Deborah Thomas PROGRAM DIRECTOR Janine Jackson S P E C I A L I S S U E SENIOR ANALYST Steve Rendall ACTIVISM DIRECTOR Peter Hart SHIPPING & SALES Sanford Hohauser WEBSITE CONTRIBUTOR Gabriel Voiles Associates Hollie Ainbinder, Robin Andersen, Kim Deterline, Laura Flanders, Carolyn Francis, Karl Grossman, Edward Herman, Jim Horwitz, William Hoynes, Sam Husseini, Norman Solomon Interns/Volunteers Krystle Manintveld, Michael Morel Advisory Board 5 Public TV? It Would be a Good Idea James Abourezk, Edward Asner, Ben Bagdikian, Jackson Browne, Helen Caldicott, Noam Chomsky, But the system is stacked against fulfilling PBS’s mandate Mark Dowie, Barbara Ehrenreich, Susan Faludi, by Jim Naureckas Phillip Frazer, Herbert Chao Gunther, Doug Henwood, Dolores Huerta, Nicholas Johnson, Paula Kamen, Casey Kasem, Frances Moore Lappé, Katha Pollitt, 6 What PBS Thinks You Need to Know Tim Robbins, Susan Sarandon, Stacey Sher, Replacement for Now & Moyers fails to fill their shoes Bob Siegel, Eleanor Smeal, by Julie Hollar Steven Van Zandt, Helen Zia FAIR FOUNDER Jeff Cohen 8 Does NewsHour ‘Help Us See America Whole’? CounterSpin is engineered at Mercer Media. A FAIR study of PBS’s flagship news show by Steve Rendall and Michael Morel LEGAL COUNSEL William Schaap, Joel Kupferman FAIR/Extra! Editorial Office 11 What’s ‘Public’ About Public TV’s News Flagship? 104 West 27th Street, Suite 10B Publicly supported, corporately owned New York, NY 10001-6210 by Janine Jackson Tel.: 212-633-6700; Fax: 212-727-7668 [email protected] http://www.fair.org 13 Charlie Rose’s Elite Meet-and-Greet For them, by them Subscription Inquiries: by Peter Hart [email protected] Newsstand circulation through Disticor: 15 This Week in Beltway Think Magazine Distribution Services. Public TV’s font of conventional wisdom For more newsstand information call 905-619-6565, or fax 905-619-2903, or e-mail [email protected] by Peter Hart Extra! (ISSN 0895-2310) is published monthly by FAIR (Fairness & Accuracy In Reporting, Inc.). U.S. & Canadian Cover art by Jem Sullivan. subscriptions are $25 per year (foreign $48), write to FAIR/Extra! Subscription Service, P.O. Box 170, Congers, FAIR, the national media watch group, has been offering well-documented criticism NY 10920-9930, call 800-847-3993, or email extra@cambey of media bias and censorship since 1986. We work to invigorate the First west.com. Periodicals postage paid at NY, NY 10001 and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address Amendment by advocating for greater diversity in the press and by scrutinizing changes to FAIR’s 10920-9930 address. © FAIR 2010. All media practices that marginalize public interest, minority and dissenting viewpoints. rights reserved. As an anti-censorship organization, we expose neglected news stories and defend PRINTED IN THE U.S.A. working journalists when they are muzzled. As a progressive group, FAIR believes that structural reform is ultimately needed to break up the dominant media conglom- erates, establish independent public broadcasting and promote strong non-profit sources of information. 2 N November 2010 Extra! SoundBites Public’s Longstanding home salaries: somewhere between Opposition to Roads $700,000 and $1.1 million dollars for When Haters Are Best Ignored the first one, and almost $3 million and Bridges ack in the 1980s, I went down to the state capitol steps in for the second. Matt Bai wrote of the Obama admin- BMontgomery, Alabama, to cover for my newspaper an event that was istration in the New York Times ‘Divisive’ Is billed by the press release as a “rally and press conference.” It turned (9/9/10), “Little was achieved by way out to be a one-man show by an out-of-town Ku Kluxer who was trying of investing in 21st-century infra- Mediaspeak for ‘Overwhelmingly Popular’ to get publicity for his newly published racist hate screed. No one structure, largely because the public showed up except me, two radio reporters and one local TV news crew. “As the first full week of the 2010 never seemed open to the idea of When it became clear how we were being played, I caucused with my general election season opens across huge new spending.” Really? When colleagues and asked them if any of them thought this was a news the country on Monday, Washington is Bloomberg (12/10/09) polled on this event worth covering. Nope. Then why would we cover this non-event, scheduled once again to debate last year, its write-up began: letting this racist jerk hurt the feelings of many of our good local folk immigration and gay men, lesbians “Americans want their government to and offending everyone except like-minded racists? No reason, we all and bisexuals in the military, two create jobs through spending on pub- agreed. As the s.o.b. began to spout, the TV guys folded up their gear, deeply divisive social issues that lic works, investments in alternative the radio folks hit the off button and I pocketed my notebook. We all threaten to polarize the conversation energy or skills training for the job- turned on our heels and walked away, hearing the desperate pleas of on the campaign trail,” the New York less.... Two-thirds of Americans back the ignored racist, first pleading for us to come back and then calling us Times’ Michael Shear reported boosting spending on infrastructure. the usual names. We laughed and returned empty-handed to our news (9/20/10). The most recent national Six of 10 also support more spending outlets. Not one of our editors disagreed with our call. poll (CBS, 8/20–24/10) found 75 on alternative energy to stimulate job —reporter Tom Gardner (FAIR Blog comment, 9/12/10) growth.” But maybe Bai knows about percent support for repealing Don’t a national referendum that was con- Ask Don’t Tell—deeply dividing the ducted that we somehow didn’t hear vast majority from the 19 percent ian anti-immigrant law (Extra!, 7/10), Over the past three years, that peace about. who oppose it. Immigration is a more yet the actual assistance U.S. gun has killed 92 West Bank Palestinians, actually polarizing issue, but when dealers are providing to violent crimi- according to B’Tselem figures. Pundits Were people are polled on the currently nals on the other side of the border is Depressing Then, Too pending legislative proposal for seldom noted in media accounts. Publishers, To read the newspapers just now is immigration reform, 70 percent Not E-Books, Are to see Bedlam let loose. Every person support it (Texas Tribune, 6/30/10). Vanishing Palestinians Pinching Authors in the country of super asinine pro- The Brookings Institution’s Martin “The digital revolution that is pensities, everyone who hates social Violence ‘Spills Over’— Indyk wrote a New York Times op-ed disrupting the economic model of the progress and loves deflation, feels From North to South (8/27/10) suggesting reasons to be book industry is having an outsize that his hour has come, and triumph- U.S. corporate media often treat hopeful about peace talks between impact on the careers of literary antly announces how, by refraining Mexican drug violence as a phenom- Israel and the Palestinian Authority— writers,” the Wall Street Journal’s from every form of economic activity, enon that threatens to “spill over” starting with, “First, violence is down Jeffrey Trachtenberg (9/28/10) reported we can become prosperous again. into the U.S. (Extra!, 6/09)—as in considerably in the region.” He point- in “Authors Feel Pinch in Age of —John Maynard Keynes (9/14/31; New York Times headlines like “Drug ed out that while 452 Israelis were E-Books.” “Priced much lower than quoted in Fabius Cartel Violence Spills Over killed in the violence during the hardcovers, many e-books generate Maximus, 6/21/10) From Mexico, Alarming Intifada back in 2002, only eight less income for publishers.... As a U.S.” (3/23/09) and “Wave Israelis have been killed since 2009, result, the publishers who nurtured Depends of Drug Violence Is and just two so far this year. generations of America’s top literary- What You Creeping Into Arizona From Completely unmentioned were fiction writers are approving fewer Mean by ‘Small’ Mexico, Officials Say” the roughly 1,500 Palestinians that book deals and signing fewer new To illustrate Republican (2/24/09). A report from have been killed since the Israeli writers. Most of those getting pub- claims that allowing the Mayors Against Illegal Guns assault on Gaza in December 2008— lished are receiving smaller Bush tax cuts to expire (9/10) underscores how the vast majority of whom were advances.” Trachtenberg is engaging for the wealthiest tax- this “spill over” metaphor minors or noncombatant adults, in sleight-of-hand here: While payers would hurt small distorts reality, noting that according to the Israeli human rights e-books generate less income for businesses, ABC World News “90 percent of guns recovered and group B’Tselem. publishers, they produce more profits, reporter Jonathan Karl (9/8/10) intro- traced from Mexican crime scenes A similar disappearing trick was since their per-copy costs are duced two small business owners: originated from gun dealers in the performed by the Washington Post dramatically lower (Extra!, 8/10).