NDM2967 - Motion to suspend Standing Orders Cynnig i ohirio Rheolau Sefydlog (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 14:00:19)

Name Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour Did not vote Gibbons, Brian Labour Did not vote Hart, Edwina Labour Did not vote Hutt, Jane Labour Did not vote Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour Did not vote Davidson, Jane Labour Did not vote Pugh, Alun Labour Did not vote Davies, Jocelyn For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour Did not vote Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour Did not vote Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour Did not vote Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative Did not vote Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru Did not vote Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour Did not vote Sinclair, Karen Labour Did not vote Lloyd, Val Labour Did not vote Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour Did not vote James, Irene Labour Did not vote Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative Did not vote Cairns, Alun Conservative Did not vote Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative Did not vote Isherwood, Mark Conservative Did not vote

For: 31

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 31

NDM2968 - Motion to elect a Planning Decision Committee Cynnig i ethol Pwyllgor Penderfyniadau Cynllunio (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 14:00:58)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour Did not vote Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour Did not vote Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour Did not vote Davidson, Jane Labour Did not vote Pugh, Alun Labour Did not vote Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour Did not vote Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour Did not vote Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour Did not vote Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru Did not vote Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru For Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour Did not vote Sinclair, Karen Labour Did not vote Lloyd, Val Labour Did not vote Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour Did not vote James, Irene Labour Did not vote Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative Did not vote Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative Did not vote For: 38

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 38

Draft Business Statement Datganiad Busnes Drafft (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 14:57:52)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru Against Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru Against Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru Against Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru Against Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru Against Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat Against German, Mike Liberal Democrat Against Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative Against Graham, William Conservative Against Bourne, Nicholas Conservative Against Francis, Lisa Conservative Against Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru Against Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru Against Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru Against Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru Against Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Against Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Against Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat Against Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat Against Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative Against Melding, David Conservative Against Cairns, Alun Conservative Against Jones, Laura Anne Conservative Against Davies, Glyn Conservative Against Isherwood, Mark Conservative Against

For: 29

Abstain: 0

Against: 25

Total Votes: 54

NDM2947 - Motion to approve legislation under Standing Order 24.25 Cynnig i gymeradwyo deddfwriaeth o dan Reol Sefydlog 24.25 (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:17:09)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 52

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 52

NDM2948 Principle - The Community Health Council Egwyddor - Cyngor Iechyd Cymuned (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:21:18)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative Did not vote Jones, Laura Anne Conservative Did not vote Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 50

Abstain: 0

Against: 0 Total Votes: 50

NDM2949 Order - The Community Health Council Gorchymyn - Cyngor Iechyd Cymuned (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:21:43)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 52

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 52

NDM2950 Principle - The Public Services Ombudsman for Wales (Standards Investigations) Egwyddor - Ombwdsmon Gwasanaethau Cyhoeddus (Ymchwiliadau Safonau) (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:22:27) Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 52

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 52

NDM2951 Order - The Public Services Ombudsman for Wales (Standards Investigations) Gorchymyn - Ombwdsmon Gwasanaethau Cyhoeddus (Ymchwiliadau Safonau) (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:22:50)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 52

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 52 NDM2952 Principle - The National Health Service (Performers Lists (Wales) Egwyddor - Gwasanaeth Iechyd Gwladol (Rhestri Cyflawnwyr) (Cymru) (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:25:28)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru Did not vote Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 52

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 52

NDM2953 Regulations - The National Health Service (Performers Lists (Wales) Rheoliadau - Gwasanaeth Iechyd Gwladol (Rhestri Cyflawnwyr) (Cymru) (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:25:46)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 53

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 53

NDM2954 Principle - NHS Charges for Drugs and Appliances Egwyddor - Gwasanaeth Iechyd Gwladol (Ffioedd am Gyffuriau a Chyfarpar) (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:26:21)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 53

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 53 NDM2955 Regulations - NHS Charges for Drugs and Appliances Rheoliadau - Gwasanaeth Iechyd Gwladol (Ffioedd am Gyffuriau a Chyfarpar) (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:26:51)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat Did not vote Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 52

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 52

NDM2956 Principle - The Town and Country Planning (Fees for Application and Deemed Applications) Egwyddor - Cynllunio a Thref (Ffioedd ar gyfer Ceisiadau a Cheisiadau Tybiedig) (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:35:51)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For For: 53

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 53

NDM2957 Regulations - The Town and Country Planning (Fees for Application and Deemed Applications) Rheoliadau - Cynllunio Gwlad a Thref (Ffioedd ar gyfer Ceisiadau a Cheisiadau Tybiedig) (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:36:09)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru For Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 53

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 53 NDM2958 - Amendment 1 Gwelliant 1 (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:49:29)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour Against Gibbons, Brian Labour Against Hart, Edwina Labour Against Hutt, Jane Labour Against Morgan, Rhodri Labour Against Essex, Sue Labour Against Davies, Andrew Labour Against Davidson, Jane Labour Against Pugh, Alun Labour Against Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour Against Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour Against Chapman, Christine Labour Against Griffiths, John Labour Against Jones, Ann Labour Against Gwyther, Chris Labour Against Butler, Rosemary Labour Against Gregory, Janice Labour Against Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour Against Neagle, Lynne Labour Against Sinclair, Karen Labour Against Lloyd, Val Labour Against Andrews, Leighton Labour Against Cuthbert, Jeff Labour Against Idris Jones, Denise Labour Against Mewies, Sandy Labour Against Thomas, Catherine Labour Against Thomas, Gwenda Labour Against James, Irene Labour Against Barrett, Lorraine Labour Against Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 22

Abstain: 0

Against: 29

Total Votes: 51

NDM2958 - Amendment 2 Gwelliant 2 (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:49:55)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour Against Gibbons, Brian Labour Against Hart, Edwina Labour Against Hutt, Jane Labour Against Morgan, Rhodri Labour Against Essex, Sue Labour Against Davies, Andrew Labour Against Davidson, Jane Labour Against Pugh, Alun Labour Against Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru Against Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru Against Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru Against Lewis, Huw Labour Against Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour Against Chapman, Christine Labour Against Griffiths, John Labour Against Jones, Ann Labour Against Gwyther, Chris Labour Against Butler, Rosemary Labour Against Gregory, Janice Labour Against Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru Against Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru Against Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru Against Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru Against Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour Against Neagle, Lynne Labour Against Sinclair, Karen Labour Against Lloyd, Val Labour Against Andrews, Leighton Labour Against Cuthbert, Jeff Labour Against Idris Jones, Denise Labour Against Mewies, Sandy Labour Against Thomas, Catherine Labour Against Thomas, Gwenda Labour Against James, Irene Labour Against Barrett, Lorraine Labour Against Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 15

Abstain: 0

Against: 36 Total Votes: 51

NDM2958 Principle - The Children (Private Arrangements for Fostering) Egwyddor - Plant (Trefniadau Preifat ar gyfer Maethu) (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:50:22)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 51

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 51

NDM2959 Regulations - The Children (Private Arrangements for Fostering) Rheoliadau - Plant (Trefniadau Preifat ar gyfer Maethu) (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 16:50:47) Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 50

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 50

NDM2961 Principle - The General Dental Services and Personal Dental Services Egwyddor - Gwasanaethau Deintyddol Cyffredinol a Gwasanaethau Deintyddol Personol (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 17:09:59)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 51

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 51 NDM2962 Order - The General Dental Services and Personal Dental Services Gorchymyn - Gwasanaethau Deintyddol Cyffredinol a Gwasanaethau Deintyddol Personol (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 17:10:18)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative Did not vote Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 51

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 51

NDM2963 Principle - The Functions of Local Health Boards and the NHS Business Services Authority Egwyddor - Swyddogaethau Byrddau Iechyd Lleol ac Awdurdod Gwasanaethau Busnes y GIG (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 17:10:41)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 52

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 52

NDM2964 Regulations - The Functions of Local Health Boards and the NHS Business Services Authority Rheoliadau - Swyddogaethau Byrddau Iechyd Lleol ac Awdurdod Gwasanaethau Busnes y GIG (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 17:11:19)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour Did not vote Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 51

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 51 NDM2965 Principle - NHS (General Dental Services Contracts and Personal Dental Services Agreements) Egwyddor - Contractau Gwasanaethau Deintyddol Cyffredinol a Chytundebau Gwasanaethau Deintyddol Personol (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 17:11:43)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 52

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 52

NDM2966 Regulations - NHS (General Dental Services Contracts and Personal Dental Services Agreements) Rheoliadau - Contractau Gwasanaethau Deintyddol Cyffredinol a Chytundebau Gwasanaethau Deintyddol Personol (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 17:12:03)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour For Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour For Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour For Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour For Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour For Sinclair, Karen Labour For Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour For Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour For Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour For Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 52

Abstain: 0

Against: 0

Total Votes: 52

Procedural Motion Cynnig Gweithdrefnol (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 17:12:48)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour For Gibbons, Brian Labour For Hart, Edwina Labour For Hutt, Jane Labour For Morgan, Rhodri Labour For Essex, Sue Labour For Davies, Andrew Labour For Davidson, Jane Labour For Pugh, Alun Labour Did not vote Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour Against Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour For Chapman, Christine Labour For Griffiths, John Labour For Jones, Ann Labour Against Gwyther, Chris Labour For Butler, Rosemary Labour Against Gregory, Janice Labour For Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru Did not vote Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour For Neagle, Lynne Labour Against Sinclair, Karen Labour Against Lloyd, Val Labour For Andrews, Leighton Labour Against Cuthbert, Jeff Labour For Idris Jones, Denise Labour Against Mewies, Sandy Labour For Thomas, Catherine Labour For Thomas, Gwenda Labour For James, Irene Labour Against Barrett, Lorraine Labour For Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 42

Abstain: 0

Against: 8

Total Votes: 50 NDM2960 Amendment 1 Gwelliant 1 (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 17:58:57)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour Against Gibbons, Brian Labour Against Hart, Edwina Labour Against Hutt, Jane Labour Against Morgan, Rhodri Labour Against Essex, Sue Labour Against Davies, Andrew Labour Against Davidson, Jane Labour Against Pugh, Alun Labour Against Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour Against Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour Against Chapman, Christine Labour Against Griffiths, John Labour Against Jones, Ann Labour Against Gwyther, Chris Labour Against Butler, Rosemary Labour Against Gregory, Janice Labour Against Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour Against Neagle, Lynne Labour Against Sinclair, Karen Labour Against Lloyd, Val Labour Against Andrews, Leighton Labour Against Cuthbert, Jeff Labour Against Idris Jones, Denise Labour Against Mewies, Sandy Labour Against Thomas, Catherine Labour Against Thomas, Gwenda Labour Against James, Irene Labour Against Barrett, Lorraine Labour Against Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 22

Abstain: 0

Against: 29

Total Votes: 51

NDM2960 Amendment 2 Gwelliant 2 (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 17:59:28)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour Against Gibbons, Brian Labour Against Hart, Edwina Labour Against Hutt, Jane Labour Against Morgan, Rhodri Labour Against Essex, Sue Labour Against Davies, Andrew Labour Against Davidson, Jane Labour Against Pugh, Alun Labour Against Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour Against Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour Against Chapman, Christine Labour Against Griffiths, John Labour Against Jones, Ann Labour Against Gwyther, Chris Labour Against Butler, Rosemary Labour Against Gregory, Janice Labour Against Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour Against Neagle, Lynne Labour Against Sinclair, Karen Labour Against Lloyd, Val Labour Against Andrews, Leighton Labour Against Cuthbert, Jeff Labour Against Idris Jones, Denise Labour Against Mewies, Sandy Labour Against Thomas, Catherine Labour Against Thomas, Gwenda Labour Against James, Irene Labour Against Barrett, Lorraine Labour Against Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 21

Abstain: 0

Against: 29 Total Votes: 50

NDM2960 Amendment 3 Gwelliant 3 (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 18:00:00)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour Against Gibbons, Brian Labour Against Hart, Edwina Labour Against Hutt, Jane Labour Against Morgan, Rhodri Labour Against Essex, Sue Labour Against Davies, Andrew Labour Against Davidson, Jane Labour Against Pugh, Alun Labour Against Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour Against Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour Against Chapman, Christine Labour Against Griffiths, John Labour Against Jones, Ann Labour Against Gwyther, Chris Labour Against Butler, Rosemary Labour Against Gregory, Janice Labour Against Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat Abstained German, Mike Liberal Democrat Abstained Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour Against Neagle, Lynne Labour Against Sinclair, Karen Labour Against Lloyd, Val Labour Against Andrews, Leighton Labour Against Cuthbert, Jeff Labour Against Idris Jones, Denise Labour Against Mewies, Sandy Labour Against Thomas, Catherine Labour Against Thomas, Gwenda Labour Against James, Irene Labour Against Barrett, Lorraine Labour Against Black, Peter Liberal Democrat Abstained Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 19

Abstain: 3

Against: 29

Total Votes: 51

NDM2960 - Welsh Conservative Party nominated debate Dadl wedi'i henwebu gan Blaid Geidwadol Cymru (Tue Mar 28, +0100 2006 - 18:00:33)

Name Political Party Vote Jones, Carwyn Labour Against Gibbons, Brian Labour Against Hart, Edwina Labour Against Hutt, Jane Labour Against Morgan, Rhodri Labour Against Essex, Sue Labour Against Davies, Andrew Labour Against Davidson, Jane Labour Against Pugh, Alun Labour Against Davies, Jocelyn Plaid Cymru For Jones, Ieuan Wyn Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Rhodri Glyn Plaid Cymru Did not vote Jones, Elin Plaid Cymru For Lloyd, Dai Plaid Cymru For Lewis, Huw Labour Against Dunwoody, Tamsin Labour Against Chapman, Christine Labour Against Griffiths, John Labour Against Jones, Ann Labour Against Gwyther, Chris Labour Against Butler, Rosemary Labour Against Gregory, Janice Labour Against Randerson, Jenny Liberal Democrat For German, Mike Liberal Democrat For Williams, Kirsty Liberal Democrat Did not vote Morgan, Jonathan Conservative For Graham, William Conservative For Bourne, Nicholas Conservative For Francis, Lisa Conservative For Davies, Janet Plaid Cymru For Jones, Alun Ffred Plaid Cymru For Jones, Helen Mary Plaid Cymru For Ryder, Janet Plaid Cymru For Thomas, Owen John Plaid Cymru Did not vote Wood, Leanne Plaid Cymru Did not vote Elis-Thomas, Dafydd Plaid Cymru Did not vote Marek, John Forward Wales Did not vote Law, Peter Independent Did not vote Sargeant, Carl Labour Against Neagle, Lynne Labour Against Sinclair, Karen Labour Against Lloyd, Val Labour Against Andrews, Leighton Labour Against Cuthbert, Jeff Labour Against Idris Jones, Denise Labour Against Mewies, Sandy Labour Against Thomas, Catherine Labour Against Thomas, Gwenda Labour Against James, Irene Labour Against Barrett, Lorraine Labour Against Black, Peter Liberal Democrat For Burnham, Eleanor Liberal Democrat Did not vote Bates, Mick Liberal Democrat For Davies, David Conservative Did not vote Williams, Brynle Conservative For Melding, David Conservative For Cairns, Alun Conservative For Jones, Laura Anne Conservative For Davies, Glyn Conservative For Isherwood, Mark Conservative For

For: 22

Abstain: 0

Against: 29

Total Votes: 51