How Industrial Relations Informs the Teaching of Ethics in Human Resource Management

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

How Industrial Relations Informs the Teaching of Ethics in Human Resource Management Southern Business Review Volume 32 Issue 2 Article 4 How Industrial Relations Informs the Teaching of Ethics in Human Resource Management Charles G. Smith Otterbein College Hugh D. Hindman Appalachian State University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/sbr Part of the Business Commons, and the Education Commons Recommended Citation Smith, Charles G. and Hindman, Hugh D. () "How Industrial Relations Informs the Teaching of Ethics in Human Resource Management," Southern Business Review: Vol. 32 : Iss. 2 , Article 4. Available at: https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/sbr/vol32/iss2/4 This article is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Digital Commons@Georgia Southern. It has been accepted for inclusion in Southern Business Review by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons@Georgia Southern. For more information, please contact [email protected]. How Industrial Relations Informs the Teaching of Ethics In Human Resource Management Charles G. Smith and Hugh D. Hindman Most people want to do also because they directly avoid the historical and the “right thing.” This is true affect people and, so, have the philosophical backdrop that in business as well as in life. It potential to bring significant give texture and substance to is the duty of business good or significant harm to these decisions, an under- educators to provide a both individuals and to standing of the intellectual framework for students and society. To better inform the antecedents of today’s peers to judge the operational, debate over ethicality of HR employment relationship, and legal, and ethical rigor of practices, the authors suggest their inherent tensions will managerial decisions. This a re-examination human afford business decision article focuses attention on the resource management through makers a framework from human resource management the lens of its historical and which to better judge the function. The importance of philosophical predecessors— significance and the ethics of human resource management the industrial relations school their actions. (HRM) practices to the success of thought. The article presents an of the firm is accepted by Contemporary disputa- industrial relations system scholars and practitioners tions on the nature of the model updated to reflect alike and will be assumed employment relationship are current business exigencies. It here. But human resource at times truncated, uninspired, further offers a brief historical management practices are and lifeless. America is not and philosophical journey into important not only because of one big happy family and America’s experience with the their efficacy for the firm, but neither are business employee–employer relation- organizations. Nor should they ship linking economic with be, as many in the human moral theory and considering Charles G. Smith, Ph.D., is professor of management, in resources field would hold. three alternative moral the Department of Business, Choices need to be made, viewpoints on the industrial Accounting, and Economics, some rooted in history, some relations system. Next is a Otterbein College, novel to the present. Some are review of the treatment of Westerville, OH 43081. operationally sound, some are human resource management not. Some choices are legal, issues in popular collegiate Hugh D. Hindman, Ph.D., is some are not, and some are business ethics texts. The professor of labor & human morally defensible and others article concludes with resources, in the Walker are not. A discussion about implications for teaching College of Business, the appropriate structures and business ethics in human Appalachian State University, polices at work is in order. resource management. The Boone, NC 28608. While business schools often authors’ purpose is not to 16 Spring 2007 Southern Business Review promote their own views, but used to order one’s beliefs, that followed the industrializa- rather to frame the debate attitudes, and behavior about tion of the republic itself. concerning the treatment of the manner in which people Figure 1 presents a revised men and women in their deal with one another at work. industrial relations system working lives. The industrial Its purpose is to provide an model updated to reflect relations model affords understanding of the contemporary realities. As an decision makers enormous development and operation of instructional tool it flexibility with their human structures and processes summarizes the dominant resource practices, work involved in the production of forces at play in the employer- structures and process. The goods and services as they employee relationship. The article identifies questions of relate to the parties involved actors in the system include concern. How they are and to the larger society. employers and their trade answered is idiosyncratic to Kochan, Katz and McKersie associations, employees and the business decision maker define it this way, “…the their unions or professional and, hopefully, rooted in premises, values, laws, associations, and the sound moral reasoning. institutions and practices that government as the govern employment representative of the body The Industrial Relations relationships” (1986). The politic. Additionally, the System classic work on industrial system recognizes the relations system theory posits importance of consumers, Students of business ethics that the role of the system is competitors, suppliers, and rarely focus on America’s the establishment of rules that other interest groups. The industrial relations system, govern the relations between primary actors then develop preferring instead to study its primary actors, labor, rules that govern the macro socio-economic forces management, and the employment relationship by underlying systems of political government. The rules establishing structures and economy such as capitalism, themselves and the techniques processes that promote their socialism, or communism or, for their establishment are respective interests. These alternatively, opting to influenced by three myriad rules tend to coalesce investigate micro socio- environmental forces, around four different models economic concerns such as technology, the market, and of workplace governance– price fixing, product safety, the distribution of power and command and control, false advertising, employment status among the actors within employee empowerment, discrimination, or bribery the larger society. Finally, collective bargaining, and (Adler & Bigoness, 1992). what binds the entire system industrial democracy. Here, however, attention is together is the shared ideals The ideas of a command directed to the institution of and beliefs of society, i.e., and control governing the employee - employer ideology (Dunlop, 1958). A structure flows naturally from relationship and the control, stable menu of rules, both the work of such management authority and decision making substantive and procedural, theorists as Fayol, Taylor, and relationships generated. These developed among labor, Weber. Proponents of a considerations are central to management, and government command and control industrial relations system before and after World War II; structure legitimize top down theory and lie on a middle however, today the system is decision making, information stratum of the hierarchy of in flux, undergoing a meta- flow, and authority theoretical abstractions. morphosis perhaps as potent relationships. Work is An industrial relations and far reaching as the one perceived as undesirable, system is a conceptual tool Southern Business Review Spring 2007 17 Figure 1 Modified Industrial Relations System loathsome, and alienating policies of the firm; and 2) A second type of requiring extrinsic reward performance monitoring—the governing structure available mechanisms, subject to market control function—making sure to American business is the pressures, to attract, motivate, intended policies are employee empowerment or and maintain needed implemented. Both of these employee involvement model. employees. Employees cede to tasks have direct and obvious Tracing back to the Human a managerial class control not effects on employees. Relations School (Mayo) and only of their labor, but of the Employees have one main following MacGregor’s (1957) rule-making processes that task—follow the rules. While Theory Y assumptions that govern the nature of how work command and control employees seek challenge and is actually performed. structures are somewhat out of fulfillment in their work, Employees are conceptualized fashion in academic circles, management has experimented as interchangeable parts in the they remain a common with a number of structures machinery of production. prototype for workplace directed at increasing (Braverman, 1974). governance today. Command employee involvement, Management has two main and control regimes continue participation, and commitment tasks: 1) policy to dot the economic landscape at the workplace. Job redesign, formulation—the command from traditional industrial TQM initiatives, quality circle, function—formulation of the sectors to white collar and self-directed work teams, and strategic and operational service sectors. employee involvement 18 Spring 2007 Southern Business Review committees are examples much of what human resource the collective bargaining type designed to unleash the management addresses with is the grievance/arbitration creative power of the collective bargaining
Recommended publications
  • Industrial Democracy: Made in the U.S.A
    Industrial democracy: made in the U.S .A. Labor-management cooperation to improve the quality of products, worklife, and the effectiveness of companies can be traced to the early 19th century HENRY P. GUZDA According to industrial relations expert Milton Derber, par- ufacturing enterprises run by the Moravian religious order ticipatory management programs, shop committee plans, at Wachovia, N .C., and Bethlehem, Pa ., groups of jour- works councils, and similar employer-employee cooperative neymen often cooperated with master craftsmen, suggesting efforts can be classified as "industrial democracy ." I There improvements in product quality and proposing methods for was a proliferation of such programs in the 1970's, spawning increased output. These efforts, stated historian Carl Bri- a plethora of books, articles, and pamphlets which dissected denbaugh, "were conducted on a wage earning economy; the concepts and drew philosophical guidelines for their they were not communistic." It may have been the first implementation and expected results. Some publications cite American experiment in participatory management .' these experiments as unique or novel, but, as Sanford Jacoby But the true antecedents of our modern system of labor of the University of California at Los Angeles management relations were formed in the 19th century, coinciding with school noted, the common presumption that these are new rapid industrial growth . At one time, class distinctions be- solutions to lagging productivity is wrong .2 "The hand of tween employers and journeymen were vague and ill- the past," said historian Richard B . Morris, "is still writ defined-most masters graduated from working ranks- large in . the labor relations of this country, and the early until rapidly expanding economies of scale soon drew de- concepts and procedures often forecast the shape of things finable, if not bold, lines.
    [Show full text]
  • Learn to Loveyour
    Learn to Love Your Job With approximately one-third of our “It’s really hard for someone who looking for things you can control. It waking hours spent at work—and isn’t happy at work to be engaged,” may be as simple as switching to a another third presumably spent Shane says. “Engagement requires a different shift to work with a supervisor thinking about it—there’s no question good bit of positive emotion, so if you’re or co-workers you find more enjoyable that where, how and with whom we feeling a lot of negativity about your or taking on a task that you are good at wwork plays a significant role in our job, the chance of being engaged or find stimulating. overall well-being. goes down.” “And you have to start each day “Being happy at work is key to being Engagement, however, is about more deciding it’s going to be a good day,” happy in life,” notes Shane Lopez, than happiness. It’s about being content Shane says. “Maybe you just start with Ph.D., Gallup senior scientist and with the work you’re doing and having a the morning, and say today is going to research director at Clifton Strengths sense of curiosity. The good news is, be a good morning. You’ll find that it Institute. “Lots of different domains in each of us has more say in our happiness bleeds over into your afternoon.” our life hinge on it. If that work domino at work than we might realize. doesn’t fall into place, it’s hard to make “You can tweak things like how you Take a Breath the most of your relationships or be your spend your time, who you’re spending it Not everyone believes that happiness best self.
    [Show full text]
  • Your Respectful Workplace What Signals Are You
    Respect & Civility at Work any behaviors commonly ex- •Differences: Participating in intolerant hibited by employees can be Big Impacts from Small Stuff behavior or using language associated with detrimental to the well-being racial, sexual, age-related, or other human M he following are some common behaviors differences that offends or contributes to a and productivity of coworkers. A T often considered disrespectful. Do you hostile, offensive, or intimidating work en- lack of respect in the workplace, if practice any of them? Have you been on the vironment. left unchecked, will drag down mo- receiving end of some? You may notice some Interpersonal: Behaving in a way that rale, create higher turnover, and missing that you have experienced. Use the • list to help you consider your role in helping invalidates someone else’s successes; increase risks to the employer. Do maintain a respectful workplace. spreading rumors, or not correcting rumors; you contribute to a respectful work- •Communication: Interrupting others talking about someone behind his or her back or taking credit for someone else’s place? while they are speaking; cutting someone off work; criticizing a coworker’s character to before he or she has finished expressing a another worker who has not formulated a thought; neglecting to say please and thank firsthand opinion; labeling coworkers with What Signals Are You Sending? you; purposely avoiding an obvious moment personality or character traits you don’t to offer a compliment, to say good morning, espect is the regard or consideration we like; habitually using cynical language or Rhave for others in all aspects of what con- etc.; criticizing someone in front of peers; us- sarcasm; not sharing in the work.
    [Show full text]
  • Business Responsibility Report
    Business Responsibility Report Business responsibility report Introduction Mindtree has historically approached business responsibility with an inward-looking approach; we are keen on bringing a significant change starting with the people aspect of our organization. Creating a responsible organizational culture is the first step towards accountability and we have put in considerable efforts and energy into it. This has led to a deeper impact on our responsibility towards our work, as we extend it to the outside world, the society and the whole ecosystem. This report demonstrates Mindtree's commitment to sustainability as a business imperative that helps clients and societies flourish. It is also an opportunity to constantly innovate and create meaningful engineering solutions to build a sustainable tomorrow. Scope This report gives an overview on the triple bottom line performance of the enterprise. It includes management of relevant risks and opportunities and adherence to the nine principles stated in the National Voluntary Guidelines (NVG) on Social Environmental and Economic (SEE) Responsibilities of Business, released by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, Govt. of India. The FY 2014-15 report covers economic parameters across Mindtree's global locations and social and environmental parameters across Mindtree's offices in India (about 86.41% of our total workforce operates out of India-based locations). Exhaustive details about our sustainability policies and initiatives are illustrated in our second sustainability report for the year 2013-14 (http://www.mindtree.com/sustainability/mindtree- sustainability-report.pdf) The content is mapped to the corresponding NVG principles as depicted below: NVG Principles Sustainability Dimension 1 and 7 Corporate governance & advocacy 4 and 9 Stakeholder engagement 3 and 5 Workplace sustainability 2 and 6 Ecological sustainability 8 Inclusive growth Sustainability framework Our sustainability framework is our cognizant approach to institutionalize what has been implicit in our culture all along.
    [Show full text]
  • The Labor Problem and the Social Catholic Movement in France
    THE LABOR PROBLEM AND THE SOCIAL CATHOLIC MOVEMENT IN FRANCE ..s·~· 0 THE MACMILLAN COMPANY NEW VORIC • BOSTON • CHICAGO • DALlAS ATLANTA • SAN FRANCISCO MACMILLAN &: CO., LtMITIID LONDON • BOMBAY • CALC1/TTA MBLBOURNII THE MACMILLAN CO. OF CANADA, LTD. TORONTO THE LABOR PROBLEM AND THE SOCIAL CATHOLIC MOVEMENT IN FRANCE A Study in the History of Social Politics BY PARKER THOMAS MOON Instructor in History in Columbia University Jat\tl !llOtk THE MACMILLAN COMPANY 1921 COPYBIGilT, 1921, BY THE MACMILLAN COMPANY. Set up and printed. •Published Ma.y, 1921. !'BIN I'Bb lll' 'l.'lm l1NlTIII> S'l.'AflS OJ Alo!UIOA TO MY MOTHER PREFACE Nor until quite recently: in the United States, has anything like general public attention been directed to one of the most powerful and interesting of contemporary movements toward the solution of the insistent problem of labor unrest. There is a real need for an impartial historical study of this movement and a critical analysis of the forces which lie behind it. Such a need the present narrative does not pretend to satisfy com­ pletely; but it is hoped that even a preliminary survey, such as this, ·will be of interest to those who concern themselves with the grave social and economic problems now confronting po­ litical democracy. The movement in question,- generally known as the Social Catholic movement,- has expanded so rapidly in the last few decades that it may now be regarded as a force compar­ able in magnitude and in power to international Socialism, or to Syndicalism, or to the cooperative movement. On the eve of the Great War, Social Catholicism was represented by or­ ganizations in every civilized country where there was any considerable Catholic population.
    [Show full text]
  • How the Science of Positive Psychology Will Revolutionize the Workplace
    University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Master of Applied Positive Psychology (MAPP) Master of Applied Positive Psychology (MAPP) Capstone Projects Capstones 1-10-2010 Happy at Work: How the Science of Positive Psychology Will Revolutionize the Workplace Daniel S. Bowling III University of Pennsylvania, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/mapp_capstone Part of the Business Administration, Management, and Operations Commons, Human Resources Management Commons, Law and Society Commons, Legal Education Commons, and the Organizational Behavior and Theory Commons Bowling III, Daniel S., "Happy at Work: How the Science of Positive Psychology Will Revolutionize the Workplace" (2010). Master of Applied Positive Psychology (MAPP) Capstone Projects. 17. https://repository.upenn.edu/mapp_capstone/17 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/mapp_capstone/17 For more information, please contact [email protected]. Happy at Work: How the Science of Positive Psychology Will Revolutionize the Workplace Abstract This capstone is a draft of a proposed book on positive psychology in the workplace, aimed at a popular audience. It contains a detailed table of contents and reference sources, as well as several complete or partially- complete chapters. It also includes an extended section on lawyers that will form the basis of a separate academic article. The book’s working title is Happy at Work: How the Science of Positive Psychology will Revolutionize the Workplace. Its thesis is that most modern human resources practices are misguided with an overreliance on process and metrics. Humans are treated as capital, and firms focus on their failings and weaknesses rather than their strengths.
    [Show full text]
  • A Reading Guide for by Jerry Colonna
    A READING GUIDE FOR Reboot BY JERRY COLONNA #ARTOFGROWINGUP | WWW.REBOOTBYJERRY.COM Reboot A READER'S GUIDE "A well-asked question creates a sense of well-being even as it disrupts the story making that has protected us for so long." - Jerry Colonna 1. How did my relationship with money first get formed and how does it influence the way I work as an adult? What was the belief system around money and work that I grew up with? (Chapter One) 2. How can I lead with the dignity, courage, and grace that are my birthright? How can I use even the loss of status and the challenge to my self-esteem that are inherent in leadership to grow into the adult I want to be in the world? (Chapter Two) 3. In what ways have I depleted myself, run myself into the ground? Where am I running from and where to? Why have I allowed myself to be so exhausted? (Chapter Three) 4. Who is the person I've been all my life? What can that person teach me about becoming the leader I want to be? What is the story my family told about being real. being vulnerable, and being true? (Chapter Four) 5. Why do I struggle so much with the folks in my life? Why are relationships so difficult? What am I not saying to my co-founder, my colleagues, my family members, my life partner that needs to be said? (Chapter Five) 6. What's my purpose? Why does it feel like I'm lost while I struggle to move forward? How do I grow, transform, and find meaning? (Chapter Six) 7.
    [Show full text]
  • A Conceptual Framework of Happiness at the Workplace
    Asian Social Science; Vol. 11, No. 2; 2015 ISSN 1911-2017 E-ISSN 1911-2025 Published by Canadian Center of Science and Education A Conceptual Framework of Happiness at the Workplace Phathara-on Wesarat1, Mohmad Yazam Sharif2 & Abdul Halim Abdul Majid2 1 Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Prince of Songkla University, Pattani Campus, Thailand 2 School of Business Management, College of Business, Universiti Utara Malaysia, Malaysia Correspondence: Phathara-on Wesarat, Dept. of Social Sciences, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Prince of Songkla University, Pattani Campus, Pattani, Thailand. Tel: 66-7-333-1304. E-mail: [email protected] Received: July 8, 2014 Accepted: October 28, 2014 Online Published: December 20, 2014 doi:10.5539/ass.v11n2p78 URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.5539/ass.v11n2p78 Abstract Happiness at the workplace refers to how satisfied people are with their work and lives. The idea of happiness is related to individual’s subjective well-being. Happiness at the workplace is crucial for improving productivity in any organization. Happy people are productive people while those people who are unhappy may not pay full attention to any task. Some scholars believe that organizations which are able to maintain long-term happiness at the workplace could probably increase and sustain productivity. Therefore, they should know what factors could affect employee happiness in order to effectively enhance happiness at the workplace. But research on employee happiness was rarely seen in the past. The issue of happiness at the workplace needs to be properly conceptualized so that useful research on it could be conducted.
    [Show full text]
  • International Socialist Review (1900) Vol 05
    TH INTERNATIONAL SOCIALIST REVIEW VOL. V OCTOBER, 1904 NO. 4 Employers' Associations. ANEW factor has entered into the industrial struggle of labor with capital. There has been a growth of concentrated cap- ital for the past twenty-five years. The appearance of con- sciously organized capital, organized for the purpose of dealing with the labor question, is entirely different and is of recent de- velopment. In 1895 in Atlanta, Georgia, Thomas H. Martin, the editor of Dixie, advocated in an editorial the consolidating and organiz- ing of manufacturing interests and the adopting of a united policy in order to meet the aggressions of labor. This suggestion was carried out and the National Association of Manufacturers had its birth. This body now consists not only of a national organization with 3,000 members in thirty-nine of the different states but we find that international relations are also maintained. "There may be some of our members," says its president Mr. Parry, "who have been modest enough to suppose that the National Associa- tion was merely national. In reality it is international in its work and scope now as it always has been." In the ninth annual report of this association one of its objects is stated. It is "an organiza- tion "which is practically an insurance against populistic and so- cialistic experiments." The Manufacturers' Association is not the only one of its class. The Metal Trades Association and various others also represent the interests of employers. While these organizations have existed for a half dozen, years at least, there has recently been formed and perfected a national association of all employers for the object of dealing with the labor problem in a unified manner.
    [Show full text]
  • Why Happiness Matters in Your Workforce and Beyond 1
    Why Happiness Matters in Your Workforce and Beyond 1 Introduction Happiness is a vague expression that is an umbrella term for many different types of positive emotional responses within an organization. But the science of happiness1 is not vague. Empirical research finds that employees who report that they are happy at work are able to be more creative, adapt better to change initiatives, solve problems faster, receive faster promotions and better feedback and earn more money over the course of their careers. By making employee happiness…a priority, leaders are better able to meet the needs of their employees while enjoying numerous critical benefits. Employers who understand their company culture and have resources and strategies in place to track the essential components for success are able to implement the solutions that promote happiness at work. This helps them avoid the mistakes2 that undermine an effective culture. By making employee happiness within the organization a priority, leaders are better able to meet the needs of their employees while enjoying numerous critical benefits. 1 http://blogs.wsj.com/source/2011/09/18/the-five-drivers-of-happiness-at-work/ 2 http://3bigmistakes.corevalues.com/ Why Happiness Matters in your Workforce and Beyond www.corevalues.com Copyright © TIGERS Success Series, Inc. 2 Problem Unhappiness in the workplace may seem like miniscule problem when compared to other, more pressing problems. Unhappy and disengaged employees, however, actually cost U.S. businesses $450 billion to $550 billion a year because of lost productivity, according to a Gallup report3. These numbers are staggering. As a result, leaders who take note and begin assessing the levels of unhappiness within their workplaces will reap productivity rewards among several other benefits.
    [Show full text]
  • The Science of Happiness // 2 Happ Y Em 1 P Lo Y E E
    WHITE PAPER WHITE THE SCIENCE OF HAPPINESS HOW TO BUILD A KILLER CULTURE IN YOUR COMPANY 2 // The Science of Happiness Happiness of Science The Every company - whether it is trying to build one or not - has a culture. And Culture matters. A great culture can make the critical difference between organizational success and dismal failure. It impacts just about every business metric we have, from customer service to productivity to profitability. It is the key to retention because employees don’t want to leave a great culture. It is the key to recruitment because applicants are clamoring to get in. Intel, which is renowned for its iconic culture, has a turnover rate of only 2% and Google gets an estimated 7,000 unsolicited Intel, which is renowned for its applications for jobs every day. iconic culture, has a turnover rate But let’s face it, the culture we have isn’t always the of only 2% and Google gets culture we want. What if your culture needs some help? an estimated 7,000 unsolicited Or a lot of help? How can companies that might lack the applications for jobs every day. resources of a Google still create a magnetic culture? The short answer is by concentrating on employee happiness. At this point, you might be thinking: “Wait… employee happiness? Shouldn’t culture start with an all-hands meeting with the CEO or with free snacks in the break room?” HR leaders encounter a lot of advice about how to manage culture—to increase engagement, decrease turnover, and drive recruitment.
    [Show full text]
  • Barbash, Jack
    The Association for Diplomatic Studies and Training Foreign Affairs Oral History Project Labor Series PROFESSOR JACK BARBASH Interviewer: Morris Weisz Initial interview date: May 2, 1994 Copyright 1998 AD T TABLE OF CONTENTS ackground orn and raised in New York City New York University Early Employment in Education 1930,s The Educational Alliance Teaching classes for Unions -PA,s -orkers Education Young Socialists League Clothing -orkers Unions Labor personalities New York University 193.-1930 Professors Dissertation1 Employer Attitudes and Methods of the Belligerent Employer -ashington2 D.C.4 National Labor Relations oard 1930-1940 La Folllette Committee Railway Labor Act Authors of labor issues Congress of Industrial Organisation 8CIO9 Communist labor development Socialists Office of Education -ashington2 D.C4 -ar Production oard 8-P 9 1940- Labor )nions in Action Unionism as an institution of capitalism Comparison with cultural anthropology 1 Observations Labor attaches European views on trade unions There+s More to More than More -alter Reuther Trade )nions and Economic Policy European labor leaders and labor philosophy AFL-CIO Swedish/German experience International Industrial Relations Association Foreign Tours > worldwide 1962 Reports on Labor Attaches The @Saposs thingA Cost of loving studies European and American concepts of labor relations European management and trade unions American management and trade unions Professors and industrial relations Transition from socialism to capitalism Cohen-Sachs disagreement Foreign Service Officers Academics Foreign Service Institute Turning from study of social systems to economics The Nobel PriBe Embassies need for economic analysis American economic publications University of -isconsin4 Professor of Labor and Economic Thought INTERVIEW -: This is Morris Weisz and this is the first side of the first tape of my interview with my old friend Jac/ Barbash in Madison, Wisconsin, on May 2 0and 12, 1994.
    [Show full text]