DOCSLIB.ORG

Libya and Britain: a Study of the History of British-Libyan Relations 1969-1979

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Libya and Britain: a Study of the History of British-Libyan Relations 1969-1979 View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Nottingham Trent Institutional Repository (IRep) LIBYA AND BRITAIN: A STUDY OF THE HISTORY OF BRITISH-LIBYAN RELATIONS 1969-1979 ALI ABDUSSALAM ABDULLA ALI A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of The Nottingham Trent University for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy May 2014 Abstract This thesis examines relations between Libya and the United Kingdom after 1969 when a new government came to power in Tripoli which seemed to pose a direct threat to a number of key British interests. The thesis is grounded on a careful reading of secondary literature which has been integrated into newly available official documents available in the National Archive. The main claim to originality is in the light these documents throw on our understanding of that relationship. The thesis uses a case study approach which examines specific themes in UK-Libya relations which include arguments over arms sales, the oil economy and the role of oil companies, and relations over the Irish question and the problematic Libyan supply of weapons and support to the IRA in the 1970s. It inevitably touches on relations between both governments and the United States, but that is not a main focus of the study. These areas have been chosen for study because they represent the most significant areas of bargaining and conflict between Libya and the UK in the time period, according to both the secondary literature and press debate at the time and the newly available documentation. The author has been aware of the limitations of using the National Archives, especially where material has newly arrived for view. These include the scope of official ‘weeding’ before documents are made available to conserve space and to avoid repetition, but also to exclude sensitive material relating to intelligence and cognate I aspects of relations with other governments. These limitations qualify, but do not undermine, the conclusions drawn. The main findings of the research refine our existing understanding of Libya-UK relations, important given that there is only a limited literature on the topic, and that no previous published work explores them using the National Archives. The archive material helps one to conclude that Straw’s (2010) argument that the basis of UK-Libya relations was always ‘strategic interest’ is partly sound but ultimately mistaken. Other important factors such as trade also mattered, and energy issues were at the same time ‘strategic’ and ‘trade-related’ for both sides. At least as important, mutual misunderstandings and a certain amount of confusion about the intentions of the other party (and what they could find negotiable) also shape the relationship, although strategic interest remains an important factor. The thesis also reveals for the first time differences in the evaluation of Libyan policy and intentions at different levels of the UK government, demonstrating that the bureaucratic politics of the British system of foreign policy making shaped some of the British responses to Libyan actions. Equally, although the evidence suggests that Gaddafi dominated Libyan policy making, it is clear that the elite surrounding him also played some part in policy making and in defining responses to British actions and announcements. Above all, the thesis demonstrates the complexity of the dynamics of UK-Libya relations in the time period studied, and that both sides consistently tended to believe that they had more influence over the other than was in fact the case. II Dedicated To To my Father and my beloved Mother To my brothers: Emhemed and Yousif Salhab To my sisters To my late brothers: Abdullah and Hassan Salhab III Acknowledgement First of all, I would like to express my deepest appreciation to Dr Christopher Farrands, Dr Imad El-Anis and Dr Nick Hayes for their guidance, support, and constructive comments which enabled me to complete this thesis I would also like to thank staff members at the Nottingham Trent University Boots Library. I owe my deepest gratitude to the people who work in the inter-library loan department. I would like also to extend thanks and appreciation to staff at the British National Archives in Kew, Staff at the Company Records of British Petroleum, and similarly those who work in the Modern Records Centre of Warwick University, and the British Library in London, who were extremely helpful and made material available to finish my thesis. Special mention goes to Jane Bonnell, Liaison Librarian for her support in finding online material through the Nottingham Trent University library system. Also special thanks to my friend Hamid Alahirsh for his help with my thesis proof reading. I am indebted to the Libyan Government and in particular the Ministry of High Education which has sponsored me throughout the period of my study. Finally personal thanks go to those individuals who have always shown an interest in my studies and thereby have encouraged me to persevere. IV Contents Abstract .......................................................................................................................... I Dedicated To ............................................................................................................... III Acknowledgement ...................................................................................................... IV Contents ....................................................................................................................... V Abbreviations .............................................................................................................. IX Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1 Originality ................................................................................................................. 5 Analysis ..................................................................................................................... 8 Methodology ........................................................................................................... 10 Historiography ......................................................................................................... 12 Looking ahead: the overall thesis narrative ............................................................. 21 Summary Structure of Thesis .................................................................................. 23 Chapter one .......................................................................................................... 23 Chapter two ................................................................................................................. 23 Chapter Three ...................................................................................................... 24 Chapter Four ........................................................................................................ 24 Chapter Five ......................................................................................................... 24 Chapter Six .......................................................................................................... 25 Chapter One: 1969: Libyan regime change and its new policy orientation ................ 28 Libyan foreign policy (influences and trends 1969-1979) ...................................... 28 The Impact of Nasserism and Palestine issue on Gaddafi’s policy ......................... 29 Gaddafi's ambitions, ideology and practices ........................................................... 33 Britain's view of Libyan foreign policy in theory and practice 1969-1979 ............. 43 The British-Libyan dispute over the Arab-Israeli conflict................................... 48 British-Libyan conflict of interests over the Mediterranean ................................ 57 British-Libyan conflict of interests in Africa ....................................................... 60 Conclusion ............................................................................................................... 64 Chapter Two: Evaluation of British-Libyan relations after 1969 and the outstanding issues ........................................................................................................................... 66 Britain evaluates its relations with Libya after 1969 ............................................... 66 V Libyan claims against the British government ........................................................ 74 British arms contracts with the monarchy 1968-69 ................................................. 75 Chieftain Tanks .................................................................................................... 75 An air defence system .......................................................................................... 76 The Libyan financial claim .................................................................................. 77 British-Libyan negotiations on resolving the outstanding issues ............................ 78 British-Libyan negotiation over the financial problem ........................................... 81 British-Libyan negotiations to the resolve arms contracts disputes ........................ 84 1- Chieftain Tanks contract ................................................................................. 84 2- The Air Defence Scheme................................................................................. 90
Load more

Recommended publications
  • As a Child You Have No Way of Knowing How Fast Or Otherwise The
    A FOREIGN COUNTRY: GROWING UP IN RHODESIA Nigel Suckling Draft: © January 2021 1 I – MUNALI – 5 II – LIVINGSTONE – 43 III – PARALLEL LIVES – 126 IV – LUSAKA – 212 V – GOING HOME – 244 APPENDIX – 268 2 FOREWORD As a child you have no measure of how fast the world around you is changing. Because you’re developing so quickly yourself, you assume your environment is static and will carry on pretty much the same as you grow into it. This is true for everyone everywhere, naturally. Most old people can, if suitably primed, talk indefinitely about the changes they’ve seen in their lifetimes, even if they’ve never moved from the place where they were born; but some environments change more drastically than others, even without a war to spur things along. One such was Northern Rhodesia in southern Africa in the 1950s and 60s. As white kids growing up then we had no way of knowing, as our parents almost certainly did, just how fragile and transient our conditions were – how soon and how thoroughly the country would become Zambia, with a completely different social order and set of faces in command. The country of course is still there. In many ways its urban centres now look remarkably unchanged due to relative poverty. The houses we grew up in, many of the streets, landmark buildings and landscapes we were familiar with are still recognizably the same, much more so in fact than in many parts of Europe. What has vanished is the web of British colonial superstructure into which I and my siblings were born as privileged members, brief gentry on the cusp of a perfectly justified and largely peaceful revolution that was soon to brush us aside.
    [Show full text]
  • A Full Copy Is Available by Clicking Here
    THE BOARD OF GOVERNORS' PROGRAMME COMPLAINTS BULLETIN January to March 2000 Issued May 2000 CHAIRMAN'S FOREWORD As well as giving figures which cover the whole of the BBC's reporting year, this Bulletin reports on the work of the BBC's Programme Complaints Unit over the period January to March 2000. It describes the cases where the Head of Programme Complaints found that there was a breach of the BBC's high editorial standards in tenns of taste, decency, accuracy, impartiality or fairness, and sets out the remedial action agreed with the programme-makers and schedulers. The Bulletin also includes the decisions of a sub-committee of the Board of Governors on cases brought to it on appeal by dissatisfied complainants. This committee's function is not confined to reviewing whether or not particular complaints should be upheld. It also considers the adequacy of actions taken as a result of upheld complaints, and this quarter has seen a significant example (see page 19). This case prompted the Governors to ask the Director-General whether the BBC was more reluctant than it should be to broadcast corrections. The Director-General's Report, overleaf, sets out his response. It is an important strength of the relationship between Governors and management within the BBC that the Governors are able to identify general issues which individual complaints occasionally raise, and to ensure that they are addressed. Sir Christopher Bland SSC Programme Complaints Unit April 2000 Page 2 REPORT BY THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL The BBC's policy on correcting mistakes is set out in the Producers' Guidelines: "When a serious factual error does occur it is important to admit it clearly and frankly If.
    [Show full text]
  • United Kingdom Defence Statistics 2010
    UNITED KINGDOM DEFENCE STATISTICS 2010 th Published: 29 September 2010 DASA (WDS) Tel: 020-7807-8792 Ministry of Defence Fax: 020-7218-0969 Floor 3 Zone K Mil: 9621 78792 Main Building, Whitehall E-mail: [email protected] London SW1A 2HB Web site: http://www.dasa.mod.uk INTRODUCTION Welcome to the 2010 edition of UK Defence Statistics, the annual statistical compendium published by the Ministry of Defence. Changes to UK Defence Statistics (UKDS) this year include a new section on Defence Inflation and an expanded International Defence section in Chapter 1, the restructuring of the Armed Forces Personnel section in Chapter 2, and a new section on Amputations in Chapter 3. UK Defence Statistics (UKDS) is a National Statistics publication, produced according to the standards of the Official Statistics Code of Practice. However some of the tables in UKDS do not have National Statistics status – some are produced by areas outside of the scope of the Government Statistical Service; some do not yet meet all the quality standards of the Official Statistics Code of Practice; and others have not gone through the required assessment process to be classed as National Statistics. All such tables are clearly marked with explanatory notes. This year UKDS is once again being issued as a web document only, due to financial constraints within the Ministry of Defence. Each table and chapter is available in pdf format which is suitable for printing. There is also a pdf version of the entire publication, and of the UKDS factsheet. We have ceased publication of the UKDS pocket cards this year, since they are of limited value in electronic format.
    [Show full text]
  • The Image of the Democratic Soldier in the United Kingdom
    PEACE RESEARCH INSTITUTE FRANKFURT Simone Wisotzki The Image of the Democratic Soldier in the United Kingdom British Case PRIF- Research Paper No. I/11-2007 © PRIF & Simone Wisotzki 2007 Research Project „The Image of the Democratic Soldier: Tensions Between the Organisation of Armed Forces and the Principles of Democracy in European Comparison“ Funded by the Volkswagen Foundation 2006-2009 Contents 1. Key Features of the Military Organisation and the Civilian Control of the UK Armed Forces 2 2. UK Security and Defence Policy: Political Directives for the Armed Forces 5 3. The Political Discourse on the Future of the Armed Forces and the Professional Soldier 9 4. The Parliamentary Debates and the Attitudes of the British Parties towards the Military 11 5. Public Opinion: The Core Debates on the UK Military and the Democratic Soldier 13 6. NATO, ESDP and the United States: To What Extent Do They Shape the British Armed Forces? 15 Conclusion: The Image of the British Soldier and Issues for Further Debate 16 Bibliography 20 Wisotzki: British Case I/11-2007 2 The following paper aims at describing the civil-military relations in the United Kingdom. It also concentrates on identifying images of the democratic soldiers at the political-societal level. I start with looking at the UK from an institutional perspective. Chapter 1 describes how Britain has established a system of rigorous civilian control over the military establishment. In Chapter 2 I look upon the UK’s defence and security policy which provide the core foundations for the operations of the Armed Forces. With the end of the Cold War, the changing security environment provided considerable challenges which also affected the operational planning for the Armed Forces.
    [Show full text]
  • Agreement Between the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of Canada on British Armed Forces’ Training in Canada
    Treaty Series No. 23 (2006) Agreement between the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of Canada on British Armed Forces’ Training in Canada Ottawa, 20 July 2006 [The Agreement entered into force on 20 July 2006] Presented to Parliament by the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs by Command of Her Majesty October 2006 Cm 6933 £4.00 © Crown copyright 2006 The text in this document (excluding the Royal Arms and departmental logos) may be reproduced free of charge in any format or medium providing it is reproduced accurately and not used in a misleading context. The material must be acknowledged as Crown copyright and the title of the document specified. Any enquiries relating to the copyright in this document should be addressed to the Licensing Division, HMSO, St Clements House, 2-16 Colegate, Norwich NR3 1BQ. Fax 010603 723000 or e-mail: [email protected] AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED KINGDOM OF GREAT BRITAIN AND NORTHERN IRELAND AND THE GOVERNMENT OF CANADA ON BRITISH ARMED FORCES’ TRAINING IN CANADA The Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of Canada, hereinafter referred to as "the Parties"; RECOGNISING the benefits to both Parties that British Armed Forces' training in Canada confers; RECALLING that transparency of process, good faith and trust underpin the relationship between the Parties; DESIRING to strengthen further co-operation and to consolidate existing relations between
    [Show full text]
  • Armed Forces Covenant Across Gwent NEWS Summer 2020
    Armed Forces Covenant across Gwent NEWS Summer 2020 Armed Forces Covenant across Gwent The Covenant is a promise from the nation ensuring that those who serve and have served in the Armed Forces and their families are treated fairly. Victory in Europe Day VE Day – or ‘Victory in Europe Day’ marks the day towards the end of World War Two (WW2) when ghting against Nazi Germany in Europe came to an end. Tuesday 8 May, 1945, was an emotional day that millions of people had been waiting for. Many people were extremely happy that the ghting had stopped and there were big celebrations and street parties. In his VE Day announcement, Winston Churchill said: “We may allow ourselves a brief period of rejoicing, but let us not forget for a moment the toil and e orts that lie ahead.” Even after 8 May, many soldiers, sailors and pilots were sent to the east to ght against the Japanese, who had not yet surrendered. VE Day celebrations were curtailed as a result of the coronavirus lockdown. Armed Forces Covenant Training Package The WLGA, with funding from the Covenant Fund, commissioned Cardi and Vale College to produce an Armed Forces Covenant training package. The package consists of a face-to-face training resource together with an e-learning resource. Both resources are aimed at local authority elected members and sta and seek to raise awareness and understanding of the Covenant. If you would like bespoke training for your department please contact Lisa Rawlings - Regional Armed Forces Covenant Offi cer [email protected] 01443 864447 www.covenantwales.wales/e-learning/ Armed Forces Covenant across Gwent p.
    [Show full text]
  • Youngest British Army Recruits Come Disproportionately from England's
    Youngest British army recruits come disproportionately from England’s most deprived constituencies Charlotte Cooper and David Gee1 Abstract Background: Public health and human rights concerns have been raised about the enlistment of young people ​ under the age of 18 into state armed forces. In the UK, some of these concerns relate to the impact of military enlistment on disadvantaged young people in particular, who may be enlisted into the British armed forces from age 16. Factors associated with socioeconomic disadvantage may increase the vulnerability of this group in military settings, yet there have been few investigations of the socioeconomic profile of soldiers recruited at this age. Objective: The aim of the study was to investigate the socioeconomic background of enlisted minors in ​ England, by looking at the economic characteristics of the areas they come from. Methods: Data showing how many minors were enlisted into the army from each English constituency over a ​ five-year period was matched with data on the relative socioeconomic deprivation of constituencies. The study investigated whether the number of recruits varied according to the deprivation of constituencies. Results: A statistically-significant correlation was found between the relative deprivation of constituencies and ​ the number of minors enlisted, with the rate of recruitment 57 percent higher in the most deprived fifth of constituencies than the least deprived fifth. Conclusion: The study found that, over a five-year period, minors were enlisted into the army ​ disproportionately from the more deprived constituencies of England, lending weight to public health and human rights concerns. Background The UK enlists for the armed forces from age 16.
    [Show full text]
  • Are the Armed Forces Understood and Supported by the Public?
    Original Article Armed Forces & Society 1-26 ª The Author(s) 2014 Are the Armed Forces Reprints and permission: sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav DOI: 10.1177/0095327X14559975 Understood and afs.sagepub.com Supported by the Public? A View from the United Kingdom Lindsey A. Hines1, Rachael Gribble2, Simon Wessely2, Christopher Dandeker2 and Nicola T. Fear2 Abstract Despite the importance of public opinion in supporting the military and their missions, little is known about how the UK public perceive their Armed Forces. This article reviews and evaluates available research and opinion poll data of public attitudes toward the UK military and situates the evidence within the civil–military gap literature. Current evidence suggests public regard for the UK Armed Forces is high despite low levels of support for the Iraq and Afghanistan missions. Public understanding of the work of the Armed Forces is limited. Nonetheless, the United Kingdom’s long history of military deployments may have given the public an ‘‘intuitive understanding’’ of the basic realities of the military compared with other European states. There are indications of differences in attitudes between the UK Armed Forces and wider British society, but no firm evidence that the civil–military ‘‘gap’’ has become a ‘‘gulf’’ as claimed by some military leaders. Keywords public opinion, UK armed forces, civil–military gap 1 King’s College London, London, UK 2 King’s Centre for Military Health Research (KCMHR), King’s College London, UK Corresponding Author: R. Gribble, King’s Centre for Military Health Research, Weston Education Centre, 10 Cutcombe Road, London SE5 9RJ, UK. Email: [email protected] Downloaded from afs.sagepub.com at Kings College London - ISS on March 4, 2015 2 Armed Forces & Society Introduction The UK Armed Forces have a well-established tradition of engagement in military operations that extends back into Britain’s imperial past.
    [Show full text]
  • Lonrho's Tiny Rowland and the Threat to Angola's Jonas Savimbi
    Click here for Full Issue of EIR Volume 15, Number 21, May 20, 1988 Lonrho's Tiny Rowland and the threat to Angola's Jonas SaviIpbi by Mark Burdman Knowledgeable security experts are warning of a live assas­ become very embarrassing to the George Bush for President sination threat against Jonas Savimbi, head of Angola's pro­ campaign. Rowland is one of the most powerful figures in Western UNITA rebel organization. The threat against Sav­ Africa, involved in a complex of East-West deals on various imbi began to come to light as talks got under way in London partsof the continent and in manipulation of ethnic and tribal over the future of Angola, sponsored by the British Foreign wars to increase his own competitive advantage in the grab Office. They involve the United States, Cuba, South Africa, for control of strategic mineral, agricultural, and energy re­ and the pro-Soviet Angolan government, with the Soviets sources. His usual modus operandi, in countries beset by present in an observer status, having blessed theevent. bitter internal conflicts, is to play all sides. In Sudan, he has Savimbi, an independent political and military leader established close ties with financial interests close to the fiercely opposed to Soviet imperial domination of southern Sudanese government in Khartoum. At the same time, he is Africa, is regarded as a major impediment to a "New Yalta" buddies with John Garang, of the Christian-animist Sudan deal over Angola which might involve the partitioning of the Peoples' Liberation Armyrebels in the South. In Angola, he country.Angola is high on thelist of "regional crisis matters" has strong links to the pro-Soviet government in Luanda, but discussions between the United States and the Soviets in the has also cultivated a relationship with Savimbi, often flying period leading up to the Reagan-Gorbachov summit.
    [Show full text]
  • British Military Special Vouchers
    BRITISH MILITARY SPECIAL VOUCHERS Order code: BRITMILALB Set of 5 Notes War can bring economic hardship—especially to the countries that lose. This was the case in Germany in 1944. Hitler was dead, the Nazi government collapsed, and the four Allied powers—Russia, France, the United States, and Great Britain—split the country into four occupation zones, to help Germany transition from dictatorship to democracy. In the British zone, the black market was rampant—goods intended for the troops were intercepted and sold at steep mark-ups to the local population. This was costing British taxpayers millions of pounds sterling. To redress the problem, Great Britain issued £10 million British Armed Forces Special Vouchers in 1946. When this measure did not destroy the black market, a second series was issued a year and a half later. The 1948 issue, combined with the improving financial position of the new German government, succeeded in driving out the war profiteers. The British government would use the tactic a few more times in the ensuing decades. A third issue, printed in 1948, was not circulated until the Suez Canal crisis in 1956. The fourth series was printed but never issued; a proposed fifth series never made it to the printer. The sixth and final series of vouchers were in circulation until 1979, when they were finally withdrawn. In 1991, the Ministry of Defense auctioned off its stock of uncirculated vouchers from the second, third, fourth, and sixth series. This collection comprises five of the extant banknotes of the kind used in Germany from 1946-1979.
    [Show full text]
  • Refugees in Europe, 1919–1959 Iii Refugees in Europe, 1919–1959
    Refugees in Europe, 1919–1959 iii Refugees in Europe, 1919–1959 A Forty Years’ Crisis? Edited by Matthew Frank and Jessica Reinisch Bloomsbury Academic An imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing Plc LONDON • OXFORD • NEW YORK • NEW DELHI • SYDNEY Bloomsbury Academic An imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing Plc 50 Bedford Square 1385 Broadway London New York WC1B 3DP NY 10018 UK USA www.bloomsbury.com BLOOMSBURY and the Diana logo are trademarks of Bloomsbury Publishing Plc First published 2017 © Matthew Frank, Jessica Reinisch and Contributors, 2017 This work is published subject to a Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives Licence. You may share this work for non-commercial purposes only, provided you give attribution to the copyright holder and the publisher. No responsibility for loss caused to any individual or organization acting on or refraining from action as a result of the material in this publication can be accepted by Bloomsbury or the authors. British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. ISBN: HB: 978-1-4725-8562-2 ePDF: 978-1-4725-8564-6 eBook: 978-1-4725-8563-9 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Cover image © LAPI/Roger Viollet/Getty Images Typeset by Deanta Global Publishing Services, Chennai, India To find out more about our authors and books visit www.bloomsbury.com. Here you will find extracts, author interviews, details of forthcoming events and the
    [Show full text]
  • Business Groups Exist in Developed Markets Also: Britain Since 1850
    Business Groups Exist in Developed Markets Also: Britain since 1850 Geoffrey Jones Working Paper 16-066 Business Groups Exist in Developed Markets Also: Britain Since 1850 Geoffrey Jones Harvard Business School Working Paper 16-066 Copyright © 2015 by Geoffrey Jones Working papers are in draft form. This working paper is distributed for purposes of comment and discussion only. It may not be reproduced without permission of the copyright holder. Copies of working papers are available from the author. Business groups exist in developed markets also: Britain since 1850 Geoffrey Jones Harvard Business School November 2015 Abstract Diversified business groups are well-known phenomenon in emerging markets, both today and historically. This is often explained by the prevalence of institutional voids or the nature of government-business relations. It is typically assumed that such groups were much less common in developed economies, and largely disappeared during the twentieth century. This working paper contests this assumption with evidence from Britain between 1850 and the present day. During the nineteenth century merchant houses established business groups with diversified portfolio and pyramidal structures overseas, primarily in developing countries, both colonial and independent. In the domestic economy, large single product firms became the norm, which over time merged into large combines with significant market power. This reflected a business system in which a close relationship between finance and industry was discouraged, but were there few restrictions on the transfer of corporate ownership. Yet large diversified business groups did emerge, which had private or closely held shareholding and substantial international businesses. The working paper argues that diversified business groups added value in mature markets such as Britain.
    [Show full text]