Psychosocial Attitudes Affecting Counseling of Homosexual Males with AIDS/ARC

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Psychosocial Attitudes Affecting Counseling of Homosexual Males with AIDS/ARC University of Nebraska at Omaha DigitalCommons@UNO Student Work 8-1-1988 Psychosocial Attitudes Affecting Counseling of Homosexual Males with AIDS/ARC Norma A. Morehouse University of Nebraska at Omaha Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unomaha.edu/studentwork Recommended Citation Morehouse, Norma A., "Psychosocial Attitudes Affecting Counseling of Homosexual Males with AIDS/ ARC" (1988). Student Work. 1842. https://digitalcommons.unomaha.edu/studentwork/1842 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@UNO. It has been accepted for inclusion in Student Work by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@UNO. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THESIS ACCEPTANCE Acceptance for the faculty of the Graduate College, University of Nebraska, in partial fulfillment of the requirments for the degree Master of Arts in Counseling and Guidance, University of Nebraska at Omaha. Committee Name Department c^r^>o 7c^/ o < y1 iV&M 4 // Ctu^r/s: i V— -------- / / % iM. Chairman / Psychosocial Attitudes Affecting Counseling of Homosexual Males with AIDS/ARC A Thesis Presented to the Department of Counseling and Guidance and the Faculty of the Graduate College University of Nebraska In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts University of Nebraska at Omaha by Norma A. Morehouse August, 1988 UMI Number: EP73582 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation ftM sNng UMI EP73582 Published by ProQuest LLC (2015). Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code ProQuest’ ProQuest LLC. 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106- 1346 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS To have been as accepted by the gay community as the researcher has been, has made this thesis a personal experience rich beyond imagination. This acceptance created a feeling of overbrimming fulness which has made it a pleasure to be in the company of so many wonderful men. It is impossible to express the amount of gratitude felt by the researcher whose life has been touched through association with the homosexual males encountered during this project. Four men, in particular, are given the researcher's heartfelt thanks. The life of the researcher has been enriched by the openness and trust demonstrated by the interviewees. Their contribution made this thesis possible and meaningful, and the researcher is greatful to them. There is no way the researcher could have selected a more compatible, cooperative, supportive thesis committee. Dr. Robert Butler, chairperson, consistently gave excellent critique of areas needing work, and correctly targeted the direction of the next step. Dr. Richard Blake supplied information early in the project which was invaluable in allowing the researcher to construct the proposal of the thesis. Dr. James Thorson supplied a creative spark from the moment he recommended qualitative methodology. Dr. Thorson's knowledge in the area of death and dying was most helpful and expedient. Dr. Wayne Wheeler exemplified excellence in teaching as he assisted the researcher with qualitative methods during this thesis. Dr. Wheeler's ability and willingness to share his expertise in interviewing with the researcher made the project "doable". Father Michael Tan Creti, personal advisor, gave both spiritual and scholastic direction. It has been the counsel of Fr. Tan Creti which has enabled the researcher throughout to maintain focus on her responsibility to the people involved. The writer's thesis committee gave support through encouragement, motivation, focus, challenge, and genuine interest in both the researcher and the topic. Assistance was available when needed. Clarity of thought, intellect, and professionalism were modeled well for the researcher by her committee members. Input was specific and invaluable. A sincere and indebted thank you goes to each committee member. Were it not for one woman, this thesis may not have happened. At the very least, it certainly wouldn't have happened as well as it did. This woman is Reverend Jan Kross. Because of her attitude towards the researcher and this thesis, Rev. Kross paved the way for acceptance of the researcher into the gay community. The researcher expresses special thanks to a deserving woman for enhancing the project's richness. Technically, Dr. Donna Holmquist in the Department of Teacher Education, and Joyce Crockett and Roger Hubbard in the Training and Computer Information Center were of tremendous assistance in the transcription and preparation of the thesis. Their time and assistance has been greatly appreciated. A loving thank you goes to family and friends who have been understanding and patient while this thesis has come about. Loved ones have been willing to loan everything from ears to money as a means of helping the researcher reach her goal. Being a known observer made it easy for the researcher to be herself, and she was well accepted from the beginning. The second week of attending services at a church, which has a large homosexual membership, brought an invitation from one of the church members to attend a bi-monthly AIDS support group, and also a monthly interfaith healing service. Among these three organizations— the church with a large gay membership, the AIDS support group, and the healing service— the researcher was able to pursue her topic. TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter 1, INTRODUCTION................................... 1 Chapter 2, REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE.............. 8 Chapter 3, METHODOLOGY.................................... 17 Interviewing.......................................... 17 Population............................................ 17 Subject A ........................................ 18 Subject B ........................................ 19 Subject C ........................................ 19 Subject D ........................................ 20 Analysis of Data..................................... 21 Chapter 4, CASE ANALYSES.................................. 22 Subject A ................. 23 Subject B ............................................. 30 Subject C ............................................. 38 Subject D ............................................. 47 Chapter 5, DISCUSSION..................................... 57 Changes in Meaningfulness of Life.................... 57 Attitudes Toward Homosexuality...................... 59 Intolerant Views................................ 59 Coping........................................... 60 AIDS Stress..................................... 61 Misconception About Homosexuality.............. 62 Coupling......................................... 63 Religion......................................... 64 Chapter 6, COMMENTS, CONCLUSIONS, RECOMMENDATIONS......... 65 Commments............................................. 65 Conclusions........................................... 66 Recommendations...................................... 69 BIBLIOGRAPHY............................................... 72 Appendix A: First Interview with Subject A .............. 75 Appendix B: Second Interview with Subject A ............. 92 Appendix C: First Interview with Subject B ............... 102 Appendix D: Second Interview with Subject B .............. 135 Appendix E: Interview with Subject C ..................... 145 Appendix F: First Interview with Subject D ............... 171 Appendix G: Second Interview with Subject D .............. 193 1 Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION As the decade of the 1980s draws to a close, it ushers in the last decade of the twentieth century. "New Age" thinking, which attempts to withhold judgement and accept individuals as unique and necessary to the whole, challenges society to more fully understand those issues such as homosexuality which have in the past caused division. New Age thinking is defined by the researcher as a philosophy in which an holistic approach to health is essential. Mind, body, and spirit— respect for these is a healthy life. Conversation about holistic health and healing is a common theme heard throughout Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS)-related group activities. Along with balance in life, holistic counseling methods challenge and increase individual "response ability". Likewise, increased response ability brings increased awareness that each of us is simply an equal part of the whole? and, therefore, necessary. On a universal scale, then, only our problems exist. AIDS is one of our problems. The Surgeon General's Report on AIDS (1987) states, "The changes in our society...will affect our social institutions, our educational practices, and our health care. Although AIDS may never touch you personally, the societal impact 2 certainly will" (p. 28). With death and dying the area of interest during graduate study, the researcher had a natural tendency to be curious about the affects of AIDS upon the gay community. Last August, the researcher began attending services at a church which has a congregation comprised largely of homosexual men and women in order to observe this particular group of people. The researcher, accepted from the beginning, was scrutinized
Recommended publications
  • Experiences of Youth in the Sex Trade in Chicago: Issues in Youth Poverty and Homelessness
    The author(s) shown below used Federal funds provided by the U.S. Department of Justice and prepared the following final report: Document Title: Experiences of Youth in the Sex Trade in Chicago: Issues in Youth Poverty and Homelessness Author(s): Laurie Schaffner, Grant Buhr, Deana Lewis, Marco Roc, Haley Volpintesta Document No.: 249954 Date Received: June 2016 Award Number: 2009-MC-CX-0001 This report has not been published by the U.S. Department of Justice. To provide better customer service, NCJRS has made this federally funded grant report available electronically. Opinions or points of view expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. Experiences of Youth in the Sex Trade in Chicago Issues in Youth Poverty and Homelessness By Laurie Schaffner, Grant Buhr, deana lewis, Marco Roc, and Haley Volpintesta 520 Eighth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, New York 10018 646.386.3100 fax 212.397.0985 www.courtinnovation.org This document is a research report submitted to the U.S. Department of Justice. This report has not been published by the Department. Opinions or points of view expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. Experiences of Youth in the Sex Trade in Chicago: Issues in Youth Poverty and Homelessness By Laurie Schaffner, Grant Buhr, deana lewis, Marco Roc, and Haley Volpintesta © March 2016 Center for Court Innovation 520 Eighth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, New York 10018 646.386.3100 fax 212.397.0985 www.courtinnovation.org This document is a research report submitted to the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • University of Houston Oral History of Houston Project Early LGBT Houston
    HHA# 00820 Interviewee: Van Cleave, Kay Interview Date: July 6, 2010 University of Houston Oral History of Houston Project Early LGBT Houston Interviewee: Kay Van Cleave Interview Date: July 6, 2010 Place: Van Cleave Home, Houston Heights Interviewer: John Goins Transcriber: Michelle Kokes Keywords: Gay life, 1950s, 1960s, Houston, Diana’s, Diana Awards, Houston gay bars, Rock Hudson, gay life for blacks, lesbians, gay men, drag queens, fund raising, house parties, race, class, A Group, Charles Hebert, Lambda, Houston Gay Pride Abstract: Born in 1937 and moving to Houston in 1953, Kay Van Cleave offers a glimpse into early gay life there and the beginnings of its organization. As a member of the group that founded the Diana’s in the 1950s, she was present at the earliest of the events. In her early years, she associated with an elite, moneyed, group that did not involve itself politically. Her interview reveals the atmosphere in the fifties and sixties with regard to coming out in those years, the lifestyle of gay individuals, and the issues of race and class. In time, however, Kay became more “out” publicly and participated in groups that she considered to be important. This included among others, membership in PFLAG and forming the first Alcoholics Anonymous chapter, Lambda, for gay women and men in Houston. HHA# 00820 Page 1 of 40 Interviewee: Van Cleave, Kay Interview Date: July 6, 2010 UNIVERSITY OF HOUSTON ORAL HISTORY OF HOUSTON PROJECT Kay Van Cleave Interviewed by: John Goins Date: July 6, 2010 Transcribed by: Michelle Kokes Location: Houston, Texas KVC: Okay I was born in 1937 in Fort Worth, Texas and my aunt (my father’s sister) had a lot of money.
    [Show full text]
  • How REAL ID's Credibility and Corroboration Requirements Impair
    CONROY_MACRO2 (DO NOT DELETE) 4/20/2009 9:47:08 AM Real Bias: How REAL ID’s Credibility and Corroboration Requirements Impair Sexual Minority Asylum Applicants Melanie A. Conroy† I. INTRODUCTION ..........................................................................................2 II. SEXUAL MINORITIES AND THE LAW OF ASYLUM.......................................3 III. PRE-REAL ID CREDIBILITY AND CORROBORATION LAW AND PROBLEMS..................................................................................................5 A. Pre-Real ID Corroboration Law......................................................... 5 B. Pre-Real ID Corroboration Problems................................................. 7 i. Corroborating the Persecution of Similarly-Situated Individuals ...................................................................................8 ii. Corroborating One’s Sexual Minority Membership ..................10 C. Pre-Real ID Credibility Law............................................................ 11 D. Pre-Real ID Credibility Problems .................................................... 13 i. Airport Statements .....................................................................13 ii. The Social Visibility Requirement: Demeanor, Plausibility, and Consistency .........................................................................15 iii. Social Constructions of Gender and Sexuality: External Consistency................................................................................18 IV. REAL ID: ITS HISTORY, CONTENT,
    [Show full text]
  • Heterosexism Within Educational Institutions
    HETEROSEXISM WITHIN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS: COPING EFFORTS OF LESBIAN, GAY, AND BISEXUAL STUDENTS IN WEST TEXAS by VIRGINIA J. MAHAN, B.A., M.Sp.Ed. A DISSERTATION IN EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGY Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of Texas Tech University in Partial FulfiUment of the Requirements for the Degree of DOCTOR OF EDUCATION Approved December, 1998 /, Ac f3 7^? z^ ^.3 1 A/^ ^ l'^ C'S Copyright 1998, Virginia J. Mahan ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I particularly wish to thank the nine members of the Steering Committee of the Lambda Social Network who served on my advisory panel and offered comments on the first draft of Chapter IV, as well as other external reviewers: Gene Dockins, Lawrence Holbrooks, M. M., Dorinda Ann Ruiz, Virginia, and other anonymous readers. I am grateful to my committee members, Mary Tallent Runnels, Camille DeBell, and Richard Powell, for their support and valuable assistance. My appreciation goes to Terry Ann Andersen, Kathy Lewallen and the rest of the library staff at South Plains College for their assistance, as well as to Fred Logan and Kaaren Mahan for running innumerable errands. I am also grateful to Texas Tech University which provided partial support for this study through a 1998 Summer Research Scholarship Award. Pivotal to this dissertation, of course, are the 14 lesbian and gay college and university students who told their sometimes painful tales so that educators might hear, learn, and know what it is like to be a gay student in Texas. I will forever hear the echoes of their voices. Lastly, thanks to Victor Shea for his courageous letter to the editor and to whom this dissertation is dedicated.
    [Show full text]
  • Heterosexist Suspicion of a Queer Outsider
    Heterosexist Suspicion of a Queer Outsider by Quinn McGlade-Ferentzy A Thesis presented to The University of Guelph In partial fulfilment of requirements for the degree of Masters of Arts in Philosophy Guelph, Ontario, Canada © McGlade-Ferentzy, January, 2020 !ii ABSTRACT HETEROSEXIST SUSPICION OF A QUEER OUTSIDER Quinn McGlade-Ferentzy Advisor(s): University of Guelph, 2019 Samantha Brennan Maya Goldenburg This project is an attempt to reconcile an increased legal inclusion of queer people into Canadian law, with an existing and troubling vein of transphobic thought in feminist philosophy. The centre of this project is Bill C-16, and how this bill exemplifies the classic liberal ideals of equality. All citizens should, in theory, be able to participate in public life. My goal is to explore what norms make this difficult if not impossible, and different ways to think about citizenship that can ameliorate inequality. My core interest is to answer, “why don’t people listen”? I use this question to ask why people do not listen to women about sexism, to non binary people about their gender, and so forth. I ask “why don’t people listen?” to explore the ways in which our understanding of belonging and civility, and even reasonableness, is rooted in a binary gender system !iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS To my supervisors, Professor Samantha Brennan and Professor Maya Goldenburg, thank you for sticking through this project through the many twists and turns. Thank you to the Canadian Society for Women in Philosophy, for giving space for the paper that grew into this. Thank you to Professor Kathryrn Norlock who let me do a huge undergraduate thesis at a school that didn’t offer that as an option.
    [Show full text]
  • 12/2008 Mechanical, Photocopying, Recording Without Prior Written Permission of Ukchartsplus
    All rights reserved. No portion of this publication may be reproduced, stored in Issue 383 a retrieval system, posted on an Internet/Intranet web site, forwarded by email, or otherwise transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, 27/12/2008 mechanical, photocopying, recording without prior written permission of UKChartsPlus Symbols: Platinum (600,000) Number 1 Gold (400,000) Silver (200,000) 12” Vinyl only 7” Vinyl only Download only Pre-Release For the week ending 27 December 2008 TW LW 2W Title - Artist Label (Cat. No.) High Wks 1 NEW HALLELUJAH - Alexandra Burke Syco (88697446252) 1 1 1 1 2 30 43 HALLELUJAH - Jeff Buckley Columbia/Legacy (88697098847) -- -- 2 26 3 1 1 RUN - Leona Lewis Syco ( GBHMU0800023) -- -- 12 3 4 9 6 IF I WERE A BOY - Beyoncé Columbia (88697401522) 16 -- 1 7 5 NEW ONCE UPON A CHRISTMAS SONG - Geraldine Polydor (1793980) 2 2 5 1 6 18 31 BROKEN STRINGS - James Morrison featuring Nelly Furtado Polydor (1792152) 29 -- 6 7 7 2 10 USE SOMEBODY - Kings Of Leon Hand Me Down (8869741218) 24 -- 2 13 8 60 53 LISTEN - Beyoncé Columbia (88697059602) -- -- 8 17 9 5 2 GREATEST DAY - Take That Polydor (1787445) 14 13 1 4 10 4 3 WOMANIZER - Britney Spears Jive (88697409422) 13 -- 3 7 11 7 5 HUMAN - The Killers Vertigo ( 1789799) 50 -- 3 6 12 13 19 FAIRYTALE OF NEW YORK - The Pogues featuring Kirsty MacColl Warner Bros (WEA400CD) 17 -- 3 42 13 3 -- LITTLE DRUMMER BOY / PEACE ON EARTH - BandAged : Sir Terry Wogan & Aled Jones Warner Bros (2564692006) 4 6 3 2 14 8 4 HOT N COLD - Katy Perry Virgin (VSCDT1980) 34 --
    [Show full text]
  • Chase and Status Blind Faith Mp3 Zippy
    Chase And Status Blind Faith Mp3 Zippy 1 / 4 Chase And Status Blind Faith Mp3 Zippy 2 / 4 3 / 4 Chase and status ft liam bailey blind faith mp3 download. Click here to get file. Chase status blind faith feat liam bailey live from london s o2 arena youtube.. DiRT 3 Soundtrack - Chase & Status feat. ... Dirt 3 OST - Track 07 - Blind Faith 9 ... Soundtrack Mp3 Download: http://www53.zippyshare.com/v/19973658/file.html ... DIRT 3 loading song/music Blind Faith - Chase and Status Ft. Liam Bailey.. Check out Blind Faith [feat. Liam Bailey] by Chase & Status on Amazon Music. Stream ad- free or purchase CD's ... Add to MP3 Cart. Song in MP3 cart View MP3 .... All goes wrong feat tom grennan salvatore ganacci remix single chase mp3 ... KEYWORDS Status, chase and status blind faith, chase and status end credits, ... All Goes Wrong ( Salvatore Ganacci Remix) 320kbps mp3 free from zippyshare.. Blind Faith. Original Mix. $1.29. Link: Embed: Artists Chase & Status, Liam Bailey. Release. $5.16. Length 3:53; Released 2011-01-21; BPM 140; Key D min .... DiRT 3 Soundtrack - Chase & Status feat. Liam Bailey - Blind Faith 8.6 ... Original Soundtrack Mp3 Download: http://www53.zippyshare.com/v/19973658/file.html .... High Contrast – If We Ever (Unglued Remix) deadmau5 – Avaritia (Dimension Bootleg) Chase & Status – Blind Faith (Loadstar Remix) (feat.. ɑ~ɗɛpʈ˷ɕ∆ʈ ⬇ DownLoad archive(MP3, 320kbps) ⬇ ... 3:54. Chase & Status. Blind Faith (feat. ... 3:33. Chase and Status - No More Idols (2011).rar. 131 МБ.. Listen on the SoundCloud app. No more previews, just full tracks.
    [Show full text]
  • PROFESSOR GREEN Looking Ahead to Another Oxford Visit
    @omsmagazine AUGUST 2011 Oxford's clubbing and electronic magazine FREE PROFESSOR GREEN looking ahead to another Oxford visit ALSO GOTTWOOD FESTIVAL, FIESTA IN THE PARK LIVE KID FURY DJ MIX – SAMPLER EXCLUSIVE / LEE ‘SCRATCH’ PERRY ANDsee back ROOTS issues at www.oxfordmusicscene.co.uk MANUVA / TOOTS & THE MAYTALS PREVIEW WELCOME Welcome to Issue 2 of the Sampler. There’s lots been happening since the first one hit the streets back in May – lots of @omsmagazine new people got in touch wanting to AUGUST 2011 Oxford's clubbing and electronic magazine write for us, and we got a pile of great FREE feedback from people who said how much they liked it and how much it was needed to bring the Oxford dance scene together. All great to hear. Please PROFESSOR GREEN looking ahead to another Oxford visit ALSO GOTTWOOD FESTIVAL, FIESTA IN KID FURY DJ MIX – SAMPLERLIVE do keep the feedback coming… THE PARK AND ROOTS MANUVA / TOOT see back issues at www. EXCLUSIVE / LEE ‘SCRATCH’ PERRY oxfordmusicscene.co.uk S & THE MAYTALS PREVIEW Next issue of the Sampler in October… Much love Stewart and the Sampler team xx Thanks to all the contributors for their help with this issue: Leo Bowder, Holly Davis, Claire Williams, Tom McKibbin, Andrew Fletcher, Will Gilgrass, Sam Saywood, Josh Lake, Dudley Prince, Will Attwooll, Oliver Sheerin, Robin Lomax, Sam King, Mark Grafton Publisher: Back & To The Left [email protected] Design: Obergine / www.obergine.com The Sampler is the sister publication of Oxfordshire Music Scene magazine www.oxfordmusicscene.co.uk Proud
    [Show full text]
  • APPENDIX D the Interview Transcriptions Olivia
    The Experience of Coming Out 207 APPENDIX D The Interview Transcriptions Olivia [1] Can you tell me when the possibility first occurred to you that you were sexually attracted to women? I think I was about…23. I was asexual…for a long time. Through undergrad and the first part of grad school. A woman approached me. Many women would approach me. And um…a lot of people assumed I was gay before I even acknowledged or even dealt with it. Once I left my father’s house, I just was not sexual. [2] So you were 23 years old, and then what happened? You were out of the house. I was out of the house. I was in graduate school already. Her name was Sara Lincoln. She befriended me. There were a couple of women but I didn’t really know what the response was. To give you some background on that, my mother left my father when I was ten. Okay? Um, So he…there was four of us, and he raised us. I took her place in the household. Okay, um …[pause] and I was a chubby child. I was bulimic. And as a young adult, I didn’t want the weight. I didn’t like um “you have a fat ass” type of thing. So even now my sister goes through this thing about how I eat. Um…If I gain, you know, too much weight I [shifted around on the couch with a deep breath] get real paranoid-hysterical? Because I don’t like the attraction of the body.
    [Show full text]
  • Music of the American Indian: Plains: Comanche, Cheyenne, Kiowa
    The Library of Congress Motion Picture, Broadcasting and Recorded Sound Division Recording Laboratory AfS L39 MUSIC OF THE AMERICAN INDIAN PLAINS: COMANCHE, CHEYENNE, KIOWA, CADDO, WICHITA, PAWNEE From the Archive of Folk Culture Recorded and Edited by Willard Rhodes First issued on long-playing record in 1954. Accompanying booklet published 1982. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number 82-743369 Available from the Recording Laboratory, Library of Congress, Washington, D .C. 20540. Cover illustration: DANCE OF THE DOG SOLDIER SOCIETIES, by Dick West. Courtesy Philbrook Art Center. Dedicated to the memory of Willard W. Beatty, Director of Indian Education for the Bureau of Indian Affairs, Department of the Interior, from 1937 to 1951. • • FOREWORD TO THE 1954 EDITION • • For a number of years the Bureau of Indian Affairs has sponsored the recording of typical Indian music throughout the United States. During this time approximately a thousand Indian songs have been recorded by Mr. Willard Rhodes, professor of music at Columbia Univer­ sity. The study originated in an effort to deter­ mine the extent to which new musical themes were continuing to develop. Studies have shown that in areas of Indian concentration, especially in the Southwest, the old ceremonial songs are still used in the traditional fashion. In the Indian areas where assimilation has been greater, Indian­ type music is still exceedingly popular. There is considerable creative activity in the development of new secular songs which are used for social gatherings. These songs pass from reservation to reservation with slight change. While the preservation of Indian music through recordings contributes only a small part to the total understanding of American Indians, it is nevertheless an important key to this understand­ ing.
    [Show full text]
  • The Instrumental Revolutions
    Concept-Driven Revolutions and Tool-Driven Revolutions: Dyson, Kuhn and Galison José Luis González Quirós, CSIC, Manuel González Villa, UCM Abstract: Freeman J. Dyson has introduced the notion of tool-driven revolution that stands in contrast to the concept-driven revolutions analysed by Thomas Kuhn in The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. We study Dyson‟s thesis, pay special attention in the interesting Dyson‟s idea of scientific tool and compare Dyson‟s point of view with Peter Galison‟s conception, as developed in Image and Logic. It seems that the differences between them are slightly stronger than Dyson suggests. Dyson‟s ideas yield some where between Galison and Ian Hacking, whose notion of disunity of science seems to be related to the abundance of tools and tool-driven revolutions Dyson has pointed. Freeman J. Dyson, the retired British scientist, who has spent most of his scientific career in Princeton at the Institute for Advanced Studies, speaks in his recent books (Dyson, 1997, 49-55; 1999, 13-21) about the existence of tool-driven revolutions, in contrast to the concept-driven revolutions analysed by Kuhn in The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Tool-driven revolutions arise in relation to the invention of new tools or instruments designed to investigate nature and discover new facts that challenge our previous concepts. According to Dyson (1997, 50), whereas Kuhnian revolutions provide some new concepts to understand nature, “explain old things in new ways,” tool-driven revolutions allow us to discover “new things that have to be explained.” Dyson states that this kind of revolution has been decisive in the recent development of most sciences, particularly in main fields such as biology1 and astronomy, and that most of the latest scientific revolutions have been tool- driven.
    [Show full text]
  • Against the Grain
    II Against the Grain apache. at. 40 In Africa every morning a gazelle“ awakens knowing that it must out-run the fastest lion if it wants to stay alive. Every morning a lion wakes up knowing that it must run faster than the slowest gazelle or it will starve to death. It makes no difference whether you are a lion or a gazelle: When the sun comes up you had better be running.” GROWTH AMID ADVERSITY During the oil and gas price collapse of the past decade... $30 $3 $20 $2 $10 $1 858869 87 88 90991 92 93 4858869 87 88 90991 92 93 4 OIL - $/BARREL GAS - $/THOUSANDCUBICFEET YEAR END PRICE YEAR END PRICE Apache countered by growing its production and critical mass. 40 40 300 Oil Oil 269 Gas Gas 31 231 30 28 25 200 188 180 19 20 17 106 96 11 100 87 9 10 8 61 56 6 38 85 8687 88 89 9091 92 93 94 85 8687 88 89 9091 92 93 94 PRODUCTION - MILLION BARRELS OF OIL EQUIVALENT RESERVES - MILLION BARRELS OF OIL EQUIVALENT Following the initial shock of lower prices, Apache’s strategy is paying off. $350 336 $35 Yearly High $300 $30 Year–End $250 $25 Yearly Low 225 $200 189 194 $20 168 157 $150 $15 106 $100 91 $10 58 $50 40 $5 85 8687 88 89 9091 92 93 94 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 CASH FLOW - IN $ MILLIONS SHARE PRICE TO THE READER n December 6, 1994, Apache turned forty.
    [Show full text]