George Kennan and the Russian Empire: How America's Conscience Became an Enemy of Tsarism
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
OP #277 George Kennan and the Russian Empire: How America’s Conscience Became an Enemy of Tsarism by Helen Hundley In 1885–1886, one of America’s the Atlantic Cable had alr eady failed most r espected r eporters, Geor ge twice. Perry McDonough Collins’ plan Kennan (1845–1924), changed his mind sought to solve the pr oblem through a about the basic natur e of the Imperial joint ef fort of the Russian Empir e and Russian government. 1 He would spend the United States. Thus, in 1865 and the subsequent four decades of his 1866, 3 the young George Kennan had a active life attempting to challenge U.S. fascinating adventur e, an adventur e policy and to mold U.S. public opin- which left him with a lifetime love— ion, a goal he was lar gely successful in Russia. achieving. After his first trip to the Kennan’s book about his travels, Russian Empire in the 1860s, he had Tent Life in Siberia gradually gained worked hard to create a benign portrait him some notoriety as an “expert” on of Russia. Given its location in Eur ope, the Russian Empire in the United its monar chical system, and its alien States, but did not pr ovide him with nature, this was no small feat. After his wealth. 4 It took some years after experiences with critics of the Russian returning fr om his first trip to the government in 1885 and 1886, he Russian Empire to establish himself. In sought to expose the American public time, he found a car eer in r eporting, and government to the evils of the and became a premier r eporter for the Russian government while separating new Associated Press. Over his car eer, its actions fr om the Russians as a he wr ote on American politics, the people. To a great extent Kennan owed Spanish-American War, Pr esident his change of opinion to the influence McKinley’s death, the Russo-Japanese of the Siberian patriot, Nicholas War, World War I, and the Russian Mikhailovich Iadrintsev (1842–1894), Revolution. 5 He wr ote for a wide and his wide cir cle of friends and variety of journals including the “hot” acquaintances, both inside and outside magazines and newspapers of his of Siberia. 2 The meeting of these two times including Century Magazine , men, early in Kennan’s investigation of Atlantic Monthly , and The Outlook .6 In the exile system, played a seminal r ole fact, a series written by Kennan might in the people he would meet, and the actually significantly impr ove the type of information he could access. readership numbers of a magazine. 7 Kennan was certainly in a posi- In no small amount due to tion to play the r ole he was to play. He Kennan’s efforts, by the 1880s a num- had been preparing for it for over ber of the American public saw the twenty years. An ar dent supporter of Russian Empire as benign, if exotic, the Union fr om Ohio, Kennan worked and filled with inter esting people. 8 A as a telegrapher during the early years number of elements played into that of the Civil War and distinguished per ception. At times, the Russian himself in the critical Cincinnati center. Empire was per ceived as being He then joined an exciting adventure, America’s “only” friend in Eur ope. an expedition to plan the laying of Secondly, the sale of Russian America telegraph line acr oss Siberia in or der to to the United States, in addition to allow swift communication between being a “Seward’s Folly” joke, was also the United States and the European pr esented in some of the American powers. At that time, the attempt to lay pr ess as a transaction which cheated 1 the Russian government when the These words were r epeated in a United States failed to see that the series of lectur es initiated in the early Russian government received all that 1880s by the pr ominent New York had been promised. minister, the abolitionist, Henry Ward Finally and tellingly, the Russian Beecher. In closing his lectur e, Empire faced “evil r evolutionaries” in Armstrong used equally unequivocal the 1880s. Americans, for their part, language, “...Russia is among States certainly wer e incr easingly fearful of the monster criminal of the nineteenth “Eastern European bomb-throwing century. Ther e ar e no evidences in anarchists” as they viewed some of the Siberia or elsewher e that can be legiti- immigrants to their own country who mately, or even decently, adduced to had opposed the Tsar or other Eur opean vindicate befor e Americans either the governments in Europe. The 1881 humanity or the justice of that em- assassination of Tsar Ale ks andr II only pire.”10 Even though serfdom had served to justify the Russian exile str uc- ended, to Armstrong and others, the tur e. Ther efor e, even to some Americans, Russian Empire continued to deserve despite its monar chist government, all the approbation of civilized people those who criticized the Russian govern- because of its policy of imprisoning ment must be wrong. and abusing lar ge numbers of its Kennan was not the person who people in Siberia, for actions which initially challenged the very views on would not be illegal in democratic Russia that he had helped to cr eate, societies. but he certainly pr ovided the most Armstrong sought to spark a influential opposition to the Tsarist battle specifically with Kennan, as the government after he changed his dean of knowledgeable American mind. Another man initiated that specialists on Russia, and one who public battle. William Jackson her etofor e had pr esented a positive Armstrong served as an inspector of view of Russia. If Kennan could “see U.S. Consulates in Pr esident Grant’s the light” his change of heart would be second term. After his experience in taken seriously by important people. Russia he came to believe that: The succeeding battle of words with You have been used to hearing Kennan in print and on the lectur e that this Tsar [Aleksandr II] is a cir cuit stirr ed up public inter est in the liberal-despot and a kind-hearted exact “natur e” of the Russian Empir e, man. You have associated his as could be clearly displayed in the figur e in a sublime act with that Siberian exile system. towering executive Chief of this At first, Armstrong’s attacks republic—Abraham Lincoln. I seemed anti-Russian to Kennan, which mean the emancipation of the caused him to strike back in defense serfs. But in thinking of their against those who criticized Russians. deaths, keep always this clear At this time, Kennan generally de- distinction in mind. Abraham fended all things Russian. For ex- Lincoln was assassinated for a ample, in 1882 Kennan lambasted cause which liberated 3 million those who sought to attack the Sibe- slaves. Aleksandr II was killed for rian exile system in a scholarly article the enslavement of ninety mil- in the Bulletin of the American Geo- lions of people—the one the graphical Society in which he pr esented martyr of Liberty, the other the an outline of the criticism dir ected at martyr of Despotism. 9 the Russian system. 11 Kennan saw two 2 special pr ongs of the attack, one fr o m support his wife, Emeline Kennan, partisan English papers, and the other while he was overseas. The Century from misguided Siberians. Kennan Company also held out the possibility criticized the inflammatory agenda of that it might publish any book arising the English “Tory papers” in their fr om this expedition. 15 To the company, attempt to isolate the Russian Empir e it did not matter what he discover ed, for international political r easons. at the very least, Kennan could be Secondly, to Kennan, if the English had expected to write another very popular a political agenda, Siberians practiced travel account. the economic NIMBY [Not in My Back Kennan attacked every issue he Yar d] of the nineteenth century. In w r ote on fr om a scholarly approach. Kennan’s analysis, after they became His work on Siberian exile was no prosperous, Siberians sought to rid differ ent. Planned articles and a book themselves of this institution which in on the Siberian exile system would be no way added to property values. Tw o resear ched fr om every point of view. Russians were specifically unmer ci- Kennan began his work with an fully pilloried by Kennan, S. Maximov, advantage few outsiders bothered to for his Siberia and the Hard Labour Exile , seek, he learned Russian. He was thus and N.M. Iadrintsev. To Kennan, able to hold conversations with every- Maximov and Iadrintsev’s works were, one he met, whether or not the inter - “...pr ejudiced and one-sided, but in pr eter was available or willing for him many cases untrue....”12 Kennan was to speak to certain people. Kennan genuinely incensed and disgusted by then sought to see as much of the exile their criticism of Russian governmen- system that he could, and meet as tal policy. Unknowingly, he attacked many people, both administrators and the very person who would soon help exiles, as possible. to change his mind for ever concerning To this end, for his trip to Siberia, not only Siberian exile, but the natur e both befor e and after his arrival in St. of the Russian government as well. Petersbur g, Kennan sought to obtain 1885 Trip to Siberia.