California Department of Fish and Wildlife Peninsular Bighorn Sheep Annual Report 2015
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE PENINSULAR BIGHORN SHEEP 2015 ANNUAL REPORT A cooperative effort by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and California Department of Parks and Recreation Photo by Janene Colby This report presents information on the status, distribution, and management of peninsular bighorn sheep in eastern San Diego County and portions of Riverside and Imperial Counties for 2015 Authors Janene Colby and Randy Botta South Coast Region California Department of Fish and Wildlife Peninsular Bighorn Sheep Annual Report 2015 Table of Contents Executive Summary………………………………………………...1 Background……………………………………………………….......3 Capture and Radio-collaring……………………………………3 Radio Collar Status………………………………………………….4 Population Size and Estimation…………………….………..5 Respiratory Disease………………………………………………..5 Cause Specific Mortality and Survival……………………..6 Lamb Survival and Recruitment……………………………...8 Distribution and Movement………………………………….11 San Jacinto Mountains………………………………………...12 Central Santa Rosa Mountains………………………........12 Southern Santa Rosa Mountains……………………….....15 Vallecito Mountains………………………………………......16 Threats to Recovery………………………………………….….17 San Jacinto Mountains…………………………................17 Northern Santa Rosa Mountains………………………….17 Central Santa Rosa Mountains………………….……...…17 Southern Santa Rosa Mountains…………………….……19 Coyote Canyon…………………………………………….….…19 Northern San Ysidro Mountains………………….….…...19 Southern San Ysidro Mountains……………………..…...20 Vallecito Mountains……………………………………………20 Carrizo Canyon……………………………………………..…...21 Future Actions……………………………………………………...22 Citations……………………………………………………………....23 California Department of Fish and Wildlife South Coast Region 3883 Ruffin Road San Diego, CA. 92123 www.wildlife.ca.gov Photo by Jeff Young EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Desert bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensis nelsoni) inhabit the desert slopes of the Peninsular Ranges of southern California and extend into the mountains of Baja California in Mexico. The population within the Peninsular Ranges was first listed as threatened in 1971 under the California Endangered Species Act. In 1974, the population was estimated at 1,171 (Weaver 1975) but by 1996 the rangewide population estimate had declined to only 276 adult sheep (USFWS 2000). Peninsular bighorn sheep were listed as a federally endangered population segment in 1998 (63 FR 13134) due to: 1) habitat fragmentation, degradation, and loss by urban and commercial development; 2) disease; 3) predation coinciding with low population numbers; 4) response to human disturbance; 5) insufficient lamb recruitment; 6) nonnative toxic plants; and 7) prolonged drought (USFWS 2000). Presently, the population of desert bighorn sheep in the Peninsular Ranges is considered to be stable to increasing based on the most recent 2010 California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) rangewide survey estimate of 955 bighorn sheep. In order for CDFW to estimate ewe (female) abundance it is necessary to maintain radio-collars on at least 25% of the ewes within each of the 9 recovery regions within the Peninsular Ranges. At the beginning of 2015, there were a total of 94 active radio-collars throughout the Peninsular Ranges (89 ewes & 5 rams). This represented only 16% of the ewe population rangewide. During the fall 2015 capture an additional 91 active radio-collars (84 ewes & 7 rams) were deployed in the San Jacinto Mountains (SJM), Northern (NSRM), Central (CSRM) and Southern (SSRM) Santa Rosa Mountains, Coyote Canyon (CoC), Northern (NSYM) and Southern (SSYM) San Ysidro Mountains, and Vallecito Mountains (VM) recovery regions. In 2015, there were 13 radio- collared sheep mortalities (11 ewes and 2 rams). Mortalities by recovery region were: NSRM = 1 ewe, CSRM = 1 ewe, CoC = 2 ewes, SSYM = 1 ewe, VM = 2 ewes, and Carrizo Canyon (CC) = 4 ewes & 2 rams. At the close of 2015, 29% of the ewe population was radio-collared with a total of 171 active radio-collars throughout the Peninsular Ranges (161 ewes & 10 rams). A field-based capture is tentatively planned for October 2016 to fill any remaining radio-collared gaps prior to the rangewide population survey in November 2016. From 1992 to 2016, on average, 12% of all active radio-collared sheep died each year of which 7% was due to predation. In 2015, only 7% of all active radio-collared sheep died of which 3.2% were due to predation, 2.2% California Department of Fish and Wildlife Annual Report 2015 Page 1 the cause was unknown, and 1.6% was attributed to nonpredation. The average age of radio-collared ewes in 2015 was 7.1 years with a range between 1.5 and 19 years (n = 173). In comparison, the average age of radio- collared ewes that died was 12.0 years with a range between 8 and 16 years (n = 11). In 2015, average rangewide survival of radio-collared ewes was 87%. Over the past 5 years (2011 – 2015), average survival of radio-collared ewes from highest to lowest was SJM (100%), followed by VM (98%), NSRM (93%), NSYM (91%), CC (91%), CSRM (88%), CoC (86%), and SSYM (80%). Survival statistics were not available for the SSRM due to lack of radio-collared sheep. CDFW has monitored lamb survival (survival to 3 months) and recruitment (survival to 1 year = yearlings) within 2 to 5 recovery regions from 2008 to 2015. The percentage of 2015 lambs that were recruited to yearlings was lowest in CoC (10%), followed by the NSYM (11%), the “urban” ewe group in CSRM (11%), the “wild” ewe group in CSRM (33%), and the IKP ewe group in CC (35%) recovery regions. Typically, lamb survival levels below 30% indicate the presence of lamb respiratory disease within a ewe group. Clinical signs of lamb pneumonia have been documented in all 5 recovery regions; however, rates of lamb survival and recruitment have varied by ewe group, season, and year. For the past 8 years, the average recruitment ratio has been very low (18%) in both CoC and NSYM. Presently, there is substantial genetic variation and gene flow among bighorn sheep populations within the Peninsular Ranges and across the US-Mexico Border indicating functional connectivity (Buchalski et al. 2015). However, as traffic levels continue to increase connectivity will be lost. The most frequent reports of sheep being killed while attempting to cross roads are on Highways 74 and 78, Interstate 8, and County Roads S22 and S3. Other concerns that may hinder recovery efforts are: disease, the loss of natural water sources, reduction and fragmentation of sheep habitat, habitat modification due to invasive nonnative plants, sheep use of urban areas, and human disturbance of essential sheep habitat especially around the urban centers. Yet, even in more remote regions renewable energy projects, completion of the US-Mexico border fence, mining, and human activities (border enforcement and off-road vehicles) may alter, discourage, or restrict sheep movement and habitat use of important resources. Hopefully, continued efforts by CDFW to monitor sheep health, habitat use, and movements throughout the range will provide federal, state, and local governmental agencies and city planners information to make land and public use decisions that allow for the health and long-term survival of peninsular bighorn sheep. Photo by Jeff Young California Department of Fish and Wildlife Annual Report 2015 Page 2 BACKGROUND This annual report highlights capture and radio- Peninsular Bighorn Sheep collaring, radio-collar monitoring, disease Map 1 Recovery Regions surveillance, cause specific mortality investigation, 3,208 km2 1 – San Jacinto Mountains – 168 km2 and lamb survival monitoring undertaken by the 2 – N. Santa Rosa Mountains – 194 km2 1 3 – C. Santa Rosa Mountains – 257 km2 California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) 10 4 – S. Santa Rosa Mountains – 562 km2 5 – Coyote Canyon – 250 km2 of bighorn sheep in the Peninsular Mountain 6 – N. San Ysidro Mountains – 86 km2 Ranges of southern California from 1 January 2015 7 – S. San Ysidro Mountains – 117 km2 8 – Vallecito Mountains – 708 km2 through 31 December 2015. 2 9 – Carrizo Canyon – 866 km2 Riverside 74 USFWS Critical Habitat The Peninsular Mountain Ranges contain 9 3 Anza-Borrego Desert State Park designated bighorn sheep recovery regions City Centers occupying portions of western Riverside, western Wind Farm Infrastructure Imperial and eastern San Diego Counties (Map 1). County Boundary The 9 recovery regions are: 1) San Jacinto 5 4 Mountains (SJM); 2) Northern Santa Rosa Mountains (NSRM); 3) Central Santa Rosa Salton Sea Mountains (CSRM); 4) Southern Santa Rosa 6 86 Mountains (SSRM); 5) Coyote Canyon (CoC); 6) San Diego Northern San Ysidro Mountains (NSYM); 7) 7 Imperial Southern San Ysidro Mountains (SSYM); 8) 78 Vallecito Mountains (VM); and 9) Carrizo Canyon (CC). 8 A Cessna 185 fixed-wing aircraft was used to conduct aerial telemetry monitoring at least once a month in all 9 recovery regions. Telemetry flights, however, were not conducted for the first 3 9 months of 2015 following the retirement of 8 CDFW’s southern California Air Services pilot in December 2014. Telemetry flights were recommenced in April 2015 when the vacant pilot position was filled. Flights were used to monitor radio-collared sheep status (alive/dead), obtain location estimates, and download GPS location data. CDFW conducted ground telemetry monitoring of radio-collared sheep twice a month in all recovery regions except for the SJM and NSRM which were monitored by the Bighorn Institute (BI). Satellite-collared sheep in the SJM, CSRM, SSRM, and VM were monitored